What does the future hold for Nagorno Karabakh? | Inside Story
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 10 июн 2024
- Azerbaijan is now in full control of Nagorno-Karabakh.
That appears to mark the end of decades of fighting over the disputed enclave.
Armenia and Azerbaijan have struggled for control of the region for decades.
It is internationally recognised as part of Azerbaijan, but is home to a large population of ethnic Armenians.
Fearing reprisals, they are now fleeing across the border.
So what will become of them?
And could this have implications for separatist struggles elsewhere in the world
Presenter: Mohammed Jamjoom
Guests
Nigar Arpadarai, Member of Azerbaijan Parliament.
Matthew Bryza, Former U.S. Mediator of the Nagorno-Karabakh Conflict
Arsen Kharatyan, former Adviser to the Armenian Prime Minister, Nikol Pashinyan.
Subscribe to our channel bit.ly/AJSubscribe
Follow us on Twitter / ajenglish
Find us on Facebook / aljazeera
Check our website: www.aljazeera.com/
Check out our Instagram page: / aljazeeraenglish
Download AJE Mobile App: aje.io/AJEMobile
#Aljazeeraenglish #News #Azerbaijan #NagornoKarabakh #armenia #insidestory
Armenian are lucky that Azerbaijan didn't treat them in the same way that they treated Azerbaijani decades ago.
U r bombing civilian building killing civilian! Clapiing doesn't come one hand
@@somn2425 Armenians are only good at lying. You have been lying and crying for decades. Don't act like you are the victim while you have committed atrocities and occupying AZ for 30 years. All the occupiers in the world deserve to be kicked out.
@@somn2425 where is the fact that Azerbaijan bombed civilians. After one day local anti terror operation Azerbaijan founded most the weapons hidden under the civilian construction. Now these weapons are located inside the civilian buildings by occasional or on purpose in order to accuse Azerbaijan as a civilian killers? Azerbaijan never kills civilians unlike Armenians killed and beheaded civilian Azerbaijani civilian even in 92 and 2020.
Why do I feel like you're lying.
@@somn2425 There was no record by the UN that any civilian had been killed.
Finally one TV station is asking both sides to express their point of view. Thank you!
❤❤❤❤❤❤
I can give you both sides point of view in one word........ Leave
It was 2 Azerbaijanis vs. 1 Armenian... better odds than usual.
Bothsides? You mean that strawman stance that people dropped years ago? There's only one side raping and decapitating women then posting videos of it.
When Russia defeats Ukraine then they will help Aremenia retake lands stolen by Azerbaijan. Russia will also help Serbia take back Kosovo. Christian Orthodox religion will rise again in the region thanks to Russia. Russian empire will return.
Bravo Negar & Azerbaijan ❤ from Bangladesh
They even took their refrigerators. In 1992, Azerbaijan people were expelled barefoot. Who didn't leave were killed. Some things are unforgettable...
Guys please, as an Armenian I'm saying enough is enough. Enough blood has been wasted in this area for more than 100 years. How many innocent people have to suffer more until this finally finds an end? Since I was a little child the most thing I always wished was peace for armenia and that region. This area have been playball for big geopolitical players for long enough, who were just serving their interests there at any cost. I know some really good turkish people here in austria, where I wouldn't hesitate to call them brothers because they are such beautiful souls and wish exactly the same like me. I don't want to start a big political discussion about what happened in the past. Both sides have blood on their hands. Just want to say, that I'm happy that the azeri refugees can finaly come back to their homes and it was a big failure to ever touch azeri civilians and made them to refugees. If some monsters did that a some point, it doesn't mean the opposite side should do the same, because then they would turn to monsters by themselves. Unfortunately many armenian civilians have now also lost their homes, but anyway I'm hoping the Turkish, Azeris and Armenian people can finally find peace after this, and maybe, someday they will live side by side together again, like they did in the past.
❤
Oh you have just got started. US has arrived and You are going to be part of EU and NATO soon enough.
You are destined to be Ukraine's fate soon. 😢😢
🥾@@70newlife
Nogerno karabakh was like Kashmir. We have an old saying in Hindustan. Do not surrender to Turks. It is worse than deatn. Abdali, Ghaznavi , Babar - study about them to know the reason. Please also watch Kashmir FILES. I am 100%sure it is not going to end with Nogerno karabakh > It is the contenuation of Armenian Holocast.
You are the one spilling blood to illegally occupy land that is not yours. You are just like the Russians in Ukraine.
I’m shocked by arguments from Armenian guest. It is imposible to prove anything to him
Well done Azerbaijan Love from PAKISTAN
Good job for Azerbaijan to finish finally this conflict. Conflicts must end, in a way or another. Frozen conflicts are exhausting everyone, someone must prevail.
End? The Nakhchivan has been ethnically cleansed, now Karabah are gonna be ethnically cleansed. Next? Armenia. This is far from over.
Agreed God bless Azerbaijan
It is not finish
Mathew Bryza’s wife is Turk or Azeri so he’s always been very pro Azeri.
Say bye to Menendez and his armenian wife
А лавров армянин + у сенатора США Менендеса жена армянка. Дальше что?
❤ For Azerbaijan From Bangaladesh
The “Nagorno-Karabakh” term was established by Armenia after Karabakh’s invasion in the early 90s. The purpose was to show Karabakh as a separate entity from Azerbaijan. I’m reality it’s just another city/district/county of Azerbaijan. There is no “Nagorno-Karabakh”, there is only Karabakh. Btw for those who wonder, Kara means black in the Azerbaijani/Turkish language, Bag(bakh) means garden in the Azerbaijani/Turkish language. Karabakh means black garden while it has no meaning in Armenian. “Karabakh Khanate” was established in 1747 by Panahali Khan and today’s Zangazur (Armenians call it Syunik”) was part of Karabakh Khanate. In 1805 Russia invaded Karabakh Khanate under general commander Sisianov’s initiative. In 1828 treaty of Turkmenchay was signed between Iran and Russia as their war ended and Russia claimed Karabakh as its vassal state. Russia also moved 140,000 Armenians to the South Caucasus (mainly Karabakh) from Iran and Turkey between 1828 and 1830. That was the first time Armenians stepped on the South Caucasus. Azerbaijani Turks officially lived on these lands since the 11th century as Oghuz Seljugs. If you do slight research about who are descendants of Oghuz Turks you’ll find out 3: Turkey, Azerbaijan, Turkmenistan.
Correct me if I am wrong, but wasn't there an "illegal separatist movement" in Kosovo a few decades ago? Whose side did NATO and the UN support then?
we all know that NATO is a bunch of hypocrites
Nigar you are the best!!!
Well done
Very very hot topic may god bring peace to people’s hearts.
The moderators did a decent job of making sure both sides got to Express their opinions and give facts about what's happening on the ground. This is very important having two people from different sides of the war speak to each other and have a debate... i know emotions get high but it would be for the best if the moderators could mute one sides Microphone while the other side is talking... give each side 5-10mins to express their views and opinions. Let one talk and then mute them and let the other talk. It gets counterproductive when both sides just yell over each other
Serbia should take notice and go into Kosovo and arrest the separatists once for all.
yes if you have balls ,just 4 days a go your Serbian terrorist try to take over north Kosovo but Kosovo forces kill them ,,the Serb terrorist run a way like doges u can see in RUclips ,,,,and Kosovo is Independent country with huge sport from USA and western,s
Yes time to retake their internationally recognised province of Kosovo and same goes for Cyprus also to flush out illegal Turks from Cyprus.
It’s not like before though. Kosovons are better off now and they would fight to their death unlike before. The world is different my friend . European hegemony is in its dying stages .
@@Adm9464 All if data points to the area of Kosovo has mmuch less young people abd way more older people. If i was alvanian looking to build or invest i would do that in albania
American expert confirmed with his statements that Azerbaijan was right and Armenia was wrong.
he is not expert he was x consula
That's not true, I'm a US. Citizen 🇺🇸 That's false information US never condemned Armenia
@@albanyildiz3076 It does not mean Jack s***, he's lying.
i know usa Armenia does not mean nothings longest Turkey there armenia not mean nothings @@johnplumber898
My heart goes out to both nations… may you find peace in your hearts and move on. Hate is never the answer.
Now that the armenias went back home, we can talk about peace.
blockading a over 100 thousand people from receiving food, medical, and other life necessities for nine months is also not the answer, but that's what Azerbaijan did.
@@HupeGarrett they learned it from Israel.
Azerbaijan is invading and the Armenians are on the oppressed side, stop with the "both sides" bs
Have you heard about the 1st ge
nocied of the arminisnz to thake there Holland? Since 1909, 1915, 1918 .1988 .2023. This genocide against the arminyans at still continues! They won't pan turkic empire buy killing arminyans !
In May 2010, the White House appointed Bryza as the United States Ambassador to Azerbaijan.His nomination ultimately was never confirmed by the full Senate, however, and after serving as Ambassador for less than a year, Bryza left the State Department and joined the Azerbaijani-government affiliated Turcas petrol board
Is his wife azerbaïdjanais???😂😂😂
We should pick into his bank account
Besides if he's talking from Istanbul, he cannot say anything against Azerbaijan.
Thank you for the information, now I understand why he supports Azerbaijan, he is an azeri.
I mean more then 10m germans were forced to live after ww2.
It's not hard to see where Matthew Bryza's blatant bias in favor of Azerbaijan comes from:
1) In May 2010, the White House appointed Bryza as the United States Ambassador to Azerbaijan. His nomination ultimately was never confirmed by the full Senate, however, and after serving as Ambassador for less than a year, Bryza left the State Department and joined the Azerbaijani-government affiliated Turcas petrol board.
2) Conflict of interest concerns including reports were raised that the then Azerbaijani Foreign Minister served as 1 of 3 groomsmen in Bryza's wedding.
3) Reporters Without Borders raised concerns about the persecution of Azerbaijani reporters who reported that an Azerbaijani government minister partially paid for Bryza's wedding. According to an article by Ganimat Zahid and Agil Khalil in the Azerbaijani newspaper Azadliq, the then Minister of Economic Development of Azerbaijan, Heydar Babayev, paid for a significant portion of Bryza’s wedding in Istanbul, Turkey.
*_Do you believe in this nonsense yourself? He tells the truth and it hurts your eyes to the Armenians!_*
Always FOLLOW THE MONEY trail to see the bias
Allahu akbar my brothers azerbajan
I wonder if those displaced Armenians had sympathized with the 700,000 Azeris who had to flee Nagorno-Karabakh and surrounding districts as a result of their victory in the first war in the 1990s. So many people pouring out heartfelt emotions in their direction today, completely oblivious or willfully forgetting that they were guilty of doing the same to their neighbors three decades ago. Some of those old men in the video clip were personally responsible for doing it to the Azeris and they went home to those now old women who celebrated and congratulated them for killing and displacing others for being different. Now, they suffer the same fate in their lifetime when they are incapable of effectively fighting back. Karma is exactly who they say she is.
You got to deal with the ones with power and that’s Azerbaijan. Abide by the Azerbaijan constitution and integrate fairly . All will be well. This is difficult though when the Armenians killed thousands and displaced almost a million Azeris from their lands in Karabakh three decades ago. What goes around comes around.
Armenians felt guilty for their crimes and left ,
Armenians are always crying that everyone wants to do ethnic cleansing. Their diaspora in Southern California is racist towards everyone not Armenian, they treat people like dirt and are the main recipients of social services that supposed to be distributed among everyone. They don't respect Blacks or Whites or Hispanics or anyone and that cultural behavior is among the reasons why people around does not want them around nor want to help them. Armenians need to be more respectful and learn they are no better than anyone, maybe then the rest of world will have some sympathy afterwards, right now your cultural behavior outcasts you from the any help.
@@najeebahmed9591 friend, you are trying to rewrite history. That area plus a whole lot more was always ARMENIAN, not Turkey aka Azerbaijan. Go find an old map and look it up.
With the attitude of abide by Azerbaijan constitution and integrate fairly..then you follow it with this will be difficult reveals the actual truth. You cannot not forgive even if they abide! Powers will make sure they do not abide so they can say, see we tried. Bah
@@marieheenan6817 dear this is not the only case . It happens everywhere. This is the product of colonialism and displacement of people and creating borders. My family hails from Africa although born in the USA. This stuff is happening not only in regions and towns but small villages. It’s difficult to understand and deal with.
Im so happy finally we got our land back from the Armenian occupation legally its ours
What are you going to do with the hundreds of Armenian monasteries and churches in Karabakh, built starting from 4th to the18th century? you could either change your religion and go visit and pray there or destroy them like you did in Nahcevan.
@@sezaavakian9901 same thing we did with christ church in Jerusalem when we got the 🗝️ to it 1400 years ago we protect it and pass down the heritage to our childrens the Armenians chose to leave they showed no love no attachment to karabah look at the Palestinians you can learn a lesson in patriotism
As an uzbek i support Azerbaijan❤
If there are old armenian churches in those lands, is because armenians were there before, am I right?
All churches before 19 century are not Armenians. First Armenians settled in Azerbaijan in 19 century by Russia and they armenased old Caucasian Albanian (predecessor of Azerbaijan) churches.
@@gm63534 that is what you learned at school. Try to judge that. It is historic revisionism.
@@gm63534 azerbaijan trying to modify history
Caucasian Albania ( not connected with present Albania) became Christian state in 2, early 3rd century and been until Arabs invasion in 7th century. Even then that churche survived until Armenians arrived in 19th century.
@@gm63534 and why did "caucasian albanians" write in armenian alphabet in those churches? There are armenian scriptions on their walls and now the armenian heritage in those lands is under risk. Just like the cemeteries in Najichevan land.
War must end... nobody is the winner at this time.move foward....armenia must focus on economic and wellfare of his people.
agree, so the people from Nagorno karabakh should fck off
🙏🇺🇸
For those viewers who are surprised by mr. Mathews's position on karabakh/ Armenia /Azerbaijan
He is the board member of several private companies in Turkey.
Well said. 😆
I was not just surprised, I was shocked. I’ve never known in America to be so heartless and malignant.
@@TenTenJ you are absolutely right. I have been living in the state for 50 years and never came across an American like this low life.
No wonder
Fair point
He is smart and fair
Fair is fair
30 years ago one million people were displaced
Now they must RETURN 28:15
Fantastic panel. I learned a lot. Here's to peace! ❤
Why did you bring two turks (at least 2 of them defending azeris' interests) against one Armenian???
Facts are facts
Don't forget 1 millions were humiliated and were destroyed 30 years ago
They must go back
Fair is fair
The Azerbaijani lands occupied 30 years ago were taken from the hands of the enemy, this is difficult for some to understand,Who will pay for the damage they have caused to the Azerbaijani state and people in the lands they have occupied for 30 years?
May Allah bless all Azerbaijan brothers.
If they have concerns fir their safety and want to leave… then leave… simple 😊
You are right 👍👍👍
Commenting things like while people like you deny ethnic cleansing and call everyone else a liar.
Karma is a bitch.I pray you find yourself in a similar situation so you'll understand how it feels to live under dictatorship (Azerbejian's President & his father ruling that country for 50 Years)@@zubirsaid8491
You make the victims, don’t blame the victim. Your tribes have been at it for years, centuries.
Khankendi ( Khans Village }
Брайза красавчик, Нигяр, моё почтение 🇦🇿🇹🇷🇺🇳🇵🇰🇮🇱🇺🇸✌
Don't put our flag with Cannibals.💪🇺🇸💪 (👹=🇹🇷.🇦🇿).
Zionist
They shoved allot of money down that former U.S. ambassadors gullet
his wife is Turkish
Karabagh is part of Azerbaijan as international community recognized
Excellent reporting!
" When you pray for rain, be ready to walk through puddles. "
When will Kashmir issue be resolved for good? Generations died waiting but still both India and Pakistan fighting for it
No final peace until kashmir is resolved completely permantly
Thank you for the news being the forth column. May all find peace.
Congratulations to Azerbaijan for marvelous victory! Love from Pakistan!
Thanks, we love Pakistan
This was not balanced interview, you have Matthew byrza works for azeris and turks. Hes involved with many turk and azeris organizations
*_Do you believe in this nonsense yourself? He tells the truth and it hurts your eyes to the Armenians!_*
Azerbaijan must arrange the safe return of the fled Armenians. Of course, I sympathize with those we were badly treated in the hands of Armenians in the Armenian invasion of 1989. This cycle of conquering and fleeing has to be broken and the onus is now on the Azeries.
Peace and love to both the nations!
Azerbaijanis are very welcoming and tolerant. I have seen many people from various ethnic backgrounds and religions living there peacefully
No
Armenians see new videos monthly of azeris doing beheadings, destroying churches, bombing civilians.... but ok.
Oh yes, as long as they are submissive and obedient, no rights, no say .
@@hertersarelshould they start rioting to run sepeaatism?
It is a propaganda myth. 95% of population of Azerbaijan is Azeris
The Armenian panelist said that there is so called 'Armenophobia' in the Azerbaijani society, but there is also extreme 'Azeriphobia' in Armenian society and all over the Armenian diaspora.
@@animambreyan2764same type of videos are hundreds from Armenia. Conflict started from ethnic cleansing of Azerbaijanies from territory of Current Armenia. So who started nationalist actions?
@@animambreyan2764girl please. All our textbooks are available online. You’re free to investigate.
The Nagorno-Karabakh conflict is the longest-running in post-Soviet Eurasia. In 1988, ethnic Armenians living in Nagorno-Karabakh demanded the transfer of what was then the Nagorno-Karabakh Autonomous Oblast (NKAO) from Soviet Azerbaijan to Armenia. As the Soviet Union collapsed, tensions grew into an outright war.
When Russia defeats Ukraine then they will help Aremenia retake lands stolen by Azerbaijan. Russia will also help Serbia take back Kosovo. Christian Orthodox religion will rise again in the region thanks to Russia. Russian empire will return.
@@remogatron1010 HELP ARMENIA RETAKE LAND STOLEN BY AZERBAIJAN?
which land kid?
imagine.... you need to learn kid....
not just dream....
armenian did first colonization like what western did on past....
and do genocide on ethnic azerbaijan
and when azeri LIBERATE their OWN LAND
you felt sad?
WHAT A BRAINLESS IDIOT
I hope so
@@remogatron1010Russia will not help Armenia reclaim Nagorno-Karabak because the Pashinyian government has been antagonistic towards Russia, hosted NATO exercises and let's not forget that aside from constantly saying that Armenia should accept that Nagorno-Karabak is Azerbaijan, he also refused to send Armenian military in 2020 and this time to defend Armenians. I mean, why would anyone sacrifice themselves in a fight when the person involved will not fight themselves? Besides, Russia has better relations now with Aliyev than with Pashinyian.
@@jesusaguilar4585
Armenia is a member of the Collective Security Treaty Organization (CSTO), a Russia-dominated alliance of post-Soviet states that pledge to protect each other in the event of an attack.
Why is Armenia mad? Because Russia for years and years have done nothing to stop or solve the issue. That forced Armenia to be upset. Russia caused it.
And a treaty is a treaty no matter if Putin feelings is hurt. Russia under the treaty has to follow it. NATO does so and Russia is a liar.
Trust me here. Russia will pay for this treason. Russia forced Armenia to be upset at them. That training with NATO troops is the result of Russia not honoring their part of the treaty and Armenia showing their displeasure. Back stabbed!
Excellent coverage!!
Excellent show of knowledge and capabilities asserted by Nigar in the dialog with the opponents
Cigar was aggressive and unyielding to hear others point of views. A always whitewashing facts and inserting bias.
The future is bright and just for Karabakh without the occupiers!🎉
Karabakh was not a disputed territory, Armenians were moved there and Azerbaijanis were expelled and occupied 33 years ago.
Thank you for unbiased covering, Al Jazeera.
Khankendi ( Khans Village }
So people are leaving because their own leaders told them to go. Those who chose to go, were free to leave. And there is an official offer to stay by those who regained control.
The words "ethnic cleansing" have a very different meaning than this and should not be used lightly.
fact is, That Armenia as a country has existed for at least 3000 years and Azarbayejan 200 years! If there is a land that land would belong to Iran or Armenia
You always say Armenians have been there for thousands of years. Who were there before you? History of humanity didnt start with you. It goes well beyond past. So who were the people living there before you? Why did you take their lands from them? Will you leave those lands when their children say they dont want you there? So stop these idiot claims , it is so nonsense
Correct. At school they teach them upside down history that Iran and Armenia belonged to them.
OSCE established its Minsk Group with co chaired by US, France and Russia for Karakabh conflict. This Minsk Group 30 years involved in Karabakh conflict. Metyu Bryza was one of the co chair from US side. He was involved to tne conflict and he did not learn the Karabakh from the media that controlled by Armenian lobby, he was the one who involved to solve the problem from US side. However Armenian people does not mention about his career as a co chair. They focused only his career as an ambassador and living in Turkiye.
I wish one day we could have peace in our wonderful region!
Hello, Georgia!
Almost every nation always there’s something wrong with border lines, Kazakhstan 🇰🇿 Armenian descent why they’re running away from their homeland,
Brainstorm by puppet fake government
They're running so they don't get beheaded.
Because it is not their homeland
@geoffreybslater1146 When there were Armenians there, your race didn't even exist, do you know even what? Race you belong to. How old history do you have? Don't tell me the fake one, the real one.
they are afraid of reprisal, being subjected to the same treatment they applied to Azeris..
Overall a good show but a touch repetitive.
Nigar was a bit aggressive but still clear in her stance & represented AZB very well. She has the right answers for each question on the topic of Karraback.
Mathew is a versatile ex diplomat and knows this topic well. His stance on the topic is however obvious & repetitive. He could therefore be replaced by another panelist
Arsen was the sole defender of Armenian cause in the discussion and was therefore on a weaker ground. He repeated the usual unsubsantiated accusations while remaining calm & respectful. But he also made some pertinent remarks on the future course of the conflict.
What will the Armenians do if they leave on their own? If they want to stay in Nagorno-Karabakh, they have to accept the sovereignty of Azerbaijan according to the laws of that country. This is regular in all the independent countries of the world. For example, Red Indians have to obey American laws in America. This is the case in all countries of the modern world.
miazbdvoic6892 ...your comparison is flawed and incorrect. The First Nation People you call red Indians have their own laws and police in their territories. When off of their lands they follow U.S. laws.
@@marieheenan6817 Know first and then tell. Because the entire continent of America belonged to them or the regional tribes of that region. There is no use in talking about five hundred years ago. Everyone has accepted the current reality. The solution is only one, everyone will leave the next land or live in the country and follow the independence of the country. thank you
Plz raise ur voice against the percecution and injustice being done on the innocent Muslim Minority in India.
why?
Inwish one day Armenia will have some adequate politicians who knows the sutuation and we can sit and discuss cases in the serious level. Not some rumors
I wish one day azerbaijan will cease to exist as a fckn dictatorship that whats to rule over other nations
Well done Azerbaijan; you got back your country.
Moderator .👍😊👍
6:52 what was wrong with the living conditions before the inpostition of a 9 month blockhade?
5:06 "azerbijani army was extremally cautious targeting only ... civilians ... "
Military civilians*
the american is a mongol? may be a sultan 's speaker
The lady is a liar!
That lady is gorgeous. I would give up all Armenia for her beauty
Rusia never told Azerbeijan do not push it. Rusia supplied all sort of weaponary to Azerbeijan.
Stop Azerbaijan, stop ethnic cleansing of Armenians!
Well done Azerbaijan..
peace love and unity for All
He wasn’t given fair time to speak. It was not fair. But God knows the truth whoever is wrong and right. We will all give account before God. God’s word says to repent and Trust in Jesus Christ the only Savior of the world. This world is temporary. Even if you get all the land.The next one is eternal. Lord Jesus we look to you for deliverance, forgiveness and You are our only hope. God have mercy on Armenians, Azerbaijanis and the whole region. Amen.
Great job Arsen jan
Great program!
Actually it was a badly managed interview.
how?@@ArmenianBishop
@@kimkardashiansdaddy2744 because it made the Armenian crocodile tears dry up
It is the right of Azerbaijani to have the land
They just had a war a week ago how do you expect them to just come back. The third Karabakh war of September 19-21 ended not that long ago
Always support azarbaijan from Bangladesh
Karabax iz Azerbaycan❤
Why Azerbaijan is using Latin letters, as well as Turks .Azerbaijan is a province of Iran and supposedly they should use Farci .
Even Armenians didnt deny it latley they said sure but give these people somekind of rights. And azerbaijan was like no they will be oppressed like any other person😂
@@glenipolus9731Azerbaijan said , don't tell us what to do with our own people , go f urself and think about ypur own wellfare , OUR PEOPLE , OUR LAND , OUR GOVERNMENT!😂🇦🇿🤘🏼
@@HelenArghoutianwhy State of Armenia had not recognized proxy “Artsakh” as an independent state for 30 years? And still doesn’t…
@@messyhessy6318 because at the moment when Armenia will announce recognition the people of Artsakh would be killed and murdered, it’s obvious
1st try 1987 -88 déclaration of independence of NKAO from Azerbaijan SSR was announced and we got thousands of killed , refuges Sumgait, Bakou Genocide
2nd try it was just said Artsakh is Armenia without any official paperwork Azerbaijan invaded Armenia we had thousands killed
3D try is happening at the same moment when Armenian population reunites with mother Armenia 🇦🇲
This is Matteo, his wife is Turkish and he is biased towards Azerbaijan
I would like to hear Matnew if he lived with his family in the Karabah and not in Turkey.
We need more of you Ms Negar. You are definitely a smart woman.
😂😂😂yes you need more "brainwashers", it's never enough for you, no limit of being delusional 🐏🐏🐑
Ms Niger is lacking basic culture of dialogue, she is interrupting her conversation partner, so rude. She is so hateful , a real fascist.
No txs, plastic women 👎
In 1993, amidst the active military hostilities, the UN Security Council adopted four resolutions concerning Azerbaijani-Karabakh conflict: 822 (April 30, 1993), 853 (June 29, 1993), 874 (October 14, 1993), 884 (November 12, 1993).
It's about boarders .What about human rights
How long turks will watch 33 years enough kick all armenians to poor armenia @@annkar1917
You can see it from the exchange of accusations/or messages(whatever you call it) how much these two nations love each other 😢
I think they love each other, but they don't know yet.
@@peterszabo3897 😆
They never like each other
speak for Ar
@@WalterThompson-rt7jm You know enemy of enemies are friends. It can change any time, when little Martians invade Earth. 😁
Mathew, you are a legend
Please stop bringing Matthew on this show. He is clearly on one side. The Azeri’s verbal aggression and emotional responses is very telling. Can’t even wait her turn to talk 🤦🏻♂️
*_Do you believe in this nonsense yourself? He tells the truth and it hurts your eyes to the Armenians!_*
This woman is unbearable...
Nothing to fear to live together side by side that is my opinion
Ermenilerin çoğu kin ve nefretle dolu. Basitçe ; Ermenistanda 1 tane bile Türk yaşayamaz. Hatta müslüman bile yok ülkede . Ermeniler için en iyi çözüm kendi bölgelerinde yaşamaları.
Hahaha
There is every reason to have fear. You are delusional
5:05 "only targeting military civilians"
So 5 and 10 year olds kids are military when they're being burned and killed.
Nagorno Karabakh is being reintergrated by Ethnic Cleansing!!! Nagorno Karabakh Never should have been Forced by the Soviet Union to be part of Azerbaijan... And if you wanted the Armenians to stay you wouldn't have Attacked Them!!!
As a Turk of Kurdish origin, I would like to say that Armenia is completely guilty. In the past, they committed genocide against civilians and occupied Azerbaijan's lands. Now they should get out of the lands they occupied.
She seems very aggressive preaching peace ✌️
There is literaly no way to spin this where Armenia was the victim here. My heart also goes out to all those families who fled and are now displaced, but by every metric, this is on Armenia, not Azerbaijan. Karabakh is entirely contained within Azerbaijan, and Armenia was insistent on keeping an armed separatist movement there. Everything that has happened for the last 30+ years has been a result of not being willing to accept reality. The irony is that they might have had a shot at creating an autonomous region under the authority of Baku at the beginning, but at this point, the current situation is probably the "most ideal outcome".
That this finally ended is a good thing for both sides, Armenia and Azerbaijan. For once, there is a real shot at a peace deal not skewered by this region standing like an elephant in the middle of the room. I know it is painful for Armenia right now, but if they can work with the Azeris to put this behind them and broker a deal that respects both nation's borders and sovereignty, both sides might come out of this in a far better position.
Until then, despite my distate for autocratic governments, I continue to believe that Azerbaijan was in the right here. I only hope they keep their word about treating the population there with dignity and respecting them as they would any other citizen so it doesn't continue to devolve. That region needs peace, healing, and reconciliation - not more violence, war, or hate. They also need to stop asking Europe, Russia, or the US to broker deals and start working with the regional powers. Iran and Armenia across the table from Turkey and Azerbaijan meeting in as neutral a place as they can find.
As a side note, they will cease to be in the right if they cross the border into Armenia and attempt to annex land for their bridge to the west. At that point, they will be the aggressors, so hopefully a peace deal comes before that happens.
Thanks for the truth Matthew. Good job.
What truth? How do you know that is the truth?
Because he said so?
What’s his credibility?
@@varujanavedyan168Because he briefly told the reason why Armenians are afraid of living in Karabakh. He mentioned the Khojaly genocide, mass killing of 613 Azerbaijani civilians including 106 women and 63 children by Armenian forces. Armenians do remember what they've done. Armenians killed people, they occupied homes. So they are fleeing.
Bravo Negar , you made my day by telling the truth. Yashasin Azerbijan.
Very entertaining.
Nigar you are amazing 👏👏👏👏
She is a parrot 🦜
Nigar loves Armenian 🍆🍆🍆
@@terminatorninja6746 you are a chicken 🐔
Excellent
Why didn’t Armenia organize hot meals and distribution of sandwiches, tea, coffee, milk or cocoa for Armenian repatriates at the border on its territory? After all, Armenia has been screaming for several months about “hunger” and “fainting from hunger,”
even “deaths” in the separatist stub. Any state showing genuine concern, first of all, immediately at the border, would organize food for people if these people were really starving. Is not it? But Armenia does not even give water to the Armenian repatriates (they all have Armenian passports). An interesting, phenomenal and very Armenian, in its deceitful essence, situation :-) Why not ask these questions to European liberals, journalists and human rights activists? And Russian anti-Putinists and pro-Ukrainian democrats who shed burning tears for the Armenian separatists must...
This American is making his living in Turkey! Dare he say anything else
İt goes both ways. i can say the same for Americans who are living along side with Armenians.
@@huk711 There is nobody speaking for Armenia!
@@stephen2975nope, very sad indeed!
One wrong move his pay is cut. He calls himself a mediator 😂
After 30 years coming back azarbaijan ❤🏡🏡🏡❤🏡🌺🥀🌹🌻🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿✌️✌️✌️✌️
NiGar is great in arguments