If you enjoyed this alternate timeline please drop a LIKE on this video 😌 what do you think of the ending?? PS. Watch all 7 Parts HERE: ruclips.net/p/PL5__VO0MYmiS7_xSxOi8Hs3fWVXLudofA
Hey there turtle, are you gonna do a what-if levi squad survived. Oh, and have forgotten about the what-if armin got the armoured titan part 2, since toy left it on a cliffhanger. Ty for this series
The way this what if ended left a severe impact, the Ackermans actually dying shocked me more than flochs betrayal, Eldians around the world coming back to paradis, Erwin status reaching legendary heights and Eren path to freedom and peace still continues even after the Eldian empire is the last nation standing. Turtle quirk is a beast with these what if scenarios.
7:26 If I had a nickel every time Eren threatened to make an Armor Titan die in the worst way possible, I'd have two nickels. Which isn't a lot, but it's weird that it happened twice.
This ending felt like a 'True anime ending' eren is alive, but at the cost of losing mikasa. The descrimination on the eldians who came from Marley just makes the ending so much better. We've come a long way watching this 'what if' thank you for making this! ^^
Let's all take a moment to appreciate this series as a whole, truly brilliant! From this episode especially the ARTWORK on the Colossal reaching out to the Armoured! Mad respect to everyone involved in the production of this and thanks a lot! ^^
I got to admit I like this ending more than the canonical one. My only complaint is the loss of Hitch as the Female Titan, would’ve been nice if she did more and survived.
In all honestly this feels like a sort of “good” ending for attack on titan, especially if you know how the manga ends. This version loops things around to the beginning in a way, the idea that this tiny area holds what’s left of humanity
im high asf and was thinking “is eren gonna erase their memories of the outside world to stop the segregation? making the entire story pointless?” if that was the ending i would’ve been laughing my ass off😭
The thing is conflict and war will always happen I mean look at the war between the scouts and the military police or the scouts vs the yeagerist eventually they would wipe each other out
@@Gamfluent would they ? The last thing Eren would do is take away the freedom and control them . The people of the island would probably split apart and fight each other . They would probably fight over resources due to their population increasing and because mostly everything in the mainland is a burned up wasteland . Look at island nations like Japan . They have limited land for farming and cattle. So they sometimes rely on other countries for resources.
Was it only Marley's Eldian's that Eren transformed? Or did he do the same thing to every single Eldian across the world on top of all the Rumbling stuff?
1. Anime/manga ending - Happy ending (bittersweet) 2. Isayamas original ending (where everyone dies) - Sad ending 3. Turtle quirks ending - True ending 4. Before ymir reaches the tree, she trips, hits her head on a rock and dies ending - Secret ending
LOVE THIS… I’m so sad that this is over:( I feel like this is more exciting than the actual show!!! You and your team are so talented and so hardworking! I love your videos!
So in this timeline, Eren will be forced to live out his life alone as punishment for committing omnicide? I like it! And to make it worse for him, he even felt like he traded so many lives for his own freedom sometimes to the point that he lost faith in himself is something that is very well executed. And I like how the aftermath has shown the tension rising between what can be described as local Eldians Vs outside Eldians here because it looked really realistic here. After all, some resentment towarded Marley will be on to them since there are no Marleyans left to blame anymore. Except for those who have been taken prisoners during the war, of course. As for the Mid-Eastern and Hizuru peoples, I wished some of them survived and restarted their civilizations soon despite how much unlikely it is.
@@Gamfluent I “support”the rumbling (support is a loose word for it) but killing billions of people is never right. It may be what’s needed for survival but calling it right isn’t correct
I'd like to say thank you for putting this all together. It's been an incredible take on this huge "What If?" scenario, and I've enjoyed every minute of it.
A stand out moment for me was Historia inheriting the jaw Titan,as although Ymir is still gone,along with the power of the titans,it feels like she’s even more connected to her now🥲
Loved this ending, as it really feels like Eren didn't get what he wanted in the end, all he wanted was to protect his friends, and as he went down this path, both Armin and Mikasa aren't there to see the freedom he wanted. I will forever believe that this was a possibility and that he had some influence over Armin being picked over Erwin. To save both. But inevitably become their enemies.
This is the best what if series I've seen I love the effort to make the custom still frames whoever did that deserves all the praise thanks for making this
TBH this is more sadder than the original AOT series, instead of Eren Sacrifice Himself for longer life of his love ones, this one is the opposite. And whats insteresting thing though is that the titan power is gone after rumbling when they returned to paradise island that woudn't potentially recycle the power of titan like eren's head was burried then the tree grew so gigantic similar to Ymir's Event. But this ending is a lot better i think. Well done Work for this video! Love it!
I waited excitedly for every episode to drop last year so happy to see it ended on a good note. I just can't explain how legendary this series is, we also gotta get a part two on What If Armin had the Armored Titan.
I loved how you took some of the aspects of the main manga like character motivations that didn't make sense at first and actually made them work especially the romance between Eren and Mikasa. Although there are some few flaws like certain character development it's easily excusable because it can be expanded if this ever became an actual manga series. W writing W character development. Would definitely watch again.
@@TurtleQuirk you gotta give me more what if Armin inherited the Armoured brother And are you open to suggestions for a new one? If so I'd love to see what if Levi fed the beast Titan to Armin a far more significant change because Eren now has no royal blood titan to help his goals and will have to find an alternative route or a completely new one
@@TurtleQuirk just in case ur open to ideas, I think it would be interesting to see a “What if Levi never became a scout?” Cause not only would the scouts have to go through the hardships without him, Levi would still be a criminal with a good chance of him joining the military police along with Kenny. That also means Mikasa would be the most powerful soldier with no one to hold her back when eren gets kidnapped
tbh i really like this timeline but i do want to see some more episodes of what happens after this because it just sounds really cool this is a piece of art really good work dude 😁
Now that the show has officially ended I have to say this ending is 1000x better. What we got just ruined the show for me honestly. Even though this is a what if scenario it manages to still stay faithful to the story whilst ending in a sad but satisfying way.
@@KamleshPatel-md5kv maybe, but Levi was my favorite character since the beginning of the show and I’m okay with how this concluded. The one thing I constantly hear from people who liked the ending when they defend it is “oh people just wanted an ending that was sunshine and rainbows.” I think killing off 3 main characters and having Eren win is much more devastating than having Eren lose and him being the only main character to die in the finale. I actually felt like the ending was sunshine and rainbows. They had all of the main cast live through the finale except for Eren and they tried as hard as possible to make him understandable which just didn’t work for me.
I hope this timeline could honestly be animated and TURTLE QUIRK I honestly appreciate you for putting so much time into these videos i loved every single video and I genuinely thank you
I don't have words to describe this finale, it made me feel sad and make my heart skip a bit like the original anime, I really like this types of videos, I beg you to continue doing series like this because I really love them
ABSOLUTE LOVED THIS MINI SERIES😤🔥but imagine how different the story would’ve been if armin received the founding and attack titan then historia becoming the beast titan and both ackermans as titans
Dude, thank you for this... this was always my biggest "what if" moment of the series, and i couldn't have dreamed of a better story. You went krazy 🙏🏼🙏🏼
I think that Eren could possibly fix the problem of the world being a barren wasteland by transforming each wall titan into plants with the power of the founder. If the founder can erase memories, and change the biology of every Eldian so they can't have kids, I don't see why it wouldn't be able to do that either.
@@SolidusJack Like, in terms of writing. I feel like eternally enslaved is way better than stockholm syndrome especially when slavery and freedom are the main theme of this whole series. And her gone due to being free'd of King Frits slavery after the rumbling would make more sense.
Honestly, I think this is perfect but I still would change one thing, I would keep the curse of Ymir around until Eren dies. I feel like keeping him alive and having the Titan curse dissappear after the rumbling is such a cop-out. It just feels a tad bit too easy. Now I think Eren should deliver a speech to unite the remaining Eldians like what you said but afterwards, he should be too guilty to keep on living so he decides to end himself and commit suicide as retribution for his failures and committing genocide. I feel like that would be very poetic in a way that it will be the exact sae way canon ended with Eren dead and the act of him doing so is what breaks the titan curse. Otherwise it feels too much of a happy ending and it would kind of justified his genocide in a way. I am not saying this is bad, but it could be even better if this was the case.
Killing yourself does not remove your sin from the world, if that's the case people would've forgave hitler by now. Him living is the best outcome so he will feel the guilt all his life like reiner and bertholdt knce did
How is this a happy ending though? Lol. Conflict is still ongoing between the Eldians, Eren can’t live with himself after committing to the rumbling, everyone basically died. If anything it’s an ending that makes at least a little more sense than what we actually got. I would agree that it’s not the best way to end the story had this been what actually happened in canon but because it’s a fan fiction, I think it was extremely well done.
I have totally thought that when eren transported erwin back in time to shiganshina where levi chose him that eren would tell him to swing his arm so that levi would choose armin in hope that would save mikasa in the future but still, it was an amazing idea
What an insane ending. Honestly, the Ackermans dying was the most shocking part of this whole saga. I could not believe it. You got balls for doing that. Another moment I thought was cool was the whole chase with Erwin and Pieck and then Eren bringing him and Historia to paths. That was neat. I also really liked Levi's statue at the end and what it stood for, that was really sweet. Okay, what I'm gonna say next might sound like I'm being mean but it's really more of a compliment than anything because I think the ending should've been extended a bit more. Again, not hating but I think it would have been cool if we got to see Eren's joy (right after the rumbling at least). I mean, he wanted nothing more than to live in a Titan free world and when he got that, his happiness is only mentioned in passing before being miserable. I think a quick celebration of his achievement would have been cool. The next part of the ending I would change would be that Eren dies. After a whole year or two after the rumbling, it makes more sense for Eren to die (could be suicide out of guilt or something else). This would be so poetic as it would show that the age of Titans is truly over. But that's just my personal take honestly. The story makes more sense to me with Eren dying in every universe/ timeline. Again, not hating, it just shows that I loved this so much if I wanted to see more 😅 Loved this saga, love your "What if?" videos and can't wait to see more.
Honestly I think Eren would commit suicide cause I don’t think Eren could live with the fact that not only that his two closet friends are dead but also feeling responsible for Mikasas death
I REALLY enjoyed this series and appreciated all the work you put into this one. If you ever continue with these I'd love to see a version of AOT where Marcel didn't save Reiner, (or was too late to push him out the way something like that) and so Ymir got the Armoured Titan. Possible outcomes could have led to a more strong Marleyan invasion with Marcel being the leader. I would think it would change the story drastically.
I thought I was the only one who thought of idea of Eren turning eldians in Marley to colossal titans in original AOT. I didn’t think I’d see it here.😂
@@Gamfluent do you really think Eren was going to let Floch live after what he did to Mikasa are you saying Eren was being selfish and should have just gotten over it?
Turtle, I just wanted to thank you - truly thank you - for giving Levi some proper rest after all of his services and duties to the Survey Corps. Despite the death of an Ackerman -make that 2- being drastically heart-wrecking, I personally think that Levi deserves a rest - no longer being tortured by his own mental after being the sole survivor of so, so many expeditions. The statue of Levi made me tear up. I'm thankful, Turtle. I truly am.
👏👏awesome work! My favourite part was the solution Erwin presented to eren. It was logical made sense and I think eren’s character would realistically agree with this, especially because of the effect experiencing grisha and eren Kruger’s memories had on him in the main series. Masterful.
I gotta admit that the official ending and this "what if" ending both make me sad.. The way you present this alternate timeline is very well done..Thank you Turtle Quirk for your hard work ^^
Nope what we got is much better than this. Like this isn't bad what he didn't made sense in terms of characters. Like show is based on life of eren mikasa and armin, and he completed ignored them and gave Erwin and historia as main character with eren. Killed mikasa, levi... Character like louis and hitch are getting more importance than reiner jean and connie 😂😂 Two brothers ep>>>> this complete ending
@@KamleshPatel-md5kv spare us that nonsense about the Isayama ending being better then this masterpiece of an ending the Isayama ending made the entirety of the series completely pointless because what happens at the end? THE ISLAND GETS BOMBED all because Armin, Connie, Levi, Mikasa and Hange wanted to be traitors
This, was amazing utterly so , it was a journey I was happy to be a part of, thank you Turtle Quirk. I would say I liked seeing Marley be taken down by Eldia and their new titan shifters, that felt good. I like this much better, it was plenty tragic with the lose of certain characters, and I am a guy who likes Floch, yet I think if he had to make a choice, he'd much prefer a world where Eldia got to live, even if he didn't get to see it.
This was totally amazing. I was hoping you'd do a loop at some point? Like the end of this video would have Eren losing, then the sore loser he is he goes into the past and changes some small detail in what he says or Erwin says in the past that convinces Levi to give to Armin, thus this actually integrates into the real canon, but at the same time I actually really liked this with an entirely independent ending. 10 points!
After seeing this in my recommendations, even though I had forgotten about it since I tried to move on from AOT (it didnt really the manga ending kinda made me feel disappointed), it actually helped me move on from this series. Thank you, Turtle Quirk for this wonderful send off to this series.
Just finished man what a journey. Thank you for making this. Your what if stories are peak and I always love them. I hope we can get many more what ifs that maybe also have alternate endings
This was a phenomenal alternate series, but there's one thing that stuck out to me that I'd definitely change. That is Levi's death scene. There is no way that Eren would've only summoned Mikasa and Floch to the Paths, Levi would've 100% been summoned too. I'd imagine when Levi would've woken up in the Paths a lot earlier than Mikasa and after Eren explained everything to him, Eren would've let Levi roam free in the Paths with one mission in his mind - to torture Floch unimaginably for what he has done. And knowing Levi he would've one hell of a job making sure Floch regretted ever being born, that when Eren would've eventually closed the Paths and time would've went on normally - Floch would've been in a vegetable state mentally from all of the torturing that Levi would've done to him in the Paths. Therefore, this way at least Levi would've gotten his revenge to Floch for killing him and Mikasa and Levi's death wouldn't have felt so empty as in this video. Nevertheless, besides this one alternative I'd make, this was absolutely awesome!
How about the Eldians from the outside world not having revenge against the islanders? Why is there no civil war happening from the coerced coexistence? Why are the outsiders not trying to get out of the island to rebuild society on the mainland as they know more advanced technology? How did the Titan curse suddenly disappear from Ymir without encountering the Hallucigenia? Don’t mean to sound ungrateful as those are only minor nitpicks for this mini-series that I have been following since the start. Thank you so much for doing this, Turtle Quirk.
I can answer these! 1 & 2: the outside eldians are *greatly* outnumbered. There’s no civil war for the same reason there was no civil war when they were living in Marley 3 . Outside world is a barren wasteland with no food, no animals etc. No one could survive. They also don’t have any tech, they just have knowledge. It’s like if I stranded you in a desert, would you be able you make a smartphone from scratch? Probably not hah 4. If Ymir is free from creating the titans, then the titans will always vanish Hope that answers everything, thank you for watching 🎉
@@TurtleQuirk Thanks man. Happy to be here. 1 & 2. Who’s to say the Eldians in the outside world are outnumbered globally? Karl Fritz might not have gotten a lot of them from a century ago and they reproduced during the time gap. 3. Fair point, but some of them might bear a lot of hatred that they would rather risk going outside than stay on the island. 4. Like the OG ending, who’s to say that Ymir has moved on? The Titans could still continue as long as the glowing worm exists.
@hessiankyojim couldn’t the eldians from the outside would just move somewhere far from the eldians of the island and create their own society on the island cause most of the island is still likely uninhabited and haven’t been touched for hundreds of years scene most people are still living where the walls once were and their not being kept in interment zones anymore
Such a Beautiful Sad Ending. Eldians finally experiencing peace through the death of billions is heart wrecking. Anyway, great Timeline though. Keep up the good work🌟.
Chapter 139.5; After Mikasa and Armin stop the rumbling sparing 20% of humanity which Marley later repays Paradis back by dropping war bombs on Shiganshina and the extermination of all Eldians out of bloody revenge. Eren and the Survey Corps all died for nothing, Floch and the Yeagerists were right along. The entire world was the true enemy outside the walls and never wanted peace.
Damn just wow. This really hits home like I almost teared up when Eren was shocked after destroying the world and him hugging Historia like this feels like ending. It works and feels ending I swear this gave goosebumps like reliving my old childhood seeing AOT when I was a small boy being spooked of the titans and loving the characters. FUCK!! This was one of the best videos I have ever watched from you. I hope the AOT ending is a good as this. I'm as whole speechless 10/10. Like this is the first ever video that touched my heart, It felt good. I love these videos. This was the ending we needed god damn it's hard to write this without feeling like crying but I must stay strong and keep moving forward. FUCK bro I loved this what if not amount of words can express how I'm feeling right now.
Eren felt so terrible for killing historia's family, and she was hearing him say it in front of her, yet she still hugged him. Historia's character arc couldn't have a better conclusion
literally the perfect aot ending.. this is what i imagined after the retaking wall maria arc ended. a war against marley, new an interesting characters, and eren getting revenge on the people who destroyed his house all those years ago. i really wish the aot creator didnt want to push the message he is with the final few seasons and instead let it play out more interestingly and naturally
i've been following this series since the beginning, you've done such a good job with creating this alternate timeline! if you're interested in doing another "what if?" i'd like to see one where ymir (freckles) doesn't leave after season 2. it may not e as long as this one, but i feel like there'd be much more significant changes than some would believe
This AU is much more satisfying to me than the one we're actually given. Even though I'm still disappointed Hange, Jean, Mikasa, and Levi died, this turn of events makes more sense to me and is more justifiable to the course of the story.
Much better ending to the series imo. There are still major losses in Mikasa, Levi and Jean, but with a satisfying ending that achieves true freedom for Paradis.
If you enjoyed this alternate timeline please drop a LIKE on this video 😌 what do you think of the ending??
PS. Watch all 7 Parts HERE: ruclips.net/p/PL5__VO0MYmiS7_xSxOi8Hs3fWVXLudofA
🐐🐐🐐🐐🐐🐐🐐
Now we need the armin armored part 2
Hey there turtle, are you gonna do a what-if levi squad survived. Oh, and have forgotten about the what-if armin got the armoured titan part 2, since toy left it on a cliffhanger. Ty for this series
What is Eren Yeager find John in the street fight with me cause a fight any in a street fight
Throughouly enjoyed the entire series thanks you 😊🎉
The way this what if ended left a severe impact, the Ackermans actually dying shocked me more than flochs betrayal, Eldians around the world coming back to paradis, Erwin status reaching legendary heights and Eren path to freedom and peace still continues even after the Eldian empire is the last nation standing. Turtle quirk is a beast with these what if scenarios.
370 likes and NO comments? Imma fix dat
@@JULES_PROFIT Perish.
eldia's still standing better than they ever did
7:26 If I had a nickel every time Eren threatened to make an Armor Titan die in the worst way possible, I'd have two nickels. Which isn't a lot, but it's weird that it happened twice.
LMAOOO
Huh, kinda weird yet ironic
Toph reference?
@@varunkaushik2732 No, it's Doofenshmirtz
Poor Floch, the man was just doing his job
This ending felt like a 'True anime ending' eren is alive, but at the cost of losing mikasa. The descrimination on the eldians who came from Marley just makes the ending so much better. We've come a long way watching this 'what if' thank you for making this! ^^
tbh i dont like the fact that billions died. but that's just me.
@@jmgonzales7701 no one does. But its still good 8/10
@@jmgonzales7701 Billions still died in the main ending.
@@jmgonzales7701 Sounds like copium ED
@@guangxi1654 not really, not everyone was wiped out.
Let's all take a moment to appreciate this series as a whole, truly brilliant!
From this episode especially the ARTWORK on the Colossal reaching out to the Armoured!
Mad respect to everyone involved in the production of this and thanks a lot! ^^
I got to admit I like this ending more than the canonical one. My only complaint is the loss of Hitch as the Female Titan, would’ve been nice if she did more and survived.
Yeah
Plus her Titan had some bakery if you know what I mean
@@aerickmon3350 I assume you meant her rear end. Yes I was aware.
A bit unnecessary yes, they could've just shown her incapacitated since it's her first time in titan form.
yeah me too i really wanna fuck hitch from attack on titan
In all honestly this feels like a sort of “good” ending for attack on titan, especially if you know how the manga ends. This version loops things around to the beginning in a way, the idea that this tiny area holds what’s left of humanity
im high asf and was thinking “is eren gonna erase their memories of the outside world to stop the segregation? making the entire story pointless?” if that was the ending i would’ve been laughing my ass off😭
The thing is conflict and war will always happen I mean look at the war between the scouts and the military police or the scouts vs the yeagerist eventually they would wipe each other out
@@justbethinking honestly thought that's what would have happened once I heard that some folks are being racist on Paradis
It would most likely be a hollow victory for eren.
@@Gamfluent would they ? The last thing Eren would do is take away the freedom and control them .
The people of the island would probably split apart and fight each other .
They would probably fight over resources due to their population increasing and because mostly everything in the mainland is a burned up wasteland . Look at island nations like Japan . They have limited land for farming and cattle. So they sometimes rely on other countries for resources.
this alternate timeline is so well written that it should be an anime of its own
Crazy to think that Levi’s one decision of saving Erwin or Armin could change the fate of the entire world drastically
99% of the world took the colosal L either way 😂
@@antiepix9555 true😂
@@shlattboi764Too bad Paradis got destroyed at the end of the manga, Hajime Isayama is a hack!
Ikr😂
@@Solaris_Paradoxwhy would you spoil
12:25 this part puts a whole new destructive meaning to “If you can’t beat them, Join them”.
Was it only Marley's Eldian's that Eren transformed? Or did he do the same thing to every single Eldian across the world on top of all the Rumbling stuff?
@ Mr. Needle-Hamster It was every Eldian across the planet.
@@averageidiot8851 OK
1. Anime/manga ending - Happy ending (bittersweet)
2. Isayamas original ending (where everyone dies) - Sad ending
3. Turtle quirks ending - True ending
4. Before ymir reaches the tree, she trips, hits her head on a rock and dies ending - Secret ending
LOVE THIS… I’m so sad that this is over:( I feel like this is more exciting than the actual show!!! You and your team are so talented and so hardworking! I love your videos!
So in this timeline, Eren will be forced to live out his life alone as punishment for committing omnicide? I like it! And to make it worse for him, he even felt like he traded so many lives for his own freedom sometimes to the point that he lost faith in himself is something that is very well executed.
And I like how the aftermath has shown the tension rising between what can be described as local Eldians Vs outside Eldians here because it looked really realistic here. After all, some resentment towarded Marley will be on to them since there are no Marleyans left to blame anymore. Except for those who have been taken prisoners during the war, of course. As for the Mid-Eastern and Hizuru peoples, I wished some of them survived and restarted their civilizations soon despite how much unlikely it is.
@@Gamfluent I “support”the rumbling (support is a loose word for it) but killing billions of people is never right. It may be what’s needed for survival but calling it right isn’t correct
@@remphz3321 Killing people in seelf defense is always right.
@@knightofcarrion7358 True. But that's not what Eren is doing
@@remphz3321 he literally said that's what he was doing lol
@@knightofcarrion7358 he’s killing innocent people like Ramzi who didn’t even persecute the Eldians
I'd like to say thank you for putting this all together. It's been an incredible take on this huge "What If?" scenario, and I've enjoyed every minute of it.
A stand out moment for me was Historia inheriting the jaw Titan,as although Ymir is still gone,along with the power of the titans,it feels like she’s even more connected to her now🥲
I love this series thanks for all the hard work you did to make it for us
Thanks for watching 😄
@@TurtleQuirk no need to thank me it was a pleasure to watch
this is one of the best fan WHAT IF aot stories I've ever witnessed. Truly matches the style of how it would go aw well, very good work
Loved this ending, as it really feels like Eren didn't get what he wanted in the end, all he wanted was to protect his friends, and as he went down this path, both Armin and Mikasa aren't there to see the freedom he wanted. I will forever believe that this was a possibility and that he had some influence over Armin being picked over Erwin. To save both. But inevitably become their enemies.
I'm gonna miss this series so much, loved the ending 🥲
This is a sad but good ending, I love it.
This is the best what if series I've seen I love the effort to make the custom still frames whoever did that deserves all the praise thanks for making this
TBH this is more sadder than the original AOT series, instead of Eren Sacrifice Himself for longer life of his love ones, this one is the opposite. And whats insteresting thing though is that the titan power is gone after rumbling when they returned to paradise island that woudn't potentially recycle the power of titan like eren's head was burried then the tree grew so gigantic similar to Ymir's Event. But this ending is a lot better i think. Well done Work for this video! Love it!
A shame this series ended it became my favorite. literally amazing
I waited excitedly for every episode to drop last year so happy to see it ended on a good note. I just can't explain how legendary this series is, we also gotta get a part two on What If Armin had the Armored Titan.
I loved how you took some of the aspects of the main manga like character motivations that didn't make sense at first and actually made them work especially the romance between Eren and Mikasa. Although there are some few flaws like certain character development it's easily excusable because it can be expanded if this ever became an actual manga series. W writing W character development. Would definitely watch again.
Sad it’s all over but I’m happy with the ending. Great Work!
My favorite parts of this series was part 3 and 4. It was awesome and interesting to see the different variations of titan shifters and their titans.
I can’t believe this series is over already. Do you plan on making more What If stories/ separate timelines?
I do! but I don’t think they’ll ever be as long as this one again hahah
Wait it's is? Where did you see it?
@@Thatgurl look at the title bru
@@TurtleQuirk you gotta give me more what if Armin inherited the Armoured brother
And are you open to suggestions for a new one? If so I'd love to see what if Levi fed the beast Titan to Armin a far more significant change because Eren now has no royal blood titan to help his goals and will have to find an alternative route or a completely new one
@@TurtleQuirk just in case ur open to ideas, I think it would be interesting to see a “What if Levi never became a scout?” Cause not only would the scouts have to go through the hardships without him, Levi would still be a criminal with a good chance of him joining the military police along with Kenny. That also means Mikasa would be the most powerful soldier with no one to hold her back when eren gets kidnapped
tbh i really like this timeline but i do want to see some more episodes of what happens after this because it just sounds really cool this is a piece of art really good work dude 😁
Unironically I prefer this to what we got. Actual diplomacy and people not waiting on their hands until Eren left. Needs to get animated expeditiously
Now that the show has officially ended I have to say this ending is 1000x better. What we got just ruined the show for me honestly. Even though this is a what if scenario it manages to still stay faithful to the story whilst ending in a sad but satisfying way.
@@hyperboi4077ending where mikasa, levi and armin got killed 😂😂. Fans would hate it more than what we got
@@KamleshPatel-md5kv maybe, but Levi was my favorite character since the beginning of the show and I’m okay with how this concluded. The one thing I constantly hear from people who liked the ending when they defend it is “oh people just wanted an ending that was sunshine and rainbows.” I think killing off 3 main characters and having Eren win is much more devastating than having Eren lose and him being the only main character to die in the finale. I actually felt like the ending was sunshine and rainbows. They had all of the main cast live through the finale except for Eren and they tried as hard as possible to make him understandable which just didn’t work for me.
Dam dude this is the most dedicated breakdown of an alternate timeline ive ever watched. Sick videos bro and keep on making these excellent what ifs!
I hope this timeline could honestly be animated and TURTLE QUIRK I honestly appreciate you for putting so much time into these videos i loved every single video and I genuinely thank you
I don't have words to describe this finale, it made me feel sad and make my heart skip a bit like the original anime, I really like this types of videos, I beg you to continue doing series like this because I really love them
ABSOLUTE LOVED THIS MINI SERIES😤🔥but imagine how different the story would’ve been if armin received the founding and attack titan then historia becoming the beast titan and both ackermans as titans
Dude, thank you for this... this was always my biggest "what if" moment of the series, and i couldn't have dreamed of a better story. You went krazy 🙏🏼🙏🏼
Thank you for doing this bro this is one of the best what ifs about anything I’ve ever watched
w series, I hope we get another series of this magnitude at some point
Man this is just...crazy. I wish there was a way to make this into an animated series. Or like a simple comic slideshow with voice acting and music.
I've thoroughly enjoyed this alt ending, as it's reignited my love for aot, thank you
I think that Eren could possibly fix the problem of the world being a barren wasteland by transforming each wall titan into plants with the power of the founder. If the founder can erase memories, and change the biology of every Eldian so they can't have kids, I don't see why it wouldn't be able to do that either.
Yeah but Ymir left after eren did rumbling
@@bruh_moment2833 only bc of that dumbass plotline with her letting go of her """love""" for King Fritz.
@@SolidusJack yeah that was very random
@@SolidusJack Like, in terms of writing. I feel like eternally enslaved is way better than stockholm syndrome especially when slavery and freedom are the main theme of this whole series. And her gone due to being free'd of King Frits slavery after the rumbling would make more sense.
@@suisus3780 yeah I agree
God this is so good would love to see it as like a short manga or something in the future
Happy I finally found the time to watch through this entire what if, great stuff as usual
Hell to the yes We were missing you turtle quirk
man that statue of levi is the best thing erwin could've done it warms my heart
Honestly, I think this is perfect but I still would change one thing, I would keep the curse of Ymir around until Eren dies. I feel like keeping him alive and having the Titan curse dissappear after the rumbling is such a cop-out. It just feels a tad bit too easy. Now I think Eren should deliver a speech to unite the remaining Eldians like what you said but afterwards, he should be too guilty to keep on living so he decides to end himself and commit suicide as retribution for his failures and committing genocide. I feel like that would be very poetic in a way that it will be the exact sae way canon ended with Eren dead and the act of him doing so is what breaks the titan curse. Otherwise it feels too much of a happy ending and it would kind of justified his genocide in a way. I am not saying this is bad, but it could be even better if this was the case.
Eren "keep moving forward" Yeager committing suicide? Really?
"Until all my enemies... are destroyed."
Killing yourself does not remove your sin from the world, if that's the case people would've forgave hitler by now.
Him living is the best outcome so he will feel the guilt all his life like reiner and bertholdt knce did
How is this a happy ending though? Lol. Conflict is still ongoing between the Eldians, Eren can’t live with himself after committing to the rumbling, everyone basically died. If anything it’s an ending that makes at least a little more sense than what we actually got. I would agree that it’s not the best way to end the story had this been what actually happened in canon but because it’s a fan fiction, I think it was extremely well done.
*omnicide
Thank you for this, it’s been fun and I’ll miss it tbh
Erwin seeing Levi die: "I miscalculated."
loved the personalised art and erens full use of the warhammer. amazing series over nearly 1.5 years xoxo
I have totally thought that when eren transported erwin back in time to shiganshina where levi chose him that eren would tell him to swing his arm so that levi would choose armin in hope that would save mikasa in the future but still, it was an amazing idea
What an insane ending.
Honestly, the Ackermans dying was the most shocking part of this whole saga. I could not believe it. You got balls for doing that.
Another moment I thought was cool was the whole chase with Erwin and Pieck and then Eren bringing him and Historia to paths. That was neat.
I also really liked Levi's statue at the end and what it stood for, that was really sweet.
Okay, what I'm gonna say next might sound like I'm being mean but it's really more of a compliment than anything because I think the ending should've been extended a bit more.
Again, not hating but I think it would have been cool if we got to see Eren's joy (right after the rumbling at least). I mean, he wanted nothing more than to live in a Titan free world and when he got that, his happiness is only mentioned in passing before being miserable. I think a quick celebration of his achievement would have been cool.
The next part of the ending I would change would be that Eren dies. After a whole year or two after the rumbling, it makes more sense for Eren to die (could be suicide out of guilt or something else). This would be so poetic as it would show that the age of Titans is truly over. But that's just my personal take honestly. The story makes more sense to me with Eren dying in every universe/ timeline.
Again, not hating, it just shows that I loved this so much if I wanted to see more 😅
Loved this saga, love your "What if?" videos and can't wait to see more.
Honestly I think Eren would commit suicide cause I don’t think Eren could live with the fact that not only that his two closet friends are dead but also feeling responsible for Mikasas death
The power of the titans is already over tho Ymir left after the rumbling was done
this is actually a better ending to aot than the canon ending great job on this
Lol Paradis deserves to be destroyed by the Global Alliance at the end of the manga. Eldia started the violence.
@@Solaris_Paradox no they should'be be blamed for something there ancestors did
I REALLY enjoyed this series and appreciated all the work you put into this one. If you ever continue with these I'd love to see a version of AOT where Marcel didn't save Reiner, (or was too late to push him out the way something like that) and so Ymir got the Armoured Titan. Possible outcomes could have led to a more strong Marleyan invasion with Marcel being the leader. I would think it would change the story drastically.
I thought I was the only one who thought of idea of Eren turning eldians in Marley to colossal titans in original AOT. I didn’t think I’d see it here.😂
Even in this timeline, Floch is still a hero. Sacrificed himself for his nation, we will forever remember you, KING.
Shinzo wo Sasageyo !
Floch killed Mikasa he is not a hero
@@gojirawilson3611Floch>Mikasa
@@Solaris_Paradox Floch sucks and is a kissass
@@Gamfluent do you really think Eren was going to let Floch live after what he did to Mikasa are you saying Eren was being selfish and should have just gotten over it?
Turtle, I just wanted to thank you - truly thank you - for giving Levi some proper rest after all of his services and duties to the Survey Corps. Despite the death of an Ackerman -make that 2- being drastically heart-wrecking, I personally think that Levi deserves a rest - no longer being tortured by his own mental after being the sole survivor of so, so many expeditions.
The statue of Levi made me tear up.
I'm thankful, Turtle. I truly am.
Wow ur so grateful 😊
👏👏awesome work! My favourite part was the solution Erwin presented to eren. It was logical made sense and I think eren’s character would realistically agree with this, especially because of the effect experiencing grisha and eren Kruger’s memories had on him in the main series. Masterful.
I gotta admit that the official ending and this "what if" ending both make me sad.. The way you present this alternate timeline is very well done..Thank you Turtle Quirk for your hard work ^^
this was a really incredile series my dude I love what you did with the story.
What you have done with this series insane. What a masterpiece
This series was amazing. A great alternate ending that makes me wish this was how the the original series ended. 10/10!!!!
reminds me of carthus jojo but ngl i might fw this more than the actual ending make more🙏🏾
Absolutely amazing. This is what creativity looks like.
That's just amazing, dude. Greatest Job!!!
This was amazing. You *need* to write your own manga, book, whatever. The ending felt really emotional too.
Glad this part is over. It's been a long time watching these videos about Erwin and his Colossal Titan power. See u on friday @TurtleQuirk.
Better than what we got for sure
Nope what we got is much better than this.
Like this isn't bad what he didn't made sense in terms of characters.
Like show is based on life of eren mikasa and armin, and he completed ignored them and gave Erwin and historia as main character with eren.
Killed mikasa, levi...
Character like louis and hitch are getting more importance than reiner jean and connie 😂😂
Two brothers ep>>>> this complete ending
@@KamleshPatel-md5kv spare us that nonsense about the Isayama ending being better then this masterpiece of an ending the Isayama ending made the entirety of the series completely pointless because what happens at the end? THE ISLAND GETS BOMBED all because Armin, Connie, Levi, Mikasa and Hange wanted to be traitors
Lil buddy had to yap@@KamleshPatel-md5kv
Now that's a ending very well worth the wait man top shelf stuff
love u, you make my turtle quirk :)
This, was amazing utterly so , it was a journey I was happy to be a part of, thank you Turtle Quirk. I would say I liked seeing Marley be taken down by Eldia and their new titan shifters, that felt good. I like this much better, it was plenty tragic with the lose of certain characters, and I am a guy who likes Floch, yet I think if he had to make a choice, he'd much prefer a world where Eldia got to live, even if he didn't get to see it.
This so much better than the actual ending
You did an amazing job at this alternate universe and it would be sick if you could get someone to animate it all
I can imagine Erwin singing Sasageyo as he walks with the wall titans
This was totally amazing.
I was hoping you'd do a loop at some point? Like the end of this video would have Eren losing, then the sore loser he is he goes into the past and changes some small detail in what he says or Erwin says in the past that convinces Levi to give to Armin, thus this actually integrates into the real canon, but at the same time I actually really liked this with an entirely independent ending.
10 points!
"Isayama works hard,but turtle quirk works harder"
-a wise man
After seeing this in my recommendations, even though I had forgotten about it since I tried to move on from AOT (it didnt really the manga ending kinda made me feel disappointed), it actually helped me move on from this series. Thank you, Turtle Quirk for this wonderful send off to this series.
Just finished man what a journey. Thank you for making this. Your what if stories are peak and I always love them. I hope we can get many more what ifs that maybe also have alternate endings
This was a phenomenal alternate series, but there's one thing that stuck out to me that I'd definitely change.
That is Levi's death scene. There is no way that Eren would've only summoned Mikasa and Floch to the Paths, Levi would've 100% been summoned too. I'd imagine when Levi would've woken up in the Paths a lot earlier than Mikasa and after Eren explained everything to him, Eren would've let Levi roam free in the Paths with one mission in his mind - to torture Floch unimaginably for what he has done. And knowing Levi he would've one hell of a job making sure Floch regretted ever being born, that when Eren would've eventually closed the Paths and time would've went on normally - Floch would've been in a vegetable state mentally from all of the torturing that Levi would've done to him in the Paths. Therefore, this way at least Levi would've gotten his revenge to Floch for killing him and Mikasa and Levi's death wouldn't have felt so empty as in this video.
Nevertheless, besides this one alternative I'd make, this was absolutely awesome!
How about the Eldians from the outside world not having revenge against the islanders?
Why is there no civil war happening from the coerced coexistence?
Why are the outsiders not trying to get out of the island to rebuild society on the mainland as they know more advanced technology?
How did the Titan curse suddenly disappear from Ymir without encountering the Hallucigenia?
Don’t mean to sound ungrateful as those are only minor nitpicks for this mini-series that I have been following since the start.
Thank you so much for doing this, Turtle Quirk.
I can answer these!
1 & 2: the outside eldians are *greatly* outnumbered. There’s no civil war for the same reason there was no civil war when they were living in Marley
3 . Outside world is a barren wasteland with no food, no animals etc. No one could survive. They also don’t have any tech, they just have knowledge. It’s like if I stranded you in a desert, would you be able you make a smartphone from scratch? Probably not hah
4. If Ymir is free from creating the titans, then the titans will always vanish
Hope that answers everything, thank you for watching 🎉
@@TurtleQuirk Thanks man. Happy to be here.
1 & 2. Who’s to say the Eldians in the outside world are outnumbered globally? Karl Fritz might not have gotten a lot of them from a century ago and they reproduced during the time gap.
3. Fair point, but some of them might bear a lot of hatred that they would rather risk going outside than stay on the island.
4. Like the OG ending, who’s to say that Ymir has moved on? The Titans could still continue as long as the glowing worm exists.
@hessiankyojim couldn’t the eldians from the outside would just move somewhere far from the eldians of the island and create their own society on the island cause most of the island is still likely uninhabited and haven’t been touched for hundreds of years scene most people are still living where the walls once were and their not being kept in interment zones anymore
All I can say is thank you for making this amazing series.
The perfect ending to Attack on Titan, Bravo Turtle, Bravo.
Such a Beautiful Sad Ending. Eldians finally experiencing peace through the death of billions is heart wrecking.
Anyway, great Timeline though. Keep up the good work🌟.
Chapter 139.5; After Mikasa and Armin stop the rumbling sparing 20% of humanity which Marley later repays Paradis back by dropping war bombs on Shiganshina and the extermination of all Eldians out of bloody revenge.
Eren and the Survey Corps all died for nothing, Floch and the Yeagerists were right along. The entire world was the true enemy outside the walls and never wanted peace.
Fantastic video dude!
Thanks man! took a lot outta me but it’s worth it 😩🔥🔥
Damn just wow. This really hits home like I almost teared up when Eren was shocked after destroying the world and him hugging Historia like this feels like ending. It works and feels ending I swear this gave goosebumps like reliving my old childhood seeing AOT when I was a small boy being spooked of the titans and loving the characters. FUCK!! This was one of the best videos I have ever watched from you. I hope the AOT ending is a good as this. I'm as whole speechless 10/10. Like this is the first ever video that touched my heart, It felt good. I love these videos. This was the ending we needed god damn it's hard to write this without feeling like crying but I must stay strong and keep moving forward. FUCK bro I loved this what if not amount of words can express how I'm feeling right now.
Eren felt so terrible for killing historia's family, and she was hearing him say it in front of her, yet she still hugged him. Historia's character arc couldn't have a better conclusion
@@Philthorn Fr
@@J-Man1000 AOT already has an ending. At least the manga. And, well, many and also I believe it is horrible
@@Philthorn and this is the reason i ship erehisu as a ship and platonic friendship
literally the perfect aot ending.. this is what i imagined after the retaking wall maria arc ended. a war against marley, new an interesting characters, and eren getting revenge on the people who destroyed his house all those years ago. i really wish the aot creator didnt want to push the message he is with the final few seasons and instead let it play out more interestingly and naturally
In my opinion i feel like this would be more interesting to watch than the main plot
best series on youtube ive seen this year
Don't have words for this.. just wanna say thank you man .
One of the greatest journey ends a couple of days before last part of anime...nice time
I like the ending more than the actual ending
i've been following this series since the beginning, you've done such a good job with creating this alternate timeline!
if you're interested in doing another "what if?" i'd like to see one where ymir (freckles) doesn't leave after season 2. it may not e as long as this one, but i feel like there'd be much more significant changes than some would believe
My video literally froze when you said it was frozen in time
Honestly, I think you should keep it goin. I wanna see what happens next.
I wanna see Eren help make things right. I wanna know what's next.
perfection, like the real show, depressing but perfect
I cant believe I got emotional for Levi and mikasa in a what if theory 😭😭 im still healing from the original story 😭😭
This AU is much more satisfying to me than the one we're actually given. Even though I'm still disappointed Hange, Jean, Mikasa, and Levi died, this turn of events makes more sense to me and is more justifiable to the course of the story.
It’s mainly because the main goals they fought for came to be and they didn’t have to suffer more
This series. Is my favorite Aot what if!
You have made a real legendary what if!
This would be so very awesome if it got ever a anime adaptation.
This is one dark alternative future in AOT
I watched all parts of this wild theory and i somehow like it. I have even made up myself an alternative future of what would have happend otherwise
We need a ovo season of it 💯
I just binged these again for the new season
Much better ending to the series imo. There are still major losses in Mikasa, Levi and Jean, but with a satisfying ending that achieves true freedom for Paradis.