How Did Our Universe Start From Nothing?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 24 янв 2024
- Nothing. What does it mean? We humans believe that something has had to exist, in order for something else to exist. So how did everything start? We say it started from nothing, but nothing can’t just turn into something, right?
Subscribe → @SpacedustDOC
#Spacedust #Space #Universe 
Наука
To the question "who made nothing" I admit it's me. I'm always doing nothing.
😂😂😂😂😂😂
My father would beg to differ - Me: "Dad, why are you mad? I did not do anything" My father "that is right you are doing nothing and that is why I am mad at you". I never got over that. >)
Oh fuck! 🤣🤣🤣🤣
😂😂😂😂😂 I did nothing to .together we are something 👍👍👍
Yeah, I've made nothing before
After watching the whole thing, I am now more confident that I know "Nothing."
And that is impossible😂
Hey, when did we meet?!
I know right. What's the big deal about nothing anyway ..
Who knew I would actually be watching something about absolutely nothing literally?
LoL! True, and clev.
ALLAH DESCRIBED THE UNIVERSE IN THE QURAN IN DETAIL (((21:30 Have those who disbelieved not considered that the heavens and the earth were a joined entity, and We separated them and made from water every living thing? Then will they not believe?) AND surah zariyat aya 47 ( 51:47 And the heaven We constructed with strength, and indeed, We are [its] expander. ) AND Yasin aya 38 (yaseen) (And the sun runs [on course] toward its stopping point. That is the determination of the Exalted in Might, the Knowing.) AND surah Anbiya aya 33 (21:33 And it is He who created the night and the day and the sun and the moon; all [heavenly bodies] in an orbit are swimming.) AGAIN AND AGAIN, ALLAH WHO CREAT THE UNIVERSE HE DESCRIBED EVERYTHING IN THE QURAN 1400 YEARS AGO. ALLAH SAID (41:53 We will show them Our signs in the horizons and within themselves until it becomes clear to them that it is the truth. But is it not sufficient concerning your Lord that He is, over all things, a Witness?) Quran 41:53 Surah Fussilat ayat 53 THERE is STILL A LOT ABOUT UNIVERSE IN THE QURAN.
It's not about ABSOLUTELY NOTHING. he qualifies his nothingness saying the nothing is full of quantum fluctuations
@@user-rt9bj7zt2dJesus Christ is God allah is no more
@@user-rt9bj7zt2dAllah is Satan.
Our brains do not possess the circuitry to comprehend "nothingness". We are doomed to understand only what our senses can perceive
but that's why clever people meditate --- they know that nothing is good for you so u just got to get close to it as pos
Nothing is separate from anything... like all that empty space way out in the cosmic void still holds all the stars and planets... there is nothing separting anything from anything other than perception itself
Love that! Very clever 😊
@@scottscottlewis11 to be separate is an attribute and that is something
@@HABLA_GUIRRRI YESSS!!
The Universe has never "started", nor will it ever "end"... It is ETERNAL. And INFINITE.
Pics or it didn't happen
@@ghosthusler Well, to start, the JWST has SHOWN Galaxies that take Billions of years to form, EXISTING BEFORE the Big Bang...
Beyond that, we don't have, and maybe NEVER WILL, means to scrutiny that Multiverse, that TRUE GOD !
Many scientists wouldnt agree with you. Stars are finite, so are galaxies,even blck holes.
Many scientists don’t know shit
If only we had time travel
I sit back with a glass of red wine and a cigar and act like I understand Quantum Physics :)
Hahaha so do I.
Then you can teach quite a bit of it.
No matter what humans think they know or create we know nothing.
God knows everything . Islam is the truth.
😮
Ya. Nothing
@@user-vk4ln4wk4j god is irrelevant, as is Islam.
@@user-vk4ln4wk4j keep your man making religion for yourself 🤣
In a book I read when I was younger, the universe was characterized as breathing. The interval of breath was called a 'skanda'. This was a Buddhist or Hindu term, I think. Inhale into nothing, then exhale into everything.
I think consciousness is the key. Consciousness is what spans all these impossibly huge distances and scales. If I can perceive it, I can go to the outer edge of the universe, or inside a single atom.
Annnnd what are we on, hippie boy?
@@davidferrara1909 nothing. I stopped smoking weed a few weeks ago. But thanks for the hippie accolade!
Bingo!!!
@@davidferrara1909 Hold on I think I found a piece of crap over here
Interesting idea, thanks for sharing
In the beginning, the universe was created. That made a lot of people very angry and has been widely regarded ever since as a bad move.
What are some good moves - if you may permit ? Fare thee well.
@@user-hy9nh4yk3p Many were increasingly of the opinion that they'd all made a big mistake in coming down from the trees in the first place. And some said that even the trees had been a bad move and that no one should ever have left the oceans
I use yoga meditation - to change - and regain - the purified spiritual condition - in the heart.
It represents a transcending consciousness and a new reality within - the Real Being.
Such is the human potential, also and am working hard - at this for 52 years plus.
Fare thee well@@Jeff_Vader
propagating the creation myth must suck. something done much?
Creation was propagated - by the Special Will within - like permission.
It is not a myth - you're real - aren't you ?
The call to truth - is actually - 'more and more; of less and less' (Ram Chandra)
Fare thee well.@@less2worryabout
Nothing. and. Something are human concepts that our brains are hardwired to expect is the way thing are. The universe is under no obligation to act the way we want and expect it to
Hogwash. Either nothing, or something, is the genesis of our existence. Those concepts are general enough to encompass things we can't even understand. So, even if the "something" from whence we spring is ineffable to our feeble brains, it's still something.
So black-and-white, up-and-down, here and there human concepts. It's a nonsense to think that language inhibits our understanding of the world
@@janecote I don't think it's language but rather our cognitive limitations. It's like trying to explain the color purple to a person blind from birth. Or better yet trying to tell a flatlander who can only move forward/backwards and right/left that there is a thing called up. Up or down would make no sense to the flatlander.
@@tux1968there is no such state as nothing, it contains the potential for something to arise.
@@a13xdunlop Totally agreed. "Something", always was. We may never understand it, but there is an eternal underpinning of our existence. Some people call it God.
I used to think about this when I was a kid in bed and it disturbed me.
This still disturbs me
You were a disturbed kid
@@mack8488 I'm probably a disturbed adult
I did too bro, I'd visualize the sky but mentally take away the planet & stars.. I use to always think like "Wtf is that dark shii in the background"😂😂😭
@@bigpolk3661 You discovered dark matter before the boffins,
Hell yeah, all us old guys who were there know.
Generation Naught represent
Ikr
Empty space is not "nothing," it is "space." (spacetime).
This is the actual main topic of everything. What is this space. Where is this space, and what is it that contains this empty space. Emptiness surrounding emptiness?
In the beginning God
@@ryanlindback9393 lame and boring. Is anyone home? Knock knock.....
@@x88868 there is no emptyness in space, there is always the field of gravity from everything around that has travelled snd has been ever since.
@@jaymxu ok, Mr. "I get my science from marvel, Disney movies"
nothing is lost, nothing is created, everything is transformed.
@@d0uble_OGod spoke the Universe into existence which is why everything in the Universe vibrates at a specific frequency and vibration is sound.
@@d0uble_O this explanation is for the sheep and those limited individuals who cannot think outside their own box
@@d0uble_Ogreat question...one we may never ever be aware enough to answer
If we dare to believe that a creator created all things...the question still remains...who created the creator. Duhhhh. There is absolutely no human being on earth capable of answering this question factually. It is a matter then of blind and ignorant faith to believe such a story. No matter how passionate the sheep are pushed into believing it.
but what is a "THING"?
An excellent and courageous presentation! A breath of fresh air on the subject of Nothing. You are to be commended for not dodging the issue, or worse yet, rephrasing the original question and answering your own modified and pointless version of it. No-one expects that you solve the greatest existential question facing humanity in a single video; when it comes to Nothing, just authentically introducing and exploring the subject with clarity equates with a great leap forward. 👏🏻
The universe is something. Even empty space is something. You can ask “how” or “from what did everything come into being.”
Its probably better to think of nothing as the absence even space and time,rather space and time without anything in them
Yes, infact ...No one knows origin of the universe,
Infinity ♾️ at anywhere and anytime, Big-bang theory is/was/will be wrong!
@@HKsTech.Info. that would rule out the Big Bang. Current research sounds like the Big Bang happened but it was a series of other bangs rather than the beginning of everything. It could still be the beginning of our universe.
@@DEANISME_ Evidently, a lot of people have difficulty with that, as they do with some other concepts e.g. infinity. Maybe the problem is in translating insights and intuitions about intangibles/abstract concepts into communicable language. The concept may be perfectly clear in your own mind, while attempts to communicate it are effectively blocked.
That was narrated in a very poetic manner.
Probably because they paid a narrator, to make this sound more informative than it actually is, and put a ton of stock videos along with it.
@@Nebukanezzerfrl bro just yappin
"Nothing will come of nothing, speak again." - King Lear
out vile spot
Time defines when an action without beginning will occur. Everything else will contribute to this event. This action started at the birth of time because time defines something to exist.
@@HABLA_GUIRRRI - *damned spot
The thing that really hurts my head is when I try to imagine precisely "where" this nothing was before it became the something...LOL. I guess I can envisage a pitch-black, "matterless" space which to all intents and purposes LOOKS like nothing, and may not even be matterless, but is just something which lacks any illumination....a bit like the darkest depths of the ocean if you like. But the leap between something "looking like nothing" (to the human eye) and it actually BEING nothing....is....I guess.....the bit that one struggles to process.
space itself wouldnt exist
@@3aeren Precisely, and the only way I can process a "no space" scenario is to imagine a pitch black void which is utterly unable to play host to "matter" (of any kind) I mean, it need not be pitch black I guess, it could be dazzlingly white for all that it matters, (no pun intended) but as a visualisation, it's just something which has no motion, no size, and is repellent to occupation by "matter" or "energy" because the moment it DOES play host to such things, it stops being "nothing" and becomes "something" even if it's a "something" defined by nought but it's relativity to the matter which has somehow invaded it.
That's because there was never "absolute nothing" and whatever they're calling Nothing in this doc is still actually "something" (space itself). "Nothing," is not. Never was never will be real, just a concept we made up, just as fictional as star wars.
best not imagine ur ''space'' since said space cannot be n o t h i n g but is something, ie a space. New brayne. . ;?
@@HABLA_GUIRRRI You seem to have a far better conceptual mastery of "nothing" than I do...which may be due to a broader personal experience with the subject matter? But then again, can "nothing" rightly be termed as subject "matter?" ⚠😉
I just love all your videos! You crack me up!!! You’re getting there!!! The place is becoming amazing!!! Thx!!!
Perhaps dark matter is the "nothing" that virtual particles emerge from. Intriguing video 🤔
Dark matter is the failure to admit that the standard cosmological model is monumentally incomplete or entirely wrong. How often are they finding structures and voids that "shouldn't exist" according to current models. "Let's create imaginary forces instead of admitting that we don't know dick"
Dark matter isn't nothing though by it's very definition.
@@SlinkShady That's why I put "..." around nothing.
Hi@@suecondon1685! You're right! 😊 Dark matter is like "nothing".
Gravity = The Spaceless and Timeless Vacuum Energy State of Matter!!! :)
I like Stephen Wolfram's take on dark matter being the caloric of our time. He theorizes it more as an emergent quality of atomized space rewriting itself
Have you ever noticed that you can't measure time without comparing it to something moving, and you can't measure motion without time 🤯
that's why there are still so many flies
sure you can
@@juliocortez5209 you can't. Time is change, change is movement, time is movement. All time measurement requires movement. Time dilation is due to movement of the measurement.
Yep. Motion through space and time are intrinsincally linked. Thats why its called "Space-time" and not "3 dimentional space" and "4th dimension of time".
I've thought that before, time is movement. If everything froze and stopped moving in the universe time would stop and everything would be frozen in time forever.
It didn't. There was never nothing.
Another video idea: how consciousness was created. That's another question we will never truly know the answer to.
not with that attitude you wont. lol nancy
Empty space is still something. An empty universe is still something. Nothing is the absence of everything..including space and time. Think again.
Right, an area where there is nothing, but something could be there, is empty space. If empty space is nothing, something could not exist there.
When I die the world will not exist because all of you and everything around you are just a creation of my mind.
Very informative and well done! Thank you!
What supported the singularity? Space didn't exist yet.
Nothing doesn't need to be created since the mere absence of something results in nothing.
Doesn't work for the Universe though.
absence is something
@@DadeMurphie by definitiojn it isn't.
@@SlinkShady false, absence of something is an attribute. Nothing can't have attributes.
@@DadeMurphieNo thing is what nothing is. This means no space, time or laws of physics. Without space, time or some kind of laws of physics you are probably left with no thing.
How can something so incredibly complicated as an atom come from nothing ???
When you look at everything within the earth and the universe you see that everything is boiled down to perfection.
If the earth was two degrees hotter we wouldnt survive, if the atmosphere wasnt a blanket of protection we would die, think about how all this time and how vast space is and not a single rock has collided that earth has spun out of orbit. SubhanAllah.
You see wildlife shows and see how all animals are adpated for their environment. This isnt evolution or a mistake. God created everything with no mistakes. Islam is the truth and for your own benefit i suggest you research more about how this universe was created and why you are really here. What is your purpose? Where are you going? What happens after you die? You dont know when you will die so take the oppourtunity to learn and research now. We dont think about it enough. Dont be fooled by this temporary illusion.❤
And when you say complicated, an atom that tuned our universe like a Formula 1 race car. I don’t believe the theory.
Atoms do not come from nothing. Atoms come from protons, neutrons and electrons.
and protons come from ......@@jfairway1
It can’t
this was so beautiful explaining that the universe and nothingness are in a symphony of a harmonic ballet.
great video, very professional and thorough.Liked and subbed
Black holes give birth to singularities, the big bang was the expansion of and the possible creation of a singularity....i propose that the formation of every black hole could be the creation of another universe.
I agree. Our universe exploded out of a singularity. It’s possible that at the opposite end of every black hole is a singularity - some with the potential of achieving a big bang. How many universes may there be? Definitely one of course, but possibly billions.
I too, like this hypothesis.
@@markenmel1 Yes, white holes 🕳 (possibly).
@@MrEnjoivolcom1I used to think white holes too, but for whatever reason the singularity seems now more the possibility. My reasoning…beats me. Maybe it’s something I ate.
Exactly!!!
Dimensional multiverses solve the problem of the impossibility of a true “void”. The theory is the best model I’ve seen to explain dark matter and dark energy as well. Basically every time a black hole is created the energy releases from ripping a hole in that universe forms a big bang in a brand new universe.
Why? Just because there is maybe more than our universe and layers of them that doesn't explain the origin beyind all of them.
@@sadskytristeciel1439 if the layers are infinite, or if the layers are spherical or bubbles folding back into themselves. That goes along with ideas of a flat universe or a curved universe. Any curvature whatsoever no matter how small means it’s spherical or bubbles. We keep discovering more and more levels of size. Just a few decades ago we thought there was only one galaxy. Now there may be infinite numbers in infinite layers. A true void is a paradox. The more we think about what a true void really means the more it hurts our brains. It is my conclusion that a true void simply is not possible unless a new realm of physics exists, but then that creates yet another paradox. Physical properties cannot exist in a void. Nothing exists in a void.
Idk a black hole would then have to make an extremely small universe, or create matter and energy to make an equivalent or roughly equivalent universe. And if we were a back hole, that black hole still exists and should be spawing matter into us somehow.
How did the first one start?
@@chrisharrison8591 L. Ron Hubbard. Scientology was right all along.
Electroshock involved!⚡️⚡️⚡️
Nothing is the limitations of the Observer, not the objective matter of a true Void. We are not adapted to observe what is in a Void, but the Voids are there. First the field of space time cannot enter a Void, then light cannot propagate into the Void to give us a way to either go there or see what light does upon entering the Void. So while access is denied, you grapple with our opinions about something or nothing concepts.
Our knowledge is limited. When we theorize dark this and that it only means we don't understand the Universe. While our "leaders" spend our wealth on killing others we could be escaping this gravity well/spacetimepimple and solve those mysteries.
greed
Even though the Universe is finite in time, there has never been a time when something did not exist.
Yes, before time.
@@spencerhewlett9082Energy existed before time, therefore there was still never a time when nothing existed. Energy cannot be created nor destroyed - law of conservation of energy. Energy and mass are also interchangeable, therefore the energy that existed before time was responsible for creating matter and, by extension, the universe.
the law does not exist in nothing, in singularity.@@Crystan
No. They made calculations and found out that an empty nothingness is not a stabile configuration. I have no idea how to interpret that just passing the info.
Nothingness is just human definition vs Nothingness is more than Nothing.
We can not fathom nothingness, nor can we understand a "time" before time.
Even nothing is something.
Everything is nothing 😂
I dont think you quite understand what nothing really is.
Can you have nothing. Is 0 real. Is nothing a thing
🤯😮🤯😲
@@skylersmith2140Theoretically yes. It is the absence of something. Since something does exist and seemingly always has we may tend to think the opposite is impossible. I don't see why something had the be the default. I could imagine nothing ever existing and since something can not come from nothing then nothing would ever exist. It is only because this is not the case that we are here to talk about this. If nothing ever existed then obviously we would not be here.
This is more philosophical than scientific. I often ask myself why is there something rather than nothing.
Can I just point out that time can not have a beginning. A beginning is a measurement of when an event occurs in relation to time. You need a running timeline to exist already if you are to talk of beginnings and ends, therefore, by default, the concept we call time has always existed. This makes the likelihood of there having once been "nothing" very small indeed. We only know the universe was incredibly small, hot and dense 14 billion years ago.
That does not equate to it having emerged from nothing,
And what about the event horizon of a black hole? Time stops there. Mathematically it's a discontinuity. It doesn't exist and the meaning of time and space as directions swap rolls once you pass. For all intents and purposes isn't the event horizon both the beginning and end of time?
You could pass through an event horizon smoothly like nothing happened, _exactly because _*_nothing_*_ happened_ !
Time does exist in black holes. It’s just compressed. Otherwise a black hole could not exist, because existence needs time to exist in.
@@zeriousvolt1245 once you are inside, all motion, the major component of its vector is in the direction of the center. Because of the speed of light, and that space itself ahead of you is accelerating faster than you, nothing falling ahead of you can be seen because it would have to send a signal faster than light for it to reach you and that can't happen, so everything in your future can't be seen. You can try and go in any other direction to slow your descent, but it will only slow down the rate you get to your future.
Also because you are accelerating with space faster than everything behind you, everything in your distant past, will seem red shifted and the event horizon will appear like the beginning of time.
Does that description of the inside of a black hole remind you of something?
@@zeriousvolt1245 we don't know that time exists in black holes. It's a mathematical assumption.
Eternity has no beginning nor ending, but "time" has beginnings and endings.
This brings back awesome memories of my cousin and I when we were 11 years old frieking out mentally over the question, "When was the beginning of nothing"? When we really try to thing about it we'd have a brain overwhelm. Ha, I miss that. But later I got some of that back from LSD.
The discussion on nothing is the first part of my book that I published on Kindle Amazon in 2012. The scientists still don't seem to understand it.
If nothing exists then it's something. How can we have something from nothing? 0 is central point for all the positives and negatives combined. Is "nothing" central to something we know only one side of?
is nothing sacred?
We bet 5 dollars on something silly. I lose. We now went from 0 to -5 and +5 without breaking any laws.
That’s the thing, their description of “nothing” is a red herring, they want to say that nothing actually is something which doesn’t answer the question because their version of “nothing” inherently doesn’t have a creation point, it just POOF appeared. Sounds to me like an argument for God.
Nothing is not something. If nothing was something, then it would not be nothing.
quite so. and the only way we are ever going to get close to expressing it is through a new language constructed from a point of absolute death which won't be much use to us just here. BUt let's not give up!! @@jfairway1
Because we cannot see in 4D, every clip showing the big bang appears as a point of light which explodes outward in an empty black void…this is wrong. The concept of nothing means not even a void for you to imagine, waiting to be filled. You can only see the universe, even to imagine it, from inside.
but an apple may itself peel
When there was nothing, there was no space or emptiness either
The fact is that we don't yet understand all facets of physics. We can only perceive a limited number of dimensions, but there may be hidden powers or phenomena that we haven't discovered yet. Our creator obviously exists. Everything fits perfectly.
Absolute nothing is what I've always thought death would be like
Me too, not anymore though, I don't think there can ever be truly nothing, now I think death is like life, but I don't think it's like life in the sense of how we perceive it now, but an equally tangible conscious experience in some mind boggling reality.
It's not that simple. Death is simply a translation from a 4D universe to something higher as Quantum Field Theory suggests- the realm of God, or Hell depending on what you think about Christ.
Death & religion enters and things get messy fast. I'd say I'm agnostic and the devil makes for good teenage horror movies which still leaves me with absolute nothing
Remember what it was like before you were born? Being dead will be a lot like that
@@Jimsimi Consciousness is an emergent property. When we die, we return to our base properties which does not include consciousness.
If we’re alive, the forever existence is the only explanation for this enigma. As long as we’re alive, we demand an explanation to existence, once we’re dead, someone alive will determine in their perspective that we’re dead and nothing is what we’re experiencing.
The most magical question ever. I look forward to the riddle being solved one day🙏✨💙
It's like when I used to have hair on my head and NOW there is nothing.
To say that the Universe "experienced" the Big Bang is a little like saying that a fetus "experienced its own conception". Worse actually because the foetus is an evolved "experience machine", while whether or not the Universe (without humans) is "experiencing" anything is a matter of some serious metaphysical debate. Not a scientific debate, since this notion is in principle - unfalsifiable and is thus - untestable.
the universe existed before the creating of humans
Nothing never existed ever.
Even this thought - expressed ? Fare thee well.
Something existed. We just can't comprehend it.
I dont know why its so bizzare to think that there is a higher being out there considering the vastness of this universe. There are clear proofs that God is real in the quran which is the book sent down to the prophet muhammad peace be upon him the religion of truth is islam
@@user-vk4ln4wk4jthere is no proof
@@user-vk4ln4wk4jit is not bizarre to think about, but it is bizarre to believe in. Fantastic claims need fantastic evidence.
Wonderfully researched, written and explained.
There was never "nothing", nor has there ever been. What we discard as empty void, is in fact every bit as substantial as the densest matter known to man.
Particles popping into and out-of existence... no such thing. All that ever was or will be; it exists and has never stopped existing. The real difference lies within Humanity's limited abilities of sensory and perception. "Nothing" is a concept we created; a category for things which are beyond our cognition.
The best comment under this video.
There is a point in which you did not exist. There is a point in which life did not exist. Every action can also be reversed to its source. Eventually, everything returns to that of which it came zero. We can collide particles and the particles' rebalance back to zero but change and allow us to discover new particles. Enargy can not be destroyed but only changed. There is always as much negative energy as there is postive in all of existence. Zero is the state of which the whole universe and its mater try to return into. This phenomenon is called emergence in science and is a property of how everything grows and becomes more than the sum of its parts. This property reversed back to the zero of which all mater tries to return back into or settle to at the source of creation. This zero space is the most primitive we can go before the formation of the first fourm of matter and particles or anything.
Particles popping into and out of existence has been measured and confirmed. It is a basic fact of quantum mechanics.
Nothing will rip something apart and vice versa, but this always occurs at a single point of interference. The universe is expanding everywhere.
No. It isn't.
Hubble proved it is.
Show me an example of nothign you creationist, Sure your name is not ray comfort or the criminal kent hovind.
Why are US citizens so under educted.
Its better to think of nothing as the absence of even space and
time ,rather space and time without anything in them
This is very calming to watch. And. Listen to.
Nothing cannot self-create out of Infinity - our Universe must have been created by Someone
Agreed. They always claim the universe was created out of nothing, and then say a singularity exploded to create the cosmos.
A singularity, however is something.
Nothing literally means "NO THING" whatsoever.
The current hypotheses on the birth of the universe is riddled with holes that preclude much of what we've been taught.
Even star formation is impossible under the current hypothesis model, yet often, you'll hear it stated as fact.
And who created the someone
@@a13xdunlopGod is infinite meaning God was always here and always will be here… we as human cannot comprehend everything about this universe because we werent made with that mental capacity or knowledge. Only Allah swt knows everything
God is self luminous
- it is religions - that are a human construct - to help and also to hinder, I suppose.
God- has never needed - religious tutelage.
If anything - whatever He is - love Him.
And so - you will do - the best for yourself and for - Him.
Fare thee well.
your problem is you assume your nothing statement is correct, that isnt necessarily so
True 👍
all theories stem from "assuming" a statement is correct, if they didn't, we would have no ideas about anything, so what is your point?
My girlfriend ids a cosmologist. I didnt know she knew so much! She does hair and eyelashes down at marybelles beauty shop. Gonna get het some flowers or something now I appreciate her so much more.
Excellent video. Thank you
Empty space is mot "nothing" as you described as having quantum fluctuation. You will never get around the necessity of having something, or Someone, always having been there, and now.
Firstly, if the universe came from "nothing" then it cannot have been caused as there was no "thing" to cause it. It would be an acausal event as there was nothing to cause it to exist. Thus looking for a reason is a pointless question if it came from nothing. For it to have a cause there HAS to be some "thing" to cause it, but that just shunts the question to that thing itself. Where did that "thing" come from that caused the Universe? And if we find an answer to that "thing" then the question just shunts to what caused the thing that caused the thing that caused the Universe and so on ad infinitum. You either have to accept there must be an acausal event at some point that was not preceded by any thing, or you have a never ending chain of causation which never has a final answer. There are no alternatives to this.
Secondly, if it was a random event that caused it then we can have no theory to explain it because you're asking for a set of mathematical equations that randomly spits out a universe. How would that work? How can you have an equation that comes out with a random solution when the mathematics is determinstic? Even if you could it would be a meaningless equation because it only comes out with random solutions. How would you decide which random solution is correct? It also implies that mathematics exists independently of existence itself. Where did that come from? We're back to my first point again.
Whichever way you want to slice it, the answer to existence is an unanswerable question. You don't even know the Universe existed before you thought you yourself did. "I think therefore I am" does not mean before you thought "I think" anything else was here. If the Universe is random it cannot rule out that it came into existence at the precice moment I considered I existed. It could all be inside "my head" if that even exists. It seems like I'm inside this body but am I? Does anything exist apart from this "thing" that I think is thinking?
The question quickly descends into a philosophical mess that doesn't get us any close to an answer.
To my mind the real absurdity is the concept of "nothing". It's a human concept and by definition it's meaningless.
Gratitude is a good start
- deepen it and bring your thinking to its deepest, too.
The answer - cannot fail - to be revealed.
Fare thee well.
@@user-hy9nh4yk3p drivel.
Thanks for posting.
we live in a society where they told you resting is lazy. don’t believe them! we shall not overwork ourselves just to prove we’re doing “something” to ppl who truly won’t care in the end.
Nothing burger
True nothingness is impossible to imagine or conceive. As soon as you think it, there's something. Space is something even if it's empty. Try to eliminate space, and what you have is death.
But there is no death either.
@@Fiilis1 death is the only true nothing
Death is something. Therefore death is not nothing.
@@jfairway1 death is a noun. Nothing more
@@peterroberts4509 Death is more than just a noun. But even so, a noun is something, not nothing.
The idea of a cyclic universe, where the universe undergoes repeated cycles of expansion and contraction, is indeed a theoretical concept. Some cosmological models propose such scenarios, suggesting that the universe may go through successive phases of creation and destruction. However, it's essential to note that these ideas are still speculative, and scientific exploration continues to refine our understanding of the universe's origins and evolution. The search for a comprehensive explanation involves complex physics and ongoing research in cosmology.
Sounds a lot like what CHATGtp been feeding me
@@Lenoxmusic283 I should have mentioned that I liked your photo.
Implicit in the question of why there is something rather than nothing was the solipsistic expectation that “something” would continue to exist, that the universe had somehow “progressed” to provide for our existence, as if we were the pinnacle of creation. Much more likely, based on everything we know about the Universe, is the possibility that in the future, perhaps in the infinitely distant future, nothingness will once again reign. If we live in a Universe dominated by the energy of nothing, as I noted, the future is bleak indeed. The skies will become cold, dark and empty. But the situation is actually even worse.
But the situation is actually even worse. A universe dominated by the energy of empty space is the worst of all universes for future life. Any civilization is guaranteed to disappear in such a universe due to lack of energy to survive. After an unfathomably long time, some quantum fluctuation or thermal fluctuation could create a local area where life could evolve and flourish again. But this will also not last forever. The future will be dominated by a universe in which there will be nothing to appreciate its vast mystery.
@@Pomorchik There is something you missed. Energy can neither be created, nor destroyed, it can only be transformed from one form to another. So where does the energy go?
@@jroar123 This is not a fact at all. This is not a law of nature, but only a physical principle. - now you just need to understand that before the big bang there was no matter as such. Our world today arose from the vibrations of almost nothingness - the vacuum. In accordance with the inflationary model, at the initial stage of its evolution the Universe experienced a period of accelerated expansion - inflation (the expansion of space faster than the speed of light does not contradict the Theory of Relativity). It is assumed that at this point the Universe was “empty and cold” (only a high-energy scalar field existed) and then filled with hot matter that continued to expand. Several hypotheses have been put forward about the causes of the Big Bang. According to one of them, the explosion is generated by a vacuum fluctuation. The reason for the fluctuations is the quantum vibrations that any object experiences at the quantum level; the probability of a large fluctuation is low, but non-zero. As a result of the fluctuation, the vacuum left the equilibrium state (see tunnel effect) and moved to a new state with a lower energy level (which led to the release of energy).
I like H.P. lovecraft’s idea on the horror of cosmology.
Fields are everywhere. There is no nothing. Theres still fields where there's no matter.
One could then ask: where did the fields come from?
@toby9999 of course. My point is, nothing isn't really nothing, we may never know why fundamental things exist. May be unanswerable.
Tiny minds are nothing
Nope. No Mass/Energy no fields.
😊
Expansion of this universe leads to nothing, that creates a rebirth of a new one.
What we know for sure is that there is something. And there is no room for nothing in something.
Omg. This is my new favorite to fall asleep 2
The answer is simple.
The universe did not start from nothing. Nothing cannot exist. There's always been something.
That's the conclusion I come to everytime. The real absurdity is the concept of nothing.
that something is the creator
@@3aeren
Yes, Ahura Mazda created everything!
Why?
@@3aerenwhere did this "creator" come from?
People think that "Nothing" is the default state. Clearly, there is "Something" (the Universe), therefore, there must be a cause external to this universe. I think this is erroneous. First: By definition, "Nothing" - the state of non-existence - is impossible. This hypothetical state of non-existence must also include Time - but, if there was nothing, then there was no clock ticking either. The length of time of "Nothing" is 0, by its own definition. Second: What it is being observed is that, the universe had a beginning and that the universe has always existed. These aren't two contradicting ideas, since the universe begun when the clock started ticking. There wasn't a before.
You may say: "Nothing" cannot create "Something". And, I say "Nothing" cannot stop "Something" from coming into existence either.
Something has to exsist just to define nothing....
How about this, if Nothing is Something, and Something is part of Everything, then Everything is Nothing. Or if you were Everything, what would there be left to be? Nothing. But if you are everything then you would also be nothing. So the All is One with Everything & Nothing, but in this spiritual realm there is no Space nor Time. This is a fact, science cannot tell you about.
Even "Nothing" comes from something.
There's no such a thing as "nothing".
Correct it was all
A true void is a paradox. We don’t even have a grasp of dark matter or dark energy that we know exists but we can never interact with it.
The law of thermodynamics states that matter cannot be created nor destroyed. it is physically impossible in our known universe for something to be created from nothing. Therefore, the universe had to start from some point with matter.
there is always something, there is no such thing as nothing, only states of matter we cannot comprehend
Here-here.
You havent done that much reading clearly
Nothing is actually something, Then absolute nothing is nearly nothing 😂😂
Why is there always something?
Nothing is the only thing that doesn't exist prove me wrong 😂😂😂😂
You're quite right. OH!! Maybe God doesn't exist.
He exists alright ----- whatever humans think - or say - or act upon.
It is one of those final experiences - one gets - willingly or unwillingly.
Fare thee well@@toni4729
What you have not imagined is “NOTHING”
The purpose of this book is simple. I want to show how modern science in its various guises can answer - and does answer - the question of why there is something in the world and not nothing. The answer comes from the breathtakingly beautiful data of observation and experiment, and the theories that underlie much of modern physics, all of which demonstrate that it is possible to create something from nothing without any difficulty. Moreover, something coming out of nothing was probably required for the universe to come into being. Moreover, everything indicates that this is exactly how it could have originated. Collapse Everything from Nothing: How the Universe Originated Lawrence Krauss
how it started is beyond our understanding...and someone started it....
Why is it so hard for you to give God His Glory, God made everything including time.
Give praise to God all of you humans!
The Lord God is Awesome and wonderful powerful and frightening, I love God and admire his creation!
God - does not really need our praise, at all - ever. It is vital - to love Him, though. Fare thee well.
It's true! Why not give God the glory because we men can't still understand everything about the universe. Not because it is difficult to understand why the universe has been formed doesn't mean there's no God. It is just so difficult for us to understand, and will always be difficult for us because only God knows everything.
God is nothing.
In meditative practice - as one experiences the extreme subtlety - of the inner Divine state - which is so vast - as to be infinite - one has to claim - that God is everything.
(If one wants to)
Me meditation guides - have stated this - over the process of 42 years - so as to inform and inspire the meditator - who will have that sublime imperience - when it is revealed. Fare thee well.@@toni4729
Raja Yoga meditation - states it thus: God is.
What - love Him.
Fare thee well.@@toni4729
What annoys me is when people use an argument for a creator, but then attribute it to an evolved primate born 2000 years ago.
Are you implying those who call Jesus(pbuh) God? Jesus peace be upon him is not God. Thats where christians are wrong. God is one and God is not a human. God is infinite . Islam is the truth go research for your own benefit
@@user-vk4ln4wk4j Christians say Islam is wrong, Muslims say Christianity is wrong, and around we go.
Religion is the great opiate to the masses. This includes Christian and Muslim "faiths". As humans it is easier to create a story attempting to explain how all things came to be and pass that story along as truth so that we may seem to have a purpose and conveniently have an understanding to that which is beyond our human comprehension. Which is why Religion is based on faith and not fact, logic or reason. Everyone has their own right to choose what they believe. I personally prefer not to believe in fairy tales.
You must be listening to the wrong people. The story of creation (whether true or not) goes back a long time before the birth of Jesus Christ. The simple answer is that we don't know and there appears to be no definitive proof for or against creation. The only thing that modern scientific discovery has revealed is a more definite timeline but we are still non the wiser.
@@Daniel-OConnell The “people” I’m talking about are Christians/Jews who believe the story of Genesis is true…
Nick is a true gentleman of this sport
In my unproven believe, which is a temporary construct, the universe did not start from nothing, but evolved in its beginning like a cloud. Like condensation process. From there this universe cloud started to expend.
The big bang tells us the dance of nothing and something came from a single point. At Zeno's law, the point will continually expand and will not vanish. Something out of its body must produce another something.
I don't get what the Universe is expanding into? Forget what created the bang, what created the void?
The universe (or actually OUR universe) expands into emptyness. Just because you can’t see the emptyness, it doesn’t mean it isn’t there. Just like you don’t see in the dark, but there are still things there.
@@zeriousvolt1245 what created that emptiness/void and when. How far does it stretch? Is there a void within a void?
@FLASHAHOLIC_TV dark energy. It's basically the force that's accelerating expansion at an ever increasing rate. Faster even than the speed of light.
@@wilsonkey4138 Hypothetical dark energy?
No one made nothing.
ALLAH MADE EVERYTHING
What is space?
One of those videos that genuinely attempts to answer the question.
BIG BANG? Bullshit. It was all already here.
At least one of them.
Even the "big bang" doesn't come from nothing.
Wrong question. The correct question is: WHAT MADE NOTHING.
Why wouldn't it be a who? Why would it be a what?
You can't make nothing. If it is made than it is something.
There's no such thing as Nothing.
@toni4729 thus, something had to have always existed
@@iamBlackGambit Yes, I quite agree. But it wasn't some GOD.
I hate doing nothing. I never know when I am done.
You're done when you quit idling about and do something. "What are you doing?" ... "Nothing" ... "Well come over here and help me move this dresser."
A higher task for the serious mystic - is to love everything- always
- 'Him - who loves all and all whom He loves' (Raja Yoga meditation) Fare thee well.
@@user-hy9nh4yk3p We're not to love money, war, violence, sensuality, gluttony, drunkenness, altered states of consciousness, getting high, idle pursuits, frivolity, or aimlessness. We're not to fight like a boxer who punches the air. We're not to run as someone with no destination. We're not to hide our treasure in the ground where it earns no interest. Whatever we put our talents to, we must do it with all our strength. Proverbs 15:22 - Without counsel plans fail, but with many advisers, they succeed.
Can’t have something without nothing.
It takes two to make a thing go right.
It takes two to make it outta sight!
Who made nothing? GOD