‘Huge blackspots’ in knowledge of Northern Ireland’s history, says Derry Girls actress

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 1 фев 2025

Комментарии • 140

  • @DaneTygheletsdrive
    @DaneTygheletsdrive 3 года назад +27

    Doesn't say much for the British education system, their wilful ignorance in relation to the absolute horrors of their colonial past is truly sickening. But hey let's wave a union flag instead.

    • @pecadodeorgullo5963
      @pecadodeorgullo5963 3 года назад

      The same way every nation hides the horrors or embarrassments of their past?

    • @Imsuper656
      @Imsuper656 3 года назад

      Are you feeling a bit of 'White guilt'?

  • @homobohemicus
    @homobohemicus 3 года назад +28

    She was and IS brilliant.. I was glued to the Derry Girls the second I saw the first episode. The entire cast is amazing & its sad to see that ignorance of ones history and lack of knowledge about your closest neighbour is eviddntly a big factor in the UKs brushing aside the NI issue.. As she perfectly said, lets replace flags and Churchillian quotes with basic education

  • @OlanKenny
    @OlanKenny 3 года назад +36

    I was born in The Republic, grew up in England, now live in Wales. Growing up with the English education system that glorifies everything about Britain's past, from Hadrian's Wall to Henry VIII to Churchill's grand speeches. The only lesson that involved Ireland's history was half an hour on Cromwell's invasion. Most of my classmates, aged around 14, had no idea Ireland was a separate country. Indeed I think many of them still have no idea. I've had family members who've gone to Ireland and been surprised that they use a different currency. The Great British Public have an astounding level of ignorance about the world around them.

    • @goblinwisdom
      @goblinwisdom 3 года назад +7

      Learn about tudors and guy fawkes. I think that teaching about NI history as a part of the uk isn't allowed due to ' sensitivities ' but even then the secondary school history I remember is that my teacher skated over the potato famine and just said 'and they voted to become a republic'.

    • @kieransavage3835
      @kieransavage3835 3 года назад

      Living in their glorious past….The sun never sets on the British Empire,….unfortunately.

    • @pecadodeorgullo5963
      @pecadodeorgullo5963 3 года назад

      @@kieransavage3835 What's wrong with that? Teaching of one's history is important so it's not a bad thing but I do believe teaching of their neighbours past would be useful as well.

    • @goblinwisdom
      @goblinwisdom 3 года назад +3

      @@pecadodeorgullo5963 Ireland's history used to be part of UK history southern Ireland became independent in 1922

    • @pecadodeorgullo5963
      @pecadodeorgullo5963 3 года назад

      @@goblinwisdom when j mentioned northern irish history, I'm referring to the history after partition since that is our own history while the rest is shared.

  • @Areflection4
    @Areflection4 3 года назад +18

    Love this brilliant woman for her work. 💚

  • @AndréVilaFranca
    @AndréVilaFranca 3 года назад +9

    I love DERRY GIRLS for all it tries to do and they shine at it. I hope we get plenty more seasons.

  • @Captain.Pugwash
    @Captain.Pugwash 3 года назад +9

    The countryside looks gorgeous

  • @theresenydahl9531
    @theresenydahl9531 3 года назад +25

    Brilliant actress, love her!❤

    • @gweilo965
      @gweilo965 3 года назад +1

      I wouldn't like to feed it

    • @norfolkenchants1238
      @norfolkenchants1238 3 года назад +1

      @@gweilo965 you know you can get hair transplants nowadays you should consider it, it's disgusting having to look at bald people in the modern world

  • @Chocolatetart88
    @Chocolatetart88 2 года назад +4

    Adore this woman ❤️

  • @michaelhalsall5684
    @michaelhalsall5684 2 года назад +3

    As an Australian I've recently "discovered" Irish history, partially thanks to watching "Derry Girls"! In Australia our media is very "London-centric" when it comes to anything to anything to do with Great Britain, consequently a lot of Australians are woefully ignorant about modern Ireland. I know of an Australian Catholic man who wouldn't travel to Belfast as tourist recently because he was worried that the Protestants would "get him". Very sad!

  • @obscuracamaria2931
    @obscuracamaria2931 3 года назад +6

    What a queen

    • @melissamieko7585
      @melissamieko7585 2 года назад +1

      Right! She reminds me of a literal QUEEN ❤

  • @brianmmacu
    @brianmmacu 3 года назад +16

    Ireland is one land. The sooner the mindless idiocy of partition and all the madness it has created the better. Talking about the place like they are two very different places is beyond ridiculous.

    • @Martial-Mat
      @Martial-Mat 3 года назад +2

      I don't know - all borders are artificial in one sense, but very real in another. Are you suggesting that the people in rural southern Ireland have much in common culturally with the people living in the northern cities that have fought for decades?

    • @robertwallace1166
      @robertwallace1166 3 года назад +5

      It cost us (The British) as much to police the whole of northern island and it does London. Happy for you lot to have it back, you guys can deal with it for a while.

    • @brianmmacu
      @brianmmacu 3 года назад +5

      @@Martial-Mat It’s an island with a shared history , for some of a few hundred years, for others , thousands of years. A hundred years of imposed partition is nothing.
      People have an ignorance of history, which is
      the height of irony in Ireland.

    • @gweilo965
      @gweilo965 3 года назад +2

      Suppose we could just take the south as well🤷‍♂️

    • @redchristy
      @redchristy 3 года назад +1

      But they are two very different places. The south.. They have had it 100 years and ran it into the ground, the schools are an absolute joke. They fought hard for it and handed it over to the EU.. Wtf!! I'm irish, my kids are irish, my parents and grandparents and generations are irish, but guess what.. The roi is not irish anymore... Its a pity the Brits didn't stay

  • @toyotaprius79
    @toyotaprius79 3 года назад +6

    Kinda hitting the same chords with the 1619 project or "critical race theory" in the States regarding the necessity of history and its truthful education.

    • @toyotaprius79
      @toyotaprius79 3 года назад +2

      @@lynchthis1 So, Plastic Paddy.
      Would you accept an official historical narrative of the Great Famine that the British government tried its best to help the Irish, but the Irish were too helpless to cook with corn flour and stop overpopulating? That the protection of the integrity of free market in England by exporting commodity foods like beef, potatoes and carrots from Ireland during the famine were of no consequence?

    • @beaglaoich4418
      @beaglaoich4418 3 года назад

      @@lynchthis1a poorly executed attempt to update US syllabus is still an attempt while speaking to British friends they don’t actually even have that in the UK.
      I’ve seen teachers and historians criticise 1619 consistently as clumsy somewhat backwards and poorly done history but in general they accept the need to increase the voices of minorities etc within the US story.
      Though compared to the 1776 they said at least those 1619 journalists were attempting history they described 1776 as borderline fantasy drivel that was completely incoherent

  • @chbry1050
    @chbry1050 3 года назад +1

    The miss understanding comes lack of exposure which 8s common in the UK in general.

  • @lynnallen1315
    @lynnallen1315 2 года назад +1

    She's the best part of the show!

  • @pongop
    @pongop 2 года назад +1

    Amazing interview! Derry Girls is awesome and Siobhán McSweeney is amazing! Speaking truth to power. Fat is beautiful! Lose hate not weight! Decolonize now!

  • @strangerrrrrrr
    @strangerrrrrrr Год назад +1

    she's so hilarious...

  • @dmfaisal
    @dmfaisal 3 года назад +4

    Picturesque landscapes….

  • @andrewvadachellum5560
    @andrewvadachellum5560 2 года назад

    Hi

  • @Xanzia1972
    @Xanzia1972 Год назад

    Not due to size, but due to having no fashion sense and preferring the appearance of an alien's baby.

  • @rohypnotist6263
    @rohypnotist6263 3 года назад +5

    When people try to convince you that they are really funny ...

  • @johnbull487
    @johnbull487 3 года назад +5

    Channel 4 promotes identity politics whilst simultaneously trying to smash stereotypes?

    • @beaglaoich4418
      @beaglaoich4418 3 года назад +1

      Laughable that someone including a picture of their national identity is complaining about identity politics

  • @Keithlfpieterse
    @Keithlfpieterse 3 года назад +4

    Size matters! I am sick and tired of jobless actors presenting information. They ACT! What happened to the trained and respected academics?

    • @RankinMsP
      @RankinMsP 3 года назад +1

      People don't know or care for them because - as educated as they may be - they may lack a certain panache or spark in presenting. No one wants to 'watch' a dull lecture.

    • @Keithlfpieterse
      @Keithlfpieterse 3 года назад

      @@RankinMsP : When knowledgeable people who also passionate about their subject material present their work they outclass all the actors in the world. I save my respect and enthusiasm for them. Have a GOOD day and thanks for your response!

  • @Martial-Mat
    @Martial-Mat 3 года назад +7

    I wonder how good her knowledge of Wales or Scotland is? And I'm sorry, but people find very obese people distasteful to watch. Rather than blaming the system, blame your inability to say no to food.

    • @gweilo965
      @gweilo965 3 года назад +4

      Self-discipline is very underrated

    • @Martial-Mat
      @Martial-Mat 3 года назад +1

      @@lynchthis1 No, not at all. There were multiple issues raised, but throughout, she was complaining how unfair it is that obese women don't get the big roles. I actually thought that her whining detracted from an otherwise rather good video.

    • @Martial-Mat
      @Martial-Mat 3 года назад

      @UC6nygsntwix-uDorRmjIeUw I very much agree.

    • @mikeryan807
      @mikeryan807 3 года назад

      @@Martial-Mat Oh but obese women do get the 'big' roles... boom boom.

    • @Martial-Mat
      @Martial-Mat 3 года назад +1

      @@mikeryan807 Don't give up your day job! :D

  • @petercarroll9167
    @petercarroll9167 3 года назад +3

    "People not realising that the Republic of Ireland was not part of the UK" - Whilst that is correct, all of Ireland was part of the UK for longer than the Republic has existed as a Sovereign Nation. So you can sort of understand where the confusion comes from.
    Still, looks like an interesting program, hopefully a more balanced view of Northern Ireland for a GB audience for a change.

    • @garethsloan5118
      @garethsloan5118 3 года назад +14

      Republic has existed for about a century to be fair, how much time is needed?

    • @maryfelton7733
      @maryfelton7733 3 года назад +7

      Ireland became part of the UK in 1801 after the Act of Union and gained independance in 1922 - a small period of time given the extensive history of the island….

    • @maryfelton7733
      @maryfelton7733 3 года назад +3

      PS. Can people still be confused 100 years after sovereignty was obtained? Do they still think George V is king??…

    • @patfeeney1098
      @patfeeney1098 3 года назад +4

      The Irish State is older than essentially every human in Britain, for a piece of information that takes five seconds to explain, you'd think 100 years is enough.

    • @clancywiggam
      @clancywiggam 3 года назад

      @@patfeeney1098 Very well put.

  • @boruttrost5750
    @boruttrost5750 3 года назад +6

    The thumbnail says "overlooked." How can you overlook someone so big?

    • @casteretpollux
      @casteretpollux 3 года назад +4

      Big talent, intellect, heart? Not you - her.

    • @RankinMsP
      @RankinMsP 3 года назад +1

      Petty...and stupid.
      Must have sounded funny in your head and to the morons liking your inane comment.

    • @norfolkenchants1238
      @norfolkenchants1238 3 года назад

      Atleast she's achieved her dreams and will be remembered for somthing unlike yourself who's sitting at home commenting on someone's size to make themseleves seem relevant in life.

  • @belkentens
    @belkentens 3 года назад +3

    Yes...
    It must be very difficult for her
    Having greenpeace throw buckets of water over you and try to roll you in the sea would be upsetting

  • @gvi341984
    @gvi341984 3 года назад +6

    So obesity is ok? Anglos are odd

    • @RR-kp5ps
      @RR-kp5ps 3 года назад +9

      She's not Anglo, she's Celtic.

    • @gvi341984
      @gvi341984 3 года назад

      @@RR-kp5ps Shes as Celtic as Americans so that makes her anglo.

    • @gavindoyle692
      @gavindoyle692 3 года назад +7

      Anglo? She’s Irish for Christ’s sake. The Anglo-Saxons settled the neighbouring island - Anglia - Angleland - England.
      She is from Cork and a Celt (with maybe some Norse thrown in). Us Irish may now be English-speakers, but we are definitely not “Anglos”.

    • @gvi341984
      @gvi341984 3 года назад +1

      @@gavindoyle692 Celt? For non anglos the modern celts are just anglos pretending to be something long gone

    • @dontworryimnotastalker5486
      @dontworryimnotastalker5486 3 года назад +2

      From what I can see she’s not obese. Also overweight and obese are medical terms so stop diagnosing people like you know anything about their situation or medical history, you don’t. Being overweight does put you at higher risk of certain conditions, that is true but you can still be healthy while being overweight but I don’t think you actually care about tackling obesity and the related issues to it, people like you enjoy the feeling of superiority you get from shaming other people for their bodies so idk reevaluate and educate yourself before talking about obesity.

  • @wanderer4568
    @wanderer4568 2 года назад

    I'm Irish and she needs to shut up about all this BS just act

  • @gweilo965
    @gweilo965 3 года назад +4

    Perhaps some self-discipline is in order?
    You can't just eat and eat and eat and expect nothing bad to happen

    • @neilmooo
      @neilmooo 3 года назад +1

      You can just eat eat and eat , if you want. And you can, not care what happens.

    • @gweilo965
      @gweilo965 3 года назад

      @@neilmooo I suppose you can but you would be a drain on society. No one wants that.

    • @norfolkenchants1238
      @norfolkenchants1238 3 года назад +3

      @@gweilo965 "a drain on society" bit ironic coming from someone who spends time judging others on their weight, she's a successful actress who's living her dream, whilst your contribution to "society" is to comment on videos about peoples weight to seem relevant in this world 😂

    • @Captain.Pugwash
      @Captain.Pugwash 3 года назад +1

      Well now that would be to take responsibility for yourself. And that just wont do.

  • @TommyBahama84
    @TommyBahama84 3 года назад +1

    Oh look, another Irish person telling us our history is bad. Pretty rich coming from the Irish.

    • @theghostintheruins
      @theghostintheruins 3 года назад +19

      The truth hurts I suppose

    • @porcupineinapettingzoo
      @porcupineinapettingzoo 3 года назад +11

      Explain why it's rich coming from the Irish.

    • @toyotaprius79
      @toyotaprius79 3 года назад

      This one is fit to go up in a museum.

    • @porcupineinapettingzoo
      @porcupineinapettingzoo 3 года назад +1

      Still waiting for an explanation there bud.

    • @glcork
      @glcork 2 года назад +3

      Want to actually explain that comment? It's hardly Irish people's fault that the British went around invading many parts of the world.

  • @수확스튜
    @수확스튜 3 года назад

    Siobhan McFatty