NewsTrack Debate: Hindu Leaders Clash Over Temple Reclamation | Bhagwat's Comments Spark Controversy
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 13 янв 2025
- RSS chief Mohan Bhagwat's comments on limiting temple-mosque disputes have faced pushback from some Hindu leaders and BJP members. While Bhagwat suggested focusing on development over historical grievances, others argue for reclaiming all demolished temples. The debate highlights divisions within the Hindu fold on how to approach religious site controversies. Hindu religious leaders express differing views on reclaiming temples allegedly built over demolished mosques. Swami Ram Bhadracharya criticises RSS chief Mohan Bhagwat's stance, calling for reclamation of prominent temples. Debate ensues over economic impact, historical grievances, and legal approach to temple surveys. Supreme Court's stay on petitions and government's response awaited.
#mohanbhagwat #mandirmasjidcontroversy #religiousdisputes #itwebvideos #rss #rssstance #bjp #hindumuslimdispute #economicimpact #hindutemples #asisurvey #legalbattle #supremecourt #yogiadityanath #templereclamation #mohanbhagwat #rammandir #krishnajanmabhoomi #kashivishwanath #religiousharmony #sanghparivar #uttarpradesh #placesofworshipact #indiatoday
Subscribe to India Today for NEW VIDEOS EVERY DAY and make sure to enable Push Notifications so you'll never miss a new video.
All you need to do is PRESS THE BELL ICON next to the Subscribe button!
India Today TV is India's leading English News Channel. India Today RUclips channel offers latest news videos on Politics, Business, Cricket, Bollywood, Lifestyle, Auto, Technology, Travel, Entertainment and a lot more.
Stay tuned for latest updates and in-depth analysis of news from India and around the world!
WhatsApp Channel: whatsapp.com/c...
Download App: indiatoday.lin...
Follow us: Official website: www.indiatoday...
Twitter: / indiatoday
Facebook: / indiatoday
I fully support the views expressed by Jagatguru and Sai Deepak. It is important to recognize that we have neither destroyed mosques nor converted them into temples throughout history. Given this context, can we not assert a claim on the mosques that have been repurposed or converted?
@@No-appeasement Rightly said. We have to claim our rich heritage.
@@gurunatharao1962Undoubtedly!
Sai deepak or anand ?
I’m not sure if you follow Sai Deepak as well. While he isn’t featured in the video, I deeply admire both these individuals for boldly voicing their opinions in support of Sanatan Dharma. 🙏🏻Together, they bring an incredible synergy, articulating the principles of Sanatan Dharma with well-researched facts and evidence. By mentioning Sai Deepak, I simply wanted to emphasize his contributions, as those who resonate with this perspective are likely familiar with him and the unwavering support he offers to this cause.
@@No-appeasement yes I follow sai deepak . He is good. Ok
1000% Correct AR !
These kind of coward thinking made hindus lose their land, temples,and culture.. no more compramise on our heridetery and dignity
Anand Ranganathan with his stern and unapologetic words 🔥🤝
AR is forgetting that a Brahmin King, Pushyamitra, destroyed Buddhist Viharas and made Brahmin temples in their place. Should this truth not be established in India.
We cannot allow Bhagwatji to cause confusion when hindus in India and all over the world are determined to assert their identity and reclaim Indian civilisation which is based on Sanatana Dharma. Ram temple building is a beginning and therefter Kashi and Mathura, Sambhal and other holy sites of hindus cannot be left ravaged and desecrated by Mughal invaders and their current apologist and islamist bigots who have no stake in our country identity. India is a cradle of Sanatani civilisation and it must take a centre stage in India, where else it would be?
All of the world?
Mohanji Bhagwat is a timid confused Hindu.
The British artificially created the Hindu religion by combining all Abrahamic polytheistic religions under the umbrella of the Hindu religion for administrative ease. In History, no king has called himself a Hindu. Even Lord Ram is not known as a Hindu King. The Hindu religion is not mentioned in the Ram Chitra mannans written by Gowswami Tulsi Das.
Are these Sangies ready to restore all Buddhist Viharas destroyed by a Brahmin King, Pushyamitra Shunga, to correct a historical injustice? After all, during Ashoka, the great India was predominantly Buddhist, from Afghanistan to Burma.
@pardeeptandon3023 : It will be restored. But it may take time.
@@pardeeptandon3023get back to roots of your ancestors dude
Very well said Anand Ranganathan !❤👍👏👏👏😍
Reclaim every looted Temple JUSTICE for HINDUS !✊🔱🕉🚩
Right. 3000+ years older than any other active society with good weather and plenty of of resources and god-fearing can give raise to innumerable monuments and temples. That is India.
Anand Ranganathan should be aware that a Brahmin King, Pushyamitra, destroyed Buddhist Vihara all over India. What if a Buddhist goes to court to claim their Viharas back.
@@pardeeptandon3023Show the evidence not just claims! Every Hindu claim has evidence !
@@pardeeptandon3023 There is no proof or avidence in this in Indian or foreign records.
And return every Buddhist Vihara and Jain Derasar to them and Give Justice to Buddhists & Jains.
Iam in my 50s and associated with RSS for more than fifteen years but now I lost my faith and hope in this organisation
@@sureshnair5690 you should have abandoned the RSS years ago. You should have known that the ideology itself is selfish, which does not fit into the democratic values of our country.
Mohan Bhagwat hatao, RSS bachao...
Super Dr Anand ranganathan. Mohan Bhagvat cannot decide on behalf of Hindus. We want to get back all 40000 temples and correct historical injustices.
DON'T Give COWARD statements against hindhu ideology.RSS is not one person its whole hindhus ideology.MB is just present leader can be taken off if not working for hindu.These kind of coward thinking made hindus lose their land, temples,and culture.. no more compramise on our heridetery and dignity
For Rahul Kanwal if a Muslim man steals a wallet from a Hindu man, the Hindu man should not go to court because that will be a Hindu- Muslim problem. How sensible is that?
As to Hindu kings breaking Buddhist places is a classic case of using an exception. Was breaking of Hindu temples by Muslims kings an exception? Who are you fooling?
Ananda Ranganathan has made the issue crystal clear. Where is the Hindu - Muslim issue?
Sanjay you are like a jayachandra traitor of india.
Rahul is chotta wala😂
Spoken the only TRUTH
I agree, who is Mohammed Bhagat to speak on behalf of Hindus?
Right he is mohammed not mohan !😂😂😂
These kind of coward thinking made hindus lose their land, temples,and culture.. no more compramise on our heridetery and dignity
Till last day he was ur father 😂😂😂
Wahhh kya religion hai 😂
Muslims are clever - they felt manipulating Mohan Bhagavat is critical and they finally did it…
Bhagavat is just fooling these fools!!
So muslims are soooooo smart🤔and sooooo influential
@@humanbeing6838 How did they rule 57 countries from zero? The radical side of muslims exploit society's weakness, grow and dominate....You lost 3 states already, losing a couple more, yet not learned any lessons.....
Accha
The proponents of the artificial Hindu religion are also clever, as they have a selective memory of History.
Rahul kanwal for once be a hindu and take a stand
I promise u wont be removed from ur job 😂
Is he a Hindu or a Christian?
He will never do that. He is a shadow Randeep sardesai. Their guru is Karan Thapar.
Rahul is an anchor and an ideal anchor is supposed to be neutral.
@@josephjames859my frnd the journalists of this country since time immorial are left liberals lutyens media...They were never neutral and they aren't neutral even now
These same people used to lick congress boots before 2014
@josephjames859 he's definitely not a neutral, he's a congress bakht
We are with Yogiji, not Mohan Bhagavat.
Andh Bhakt
Ranganathan is on 🔥
And Rahul Kanwal is 💦.
The central modi govt shud reply to the SC notice and ask them that reclaiming their temples is the legal rights of the hindus and it shud not be held back by the judiciary at any cost..
yes we need only temples .. our great great culture
This anchor Rahul is also becoming Rahul 😂
Anchor Rahul = Rahul 😂
Every single temple must be released from Govt control, mosque and church control. We need this civilisational fight to continue to the end. It is highly ridiculous that Sanatanis are having to fight for EQUAL rights in our own nation. We waited for too long from the BJP to do the right thing but we are disappointed in this regard. I stand with my Sanatani gurus, AR JSD and others in reclaiming every temple.
Every village of india is divided into Caste Hindus area and dalit area..when this issue will be resolved , when Mr RSS will work for this to remove the barrier?. What is the solution u are having to resolve this issue?.
Mohan bhagwat has gone insane.. his old age is showing little earlier.. the worst sangh chalak ever.. the worst RSS supremo since it's inception..
Justice for Hindus
Justice for civilization
Justice for all the sacrifice
So Hindus should work hard, make money, improve economy and pay taxes so that the Muslims can be given the privileges that they think they are entitled and not worry about their culture, tradition, history and heritage. That way India will never be economically prosperous enough to take time for what really matter to the majority of its citizens. Heights of appeasement!
Mohan bhagwat shud retire and quit the top post of RSS. Enough of his nonsense we hv heard
Ranganathan is right.
For a darwinian atheist he doesn't seem to believe in the evolution of society from historical times to now...how strange 😂
A R perfect😊😊😊😊
Who is Mohan Bhagwat to decide what to do.
3000 kyun 30000 hai ,toh bhi chahiye... Kisi ka 10 flat hone se wo dwo flat public ko de dega kya...
With leaders like these,you you do not need enemies.
भारत अत्याधिक धर्मोन्माद धर्मांधता पाखंडवाद अंधविश्वासों के कारण ही गुलाम हुआ था। इन दिनों ये सब बातें पुनः उभार पर हैं, अगर इन्हें रोका नहीं किया और समाज में वैज्ञानिक तार्किक विचार धारा विकसित नहीं की गई तो भारत फिर से गुलाम हो सकता है। इस बार गुलामी उत्तर -पूर्व दिशा से आएगी?
बुद्ध विहार तोड़े -- कहा तोड़े भाई??? 😁😁
सीताराम गोयल ने जब पूछा था उसका उत्तर केवल वामपंथियो ने एक pamphlet से दिया था।।
I agree with Annan
Country is facing problems and other priorities and why Hindus should claim their Astha or fundamental rights? What sort of argument is this ? You mean to say Hindus should leave all their fundamental rights to live, practice and profess their belief? How could Judiciary says don't come to the Court if its a temple issue?!!
Bhagavat was never a final word on Hindu issues .
He used to sensibly take stand of majority Hindus.
Every thing that is national is hindus' .
I fully support to each word spoken by Mr. Anand RangaNathan. Bhagawat is absolutely wrong in his quoted pronouncement. He is no representative of Hindus/Hinduism. His sense of justice is compromised and influenced by Macaulays' theories.
Mohan Bhagavat is not Hindus spokesperson, if he wants to keep united both Hindus and Muslims let him go to Bangla Desh and unite otherwise let him mind his own business. Hindus are better known whom to be united or not. Hindus want all the Pooja Mandir back. Jai hind
What was RSS doing when Hindus were treated so badly in Bangladesh
Bangaldesh ki choro bengal or kerala mai apne rss ke logo ko nhi bacha sakta or khud ko hindu dharam k thake dar bane batha hai
Hare Krishna🙏
Let the buddhists come and claim if it’s proved I am sure our community will return in back.
They won't. They are Buddhist!
Bhagwat ji has done an ADWANI and he will be dethroned same way as ADWANI was!
Rahul Kanwal has read Romila Thappar's history which has been written mainly on gossips than proofs. There is no proof of any Hindu Kings destroyed Buddhist viharas. Dr Ambedkar in preface to his book Buddha & his Dhamma has categorically mentioned that Buddhism extinguished in Bharat because of Muslim invasions in which they destroyed viharas, stupas etc.
What about those thousands of temples which jihadists desecrated and vandalised in Kashmir, post 1990 when genocide of Kashmiri Hindus was perpetuated by Islamist jihadists ??
As usual Jha makes no sense. Why is he always invited?
As for MB he is tired of the fight and needs to retire.
Thanks to AR for being laser focused on the task
Rahul Ji is having a balanced opinion. Well done. Good anchor
Mohan Bhagwat should remember that he is also a leader of Hindus... Not leaders of all Indians ... Jis din Hindu minority hoga, uss din pehele RSS aur Mohan Bhagwat na number at first ayega...
370 removed Kashmir is developing
If it's a legal procedure, how development stops? Then it's a weak democracy ❤ as simple as that
Now Rahul kanwar may I ask you a question, we were under foreign occupation for several centuries, is that indicates that we don't wants freedom from them? Or the freedom movement was wrong?
The very noble bill for kisan paralyzed the country for a year , so it's all shows the weakness of law and order department of India,
A powerful law and order situation never paralyze the economy, the demon's in the opposition paralyzes the country
विश्व स्तर पर जो स्थापित और मान्यता प्राप्त "ऐतिहासिक क्रम Chronological Order)" उसके अनुसार रामायण, महाभारत, गीता आदि धर्म ग्रंथों में वर्णित धटनाओं एवं पात्रों को ऐतिहासिक मान्यता प्राप्त नहीं है। अर्थात वे सभी काल्पनिक घटनाएं व पात्र (Mythical Events and Figures) कहलाते हैं।
जबकि, गौतम बुद्ध,ईसा मसीह एवं मोहम्मद साहब को ऐतिहासिक व्यक्ति (Historical Personality) की मान्यता है।
Exactly, Hinduism is based on imaginary concepts that were very popular worldwide, all those are nothing compared to what Buddha, Jesus and Muhammad bought as religions.
All hindus are not part of RSS....so, who is sarsanghchalk to lecture all Hindus....is he positioning him self as the only Hindu leader
Anand Ranaghatan is absolutely right
Chakrapaani jee sahi bol rahe hain...
Rambhadracharya jee koti koti naman.....sahi bol rahe hain
Instead of searching temples in Mosques BJP should search those thousands of temples who unattended and abandoned since centuries.
You can never understand the pain of a Civilisation whose very important Temples were desecrate and demolished by barbarians and constructed their own place of worship as a sign of humiliation as never had to face this situation. Your ancestors were humiliated and forcefully converted. You have no emotions to your ancestors. I always wonder Marathas who ruled Bharat after Moghuls have not restored our Temples back after demolishing the Mosques built over our Temples. Unfortunately, retribution and hatred is in Sanatani culture and genes.
Atleast now, restore our civilisational pride what us wrong in making legal case?
* not" to be added
Let us think about the existing templates and their position . I visited lot of temples in TAMIL NADU most of the old temples are very big but facilities NIL. The pundits who are working in temples are in very bad financial conditions. So I request these Gurus please visit these templates and see the struggles of people and try to find some way to improve their living standards and at the same time promote the temples and reach out to public to explain the importance of temple and try to get more devotees who can develop the temples.
"...last word on matters to do with the hindu faith.." this sounds like a joke. Who is Mr. Mohan Bhagwat..? He is just a citizen of India who has his own selfish agenda.
Excellent debate. No shouting over each other. And it was genuine exchange of views. And kudos to you Rahul Kanwal for moderating the debate and keeping it under control. (As an aside, please do NOT bow down to Pappu & his slaves for boycotting you. Let them do so. They add no value anyway other than uncouth noise).
That said, fundamental issue here is one of truth. It may not be a 'secular' thing to say, but for Muslims and many deracinated Hindu elite, the destruction of so many Hindu temples by Moghul invaders is a matter of "pride" in "syncretic culture". This abomination must be upended, and the real truth must be upheld. At that point, there will be scope for give and take, and reconciliation.
Yes, all mosques cannot be demolished even if they were built on demolished Hindu temples. But once truth is established, Hindu side has to give some, the Muslim side has to give some, and we move on.
But to see Muslims celebrate Aurangzeb and Babar or justify the demolishing of temples only rubs salt to Hindus' wounded feelings. Furthermore, using the specious arguments such as the one you cited, namely, Hindus also destroyed Buddhist temples, so Hindus should forget about their temples, is another bogus canard. Buddhists are most welcome to come forward with their grievances with evidence, and let courts decide.
No one celebrates Aurangzeb and Babur. True Muslims don't even celebrate our beloved prophet . It's only ONE GOD. So what r u talking about. Your info is indeed half baked. Though I must say u have presented it well.
While your argument is presented logically, I can foresee quite a few problems in it. First of all, once we go down the track of cultural reclamation, there will be no negotiations or compromises. There will be no 'you-take-some-and-we-take' policy. The Hindus are going to say that it's all theirs and that Muslims have been given two countries to build their mosques in. More importantly, it's not difficult in a Hindu nation to 'prove' that there are temples under every mosque, even under the Taj. Remember, the archaeologists and historians were split down the middle vis-a-vis the existence of a ruined temple under the Babri Masjid, depending on their ideological leaning. There are reputed scholars who hold that there was no temple there. The government can always do some cherry picking among the historians to get a team which will support their view. The SC CJ's startling revelation that the Ayodhya judgement was delivered under the divine intervention points to the modus operandi which will be followed to achieve the goal of a mosque-free India.
Ranganathan is very correct. Mohan Bhagat shouldn't have made such statement.
We need more Anand Ranganathan
Anand ranganathan ji should head the bharat khod yatra. But can he do it in his suit boot😂
We want hindu country
Usase kya change hoga? Tere pe tax lgna bnd ho jaega?
You want a hindu country or khod country?
Nepal: Cringing hard..
मान. सर्वो. न्याया.की एक बहुत बड़ी बैंच ने आप. प्र.क्र.291/1971,उ.प्र.सरकार बनाम ललयी सिंह यादव में स्थापित किया है कि रामायण एक काल्पनिक ग्रंथ है।
उल्लेखनीय है कि वे तर्क और आधार रामायण को काल्पनिक ग्रंथ स्थापित करने में प्रयोग किये हैं वे ही तर्क और आधार महाभारत गीता आदि हिंदू धर्म ग्रंथों पर भी लागू होते हैं। अर्थात ये भी काल्पनिक हैं।
अब कोई यह नहीं कह दे कि सर्वोच्च न्यायालय तो राष्ट्र विरोधी है?
Sanjay Tattikhor Jha!
😁😁😁
The onus of Social harmony cannot and should not be on one community.
Rahul bhai ne aaj sahi sawal uthaye
Mohan Bhagwat sathiya gaya...
Mohan Bhagwat hatao, RSS bachao....
Sanjay jha , u are a servant of sonia - rahul Gandhi. So u can't be a practicing hindu
We should stand by our constitution and SC judgments. ❤
Mr.Sanjay Jha we have seen how tolerant Congress was during the killing of Hindus in Kashmir.
Toh kya Bullet train rokh diya jaye...Deah mein bahut garibi abhi bhi hai na...
Desh Ratan Nigam is spot on.. and defends his position in a reasonable way.
Mohan Bhagawat is not thekedar of Sanatan Dharma.
Now reclaiming temples is not the issue , issue is our security and economic growth
Rajdeep Sardesai’s favourite narrative is on POLARISING.
SABA MANDIRA LEKARA RAHENGE❤❤❤
आक्रांताओं की बेड़ियों में सिसकते प्राचीन मंदिर मुक्त हो।आध्यात्मिक विरासत से अतिक्रमण हटें, जीर्णोद्धार हो। उनमें निहित शक्ति केंद्रों में अलौकिक ऊर्जा 🪔 का संचार आरंभ हो। भारत सोने की चिड़िया बनें।
Meenakshi Jain has given enough evidence that the Ramjanma bumi was demolished and a mosque was built..What is Sanjay the saying
Why did the Mughals desecrate temples in the first place..They had scant respect of Hinduism
Hindus also desacrated Hindu temples back then.
Rss try to become invisible master of hindu.
What nonsense is Rahul talking a out. The RSS chief was NEVER the custodian of the Hindu faith. Only of Hindutva.
To divert from Ambekar issthis Bhagwat issue is raised. There is no fight between Modi n Bhagwat.
3000 nahee 40000 ho sakta hai
Welcome Anand sir on India TV
Why no one speaking in waqt acquiring Hindu lands ???
What about hundreds of Shivlings destroyed by Modi & team during Banaras corridor creation??!
No criticism of that???
It is more than obvious such sentiments are only heightened for political reasons..!!
How long Modi model will use these hate model by using some historical incidents and many concocted stories?!?
Bhagat idea looks a bigger plan. Now Hindu Seers have distsnced themselves with RSS, saying RSS is not the owners of Hindus. The idea is to keep the religious sentiments flared up and alive, so that BJP regain loosing grip on voters. It is a pre meditated idea.
Rahul-do not incite people by mentioning what is happening in Israel and Palestine-just because criminals get angry, does not mean they should not be punished. You may have a very narrow mind and wants to forget things that used to exist or happened hundreds and thousands of years ago but for us that is valuable. The older it is, the more valuable it is for us from both our religious point of view and from our history point of view.
Ranga sir always true
Iss dash ka pehechaan IIT, IIM, ISRO jaisa institutions. Iss desh ka pehechaan Mandir, Masjid aur Girja hai.
3000+ years older than any other active society with good weather and plenty of of resources and god-fearing can give raise to innumerable monuments and temples. That is India.
Polarizing is Part of Rajdeep Sardesai’s favourite narrative.
I dont understand the relevance of blip in india gdp to temple reclamation claims. How long will it take for a small ASI team to scientifically prove that kashi mosque waa erected on temple ruins.
Tamilians will support RSS only if they spread equality not on birth...let them make dalits as thier family members
Han sab theek Chal Raha Hai. Mandir masjid mat band karo NAHI to Ranganathan Jaison ki Dukan band ho jayegi.
Who promised that no places other than Ram Temple will be claimed ??
Also remember they took Pakistan and Hindustan is Hindus.. why should we entertain what the people who already took their share and now want more?
Oh shut the fk up and grow up.
Go get a job in Arab nation. 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Bhagavat wants selective leaders .
Why not new leaders beyond his reach ?
Anand's 'justice ' bakwaas
Can somebody tell me what hinduism is? Where does HINDU word came from? What this religion preach? Where does in hindu scriptures HINDU word is mentioned? What is your way of worship? Who is god according to you? How many gods in total you have?
We cannot agree with Mohana.
Today,
Hinduism exists
Only bcz of Rss
BhagawatJi has brought ..Hinduism in other words Humanity
Even this debate
To the centre of attraction
Rather
The play of facts
For the facts
By the play
Through these debates
Yudhishtira said
"Ashwathama hatha 'gaja'"
from which krishna stopped 'gaja' to the ears of Acharya Drona
So I wish to say...
All of us must
Read bhagawat 10 times
Listen Bhagawat twice
&
Learn from it
As the world demands.
The right of the right world for the right people
Who're the interests
For humanity
Find
Learn
The facts
None can close any hole with darkness
Come out
Smell, wish and
enjoy the truth
Jay shree Ram, Jay jogiji maharaja 🙏🌹🌹🙏🚩🚩🙏
Let us be more tolerant. Sit and sort out the issues.
Who is this Anand Ranganathan? They have been created by the Sangha Parivar and now they have become their 😂
What is the so called Hindu tekedars doing when existing temples are being run by ruling governments as though it is their fiefdom?
Why not the endowment ministry come out with a system of handing them over to the stakeholder devotees in the form of a workable cooperative model with accountability and democracy.
There should be no effort to hand it over to Hindu religious groups lije Shankaracharya or other Maths
Each place has a different culture and different procedure of conduct of temple rules. Hence it ahould be only local stakeholder devotees