Prabodh Agarwal this would never be included in the history books as then nobody will ever support the INC . Even the true history of independence and partition would never be taught in any history book.
This video is indeed a gem.. Let's take a moment to pay tribute to Nani Palkhivala, Shanthi Bhushan, Prashanth Bhushan and others who defended the democracy during those times.
The saying " history always written by the victors" holds true here. During the last 70 years, Congress was in power for the most of the time and made to wrote textbooks according to their tastes without mentioning their wrong doings. I thank and appreciate the channel for bringing such an extensive coverage of the case that shook the nation. Thanks again.
Was it really? Because it seemed like it’s essentially a form of the ship of thesus argument: which can be resolved by arguing that it’s not the individual components but their relationship to each other that constitute the identity. i do concede that making sense of the constitution this way might be unreasonable but I can’t think of a coherent argument for the same
I think no one can do this with such profound knowledge.. when I searched 'why emergency is imposed in India' your video is not in the top recommended videos but when I saw ur video named part 1, then I got a hope that u will cover in more detail with good timeline. Now I can say u r explanation and the lawyers explanation is far from what I expected and thank you for giving this information.
That was a clear picture. I was asking many people about this Emergency case. But, hardly people knew about it. Thanks for this documentary. Congress party being corrupt won’t signify that BJP is corruption-free. Of course, BJP lead by great leaders like JP, Vajpayee, and Advani (to some extent) WAS secular and democratic which are the identities of Indian constitution. In my viewpoint, the current BJP is equally unstable and corrupt like the Congress party. We must be unbiased when it comes to the welfare of the people and the system.
U mean Indira Gandhi vs Raj Narain. Allahabad HC. True but legislation has to pass the test of constitutionality (KB case) and due process (Maneka Gandhi case)
This is the first (actually second - first was previous video) video from this channel that I have watched and really liked the way incident has been narrated. In the previous video the background music was overpowering the narration. This video did not have such issues. Job well done.
Someone else is also having an eye for capturing the power forever, not just by altering the system but also by changing the basic nature of Indian Society. We must be aware about his intentions.
So true spineless presidents and spineless judges. But Indira was corrupt but powerful nonetheless. In my opinion there's more to it than what meets the eye. Her power is over 9000!!!
He was Happy making Indiia Secular so that Saudi and Christion Missionary money cud be Flushed into India to convert Tribals Dalits , Buy Leaders in India, fund Communists to write our History books, provide money to Poor Muskims who produce 7 8 Children Per muslim women....
Thank you for taking the effort to make the documentary - for all the news channels we have in our country very few touch upon important issues and history !! Well done and thank you !
Ghanta bc. Jhaat h congress. Rahul pappu can't even speak properly. Ain't voting for a half Indian half firangee ever. I just cannot accept that Rahul has the best interests of India at his heart. He just doesn't have the motivation for it.
@@devyanshigarg4667 yes, realisation came in form of manishankar ayyars pakistan visits, rahul gandhi's china visits and false issues raised across india such as award returning row before state elections, dalit issues which faded right after another state elections, creating doubts in the mind of common public about security forces, showing disrespect and disbelief in electoral commission in media without following any legal procedures like shanti bhushan, quoting informal conversations with heads of other nations to put allegations without giving antly evidence of such conversations, deluding the image of nation from international podium to list few. What kind of retarded brain is this to say that they got some realisation from this. That party is made to control indian politics for some foreign interests and loot the indians off of their rights to free speech and ultimately freedom. Have a nice day ahead.
Informative and well narrated. Really must appreciate the effort u guys have put in to make this documentary. These stories must be added onto the school syllabuses so that the students get a coherent idea about the history of the darkest times of Indian democracy.
Why was all this not in my 10th-12th cbse history books?!
3 года назад
its in the 12th std pol sci textbook (ncert) history is from ancient times/starting of ancient times/inception of the world till the end of british rule this is political science / political history
Oh they do it even today, making party donations unlimited and anonymous, hiding away 9-10 official reports containing exposure, even media is govt controlled through ib mininstry, just that it became more sofisticated now, also you hardly come to know about it , because guess what, mediaaa- ib min.... lol.
She changed constitution 20 times baba saheb Ambedkar never put secular word in constitution she did it on her own lord Ganesha picture was removed from constitution by that Shaitan woman
My goodness....look at the precised context mentioned by Mr. Shanti bhushan , the way he explains with examples , the way that he questioned Mrs . Gandhi so clever with intellectuality. One should realise that though the country runs towards corruption at one side these , ellites instigates faith to re-establish the virtue Thanx for this avow explanation in this video.
I DARE @THE QUINT TO MAKE A VIDEO ON THIS! IF YOU HAVE THE BALLS TO DO IT THAT IS!! THEN YOU WOULD GET THE CREDIBILITY YOU DONT HAVE IN THE PUBLIC EYE.
Make more videos on landmark judgements. I am not a law student or a lawyer but found this video very interesting. Pl make videos on other cases like shah bano etc
Jo party ye kahti he ki modi ji apna faida dekhte he power ki padi he unhe ek bar ye dekh lena chahiye ki power actually me kise chahiye thi Salute to bhushan sir
What a intellectually stimulating historical piece by piece account of events leading up to the Emergency. Unfortunately the current generation is seeing a repeat of events on similar lines. This time though, the media too is playing the the power centre's tunes. Plus this govt has the advantage of technological advances like Aadhaar which they can use to establish dictatorial authority with impunity and no oversight. Thank you very much mylaw for this wonderful presentation.
I was a kid when this case came about. I knew Emergency was a dark blot on Indian democracy...but the extent to which Indira Gandhi was corrupt and a power-luster is staggering. What an abysmal liar and shameless woman she was! No doubt, she believed she had a God-given right to rule the country and would not allow anyone to challenge that perceived right!
"After all he was brought down on petty...." You mean, Indira Gandhi right? If so, I don't think she was brought down on petty misconduct charges - she abused government machinery for her own ends and even modified the rules to suit her. Doesn't get any worse than that! As for Modi, you're right in saying he might do likewise. But, it would still be wrong on principle and ethics, no matter how many people do it.
I sincerely appreciate the people who were the master minds behind helping her out! Though I hate the idea of an emergency and the abuse of power.But these guys had one job, to help Indira Gandhi get aquitted and they guys just took the loop holes in our system for a ride. Just brilliant in my opinion. Can't believe I'm saying this though.
Aditya V. Where did you find that Indira was 'acquitted' ? The 'Stay' in Allahabad H.C was just obtained by 'Luck' as Mr. Shantibhushan was absent & could not oppose it, otherwise, it is grossly 'unusual & incomprehensible' for a Judge to give a 'stay' on his own verdict! Js Krishna Iyer did allow only 'Conditional & partial' stay on Allahabad HC and allowed for hearing of 'further argument'. But Indira did not wait and went for the 'Emergency' and unleashed the series of amendments of acts and the Constitution (39th amendment) itself and that too, with 'retrospective effect' which made the case against her itself irrelevant. Her lawyers did not get any chance to prove her 'Not guilty' because she changed the Law itself! She did not win in the 'Court of Law' and manipulated the 'Law' taking the advantage of the 'Parliament'! Do u find it praiseworthy?
Thank you. Even in my 10th class social studies textbook, it was just mentioned Emergency was declared bcoz of some internal affairs . But I got the truth now. Thanks for the Law.
To be honest! I never thought Emergency was placed only to safe Indra Gandhi PM Seat....There should be a mention in history books as showing the both faces on Indra Gandhi..so that today students should be aware about the dark truth about the time period of Emergency
Jagjivan Ram should have been given a chance to become PM. Then. What was the verdict of Nana Palkiwala afterwards? She was the origin of corrupt practices. She paid a price later with her life
Cleary the judges of the supreme court have failed to honour their responsibility and so permitted oppression. The court should have ruled that the parliament does not have the right to make retrospective laws. Regards, Geoff. Reeks
I recently realized, emergency was never covered in history/civics books. Atleast not when I wrote my ICSE exams in 2010.
It is sad.
I'm not sure any govt. be it the one in power or the one in opposition will support emergency.
And knowledge gaps like these help govt maintain status quo
Prabodh Agarwal Dude i read about it in class 12 th and knew about it btw i am from CBSE ☮️
Prabodh Agarwal well noted...
Prabodh Agarwal this would never be included in the history books as then nobody will ever support the INC . Even the true history of independence and partition would never be taught in any history book.
This video is indeed a gem.. Let's take a moment to pay tribute to Nani Palkhivala, Shanthi Bhushan, Prashanth Bhushan and others who defended the democracy during those times.
Prashant bhushan was 15 years old back thn.
Nani palkhiwala was fighting for indira gandhi in supreme court
@@kaharmahasangh5412 Nani palkhivala withdrawn once emergency talks have started. Palkhivala always stood with citizens
Why does no one discuss this in school books and news channels ??
Biased history. There is always a dark side to history in many of the events of the past. You only get these things when you start digging up.
Because the history books r also written under the guidance of same government
cuz Congress was in power for the most time in history of independent India and for the most time we were in school
These incidents are mentioned in a few lines in history books. If not, then the Congress did what the BJP is trying to do now: delete history.
History syllabus for 10th is till Independence of India
A worthy documentary to be seen by all of us Indians.
WOW WOW,,what a knowledgeable person Shanti Bhusan was,,,,salute to you Sir
But pity his son who fights for Rohingyas
why shanti bhusan didnt filed a case against BJP who won the 2002 elections because of the 2002 riots????
The saying " history always written by the victors" holds true here. During the last 70 years, Congress was in power for the most of the time and made to wrote textbooks according to their tastes without mentioning their wrong doings. I thank and appreciate the channel for bringing such an extensive coverage of the case that shook the nation. Thanks again.
Shanti Bhushan's explanation of the basic structure doctrine was amazing.
Was it really? Because it seemed like it’s essentially a form of the ship of thesus argument: which can be resolved by arguing that it’s not the individual components but their relationship to each other that constitute the identity. i do concede that making sense of the constitution this way might be unreasonable but I can’t think of a coherent argument for the same
www.business-standard.com/article/economy-policy/shanti-bhushan-to-move-sc-on-i-t-deduction-for-heart-surgery-111060200085_1.html about shanti bushan
@@epsilonzeromusic yuuuccck🤮
I think no one can do this with such profound knowledge.. when I searched 'why emergency is imposed in India' your video is not in the top recommended videos but when I saw ur video named part 1, then I got a hope that u will cover in more detail with good timeline. Now I can say u r explanation and the lawyers explanation is far from what I expected and thank you for giving this information.
I never knew a case like this even existed . Wonder why they dont put things like this in history books
That was a clear picture. I was asking many people about this Emergency case. But, hardly people knew about it. Thanks for this documentary. Congress party being corrupt won’t signify that BJP is corruption-free. Of course, BJP lead by great leaders like JP, Vajpayee, and Advani (to some extent) WAS secular and democratic which are the identities of Indian constitution. In my viewpoint, the current BJP is equally unstable and corrupt like the Congress party. We must be unbiased when it comes to the welfare of the people and the system.
Current govt is better then any other govt in the history of Indian politics
Please support your point about the current govt. with valid arguments or STFU
@@34kaushik he's biased
Make a video on Kesavananda Bharti case as well. Please.
What a thoroughly researched, marvelous documentary! It was an absolute pleasure to watch this. Hats off!
Great to see a channel showing our country's history in such quality of information to provide some vigilance to our citizens. Great job 🙏
This is why I trust my country's future with the judges and law. Not politicians and other citizens. LEX REX!
lex clearly bended down by gandhi..ti is people who defeated her..believe in dēmokratía..
But even then we will need democratically made laws. Democracy will only give us what we deserve, not need.
In democracy, believe it or not , legislation reins supreme, be it shabano or be it indira gandhi vs RN.
U mean Indira Gandhi vs Raj Narain. Allahabad HC. True but legislation has to pass the test of constitutionality (KB case) and due process (Maneka Gandhi case)
Sorry to say even they can't be trusted because they are not immune to political influences
"Absolute POWER corrupts absolutely."
Pardesi Binda thats why democracy always goes in parallel with decentralisation.
As long as the local authority has honest intentions.
This is the first (actually second - first was previous video) video from this channel that I have watched and really liked the way incident has been narrated. In the previous video the background music was overpowering the narration. This video did not have such issues. Job well done.
Someone else is also having an eye for capturing the power forever, not just by altering the system but also by changing the basic nature of Indian Society. We must be aware about his intentions.
Hats off on the mind opener
keep up you good work team for putting together a vital or rather important documentation
wow, what a spineless President we had whose name was Fakhruddin Ali Ahmed.
yes he was,except abdul kalam name one president who had spine,no one .presidents are good for nothing.
Owais 6:16 Aren't you forgetting S. Radhakrishna?
He was a muslim.
So true spineless presidents and spineless judges. But Indira was corrupt but powerful nonetheless. In my opinion there's more to it than what meets the eye. Her power is over 9000!!!
He was Happy making Indiia Secular so that Saudi and Christion Missionary money cud be Flushed into India to convert Tribals Dalits , Buy Leaders in India, fund Communists to write our History books, provide money to Poor Muskims who produce 7 8 Children Per muslim women....
Thank you for taking the effort to make the documentary - for all the news channels we have in our country very few touch upon important issues and history !! Well done and thank you !
Wonderful...fact packed documentry...all appreciations and praises... I wish every youth sees this...
Appreciate your efforts.. Very much unbiased and true deception of the event.. What shameful president we had at that time..
this is the best video i have seen about this case. thank you
Sir,also please add law cases which amended Constitution
My special thanks to Advocate Shanthi Bhooshan sir who fought to save the Democracy. Iam so proud of you sir. Your effort is like "Bhagiratha Effort"
This is something everyone should know about india and not get blinded by our history books and media
2:00 Could have prevented emergency
3:08 palkiwala
3:37 Influence
6:10 can't vote - reduced powers
6:30 extra constitutional -
8:00 Emergency
9:15 consequences - tinpot dictatorship
10:10 shock fear complex
10:40 Sterilization process - Sanjay Ghandhi
11:10 Bulldozing
11:50 amendments
12:30 amendments to exonerate her corruption
15:00 cricket
16:30 revenge
15:50 basic structure
16:25 packing supreme court with supporters
17:40 basic structure
18:20 basic structure explained
20:20 dictatorship
20:50 violates basic structure
21:30 indira wins validation inspite of corruption
22:10 consequences
22:45 back in power
23:00 19 months without democracy in India
Worthy Information...Hats Off
I didn't knew the real series of events leading that USELESS and TERRORIZING emergency. Thankyou! But, now im curious how we got out of the trap?
Bcoz there is a limit to the amount of time emergency can be implemented
She lifted the emergency in 71 i guess ,for the next elections .
Thank you so much for this
Very well explained and a great clarity in speech.
and people call Modi a fascist.
He is, do we need to repeat the history?
Devyanshi Garg so let's give that chance to Congress again right?
@@886arunchoudhary I guess they would have realized now that what harm they were doing to the country by tasting der own medicine.
Ghanta bc. Jhaat h congress. Rahul pappu can't even speak properly. Ain't voting for a half Indian half firangee ever. I just cannot accept that Rahul has the best interests of India at his heart. He just doesn't have the motivation for it.
@@devyanshigarg4667 yes, realisation came in form of manishankar ayyars pakistan visits, rahul gandhi's china visits and false issues raised across india such as award returning row before state elections, dalit issues which faded right after another state elections, creating doubts in the mind of common public about security forces, showing disrespect and disbelief in electoral commission in media without following any legal procedures like shanti bhushan, quoting informal conversations with heads of other nations to put allegations without giving antly evidence of such conversations, deluding the image of nation from international podium to list few. What kind of retarded brain is this to say that they got some realisation from this. That party is made to control indian politics for some foreign interests and loot the indians off of their rights to free speech and ultimately freedom. Have a nice day ahead.
Shanthi bhusan what a Genius!!!. Wowwwwwww
I'm 23yrs old n I came to know 2day after 14yrs of education.
The footage used in this was awesome.
Informative and well narrated. Really must appreciate the effort u guys have put in to make this documentary. These stories must be added onto the school syllabuses so that the students get a coherent idea about the history of the darkest times of Indian democracy.
This video successfully captures how power fails everything, even basic human rights.
Very good info to know how our country was handled by our own people
Amazingly documented and explained. I wonder why we never learnt these things in school
Awesome efforts keep posting sir 👌👍
Very well explained the values of democracy... Thank you...
Thank you so much for educating us , nowhere it is available in such detail , Keep up the good work
Very effective and useful
Astonishing work, couldn’t understand emergency better..
Thanks for this information 👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼
Why was all this not in my 10th-12th cbse history books?!
its in the 12th std pol sci textbook (ncert) history is from ancient times/starting of ancient times/inception of the world till the end of british rule this is political science / political history
How can she easily played with our constitutional laws and also get away with it, really we have very short memory. I won't forget this.
Oh they do it even today, making party donations unlimited and anonymous, hiding away 9-10 official reports containing exposure, even media is govt controlled through ib mininstry, just that it became more sofisticated now, also you hardly come to know about it , because guess what, mediaaa- ib min.... lol.
She changed constitution 20 times baba saheb Ambedkar never put secular word in constitution she did it on her own lord Ganesha picture was removed from constitution by that Shaitan woman
My goodness....look at the precised context mentioned by Mr. Shanti bhushan , the way he explains with examples , the way that he questioned Mrs . Gandhi so clever with intellectuality.
One should realise that though the country runs towards corruption at one side these , ellites instigates faith to re-establish the virtue
Thanx for this avow explanation in this video.
I really appreciate your work here. I don't ever remember reading this ever I'm school.
Extraordinary video
I am totally shocked how the president signed the emergency declaration
after all he was congi. how can he reject. Applying own's mind was out of bound for him
I heard that he was called a "Rubber Stamp President" so was Mrs. Patil
Bro whats emergency declaration
Excellent. Very sad to know that due to some loophole in our legal system democracy faced a set back. Every person should know this reality.
Just too good to get heard of.. Thanks a lot for this video..
Very well done documentary.. Kudos
Best video I have watched
Thank you. It was very educational.
very well compiled in 40 mins ,
DIRTY & SHAMELESS CREATURES OF NEHRU LINEAGE.
I DARE @THE QUINT TO MAKE A VIDEO ON THIS! IF YOU HAVE THE BALLS TO DO IT THAT IS!! THEN YOU WOULD GET THE CREDIBILITY YOU DONT HAVE IN THE PUBLIC EYE.
They've actually interviewed Adv. Shanti Bushan a year before this video was made.
Watched both part 1&2 , very good videos...make more...
Make more videos on landmark judgements. I am not a law student or a lawyer but found this video very interesting. Pl make videos on other cases like shah bano etc
Very good ✌️
A wonderful documentry
Very insightful ! Crisp to the point with facts .
please suggest some more channels like this on youtube which can enlighten me more about such truths.
your videos have helped me SO much for my legal studies project, thank you!!
Jo party ye kahti he ki modi ji apna faida dekhte he power ki padi he unhe ek bar ye dekh lena chahiye ki power actually me kise chahiye thi
Salute to bhushan sir
What a intellectually stimulating historical piece by piece account of events leading up to the Emergency. Unfortunately the current generation is seeing a repeat of events on similar lines. This time though, the media too is playing the the power centre's tunes. Plus this govt has the advantage of technological advances like Aadhaar which they can use to establish dictatorial authority with impunity and no oversight. Thank you very much mylaw for this wonderful presentation.
It sickens me to the core when I use names such as I Indira Gandhi International Airport.
Probably the airport was named after Indira Gandhi because it has most number of 'Emergency' exits 😂 #JustForFun
@@sharathatchandra 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Great 👌👌👏👏
My hearty thanks to Mr. Shanti Bhushan for sharing.
Commendable work. I would say extraordinary video👏
The story ends but leaves us black side of politices in earlier days of history. Hope future generations will take lessons from it..
Great work guys!
Great video 👍
Indira took a great step , We love Indira
Wow this is amazing!
amazing documentry.
Never knew this. Great documentary
Excellent video
Please make more videos like this on famous cases.
Well put, appreciate the effort you have put in, would you please make a video on keshavanada case
2:25 this is a right of every person to appeal at a higher court.
very useful info...
I was a kid when this case came about. I knew Emergency was a dark blot on Indian democracy...but the extent to which Indira Gandhi was corrupt and a power-luster is staggering. What an abysmal liar and shameless woman she was! No doubt, she believed she had a God-given right to rule the country and would not allow anyone to challenge that perceived right!
"After all he was brought down on petty...." You mean, Indira Gandhi right? If so, I don't think she was brought down on petty misconduct charges - she abused government machinery for her own ends and even modified the rules to suit her. Doesn't get any worse than that! As for Modi, you're right in saying he might do likewise. But, it would still be wrong on principle and ethics, no matter how many people do it.
@@MedianMagic There is a very big difference between having done it and “may do it”.
@@VMRDY
Sure, any one can see that. But why point that out to me? I did not claim Modi has imposed Emergency!
Thanks a lot sir , for making it
I sincerely appreciate the people who were the master minds behind helping her out! Though I hate the idea of an emergency and the abuse of power.But these guys had one job, to help Indira Gandhi get aquitted and they guys just took the loop holes in our system for a ride. Just brilliant in my opinion. Can't believe I'm saying this though.
you spat some freely willy shit :D
Aditya V. Where did you find that Indira was 'acquitted' ? The 'Stay' in Allahabad H.C was just obtained by 'Luck' as Mr. Shantibhushan was absent & could not oppose it, otherwise, it is grossly 'unusual & incomprehensible' for a Judge to give a 'stay' on his own verdict! Js Krishna Iyer did allow only 'Conditional & partial' stay on Allahabad HC and allowed for hearing of 'further argument'. But Indira did not wait and went for the 'Emergency' and unleashed the series of amendments of acts and the Constitution (39th amendment) itself and that too, with 'retrospective effect' which made the case against her itself irrelevant. Her lawyers did not get any chance to prove her 'Not guilty' because she changed the Law itself! She did not win in the 'Court of Law' and manipulated the 'Law' taking the advantage of the 'Parliament'! Do u find it praiseworthy?
Rajiv Ghandhi should have been sterilised
Very true pappu pink desh per bojh panoti
Never knew Nani Palkhivala helped her get that stay order
Basic structure is the identity of the Constitution 💐🙏
seeing the current situation of our country in my personal understanding we r nearing to another emergency...praying tat m wrng...
Excellent
Thank you.
Even in my 10th class social studies textbook, it was just mentioned Emergency was declared bcoz of some internal affairs . But I got the truth now.
Thanks for the Law.
Please make a video on Kesavananda Bharati Case. Thanks
To be honest! I never thought Emergency was placed only to safe Indra Gandhi PM Seat....There should be a mention in history books as showing the both faces on Indra Gandhi..so that today students should be aware about the dark truth about the time period of Emergency
Jagjivan Ram should have been given a chance to become PM. Then.
What was the verdict of Nana Palkiwala afterwards? She was the origin of corrupt practices. She paid a price later with her life
She contested election by false name her real name was MAMOONA Begum
Nehru highjacked congress with help of gandhi from sardar patel lala Lajpat rai
This emergency true story should be propagated by our present Central Government in our history and civics books.. Let the youth know the truth..
How unfortunate and disheartening is it when your father has more hair then you do!
I face it daily :P
Best comment so far...
Thank you.
Cleary the judges of the supreme court have failed to honour their responsibility and so permitted oppression. The court should have ruled that the parliament does not have the right to make retrospective laws.
Regards,
Geoff. Reeks
Thank you Mylaw.