I completely agree with you I for one think that as architects and designers we cannot compose the whole situation and narrative of the work according to our idea We need to leave room for the users to impact the design when its built otherwise we are selling lies And thats why i think renders neednt try to be realistic because we cannot predict what the final product will look like nor how it will be used
You should look at the new makers bureau renders for their project. I feel like they communicate the idea of the project(in renders) as though it's a dream yet to be realized, without too much detail.
I find it very interesting that like if we try to do super realistic renders we get criticised for not the right shadow or thing and that is not accurate but if we do like a collage its okay for it to not be perfect what do you guys think?
You know what yh that's actually so true, I once did like a realistic render or well I tried to but teacher kept going on ghat the bricks where not perfect.
@@artdray1015 Nice quick reply buddy. It depends on what type of rendering software you use aswell though. Like I used enscape and its not the best especially if you go up close its shite lol
Something interesting with real-life renders or just renders in general is the perception of use, how people move through a space, how they perceive it, etc. From my experience, a render or diagram rarely seems to depict this correctly, despite it being perhaps the most important aspect
Yeah that's interesting actually. I've read a research paper on the emotional response of renders and from the results, it didn't look like realism had an impact on the perception of space/use
Great video. I agree with the idea that it should be discussed, including AI generated images now. I couldn't find the Milanote referral link, is it in the description box?
I agree with you 100% and I'm really glad you spoke about this. I personally think that hyper realism rendering turned architecture to fully commercial product. The focus goes on how to achieve realism with a little consideration for the architecture itself, the functions and user experience when it should be the opposite.
Great video I was really engaged by your explanation of realism vs naturalism and breaking down what our motivation is for trying to depict things as realistically as possible
I never show my clients realistic renders because they then get distracted by trivial details. Honestly, I don't care about your (the client's) preference for chrome ironmongery - just tell me you're happy with the space...
I completely agree with you
I for one think that as architects and designers we cannot compose the whole situation and narrative of the work according to our idea
We need to leave room for the users to impact the design when its built otherwise we are selling lies
And thats why i think renders neednt try to be realistic because we cannot predict what the final product will look like nor how it will be used
Exactly! realistic renders dont leave any room of interpertation and it feels too "finished" when clients want to add their own touch
You should look at the new makers bureau renders for their project. I feel like they communicate the idea of the project(in renders) as though it's a dream yet to be realized, without too much detail.
I find it very interesting that like if we try to do super realistic renders we get criticised for not the right shadow or thing and that is not accurate but if we do like a collage its okay for it to not be perfect what do you guys think?
You know what yh that's actually so true, I once did like a realistic render or well I tried to but teacher kept going on ghat the bricks where not perfect.
@@artdray1015 Oh, wow tbh brick is always one of those things that hard as when you look for brick texture its always new brick.
@@TheArchitecturalInsider I use dirty bricks too sometimes though but still lol, I also about making bricks have a decent depth many images are flat.
@@artdray1015 Nice quick reply buddy. It depends on what type of rendering software you use aswell though. Like I used enscape and its not the best especially if you go up close its shite lol
@@TheArchitecturalInsider I'm enjoying the conversation Hahaha. Yh true I use escape aswell but you seen Rashas video on D5 that programme looks mad
What are your thoughts on hyper realistic renderings?
As a facade engineer myself, I couldn't agree more on this topic. Great Work.
Thank you so much
These kind of explainers are interesting to listen to, its like a presentation from a co-student of architecture. I appreciate it
Glad you like them!
Something interesting with real-life renders or just renders in general is the perception of use, how people move through a space, how they perceive it, etc. From my experience, a render or diagram rarely seems to depict this correctly, despite it being perhaps the most important aspect
Yeah that's interesting actually. I've read a research paper on the emotional response of renders and from the results, it didn't look like realism had an impact on the perception of space/use
Great video. I agree with the idea that it should be discussed, including AI generated images now. I couldn't find the Milanote referral link, is it in the description box?
milanote.com/survivingarchitecture0223
When there are blue skies in London... That's when you know it's a render
I know right lol
I agree with you 100% and I'm really glad you spoke about this.
I personally think that hyper realism rendering turned architecture to fully commercial product. The focus goes on how to achieve realism with a little consideration for the architecture itself, the functions and user experience when it should be the opposite.
Great video I was really engaged by your explanation of realism vs naturalism and breaking down what our motivation is for trying to depict things as realistically as possible
Awesome, thank you!
Amazing video such high quality.
Much appreciated!
I know!! It's amazing
Oh wow I haven't thought about it that way. Thank you for your insights
Glad it was helpful!
Brilliant! Thanks
Glad you liked it
Another absolutely top notch video
Glad you enjoyed it
I never show my clients realistic renders because they then get distracted by trivial details. Honestly, I don't care about your (the client's) preference for chrome ironmongery - just tell me you're happy with the space...
love your channel, I have been a subscriber since you had 30.000 subs!
Awesome! Thank you!
You're just mind blowing 💖💖💖
Thank you Gupta
@@SurvivingArchitecture 😳💖love it
Unique episode, and a good reality check!
Glad you enjoyed it
Can ai replace architect in the future?
Will make a video about it
I don't think so.. but they can try lol
@@SurvivingArchitecture thankyou 😊
@@misdede1959 lol 😁
I love rendering of building projects
Me too
cat fished by a skyscraper! pff what's this world coming to
lol haven't thought about it like that
I could not agree more
Glad you think so
Good video
Thanks for the visit
profound...
Thanks to Milanote for sponsoring this video! Sign up for free and start your next creative project: milanote.com/survivingarchitecture0223