Fellow VS Saki - Which is the Best Gooseneck Tea Kettle?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 28 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 13

  • @zapster1984
    @zapster1984 Год назад +9

    Great breakdown and honest review! Thanks for showing the inside - not enough people are aware of the dangers of plastic & silicone material leeching microplastics into boiling water, so the SAKI wins for me. Just ordered!

    • @JeffreyMcIntosh
      @JeffreyMcIntosh  Год назад +1

      Glad it was helpful! The devil is in the details, especially with water quality and the effect on taste and health. :) Thanks for watching.

  • @Katt1989
    @Katt1989 9 месяцев назад +2

    Terrific review - thanks very much!

  • @rbedford6965
    @rbedford6965 18 дней назад

    The view into the Saki shows two blacked areas. The first one at 3:31 looks like two small black dots on the lower vertical surface, and a third oblong black spot on the raised rim of the bottom. The second one at 3:34 is an irregular shaped area at the seam. I'm surprised that these were not mentioned in the review. Could you please explain what these two areas are? I know that Fellow states that their kettle has no plastic touching the water, but there is a silicone seal, and many users indicate a plastic-like odor/taste with their kettle, even after a time. It makes me wonder if the taste/smell is their silicone seal, or if that seal is mis-attached/lose and if the taste comes from inside, below that seal. With the Saki, you state that there is no visible silicone or sensor inside the kettle, other than the silicone seal on the lid, but those blacked areas are not mentioned. Please clarify, if you can. Thanks!

  • @Barrigard
    @Barrigard Год назад +3

    Another great video from Jeffrey! I hadn't heard about the Saki until today. I'm still rocking my Bonavita Goseneck until the day it dies. Good to know the Fellow is still being used after a few years on the market. I'm always concerned about long term usage when buying a brand new product at a premium price. I'll probably get a Fellow whenever I'm in the market for a replacement.

    • @JeffreyMcIntosh
      @JeffreyMcIntosh  Год назад +1

      Thanks for watching! Yeah long term is so important, especially at these price points. I have really enjoyed the Fellow, it’s was my go to and still is, however I have been pleasantly surprised by the saki.

  • @DoEverythingDerek
    @DoEverythingDerek Год назад +5

    Have you had any issues with the Saki? I saw a few reviews of people saying they smelled like chemicals and one showed the plate at the bottom burned through

    • @JeffreyMcIntosh
      @JeffreyMcIntosh  Год назад +3

      I have not had those issues, I have had and used mine for one year, however now I notice the touch panel is harder to turn off and is a little funky, for instance it may take holding down the power button 5 seconds instead of the normal 3 seconds. But the kettle has not had issues yet. Hope that helps. The Fellow is indeed much better built, I am going on 4 years for my kettle.

    • @chappyo5528
      @chappyo5528 Год назад

      Hi, I'm looking for a kettle, settling on the Saki Luna or Fellow Corvo, but both seem to be of similar quality so I'm surprised that you suggest the Fellow is of much better quality. I've seen one reviewer criticize the quality of the Fellow plastic base and switches on back, and another goes into how simplistic the electronic components are in the expensive Fellow. I was under the impression that the Saki was a heavier gauge steel, but there might be a learning curve with the capacitive buttons. I would probably prefer the dial on the Fellow, but otherwise thought for 2/3 the price I was getting the same overall quality with the Saki. PS: the Saki apparently has zero contact between the water (directly or through steam/condensation) and any plastics/silicone: can you confirm that there's no sensor inside the bottom of the kettle with a silicone ring?
      If so, that's pretty impressive I think. Thanks for any info you can share.

  • @geslinam9703
    @geslinam9703 11 месяцев назад +2

    Now that you have had the Fellow pink for a while, have there been any issues with the finish? Any scratches or chipping? I really love the pink, though I wish it was all pink, without the wooden handle. And I’m thinking the black would hold up nicer over time, be more forgiving to signs of wear and tear.

    • @JeffreyMcIntosh
      @JeffreyMcIntosh  11 месяцев назад

      Great question. The Fellow has held up better then any of my other kettles, however the pink kettle body as picked up some cosmetic scratches that are noticeable (scratches). However in terms of durability and function there are no issues and I still use it almost daily. I also have two black Fellow kettles, neither have noticeable scratches like the pink. (but I also travel to events with my kettle a lot, hence why there might be scratches)

    • @geslinam9703
      @geslinam9703 10 месяцев назад

      @@JeffreyMcIntosh thanks, another thing to consider in my decision. I have been considering which one I want for a week now. I think if not for the wood, I’d have bought the pink already.

  • @agatagoss6444
    @agatagoss6444 Год назад +1

    What model of kettle have function to keep set 120 deg F for Gyokuro tea. Or keep custom temp for up to 2 hours. Or maybe you recomend other brands of kettle. Thank you