Who should I react to next: www.maggierenee.com/book-me/sponsor-a-reaction-live What should I sing next: www.maggierenee.com/book-me/sponsor-a-song-liveAnd just for you: ‘Sing Better Instantly" my FREE Singing Course: skl.sh/3aHdSuy and for EXCLUSIVE VIDEOS AND PERKS: www.patreon.com/MaggieRenee
WOW, WOW. What a glorious rendition of this classic song. Unbelievable. Better than any version I have ever heard. Lucy is so talented and has a gorgeous tone with perfect pitch that puts her head and shoulders above most singers of her generation. Lucy is phenomenal. Only once in a lifetime does someone like Lucy come along! She makes a masterpiece of every song she sings!! We are all blessed to have Lucy spreading love and light in our troubled world. She is a gem!!
I have been following this girl since her beginnings at age 11 on kids singing shows. Her tones are magical!!! never have i heard a negative word toward anyone. Besides that she has shown us her wonderful life and family in the UK. She is just adorable! Jim
...and what a beautiful performance it is, she sounds even better live then in studio which makes a complete mockery of those trying to discredit her because of the pitch correction being added to her voice on the recordings.
She was about 19.5 here. She went 20 on feb 21. I think nothing happens is this song outside her control. She is fantastic. It sounds like she still has some air left after the last note🥰 I hear much more dedication and perfection with Lucy than with Babs.
Glad that you had no hesitation to hear Lucy again at her finest. The technique used by her is masterful and you were able to catch on to them pretty easily. Try We Can Change The World from her upcoming musical Rosie.
Love the way Lucy’s warm rich voice just caresses the notes of this song! I’ve always loved this Barbara Streisand song, and Lucy really does it justice. As you said so well, she does indeed use a stunning and “floaty” voice technique. Just gorgeous! ❤️
Hi, Maggie... you actually have heard this song before. You reacted to the OG of it about 6 or 7 months ago. You may recall it was the scene from the movie "A Star Is Born" with Barbra and Kris Kristofferson. "Evergreen" was written by Streisand with lyracist Paul Williams and went on to win an Oscar for Best Song in a Motion Picture, and two Grammys. The scene and song from the movie was actually done in one take... it was the rehearsal, but was so good they put it in the movie as is. Just a little history on this classic song.
"Kermit the frog quality" - so funny, yet so true! As an ex-chorister with over 20 years choral singing, all I can say is Lucy TRULY must have the voice of an angel - it cannot be improved. She melts my heart - technicalities are not important, emotion is everything.
Hello Maggie. Thank you so much for the insightful review of Lucy. Lucy has a way of drawing you into a song and gently hanging on to your soul. On March 5th this year Lucy performed her first live concert in Manchester, UK. She has just released the first song of that evening. She performed 17 songs that night and two of them included Martha. I am looking forward to the remainder of the recordings. As you know Lucy has recorded 60 songs and growing. I would like to see you react to more of Lucy’s recordings. I don’t know which song is best because I like all of them. Stay Free, Safe, and Healthy my friend.
Hello Maggie, thank you for reacting to Lucy singing " Evergreen " this is Lucy at her best singing a copy of her idol Barbara Streisand & she sings this cover so beautifully, Lucy has such an amazing voice so very beautiful, she is moving up the ladder to stardom. Take care Barbara.
Nice comments Barbara. You are always right there to comment and always have the brightest things to say. I am afraid it won’t be to long we lose our Lucy angel to the beast of the entertainment word. But she is the best vocalist of today and I would say in history. Be free, safe, and healthy.
her name..which is on dozen albums and countless awards and milions of articles is..Barbra. One of her album, one of her tv shows and last years memoir are in fact called...my name is BARBRA
Kudos i ripped into you on your reaction to Lucy and Martha's The Prayer because you didn't understand how young Martha was and their pronunciation of Italian wasn't perfect, but now you can see Lucy is the one chasing a singing career and Martha isn't. Lucy is by far the best female singer i've heard in years and will succeed in her chosen field of musicals of that i have no doubt.
You don't know Evergreen? Granted the song is 48 years old and your field classical music, but I find it remarkable that even top pop singers don't know the history of music from even 20 years earlier. There are exceptions who are de facto historians, like Lady Gaga, but the ignorance in their their own field of expertise is amazing. This may be the only, song by Barbra Streisand that she gets a writing credit, for the music--Paul Williams wrote the lyrics. It earned an Academy award for best original song and it was a number one hit for Barbra.
@@jamesprior2496 You obviously weren't paying attention. I could tell you to watch the video again but I'll save you some time. At 2:18 Maggie clearly says she doesn't know this song.
Please react to one of Lucy’s original songs such as her most recent “We can change the World” or “ Broken dreams” both from the, as yet unreleased musical “ Rosie” which has been written with Lucy’s voice in mind
Interesting to say Lucy has come a long way since hearing her brilliant rendition of Hallelujah, However, Lucy did a cover of "Memory" from the musical "Cats" when she was a mere fifteen years old. Her lower register at one point reached the low "f". But towards the end she explodes with an absolute sonic Belt. Her soprano tone throughout this masterpiece is unbelievable for someone so young, Would be interesting to get your take on it!
Lucy was 20 in February, I don't know if you reacted to her cover of Somewhere from West Side Story but if you did you might want to check out the live version she did at her first live Concert in Manchester that is now available on her RUclips channel.
Stunning,check out Lucy's first major concert in Manchester on 5th March!,she opened with 'Somewhere' ,others will follow,you need to check out some of Lucy's 70 odd video's to understand she dosen't play safe!,one I would recommend is 'A Whiter Shade of Pale',gorgeous!😊.Ps. I think she has brushed up on her Italian since you last asses her!😉
With all respect to Barbara this cover by Lucy is better than the original. It is a hallmark of Lucy's that many of her covers are better then the original. And of course Lucy has released several of her own songs (written by Chris Broom) from the forthcoming musical "Rosie". As you say Maggie, simply stunning!
We are fortunate to live in a marvelous time of great young female singers...Arpi Alto, Laura Bretan, Emily Bear, Harriett, Emma Kok, Emily Linge, Malinda. Lucy Thomas, probably more. Alphabetical here, all favorites. Wish I would live long enough to watch them grow.
Glad there's someone else out there who appreciates the contributions of Paul Williams. I have several CD's of Paul singing his songs and this is one of them.
Hello Ms. Renee, I know you are very busy, but I would love to see your reaction on another Lucy Thomas song. She has two newly released songs. One is "Unchained Melody " by Righteous Brothers, then "One moment in time " Whitney Houston. Thanks...❤😊
@@doloreschokas3844 I know the Barbra Streisand version very well, I sponsored it for Maggie long ago as part of a Featured Artist set. I stand by my opinion. You of course are entitled to yours. Debating opinions never leads anywhere.
I don't understand the comparisons with Barbara or Celine she sounds nothing like them and her vibrato isn't as harsh and shrieky and is alot more smooth and sounds classically trained, personally I think she's already much better then the aforementioned and more in the Karen Carpenter mold if anyone at all.
@@Julien-pt6qsOooow. I don't usually react toTrolls but on this one you've got my attention. Sounds like you've got a grievance, sad. Firstly, you have absolutely no proof this took more than one take. Secondly, you're obviously not a musician if you're inferring this a copy of Barbra Streisand rendition. Lucy's voice is uniquely superior to both Streisand and Dion's. And this rendition is kept true to the original as a tribute to Barbra Streisand.
@@Julien-pt6qsshe just sang live in her Manchester concert and did great, so you’re wrong. She can sing and she’ll be more famous in the next few years
@@Julien-pt6qs What nonsense you talk 😂 You can be influenced and pay tribute to an artist that inspired you which Barbara Streisand clearly did for Lucy and she has openly admitted this but there's a major difference between being influenced and merely being a copycat, Lucy does not copy she only enhances and improves already well known songs. Her tonality and vibrato are unmistakable and completely unique to her.
@@Julien-pt6qsA lot of singers that put their twist to great classic are just shredding the songs. So better stick to a version and make it great than being original and scrap it!
Sorry, respect you're classically trained, but your voice tone does not come anywhere near Lucy's quality or softness when trying to replicate in this reaction. 😏
Lucy is very good, but if you want to hear a love theme with real punch check out Leah Barniville singing "Parla Pia Piano ' in her semi final appearance on Britain's got Talent.
When you make song your own, it is rarely as good as the original. I literally prefer when people copy the original and make it sound perfect. One in a while a remake is as good or better than the original, but that really only occurs with established groups or singers who create great music in own their right.
Try her version of "Bridge Over Troubled Waters" One of my all time favourites from it's first release 1971 I think it was along with all of Simon and Garfunkel's music. I hesitated to listen originally because the original is so much a part of my memories and I have heard versions that did it no justice. I know how good she is and have followed her for several years, I shouldn't have doubted her it is magnificent.
You are so right on your last comment, to me she feel so young with no caractere... she sings well like good singer in a karaoke she is about 20, Barbra at her age was fare ahead in her own artistic path. hear brabra at her age, her song choices and original spin on classic standards... Barbra is a legend that everyone is admiring curious to see our she is making song her own, like steve wonder golden hits(all is faire in love, You & I...) anyway lucy is forgettable if she does not put emotions and take artistic risks that will make her special ...many good singers only few icones
Lucy's vibrato is far cleaner and free in the high end range, when Barbara used to try full belt I'm sorry to say she started shrieking and was no longer actually singing with pure tone and I mean no disrespect to Barbara Streisand who is amazing and a legendary singer but to my ear Lucy is already far superior.
If you want to put more credibility to your laughable comments, I suggest you learn how to spell correctly, use correct punctuation, better grammar, and more logical sentence structure, Troll.
To compare Lucy is a karaoke singer shows that you know absolutely nothing about her. You are so far off base with your comments it is almost laughable if it was not so pathetically insulting. Your opinion goes against 99.999999999999999999...% of the people who follow Lucy and also those who do the reactions to her music. Get a life!
I have to say that this is horribly pitch corrected. Lucy is a very good singer but so many notes in this sound thin and metallic and step like because of the autotune--it is detrimental to the sound of her voice. You can hear some of the notes that are largely unaffected have a nice full sound with vibrato. You should listen to the original by Barbra Streisand.
The pitch correction on Lucy's recordings aren't alot just minor tweaks here and there which to be honest are totally unnecessary, she's actually more talented then even her producers realise but sadly there isn't a contemporary singer in the world today who isn't falling victim to the industry and being manicured in the recording studio. At least she isn't using vocoder tuning like most of the rubbish Pop diva's today. As for the Streisand original as amazing as it is to my ear at least her top range belt sounds screamed and not sang with clean vibrato which Lucy's is so for that reason Lucy's vocals sound more classically trained.
I can assure you that Maggie would have mentioned it if this had been horribly pitch corrected. Perhaps you should tell both Lucy and Maggie where they are both going wrong. Tell me, why is it that nobody else appears to agree with your expert opinion?
@@philharris5848 People seem to be in denial about pitch correction. I can hear it, but I also put it through a pitch monitor and it's very step-like, snapped to the lines, always centered on the lines for the vibrato and flattened out on the lines for the longer held notes, which is when it sounds synthetic, unless you're so used to autotune you don't realize it's not natural. Natural vocals never look like that step like waveform. I don't understand why they do it or why she allows them to do it, because Lucy Thomas is an excellent singer and sounds much better without the autotune.
@@adamknight7041 I don't always prefer Streisand's singing but who you prefer is a matter of preference. However, you are wrong that there isn't a lot of pitch correction and just minor tweaks here and there. If you looked at the pitch monitor graph you would see every single note, including those with vibrato, is dead on the pitch lines, and the more extended notes are flattened out completely on the line, which is where you can hear the synthetic effect. And the parts that look like a piano was being played--very step-like, snapped to the lines. Every note in this recording is pitch corrected. I agree she doesn't need it and actually she would sound much better without it because it distorts her voice, reduces expression, and diminishes resonance.
@@philharris5848 I reviewed the pitch monitor for this again, and I was thinking of the Faouzia recording in which which is every vibrato and straight notice centered straight on the line. In this they allow some of the notes with vibrato to vary upper or down from the pitch slightly, but on average 80% of it is centered on snapped to the line, including all the longer held notes and the quick change notes that go up and down like a stepladder.
Why oh why Maggie? You are a better singer who can sing without pitch correction software! Why are you reacting to someone who clearly IS? Check out Zhou Shen for instance..he can sing without such trickery
Lucy can sing without pitch correction too her live performances illustrate this, whatever is being done with her voice by her production team might well be beyond her creative control. 99%+ of what you hear is her anyway, the pitch correction is very minimal. She actually sounds even better live then on her recordings which totally discredits your armchair critique of her 😂
You're talking utter nonsense, Lucy sounds exactly the same "Live" in concert as she does hear. She's performing a solo concert next in Tokyo Japan. At the end of the year she's starring in a brand new musical especially written for her called "Rosie." Lucy doesn't need any pitch correction, and utube doesn't need jealous trolls like you.
Who should I react to next: www.maggierenee.com/book-me/sponsor-a-reaction-live What should I sing next: www.maggierenee.com/book-me/sponsor-a-song-liveAnd just for you: ‘Sing Better Instantly" my FREE Singing Course: skl.sh/3aHdSuy and for EXCLUSIVE VIDEOS AND PERKS: www.patreon.com/MaggieRenee
the question is ! is it real or memorex todays singers we don't know if is real or not ?
Maybe someone who isn't totally pitch corrected? For pete sake..you'd sing this song without and better
Lucy has just had her first public concert (a sell out) and her opening song (Somewhere) is now on YT. Worth a reaction as she is singing live.
Why don't you shut up and let the girl sing.!
She rocks blows most out of the water clean pure stunning
How could have never heard this song??She is one of the best female singers
I have ever heard. I am blown away by her.
WOW, WOW. What a glorious rendition of this classic song. Unbelievable. Better than any version I have ever heard. Lucy is so talented and has a gorgeous tone with perfect pitch that puts her head and shoulders above most singers of her generation. Lucy is phenomenal. Only once in a lifetime does someone like Lucy come along! She makes a masterpiece of every song she sings!! We are all blessed to have Lucy spreading love and light in our troubled world. She is a gem!!
She just melts the skin right off my body... Lucy is absolutely incredible, with a beautiful heart and soul to match her beautiful voice... ♥ 🙏
From one skinless skeleton to another, I absolutely agree 100%! Lol!
She is so good. I would not think anyone could match Barbara but she does. I love this
this girl.
Her cover of Hallelujah is BREATHTAKING !!! ❤❤❤❤❤
I have been following this girl since her beginnings at age 11 on kids singing shows. Her tones are magical!!! never have i heard a negative word toward anyone. Besides that she has shown us her wonderful life and family in the UK. She is just adorable! Jim
Lucy's first live performance at her first concert is now available on her page.
...and what a beautiful performance it is, she sounds even better live then in studio which makes a complete mockery of those trying to discredit her because of the pitch correction being added to her voice on the recordings.
@@adamknight7041 0:30
She does excellent cover superbly beautiful voices high quality every notes is flaweless so richness tenderly limitless beautiful voices.
Good job Maggie.Lucy Thomas has the most beautiful voice that I have ever heard.
BREATHTAKING.....beautiful! ❤
Lucy was always confident and consistent! She is is best and crushed this song, don’t really think she needs your advice. JMHO
this is one of my favourite Lucy songs such a stunning voice as good as any i have heard . love your comments and promotion of Lucy
She was about 19.5 here. She went 20 on feb 21. I think nothing happens is this song outside her control. She is fantastic. It sounds like she still has some air left after the last note🥰 I hear much more dedication and perfection with Lucy than with Babs.
Glad that you had no hesitation to hear Lucy again at her finest. The technique used by her is masterful and you were able to catch on to them pretty easily. Try We Can Change The World from her upcoming musical Rosie.
Love the way Lucy’s warm rich voice just caresses the notes of this song! I’ve always loved this Barbara Streisand song, and Lucy really does it justice. As you said so well, she does indeed use a stunning and “floaty” voice technique. Just gorgeous! ❤️
Hi, Maggie... you actually have heard this song before. You reacted to the OG of it about 6 or 7 months ago. You may recall it was the scene from the movie "A Star Is Born" with Barbra and Kris Kristofferson. "Evergreen" was written by Streisand with lyracist Paul Williams and went on to win an Oscar for Best Song in a Motion Picture, and two Grammys. The scene and song from the movie was actually done in one take... it was the rehearsal, but was so good they put it in the movie as is. Just a little history on this classic song.
"Kermit the frog quality" - so funny, yet so true! As an ex-chorister with over 20 years choral singing, all I can say is Lucy TRULY must have the voice of an angel - it cannot be improved. She melts my heart - technicalities are not important, emotion is everything.
When you compared to all the greats means your the best
she has a sultry smokey under vibretto if that is right word-stunning version-looks confident and at ease singing-rich and lovely voice....
Hello Maggie. Thank you so much for the insightful review of Lucy. Lucy has a way of drawing you into a song and gently hanging on to your soul. On March 5th this year Lucy performed her first live concert in Manchester, UK. She has just released the first song of that evening. She performed 17 songs that night and two of them included Martha. I am looking forward to the remainder of the recordings. As you know Lucy has recorded 60 songs and growing. I would like to see you react to more of Lucy’s recordings. I don’t know which song is best because I like all of them. Stay Free, Safe, and Healthy my friend.
Hello Maggie, thank you for reacting to Lucy singing " Evergreen " this is Lucy at her best singing a copy of her idol Barbara Streisand & she sings this cover so beautifully, Lucy has such an amazing voice so very beautiful, she is moving up the ladder to stardom. Take care Barbara.
Nice comments Barbara. You are always right there to comment and always have the brightest things to say. I am afraid it won’t be to long we lose our Lucy angel to the beast of the entertainment word. But she is the best vocalist of today and I would say in history. Be free, safe, and healthy.
@@jimivison5837 First and only singer you ever heard Jim?
her name..which is on dozen albums and countless awards and milions of articles is..Barbra. One of her album, one of her tv shows and last years memoir are in fact called...my name is BARBRA
@@reddragonreadySo you are the grumpy one on this Chanel I guess!
Kudos i ripped into you on your reaction to Lucy and Martha's The Prayer because you didn't understand how young Martha was and their pronunciation of Italian wasn't perfect, but now you can see Lucy is the one chasing a singing career and Martha isn't. Lucy is by far the best female singer i've heard in years and will succeed in her chosen field of musicals of that i have no doubt.
she is going to be a superstar
7:16 - LucyYodels - "Time..."
Can't get enough of her.
You don't know Evergreen? Granted the song is 48 years old and your field classical music, but I find it remarkable that even top pop singers don't know the history of music from even 20 years earlier. There are exceptions who are de facto historians, like Lady Gaga, but the ignorance in their their own field of expertise is amazing. This may be the only, song by Barbra Streisand that she gets a writing credit, for the music--Paul Williams wrote the lyrics. It earned an Academy award for best original song and it was a number one hit for Barbra.
You obviously weren't paying attention. Watch the video again.
(The written title of the video is also telling.)
@@jamesprior2496 You obviously weren't paying attention. I could tell you to watch the video again but I'll save you some time. At 2:18 Maggie clearly says she doesn't know this song.
Please react to one of Lucy’s original songs such as her most recent “We can change the World” or “ Broken dreams” both from the, as yet unreleased musical “ Rosie” which has been written with Lucy’s voice in mind
Lucy just dropped a live performance of Somewhere. Love to see what you have to say about a live performance.
I always thought that no one but Streisand would give me goose bumps but this girl is doing it .
This is a Barbara Streisand cover…….and she does cover Celine.
Interesting to say Lucy has come a long way since hearing her brilliant rendition of Hallelujah, However, Lucy did a cover of "Memory" from the musical "Cats" when she was a mere fifteen years old. Her lower register at one point reached the low "f". But towards the end she explodes with an absolute sonic Belt. Her soprano tone throughout this masterpiece is unbelievable for someone so young, Would be interesting to get your take on it!
she is so lovely and her voice a sirens voice and I would jump
Lucy was 20 in February, I don't know if you reacted to her cover of Somewhere from West Side Story but if you did you might want to check out the live version she did at her first live Concert in Manchester that is now available on her RUclips channel.
Happy you are reacting to Lucy!!
Lucy your the best!
Stunning,check out Lucy's first major concert in Manchester on 5th March!,she opened with 'Somewhere' ,others will follow,you need to check out some of Lucy's 70 odd video's to understand she dosen't play safe!,one I would recommend is 'A Whiter Shade of Pale',gorgeous!😊.Ps. I think she has brushed up on her Italian since you last asses her!😉
It was actually Martha she criticised for that not Lucy although neither of their Italian was particularly fluid.
She is twenty in February.
LOL Niceeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee! thumbs up! wait till you hear her live.
I loved when Barbra sang this in French, Spanish and Italian.
With all respect to Barbara this cover by Lucy is better than the original. It is a hallmark of Lucy's that many of her covers are better then the original. And of course Lucy has released several of her own songs (written by Chris Broom) from the forthcoming musical "Rosie". As you say Maggie, simply stunning!
This is just an exact copy of Barbra’s version but without the feeling Barbra puts into hers.
Happy to see you get right back on that horse. 😁🤐
She sounds like Lucy Thomas. She has a basket full of techniques just like the other greats you mentioned.👍❤️
❤
We are fortunate to live in a marvelous time of great young female singers...Arpi Alto, Laura Bretan, Emily Bear, Harriett, Emma Kok, Emily Linge, Malinda. Lucy Thomas, probably more. Alphabetical here, all favorites. Wish I would live long enough to watch them grow.
The lyrics to this song are out of this world. Thank you little Paul Williams.
Glad there's someone else out there who appreciates the contributions of Paul Williams. I have several CD's of Paul singing his songs and this is one of them.
Hello Ms. Renee, I know you are very busy, but I would love to see your reaction on another Lucy Thomas song. She has two newly released songs. One is "Unchained Melody " by Righteous Brothers, then "One moment in time " Whitney Houston. Thanks...❤😊
Wow, you smiled all the way through and got all the hate heat off of you...Good job..lol Really, Good Job.
👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
Really good performance, similar to but not a copy of Babs, rather her own take on the song. Good reaction, good analysis.
Are you kidding? She just copied Barbra’s version exactly. She didn’t put her own take on the song at all. Watch Barbra’s version, then watch this.
@@doloreschokas3844 I know the Barbra Streisand version very well, I sponsored it for Maggie long ago as part of a Featured Artist set. I stand by my opinion. You of course are entitled to yours. Debating opinions never leads anywhere.
The movie star is born is so damn good,Barbera struesand and Kris kristifersin! If you like painful reality check it out!
I don't understand the comparisons with Barbara or Celine she sounds nothing like them and her vibrato isn't as harsh and shrieky and is alot more smooth and sounds classically trained, personally I think she's already much better then the aforementioned and more in the Karen Carpenter mold if anyone at all.
I rate her alongside Linda Ronstadt myself best two popular singers I've ever heard. And 55 years apart.
@@stephen8639 spot on I agree 100%
@@stephen8639
Good call that 👍👏👏👏 yes Linda was incredible but Lucy equally as much so.
Absolutely yes!
👍❤️
“Have a Cigar”-Main Squeeze(Pink Floyd cover) Live in studio/Hive Awesomeness!!!!
Better than Streisand's version. And Barbra's version was beautiful.
NEVER! She just copied exactly what Barbra does.
No no,not Celinne Dion. I don't hear the Celine or Barbra irritating nazal tone. Lucy's tone at nineteen is already superior to both of these divas.
she is a copy cat, she does not evenadd her spin on the song... it is not one take and she is not singing live ... nothing sound natural
@@Julien-pt6qsOooow. I don't usually react toTrolls but on this one you've got my attention. Sounds like you've got a grievance, sad. Firstly, you have absolutely no proof this took more than one take. Secondly, you're obviously not a musician if you're inferring this a copy of Barbra Streisand rendition. Lucy's voice is uniquely superior to both Streisand and Dion's. And this rendition is kept true to the original as a tribute to Barbra Streisand.
@@Julien-pt6qsshe just sang live in her Manchester concert and did great, so you’re wrong. She can sing and she’ll be more famous in the next few years
@@Julien-pt6qs
What nonsense you talk 😂 You can be influenced and pay tribute to an artist that inspired you which Barbara Streisand clearly did for Lucy and she has openly admitted this but there's a major difference between being influenced and merely being a copycat, Lucy does not copy she only enhances and improves already well known songs. Her tonality and vibrato are unmistakable and completely unique to her.
@@Julien-pt6qsA lot of singers that put their twist to great classic are just shredding the songs. So better stick to a version and make it great than being original and scrap it!
It's a Barbara Streisand sound, not Celine.
I would love you to react to queen's Live aid performance.
The best ever live show
Celine definitely no, lucy is much better, no nasal tones, a much more pure tone. Nice reaction though.
Sorry, respect you're classically trained, but your voice tone does not come anywhere near Lucy's quality or softness when trying to replicate in this reaction. 😏
Lucy is very good, but if you want to hear a love theme with real punch check out Leah Barniville singing "Parla Pia Piano ' in her semi final appearance on Britain's got Talent.
Jonathan Antoine's version of that is phenomenal
لطفا آهنگ جدید دیماش رو ری اکت برو🙏🙏
When you make song your own, it is rarely as good as the original. I literally prefer when people copy the original and make it sound perfect. One in a while a remake is as good or better than the original, but that really only occurs with established groups or singers who create great music in own their right.
Try her version of "Bridge Over Troubled Waters" One of my all time favourites from it's first release 1971 I think it was along with all of Simon and Garfunkel's music. I hesitated to listen originally because the original is so much a part of my memories and I have heard versions that did it no justice. I know how good she is and have followed her for several years, I shouldn't have doubted her it is magnificent.
DIAR MAGGIE TRY TO REACT LOVEBITES BAND SONG EPILOGUE
You are so right on your last comment, to me she feel so young with no caractere... she sings well like good singer in a karaoke she is about 20, Barbra at her age was fare ahead in her own artistic path. hear brabra at her age, her song choices and original spin on classic standards... Barbra is a legend that everyone is admiring curious to see our she is making song her own, like steve wonder golden hits(all is faire in love, You & I...) anyway lucy is forgettable if she does not put emotions and take artistic risks that will make her special ...many good singers only few icones
Lucy's vibrato is far cleaner and free in the high end range, when Barbara used to try full belt I'm sorry to say she started shrieking and was no longer actually singing with pure tone and I mean no disrespect to Barbara Streisand who is amazing and a legendary singer but to my ear Lucy is already far superior.
If you want to put more credibility to your laughable comments, I suggest you learn how to spell correctly, use correct punctuation, better grammar, and more logical sentence structure, Troll.
To compare Lucy is a karaoke singer shows that you know absolutely nothing about her. You are so far off base with your comments it is almost laughable if it was not so pathetically insulting. Your opinion goes against 99.999999999999999999...% of the people who follow Lucy and also those who do the reactions to her music. Get a life!
I have to say that this is horribly pitch corrected. Lucy is a very good singer but so many notes in this sound thin and metallic and step like because of the autotune--it is detrimental to the sound of her voice. You can hear some of the notes that are largely unaffected have a nice full sound with vibrato.
You should listen to the original by Barbra Streisand.
The pitch correction on Lucy's recordings aren't alot just minor tweaks here and there which to be honest are totally unnecessary, she's actually more talented then even her producers realise but sadly there isn't a contemporary singer in the world today who isn't falling victim to the industry and being manicured in the recording studio. At least she isn't using vocoder tuning like most of the rubbish Pop diva's today.
As for the Streisand original as amazing as it is to my ear at least her top range belt sounds screamed and not sang with clean vibrato which Lucy's is so for that reason Lucy's vocals sound more classically trained.
I can assure you that Maggie would have mentioned it if this had been horribly pitch corrected. Perhaps you should tell both Lucy and Maggie where they are both going wrong. Tell me, why is it that nobody else appears to agree with your expert opinion?
@@philharris5848 People seem to be in denial about pitch correction. I can hear it, but I also put it through a pitch monitor and it's very step-like, snapped to the lines, always centered on the lines for the vibrato and flattened out on the lines for the longer held notes, which is when it sounds synthetic, unless you're so used to autotune you don't realize it's not natural. Natural vocals never look like that step like waveform. I don't understand why they do it or why she allows them to do it, because Lucy Thomas is an excellent singer and sounds much better without the autotune.
@@adamknight7041 I don't always prefer Streisand's singing but who you prefer is a matter of preference. However, you are wrong that there isn't a lot of pitch correction and just minor tweaks here and there. If you looked at the pitch monitor graph you would see every single note, including those with vibrato, is dead on the pitch lines, and the more extended notes are flattened out completely on the line, which is where you can hear the synthetic effect. And the parts that look like a piano was being played--very step-like, snapped to the lines. Every note in this recording is pitch corrected. I agree she doesn't need it and actually she would sound much better without it because it distorts her voice, reduces expression, and diminishes resonance.
@@philharris5848 I reviewed the pitch monitor for this again, and I was thinking of the Faouzia recording in which which is every vibrato and straight notice centered straight on the line. In this they allow some of the notes with vibrato to vary upper or down from the pitch slightly, but on average 80% of it is centered on snapped to the line, including all the longer held notes and the quick change notes that go up and down like a stepladder.
Why oh why Maggie? You are a better singer who can sing without pitch correction software! Why are you reacting to someone who clearly IS? Check out Zhou Shen for instance..he can sing without such trickery
Lucy can sing without pitch correction too her live performances illustrate this, whatever is being done with her voice by her production team might well be beyond her creative control. 99%+ of what you hear is her anyway, the pitch correction is very minimal.
She actually sounds even better live then on her recordings which totally discredits your armchair critique of her 😂
You're talking utter nonsense, Lucy sounds exactly the same "Live" in concert as she does hear. She's performing a solo concert next in Tokyo Japan. At the end of the year she's starring in a brand new musical especially written for her called "Rosie." Lucy doesn't need any pitch correction, and utube doesn't need jealous trolls like you.
Very Nice !!