Many comments on the accompaniment.. but I look at it from another angle. That this is a performance in a busy mall where people usually dont bother about such performances. The "fullness" of the accompaniment helps to attract people over, and in a way covers, or not expose the vocals too much. After all, I think the focus is allowing the singers to not have stage fright and is a semi-pro or even amateur group performance. But then again, I am not the pianist nor was I at the venue. Just my thoughts on the overly full accompaniment. Probably would be played differently in say a concert hall or in a studio.
不足16 歲未出道的小小鄧已唱至此水平，利害!
2007年上載, G.E.M.當時只有16歲....重要追住個"主音"琴手呢唱.....已經算係咁.
简直为钢琴而生的。有种钢琴 不叫朗朗 不叫李云迪！ 叫做对 钢琴-爱！ you are the number 1 in my heart！
各位請記住，GEM當時未夠十六歲，尚未出道。Phoebus當時已經在海港城表演了四五年之久。
只用一种乐器演奏出这样震撼的伴奏效果
非常好听
唱的真好
好好聽呀
好好听呀，赞
GEM果陣16歲都未有。。。好勁
this is gem tang..
業餘中都算不錯，學友的歌幾難大家都清楚，她聲線高音部份控制不錯。
Many comments on the accompaniment.. but I look at it from another angle. That this is a performance in a busy mall where people usually dont bother about such performances. The "fullness" of the accompaniment helps to attract people over, and in a way covers, or not expose the vocals too much. After all, I think the focus is allowing the singers to not have stage fright and is a semi-pro or even amateur group performance. But then again, I am not the pianist nor was I at the venue. Just my thoughts on the overly full accompaniment. Probably would be played differently in say a concert hall or in a studio.
天后鄧紫棋 , 名氣大大
2個都幾勁
好好聽wo~
錄影o個個近Phoebus多過近G.E.M,，個琴大聲過G.E.M.好正常o者，現場就唔會嫁啦....又話人地喧賓奪主=.="
好靓啊
其实邓紫棋可以随便唱任何广东话旧歌，如果推出一张广东话翻唱歌专辑，如果，，
@Kcohlorskyfo
有幾多人真係可以唱到佢咁....但佢始終都會有老既一日..點都會有離開樂壇既一日..所以有後輩接班點都算係一件好事...而且話明後輩..當然要經很多的磨練先會成器~
彈鋼琴果個嘅手太搶鏡。。
當時鬼有人留意gem咩
話人唔投入嘅呢位人兄, 請問你有冇彈過琴? 甚至連牧童笛都未掂過?
不錯聽,但感情多放一點會更好。
樓下，呢个唔系學友嘅，系杜麗莎版本
wow
话说紫棋先天厉害，不如说张丹更厉害，慧眼识人，加之培养到今天影响华语乐坛的新一代天后，可谓功不可没。谢谢你张丹，因为你让我们认识了现在的gem
觉得弹琴个个先系主角 =。=
her canto songs are good..
but eng songs..not good enough
a little flat i think. especially the loud parts when she tries to shout. she doesn't get there.
爛音響中顯現不平凡，終非池中物
條裙好令:P
鋼琴太搶 喧賓奪主
彈琴o個個人好似手抽筋 =.=
蹬個琴慘 T_T
淨係聽個琴猛咁fillin就已經咩都唔洗聽
話彈琴者造作的前世未見過人彈琴...或者見親都係低手
The pianist needs to improve his accompanying skill!
佢都唔係唱高音
they get this song completely wrong..
her voice is about average..and the piano is 100% disaster. nothings good
这是邓紫棋？主唱节奏乱不见了，键盘手烦死
David Sis 是邓紫棋,這是紫棋16歲的時候唱的
唔多掂
呢首要用感覺唱
gem佢注重技巧
尾音太肉緊
完全唱唔到首歌既靈魂
失敗
去聽下容祖兒個個版本先好唱啦...冇感情=___="佢影衰首歌.俾人感覺係嗌交feel.橫刀奪愛咩依家??!=[[[[[[