The saddest moment in history of Pakistan. People cannot even begin to understand the loss it was for Pakistan. Still I am extremely happy that Bade Ghulam Ali shb went to India because had he stayed in Pakistan he would have been forgotten and Pakistan would have wasted another big name to celebrate besuras like Aima Baig in the name of music. As a Pakistani I cannot thank India enough for giving the legend the respect and honor that Bade Ghulam Ali Khan shb deserved and preserved his legacy that a person like me can enjoy in Pakistan. All differences aside one cannot even begin to praise the way India treated Bade Ghulam Ali Khan shb that Gandhi g asked Bade Ghulam Ali Khan shb to perform before his speech and Pandit Nehru stood at the gate and waited because Bade Ghulam Ali shb had begun his music. Such respect by the likes of Gandhi g and Pandit Nehru and here a babu though to be above Bade Ghulam Ali g. What a tragedy for Pakistanis like me. But I am happy that an artist like Bade Ghulam Ali Khan g got the respect and recognition he deserved. Pakistan was fortunate to have the good artiste and connoisseurs in the beginning but soon lost their legacies to nepotism. We still had Ustad Salamat Ali Khan shb, Ustad Amanat Ali Khan g and Bade Fateh Ali Khan, Roshan Ara Begum g and many more but Pakistan continues to treat true art like shit and celebrate besuras all over. God protect us!
Bade Ghulam Ali Khan sahab Rehti duniya Tak Amar ho gye Unki tauheen karne walon ko rehti dunia Tak laanat barastii rahegi Baba e mausiqi Ustaad e mohtaram janaab Bade Ghulam Ali Khan ko Pranaam 🙏
I had read an interview with Ali Sardar Jafri in Outlook magazine back in 1997, on the occasion of India's 50th anniversary of Independence. Bade Ghulam Ali khan had migrated to Pakistan sometime after partition and was performing at a function. He started singing "Mohe chhedo na Nand laal" when he was rudely stopped by the organiser, Muhammad Ali ,who told him, "Kuchh 'Pakistani' music bajaiye!" To which Khan sahab responded, "Meri gardan na marodo Muhammad Ali!" and left the function. He later migrated to India and used to advise other Pakistani singers to do the same. I think it was Salaamat Ali Khan, my memory fails me, who was quoted in another article in the same issue, who said that Khan sahab told him, "Come to India. In Pakistan you will only find people who listen to Qawwali!"
I had read that during one concert he sang one composition hailing kanha that is lord Krishna. Someone objected n ustad ji decided to move to India. My pranaam to the great soul.
This story teller doesn't hav respect for the great Bapu called Mahatma Gandhi ji..he is saying Gandhi not even Gandhi ji .. whereas for gulam saheb giving full respect.... secondly he is comparing Tansen saheb with bade gulam...so 😭..
Urdu ke bahut sare alfaz samajh to nhi aye par suna end tak aur labboluab samajh aa gya ki mausiki ke bade fankaron ke ustad the marhoom bade Gulam ali sahab aur self respect se bhare huye.
respect to india and indians who helped khan sab to be free respected and revered in india. Pakistani govt has a big ego and highest degree of bigotry that they have always have degraded, abused and insulted their talented heros. Prof Abdussalam is another case in point.
@@RajeevSharma-bk2qg appreciated 👍 to indians and India Government they respect and given nationality to valuable person without race, if Hindues mentally accept Muslims along with their religious activities as others countries in the world, they live together with love getting marriage together not government involvement and getting civil rights/laws according to constitution the public is allowed to choose civil rights from court or religious law, if accept hindous India was not divide.
یہ سچ ہے کہ بڑے غلام علی خاں صاحب اور ان کی طرح بہت گلوکار اور بہت سے شاعر حضرات کی پاکستان کے لوگ کوئی خاص عزت نہیں کرتے قدر نہیں ہے اور جہاں بھارتی ان سب کی قدر کرنا جانتے ہیں
Today the eco system for learning and performing Hindustani classical music is very much alive in India. The eco system for Carnatic classical music is even stronger in South India. But it looks like there is no real environment for classical music in Pakistan. I am not aware of any worthy musical heirs to pre partition classically trained musicians like Salamat Ali Khan or Ghulam Ali
@@qureshi701 The ignorance you people possess ! The way you people hate your root is incomparable with Bangla Muslims ( they still practice their roots ) !
He left Pakistan because people in Pakistan do not know how to appreciate music. His preference to settle in India was Hyderabad Deccan, where he stayed with dignity and we loved him wholeheartedly.
Are dekhi zamaane ki yaari : Bichhde sabhi baari baari. Ud ja, ud ja pyaase bhawre : Rs n milega khaaro me, kaagaz ke phool jaha khilte hay, beyth n un gulzaro me...( Rafi ji. Film : kaagz ke phool )
When the great Italian opera musician and singer LUCIANO POVERATTI died the whole Italy fall into mourn for weeks and given him state funeral that was great loss for Italian people's and state . When the great singer of Argentina MERCEDES SOSA died her coffin kept in government state house and whole nation mourn Argentina declared state funeral When legend Mexican singer Juan Gabriel passed away the whole nation mourn. When Egyptian singer umme Kalsoum died the Egypt gave her state Funeral . But sadly in Pakistan when legend Noor Jean and Mehadi Hassan sb and Nusserat father Ali Khan sb died no one care about that great loss here people's don't respect the artist they degrade and called them مراثی they don't understand those artist are the face of any Nation and those who value them they never disrespect them but always feel proud they have such legends . Where we Pakistani stands here ??
Humry boht se log inahi ghtia harktain karty Han Jin ki wajha se boht se log zalil ho k mar khap gay or Jo chly gay unho na Dunia Mai nam kea per un k Dil pakistan Mai rahy afsos ki bat ha
No doubt Lahore was the capital of great India music , still now people of Lahore knows the Sur Sangeet , but unfortunately we have also narrow minded people, music doesn't have borders it freely flies like birds ,
Kia faraq parrta hay k aik ustaad chahay Pakistan main rahain yaa India main rahain... Ustaad Fateh Ali Khan Mubarak Ali Khan Pakistan main aanay k Baad bhi poori Dunia ka asasa maanay ga'ay.
Unka niwas Park Circus, Kolkata ka zikr nahi hua isa video me. Ustad ji, unke bete unke pote Kolkata ke shan bane aur bare bare gawaye ko gana sikhaya. Pandit Ajoy Chakraborty, Ustad munawar Ali khan ke hi shagrid rahe. Ustad Munawar Ali khan, khansab ke shahzade hai.
Aisa lagta hai jaise hamrey mulk ko badua hai k ham kabi b aisey achey logon ki qadar nai karsakey or onho ne osi waqt boht acha faisla Kia k wo izzat se yah yahan se chalegaye
I think we should accept this fact Pakistan got freedom on Islamic base theory and Ustad baray Ghulam Ali Khan sahab take right decision to india citizenship
The original philosophy behind partition was economy and not religious freedom.Muslims were economically much marginalised by the British due to various reasons.
Nai Nai aisa bilkul BHI Nahi classical music ki ap history utha Kar Dekh Lein bare auliya aur sufiya ko ap khawaja ameer khusro ki missal Dekh Lein unhon ne jitna is ziman mein kaam Kiya shayad hi kise ne Kiya ho mosseqi to wasile Allah hai Allah se wasl Karne Ka zariya hai Islam prohibit Nai karta isko Woh alag baat hai keh ap Iska kaise istimaal karte Han isse Ibadat samajh Kar karein to yeh aik Ibadat hai yahi mosseqi Naat ban jati yahi Hamd ban jaati yahi thumri ban jaati yahi dadraa ban jati yahi geet ban jaati iski Kai shaklein Han
My God!!! For me it is unthinkable that UBGAK - taaya ji for me - could have lived anywhere but in India. My father (who was a total devotee of classical mausiqii) and he were close friends, I grew up listening to his divine singing in person. Every word spoken in this video is correct. I can not imagine any one - even Taansen - being his equal. The greatest blessing in my life to have known, and heard him up close.
پاکستان میں ہر قابل اور احسان کرنے والے کو ہمیشہ زلیل و رسوا ہی کیا گیا ہے۔ شاید یہی وجہ ہے کہ ہماری قوم نے 70 سال میں کوئی بڑا نام پیدا نہیں کیا کیونکہ قوم دیکھ رہی ہے کہ یہاں ڈاکٹر عبدالقدیر خان صاحب جیسے سُچے ہیرے کو جس طرح رسوا کیا گیا اسکو دیکھ کر تو کبھی کوئی دوسرا پاکستانی سائنسدان بننے کا سوچے گا بھی نہیں۔
Self pity. Great people do not require to be praised and worshiped. They are born to do certain task without any fear or favour. Nation has respected DrAW Khan and will continue to do till end of this world.
In entire commentry only one Urdu word was mispronounced ie "udhed". It is actually "adhed". " ادھیڑ" کے الف پر زبر ہے. پیش نہیں. لیکن پوری کمنٹری بے حد دلچسپ اور مفید ہے اعر مرتبین مبارکباد کے مستحق ہیں
Thanks to Hindu majority India for understanding the value of Gems. Not just Pakistani muslims, even Indian Muslims if given a chance would behave the same way. Majority of muslims whether Indian or Pakistani , have become captive of falls notion of ISLAM which made them forgot their cultural & Historical root that is " SANATAN HINDU CIVILISATION & CULTURE". INDIA has always given fatherly treatment to Pakistan, but Pakistan failed to understand this.
انڈیا سے پاکستان ہجرت کرنے والے فنکاروں کو وہ عزت کبھی نہ ملی جو وہاں ملتی ۔۔۔ روشن آرا بیگم ۔ نورجہاں ، اقبال بانو۔ فریدہ خانم، مہدی حسن ،،ملکہ پکھراج ۔۔ یہاں پران فنکاروں کی صلاحیتوں سے مکمل استفادہ نہیں کیا گیا۔۔۔
وہ ماضی کے افسانے ہیں۔۔ آج پاکستان سے انڈیا جانے والے فنکاروں کیلئے وہاں ذلت ہے تمسخر ہے بیہودگی ہے۔۔ بھارت ایک متلون مزاج سوسائٹی ہے جہاں مذہبی انتہا پسندی پاکستان سے کچھ زیادہ ہی ہوگی کم نہیں۔۔
This is wrong. If it was true then how come Mehdi hasan Mehnaz Noorjehan and others opted to come to pakistan. The only thing was how better they would be paid. India was not only bigger but an established country. These singers felt they were better off there.
@@extraorchidinary6347 i don't think you've heard this video....watch again and listen this time..there were attempts by your so called leadership to islamize the classical music and to top it off the attitude of your bureaucracy towards your indigenous talent was despicable....anyone with self-esteem would've done done what he did.
I had read an interview with Ali Sardar Jafri in Outlook magazine back in 1997, on the occasion of India's 50th anniversary of Independence. Bade Ghulam Ali khan had migrated to Pakistan sometime after partition and was performing at a function. He started singing "Mohe chhedo na Nand laal" when he was rudely stopped by the organiser, Muhammad Ali ,who told him, "Kuchh 'Pakistani' music bajaiye!" To which Khan sahab responded, "Meri gardan na marodo Muhammad Ali!" and left the function. He later migrated to India and used to advise other Pakistani singers to do the same. I think it was Salaamat Ali Khan, my memory fails me, who was quoted in another article in the same issue, who said that Khan sahab told him, "Come to India. In Pakistan you will only find people who listen to Qawwali!"
ایک حالیہ انٹرویو کے مطابق تو استاد کے بھتیجے نے یہ کہا ہے کہ وہ سیّد ذوالفقار علی بخاری کی وجہ سے ہندوستان نہیں گئے تھے بلکہ اس فن کو مزید سیکھنا چاہتے تھے۔ زیڈ اے بخاری کے مطابق اس روز ان کے پروگرام کا سلاٹ ہی موجود نہیں تھا۔۔۔۔ ریڈیو پاکستان لاہور کا ایک اکلوتا اسٹودیو تھا نہ کہ ہالی وڈ کہ ایک ہی وقت میں متعدد ریکارڈنگ ہو رہی تھیں ویسے استاد چھوٹے غلام علی کو ہم نے جیسے آسمان پر بٹھا رکھا ہے
Fact of the matter is people like Badey Gulam Ali Khan & Sahir Ludhyanvi proved wiser lot vis a vis people like Sahadat Hasan Manto, if you know what I mean😁
میں استاد فتح علی خان پٹیالوی صاحب کے بطور سیکریٹری انٹرنیشنل ٹورز آرگنائز کر چکا ھوں۔اٹلی۔جرمنی۔اور انگلینڈ۔۔میوزک کی دنیا کی ڈکشنری تھے۔خان صاحب بھی بڑے مھا کلاکار تھے۔بے بھا راگوں پہ دسترس تھی۔
1:47 bulkul ghalat bhai jaan aisa nahi ke me khan sahab ki tohin kr raha hu but ye kehna galat hai ap kisi ko bhi tansen ji se zyada nahi bol sakte ek or bat ustad salamat ali khan sahab to phir bade khan saab se bohat zyada acha gate hain mafi le sath🙏🏻
There is no comparison. No one should do these silly comparisons when artists like them never did so. Ustad Salamat Khan shb himself said to his son Ustad Shafqat in reverence of Ustad Bade Ghulam Ali Khan shb: "Pointing at his head, Bade Ghulam Ali Khan yahan bethay huay hain" meaning he is above my head. This is in no way to say that there was a single artist of Ustad Salamat Ali Khan shb's stature.
Joash milabdi k sath bhi bura slook huwa raja sahab mehmoodabad wapus india chalay gay thay yea mojuda pakistan qaide azam wala pakistan nahi bulkay punjabeestan hay
Punjabeestan ho tab b theek hai but ye log to punjabi ko b hakarat ki nighahon se dekhtey hai Identity kho chuke jahil log hai inko naa to pta Urdu speaker naa inko pta local languages bolni Urdu khud UP ki language hai to socho jo language bhi apni khud ki nai boltey to wo hee hongey
Z A Bukhari the killer of legend of music he insulted the ustad baray Ghulam Ali sb,this the approach and thinking of our government officials they are still on same track, how the indian gave him respect and honour.
جس ملک میں فنکار کو عزت تو دور کی بات مرنے پر دفنانے دو درجن شہر کے لوگ شکرکت نہیں کرتے۔ ملک چھوڈنے کے سوا کیا چارا تھا۔ کہتے ہیں میڈم نورجہاں کے انتقال پر یہی صورت حال رہا۔ جب 65 کی جنگ جاری تھی اس دوران میڈم کے قومی ترانے گانے ہر ایک کے زبان پر تھا۔المعیہ دیکھیے۔
But Z A Bukhari is often considered to be one of the stalwarts who established radio broadcasting in this subcontinent even before India got divided. It is really shocking to know that Mr Bukhari could be so insensitive and obnoxious while dealing with a genius like Bade Khan sahab.
There are thousands or millions of people like you who have passed BA in this country but Bade Ghulam Ali is one. An utterance of incomparable worth.
An outstanding musician with a large heart. Hari Om Tatsat speaks for itself. A true class artiste who was a complete musician
Bhai listen to his adana in drut lay 'Lanka Charho Raam'. You'll be mind-blown
@@MK-yg7zf thank you sir. I enjoyed Adana very much
بھت ھی اعلی. معلومات ھے اور پاکستان کی تباھی کی وجوھات بھی سمجھ ا گئ ھیں.....
Bahut Khoob
Bohat behtar bat kahe
The saddest moment in history of Pakistan. People cannot even begin to understand the loss it was for Pakistan. Still I am extremely happy that Bade Ghulam Ali shb went to India because had he stayed in Pakistan he would have been forgotten and Pakistan would have wasted another big name to celebrate besuras like Aima Baig in the name of music. As a Pakistani I cannot thank India enough for giving the legend the respect and honor that Bade Ghulam Ali Khan shb deserved and preserved his legacy that a person like me can enjoy in Pakistan. All differences aside one cannot even begin to praise the way India treated Bade Ghulam Ali Khan shb that Gandhi g asked Bade Ghulam Ali Khan shb to perform before his speech and Pandit Nehru stood at the gate and waited because Bade Ghulam Ali shb had begun his music. Such respect by the likes of Gandhi g and Pandit Nehru and here a babu though to be above Bade Ghulam Ali g. What a tragedy for Pakistanis like me. But I am happy that an artist like Bade Ghulam Ali Khan g got the respect and recognition he deserved.
Pakistan was fortunate to have the good artiste and connoisseurs in the beginning but soon lost their legacies to nepotism. We still had Ustad Salamat Ali Khan shb, Ustad Amanat Ali Khan g and Bade Fateh Ali Khan, Roshan Ara Begum g and many more but Pakistan continues to treat true art like shit and celebrate besuras all over. God protect us!
Why Pakistan lose all the artists like Sahir and others.
Why you still had the great salamat & nazakat. I still thier rendition of sind bhairavi
Sadly, Roshanara Begum regreted her decision to move to Pakistan
I don't think Aima Baig is a bad singer.
@@silverline451 - ਨਹੀਂ ਵੀਰੇ ਸਾਹਿਰ ਸਾਹਿਬ ਤਾਂ ਲੁਧਿਆਣੇ ਦੇ ਜੰਮਪਲ ਤੇ ਪੜ੍ਹਾਈ ਵੀ ਇਥੇ ਹੀ ਕੀਤੀ ਸੀ। ਥੋੜੀ ਦੇਰ ਲਈ ਲਹੌਰ ਗਏ ਸਨ ਪਰ ਉਦੋਂ ਲਹੌਰ ਵੀ ਇੰਡੀਆ ਦਾ ਹੀ ਹਿੱਸਾ ਸੀ।
Bade Ghulam Ali Khan sahab Rehti duniya Tak Amar ho gye
Unki tauheen karne walon ko rehti dunia Tak laanat barastii rahegi
Baba e mausiqi Ustaad e mohtaram janaab Bade Ghulam Ali Khan ko Pranaam 🙏
I had read an interview with Ali Sardar Jafri in Outlook magazine back in 1997, on the occasion of India's 50th anniversary of Independence. Bade Ghulam Ali khan had migrated to Pakistan sometime after partition and was performing at a function. He started singing "Mohe chhedo na Nand laal" when he was rudely stopped by the organiser, Muhammad Ali ,who told him, "Kuchh 'Pakistani' music bajaiye!" To which Khan sahab responded, "Meri gardan na marodo Muhammad Ali!" and left the function. He later migrated to India and used to advise other Pakistani singers to do the same. I think it was Salaamat Ali Khan, my memory fails me, who was quoted in another article in the same issue, who said that Khan sahab told him, "Come to India. In Pakistan you will only find people who listen to Qawwali!"
I heard that he has been asked to replace the word "RAM" from the song "Yad Piya ki aye" or remove the word
I had read that during one concert he sang one composition hailing kanha that is lord Krishna. Someone objected n ustad ji decided to move to India. My pranaam to the great soul.
The Future generations will definitely Resurrect Bade Ghulam Ali Saab !! The man of Soil and Arts, not sold to politics or religious parasites.
P
P
P peer
P
L
इतनी अज़ीम मलूमातों से रु -ब -रु कराने के लिए आपका शुक्रिया सद शुक्रिया!
Have been waiting for that answer . Thanks . What a agonizing story.
जब तानसेन को तुमने सुना ही नहीं तो कैसे कह सकते हो कि बड़े गुलाम अली खां तानसेन से बेहतर थे
This story teller doesn't hav respect for the great Bapu called Mahatma Gandhi ji..he is saying Gandhi not even Gandhi ji .. whereas for gulam saheb giving full respect.... secondly he is comparing Tansen saheb with bade gulam...so 😭..
Wah
Zabardast research aur bilkul haq ba janib. 🙏👌👍
Urdu ke bahut sare alfaz samajh to nhi aye par suna end tak aur labboluab samajh aa gya ki mausiki ke bade fankaron ke ustad the marhoom bade Gulam ali sahab aur self respect se bhare huye.
Salute to Murtaza solongi respect to Legend classical singer Bare Gulami Ali and released his songs from Radio Pakistan for public.
respect to india and indians who helped khan sab to be free respected and revered in india. Pakistani govt has a big ego and highest degree of bigotry that they have always have degraded, abused and insulted their talented heros. Prof Abdussalam is another case in point.
@@RajeevSharma-bk2qg appreciated 👍 to indians and India Government they respect and given nationality to valuable person without race, if Hindues mentally accept Muslims along with their religious activities as others countries in the world, they live together with love getting marriage together not government involvement and getting civil rights/laws according to constitution the public is allowed to choose civil rights from court or religious law, if accept hindous India was not divide.
I had read that there was objection to him singing Hari Om Tatsat, so left Pakistan.
Urdu is extremely beautiful
Bahut umda zankari ke liye aapka shukriya-a Pakistan lover,Indian
Thank you, Solangi sir.
Thanks for Sharing 💕dear....!!!
👌👌👌👌👍👍👍
اردو زبان و موسیقی پورے برصغیر کی مشترکہ میراث ہے.. مرتضیٰ سولنگی صاحب کو کروڑوں سلام پیش کرتا ہوں.... آفتاب عالم خان بینکاک
Urdu mohabbat ki aavaz he
Classic of Classical
B.Gulam Ali Khan sb
L4all Salam Pakistan
❤❤ ❤❤ ❤❤ ❤
Assalamalekum n namaskar zanaab ustadji k barime bus dilkhush hogaya aise bade l9gonk barime aur b vlogs banaye ye gujarish thanks
Solangi sab is really a man if vision. I dont know why gems like him are so hidden for a long time and were not highlighted.
Masha Allah ustado ka Ustad Bade gulam Ali sahab Allah janntul firdosh ma ala mukam ata farmaye aameen
Un ustaado ko ❤ se laakhon Salaam, jin ke shaagird Ghulam Ali Khan hai
❤❤
یہ سچ ہے کہ بڑے غلام علی خاں صاحب اور ان کی طرح بہت گلوکار اور بہت سے شاعر حضرات کی پاکستان کے لوگ کوئی خاص عزت نہیں کرتے قدر نہیں ہے اور جہاں بھارتی ان سب کی قدر کرنا جانتے ہیں
Today the eco system for learning and performing Hindustani classical music is very much alive in India. The eco system for Carnatic classical music is even stronger in South India. But it looks like there is no real environment for classical music in Pakistan. I am not aware of any worthy musical heirs to pre partition classically trained musicians like Salamat Ali Khan or Ghulam Ali
I feel pity for your ignorance.
@@qureshi701 The ignorance you people possess ! The way you people hate your root is incomparable with Bangla Muslims ( they still practice their roots ) !
@@BJha-bc2li again it sounds more like a fart 💨💨💨, than a comment , again a little knowledge is dangerous.
@@qureshi701 A frog of well thinks there's no world outside same is happening with you ! Learn to accept truth .
@@BJha-bc2li yes, again you mouth fart sorry comment tells your knowledge. Keep watching Bollywood.
Very informative.
He left Pakistan because people in Pakistan do not know how to appreciate music. His preference to settle in India was Hyderabad Deccan, where he stayed with dignity and we loved him wholeheartedly.
Are dekhi zamaane ki yaari : Bichhde sabhi baari baari.
Ud ja, ud ja pyaase bhawre : Rs n milega khaaro me, kaagaz ke phool jaha khilte hay, beyth n un gulzaro me...( Rafi ji. Film : kaagz ke phool )
Bade Ghulam Ali Khan was the Ustad of Mohammed Rafi Sb and Ghulam Ali sb
He was not Rafi’s guru. If u have a reference to your claim, please provide
India is a great country. India has accomodated all section of society. Pakistan has foundation built on hatered and relegious orthodoxy.
The accommodation of all sections of society was clearly highlighted in Haridwar gathering few weeks ago.
India is ruled by neo nazis now.
When the great Italian opera musician and singer LUCIANO POVERATTI died the whole Italy fall into mourn for weeks and given him state funeral that was great loss for Italian people's and state .
When the great singer of Argentina MERCEDES SOSA died her coffin kept in government state house and whole nation mourn Argentina declared state funeral
When legend Mexican singer
Juan Gabriel passed away the whole nation mourn.
When Egyptian singer umme Kalsoum died the Egypt gave her state Funeral .
But sadly in Pakistan when legend Noor Jean and Mehadi Hassan sb and Nusserat father Ali Khan sb died no one care about that great loss here people's don't respect the artist they degrade and called them مراثی they don't understand those artist are the face of any Nation and those who value them they never disrespect them but always feel proud they have such legends .
Where we Pakistani stands here ??
100s of great artists left Hindustan during 1947. Includes Nazir Qasmi Fateh ali khan and others. Why ?
Pakistan mea konsa aysa funkar hay jiski izzat ke jati hay ? Pakistan mea srif Jahilo ke izzat ke jati hay aur unko hero bunnaya jata hay
G izat ki jati hae jub wo dunya se rukhsat ho jaeye...
@@GuchoKaDhaba 100% right app such boal rahee hain
Humry boht se log inahi ghtia harktain karty Han Jin ki wajha se boht se log zalil ho k mar khap gay or Jo chly gay unho na Dunia Mai nam kea per un k Dil pakistan Mai rahy afsos ki bat ha
informatic video
No doubt Lahore was the capital of great India music , still now people of Lahore knows the Sur Sangeet , but unfortunately we have also narrow minded people, music doesn't have borders it freely flies like birds ,
Absolutely
4:04 py video start
Thankss
Bade dadu ❤️🙏🌸
The whole world knows Ghulam Ali khan while only few know the officious ZA Bukhri and that too because of Ghulam Ali khan.
Oh ! Our establishment , with out thinking what they think ?
We are preachers of his music we are not concerned about his origin we are his fans Remember his Thumri in Mogale Azam A great gr8 classical singer
Kia faraq parrta hay k aik ustaad chahay Pakistan main rahain yaa India main rahain... Ustaad Fateh Ali Khan Mubarak Ali Khan Pakistan main aanay k Baad bhi poori Dunia ka asasa maanay ga'ay.
Unka niwas Park Circus, Kolkata ka zikr nahi hua isa video me.
Ustad ji, unke bete unke pote Kolkata ke shan bane aur bare bare gawaye ko gana sikhaya. Pandit Ajoy Chakraborty, Ustad munawar Ali khan ke hi shagrid rahe. Ustad Munawar Ali khan, khansab ke shahzade hai.
Wht a legend,
Aisa lagta hai jaise hamrey mulk ko badua hai k ham kabi b aisey achey logon ki qadar nai karsakey or onho ne osi waqt boht acha faisla Kia k wo izzat se yah yahan se chalegaye
Vo alag time tha.
I think we should accept this fact Pakistan got freedom on Islamic base theory and Ustad baray Ghulam Ali Khan sahab take right decision to india citizenship
The original philosophy behind partition was economy and not religious freedom.Muslims were economically much marginalised by the British due to various reasons.
Islam prohibits Indian classical music . He did right to come to the land of art and culture ...
Who told you Islam does such none sense 😅😅 do some reading before giving sweaping statements bro
Very Bad..but Islam allows Pure Music...
Nai Nai aisa bilkul BHI Nahi classical music ki ap history utha Kar Dekh Lein bare auliya aur sufiya ko ap khawaja ameer khusro ki missal Dekh Lein unhon ne jitna is ziman mein kaam Kiya shayad hi kise ne Kiya ho mosseqi to wasile Allah hai Allah se wasl Karne Ka zariya hai Islam prohibit Nai karta isko Woh alag baat hai keh ap Iska kaise istimaal karte Han isse Ibadat samajh Kar karein to yeh aik Ibadat hai yahi mosseqi Naat ban jati yahi Hamd ban jaati yahi thumri ban jaati yahi dadraa ban jati yahi geet ban jaati iski Kai shaklein Han
My God!!! For me it is unthinkable that UBGAK - taaya ji for me - could have lived anywhere but in India. My father (who was a total devotee of classical mausiqii) and he were close friends, I grew up listening to his divine singing in person. Every word spoken in this video is correct. I can not imagine any one - even Taansen - being his equal. The greatest blessing in my life to have known, and heard him up close.
پاکستان میں ہر قابل اور احسان کرنے والے کو ہمیشہ زلیل و رسوا ہی کیا گیا ہے۔ شاید یہی وجہ ہے کہ ہماری قوم نے 70 سال میں کوئی بڑا نام پیدا نہیں کیا کیونکہ قوم دیکھ رہی ہے کہ یہاں ڈاکٹر عبدالقدیر خان صاحب جیسے سُچے ہیرے کو جس طرح رسوا کیا گیا اسکو دیکھ کر تو کبھی کوئی دوسرا پاکستانی سائنسدان بننے کا سوچے گا بھی نہیں۔
True
Humari history b aik doosre k gale katne pe mushtamil ha
Self pity. Great people do not require to be praised and worshiped. They are born to do certain task without any fear or favour. Nation has respected DrAW Khan and will continue to do till end of this world.
RIP Ustaad bare Ghulam Ali Khan, aameen 🤲🤲🤲
yeh ZA bukhari jesa logon par aaj ki pakistani awam ki lanat .
Jo humara asasa tha inho na barbad kia .
The great ustad ji
best singer ever
In entire commentry only one Urdu word was mispronounced ie "udhed". It is actually "adhed".
" ادھیڑ" کے الف پر زبر ہے. پیش نہیں.
لیکن پوری کمنٹری بے حد دلچسپ اور مفید ہے اعر مرتبین مبارکباد کے مستحق ہیں
Shukar hai barey ko badey Nahin Likha
Thanks to Hindu majority India for understanding the value of Gems. Not just Pakistani muslims, even Indian Muslims if given a chance would behave the same way. Majority of muslims whether Indian or Pakistani , have become captive of falls notion of ISLAM which made them forgot their cultural & Historical root that is " SANATAN HINDU CIVILISATION & CULTURE". INDIA has always given fatherly treatment to Pakistan, but Pakistan failed to understand this.
Andhbhakt?
@@Skhatik2001 Thank you.
@@Skhatik2001 your mind has been polluted......you need to understand your forefathers were hindu converted by muslim invaders.
@@Skhatik2001 librandu ?
Hindu civilisation? Lol
I am from district kasur, punjab, pakistan.
How you challenge Tansen ??
انڈیا سے پاکستان ہجرت کرنے والے فنکاروں کو وہ عزت کبھی نہ ملی جو وہاں ملتی ۔۔۔ روشن آرا بیگم ۔ نورجہاں ، اقبال بانو۔ فریدہ خانم، مہدی حسن ،،ملکہ پکھراج ۔۔ یہاں پران فنکاروں کی صلاحیتوں سے مکمل استفادہ نہیں کیا گیا۔۔۔
بھائی آپ نے سُنا نہیں کہ۔۔ زیڈ اے بخآری نے اتنے بڑے بڑے اور نامور فنکاروں کو میراثی کہہ کر زلیل وخوار کرنے کی کوشش کی۔۔۔
Aisi izzat par lanat...Kanjar Baighairat Marasi loog
Thanks Sir, beautiful video and sentiment 🙏🙏🙏
وہ ماضی کے افسانے ہیں۔۔ آج پاکستان سے انڈیا جانے والے فنکاروں کیلئے وہاں ذلت ہے تمسخر ہے بیہودگی ہے۔۔ بھارت ایک متلون مزاج سوسائٹی ہے جہاں مذہبی انتہا پسندی پاکستان سے کچھ زیادہ ہی ہوگی کم نہیں۔۔
Badey Ghulam Ali Khan? Subhanallah. What an irony!
Mirasi for Pakistani Muslim ashrafiya but embraced as badshah e mausuqi in Hindu India.
This is wrong. If it was true then how come Mehdi hasan Mehnaz Noorjehan and others opted to come to pakistan.
The only thing was how better they would be paid. India was not only bigger but an established country. These singers felt they were better off there.
@@extraorchidinary6347 i don't think you've heard this video....watch again and listen this time..there were attempts by your so called leadership to islamize the classical music and to top it off the attitude of your bureaucracy towards your indigenous talent was despicable....anyone with self-esteem would've done done what he did.
@@Mandamus7 oh so music can be islamized too. Salam to your thinking.
Noorjehan madam regretted shifting....I strongly believe that her reason for shifting was her then husband and nothing else
I had read an interview with Ali Sardar Jafri in Outlook magazine back in 1997, on the occasion of India's 50th anniversary of Independence. Bade Ghulam Ali khan had migrated to Pakistan sometime after partition and was performing at a function. He started singing "Mohe chhedo na Nand laal" when he was rudely stopped by the organiser, Muhammad Ali ,who told him, "Kuchh 'Pakistani' music bajaiye!" To which Khan sahab responded, "Meri gardan na marodo Muhammad Ali!" and left the function. He later migrated to India and used to advise other Pakistani singers to do the same. I think it was Salaamat Ali Khan, my memory fails me, who was quoted in another article in the same issue, who said that Khan sahab told him, "Come to India. In Pakistan you will only find people who listen to Qawwali!"
Bade gulam Ali Khan,absolutely was and is one and only.
Khan Sahib was against linguistic corruption in Classical Music. He was a insulted by a bureaucratic writer.
uss time pe bhi Mumbai mein traffic thi ?
Lata Di respected him a lot .
ایک حالیہ انٹرویو کے مطابق تو استاد کے بھتیجے نے یہ کہا ہے کہ وہ سیّد ذوالفقار علی بخاری کی وجہ سے ہندوستان نہیں گئے تھے بلکہ اس فن کو مزید سیکھنا چاہتے تھے۔
زیڈ اے بخاری کے مطابق اس روز ان کے پروگرام کا سلاٹ ہی موجود نہیں تھا۔۔۔۔ ریڈیو پاکستان لاہور کا ایک اکلوتا اسٹودیو تھا نہ کہ ہالی وڈ کہ ایک ہی وقت میں متعدد ریکارڈنگ ہو رہی تھیں
ویسے استاد چھوٹے غلام علی کو ہم نے جیسے آسمان پر بٹھا رکھا ہے
Unfortunately, the time has failed to change the mindset of the Pakistani administration.
wht a legend
Fact of the matter is people like Badey Gulam Ali Khan & Sahir Ludhyanvi proved wiser lot vis a vis people like Sahadat Hasan Manto, if you know what I mean😁
Us waqt traffic block ho gaithi? Kuch soch k to bol
@saleem Rana us waqt gaadiya kum aur log jaada the road par. Is wajah se traffic jam
@@2002gopal achaa us waqt Hindustan ki papulation kitni thi
Ali Warsi Rocks !! 👍
वाह
He had Afghan Roots :)) From Ghazni kya baat hai bhai
مغل اعظم 60 کی نہیں 50 کی دہائی میں بنائی جارہی تھی۔ ریلیز 1960 میں ہوئی تھی۔
Pakistan jisko chuaa wo ujdaa
Urdu ke word search kar kar commentary ki hai.......................Simple baat Karo bhai
Her jagah hota hy. India may bi hota hy. Jysy k ustaad bismillah Khan. Santos anand. Etc
@akash kumar bro ap ki bat theak hy but un ki bohat zyada ghurbet may death hue.
@akash kumar okay thanks for updating me
کیا کیا نمونے ہماری بیوروکریسی میں پائے جاتے تھے اور ہیں
AAPNE INKA KOI RAAG KION NAHI SUNAYA ?
میں استاد فتح علی خان پٹیالوی صاحب کے بطور سیکریٹری انٹرنیشنل ٹورز آرگنائز کر چکا ھوں۔اٹلی۔جرمنی۔اور انگلینڈ۔۔میوزک کی دنیا کی ڈکشنری تھے۔خان صاحب بھی بڑے مھا کلاکار تھے۔بے بھا راگوں پہ دسترس تھی۔
1:47 bulkul ghalat bhai jaan aisa nahi ke me khan sahab ki tohin kr raha hu but ye kehna galat hai ap kisi ko bhi tansen ji se zyada nahi bol sakte ek or bat ustad salamat ali khan sahab to phir bade khan saab se bohat zyada acha gate hain mafi le sath🙏🏻
There is no comparison. No one should do these silly comparisons when artists like them never did so. Ustad Salamat Khan shb himself said to his son Ustad Shafqat in reverence of Ustad Bade Ghulam Ali Khan shb: "Pointing at his head, Bade Ghulam Ali Khan yahan bethay huay hain" meaning he is above my head. This is in no way to say that there was a single artist of Ustad Salamat Ali Khan shb's stature.
❤❤❤🙏
Half family in pakistan and half in india...great loss for
Nothing much has changed yet
Joash milabdi k sath bhi bura slook huwa raja sahab mehmoodabad wapus india chalay gay thay yea mojuda pakistan qaide azam wala pakistan nahi bulkay punjabeestan hay
Punjabeestan ho tab b theek hai but ye log to punjabi ko b hakarat ki nighahon se dekhtey hai
Identity kho chuke jahil log hai inko naa to pta Urdu speaker naa inko pta local languages bolni
Urdu khud UP ki language hai to socho jo language bhi apni khud ki nai boltey to wo hee hongey
So sad
2:07 you referred him as “Miya Tansen”. But he was Hindu. Check Wikipedia.
To kya hua 😂?
Z A Bukhari the killer of legend of music he insulted the ustad baray Ghulam Ali sb,this the approach and thinking of our government officials they are still on same track, how the indian gave him respect and honour.
Achaa kia chaly gy
Omg 😳
جی ہاں ہم لوگوں کی عزت اسی طرح کرتے ہیں ۔برٹش راج کی باقیات کا فنون لطیفہ سے کیا تعلق ۔
Sun kar dukh howa
Z A Bokhari b marasi hi tha
Mirasi ka matlab great artist hota hai jo sangeet ke ras me duba hua.
Gandhi
Khan Sahab...
Thoda Gandhi jee ko bhi IJJAT de do
Father apka hoga hmara to nhi
جس ملک میں فنکار کو عزت تو دور کی بات مرنے پر دفنانے دو درجن شہر کے لوگ شکرکت نہیں کرتے۔ ملک چھوڈنے کے سوا کیا چارا تھا۔ کہتے ہیں میڈم نورجہاں کے انتقال پر یہی صورت حال رہا۔ جب 65 کی جنگ جاری تھی اس دوران میڈم کے قومی ترانے گانے ہر ایک کے زبان پر تھا۔المعیہ دیکھیے۔
Urdu mohabbat ki aavaz he dard he
But Z A Bukhari is often considered to be one of the stalwarts who established radio broadcasting in this subcontinent even before India got divided. It is really shocking to know that Mr Bukhari could be so insensitive and obnoxious while dealing with a genius like Bade Khan sahab.
Ego ?
Bukhari is dead in history but Ustad Bade GAK still alive in Audience Memories.
La qanooeyath India may zyada hay ya Pakistan may...... marshal law nahee loga India...kon zyada jamhoreyath Pasand hayn.. corruption Kaha zyada hay.
Jo musalman pakistan pakistan karte hain unhein dekhna chahiye
ہر اس شخصیت کو باقاعدہ پلاننگ کے تحت ذلت آمیز حالات کا سامنا کرنا پڑا جو اس مک سے مخلص تھا