Steve Rattner: Confusion, misinformation clouds immigration debate
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 24 авг 2024
- Morning Joe economic analyst Steve Rattner discusses immigration as a 2024 election issue and why he says the debate about immigration policies is filled with confusion and misinformation.
» Subscribe to MSNBC: on.msnbc.com/Su...
Follow MSNBC Show Blogs
MaddowBlog: www.msnbc.com/...
ReidOut Blog: www.msnbc.com/...
MSNBC delivers breaking news, in-depth analysis of politics headlines, as well as commentary and informed perspectives. Find video clips and segments from The Rachel Maddow Show, Morning Joe, The Beat with Ari Melber, Deadline: White House, The ReidOut, All In, Last Word, 11th Hour, and Alex Wagner who brings her breadth of reporting experience to MSNBC primetime. Watch “Alex Wagner Tonight” Tuesday through Friday at 9pm Eastern.
Connect with MSNBC Online
Visit msnbc.com: on.msnbc.com/Re...
Subscribe to the MSNBC Daily Newsletter: MSNBC.com/NewslettersRUclips
Find MSNBC on Facebook: on.msnbc.com/Li...
Follow MSNBC on Twitter: on.msnbc.com/Fo...
Follow MSNBC on Instagram: on.msnbc.com/In...
Steve Rattner: Confusion, misinformation clouds immigration debate
#Immigration #Politics #Election
Imagine a government that actually used American leverage to benefit the American people...🇺🇸🤷♂
imagine joe ever supporting america.
THis was the best analysis of this sticky problem. Broadcast to all of MAGA 24X7.
It was if you want another 10 million illegal immigrants in the next 36 months.
Even if we manage to fix our immigration system, the right will still whine, cry and shake their fists about the legal immigrants because they just don't want them, period.
They're allergic to facts unfortunately.
Why did Biden end border wall construction on day 1 of administration, and ended remain in Mexico???
@@archieclement2977Your ignorance is encyclopedic.
What's up with the Amazon bots posting comments? My god, this is out o' hand.
IKR! It’s just exploded over the past couple of weeks! It’s NUTS! 😳
Bezos must have purchased an Indonesian bot farm
Report it as spam! Make sure to hit the OK and they are deleted from the thread.
Unfortunately the people who most need to hear this aren't watching or will call it lies.
This breakdown is so informative, I think every voter should watch it. There's no shortage of discussions of the problems with illegal immigrants, but very few are talking about the humanitarian visas and the wait time to process cases.
Don’t even start, do you guys still stick with your standpoint from a few years ago about having a border is racist?
@@Tylerd838
Nobody ever said that, let alone "us guys"
@@jockyoung4491 yes they did, during trumps presidency, he wanted to build the wall and all the democrats criticized him, it’s not hard to find it on RUclips
1.6 mil gotaways have come in since the current guy has been in office. He has no idea who they are, where they are, or what they are doing.
@@Tylerd838 This is exactly what I'm talking about, it's so easy to point out problems, point fingers and feed on anger. I'm just glad this segment dug a little bit deeper and gave us a different perspective.
-"Santos Exposed" vid: 60k views in 2 hours.
-"Santos won't run for reelection" vid: 45k views in 2 hours.
-"Dysfunctional border" vid: 3.5k views in 2 hours.
isn't that just SO surprising lol
People love drama and despise facts. There are many people who are just contrarian and enjoy stirring the pot. Some people have become lazy because they are doing so well under Biden s leadership.
Algorithm hijinks.
Well done!!!
Loud and clear
Thank you Joe in the morning team 😊
Why is a decline in population bad? Serious question.
Exactly. they're trying to keep the growth we've had in the last 20 years calling, it's not sustainable. we shouldn't even have had this growth for the last 20 years
Because if there aren't a lot of people struggling to survive you can't get them to work for less than human wages.
@@larindanomikos Sounds about right...
@@Billkwando
you have more people at retirement age relative to fewer people still working to fund the retirement system. We won't be able to take care of previous generations.
A lower population means fewer workers for everything from dairy farms to car manufacturing to military recruits, less taxes to help fund our govt, which means less govt $$$ to farms, colleges, police. And a whole lot more.
We already have a shortage of affordable housing! And your answers are to bring in more immigrants to take what housing we do have, seriously?
Customs and border protection are allowed to let them go into the country! This illegal immigration issue is overwhelming citys like New York and Chicago. Legal immigration is fine but that is not what is happening. This video is so stupid and out of touch.
🤡 And now states like NY and IL want to give illegals the right to vote and give them ID’s. It infuriates me to hear this!
Democrats logic.
The sink is broken and overflowing.
Instead of turning over the tap to stop the flow. They turn it up and then wonder what’s happening.
True. Pure incompetence from incompetent blue
Yeah, but but, muh racisms!
Excellent presentation. Some of us are informed about this situation; most seem not to be. That is unfortunate and allows republicans to use immigration as a scare tactic rather than the absolutely necessity for survival that it is.
Thank you, Mr Ratner, that was very helpful.
PROBLEM with this video clip !!! In 2023 ,ILLEGAL immigrants from the Southern Border HURTS red skinned indigenous not Latino Indigenous , black skinned indigenous and black grassroots Americans policy wise PERIOD . These illegals has destroyed our communities jobs , land and housing . Red skinned indigenous, black skinned indigenous and black grassroots Americans are the only people who are not immigrants to USA but US government won’t pay their overdue REPARATIONS debt to black folks but keeps putting money to illegal immigrants. This is why Trump is winning over some black voters
So you’re saying Trump will pay reparations? 🤣 seriously? 🤦🏻♀️
If it was about a wall,trump maga republican wouldn't be taking away from it$...
Reinstate remain in mexico.
Good explanation for the importance of welcoming immigration - every voter needs to watch this to understand
Great graphs and stats, very informative, very helpful to see a bigger picture instead of the fear and hyperbole that the GOP foments.
Why do we need our population to grow? How does more people make life better for all Americans?
It doesn't. Keep asking questions. The 3rd point at 5:52 is openly admitting the great replacement theory which I find quite amusing since the Dems have labeled it as only a conspiracy theory for the past decade plus.
Without immigration the biggest ponzi scheme in the world, Social Security will fail without rational management.
Keep them out
I agree with johnk.....all those MAGA immigration snowflakes need to listen to these facts.
These ARE NOT FACTS. The FACTS are in your face!!!! WOW, I can't believe how gullible Democrats are. Literally led like sheep. Talk to NY and Chicago and see how they feel right now. You people ARE IDIOTS!!!!!
Building walls keeps others out but locks us in. Fortress America is also a prison.
Wrong fascist blue, that ignorance is also in fascist 46
There are these things called entry ways 😂. Similar to doors on houses, and gates on fences 😮. Shocking right!
Joe spoke on Tuesday about "his administration’s historic actions to address the climate crisis" at the White House. He keeps trying to propagandize his "achievements" to the American people, even using the bully pulpit of the White House to do so. But all the American public can see is the bad results of what his time in office has wrought, including paying more for everything.
With all the crises we're facing and Americans being held hostage for a month by muslim terrorists, what was Joe saying was the big danger on Tuesday? Democrat Joe claimed that climate change is the "ultimate threat to humanity."
No, the ultimate threat to humanity may just be having an incoherent democrat leader of the free world. He's "seen first hand" bad weather and makes everything about climate change.
Joe wasn't looking good and it got worse. This next mess was with a teleprompter and still his brain broke midway and he started just spewing random words that made no sense, as he slurred heavily.
"It's an impact that decades are making, because inaction are, uh, inaction are much too long," struggling Joe is gone.
If you ever watched a train pile up on the tracks, that's what it looks like. At this point it's so bad, it sounds like he just had a stroke. Except with him, it's a progressive thing that has continued to get worse. This is scary to think that this guy has any power over anything. Democrat Joe also appeared to be coughing more than normal.
And now Joe's supposed to be meeting with Xi Jinping at the APEC Summit? One has to wonder what might he say there and if Xi Is going to see what a mess he truly is.
Democrat Joe struggled to explain how he would define "success" from his meeting with Xi on Wednesday, He had a long befuddled-looking pause, then said getting back on a normal course,
Biden said, "We can't take," and then can't seem to finish that thought. He then explained he didn't want to "decouple" from China. That's clueless, they should be trying to decouple and realize the problems of dependency and having too many of our industries influenced or connected to China. But that would require China Money Biden to act in the best interests of America.
Democrat Joe then started to toddle off and was asked about a real issue: the hostages, "Can you address the hostages directly and give them a message of hope?"
What is he saying here? No, he hasn't been speaking to the hostages. I think he's trying to say that he's talking to "people involved" meaning people in his administration working on the question. This is just a version of the same thing he's said for a few days now - that he's hopeful - but there have been no results.
But notice how they had a "Biden handler" there to help make sure that he didn't get lost and found his way off the stage. Last night he had to be helped by Doctor Jill Biden to deal with basic questions from the reporters, and he still made bad remarks.
Something is very wrong. They may not want to acknowledge it. But it's getting worse, and as we go into the election, it's going to become much more evident.
Are you really that dumb? Creating a barrier allows control, not a prison. Hate to see how you feel in your home.
I bet you could find a way out.
What debate? Finish the Wall and Secure our Borders!
The wall does nothing and Republicans are against securing he border.
Did you pay attention to anything in this video?
@@sandiegotrafficlightstrain354if the wall does nothing why did you lying dems say it was racist to use walls?
Why is the border much more secure when Repubs are in office?
When will you stop lying? Never. You're a Democrat, lying is part of your ideology.
@@DLordSadow Give me your assessment.
My assessment is that white people are afraid of a black and brown majority in the country that was stolen for white people. How about instead of white people freaking out and trying to control the masses, they go make love and make babies. This is a nation of immigrants with the exception of me and my people who were forced to stay here. And the exception of the Black people that were already here with the natives. I'm not sure how and why anybody gets to tell others where they can live on the earth they were born on.
Just like a 'professor'!
Well explained to all us 'dummies', I mean me😂!🌊💙🇺🇲🇺🇦🏳️🌈🇨🇦🌊
Steve Rattner!
6:10
If America The Nation had NO IMmigration
*6:14* ! We would peak and *no* *longer* *grow* .
6:17 America The Nation would *DECLINE* in population !!
Yes, good job pointing out fearmongering. Those are good examples.
We ate full
Fantastic visual explanation.
The misinformation is you fools talking about it 😂
Nobody deals more wonton misinformation than MSNBC. The Devil's network.
To put this in perspective, China is very close to the size of USA (slightly larger) and has 1.4 billion people compared to USA 335 million. Now, the chinese population is ridiculous but on the other extreme, compared to the vast majority of developed countries, so is USA in being underpopulated.
If these immigrants were heading out to develop the “under populated” USA I could agree with you, but they are not. They’re heading to the overpopulated cities looking for government handouts and infesting them with crime and drug gangs.
Continue with whatever thought you have......
People who willingly come here illegally and think they can demand anything is beyond hilarious.
Zero illegal immigrants entered by scaling the wall Trump built! BUILD THE WALL!! 🇺🇲
I don’t understand why it is a given that a higher population is better. Yes, the country will have a higher GDP and more power, but I don’t see how it will make life better here. Lower population means lower housing prices, especially in desirable areas, less water usage, less pollution and a more natural life.
Lies
RFK Jr. actually visited the border months ago and has a plan and he won't use the but but but the republicans excuse..
MSDNC just trying to make it look not as bad as it really is, kick em all out.
Right after some of TFG's wall was built, RUclips videos were uploaded showing a 13 year old girl scaling the wall in less than 10 minutes and others using a rechargeable reciprocating saw available at Home Depot for less than $75. cutting through the metal slats in just a few minutes. So much for TFG's BILLION dollar wall. More men and technology are needed at the border, not some ineffective wall.
7 billion most of which was kickbacked to Trumpers like Bannon
It needs to be shut down for a year to fix it......
And how exactly to you “shut down” a border? Are you proposing to make this backlog infinitely worse by shutting down the Border & Immigration Agencies? What do you mean?
@@DLordSadowDeSantis will have a wall up in 6 months and Mexico will pay for it this time
You vote? No wonder criminal 46 was elected
The left wants us in ruin.
@@DLordSadowyou turn them back and don’t let them in, simple
Vote vote vote 💙
No
never again.
F-America hating blue
Vote blue for more immigrants and chaos.
NEVER, I am for American Citizens!!! ❤ All the way!!!!
I'm lost on why we "need" to have more population.
Worker bees.
Because when you are old, someone has to keep the services running. If they are fewer than 1m people a year coming in, we will not be able to take care of everybody.
@@maneshipocrates2264Maybe if we stop aborting all the babies...
I agree but women should have the condition to give birth to more kids. And we should let them make that decision or all men who sleep with them and get them pregnant must marry them. or men should not tell them what to do with their bodies because men do not get pregnant. But we still need more people even if all babies are born@@billbillerton6122
I still don't get it. All media, except Fox News, i would guess. Should rise up and stop what Trump is trying to do. Media seems to be helping Trump to get his messages out to the world. This is building more Trump like wanter be all over. This is scary. If Trump succeeded. I blame the media, who gave him the platforms
MSNBC is the main one, all about the rage click revenue.
*except
Ots not the job of the media to stop or help anyone just because you don't or do like them .the job of the media is to objectively report newsworthy events accurately. You snowflakes are clueless
@@paulpaul9226If you consider their definition of Democracy looks more like Authoritarianism, it makes more sense.
@@larindanomikos thank you for correcting my spelling. Bla Bla Bla!!
DID HE JUST SAY WE NEED MORE PEOPLE TO TAKE THE JOBS OF THE FUTURE😡😡
KNOWLEDGE MY BROTHA
Wooooooow its almost like none of this matters they need to leave. Period
It's like you didn't watch the video?
I watch these videos the same way commies sit in on meetings with tape recorders 😁
@@terazakdil7529 did it hurt when the mule kicked you in the head?
@@xiaoka no actually it's this communist propaganda. It's not even clever or smart.. I mean it's embarrassing tbh
This is great, very unfortunate that people will take the second segment about immigration and population as Great Replacement Theory red meat
If I could afford it, I’d expat from the US to Norway.
Yah, me too. My family is from Tolga.
Norway has strict immigration laws, they do t want you.
Me too. Or Holland or Denmark.
@@larindanomikos if you can’t afford it, then you can’t afford to live there. White burden them with your welfare?
Facts and hard data won't convince people who think opinions and beliefs trump facts.
"Raise your hand if you want to fund Medicare for illegal immigrants." During the debates every democrat candidate raised their hand. Now they cant figure out where all these illegal immigrants are coming from.
Yes, they did all do that. They want us to work longer and harder to support their pawns.
The trolls never stop coming, do you?
Also, congressional testimony reveals 1.6 mil gotaways have come in under joe. He doesn't know who, where, or what they have done or are doing.
@@kelperdude Bingo! We have a winner.
@@Nobodyandeverybody713 No, we're never going to stop coming. This is our country, and we're fighting for it.
Clown show
Trump 2024!!!
Just about anyone other than American hating Stalin Biden
America and Canada would open their immigration borders to the Filipino people they are quiet and behave just to work and earn money for themselves and their family and most of all workaholic they super respect the law and they don’t want trouble.
No room here
@@JudyStroyer-bk6fbCanada is huge, we'll make room.
@@mytruecrimelibrary Go for it. As long as they don't come to the United States
@@JudyStroyer-bk6fb then you'll end up with no workers for agriculture and construction like in Florida.
@@mytruecrimelibrary That's not true. Florida has workers, And there is no shortage of workers in the United States. there are a shortage of jobs that pay a living wage. those jobs need to go away or pay better, not Import cheap labor. it's OK if costs go up. these people are a national security threat and a drain on our economy and they need to leave
Easy to see: the backlog exploded under the orange monsterbaby.
The migrants said themselves that they waited for Biden to become president.
Because people are coming here who don't qualify for asylum
@@JudyStroyer-bk6fb Yes. Just like your ancestors. If not the indians would still rule.
@@ronnyskaar3737 My ancestors are Polish. so, no. And the native Americans were not one people
@@ronnyskaar3737 That's in the past and there's nothing we can do to change it.. we can change what's happening in the present… which you admit is a problem
A President that put American's interests before the interests of lobbyists would shut down the border and force Mexico to agree to every one of our demands before we re-opened it to ANY sort of trade, tourism or migrant workers.🇺🇸🤷♂
So, the solution is economic suicide? 🙄🤦♂️
Throw thousands of Americans out of work, tank commodity prices and the stock market, eh? What are you, 12 years old? Stop smoking that dope and get real.
Wow, you know Mexico is out largest trading partner, right? Do you know what that would do to the economy?
and now we have joe, who is not america first, at all.
🦆 In order for New York Democrats to provide everything for the Illegal Aliens Mayor Adams has proposed a NYPD hiring freeze that would reduce the number of available officers to below 30,000. This move would reduce the police force to a size not seen since the 1980s when the city had over one million fewer people. The city’s Department of Education will see a budget cut by $1 billion over two years. This will impact summer school and prekindergarten programs. Also, programs to mitigate the rat population in Staten Island and The Bronx will be limited.
🦆 New York City Mayor Eric Adams announces deep budget cuts for the upcoming fiscal year due to a $7 billion budget shortfall. Adams says the key issue contributing to the budget shortfall is the migrant crisis. Over 130,000 migrants have flooded the city in about one year. The city has been searching for ways to accommodate the never-ending flow of people in an already densely populated place. Landmark locations such as the Roosevelt Hotel have become run-down migrant encampments. So-called “anchor babies” are being born at the Roosevelt at a rate that is probably the highest for one location anywhere in the world. The migrant problem in NYC is unsustainable, yet it persists and the price tag is astronomical.
sadly your family has to acknowledge your existence.
@@mikemannsongs5406That's your retort? Weak.
Do you even hear yourselves? I cannot justify any of it.
Go President Trump!
Now let’s talk about the ones who snuck in and how many may be terrorists.
Definitely know of one.
Why would a terrorist need to fly to Mexico just to sneak in through the border? They have passports, they can clearly afford plane tickets. You guys are just stone cold stupid.
Yes. More known terrorists entered the country by the northern border then the southern border. In fact, in the past 15 years, no known terrorists have come up from the southern border while at least 7 came down from the northern border. And so many more terrorists were born here. I refer you to Jan. 6th.
At least 1 did a month or so ago @@222aztek
@@xiaokaDo you really think somebody on a terrorist watch list could use their passport to enter through an airport?
🧑🌾 I do not understand
Rattner: "We need immigrants to come take the jobs (from Americans) that we are creating for the future." Black support for Trump should skyrocket!!
"There are dozens of us! DOZENS!" ~ DaerthGrumer's sock puppets
Boycott Comcast
What’s so hard to understand our border is wide open, CBP has been reduced to Im processing duties, all the while the taxpayers who pays the federal government to safeguard their borders doesn’t but still collects taxes. Let’s see how long that works out.
The border isn't wide open.
Is "wide open" the same as 2.5M apprehensions? An 80% rate. Hamas proved walls don't work. Israel's triple fence failed despite border patrols and being 1/5 the length of our border. Democrats have proposed real solutions both for handling the influx and eliminating the motives for them coming. Ask yourself why MAGA Republicans oppose them. They prefer the phony security of a provably worthless fences and more importantly the political value of xenophobic performative outrage. Fearful sheep look opportunistic shepherds.
you can watch footage of joes people cutting wire to let them in.
@@kelperdudeThe law says anyone can walk into the country and ask for asylum. CBP is responsible for processing the asylum seekers. Republicans can participate in fixing this but they won't.
@@yvonneplant9434yes it is wide open
♟2006-2021🕸️
Will the democrats finally admit that trump was right about the border?
Steve is a lying little goblin 😊
We don't want the population to grow, there's no room. 200 million is perfect
The population is over 330 million........
@@verilyveronica8430 Exactly….. we are overpopulated by a lot
@@verilyveronica8430 There's not enough housing in this country for the people who are here now. and there's not ever going to be. there are too many people here. If the population declined by a 100 million, the 200 million left would benefit greatly
@@JudyStroyer-bk6fb More than half the country is undeveloped wilderness. 7 US states and a section of Canada is the least populous place on Earth.
@@JudyStroyer-bk6fb I bought 20 acres and a home .......
Let’s not have the people here learn said jobs, we have to bring others in because our people are what, too busy partying?
No, because they won't do the hard physical labor jobs at the salary of what the job is worth, skill wise.
Maybe I must go to USA, and bring back my 6 US classic cars, to where they came from :- )
This is what happens when a 24/7/365 problem is dealt with by an administrative system that works, at most, office hours, 5 days a week.
Why is it that essential industrial processes run 24/7, while essential administrative services run 9 till 5, Monday through Friday?
The answer to the asylum problem is simple, 24 hour industrial time-keeping, creating at the same time thousands of decently-paid jobs in administration until the back-log is cleared.
No one is illegal on stolen land
This isn't stolen land. Grow up and get an education.
@@TheChopf26 Just because you think your country isn't stolen land doesn't mean America wasn't. Stop embarrassing yourself.
Now you have a taste as to what Native Americans endured during the aggressive onslaught of Europeans
@@DarthSailorMoo just because you say it is doesn't mean it is. Grow up.
@@user-rc1xj9wr6h I'm Native and we disagree with you.
They said Amazon's AMA49X could be a milestone in tech history. I guess time will tell.
Heard a rumor that Amazon's AMA49X is going to be integrated into everyday tech. Can anyone confirm?
Biden doesn’t believe in the wall except in Yuma, his wall design is pretty nice too, nevertheless, I guess he decided things are getting a little too hot in the kitchen. I’m glad it will help.
Heard through the grapevine that Amazon's AMA49X will be part of an upcoming major event. Any truth to that?
Feels like Amazon's AMA49X is the only thing worth talking about in the tech space right now.
Amazon's AMA49X seems to be this cryptic puzzle that the tech community is collectively trying to solve, and with each piece, the picture gets more fascinating.
I'm all for innovation, but is Amazon's AMA49X really the breakthrough they're making it out to be?
It's not just about the tech; it's the vision behind Amazon's AMA49X that's captivating. It speaks volumes about where we're headed as a digital-first civilization.
So, Amazon's AMA49X is the new kid on the block. Let's see if it lives up to the playground rumors.
Make a bet, is the next video you watch commenting about Amazons AMA49X or not? it is everywhere lol
It's just you running a bunch of bot accounts.
Let's be honest, Amazon's AMA49X sounds like it's from a movie. Can someone confirm this is real life?
I've been hearing whispers about Amazon's AMA49X in tech circles, but I'm still trying to wrap my head around the concept.
Is Amazon's AMA49X the next big thing or just another blip on the tech radar? The jury's still out.
Amazon's AMA49X might just be the secret weapon we didn't know we needed in the tech war.
You can't swing a cat in the tech community without hitting news about Amazon's AMA49X these days.
It's intriguing to see how Amazon's AMA49X is weaving itself into the fabric of tech narratives, promising to be the thread that pulls future developments together.
Trump 2024
Is that the best you can do? He NEEDS you! He's weeping!
@@SwiftJusticehe’s fine. Fascist bidens banana republic is hilarious
@@SwiftJusticelove the hypocrisy and political hate, fascist blue
And now MSNBC is coserned about the southern border lo lol lol lol lol lol FJB.
Only Republikans are afraid of borders
*concerned
Every tech head on my feed is either praising or questioning Amazon's AMA49X. What's your stance?