Ironically, now it’s going to cost more. so many students will end up back in the public schools, which the government will have to pay for, and they will fail to collect any revenue from the students. A net loss for the government, but come on now… we know this has nothing to do with money…
No it's not, rich people will continue to pay. The money the government makes from the vat is going to be relatively negligible. What they want is for people who currently can just about afford a private education to no longer be able to do so. They want the population all in state schools and only the elite have private education. Labour want the population totally dependent on the government
Nah, they want a business that declares itself a charity, to pay taxes. It's pretty simple. Id be interested to look at this.........st. Joseph's(?) books. I mean every private school so far, that has closed, "as a result of now having to pay tax," actually turned out to have a minimum of 3 years where their spending was higher then their revenue.......
@@dafyddroff8084 Now , then who has misled ? And he has caught me in his net. he has crushed and abandoned ,He has a house that he did not build. God has made me And the Almighty has made me But who has denied For he has not, Nor has he taken Remember the works They have performed, There miracles and the judgments They has pronounced, They seized me; they surrounded me with bitter poison and hardship. They worn away my flesh and my skin; There is an outcry The sound has been heard the sound of their falling ‘The strength has been cut down Remember the wonderful works he has performed, His miracles and the judgments he has pronounced, good is it one has the means to acquire When he has no heart for acquiring it? For the one who has died has been acquitted from his sin. True wisdom has built its house; It has carved out its seven pillars. For “who has come to know Jehovah’s mind, or who has become his adviser?” He has brought powerful men from thrones and has exalted lowly ones;
@dafyddroff8084 why would it cost the parents if they refuse to pay and put them in state schools. Not all independent schools are Eaton! Most are hardworking. This will flop.
The fees are not that crazy and private schools are for the rich to start with. If they cant afford it, they can go to public schools like the rest of us poors..
@bigbadpanda Agreed, and just to show that this government’s not being vindictive, they should put 20% VAT on university fees as well. That’ll bring in far more money. Around 50% of all school leavers go on to university.
Does anyone tax education or is it just our government planning to do this? Private school saves the state sector millions by paying for education outside of the state system. Also how is making private schools more expensive and exclusive a good thing??
They pay tax like everyone which pays for state schools , they also pay for there own children's education easing preassure on state schools , Labour are wrong to do this it doesn't make sense, just envy.
@MsZelda2012 Yes, it's difficult for Labour to wean itself off its Marxist roots. Never mind that it didn't work in communist countries! They will be booted out next election!
@@michaelking8642 Great. Make up the shortfall out of your own pocket. I’m not one of them by the way, but anyone highly paid who gets paid via PAYE in this country, for example, a surgeon ain’t gonna be doing overtime for the NHS. They’ll simply leave for, say, New Zealand where they’ll get better paid & pay less tax.
They should honestly just scrap private schools outright across all disciplines including elitist ones such as the arts or business schools. Either that or make all schools private to force competition and reduce the price of schooling across the board.
Surely the right thing to do for this school would be to give it the £8k per pupil that state schools get. Then let the parents top up within their means to enable the school to meet their children’s full needs.
The typical priveledge one ' pleading povety yet taking the government to court ' this will save us about £ 100,000, mumzy ' good thinking dear ' their not just pleading povety ' they are acting dumb 🤷♂️
The level of most of the comments shows why parents who ‘can’ ( even if they have to do without holidays/ new cars/ extensions et al) actually ‘do’. If this demonstration of outpourings indicates the common standard of education that a Labour government wants to reduce us all to (as demonstrated by the comments) god help this country.
@@alisabristleface And there it is a “hater comment”…..I rest my case 😂 We should be encouraging/incentivizing people with wealth to be investing in our country so they create jobs and create wealth for people through the economy. Instead we punish them by the state taking more wealth from them. Hence, wealthy people are leaving The UK.
@@alisabristleface or perhaps realise they have taken many risks to achieve their goals. Perhaps do the same yourself and don’t expect others to subsidise your lifestyle. Look at the facts and figures and see the rich pay 80% of the taxes in this country!!
Pfft, nothing to do with jealousy. Just stick of the rich behaving like tax dodging welfare cheats. If they paid their fair share, state schools would be in such a mess! Properly taxing just ONE hyper rich person would pay for EVERY state school. Just let that sink in.
@MBReader410 a independent school has closed. This is costing the state. Your country is ruined. Main taxpayers are leaving in flocks. England will be ruined under labour
@@bbrs925 … pour the taxpayer money sent abroad into UK state schools; instead bring up the standard of state education within the nation. Alleviate the requirement for parents to find good alternatives for failing state offerings by providing excellent quality therein.
It will do. If that girl was designated to not require an EHCP, that means she has nothing wrong with her when observed by a professional doctor. Hence the "doesn't meet the threshold". She basically just said she struggles to pay attention due to disruption, which is likely due to behaviour within the classroom - or her own. Not requiring some sort of expemption.
Let's be very clear on this. Private schools are exempt from VAT because they enjoy charitable status, and rightly so: at least in this country. They are not set up to make a profit, and any spare funds are used to fund scholarships, improve facilities, or provide a cushion for a rainy day. The concept of schools as charities goes back about 500 years! TTK's problem is that most state schools are abysmal, and the private sector shines a very bright light on this uncomfortable truth.
They are businesses, they set fees, they are run to make profits, they should pay VAT like any other business. They invest in facilities because it makes the school more attractive AS BUSINESS. Claiming that makes them a charity is like claiming a hotel that puts in a spa is a charity.....
Well if thats the case it will be a jolly good thing if more people who choose private schools are forced to use the state sector because they can use all their influence and experience in order to put pressure on those ‘abysmal’ state schools to improve!
@@DeneMonkey most of those people are not rich. Their actions are damaging to themselves, the governments schools (who shall need more money) and damaging by lowering UK standards of education and will burden the taxpayers with mor cost. Your snide remarks reflect badly on yourself.
Labour, not satisfied that they've ruined public schooling now targets private schooling. Can't have that obvious disparity in quality of education sticking out like a sore thumb now can they?
@@edwardchester1 Well of course, the tories had no resposibility to fix anything while they were in gov. They were just there to deliver brexit and trash our economy.
The most best schools , teachers , knowledge scientists , mathemstissiens , astrophyzisciens etc are anglosaxons , like E Hubble , etc .... I Newton , etc .... 😐🇬🇧
They want a population of compliant wage slaves, indoctrinated into their values. State schools are sausage factories that are nothing to do with education and all about getting a so called 'good job' and not thinking for yourself.
It’s Labour. Their primary objective is always that they need more money. Secondary objective is the story they concoct for their supporters to justify why robbing people is a morally superior thing to do. If only they weren’t such planks
At least LAbour are planning to spend that money on the public, rather than funnelling it all into the offshore bank accounts of their mates like your lot did!
@@michaelcoward1902 the middle class is effectively being made poor whilst the rich get to buy all the assets they relinquish and charge rent/interest/profit and become richer. Stop dragging down the people who will be priced out and start looking at the ones who wouldn’t bat an eyelid at a change in cost…
@@michaelcoward1902No they won't they'll spend it on a larger government and more expensive ways of controlling the public and removing freedom. Usually in the name of safety.
Not exactly cruel. The rich will only share their wealth if they are forced. About time they coughed up -public services have been starved for too long
How is it cruel making 7% of students getting privileged education, to pay tax, when that privilege is too expensive for 93% of parents? Private education should be abolished, tax the rich more to improve public education and make achievement based on merit, not how rich your parents are and nepotism. Nepotism and private education gave us the likes of Boris Johnson and David Cameron, who ruined the country and were not qualified nor had earned such lofty positions but where there through privilege based on the access private education gave them.
Remove charity status from private schools!!!!!!!!
No beta
@@Cherrytune386 Providing education is a charitable cause
@@realityalwaysbulliesopinio1961When it’s run for private profit it ceases to be a charity.
@@IsSalty They don’t make profit on the education services they provide, hence it’s a charity.
Taxing education is immoral no matter what the political stance. But hard Left always goes to its Marxist roots!
They say tax the rich this is what labour is doing 👏
Ironically, now it’s going to cost more. so many students will end up back in the public schools, which the government will have to pay for, and they will fail to collect any revenue from the students. A net loss for the government, but come on now… we know this has nothing to do with money…
There are more rich people in state schools than in independent schools. Why are they off the hook? Taxes paying for schools for millionaires.
No it's not, rich people will continue to pay. The money the government makes from the vat is going to be relatively negligible. What they want is for people who currently can just about afford a private education to no longer be able to do so. They want the population all in state schools and only the elite have private education. Labour want the population totally dependent on the government
Nah, they want a business that declares itself a charity, to pay taxes.
It's pretty simple. Id be interested to look at this.........st. Joseph's(?) books. I mean every private school so far, that has closed, "as a result of now having to pay tax," actually turned out to have a minimum of 3 years where their spending was higher then their revenue.......
😂
What's next then, VAT on university and nursery fees? Come on, fairs fair!
Won’t someone think of the poor unfortunate private school parents!
@@dafyddroff8084 Now , then who has misled ? And he has caught me
in his net.
he has crushed and abandoned ,He has a house that he did not build.
God has made me And the Almighty has made me
But who has denied
For he has not,
Nor has he taken
Remember the works
They have performed,
There miracles
and the judgments
They has pronounced,
They seized me; they surrounded me with bitter poison and hardship.
They worn away my flesh and my skin;
There is an outcry
The sound has been heard
the sound of their falling
‘The strength has been cut down
Remember the wonderful works he has performed, His miracles and the judgments he has pronounced,
good is it one has the means to acquire When he has no heart for acquiring it?
For the one who has died has been acquitted from his sin.
True wisdom has built its house;
It has carved out its seven pillars.
For “who has come to know Jehovah’s mind, or who has become his adviser?”
He has brought powerful men from thrones and has exalted lowly ones;
@dafyddroff8084 yes they should. As it will cost the state now
@@si8568 sounds more like it’ll cost the parents mate
@dafyddroff8084 why would it cost the parents if they refuse to pay and put them in state schools. Not all independent schools are Eaton! Most are hardworking. This will flop.
I think of the poor state sector teachers. In Keir Starmer’s London constituency the best state schools are massively oversubscribed.
A bit hypocritical of Keir Starmer to introduce VAT on school fees as he went to private school himself.
like how they worded it as every parent .not just tax dodging spivs .
The fees are not that crazy and private schools are for the rich to start with. If they cant afford it, they can go to public schools like the rest of us poors..
@bigbadpanda
Agreed, and just to show that this government’s not being vindictive, they should put 20% VAT on university fees as well. That’ll bring in far more money. Around 50% of all school leavers go on to university.
Does anyone tax education or is it just our government planning to do this? Private school saves the state sector millions by paying for education outside of the state system. Also how is making private schools more expensive and exclusive a good thing??
My heart bleeds. Labour have stated that this would be their intention for years. Cut your coat according to your cloth.
They pay tax like everyone which pays for state schools , they also pay for there own children's education easing preassure on state schools , Labour are wrong to do this it doesn't make sense, just envy.
Well said.
Parents at state schools should pay fees. That would actually make a difference. Means test it.
Envy and ideological.
@@parsaeyeHa ha. Maybe but it’s happening regardless of the protestations.
@MsZelda2012 Yes, it's difficult for Labour to wean itself off its Marxist roots. Never mind that it didn't work in communist countries! They will be booted out next election!
Yup, tax them to the max 👍
We learned in a normal school my mum and dad could never afford a private school, but I’m glad I went to open school great times
1:25 Without being rude the parent seems to be unduly influencing Addison into repeating a speech for her that was prepared earlier
Yeah ' & dont mention the £ 500,000, i put aside for your 1st house either 🤣
It could be that she is just keeping an eye on her in case she had one of her moments.
Saying, “Without being rude” before being rude.
@@MBReader410 Brush up on your grammar first your punctuation is abysmal
Am I crazy or are her glasses different shapes ?
I thought I was tripping 😂
No your good, left is square right is round
1:35 Yea I see it now.🤣🤣🤣🤣
There designer ones ' shows how priveledge they are
Labour is the one that brought alot of good schools down in the 1970's those became rough.
Um... what the hell has that got to do with tax!?
I ❤ love to hear wealthy people moaning about the cost of living.😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
They won’t moan. They’ll just leave the country.
@@dcoughla681 I’ll get their suitcases
@@michaelking8642 Great. Make up the shortfall out of your own pocket. I’m not one of them by the way, but anyone highly paid who gets paid via PAYE in this country, for example, a surgeon ain’t gonna be doing overtime for the NHS. They’ll simply leave for, say, New Zealand where they’ll get better paid & pay less tax.
Thoughts and prayers 😂😂
The rich are always moaning when they take a hit.
The poor are always moaning about the rich 💩💩
Closing a tax loophole that only wealthy people can take advantage of is a good thing, find more tax loopholes and close them too
Tax loophole?
They should honestly just scrap private schools outright across all disciplines including elitist ones such as the arts or business schools. Either that or make all schools private to force competition and reduce the price of schooling across the board.
They should scrap free education for parents who could easily afford to pay modest fees to improve state schools
I would advise home learning rather than state schools
My daughter is on the spectrum and we cannot fault our local state school
Not everyone is lucky enough to live in the right area
I think at private schools they teach people how to be snobs and how not to give a toss about those less fortunate than themselves.
@@DH-uq1zwSame applies to having the right private school close by.
Surely the right thing to do for this school would be to give it the £8k per pupil that state schools get. Then let the parents top up within their means to enable the school to meet their children’s full needs.
I have no problem with this happening.
Oh, the hardship they have to endure.
We all know who’ll need the “special needs”
The typical priveledge one ' pleading povety yet taking the government to court ' this will save us about £ 100,000, mumzy ' good thinking dear ' their not just pleading povety ' they are acting dumb 🤷♂️
The level of most of the comments shows why parents who ‘can’ ( even if they have to do without holidays/ new cars/ extensions et al) actually ‘do’. If this demonstration of outpourings indicates the common standard of education that a Labour government wants to reduce us all to (as demonstrated by the comments) god help this country.
I see all the “hater comments” here. People really are envious of people who have that much more and want to burden the state less
No envy about it, it's about paying their way.
No, the rich should be sharing their excess wealth.
@@alisabristleface And there it is a “hater comment”…..I rest my case 😂
We should be encouraging/incentivizing people with wealth to be investing in our country so they create jobs and create wealth for people through the economy. Instead we punish them by the state taking more wealth from them. Hence, wealthy people are leaving The UK.
@@alisabristleface or perhaps realise they have taken many risks to achieve their goals. Perhaps do the same yourself and don’t expect others to subsidise your lifestyle. Look at the facts and figures and see the rich pay 80% of the taxes in this country!!
Pfft, nothing to do with jealousy. Just stick of the rich behaving like tax dodging welfare cheats.
If they paid their fair share, state schools would be in such a mess!
Properly taxing just ONE hyper rich person would pay for EVERY state school. Just let that sink in.
It wasnt already subject to it? Triple the tax on them then to make up for it, private schools in the first world 🙄 beggars belief
Its costing the state
Parents should pay
@MBReader410 a independent school has closed. This is costing the state. Your country is ruined. Main taxpayers are leaving in flocks. England will be ruined under labour
Stop sending money abroad and start saving the UK 🇬🇧
Well, I agree with that!
How does that relate to the news story here..
@@bbrs925 … pour the taxpayer money sent abroad into UK state schools; instead bring up the standard of state education within the nation.
Alleviate the requirement for parents to find good alternatives for failing state offerings by providing excellent quality therein.
@bbrs925 The '£22 Billion Black Hole' being filled by pensioners ....and this(!).
Definitely should be taxing the rich more
Cool what happens when they all leave and there’s nobody left to prop our economy up
A serious plan to improve schools would include allowing state schools to charge fees, means tested.
Liebour = the nasty cruel party.
No no no....nasty only to British citizens. Cares for the rest of the world.
@@IeuanBevan. agree, they care more about Palestinians and the Chinese Gov than British citizens
Vat should be charged and the schools should not have charity status. There a luxury
Hopefully this ridiculous middle class tantrum gets thrown out of court
You clearly have no idea what is going on in the real world. Must be a labour voter.
Hardly middle class more like upper class everything private should be taxed
@@Deathwink1 So that losers can sponge.....
middle class is keeping britain’s lights on
It will do.
If that girl was designated to not require an EHCP, that means she has nothing wrong with her when observed by a professional doctor. Hence the "doesn't meet the threshold".
She basically just said she struggles to pay attention due to disruption, which is likely due to behaviour within the classroom - or her own. Not requiring some sort of expemption.
Let's be very clear on this. Private schools are exempt from VAT because they enjoy charitable status, and rightly so: at least in this country. They are not set up to make a profit, and any spare funds are used to fund scholarships, improve facilities, or provide a cushion for a rainy day. The concept of schools as charities goes back about 500 years!
TTK's problem is that most state schools are abysmal, and the private sector shines a very bright light on this uncomfortable truth.
Preach!!!!
Precisely.
Allow state schools to charge fees. That will actually drive change. The state will never be about to provide significantly more funding per pupil.
They are businesses, they set fees, they are run to make profits, they should pay VAT like any other business. They invest in facilities because it makes the school more attractive AS BUSINESS. Claiming that makes them a charity is like claiming a hotel that puts in a spa is a charity.....
Well if thats the case it will be a jolly good thing if more people who choose private schools are forced to use the state sector because they can use all their influence and experience in order to put pressure on those ‘abysmal’ state schools to improve!
Totally ridiculous. Labour the party of envy.
Oh no the rich need to pay more
@@DeneMonkey most of those people are not rich. Their actions are damaging to themselves, the governments schools (who shall need more money) and damaging by lowering UK standards of education and will burden the taxpayers with mor cost. Your snide remarks reflect badly on yourself.
@@Land-of-reason so don’t brother fixing public schools
@@DeneMonkeynot a good prison 😊
Can't think of a single "we have costed everything" policy that is not falling apart at the first touch with reality from the Stasis.
vat on education!!!! Only Starmlim would do that. There will be on VAT on food next. Mark my words.
There is 🤷♂️
96% of families are still not paying anything, even VAT, for education!
@@thefamousjmc Tax? Is that not paying?
@@JohnSmith-lk8cy rhetorical question? What’s your point?
@@thefamousjmcexactly parents are state schools should pay fees. That would be a game changer.
Money paid to a private school is wasted. Eton etc are at a different level Just speak and understand your childs education .
Immoral
Labour, not satisfied that they've ruined public schooling now targets private schooling. Can't have that obvious disparity in quality of education sticking out like a sore thumb now can they?
Labour, a party that hasn't been in government for 14 years, ruined public schooling?
M'kay.
No they can’t, because people shouldn’t be able to buy better opportunities.
@@thefamousjmc that is kind of how life works generally lol
How on earth has labour ruined public schooling? They've not been in the position to touch it for a decade and a half.
@@edwardchester1 Well of course, the tories had no resposibility to fix anything while they were in gov. They were just there to deliver brexit and trash our economy.
The most best schools , teachers , knowledge scientists , mathemstissiens , astrophyzisciens etc are anglosaxons , like E Hubble , etc .... I Newton , etc .... 😐🇬🇧
Thanks yet again to Tier Starmer for making working people's lives even more difficult
Schools need to reduce fees or parents need more money.
State schools need to charge a modest fee. That’s where the real problem is.
Ok stop giving taxpayers money for Israel
The rich need to cough up.
Yes, parents who can afford it should pay fees at state schools.
I’m sure 6,500 will fund all the state schools 😂😂😂😂
A little African country (island)😂
Why does Labour hate education?
Labour HATES EVERYTHING
They want a population of compliant wage slaves, indoctrinated into their values. State schools are sausage factories that are nothing to do with education and all about getting a so called 'good job' and not thinking for yourself.
It’s Labour. Their primary objective is always that they need more money.
Secondary objective is the story they concoct for their supporters to justify why robbing people is a morally superior thing to do.
If only they weren’t such planks
At least LAbour are planning to spend that money on the public, rather than funnelling it all into the offshore bank accounts of their mates like your lot did!
@@michaelcoward1902 the middle class is effectively being made poor whilst the rich get to buy all the assets they relinquish and charge rent/interest/profit and become richer. Stop dragging down the people who will be priced out and start looking at the ones who wouldn’t bat an eyelid at a change in cost…
The only way to get significantly more funding into state schools is to charge fees. Means test it.
@@michaelcoward1902No they won't they'll spend it on a larger government and more expensive ways of controlling the public and removing freedom. Usually in the name of safety.
@@MBReader410 State schools get plenty of funding, issue is there are too many bureaucrats in the system draining the money.
Why is the reporter wearing Islamic garb?
Because she's Muslim presumably.
She’s a Muslim I’d guess!
Unfortunately, London looks like the Middle East nowadays.
Bigger problems exist.Really.
braindead
Can we create a forum to fund the legal action against govt. I am willing to join.
Cruel policy based on lies and envy. “We know best” Labour at their worst.
Not exactly cruel. The rich will only share their wealth if they are forced. About time they coughed up -public services have been starved for too long
How is it cruel making 7% of students getting privileged education, to pay tax, when that privilege is too expensive for 93% of parents? Private education should be abolished, tax the rich more to improve public education and make achievement based on merit, not how rich your parents are and nepotism. Nepotism and private education gave us the likes of Boris Johnson and David Cameron, who ruined the country and were not qualified nor had earned such lofty positions but where there through privilege based on the access private education gave them.
About time the majority of parents at state schools pay fees. Most could easily afford to pay something and this would transform education over night.
VAT is charged on virtually everything why not school fees ?
Good
Not only should private schools not pay VAT they should actually get grants from the government and part of the tuition should be paid for by them.
Yhawedsanoujonomoihuwayhauno
Oh no so the money can’t fix up crumbling public schools
Private schools are businesses and MOST PAY VAT
If parents can't buy the service, that acceptable
Didums, go to state school then.