You may laugh but don't forget Pakistan is a nuclear power with modern ballistic missiles integrated with MIRV technology with mach 18 velocity, and has the credible capacity to destroy India in 10 mins. Now, you can drink my juice if your laugh is over!
Yeh log PUBLIC PLATFORM AAKE JHOOTH KAISE BOL SAKTE HAIN..HATS OFF TO THIS PEOPLE...ND THEN THEY TALK ABOUT CREDIBILITY..btw he is a international law expert
PM Nehru was overly generous in allocating 80% of water to Pakistan in the Indus Water Treaty of 1960 . Maximum water for Pakistan , as a lower riparian nation , should have been less than 50%/ India should seek a review in her favour of the Indus Water Treaty. River Beas is only a tributary of River Sutlej . Beas does not even enter Pakistan. Chenab i.e. Chandrabhaga is basically a river of Himachal Pradesh. It belongs to HP and has a very small Kashmir connection. Chenab's waters should be diverted to Ravi and other Indian rivers including Yamuna. India got in her share waters of only two rivers compared to 3 rivers for Pakistan..
Diverting Chenab water to Ravi and on-wards can solve our Indian Punjab's water issues. SYL project can be upgraded as CSYL -Chenab- Sutlej- Yamuna Link Canal
India is taking the right steps well within her rights in the Indus Water Treaty i.e. Stopping totally the waters of River Ravi by constructing Shahpur Kandi Dam and dams on Ravi’s tributaries like River Ujhh and River Basantar . Construction of maximum number of hydro electricity dams / navigational facilities on Rivers Chenab , Jhelum and Indus and also utilising fully ,for irrigation-al / drinking water purposes, India’s small share in these rivers.
When POK is not an integral part of Pakistan as one of its province than how it can enter a treaty relating to POK. There is a independent govt on POK. Therefore treaty is null and void in itself
The problem that we are facing is that our most of the projects are struck everytime u find one and other way to halt our project thats why indian govt is interested in renegotiating it and one more thing this treaty is favouring pak
PM Nehru ,in `1960 under the Indus Water Treaty , gifted 80 % of Indus river systems water , to Pakistan. As a lower riparian State ,Pakistan was entitled to a maximum of 50% . Nehru had hoped that his magnanimity would usher in an era of friendship and cooperation with Pakistan. A few years later , in 1965 ,Pakistan returned Nehru's grand olive branch gesture , by invading India
India is saying if Pakistan considers jihadi terror as OK, India also doesn’t consider anything holy in IWT. The ball is in Pakistan’s court. They have to decide and come to terms with a big India which won’t allow Pakistan to engage in jihad at no cost. I don’t think that is fair right?
When Pak can break Shimla accord, why expect India to honour Indus Water treaty ? Moreover, why expect BCCI to send team for Asia cup, when Pak gov ended trade, denies airspace to Srinagar flights, continue to protect Mumbai attackers
thank you for such a great one sided discussion ! But I enjoy the pain of Pakistani state narrative during ModiEra. Congress time mai to ye log utsav mana rahey they :) cricket jo band kar rahey they mutemohan ji.
Informative discussion with an eminent legal expert. As regards IWT it is successfully sustained the test of the time. However, as regards environmental flows in three rivers where water is stopped by India as per IWT, it may require a review may be a separate treaty as an addendum to existing IWT. This could be examined by the experts associated in execution of IWT.
If a party is violating the treaty, other party can walk out from it. Pakistan has been violating Indus water treaty with impunity. Pskistan has been getting more water from the indus river system than is allowed in the treaty. Pakistan is not allowing India to use its share of water Whenever India tries to build run of the river installations, Pakistan adopts delaying tactics and the construction get halted for many years. In view of Pakistani intransigence, which tantamounts to violation of the Indus water treaty, India can walk out from the treaty today if India wants.
Getting lecture from beggers is so demeanour as an indian that i can't explain in words. Everything is fare in love and war so Pakistan is not our friend and kya kar loge if treaty is voilated , Russian attacked whole ukraine and world didn't has potential to do anything so do you think world can do anything against India. Jiss aaba ke pass jana hain jao and no one is going to help😂
I can tell you from India, India is taking this matter of discussion of review request very seriously for the purposr of enhanced electri,ty generation in India and agricultural purposes. If Pakistan ignores it, India may go for unilateral decision, believe me. I believe, delay / going to World Bank, International Tribunal won't solve request for talk on review request by India.
Dishonesty much? Opens with "unilateral" when it is just a notice to renegotiate. Ignores the parallel redressals sought by Pakistan when treaty mentions step by step process.
Sending surreptiously terrorists into Kashmir is aggression My dear Anchor. No treaty can be indefinite or perpetual in this world. As time goes by it is necessary to revisit in the light if new circumstances
treaties are an agreement between two parties. The reason the agreement stands if the relationship is maintained. Since Pakistan has done everything to ruin all relation, why is pakistan expecting India will not scrap all agreements. There is no oversight over countries, all this talk about seeing this as some law is foolish. Pakistan should see how China dismisses International court on south china sea. India will ignore all International forums that Pakistan will go to and just say.. Implement China's orders first before talking to India.
7 rivers cross from india to Pakistan, 3 rivers satluj, Ravi, Chenab to India, Jhelum half to each nations, neelum, Indus, and shyok rivers to Pakistan,that's the only solution.aur beas river Pakistan mei nahi hai.kya intellectual hai yeh.iski beas river sukh gai.🤣😂😁
Had pakistan ever upheld any of its agreements ? Why should they be entitled to 80% of the water and indja 20%? India had full rignt to withdraw or renegotiate the treaty. This has been done by many other countries unilaterally including USA and China
6:12 Anchor Lady, have you read the resolution of the UN? Keep lying. Nothing will change. The water treaty will be changed, modified according to India's wish. And Pakistan can't do anything in its present situation.
Ap ek time pe ek hi arbitration kr skte ho na ki dono sir we don't care who the hell this P5 countries are we are also a major power becoming more powerful day by day
Dear Anchor Please ask Pak army to completely withdraw from Pak occupied Kashmir as per the sequential points of UN resolution. Please study the UN resolution as a member of policy research institute before commenting. In any case UN resolution is nullified and abrogated after Simla agreement between the two countries
Its is ridiculous. If India decides to break up the treaty what can pakistan do except complain that this violation of International law. India scrapped article 370 what did pakistan do other than complaining
इंडिया मे तुम्हारे जैसे स्पेशलिस्ट यहा के लॉ स्टूडेंट का बस्ता ढोता है इंटरनेशनल लॉ होता क्या है? कोई ऐसी machinery हैं जो ऐसी कानून को inforce करा सकता है?? Let's see कैसे tumhare abbu मोदी जी... ऐसी treaty का मज़ाक उड़ाते है 🇮🇳🚩🕉️
filhal treaty pakistan ke fevour me hai (Nehru ki daryadilli @BLUNDER) , jo powerful nation hoga wo treaty ko break kar sakta hai geopolitics kisi law se govern nhi hoti POWER is the only law
Treaties are always broken..wait n see what happens! Modi he to mumkin he
munaafiq kee ain yehi nishaani hai
@@kayaar00 bhag Pakistani musalman
@@kayaar00 Munaafiq to tum ho jo hindo ka pani pii rahe ho 🤣
Ham to kafir hai
Bhai mere to smjh nhi aata in satvi fail jahilo ko expart kon bolta h 😂😂😂
The moment Pakistan use the force even once, the Indus water treaty will permanently become null and void.
Already many acts of violence has happened..
Abe sale 80% water tumko hi milta hai , phir bhi tumlog ki g@nd sukhi hai .Kitna pani lagta hai tumko
Pakistan giving lecture on international laws , what a hypocrite 😂
You may laugh but don't forget Pakistan is a nuclear power with modern ballistic missiles integrated with MIRV technology with mach 18 velocity, and has the credible capacity to destroy India in 10 mins.
Now, you can drink my juice if your laugh is over!
Any country can withdraw itself from a treaty when it feels it doesn't benefit it. 😂Wait and watch, Pakistan.
We should withdraw from this treaty at once. Just like how Pakistan has not adhered to the Shimla agreement.
Yeh log PUBLIC PLATFORM AAKE JHOOTH KAISE BOL SAKTE HAIN..HATS OFF TO THIS PEOPLE...ND THEN THEY TALK ABOUT CREDIBILITY..btw he is a international law expert
😅
i find it hilarious.... Pakistani experts, anchor persons talking of human rights 😂
Pakistan is talking about international laws 😂😂and principal
Hippocracy ki bhi Sima hoti hai😂😂
PM Nehru was overly generous in allocating 80% of water to Pakistan in the Indus Water Treaty of 1960 . Maximum water for Pakistan , as a lower riparian nation , should have been less than 50%/ India should seek a review in her favour of the Indus Water Treaty. River Beas is only a tributary of River Sutlej . Beas does not even enter Pakistan. Chenab i.e. Chandrabhaga is basically a river of Himachal Pradesh. It belongs to HP and has a very small Kashmir connection. Chenab's waters should be diverted to Ravi and other Indian rivers including Yamuna. India got in her share waters of only two rivers compared to 3 rivers for Pakistan..
Atta mil raha he ki ni 😂😂😂😂
🤣🤣🤣
Indus Water Treaty of 1960 is the root cause of Indian Punjab's water issues.
Diverting Chenab water to Ravi and on-wards can solve our Indian Punjab's water issues.
SYL project can be upgraded as CSYL -Chenab- Sutlej- Yamuna Link Canal
The INCOMING PRESIDENT of WORLD BANK is an INDIAN American, AJAY BANGA.
BRACE BAKISTAN BRACE❕❕❕
so what ? world bank president has to be American national not bhikari Indian.
India Don't even think about it Jawaharlal Nehru Indus water treaty.
girl read UN resolution first before talking
Arrey bhai even if they read that 2+2=4 they will deny if it is decreed.
Thankfor taking step on the agreements of 1947 May Allah help both of the coutries to solve this matters .
Pay attention to the wording of the notice. That wording is not found in the IWT but in certain omnibus international laws. IWT is burnt toast.
Both are trying to sell Lahauri Churan 😅😅😂
India is taking the right steps well within her rights in the Indus Water Treaty i.e. Stopping totally the waters of River Ravi by constructing Shahpur Kandi Dam and dams on Ravi’s tributaries like River Ujhh and River Basantar .
Construction of maximum number of hydro electricity dams / navigational facilities on Rivers Chenab , Jhelum and Indus and also utilising fully ,for irrigation-al / drinking water purposes, India’s small share in these rivers.
I am challenging if there will be use of force from Pakistan side they will be wiped out from the world map. Be careful.
There are so many examples all over the world. "Dil bahlaney ke liye Galib ye khayal achha ha".😃
Partition should be revisited 18% got 3 countries
Beggaristan
It is high time..... we should amend paxtan itself....
It is successful because it is favourable to Pakistan otherwise it has violated so many agreements. Now time has come for India.
When POK is not an integral part of Pakistan as one of its province than how it can enter a treaty relating to POK. There is a independent govt on POK.
Therefore treaty is null and void in itself
The problem that we are facing is that our most of the projects are struck everytime u find one and other way to halt our project thats why indian govt is interested in renegotiating it and one more thing this treaty is favouring pak
PM Nehru ,in `1960 under the Indus Water Treaty , gifted 80 % of Indus river systems water , to Pakistan.
As a lower riparian State ,Pakistan was entitled to a maximum of 50% . Nehru had hoped that his magnanimity would usher in an era of friendship and cooperation with Pakistan.
A few years later , in 1965 ,Pakistan returned Nehru's grand olive branch gesture , by invading India
Paxstan doesn't deserve any good. We just have to stop all kinds of visas forever
@@abrakadabbraabk958 OK
India is saying if Pakistan considers jihadi terror as OK, India also doesn’t consider anything holy in IWT.
The ball is in Pakistan’s court. They have to decide and come to terms with a big India which won’t allow Pakistan to engage in jihad at no cost. I don’t think that is fair right?
When Pak can break Shimla accord, why expect India to honour Indus Water treaty ? Moreover, why expect BCCI to send team for Asia cup, when Pak gov ended trade, denies airspace to Srinagar flights, continue to protect Mumbai attackers
International law ka theka sirf India na Nahi Liya Hai !
Treaty is lop sidedly in favor of Paakistaan. It needs be abrogated.
thank you for such a great one sided discussion ! But I enjoy the pain of Pakistani state narrative during ModiEra. Congress time mai to ye log utsav mana rahey they :) cricket jo band kar rahey they mutemohan ji.
Namaste intelligent people from both sides of borders how you people are doing sir 👍👍
India want that you start military action on water treaty and then India can capture pok and baltistan.
Matchless conversation
These agreements all depend on the goodwill of India. Once that is gone anything can happen.
If Pakistan is adamant then India will finish Pakistan by breaking into 5 parts .
West pakistan did not allow his own constitutionally elected Mujib Rahaman to become PM
Informative discussion with an eminent legal expert. As regards IWT it is successfully sustained the test of the time. However, as regards environmental flows in three rivers where water is stopped by India as per IWT, it may require a review may be a separate treaty as an addendum to existing IWT. This could be examined by the experts associated in execution of IWT.
He is a Pakistani legal expert. In educated countries, he will not get the job of a peon in a law office.
@@atulbesra822 Grateful for your kind reply.
If a party is violating the treaty, other party can walk out from it. Pakistan has been violating Indus water treaty with impunity. Pskistan has been getting more water from the indus river system than is allowed in the treaty. Pakistan is not allowing India to use its share of water Whenever India tries to build run of the river installations, Pakistan adopts delaying tactics and the construction get halted for many years. In view of Pakistani intransigence, which tantamounts to violation of the Indus water treaty, India can walk out from the treaty today if India wants.
This guy is saying the most ridiculous things with a straight face😂
Getting lecture from beggers is so demeanour as an indian that i can't explain in words. Everything is fare in love and war so Pakistan is not our friend and kya kar loge if treaty is voilated , Russian attacked whole ukraine and world didn't has potential to do anything so do you think world can do anything against India. Jiss aaba ke pass jana hain jao and no one is going to help😂
I can tell you from India, India is taking this matter of discussion of review request very seriously for the purposr of enhanced electri,ty generation in India and agricultural purposes.
If Pakistan ignores it, India may go for unilateral decision, believe me.
I believe, delay / going to World Bank, International Tribunal won't solve request for talk on review request by India.
Instead of discussing the issue of water treaty or maintenanability of Indian notice, it has been reduced to putting out standard Pakistan views.
Water is flowing from Indian river.
If Pakistan wants India to follow Treaty, vacate Kashmir under UN resolutions .
Dishonesty much? Opens with "unilateral" when it is just a notice to renegotiate. Ignores the parallel redressals sought by Pakistan when treaty mentions step by step process.
Pakistan people can use tissue paper to clean or use page of Quran.
Sending surreptiously terrorists into Kashmir is aggression My dear Anchor.
No treaty can be indefinite or perpetual in this world.
As time goes by it is necessary to revisit in the light if new circumstances
Aree yaar ak Pakistani bhi nahi hai is comment section ke andhar.
Udhar internet zayada hi kharab hain lag raha maybe😂
THERE IS NO INDUS VALLEY TREATY NOW.
What does P5 have to do with the treaty. Are they jobless 😂😂😂
No treaty can be amended or altered unilaterally. This is logical you don't need to quote law.
US broke nuclear treaty with Iran, What is logical is that stronger nation decides what should be the treaty.
In this case Pakistan has been breaking Indus water treaty and then playing victim card.
SYL project should be expanded to CSYL- Chenab- Sutlej- Yamuna Link
Instead of giving water to Pakistan, Give water to Punjab and all lower states.
@@mayurbisne Sir. Well said
I am a kashmiri, tumloog nasoor hoo iss duniyamai
India had so many bruises in past..2008 to kargil..we should have done that earlier
India will scrap / withdraw from treaty not amend/change/modify
treaties are an agreement between two parties. The reason the agreement stands if the relationship is maintained. Since Pakistan has done everything to ruin all relation, why is pakistan expecting India will not scrap all agreements. There is no oversight over countries, all this talk about seeing this as some law is foolish. Pakistan should see how China dismisses International court on south china sea.
India will ignore all International forums that Pakistan will go to and just say.. Implement China's orders first before talking to India.
China ne Bharat ka Bhramputra dariya ka pani Rok diya.
7 rivers cross from india to Pakistan, 3 rivers satluj, Ravi, Chenab to India, Jhelum half to each nations, neelum, Indus, and shyok rivers to Pakistan,that's the only solution.aur beas river Pakistan mei nahi hai.kya intellectual hai yeh.iski beas river sukh gai.🤣😂😁
Had pakistan ever upheld any of its agreements ? Why should they be entitled to 80% of the water and indja 20%? India had full rignt to withdraw or renegotiate the treaty. This has been done by many other countries unilaterally including USA and China
Dar ka mahaul hai😂🔥
Why every one calling success full treaty ( success mean not violated , so can be violate by upper stream).
What happened to the minorities in Pakistan?
It seems the guest has not studied the Indus water trety and the resolution on Kasmir.😢
6:12 Anchor Lady, have you read the resolution of the UN? Keep lying. Nothing will change. The water treaty will be changed, modified according to India's wish. And Pakistan can't do anything in its present situation.
Lol
Then what About Shimla treaty ???
Modi finds way that's why he sent notice. It will b cancelled through viena convention wait & watch.
Waise to bahot sare ruels hai,how many rules Pakistani followed?? Who had illegal inflitrated kargil in 1999???
Ap ek time pe ek hi arbitration kr skte ho na ki dono sir we don't care who the hell this P5 countries are we are also a major power becoming more powerful day by day
International law expert......
Bull ahit discussion
INDUS WATER TREATY WILL END UP BECOMING SAARC
FOOLISH NEHRU ALONGWITH IWT FREE WATER GAVE A GRANT OF GBP62BLN.
Modi kisi treaty ko nhi manta bhai sab 😅😅
Bhai sahab
370 ka rona kab chhodoge
Dear Anchor
Please ask Pak army to completely withdraw from Pak occupied Kashmir as per the sequential points of UN resolution.
Please study the UN resolution as a member of policy research institute before commenting.
In any case UN resolution is nullified and abrogated after Simla agreement between the two countries
Jis din Pakistan Banjar hoga mere 15 lakh mujhe mil jayenge. 😊😊😊
Modi g shikari aadmi hain.
Trriti jaye bhad mein.pani hamara hame cyeye.
Tum logo ne minority ka kya haal kiya hain, state sponsors hindu atrocity chal rahi hain, you don’t have moral ground to speak for any treaty.
Its is ridiculous. If India decides to break up the treaty what can pakistan do except complain that this violation of International law. India scrapped article 370 what did pakistan do other than complaining
Jai hind
Namkeen paani ke istemaal ki aadat daal lo. Rainwater harvesting start kar do. Embrace permaculture. Aane wale din kharab h aapke.
Who told you India violated UN treaty,Pakistan totally violated UN resolution not vacating j&k but also illegally occupied j&k not only
Churan as always
nothing is definite in this world .
इंडिया मे तुम्हारे जैसे स्पेशलिस्ट यहा के लॉ स्टूडेंट का बस्ता ढोता है इंटरनेशनल लॉ होता क्या है? कोई ऐसी machinery हैं जो ऐसी कानून को inforce करा सकता है?? Let's see कैसे tumhare abbu मोदी जी... ऐसी treaty का मज़ाक उड़ाते है 🇮🇳🚩🕉️
filhal treaty pakistan ke fevour me hai (Nehru ki daryadilli @BLUNDER) , jo powerful nation hoga wo treaty ko break kar sakta hai geopolitics kisi law se govern nhi hoti POWER is the only law
Modi finds way that's why he sent notice. It will b cancelled through viena convention wait & watch.