it's becoz the recorder stand right next to the pianist! it's not the problem of the pianist coz i admire him very much. If the recorder stand next to the speaker, gem's voice wud b so much louder. function ur brain pls guys..
For much of the performance, it seems to be an exercise to see if the pianist could overpower the singer. To the singer's credit, she held her own. The comping, if that's what you can call it, was way too dynamic for this essentially melancholic piece.
Maybe the pianist is very skillful, but I think as an accompanist, he should match the feeling of the song. In this case, I don't think the accompanist matches with the soloist much... and he is too rude to the piano...
剛簽約仍在讀中四 , 已在張丹的培養下鍛鍊 , 8年後的今天已完全能駕御樂隊的舞台王者 !
這鋼琴真的太猛了!!整個被震撼到,第一次聽人家唱歌,把歌手的歌聲當成拌奏在聽,整個聽覺全被鋼琴所吸走了,這真的太利害了!!
确实弹太用力了
是啊～鋼琴比歌唱強太多了
歌唱弱到寧可聽鋼琴獨秀就好了
@@swimjay228 你確定嗎 歌手明明就唱的很好
我每次暑假返香港我都有去o個個商場, 每次聽到佢彈琴都會有一種莫名其妙o既吸引力, 我覺得彈琴o既男生有一種好獨特o既吸引力~
RUclips听了那么多听海，这个伴奏的和弦编曲是唯一比原曲编曲还好听的，Phoebus真的非常强
明明就是鋼琴是主...那時候gemgem都無未有人識...
只能說未出道的G.E.M.唱live 已經比好多今天所謂的香港天后還好
真的是邓紫棋哦！
GEM sings very well !!!
shes has a ton of potential being so young and singing like this. and the piano guy is crazy good!
so many comments about the show
i agree both of you
GEM got a good voice
her support is bravo
and the pianist Phoebus did a gd job！
Tan adorable ella, con sólo 16 o quizás 15 y una voz increíble, amo sus canciones, best singer from China for me
both of them r amazing!!!
G.E.M.加油ar!!!
gosh the piano's taking all the spotlight, he's playing like he's in a solo
Phoebus is awesome!!!!
不聽原版卻聽呢條片請比手指公
i love GEM!
唱得好好聽啊～
彈得又好正啊～
＾３＾
i love gem's outfit
I LOVE YOU GEM！ ！！！！！！！！！
it's becoz the recorder stand right next to the pianist! it's not the problem of the pianist coz i admire him very much. If the recorder stand next to the speaker, gem's voice wud b so much louder. function ur brain pls guys..
天呀
她這時候只有十六歲呀
都很好！
去phoebus既場當然phoebus係主角啦, 而且佢當時仲係靚妹, 有鬼人色
Phoebus加油
彈得很有氣勢,不錯
好喜歡鋼琴的演奏呀!!!
好勁呀 :)
i would love to play like that...
有唱geh弹geh一成已经好开心
呢個扮曬野嘅鋼琴主角 相信佢都世估唔到傍邊個小妺妹 十年後RUclips subscribers 比佢多出80幾萬 一個MV一年已經過億.......
講咩 佢依家都好成功喎 扮咩野 咁佢地紅嘅年期不同啊
the piano is closer to the recording mic. that's why it sounds louder than vocal
第一次覺得鋼琴成了主旋律，
而人聲卻成了伴奏.....
Wow ... the onw whos 彈琴ing is ... AMAZING O.O
紫棋就是最桻了
For much of the performance, it seems to be an exercise to see if the pianist could overpower the singer. To the singer's credit, she held her own. The comping, if that's what you can call it, was way too dynamic for this essentially melancholic piece.
I think they are 'jamming' & challenging each other...It's good..FOR FAR!!
it's just becoz the camera was film from the piano side...i think they are balance in the actual venue..
我記得好似系鋼琴王子既表演黎架，系鋼琴王子請左GEM做嘉賓
彈琴好突出~
4年前波a_a!!
部鋼琴近住部camera 所以琴聲比較大聲？
like the piano =) gem is just soso
談鋼琴的那個人好激動= =
這是我第一次那麼不喜歡看一個人談鋼琴！
勁
her name is G.E.M - search her songs on utube. then judge =)
2:39 有粒琴比Phoebus彈凹左@@
@519573 its probably because the camera is closer to the piano
不如G.E.M.自彈自唱仲好
accompanist seems like he is playing a prokofiev piano concerto :)
现场合作,第一次合作...男帅女美...没comment了咯
the piano make it too noisy
🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
你地唔知個show係彈先係主角
Phoebus 演奏
鋼琴王子好似唔想比GEM搶風頭 特登越彈越大聲-_-
不過可以話佢投入 唔知自己彈到咁大聲
同埋camera近鋼琴王子多d 收琴聲係大聲d嘅:3
画面差了点，音质还算不错
錄音嘅位置同器材問題吧...
GEM已經唱得不錯了~
??? This is in Mandarin right?
GEM! =]
um..was GEM mr.phoebus's student or something?
is this piano guy a pro? he seems like it
Phoebus真系好劲。。。
After watching more of his vids its certain he has only 1 playing style. Loud and busy...clam down man!
我覺得可能因為距離問題~
哈哈~~~你留錯言呀？Where did you go都叫做有句英文ge，聽海邊到有？
agreed with the previous comments. the pianist overplayed his part =/
The lady spoiled the whole piece. First time where the accompliment out performs the singer
但係GEM很多高音的尾音都唱到flat晒（譬如"還哭的聲音"嘅"音"字，所以她之後唱到類似地方時加咗裝飾音），真係要加啲油喇！
彈琴個野比電視訪問過.,,,
真係幾勁下...
我覺得係因為彈果個彈得太好喇
距離同聲浪問題
+上你地聽唔慣
彈琴果個發羊吊咁既能款
Fai Ar 👍👍👍
He was good, or supposed to be good, but....what we need is team work..
i cannot agree more. felt as though the pianist was fighting the vocals.
鋼琴同歌聲完全是兩樣獨立野,不如5要把歌聲,鋼琴就會好聽好多(5係話G.E.M.唱得5好聽,而係話佢地兩個好5夾)
no not at all, if compare avril with the other singer in U.S.A.,e.g. beyonce,christina, she's not really powerful but i like the song composed by her
首歌好正,,,,gem,,唱得好,,,,不過彈琴的更好!!!
個陣G.E.M味紅@3@
背後的努力xp
成功的女人背後一定有一個成功的男人-__-v
@glocklkjlkj
你言下之意姐係話你自己好pro啦@@
聽吓 3:01 , 唔pro就唔識執生...
點解gem個樣同依家爭甘多既
鋼琴家太過於show off自己了...差d出事蓋晒gem了...作為伴奏係要鋼琴就人...唔係人就鋼琴...大家唔好誤會lee個concept
12rico21 这段表演可以话gem係配角个pianist先係主角，我觉得唔问题，即系伴奏係焦点，而唔係個歌声。
12rico21 有甘好既琴技唔showoff蝦，mai好可惜? 歌手自己识执生，唔可以赖sai個伴奏师度。
完全同意！ 彈琴戈位阿生太用力啦。見到佢彈就辛苦。佢咁好力適宜打鼓多D！
the guys playing piano is much better
huh？ i dun get you =.=
gem唱英文歌仲好聽過佢唱中文歌
真係好勁牙phoebus chan 2個都+油
=0=而家係show off自己囉彈琴條友.
既然係伴奏.咁緊係要比唱歌條友show off自己啦...搶晒人條鏡.不如佢自己唱埋/佢一個彈琴表演算啦...
琴師好搶呀
唱得幾好...不過收音鋼琴好大聲~@@
唔係呢個問題...
佢大聲... 就係唔match...
係咁多...
music is sth about matching and combinations.
The pianist thought he was having his own piano concerto... totally overpowering the singer.. sorry GEM, you became the pianist's background music..
彈琴果位真係幾勁.....不過有d搶左個主題...
搞到gem 好似陪唱禁
re:歌手的聲音竟然被琴聲蓋過...=.="
你冇用腦緊係la..部piano本身有聲..錄o個個人o係部piano側邊..佢把聲要o係音響出....
仲有..商場音響好極有限..首歌係難唱...佢語氣部分唱得幾好...層次分得唔錯...唱得好好ga la...
Maybe the pianist is very skillful, but I think as an accompanist, he should match the feeling of the song.
In this case, I don't think the accompanist matches with the soloist much... and he is too rude to the piano...
就算主角係彈琴果個人,但係呢個表演係要兩個人合作,雖然佢彈得好聽,但同把歌聲完全唔夾, 所以結果出黎就係唔好聽.
鋼琴大概小聲點會更好吧
piano override singing?? he needs to learn the meaning of "accompaniment"....
我上臺表演果時都唱過《聽海》不過佢唱得好低！！我唔系幾中意佢咁唱！
you got that right! thats because she sings poorly.. so the piano music was there to cover up
其實phoebus 彈得無問題, 有問題的是編曲
寫信給宥嘉 今天心情是甚麼顏色 ~
個琴應該細聲d,啊G.E.M就得好辛苦！
M
麻麻地
the pianoist is trying to show off. gem's voice isn't powerful enough. the orginal version is better.
彈琴老, 彈咁大聲想點吖? do you know what's call (respect)?? you know this life show wasn't only just for you!!