This woman is over 40 and has been hitting high notes for over 20 years. People's voices change as they get older. She hasn't lost her voice, it has just changed. Grow up. Why do people hate her so much that they can't even give her credit for anything? How many artists do you think will still be able to hit such high notes when they are her age?
I aM Honey please. Stop being delusional. She only lose ease on her upper belt register. Her lower register is better than ever, her whistle is still intanct, her head voice is still great. Why only focus on one register?
Krayola D You're so annoying too. You keep coming into these videos though your opinion is not needed. You're also delusional because your janet jackson cannot sing better than Mariah Carey.
The west coast version was edited. It’s possible the audio at the end was replaced with one of the 2 warm up performances to preserve the crowd sounds. They had to make the edit pretty quickly.
Mariah is singing for real, this is live....She looks gorgeous and her voice is just amazing and beautiful as always has been... Actually she sounds even better right now... Great Job Mariah, we are happy you are back SUPER HUGE STAR !!!!! Guys Check Also a Brilliant Brazilian Singer called Marisa Monte. Marisa Monte and Mariah Carey are for me the best singers in the world, amazing voices !!!
Wtf ppl she doesn't sing bad. Maybe not the best performance of all time for her but she can still sing better than all of us. She is older now and ya can't expect her to be like when she was 20. For a 44 year old woman she's great.
Mariah Carey the queen. Just remember your favs couldn't do half of the amazing things she's can do and has accomplished. She's the best female selling artist. As for her whistle notes wether she hits or not just know you couldn't do it.
this is real, just look a everyone's reaction when she hit the whistle notes, they were cheering, and when mariah knows that her whistle is not being good she always does other ad libs in place of the whistle, the mess in the edited video can never happen
Unfortunately there are a lot of clips from the East Coast "live" feed that show the struggle was real. You can tell because the local temperature on the bottom right corner is local to whoever caps the video, and there are quite a few different ones. That'd be a lot of faking.
I love how people born to hate. THIS IS THE REAL VERSION. YOU CAN SEE SHE GOES OUT OF BREATH IN THE END OF THE WHISTLE AND START TO BE A LITTLE LESS ACCURATE TO REACH THEM, BUT IT'S NOT COMPARED TO THE EDITED VERSION WHERE THEY PUT SOMEBODY STRUGGLING AS IF IT WAS HER. She can, babies, just accept. She is so amazing as this perfomance. It's a fact !
There are literally at least 5 fan recording from in the crowd proving that she couldn’t hit the notes in the live performance. She DID hit them in the warm ups. For all of those people there and all of the DVR’s from the east coast version to be edited would be a bigger conspiracy theory than 9/11.
why are you guys writing negative comments about Mariah carey. she's been around for along time and still sounds amazing, when you guys can sing like her post a video and say what you want other wise keep your negative words to yourself. smh. can you hit those notes? if so, (doubt) when you get older let us know how your voice changes!! go ahead Mariah carey =)
She hasn’t lost her voice. She’s been singing vocal suicide songs for over 20 years. Her voice has just changed. I can’t believe there are some haters that don’t give her credit for anything.
I came here as I saw a comment on something else about Mariah not singing very well on this occasion. Well I couldn't see anything wrong with his performance. As always flawless in my eyes! I'm a lamb for life! X
She looked so great during this period (and right now she is also looking good). I loved that dress and her hair during this concert was so pretty. When people write something negative about her voice, you have to remember that she is in her 40´s now and she has had to babies. Of cause she is not going to sound like what she did in the beginning of her career. :)
*She slayed that day, as usual. Even when she had nodes.* *The thing is this fake/hater videos just doesnt make any sense. She still had 18 #1's, a star in the fame walk a guiness record for her vocal range and more than 200 millions records sold. Go and search for it, search for the rehrearsal of that song that same day as well.* *PD: ari is ok, but I don't think she what has to do with this, however I'd like to say that Mariah by the time she was 21 already had 4 number 1 billboard hits and 2 grammys, she had been doing whistles since day 1, Ariana was that age last year and still she has no grammys, no number 1's and no live whistles. LOL.*
Only today I have found out that she struggles with bipolar disorder and feel or felt extremelly stressed when she had to step in stage. God is with you Mariah and I think this is the most important
I love how mariah carey she can control a whole room and miguel is a amazing singer too and very handsome they are two amazing people and singers!!!❤️❤️❤️🌹🌹🌹😍😍😍
Mariah is the biggest female singer that ever touch the ground. Almost 30 years of career, and she is still giving all of her. Bow down new one... Mariah is one of that brave girls who dare to be sexy, to be independent, and EVERYTHING that she wanted
C'mon people she doesn't sound that bad at all. And no one should blame her because it is hard to hit whistle tones. Also I've heard that she has something wrong with hitting high notes but I'm not positive if that is true or not. So all you Mariah haters go AWAY, and if you don't like her don't watch these videos just to make fun of her and say mean comments!! So people that are being mean stop it is not worth it at all!!!!!!
The people saying she is bad or whatever, when she was younger her voice was flawless. Sure, she doesn't sound as good as she did when she was younger, but she still sings better than most "Singers" these days. To me her voice is stunning.
Видеоклипы
![[HD] Mariah Carey - #Beautiful feat. Miguel - Live on Good Morning America (Real Version)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/xKFKpi9ddDI/mqdefault.jpg)
This woman is over 40 and has been hitting high notes for over 20 years. People's voices change as they get older. She hasn't lost her voice, it has just changed. Grow up. Why do people hate her so much that they can't even give her credit for anything? How many artists do you think will still be able to hit such high notes when they are her age?
blacksmartie She is losing her register. Do not lie. She needs to take a royal seat because she has already earned legendary status.
I aM Honey please. Stop being delusional. She only lose ease on her upper belt register. Her lower register is better than ever, her whistle is still intanct, her head voice is still great. Why only focus on one register?
Lamb Forever That's cute and all, but she still needs to have a seat and stop performing live.
Krayola D You're so annoying too. You keep coming into these videos though your opinion is not needed. You're also delusional because your janet jackson cannot sing better than Mariah Carey.
Oh -hell-to-the-no LIES AND DECEIT. Why would someone lie and say that Janet can sing better. You mean PERFORM BETTER
This whistle is live. You can hear the breathiness and everything.
Actually No. Its Not Live But She Did them live In The REHERSEAL!
@@benriveranavand how would you know. I doubt if you worked back stage 🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄
Y'all sound crazy how is her whistle lipped. Just say you're jealous
@@kennettabradford6566 i mean...every prerecorded track is the same and its pretty easy to tell
The west coast version was edited. It’s possible the audio at the end was replaced with one of the 2 warm up performances to preserve the crowd sounds. They had to make the edit pretty quickly.
I love Mariah and everyone thinks she is "Struggling" "Old" She is PERFECTLY AWESOME!!!
Mariah is singing for real, this is live....She looks gorgeous and her voice is just amazing and beautiful as always has been... Actually she sounds even better right now... Great Job Mariah, we are happy you are back SUPER HUGE STAR !!!!!
Guys Check Also a Brilliant Brazilian Singer called Marisa Monte. Marisa Monte and Mariah Carey are for me the best singers in the world, amazing voices !!!
*Mariah's legs are everything*
And Miguels face is everything too! Lol ❤️😊
Wtf ppl she doesn't sing bad. Maybe not the best performance of all time for her but she can still sing better than all of us. She is older now and ya can't expect her to be like when she was 20. For a 44 year old woman she's great.
Imthatgrl nah this the real version but from a musical perspective it was bad
Rachel Drummond not bad
I enjoyed it and I'm musically trained.
damn...Mariah is still fire...never in history have so many mature females look so good...wow
I love mariah carey this live its amazing whistle :)
She's great and lets tell those haters to just whistle like her.
Damn her voice is just soooo AMAZING mahn!!....
i know ryt!!!....and miguel is just soo hot!!...hahaha
Mariah’s lyrics are unmatched. She puts words to our innermost feelings
Mariah Carey the queen. Just remember your favs couldn't do half of the amazing things she's can do and has accomplished. She's the best female selling artist. As for her whistle notes wether she hits or not just know you couldn't do it.
Facts and I loved it
this is real, just look a everyone's reaction when she hit the whistle notes, they were cheering, and when mariah knows that her whistle is not being good she always does other ad libs in place of the whistle, the mess in the edited video can never happen
Unfortunately there are a lot of clips from the East Coast "live" feed that show the struggle was real. You can tell because the local temperature on the bottom right corner is local to whoever caps the video, and there are quite a few different ones. That'd be a lot of faking.
+Patrick C yes
Ich bin Shin she was sitting
Madonna
@@corycooldangerous she did the performance in a few different takes and it one of them she actually hit the whistles.
Miguel is sooo handsome
Miguel and his little dance moves near Mariah :')
When Mariah do the whistle thing, she is just sooooooooooo Cute!
Mariah & Miguel!! Mannn, that’s REAL singing! 🎤🎤 💕💙
This performance was so good, why y'all hating
cause its the dubbed performance the real video shows her fucking up
The dubbed one was the bad one created as a joke lol. This was live dumbass.
Aqua Stone Its not live fuckface....Abc gma said they edited it themselves and several articles states so as well bitch
Lol lies you tell
Aqua Stone Lol the lies you tell
I love when she laughed. She killed it at the end.
Mariah can sing!! Grew up listening to her and still love her! I need to see her perform live.
Ppl hating on a icon!
SHE IS A LEGEND!
mariah!!! beautiful!!!!
Mariah it's been singing for years, just learn to apreciate, she has beautiful songs!! And she's a beautiful person! God bless you Mariah!! ❤️😍
she is acting and looking like a queen! I love my Mimi what a BEAUTIFUL song!
mariah is so perfect and she looks so great
3:10 had me dying!!!!!’
Love Mariah shes such a legend! Always will be. And Miguel is just wow♡
mariah fucking killed the ending with here high notes
Both sound just impeccable live ❤❤
I love how people born to hate. THIS IS THE REAL VERSION. YOU CAN SEE SHE GOES OUT OF BREATH IN THE END OF THE WHISTLE AND START TO BE A LITTLE LESS ACCURATE TO REACH THEM, BUT IT'S NOT COMPARED TO THE EDITED VERSION WHERE THEY PUT SOMEBODY STRUGGLING AS IF IT WAS HER.
She can, babies, just accept. She is so amazing as this perfomance. It's a fact !
exactly! I also watched LIVE when it was broadcast and there was no Flaw on her vocals at all!
.
There are literally at least 5 fan recording from in the crowd proving that she couldn’t hit the notes in the live performance. She DID hit them in the warm ups. For all of those people there and all of the DVR’s from the east coast version to be edited would be a bigger conspiracy theory than 9/11.
why are you guys writing negative comments about Mariah carey. she's been around for along time and still sounds amazing, when you guys can sing like her post a video and say what you want other wise keep your negative words to yourself. smh. can you hit those notes? if so, (doubt) when you get older let us know how your voice changes!! go ahead Mariah carey =)
Preach. I was able to hit only one of those notes just once. That was it. Once. She is talented as hell
She hasn’t lost her voice. She’s been singing vocal suicide songs for over 20 years. Her voice has just changed. I can’t believe there are some haters that don’t give her credit for anything.
omfg her whistle GOD BLESS HER
I came here as I saw a comment on something else about Mariah not singing very well on this occasion. Well I couldn't see anything wrong with his performance. As always flawless in my eyes! I'm a lamb for life! X
The problem is this was edited and Mariah's not actually hitting the high notes
No the bad video was for a vine. Lol
JackHow97 its not edited tho. What’s your point?
This will always be another one of my favs from the 1& only Mariah Carey!Miguel is great, also!
The end always amaze me :) I love #Beautiful
Mariah carrey has more Natural and beautiful voice than other female singers
Mariah has a beautiful soulful tone to her voice and that Angelic whistle ❤
This never gets old! I love them both!!! ❤️🩷🔥
She looked so great during this period (and right now she is also looking good). I loved that dress and her hair during this concert was so pretty. When people write something negative about her voice, you have to remember that she is in her 40´s now and she has had to babies. Of cause she is not going to sound like what she did in the beginning of her career. :)
Her voice is perfect
I love how she changes the whistle slightly at the end!Amazing!Finally got to see her live in Atlantic City last month!!!Still not over it!!!😅😍😘🤗😇👏👏👏👏
I love both of artists. Thank God for them!!!
This song is so so so BEAUTIFUL ❤️❤️❤️
Miguel is one of those artists that sound good on record on record and live, love this :D
Holy lord Mariah is a queen!! No one can sing like her!!
I just love how youthful she looks and acts. She seem like such a relaxed,fun person.
this is the non edited I watched it on tv and it was like crispy clear baby, fight me
I can't believe she hit those notes *.* Left me in aweeee
Mariah is a true queen with a voice! Beautiful!
this should have been a #1 hit.
she is so beautiful and amazing!!!!
Them high notes were perfect
Wow those high notes !!!!!❤️Mariah Carey
100% live . Stopping being a
hater
Someone explain what was wrong with performance? I watched it 4 times to see what y’all are seeing......
It’s was awesome.
Those whistles at the end LOVE LOVE LOVE LOVE
Those high notes at the end
*She slayed that day, as usual. Even when she had nodes.*
*The thing is this fake/hater videos just doesnt make any sense. She still had 18 #1's, a star in the fame walk a guiness record for her vocal range and more than 200 millions records sold. Go and search for it, search for the rehrearsal of that song that same day as well.*
*PD: ari is ok, but I don't think she what has to do with this, however I'd like to say that Mariah by the time she was 21 already had 4 number 1 billboard hits and 2 grammys, she had been doing whistles since day 1, Ariana was that age last year and still she has no grammys, no number 1's and no live whistles. LOL.*
yasss
Hi how are u? Ariana is now have all the things that she don't have before. That's the fact.
Mariah carey is so cute ♥
Wow she sounds amazing
Omg. I am hear for Miguel. I have always loved this song.
She literally looks like she's in so much pain singing those last high notes
Only today I have found out that she struggles with bipolar disorder and feel or felt extremelly stressed when she had to step in stage. God is with you Mariah and I think this is the most important
this performance is awesome
I love how mariah carey she can control a whole room and miguel is a amazing singer too and very handsome they are two amazing people and singers!!!❤️❤️❤️🌹🌹🌹😍😍😍
And mariah carey is a very very beautiful woman and have a very great personality she's beyond this world amazing!!!❤️😍🌹😊💪
I love Mariah
she's amazing!
My live favorite of Beatiful
everyone’s talking about Mariah but miguel killed it like usual🥰😍❤️
Amazing mariah her voice is the best. Love you mimi
Beautiful!!
applause to #MariahCarey ...i love her so much ...
Bruh so much talent
one of her best single in years... so sad that she had that accident... she was on point
Those high notes ! Wow
I LOOOOOOOOVE THIS! Perfection!
HIGH NOTE at the end..wow!! freaking beutiful ...love u soo muchhh
She is such a Diva 😊 I like her
I always choose to listen to this performance rather than the original video cause this one hits different 😊😊🤗
Mariah is the biggest female singer that ever touch the ground. Almost 30 years of career, and she is still giving all of her. Bow down new one... Mariah is one of that brave girls who dare to be sexy, to be independent, and EVERYTHING that she wanted
C'mon people she doesn't sound that bad at all. And no one should blame her because it is hard to hit whistle tones. Also I've heard that she has something wrong with hitting high notes but I'm not positive if that is true or not. So all you Mariah haters go AWAY, and if you don't like her don't watch these videos just to make fun of her and say mean comments!! So people that are being mean stop it is not worth it at all!!!!!!
The people saying she is bad or whatever, when she was younger her voice was flawless. Sure, she doesn't sound as good as she did when she was younger, but she still sings better than most "Singers" these days. To me her voice is stunning.
Omg l love her voice.
Man you go girl!!!!!! amaZing! !!!! Both amazing
Omg she was so beautifull and in perfect condition this year😫❤
I got teary at the last part. 😊
That performance was #beautiful
Love this song.
Bird' Sing.... Love it... love Mariah!
God reflects Himself in his creation, like Mariah, she has been gifted so greatly by HIM!
I feel like this. That's Mariah Carey she has nothing to prove to anybody at all. She done it all and has been everywhere. She's already at the top
I had a huge smile on my face when I heard the whistles.
she's such a diva. those high notes! haters can't say anything at all
Most amazing song she has sung since hero!
MARIAH is the bomb!
I love Mariah♥
Im really Glad MC is Back!!!! not might be as Great as she used to be but I so miss Her Golden Music....
She sounds just like the recording and wow this is live 😍
artist of all decade, millenium, year! of all time!
I love You MC!!!