Why is Kerala Falling Into an ECONOMIC crisis? Why did Supreme Court intervene? Explained in Detail
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 6 май 2024
- Join the Masterclass now using this link: bit.ly/personalfinancemasterc...
@onepercentclub12
VIDEO INTRODUCTION:
The state of Kerala is nearly Bankrupt!
The state that is known to be the most developed and literate state of India, the state that is called as the God’s own country, is now facing an economic crisis, just like Sri lanka!
As of last week, salaries of 3.5 lakh government employees are delayed, the one who got their salary are not able to withdraw the entire amount, social security schemes of 55 lakh people have been put on hold and now the state of kerala is asking the center to bail it out! And if you are wondering why politics and economics are important for you as a citizen, I need to tell you that, in our case study of 2022, we presented a case study from the RBI’s research which clearly alerted everyone about this problem!! And like I said in 2022, even today if you don't pay attention to your state’s finances, your state will be in the same condition as kerala!!
So if you want to be a sharp student of economics or a sensible citizen, you need to understand,
How did Kerela fall into an economic crisis?
In Spite of being so educated and development focused, why couldn't the leaders of kerala save the state from this crisis?
And most importantly, as citizens of India, what are the lessons we needs to learn from the fall of Kerala?
Our Best Indian Business Case Studies:
1. Asian paints - • How Asian Paints Built...
2. Amul - • How Amul beat its comp...
3. Haldiram - • How did Haldiram Build...
4. Lijjat Papad - • How 7 Mumbai-based wom...
✅Study Materials:
www.onmanorama.com/content/mm...
sansad.in/getFile/annex/262/A...
sansad.in/getFile/annex/262/A...
www.newindianexpress.com/stat...
theprint.in/economy/one-of-th...
prsindia.org/budgets/states
Think School is a Digital School that we all deserved, but never had
►►Check out Think School's Online courses: www.thethinkschool.com
(The 1% Club, Finance Community, Retire Early, Financial Freedom, Personal Finance, Stock Market, Financial Independence, FinancewithSharan)
#kerala #congress #bjp
#thinkschool #businesscasestudy #geopolitics
Join the Masterclass now using this link: bit.ly/personalfinancemasterclassTS
Make a analisis on West Bengal please.
Kerala Gets Only Rs. 21 GST Share from Centre out of Rs. 79-100. Most of those money goes to state like UP. BJP wants a fail govt there so they can grip there
@@Warrukbadikpapa not just up also the States of North East India.
@ThinkSchool the photo you used at 0:20 is that of Goa's capital, Panaji...its not Kerala brother!😊
@thinkSchool Do you have Guts And Analysis power to make video about how central is discriminating South india, in allocation of Funds, projects, etc?
Before elections can you make it😅!!
I challenge you LOL.
Come up video with full data, Facts, Graphs your Theories, your justification etc as well
😂
Bengal and Kerala - two of the most influential and cultural hubs of India completely ruined by lunatic communists
sad reality😢😢
Keep feel sad😂😂😂😂
😢😢 that's why we choose BJP 😊
Kerala is still the best state, economic crisis come and go.
@@hashone1251Best state where most of the population are packed to absolute religious monarchy which has 0 labour laws and works as cattle.
if you are educated doesn't mean you are knowledgeable person and, exactly same thing happened in Kerala,I see many Bihari he is uneducated ,but he is knowledgeable,skill, hardworking
As an entrepreneur from Kerala, I don't see any hope in this state, it's government and the majority of population who blindly elect corrupted politicians. People are responsible.
Satyam😢
U can go to Maharashtra, TN or Gujarat as they are better for business as business travels in air of Gujarat😂
Welcome to Maharashtra
Why Kerala keep voting Communist & Pinaray? I thought Keralites are educated.
@@mathaveuplands4395 There are so many fake narratives built by medias and left-jihadi eco systems. Like communism is the best ideology.. People believe it and keep on electing the worst leaders.
That is the basic lesson of SOCIALISM and COMMUNISM… poverty, dictatorship and tyranny. As a Bengali we already went through it.
True
agreed, as a malayali we are seeing this for last 60 years. Communists will never bring any development .they worship only poverty
Agree with it
and the bigger problem is that momta begum has convrted bengal to mini p0xtan wherein even Hindu processions are treated with pelting stones. Seriously that too after 1947, when p0xtan / bongaldesh got what they wanted 🤦♂
there is no country in the world that thrived on socialism and communism. Yet people don't have a brain to think whats good for them. Its capitalism that makes a country rich although it has its own flaws.
Iam from kerala and this is a eyr opener to everyone. Thank you Bhai ❤
now I feel that UP is more developed than kerala😂
@btsarmygirl8367 PLEASE SEARCH IN GOOGLE kerela is the best state .
I am from Kerala. The news sounds very genuine. 😢
It is BJP propaganda dude😂
Note: I hate both congress & BJP. I'm from Tamil Nadu. I support NTK(3rd largest)‼️
@@im1480 Yes everything is BJP propaganda when people can see. Stop taking people as fools. You are not only smart here
A recent Right to Information (RTI) response has unveiled that from 2016 to 2024, the Kerala government created 5,839 jobs with an investment of ₹1,520.69 crore in companies boasting a turnover of ₹5 crore, bihar is poor state he give 4 lakhs government jobs people
@@im1480 its not bjp papoganda simple data and history also tell that communism is failed concept
@@sreehari447 ok be in dream land
As a Keralite i can whole heartly confirm the infos. The lavish lifestyle of the government is a most cause. Really Fed up with the Kerala Government.
Just wait for our rise; the current development of Kerala plays no role for the BJP. Thus, we can confidently say we shall overcome. However, I have doubts regarding those who follow think school. If a state adopts a family planning policy leading to population control, does it become ineligible for GST contributions, unlike UP and Bihar?
@@maxverstapanfromkerala😅
if you are educated doesn't mean you are knowledgeable person and, exactly same thing happened in Kerala,I see many Bihari he is uneducated ,but he is knowledgeable,skill, hardworking
Why can’t you vote and change it?
I think the problem is they hate modi. Imo they should follow modi. He has made a legal way of corruption aka electoral bond
That was truly remarkable. As a Keralite, I can attest to the fact that the politicians in Kerala have largely failed to address the current crisis. While governmental change is inevitable, the consecutive terms under the Communist government have seen the state's condition deteriorate significantly, shifting from prosperity to adversity
Why did India going Bankrupt?
The answer is clear, without planning mismanagement of PM Office of Bjp they took 150 lakh Crores as loan, where did the money gone is unknown.
@@Ottomans2kwhen did India go Bankrupt?
now I feel that UP is more developed than kerala😂
@@Ottomans2kyour ottoman aka Turkey how is it going there 😂😂 70 percent inflation😂😂
@@Ottomans2kyou noob, when did India go bankrupt? Who took the loan from where? Don't come out if you are a noob dude.
No economic discipline. No development. A universal truth.
now I feel that UP is more developed than kerala😂
@@btsarmygirl8367 you are absolutely right. UP is under the, able leader sreeman YOGIJi.
Yea right , stop the bullcrap , more than half the population is uneducated and they get more leniency from the centre
Kerala receives only a paltry 25 paisa for every rupee of tax it contributes to the Union, Tamil Nadu's benefit is a mere 40 and Karnataka gets only 47 paisa. In comparison, Uttar Pradesh receives ₹1.79 for every rupee they contribute.south Indian peoples are the main reason for the development of up
Kerala people money using for development up
Give Respect to south india
@@btsarmygirl8367No literacy and no woman safety but you still call it developed. Economic crisis doesn't always conclude no development.😂
As a Malayalee, the political situation in the state is such that, if I have to start a business, my first choice would be Tamil Nadu, especially Coimbatore or nearby. I think all Malayalees will understand why.
So long as militant CITU is active in Kerala,no entrepreneur can survive in Kerala.
But you only do it in Karnataka 🤣
@@mysterious_billionaire absolutely true I see many malayalis doing business in Mysore , Bangalore and many other places. I wonder how easily they set up a business outside their state.
💯%
Bills collection from goons in kerala
Kerala’s MP and MLA pension should be stopped immediately
Kerala MLA's salary is one of the least when compared to any state
@@psgbuddaunko WhatsApp University see news atahay samjha karo 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@raj-bs2sy Thats what you do nah?? RSS Shakha Whatsapp University se degree mila aapko 😂😂😂
So what still stop it… that will help
@@ashwinikumar30 Help what.... BJP is a complete lies party... Both BJP and Congress has to be sent to Pakistan
Thanks for doing this !
Love from Kerala ❤
Hey hello I am Madhav from Telangana but boy 😂
@@14daysurl
simp alert
@sangeetha, Is this a support video?, I didn't watched this, but from the comments, I thought this is a propaganda video...
@@Nidheeshmtrwhat propoganda if truth speaks some replying propaganda 😂😂
Very smart way of explaining complex concepts in depth.
Quite engaging and comprehendable sessions :)
Only problem is that the details are partially correct.. BJP has been saying Kerala is like SOmalia and Sri Lanka and yet nothing happened. They forgot to mention that Kerala is not in the top 10 list of highest debt filled states and they forgot to mention about India's 2.5 lakhs crores debt.. Thats why we South India want a partition.. We dont want to pay the debts of the North..
Thanks for bringing this up man. A politician from Kerala said that CPM used to deliver food to patients who come to hospital when asked why there are less medical supplies 😂
Note : Her name is Chintha jerome
😂
pothichoore by chanthi jorome phd in vazhakula angane full parayu
Chintha jerome the poet🤪
The ചിന്ത ജെറോം 😂😂
Chinta ji😂😂😂😂
As a Keralite now settled and working in Mumbai, it became very easy to understand the stark differences. Here in Maharashtra I see massive push into infrastructure building and long term strategy, Kerala also needs to relook at the long term game and decide strategy, there was a statement that only Tourism and IT are major drivers for Kerala GDP. Might need to look into creation and expansion of other sectors to enhance revenue generation and minimize borrowings. For all this ,political will is crucial, Hope better sense prevails when we see 4th June LS results
For development you need to vote BJP.
Great u r in Maharashtra n acknowledges reality , Maharashtra is flag bearer of nationalism but some people over from kerala n bengal still showers hollow praises on 'failed kerala model' n yet calls themselves educated n try to spread wokish ideology in dis state which is predominantly martial hindus ,it riles up natives
Tourism, IT, lottery and beverages as well
When did you settle and work in Mumbai? You must have got transferred to Mumbai. Also Companies are leaving Maharashtra, Maharashtra isn't growing properly.
Other Southern states and UP and Gujarat are doing much much better than Maharashtra. Companies are leaving Maharashtra, Maharashtra isn't doing well.
As another Keralite, I am vouch for this. And this is a large cause for most of the youth to not even think of going back for holidays.
Then why keralites are still voting for this cancer do they want to make their state like north india learn something from karnataka where we give chance to every govt. and we are doing pretty well.
Kerala has the most educated people. But, no employability. People are ready only for white collar jobs. Every family is mininum middle class and have good Financial stability. Abroad population from Kerala is more. But, in the state, there is no space for business, enterprenuer ship and employment.
100% truth.
Proud Indian from kerala residing in London.
Here because of the “state” of my state .
Why didn't u go to Gujarat 😂
@@mithunraj9292 what ?
why taking Gujarat here
more Gujarti people live outside India
basically Gujarat is dominated by Gujaratis but along with Marwaris .. Paris and sindhis
@@mithunraj9292already 1.5 million malyalis are living in Gujarat😂
How much more u want to send
Gujarat has 6 million sindhis
2 million marwaris
1.5 million malyalis
1 million biharis and from UP
5 lakh marathis
And 5 lakh tamil, telugus 😂
But u will rarely find any Gujarati except for delhi, mumbai and Banglore because we mainly go to USA and Canada😂
My state is not dharmshala
Don't overflow it buddy😂
@@mithunraj9292 brooo!!! why do people(Keralians) come to Karnataka for education , healthcare , for jobs ? Anyways we welcome Keralian bothers😊
The state of your state is because citizens like yourself reap the benefits of your state expenditure, then leave the country and settle abroad and pay taxes there.
Excellent session
now I feel that UP is more developed than kerala😂
thanks a ton! you are brilliant and inspirational!! we need more people like you .. from a concerned malayali
As a Keralite and Think School subscriber, this video was what I was dreading for the past 2 years. I knew this was coming. If you're wondering why this is happening to Kerala despite high education, health, literacy, low income inequality, etc. then yes, the leftist governments have focused on educating everyone and providing basic services for all people. However, the're always anti-business. So we're a state where everyone gets educated but they can't get a job because there are no businesses. So the Keralite youth is forced to migrate to other states and countries. They pay their taxes over there. They spend their money there. So how can a state generate revenue where there are less businesses, most of their people work outside Kerala and pay taxes outside Kerala?
This was a very good point bro..
Same here, you were that alert after RBI announced the financial distress right
Bro ,when comparing with other states we have some disadvantages estblishing big businesses,30 percent of our land belongs to western ghats ,so we cannot efficiently use that ,and in rest part people live in congestion, the population density of Kerala is the highest among states,so the land availability is so less,and the average wage in Kerala is truly high,so Kerala is not a suitable place for many businesses.
@@Stoic2636should have established it like bengaluru. Only state with 4 intl airports
Then just talk about the Kerala Story, Federalism, and GST
I am from kerala , thanks for bringing truth up. Out politicians are trying to hide it.
Still next time give vote to communists party candidate 🤡🤡
@@jdjjdd620 yes will give votes to communist party rather than bjp
@@mathewpaulparacka3034This mentality really is going to take your state to the doom.
First there health care propogenda got exposed in 2021
And now their so called economic model
People still believe those propaganda index made by west 😂
@@mathewpaulparacka3034thuuuuiii
Hi! Great work guys. One feedback I would like to give is that whenever you are deep-diving into a segment which is a major hitter of your segment, can you just represent them with some vertical stacked graph and similarly when you are deep diving into that category more you can use another chart. The reason for this is because when I watch the case study in one-go, I loose context and have to go backwards to find why we are exploring this topic. Otherwise, phenomenal job!
Thanks for nice knowledgeable videos. Keep making more.
Thanks a **** lot for this video. I am a keralite and the communists have ruined my state, just like W. Bengal. Kerala should have been the crown jewel of India due to our high literacy and health indicators... Extremely wrong financial decisions have screwed our state. Imagine this, the idiot who made a strike against ISRO is the education minister now....
And I don't understand why the Supreme Court is intervening in this...this is directly against the Finance commission, FRBM act etc. Now every state will quote SC and ask for money even if they don't keep financial discipline.
For whom are you planning to vote in the general election?
True brother.
I am also a keralite and what you said is absolutely correct 💯
Very true and absolutely true
Actually, West Bengal was ignored by the Congress government, the communists fucked up the industries and now this government is the worst doing absolutely nothing but giving pennies to poor ass people. The only good thing the communists ever did was provide education.
SC isn’t intervening in any matter. It was Kerala Govt who went to SC against CG. And after listening all arguments, ball is in CG court. SC just told, not ordered them to consider for a bail* package for Kerala bcoz if any states fall, eventually it’s part of India who is falling, so it’s not good for either side. Let’s see how CG reacts.
If CG has already released a package, I don’t know about it.
I am from Kerala, the situation is here is very worse than anyone can imagine, despite this financial crisis, the state government does unwanted extravaganza for events like Keraleeyam, Nava Kerala Sadas, F2F etc... all events cost more than 200crores and this was done during the time when, poor old people were not given ₹1600 pension, salary to KSRTC, govt employees etc..., no basic products like rice, wheat etc in shops, the govt hospitals are yet to pay several crores to surgical distributors.
When common people like us question, they either threaten, beat or kill. A student by the name Siddharthan was killed in Pookode by the ruling party's student union, the CM is taking steps to protect his party members, in Kasaragod, a family couldn't take coconuts from their own land (ruling party members came and harrassed them), all vice chancellors in college/University are representatives of the ruling communist party and when governor questioned, the student organisation mentioned earlier attacked the governor.
Kerala is not at all a safe place, we feel threatened and helpless. All basic amenities like electricity, water also, rates have been increased drastically.
All this, the CM and the ruling party are facing allegations of looting from a company for minerals from the state. This is the CMRL exalogic case.
Proof of any of the above, ready to submit.
Meanwhile the left funded/left leaning malayalam medias will play it down or blame it on the Centre while analyzing, dissecting, disseminating and discussing even a Sanghis fart in UP for weeks.
You can vote for change in the upcoming election
Bro this is the state of West Bengal right now, it was worse in the communist days. The sad truth is that these politicians form a cartel in the system, from which they are very difficult to uproot from.
Proof of all of the above requested.. preferably from unbiased sources..
thats horrible to here...
Very well explained with some good examples 👏
Very well explained. Nice video. Keep up the good work.
my father was from kerala, but due to lack of jobs he came to bangalore and now we will vote for bjp
Good For you Man, To think that except Kerala All BJP states are with Zero Umployment!!
What a Silly and Foolish thought😅
@@propertiestelangana.realestateHe never said that though. Why are you so quick to jump on to the conclusion.
@@propertiestelangana.realestate i didnt said like that but i said kerala is really performing worst and still many people kerala is educated state, best state like taht
if you are educated doesn't mean you are knowledgeable person and, exactly same thing happened in Kerala,I see many Bihari he is uneducated ,but he is knowledgeable,skill, hardworking
My father is from kerala, he got job in kerala, so we won't vote for cow dung bjp
Kerala govt employees are getting 1-2 lakhs/month for doing nothing. Complete mismanagement of financials.
2 lakhs 🙄
An Assistant Engineer gets 50k
LDC gets 40K
1lakh maybe possible...
2 lakhs?
Tell me which post so i can study for that job 😅😂
if you are educated doesn't mean you are knowledgeable person and, exactly same thing happened in Kerala,I see many Bihari he is uneducated ,but he is knowledgeable,skill, hardworking
@@AchuthanKarnnan LDC 40k 😅😅 26.5k is basic pay ..
@@theempire3849 what does that have anything to do with what was asked here?
@@karthi8537 i was being generous 😅
Calculated the performance of my state also- HARYANA
1) Capital outlay as % of Net Expenditure = 12.4% (23-24 (Budgeted))
2) Committed Expenditure % of revenue receipts = 62.5% (2022-2023 (Revised))
= 57.59% (2023 - 2024 (Budgeted))
3) Interest % of Revenue receipts = 21.6% (2022-2023 (Revised))
= 19.47% (2023 - 2024 (Budgeted))
4) Revenue Deficit - 1.8% (2022-2023)
Fiscal Deficit - 3.3% (2022-2023)
Overall, the analysis indicates a mixed fiscal performance for Haryana. While there are improvements in certain areas, such as reduced interest payments relative to revenue and a slightly lower committed expenditure percentage, challenges remain, particularly in managing deficits and increasing capital expenditure to spur growth and development.
It is doing moderately well compared to other states, but the unemployment rate is still very high.
What are your views?
Why there is unemployment?
Can everyone get a govt job?
Is govt is to govern or do business?
How govt gets the money?
-TAX
How people gets money?
Any kind of job and business
Who created job opportunity?
- company that needs talent for their company to make a product or service
What govt can do to increase employment?
- nothing, because they are running because of us the people,
Then why the hell govt tell they will increase employment opportunity in their election manifesto?
- govt can make some subsidy, tax reduction, favourable conditions, infrastructure to make it attractive for companies and business to run in their state. Which indirectly increase the employment opportunities.
So the govt is lie to us ?
-No they not untill they are building infrastructures and many exceptions and other things that will make your state look attractive for business to cherish with much profit for the business,
If your govt not doing anything like that then yeah then those guys are telling lie😂 if they do all these sort of things then they are really caring about it atleast according to their manifesto
Then why still we have unemployment ?
- because of us the people. We are the main problem for all our unemployment. Why we all asking for job rather than facilities to start a business? Why you not start a business and give job for 10 people? Why all shouting for job but not for a corridor for business development? Why people scold all business men and telling govt doing everything favourable for them while that favorable is going to give 1000 of job openings? Why you don't have the mentality to start a business? Why we all Indians are thinking like slaves to do the job for other people while not ready to take a risk to start a business? Why we all are still being in the mindset that British development in our ancestors that getting a job is safe rather than doing a business while you always in a unsafe situation that you can be fired from the job 😂 where the safety comes from? We Indians mainly southern part of India is more and more in trade and attracted traders from Greece to China and controlled 23 to 45 percent of world trade under the trade route by using southern part of India as a trading ground for the world but why now all of us afraid of business now while our ancestors are kings in international trade? Why we people want Saturday and Sunday holiday and 9 to 5 job and rest of time see social media or other entertainment and waste our time? This mentality is the thing that keeps most of the people out of thinking of doing business. Etc etc there is a lot to tell I better stop with this my fingers hurt 😂.
Why people say they don't get loan from banks they always gives to the rich business man and decline our request?
- because they didn't try properly. Bank only provide funds to successfully running business that need to scale the business because they don't want to risk the money because at the end of the day the money the bank has is also belongs to people like us, so bank are responsible to give it to the winning horse rather than rookie horse which has potential. But in some case if the product are service is good and the way you pitched your idea properly with prototype you may lucky that a manager of a bank would take risk and approve for you. But the best option is crowd fund people forgot that how good was joint families are. In those days a family would consist of three generations in one house so collect fund is little easy, but today scenario you may ask financial help from all your close relatives or if you tell you don't like none because all those relatives are wanting to see you fail😂 them the best and the proper thing first to do is to find a investor or seed funder.
Then what did the govt is doing for youngsters like me to start a business?
- I can't comment on you state govt because I don't know what type of schemes they have but central govt have some schemes and a platform to you to find some investors and business guides and seed funders. Also don't forget the MSME you can register in it and even there are some schemes in it for new comers that helps to get loan fast from bank etc etc there is lot of options but the problem with us people is we never tried so we never know all the opportunities 😅 rather than going to a bank and bluntly asking for a loan to start a business that's it 😂. But some lucky bastards even got funds like that too but that's not the proper way.
If that's the case why govt can't build these type of infrastructure for us and educate us about this?
-😂 the truth is we and our mentality is the reason😢 when a govt build a business corridor the first common man comment is " this is not a needed thing we need govt hospital school ration etc etc most villages in India don't have toilets many people don't have house etc etc why govt always favourable to the business man and making many infrastructure for them but don't care about common people like us who asked for building like this we need the govt to spend money on us and stop being supporting only business and corporate and we think you people getting money from the corporate so that you are making all things for them and neglected us, who the hell asked for that building the govt is a corporate slave, next time come here asking for vote we will beat you and through you out" 😂 this be the words comes from them and what the opposite party do is add more petrol to that burning fire boom 💥 the govt will start giving freebies and many things to please us 😂.
So what are you exactly try to say?
- stop acting like victims and come out of this victim mentality. Being unemployed is our fault, there is job from loading a truck to being ceo of a company, we all try to get a specific job Where 90 % of the competition is there so most will not get it some will get a job but not a value to money to the work done because the demand is high so the companies not depend on us.
I am not saying you guys to get a janitor job because less competition I am saying if you are a engineer create a floor cleaning machine and sell to big companies both job is same but the way you do is different also in that way you create another 50 jobs for others now you became a job giver rather than complain about unemployment.
This is the difference the difference begins with us within us. If we not change no matter how many govt comes this unemployment story you will even here when you are at your 100 years age too.
Stop complaining govt for unemployment complain about no facility for you guys to start business and cherish and make 1000 jobs opening
You may think it is good to talk in world but in reality it's different yeah I agree but rather than spending 4 hours in social media better use those 4 hours plus take loan of 2 hours from your sleep you get 6 hours of productive time that you can spend either learning a skill are doing freelance are anything it's upto you.
Bro... For spending for state matters State Government have their own budget. Here state highways, Daily needs for people are stocked with Kerala own fund. For the 1 rs tax we pay for central we are getting back only around 15ps. Whereas for Bihar and UP they're getting more than 1 they spend. Not supplying fund for cash crops, FCI and many more central is blocking. Here for central projects state is bearing 40:60 cost. You say which state will bear for any central projects.
We're getting back around 60ps
As a Keralite, I must express my dismay. The people of Kerala deserve better. They trusted the LDF and now they're suffering. Not a single educated minister in this supposedly educated state! Corruption pervades every corner, and the state government shamelessly claims credit for the central government's initiatives. Even the Chief Minister's daughter is embroiled in controversy, which is why when the PM visits Kerala, he panders to them. If news breaks that the Kerala CM has been arrested, it wouldn't shock anyone; after all, he's been involved in shady dealings like the Lavalin case. The ruling party manipulates the youth, turning them against Congress and BJP. Let's not forget, this party has even protested against computers and manufacturing facilities, turning Kerala into a mere consumer state with exorbitant taxes.
Exactly. The stupidest one became the educational minister. And Higher educational minister is another joke!
Most people cast their votes based on inherited beliefs rather than considering the future or understanding reality.
True
The current education minister can't even read numbers 😂
Just watch how our ministers speak in English. At least watch our education minister. he cant even read a four digit number. then you people can understand the reality. Literacy rate is not the tool to identify the knowledge of a particular state. It just indicates how many people of the state know to read and write.
Comrades from Kerala are gonna bombard this comment section with their literacy skills..😢
No worries most of their English PhD holders don't speak English 😂
@@mallu_boy123😂😂
What the hell are you going to with High literacy when there aren't employment opportunities and youth are compelled to leave the state?
@@fairviewib The comment is a sarcastic one my guy
@@fairviewib very true .
Excellent clarifications. All states and their ministers, and decision makers need to see this video
Thank you for pointing out that there are no financial irregularities in any part of the country outside of Kerala and Tamil Nadu. We just suck at our finances unlike the rest of the country right? What an enlightening 17 odd minutes everyone gets, thanks to you sir !
By understanding your comment, I think that ye forgot to understand the fact that If you make a Video on a crises, you talk about the core reason and it's effect within the state, it's so freakin hilarious that ye here still blaming him, get some lifers
Without even freebies they went bankrupt, I am worryed abt Karnataka now
Me too bro ! Even if it's a divisible pool of taxes also been heavily affected
😂
Andhnamazis nhi manenge lekin bhai 😂
half of kerala government revenue goes to pay high pension 1600( kerala gov)+400( panchayath )+200( central gov)
And too much government employees are recruiting by psc and they had high salaries when compared to other states..
The subsidized electricity, paying salaried of aided school teaches are another expenses...
I don't think Karnataka spends that much on freebies
Karnataka was damned the day Congress won the elections. Telangana is next in line as well. 2 financially well off states now turning into disasters
I'm a Keralite, from Alappuzha 🙌🏻
Even if this state is gonna go bankrupt, if we ask to people, still many of them will say, "it's okay but we will not allow BJP here"
Can you imagine how the malayalis are brainwashed...we can't even understand the consequences of bankruptcy and rather focusing on proudly saying we don't allow BJP
I always say to many of my friends that literacy, education & commonsense are entirely different concepts
If govt conduct a study of all those 3, Kerala will win only in literacy rate.
Coz, if you know 'how to read & write your own name', that's the only criteria for the literary 🤦🏻♀️
Almost similar situation here too in Tamilnadu, but atleast we have Annamalai here and we are expecting atleast 2 MP seats from BJP
As if u read what did BJP did In the states they heading
Hi I am from Rajasthan and even though our state has 78 percentage literacy rate. We give chance to every party to see if they contribute to the development of state . Usually it's about creating jobs and infrastructure.
gujarat and uttarpradesh are 2 good examples of BJP's policies
people feel proud supporting congress but forget their caste polarisation tactik.
@@sughanthan157 yes bro, we don't even have a strong leadership like Annamalai here
But the mentality of people towards BJP has changed a lot here in Kerala too during recent times
I hope it'll reflect in this upcoming election
It's an open secret .Everyone knows and yet still voted for the same ideological govt in Kerala.
🤡🤡🤡 still better than most of the states in india. Go and see the judgement from supreme court how union government is holding the fund money from kerala
@@astlinj I bet you haven't even read the judgment, but have taken info from the commie funded malayalam news channels 😂😂
Yes. And people still voted for the same corrupted government.
@@thereisnospoon123❤
Yes one should vote based on ideology only when basic things are done like western developed countries doing now but now in India no state is at that level but we are busy in ideology battle.
Bro the video was really informative. Just a suggestion that it would be really nice if u could just tell all the causes that led to the situation at the last, just point by point.
That's a very informative and deep research and presented on a very simple manner.
Imagine you're earning 1 lakh per month, you end up spending all of it, also you borrow 3000 from your friends and you end up spending that as well and you do it every month. This is what this state has been doing.
These huge institutions have lost a basic sense of economics.
🙋🏻♂️ഞാൻ കേരളത്തിൽ.. അല്ല, അൽ ഖേരളത്തിൽ നിന്നും ഉള്ള ഒരാൾ ആണ്.
ഞാൻ പറയും 2✌️ കാരണങ്ങൾ ആണ് ഈ നല്ല നാട് നശിക്കാൻ ഉള്ള "അൽ കാരണം"..!😅
🙋🏻♂️
1. കമ്മ്യൂണിസ്റ്റ് രാജ്യവിരുദ്ധർ - മനുഷ്യവിരുദ്ധ ദ്രോഹികൾ ആയ ജിഹാദികളുമായി സഖ്യം ചേർന്ന് ഖജനാവ് കൊള്ളയടിക്കുന്നു.. സകലത്തിലും കള്ളം.. എന്തിലും ഏതിലും അഴിമതി..😓
This presentation is the best that I have watched over a long period of time.
It''s more like you earn 1 lakh , your mom takes away 50000 and gives you like 10000 back. And also on top of that you have to pay rent. And then one day she halfs the money given to you and then tellls you your rent has doubled.
@@greenrico10 but same mom makes roads, gives pensions, rations etc, if all tax given to state they would have still gone bankrupt
The worst thing is, for upcoming elections the KARNATAKA govt might launch a new freebie scheme of 1,00,000 to every house.
#freebus
#freeelectricity
#2kforwomens
#3kforunemployedyouths
And now 100000 to households.
You should make a video on freebies scams like these pelase💔.
Yeahh true.. but they won't be able to do that because they don't have money to even fix road.
yes .. freebie is the biggest scam...this is not a scheme anymore.. it has turned into vote bank politics.
That is bad, money to be invested in capital expenditure is getting wasted in unwanted revenue expenditure.
Capex matters a lot unfortunately current government has become disastrous
We as youth should raise our voices against freebies
I was here since u had around 50k subs. If i remember correctly. Im totally glad to see the channel grow. Giving better contents. All the best in your future endeavours
i am overwhealmed by your research work and how you use easy examples to make a topic understand . i request you to make a video on the economics of west bengal . thanks in advance
Communist policies worldwide have failed, just need a political party along with political can solve current crisis... excellent analysis ❤
Bro, isn't China a communist nation, I am not defending communism and definitely democracy is very good but your statement is wrong.
Bro china sold their future for their present
their one child policy mean they dont have unvle aunties mama, nephew cousin, bhabhi
Whole family tree is just one single node. Now they are failing horribly
Whereas west just orint unlimited dollar funds teoeeism war drugs human rights cia etc@@Ronit_9977
@@Ronit_9977 CCP is even more capitalist than the BJP.
@@Ronit_9977 Nope, China is only communist in its political ideology they are capitalist in economic terms they opened their economy and liberalised it just after the death of mao ze dong infact India was more socialist than China until you finally got your ass kicked by WB and IMF and libralised your economy in 1990s.
@@Ronit_9977not fully communist buddy...
Im from Kerala. Like you said government is spending the money in wrong direction. They are starting many initiatives despit having financial crunch like Kphone,Krail,Krice etc. They are just starting the projects and dropping it in the middle. This is frequently happening in Kerala
No industries and business in kerala
Then how state get revenue.
The kerala businesses are shifting to tamilnadu
So tamilnadu was a industrial state
Government is building kphone ,krice and krail from borrowings and it's gonna back fire only private industries can save india now which is mostly oppressed in communists rule like kerala kerala communists are not like Chinese communists Chinese are communo-Capitalist
Excellent Work - Outstanding script and presentation - Pls do more videos
I am from Kottayam ,Kerala. The only district in India having zero poverty and the first to achieve 100% literacy in India and home of many highly educated people. But there is hardly any youngsters remaining here.Most went outside or are in other states .I am also going to UK this year soon God-willing .
Bihar of South
Is this a good thing? What will you do of literacy when your just labour in middle East
@@Chanakya2 what? That's only a poor section of mallus.And gulf bloom almost ended for mallus .Nowadays most migrate and work in developed countries. I have a lot of friends and relatives in Australia,UK and US with some in other western countries
Unfortunately am also a keralite and suffering because of the nonsense utopian rule of our 'so called' govt. Thanks to think school for choosing this crises as it gives more insights as well.
If all says Kerala is this and that
But reality is half of keralaites live outside kerala
Here says unemployment is high in kerala
And another is no industries are there in Kerala
The kerala industries going to tamilnadu
And 3rd one British given lands to missionaries so Christian missionaries are got lakshs of crores these using for conversion
Where communism ideology and communist govt then there is no industries
Example kerala, West Bengal,bihar and tripura etc...
Unfortunately you haven't watched the video , did you understand the real reason for Kerala get less funds
The perfect content. Proudly a keralite residing in neighbouring state.
We relocating to Europe and other western countries for more standard of living 😮
Im in Bangalore😂 being a Mallu
America: In God we trust
Kerala: In Gulf we trust
@@BijuJacobmangaly Then why not come back to India and help Kerala?
@@BijuJacobmangaly sir, you have money, we are the poor😢.
It's unfortunate that such a geographically blessed state with hard-working and talented educated people is mismanaged by lunatic government. 😑😑
Very well explained and informative video without any bias. This is high time for people of Kerala to think about this issue for their present and future. Industry and entrepreneurship is something which generates huge amount of jobs for people along with govt jobs. Besides that industrialists also pay taxes to govt resulting surge in govt revenue. Throw out such incompetent corrupt govt which is anti entrepreneurship & business. Being from West Bengal we know very much about their political agenda. In name of socialism and rights of poor etc. they only want to hold on the power by doing political violence. They are not only anti to industrial development but culture and philosophy of Bharat. Even the interest of country isn't the priority for them but their ideology is. Love from WB. Jai Hind!
Sad but true, as a Malayalee I have atmost grudge against Communist for their actions which made us plummet to this situation. Unfortunately they played minority politics and staying in power 😡😡😡
Bengal will eventually use hindutva to defeat communism and mamata, but demograohic change in kerela will stoo hindutva dharmic economic model so kerela is gone case
watch exmuslimsahil to know truth about islam with proof from quran and hadis.
Kerala is a gone case? Seriously
Just because we are having financial crisis doesn't mean that it's the end
Have you been to kerala?
It is one of the most religious states and it's peaceful to its roots. Never spread your venom because it's a very dangerous thing
I think Ganeshprasad Sridharan has some hidden agenda here; he's just trying to create 'Kerala Story Part 2' for intellectuals. Just as in Part 1, it was based on fake numbers, this story is too.
There are many states in India that have more debt as a percentage of their state GDP, but none of them are being arm-twisted by the central government by not helping them out in this crisis.
It's just the central government trying to get back at the Kerala state for not voting them into power. If the state funds dry out, the people who will not receive salaries will be in distress, and in that distress, they will lash out at their state government. Then the BJP might have a chance to get voted in.
*He doesn't explain all these hidden agendas from the central government, like why is the central government helping those states that have more debt as a percentage of their state GDP than Kerala, just because they have a ruling government in their?*
He is just another guy who appears to be neutral but subtly pushes the big brother's agenda forward. No one is neutral now, especially when the elections are just around the corner.
Delhi also has a lot of free services but instead of bankruptcy, Delhi is one of the few states to get a fiscal surplus that is we are a profitable state. Do not cloud your vision, BJP tried to the same in our state but AAP govt proved to be right, and now they are doing everything in power to destroy Delhi govt. This is a problem in Delhi because a lot of central agencies are in the hands of BJP. Remember, kerela's contribution to GDP is very high yet they get very less of the share, same like Delhi. But states like UP and Bihar they get a lot of share of GDP but contribute very less.
നന്ദി ഉണ്ട് മിഷ്ടർ പിണറായി വിജയൻ വളരെ അധികം നന്ദി ഉണ്ട് 👏🤝
Still u will not vote for BJP and will say us as sanghis😂 good keep it up😂
We would love to see Kerala becoming next WB
We won't. If things go south we'll vote UDF. They are enterprise-friendly and better.@@infinix2005
No bro never. I am a bjp supporter too they call us sanghi so that we start hating their whole state and they can continue their divode and rule @@infinix2005
@@infinix2005yea we'll vote bjp and turn it into another uttar Pradesh 😂😂😂 no thanks bye bye bjp isnt getting a single seat here piss off
@@Chess845 woah what an illiterate guy
UP before BJP - 150 billion usd
Up after BJP - 328 billion usd
😂😂 gdp per capita got doubled
UP was destroyed by parties of INDI alliance now see development of UP under BJP 😂😂 in 10 years UP's gdp will be more than a trillion dollar and in 15 years it will have higher gdp per capita than Kerala😂😂
What did u expect that BJP will make UP Switzerland in 8 years?
Development happens slowly and BJP is doing far better in UP than Kerala government😂😂
Why u don't have balls to compare Kerala with Gujarat where BJP ruled for 29 years 😂😂 because u know your state is nothing in front of West Indian states like Maharashtra, Gujarat, goa and all are BJP states🤣😂😂
Mind blowing content 🙌
Extraordinary Work !!
As a maharashtrian I feel very happy that my state has one of the best economic indicators and also has relatively good social indicators... Certainly thanks to our leaders for this...
Tell this in r/Mumbai sub as they seem to love Penguin and his father.
@@kumarrahul1982 i am not just talking of the current leaders brother... Our state's fiscal policy has been handled well for decades and thus it is in good shape...
True it is very hard to screw up an economy like Maharashtra
It is very hard to screw up an economy like Bengal too, look decades of communism & still 6th largest economy and tax payer
In governance , our state is worst.
GUJARAT is doing better than Maharashtra
As a Mallu I've been quite frustrated about Kerala's economy. There's no point in wearing the "welfare state" crown if you're broke. This is the kick in the backside that Kerala needs. I hope at least now they focus on policies that improves its economy.
Its you Mallu's who has elected communist and congress government. Elect your leader wisely
Bro don't be sab the time changes elect someone who can deal with it. Love from north 💕💕
@@chandanrandive6951BJP is far right to the political spectrum and there are no centrist party in Kerala so we elect communistvand Congress government alternatively. The day BJP become centre to centre slightly right approach we will elect a BJP Government
@@NerdCentral_ lol by then kerala would be in a civil war like financial condition, even BJP will loose interest in your state😂
@@breakmemer4387 BJP crushing nonbjp states with not giving enough share in GDP and jail the opposition leaders freezing opposition account. Being nationalistic is good but being a dumb bhakth is not
Great video thanks for the information 👍
Wonderfully explained ❤
U missed a very important thing here. Kerala goverment appoints private secretaries to the tune of 15-20 party cadres per minister at a salary&perks of Rs.1.5-2L per secretary and they will get life time pension after they come out. Funny part is every 2 years these secretaries will be replaced so that more cadres get life time pension!!!
Rightly said. You nailed it... Pinaryi is living his life as though there is no tomorrow and the making the future generations suffer.... How pathethic. No long term focus and planning.....
This pension for PA of ministers Should be challenged in SC and abrogated.
Tommorow Karnataka will come to same conditions Due to Freebies .corruption and minority Appeasement God only save us
Commeted on this once in instagram and got harrassed by illiterate commies who started calling me an andhbhakth .
😂😂And they call themselves most literate .
@@manognyak6474 We don't call ourselves literate. The Census report does. No matter wherever you go , you will find people filled with hate. You can't judge an entire state based on them.
Sorry on behalf of those commies.
@@manognyak6474 Irony is that I am from Kerala too
@@yadunandan4227 chettan situation 😢
They are brainwashed that blaming Bjp mindlessly make them educated 😅.
"" We are educateddd saaarrr !!! ""
Heyy Thinkschool, it woukd be better ifnu could make a video on from where we could obtain all these sources of information related to borrowing and fixed spending by each state and our country so that we could determine how our state or country is performing
Excellent Explanation
I am from Kerala and all that is covered in this video is 50% of the problem. The other 50% is corruption at its finest.
I hope the people of Kerala will one day start using their literate brain to actually understand what the Kerala government has accomplished with the money they have received and borrowed so far.
But your CM said in India today interview that corruption in Kerala is way less and going to eradicate it. I mean isn't the politics of kerala progressive or it's just a mask of false promises?
@@harsh_2562 by the end of his term there wont be anything left in the treasury. With an empty treasury there will not be any room for corruption. So you can believe our honourable CM
@@amalvijayan169😂😂😂
@harsh_2562 you said every truth yourself 😂 CM is the top of corruption and what do you expect him to tell lol
Corrupt politicians are there across the country, because you may not have lived in other states you may not know how corrupt other states are. I have lived in three states , MH (Pune), TN (Chennai) and Kerala (Calicut)- take my word for it, Kerala is the most livable state. KL is deprived of central funding coz opposite ideology govt sits in centre, which makes sure funding meant for states like KL is diverted to BJP ruled states. This happens even during calamities which KL has faced a lot. KL is suffering from a reservation like phenomenon wherein states doing well are sucked out and that funding is poured into poorly performing states (indirectly means corrupt and so highly inefficient).
Why do you think migrants are entering in KL in thousands everyday? It is indirectly coz per capita income (real) is higher in KL, compared to any other state in India. Looking at how natural resources are depleted in other states inclined to capitalism, you should be thankful that you still have clean air, water and soil - which most of Malyali's I believe take pride in and other state people are suffering from lack of it.
If you are educated doesn't mean you are a knowledgeable person, and exactly same thing happened to Kerala 😅
Bro i am from kerala. Kerala is high in literacy which means 100% people know hw to write and read their name and sign in documents. Thats it. It doesnt mean education. But comparatively keralite community gives very high importance to education. Unfortunately they were educated by lefistssss. and the political party and media prevents the malayali people from knowing whts happening all around the world and in neighboring states. The students get into political parties and influence the mindss early. so they do not think about the truth. they are fed with left propaganda and they believe it. The eco chambers in kerala media and social media is highly influenced by lefist narrative. Imagine a party whivh opposed the induction of Computers and debit card, this communist party literally protest against computers and debit cards. And now is in power. So....
I see many uneducated Bihari,but he knowledgeable, hardworking.
@@swaroopramesh3248💯
Bro there is difference between educated and literacy
😂😂😂😂
Very nicely explained. It does explain a lot as to the impact of financial indiscipline...
V nice video.Thanks for such a beautiful insights❤
😊
now I feel that UP is more developed than kerala😂
When teachers and professors are getting lakhs of rupees salaries for doing nothing, and most of our younger people's are leaving Kerala like no youth are staying in Kerala 😢
Y dont u become a teacher yourself if its so easy and stop complaining
So you want teachers to earn peanuts? people say education is important and then they say that teachers do nothing. I am not a teacher but a medical professional.
@@JMian professor's are doing 2hr job and getting lakhs of salary and a police officers work 12+ hr and getting 1/4 of teachers salary and you are telling it's fair , well it's not
Yes teachers have very high salary and do nothing .. Just read books ..in all states ..same problem
@@JMianEven the salaries of assistant professors are high in kerala compared to other states in India. The problem with this is that the government doesn't have enough money for paying this much salary. All this is for pleasing them to get their support. There was a delay in this month's salary for government employees. The government employees used to receive salary in the first day of every month but they didn't receive full amount Even after the 4th day of this month. There was a limit set on how much salary they will receive even on 4th day. The government lied about the cause saying this was a "technical" difficulty, the reality was that they didn't had enough money at that time.
Kerala is the only place where leaders are concerned more about gaza than gas price.
Because the centre government controls gas prices lmao
@@footballinshorts2711 How much is tax share for State and central govt ? LMAO
Humanity is.more.important..
..
Being a fellow malayali...does your heart not bear for Palestinians?
@@Udfortuneguitaristwe do
but For myself my Country is first priority
Geopolitically Israel is the country who are beneficiary for us in every manner
meanwhile Palestine is just taking free aids from Bharat
we are giving them that always
But Israel is first priority for Country purpose
for humanity we are helping Palestine for no reason
Understand this Gaza and Palestine is different
Gaza having terrorism and Palestine having innocent citizens
Very well articulated!!
I never visited kerela but really hope best for that state and their people... Blessings, hopes and love from Chhattisgarh
Kerala over the last 40 years have become the graveyard of entrepreneurs. Politicians and corrupt government employees looted every entrepreneur who did business in Kerala. Entrepreneurs are the only ones who pay taxes and create jobs. Today our youth do not have jobs in Kerala and hence go to every corner of the World searching for jobs. Political Parties in Kerala have this habit of giving party workers (majority criminals) Government jobs by creating Public Sector Undertakings or by creating unwanted Government jobs. This increased the salary outgo of the state. Today with very little tax revenue and very high salary the state is left with no other option but to borrow and blame the Government of India for their problems.
Make that 50.
I’ve started a business in Kerala. It’s been three years. There has been nothing but positive support from the govt machinery. Don’t spread this kind of false propaganda.
@@nitinandezhathsoman4379 Good luck to you, sir. Your experience doesn’t speak for the experience of hundreds of thousands of could-have-been business owners over the past four to five decades. We all know the culture and we all know the attitudes towards business. We all know about the bandh culture and we all know about the bureaucratic harassment.
The only evidence you need to debunk any notion of propaganda here is if you look at the size of the carrybags at airport departures (going out) versus those at arrivals.
Mr. Roshan pretty much hit the nail on the head with his description of events.
Roshan, Ernakulam district has industries, however, unfortunately no metro ciites in Kerala..
@@nitinandezhathsoman4379 you have started some tech based industry for sure or some consumer whole sale retail business.Mild or heavy manufacturing business is difficult to cherish in kerala.
I am a Malayalee born and brought up in Chennai. I visit my native place once in 2 or 3 years for a week's vacation. In that period there will be a Bandh. This Bandh is one of the reasons I believe that the state is doing poorly in Finance.
In the past 3-4 years there is hardly any bandh
Ndu tallanu bhaii😂😂😂
if you are educated doesn't mean you are knowledgeable person and, exactly same thing happened in Kerala,I see many Bihari he is uneducated ,but he is knowledgeable,skill, hardworking
True that
@@amalbvas5793Paranariyude Kunna irunu taangiko
I loved your video man!
You neglected to include a crucial point previously emphasized by Dr. Sashi Tharoor: Kerala fulfills 72% of its financial needs from its own state taxes and only receives 28% from central taxes. On the contrary, states like Bihar rely on central taxes for 77% of their financial requirements. To put it into perspective, for every 1 rupee contributed by Kerala, the state receives around 40 paisa back, while Uttar Pradesh receives approximately 1 rupee and 70 paisa in return.
The economic crisis has been primarily attributed to the reduction in funding by the central ministry. Kerala currently receives less than 25% of its state's financial requirement from central tax, yet it continues to make a significant contribution to the GDP, outperforming states receive a larger share of central tax funds.
The Kerala government has approached the Supreme Court not to request an increase in funding beyond the allocated amount, but to seek disbursement of the approved funds that have not been fully disbursed for the past few years.
Conclusion: 1) Kerala is not requesting additional funds or seeking a portion of others' share; rather, it is simply asking for the basic minimum from the Central Tax, not from anybody's family property!
2) Wow, how shocking that those from BJP-ruled states are experts at pointing fingers at Kerala for corruption while conveniently forgetting about their own party's massive stash of 9000+ crores in shady electoral bonds.
3) At least Kerala can take pride in the fact that the ruling party is not implicated in the electoral bond corruption.
4) At times, the Kerala government does not extend support to businesses, construction activities, and manufacturing facilities due to the vulnerable climate prevalent in the state. That's true!
Surprise, surprise! Godi media is back with another smear campaign against Kerala!🖕
TIME FOR INDI@N MEDIA TO CELEBRATE ANOTHER PROPAGANDA AGAINST KERALA!😂
1. Why did the supreme court not take that into consideration? Also, the demand before the court was never to give the money owed to Kerala, but to permit them to take more loan. Maybe you should advise the government to present a stronger case in court.
2. Electoral bonds - please go to court and get them to arrest all bjp bhakts.
3. Read point 2.
4. Cool commie! Calling out financial mismanagement is an attack by Godi media on your state and misinformation. Tell the same to Kerala government staff too.
🎉
There are many states like haryana, Maharashtra and Gujarat which receive way less than even Kerala. Kerala receives around 60 rupees for every 100 rupees it contributed(highest amount in south state of India) while haryana receive 15-20 rupees and Maharashtra even like 10 rupees. You can't put blame on others for your mismanagement of funds. Try to blame on your high spending without any major increase in tax revenue
Why you people always compare your state with UP-Bihar and immediately run away when compared with Gujarat , Maharastra ? 😂😂
😂😂😂you nailed it bro: I would like to add some more points:
1. Huge advertisement by government
2. High govt employees salary( kseb driver receives an amount of 1.4lakhs)
3. Unwanted programs like Navakerala sadas etc
4. Unfruitful foreign trips by officals( where as stallin bring 8000crore development in a single trip)
5.retired employees are placed at many of the posts with huge salary
6. Nearly 8000crores pending to contractors
7. Sudden increments of employees salary
8. Shut down of companies and don't allows entrepreneurs to flourish
9. Over interference of politics in each and every sectors
You know govt is trying to increase its income by increasing its tax from all sectors but still it's fails, our ration shops and supplyco outlets are empty due to debt to vendors who supplied. We are the high petrol charge payers even in the country
😂😂❤ even though we will look towards UP and others and say"WE Are No.1"😂😂😂
You nailed it
Apart from that the government is employing many personal staff for each Minister who will receive salary as well as pensions.
Add this as well.
Kerala gets less share of taxes from the central pool, than it contributes.
As per 14th finance commission kerala received 2.5% of the central pool of taxes.
In the 15th finance commission it was reduced to 1.9%
Meanwhile Chhattisgarh which has same population as kerala received 3% (as per 14th fc) and an increment of 3.5% (as per 15th fc).
Also, the central government does not count the extra budgetary borrowings via central government owned body corporates in its balance sheet, but expects kerala to count its extra budgetary borrowing via kiifbi, there by slashing the state's borrowing power.
That's exactly why the case is being fought for in supreme court.
Also, the kerala is the only state that pays hightst land acquisition costs for centrally funded projects like national highways. Maharashtra spends 0 on land acquisition.
The funds received in PMAY scheme from center is 0 since past 2 years. While for UP its well above 2k crores.
Also, kerala spends more %of its sgdp on healthcare and education, and pensions, than any other state in india.
This is exactly why supreme court insisted on seeing this as a unique issue and grant kerala a stimulus package.
Pls pin this comment
Are sure the drivers get 1.4 laks per month and not per year?
But Dr. Banerjee from IIM Dholakpur said gujarat model is inferior to kerala
Laugh at them
I think Ganeshprasad Sridharan has some hidden agenda here; he's just trying to create 'Kerala Story Part 2' for intellectuals. Just as in Part 1, it was based on fake numbers, this story is too.
There are many states in India that have more debt as a percentage of their state GDP, but none of them are being arm-twisted by the central government by not helping them out in this crisis.
It's just the central government trying to get back at the Kerala state for not voting them into power. If the state funds dry out, the people who will not receive salaries will be in distress, and in that distress, they will lash out at their state government. Then the BJP might have a chance to get voted in.
*He doesn't explain all these hidden agendas from the central government, like why is the central government helping those states that have more debt as a percentage of their state GDP than Kerala, just because they have a ruling government in their?*
He is just another guy who appears to be neutral but subtly pushes the big brother's agenda forward. No one is neutral now, especially when the elections are just around the corner.
Gujarat is far superior mainly because of the people's mindset over there. I'm from Andhra my state is probably even worse
Gujarat is the king because it's the economic power house of India
@@cracked8349I am sorry to say but u people vote for jagan
Andhra is literally becoming bihar of south
@@cracked8349 which caste you are hope not kamma
Iam from Andhra Pradesh.
Currently, Iam working in kochi.
Iam a IT fresher.
Here rates are too high .
I think 1kg apples 300rs.
I did ask them.What they are telling that We do imports from Tamilnadu. So rates are too high .
I don't know whether its correct or not. I don't know all these social subjects like Politics and Economics ,But what i know is imports are injurious to Economics.
Great info. Can we have a overview of all states in terms of there economics.
people cursing Northern states and comparing them to Kerala on the basis of factors like Literacy rate solely because they are mostly BJP ruled states but States like Gujarat, Maharashtra, Haryana, etc. are performing way better in economic & other parameters while highly contributing in taxes. Even so called "Bimaru" states like Uttar Pradesh is performing way better under Yogi's rule.
Yes bro specially western India maharastra goa n gujarat all bjp states
Dog's own country
@@tifteendon't abuse them, whatever they are facing because of their decisions but in the end they are our country men.
@@tifteenbro as a Gujarati and proud BJP voter
It's really disgusting to mock keralites just because they don't vote for BJP
Are u mad? It's their choice
Kerala is God's own country without any doubt because of it's nature and u should delete this comment
After all we are all indians not Gujaratis, marathis, hindi speaking belt and malyalis
@@tifteenu should visit kerala and kerala people ..and then comment here..
The problems in Kerala show us that while socialism sounds good in theory, it doesn't always work out perfectly in real life. It's like having a great idea for a game, but when you try to play it, you realize there are a lot of difficulties you didn't anticipate. So, even though we might like the idea of everyone being equal and taken care of, making it happen can be really hard.
Ofcourse socialism is the termite that will gradually swallow you .
Only capitalism persists
socialism has never worked......literally look at every socialist country
When theres no wealth creation through private enterprises, how will wealth get distributed 😂
A government doesn't create wealth. It just takes our wealth (taxes etc) and PRETENDS to spend it wisely.
UK’s a socialist country. So is Singapore and China
@@soar865 In name only.It is more of a capitalist country heavily controlled by the state..You thinking china a socialist country made me think you are not aware of the reality.
Well presented, without any political siding.
As a Malayali; as a Keralite- i deeply thank you for making this video and its efforts. Pray for us guys. Bagwaan hamey bachaye..Insha Allaah
bhagwan hume bachaye ... inshallah 💀
@@yourfriendlyneighborhoodguyleast secular keralite Hindu. It's only go for hindus by the way 😒
@@yourfriendlyneighborhoodguyso much secularism 😂
I’m from Kerala and Wow amazing piece of information.
this is godi media
"We don't need to take more loans if the RBI starts printing more money and giving it to us," stated a former finance minister (Dr. Thomas Isaac) during the previous Pinarayi Vijayan administration (five years). The irony is, Dr. Thomas Isaac is known as an economist.
😂😂value of rupee 📉📉📉
Wtf lmai
Even a non economic background person knows about inflation😂.
@@singularity3021yup bro 😢currently 1usd is crossed 85rupee
This is the same guy who did lot of research to save state and finally introduced KIFBI which takes foreign loans at 9 percent interest where earlier govt used to somehow get loans at 1 percent. This is the great economist reform of an idiot and his kammi party
Please share regarding Andhra like this....love ur analysis ❤
splendid.
kerala is an example of
literate vs educated.
jai hind
at 12:21 : even if allocation for 1971 census in 15th FC was made zero.. the total allocation is still the same when added as per table. 😊
I'm from kerala your research on this subject is on top notch and precisely explained everything thanks for bringing this matter outta here.. Condition of kerala is really getting deteriorating 😢
Answer simple, as I personally know from experience,😆😆backdoor appointment, mismanagement, 100% party appoint ment, corruption, trade unionism , shutting down businesses etc
I live in UP and I was not a supporter of BJP but after seeing Yogi Ji handling finances and development projects I am a all time voter of BJP atleast in Uttar Pradesh
Fact said bro ...
Meanwhile people from UP are going to Assam, Odisha, WB using fake domicile certificate just to appear in govt exams, lol ..... Crime rate and rap*** rate in UP is also increasing....
@@Gareeb1997 Okh 🤣
if you are educated doesn't mean you are knowledgeable person and, exactly same thing happened in Kerala,I see many Bihari he is uneducated ,but he is knowledgeable,skill, hardworking
@@theempire3849 Bihari people are vey hardworking thats why UP and Bihar youth consists of more than 40 %(estimate) of javaans in Indian Army
Very insightful analysis.
Nicely explained
As a keralite i would say he is the kim jong un of kerala...And there are idiots thinking he is a god or something...And youth already fled to uk, germany. This economic crisis may happen way before unless the money flowing from the gulf countries.
It's just a propoganda. Think school is funded by the central government to create a false narrative in all nonbjp states. His last podcast with Nithin Gadkari proves it
Antham Kammis will defend their leader and rot in poverty sadly... He will take a bus ride with all his ministers in another couple of years and they will be happy...
Never seen any keralite in UK in my entire life..I think Middle East is for keralites…
When u Talk truth about kerala, some extremist will make u feel bad and harm u.
Wait for Innova!!
Antha bhayam irikkattum
@@frustratedDocEnna da pana mudiyum unala keyboard warrior 😂😂
Bro Kerala Gets Only Rs. 21 GST Share from Centre out of Rs. 100 , this not going to tell this because ED CBI or income tax dept will for him
@candogen Nice Maharashtra gets 7 per 100.
It was a very informative video, please make a video on telangana also, because it has a very high off budget borrowings and unaccountable debts which common people may not know
We’ll explained case study ❤
If there is no foreign currency coming to kerala, from NRI’s, it will be one of the poorest states in India
"Think School" serves as a soft propaganda channel for the BJP. The messaging is so subtle that one might hardly realize the tailored, aspirational Indian narrative.
As an economy develops, there's more excitement about the state of effort by the country's youth.
However, it should also be noted that comparing Kerala to Tamil Nadu, Maharashtra, and Gujarat is like comparing apples to oranges.
To compare the total square kilometers with this level of human density and total it with highly educated people demarcated by high development and healthcare indices is no easy feat for any state. While this was easily achieved in Kerala over the last few decades.
Does the geography of Kerala support rapid industrialization like these central and western states? No. Besides, various groups and grassroots movements, more than communism, have strived to achieve that steady balance. This extends to minimum wage as well, with the bulk share of Kerala's offered minimum wage benefiting BIMARU and the Eastern states of India.
Think School has conveniently overshadowed the fact that Kerala incubates the maximum number of startups. These are all great feats considering what a small state is achieving. Added to this is the diaspora of Keralites who equally contribute to the developed world and in building the Neo-age metros of new India.
Of course, there were disproportionate spends, but this spendthrift behavior is and has always been a part and parcel of state governments in every other state.
It is an act of treachery that a small state that has powered the world has to be cornered and criticized by the rest of India or by the ruling dispensation because of their left lineage.
Soft Propaganda of Think School.
This is very evident in the way they have conveniently alienated Kerala and labeled its spending as spendthrift, while the essential part where the central government has scrutinized the spending and depleted the coffers is not detailed but conveniently brushed under the carpet as a government policy.
The walk of dictatorship is that soft mouthpieces help further the cause of ulterior motives rather than the hard right. And the ruling party and its vehicles know how to propagate it. It is sad that the state is betrayed by its own youth who are falling for covert politics and believing in new-age cult gurus who mask politics as business case studies. If this is not a reason for the global Indian to be dismayed by the country and move out, then what else is?
@@reel_mankond case kodukk
@@josephalex9660 cry maire
😢😢yeah you pointed out the hidden agenda..but economy is in bad shape now
@@reel_managrees that thinkschool is a pro BJP propaganda channel. Kerala can't have massive industries due to the ecological sensitivity in most parts and lack of land availability. But then we should focus on the service industry. We don't even have 5% of the software companies compared to the other south Indian states. Being a state who pioneered tech parks , it was a lost opportunity. As Margret Thatcher said "the issue with socialism is that they eventually run out of other people's money ".
I trace my maternal side to Palakkad and hence we frequent Kerala for temple visits. Commu nism has ruined Kerala. Absolutely no Industries and ZERO economic prospects and thays why the people migrate to other states and Middle east. Given an option, no malayali would leave his home. Kerala also receives the most amount of foreign remittance. But eh ' Enta naatil ellarum vidhyabhyasa ullavar aanu' 🫡
😂 Still you are OK with Centre s' concept that States with population control need to suffer
@@s9ka972 And thats the only reason why Kerala is in financial crisis, great joke .
@@naveenkumarjbyju7915 But it's also one Reason. Video presenter didn't stress on the subject .
@@naveenkumarjbyju7915 TN is the most industrialized state in India and the 2nd in the highest GSDP. You know what Union does, 2.5k crores as tax returns while UP recieves 25K crores, why are we getting punished for population control while the UP people seems to not care in population control. Answer this.
@@shaarumenan4454 you guys build those industries by looting the northern states via freight equilization act, but when it came your time to pay north Indians you are crying about your tax money.....
Hypocrisy at its peak
The situation Kerala is facing today is really difficult to handle. The pitfalls in tax collections could be rectified by an unbiased government. But, when it comes to business generation, it is not going to be easy. Huge scale development in infrastructure and manufacturing is not really feasible as the ecology in Kerala is sensitive and fragile. This was evident from the floods in 2018 and the successive years. Also, many cities like Bangalore and Hyderabad are facing the backlashes of poorly planned infrastructure developments today. In such a scenario, finding and developing areas which can generate revenue is a challenge and requires intelligent intervention. I still believe there is still scope for more income from tourism by providing safe food and accomodation facilities to tourists, and exploring the natural resources for tourism without harming the environment.