Who wins? Top 100 American Whiskeys of 2024

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 16 янв 2025

Комментарии • 108

  • @FredMinnick
    @FredMinnick  19 дней назад +3

    After you've watched the finals: x.com/FredMinnick/status/1873049163123798177

    • @EdSweeney-u9w
      @EdSweeney-u9w 19 дней назад

      @@FredMinnick As an old SOB, the talking filter I had, blew out a while ago around 60. Being frank, 100 whiskies is too many and probably going to kill ya at some point. Whether you’re eating lamb, drinking coconut water or spitting it out, it’s still not good. I would rather see a “sweet 16” for another 20 years than a top 100 for????? Be well.

  • @mikedubs9940
    @mikedubs9940 7 дней назад

    Geez Fred .It was nice getting buzzed with you.The spit cup is a belly acre but better than getting kicked in the nuts..If ya don’t sleep under the desk
    You make me laugh in a time when it is tougher to laugh.Thanks man.First for your service.

  • @michaelcastorino5184
    @michaelcastorino5184 9 дней назад

    Just got my Nashville Barrel Company Connected Spirits, your #4, and it’s incredible. The Pinhook is on the way. Thank you for your recommendation. Your list is always spot on with my palette.

  • @Lithanify
    @Lithanify 16 дней назад +1

    Can you confirm the ecbp batch that was 15? Seems b524 in video @35:00 (proof 130.6) but your list says a124.

  • @StreetGlizzy
    @StreetGlizzy 19 дней назад +11

    I said it when I tried my first sip, that RR15 was the best whiskey I had ever tried in my 38 years of life.

    • @MattD86
      @MattD86 19 дней назад

      @@mikedubs9940huh

  • @jonsnow782
    @jonsnow782 15 дней назад

    Super stoked to see the Ponfeigh Rye on the list, especially at 35. Awesome bottle that flies under the radar.

  • @mikedubs9940
    @mikedubs9940 19 дней назад +1

    You are a great man thank you. We should make more cats like you.

  • @nickp5511
    @nickp5511 19 дней назад +9

    Great job! Russell’s 15yr is awesome!!!!

  • @mikedubs9940
    @mikedubs9940 19 дней назад +1

    An excellent persona just a good dude

  • @7nash974
    @7nash974 19 дней назад +3

    Marked on the sheet as number 1 before he announced it?

  • @user-da3kjk2lk4lw
    @user-da3kjk2lk4lw 19 дней назад +6

    Why were Old Fitz 13 Year VVS, JD10/12, and Bardstown Bourbon Co Discovery Series 12 not considered?
    You mentioned Old Fitz decanter series was the worst this year. Are you referring to the 10 Year spring release? Or VVS?

  • @jamesparr188
    @jamesparr188 19 дней назад +2

    Redwood Empire's haystack needle from this year should have been in the top 5 at a minimum. One of the absolute best from 2024 imo.

    • @thersabugonmytv
      @thersabugonmytv 13 дней назад

      It’s a single barrel? You def didn’t try the one he had😂 I’ve had 3 and 2 of them were much better than the other

  • @DoubleTapFitness
    @DoubleTapFitness 19 дней назад +3

    I’m very curious.. how or why was Old Fitz 13 VVS not considered?

    • @gnrfan504
      @gnrfan504 19 дней назад

      Didn’t he call it the worse release of the year during the stream?

    • @user-da3kjk2lk4lw
      @user-da3kjk2lk4lw 19 дней назад

      @@gnrfan504 He did. However, he did not specify what release. Fall 2023? Spring 2024?, VVS? VVS was arguably one of the best releases this year. I believe it’s worth a mention at least (even if it does not qualify Top 100 for whatever reason).

    • @s.t.e.r.e.o.
      @s.t.e.r.e.o. 19 дней назад

      @@user-da3kjk2lk4lw I think he did mention it as a whole worst release

  • @jamesparr188
    @jamesparr188 19 дней назад +2

    What barrel # was the Nashville barrel Co bourbon? I've heard the #3XXX are the best from this year but was curious what you guys were tasting

    • @teofilstevenson
      @teofilstevenson 19 дней назад

      Good questiom

    • @jacobparrish7503
      @jacobparrish7503 19 дней назад +2

      These were both batched I believe, not SiBs.

    • @trackvol
      @trackvol 19 дней назад +1

      @@jamesparr188 it's my understanding that he disqualifies SiB from his personal top-100. So we shouldn't expect to find any SiB labels here. No matter how good a particular Henry McKenna, Russell's Single Barrel, King of Kentucky, Blanton's SFTB might be.

    • @trackvol
      @trackvol 19 дней назад +1

      @jacobparrish7503 that is my belief as well. He disqualifies SiB.

    • @s.t.e.r.e.o.
      @s.t.e.r.e.o. 19 дней назад +1

      He is doing a separate tasting for single barrels

  • @LittyGangGooch
    @LittyGangGooch 17 дней назад +1

    A good salesman could sell bad whiskey, but good whiskey sells itself, so I’d have to say the distiller is infinitely more important

    • @FireontheMountain321
      @FireontheMountain321 17 дней назад +1

      Agreed. A great salesman can sell bad whiskey once. A great distiller can sell good whiskey for a lifetime. Industry people who are more on the marketing side of things, like Minnick, put a greater emphasis on the importance of marketing, perhaps for job security. The whiskey industry is slowing in large part because of bad marketing/pricing and bloated marketing budgets. Whiskey became too popular and profitable too quickly, which allowed for people who do not actually care about whiskey into the industry.

  • @jessemichael3273
    @jessemichael3273 11 дней назад

    Bluegrass distillers drinking the blue corn and i got to bottle my own toasted from a single barrel ive been to both midway and lexington and tried the elkwood reserve great stuff its hard spending that much though

  • @AtilanoSetsuko
    @AtilanoSetsuko 19 дней назад

    Great content, as always! A bit off-topic, but I wanted to ask: My OKX wallet holds some USDT, and I have the seed phrase. (alarm fetch churn bridge exercise tape speak race clerk couch crater letter). How can I transfer them to Binance?

  • @jwalkblue7
    @jwalkblue7 17 дней назад

    The NBC Finest Small Batch surprised the hell out of me. Super fruity, but still some leather and oak that stuck around at the end. So mad at myself for not grabbing a backup while I could.

  • @gshankaran
    @gshankaran 19 дней назад +3

    What batch of Elijah Craig was it in position 15?

    • @stephenyuhas9162
      @stephenyuhas9162 18 дней назад

      Must be the 18 year? I wish they would say.

    • @il5bdb
      @il5bdb 18 дней назад +1

      B524 (earlier on the video it has a list that says 130.6 proof)

    • @Lithanify
      @Lithanify 16 дней назад

      His website says a124 which is insane... a124 was very very mediocre... b524 makes sense.

    • @stephenyuhas9162
      @stephenyuhas9162 16 дней назад

      A124 tastes like straight dirt

  • @randyshearer9886
    @randyshearer9886 19 дней назад +2

    Agree, did he invert 5-10?

    • @FredMinnick
      @FredMinnick  19 дней назад +3

      Yup. Caught in the rewatch. Sorry, man.
      x.com/fredminnick/status/1873049163123798177?s=46&t=PqrU0VPUECfaTpA-au6SJg

  • @cjjohnson4231
    @cjjohnson4231 19 дней назад

    Awesome list and great palette to taste this many at one time. Hoorah!!

  • @ChapsChris
    @ChapsChris 19 дней назад

    Taking care of yourself. Good for you, Fred!

  • @brazenmorris
    @brazenmorris 4 дня назад

    Bro what that hell is up with you tie, and no under shirt? Wild

  • @mikelester816
    @mikelester816 19 дней назад

    Is there a list in order.

    • @FredMinnick
      @FredMinnick  19 дней назад +2

      working on it

    • @mikelester816
      @mikelester816 19 дней назад

      @@FredMinnickI look forward to vehemently disagreeing with you 😁

    • @Gzickgraf
      @Gzickgraf 17 дней назад

      @@mikelester816it’s posted on his instagram now

  • @michaelcastorino5184
    @michaelcastorino5184 18 дней назад

    Anyone know the pinhook that on there?

    • @FredMinnick
      @FredMinnick  18 дней назад

      12: Pinhook Straight Bourbon Vertical Series 2024 Release (unfiltered) 9 Years Old, 114.3 Proof, $99.99

  • @michaelpauley4973
    @michaelpauley4973 17 дней назад

    Infinity but not the reserves. Like hear that explanation!

  • @EdSweeney-u9w
    @EdSweeney-u9w 19 дней назад +5

    Glass A is 5 or I don’t know this magic.

  • @mattstorr728
    @mattstorr728 19 дней назад

    It was a great time Fred! We appreciate what you do thanks for the time and effort put into the top 100🥃💨

  • @trini-xrp1656
    @trini-xrp1656 19 дней назад

    Happy i can find all 3 HH products collecting dust locally 😅...let me go get them

  • @mikedubs9940
    @mikedubs9940 7 дней назад

    There’s no way to taste all bourbons without getting gogleeyed.America loves our soldiers…Leather comes to mind.due to their strength

  • @mohavie2360
    @mohavie2360 6 дней назад

    Fred, id love to be able to blind taste like this brother. however, there are a couple things to note that could affect the taste of the whiskey as well. im sure u know this but whiskeys does start to taste a lil different as it work its way down the bottle. at every level of the bottle, depending on the time it sit in, the taste would alter a lil bit and different flavors become more prominant. secondly, i cant help but think all the water you were drinking. we all know as our bellys starts to fill up, our mind starts to think differently on what it like to taste. imo, if you are going to spit the spirit out, i also think you should spit most of the water out as well so your belly wont get to full. but once again, i love this list and wish i could have taste all of these in one setting:). ive done the GTS and Russells 13 & 15 side by side and for me personally, i like the GTS 2023 better because of how well rounded it is to my tasting.

  • @fishingtherapy4565
    @fishingtherapy4565 16 дней назад

    why wasn't weller 107 or cypb on the top 100?

  • @trackvol
    @trackvol 19 дней назад +1

    I called it. 2 or 3 weeks ago, I said this would be the winner, and it was!

    • @teofilstevenson
      @teofilstevenson 19 дней назад

      Dude, it’s been called the best for months now

  • @youknowweezy
    @youknowweezy 19 дней назад +3

    Agreed, RR15 stands alone!

  • @DaveC-n6z
    @DaveC-n6z 18 дней назад

    No bardstown disco 12?

  • @RobAnderssen
    @RobAnderssen 19 дней назад

    I volunteer to drink the coffee cup blend! 😂

    • @FredMinnick
      @FredMinnick  19 дней назад

      now that's a true bourbon fan. LOL

  • @dewalt5599
    @dewalt5599 19 дней назад

    2's finish fell of a clif. If you swallowed the top 10 how would your order have changed?

    • @retleftolcs
      @retleftolcs 19 дней назад +2

      @@dewalt5599 he judged the finish of many more last year. It was much more in depth.

  • @LittyGangGooch
    @LittyGangGooch 18 дней назад +1

    Way too many ads, just back to back

  • @gnrfan504
    @gnrfan504 19 дней назад +6

    Fred you messed up 5-10 man. Gotta go watch the film.

    • @FredMinnick
      @FredMinnick  19 дней назад

      x.com/fredminnick/status/1873049163123798177?s=46&t=PqrU0VPUECfaTpA-au6SJg

  • @retleftolcs
    @retleftolcs 19 дней назад

    I’m only seeing 2 comments. Where’d they all go?

    • @k.johnson2722
      @k.johnson2722 19 дней назад

      live stream comments won’t be here after the live ends

  • @pjwillsr
    @pjwillsr 19 дней назад +1

    Slow on the graphics/chunks.

  • @ghantakha5568
    @ghantakha5568 19 дней назад

    I have never, will never gonna argue on RR15 . Best one so far in my 4 yr bourbon journey. switched from scotch to bourbon . never looking to go back to malt again.

  • @betterphysicaltherapy
    @betterphysicaltherapy 19 дней назад +1

    Why no Jack Daniels offerings? JD SBBP Rye was easily top 100 and Coy Hill top 10.

  • @mikedubs9940
    @mikedubs9940 19 дней назад +1

    All of the ridiculous comments aside you’re a great one

    • @gnrfan504
      @gnrfan504 19 дней назад

      He did awesome. He made a small mistake where he did the tasting on the 5 through 10 spots and lined them out in the exact order he wanted them ranking them one by one against each other. And then when he finished he got distracted and called them in the wrong order but still pulled the top 4 in the right order. It was weird and I’m sure he will realize.

    • @FredMinnick
      @FredMinnick  19 дней назад

      Yup got it. The list will be the proper ranking and I tweeted about it as soon as I could review x.com/FredMinnick/status/1873049163123798177

    • @alexanderlai9160
      @alexanderlai9160 18 дней назад

      @@FredMinnick Great livestream, hope you've recovered! Hey, when you release the final list, make sure you have the correct Little Book version, because on the unranked top 100 list, it says chapter 8 but it has the price and proof of the Infinite version.

  • @Simplycoburn
    @Simplycoburn 19 дней назад +1

    That George t stagg is my number 1 this year

  • @jasonkimmins1717
    @jasonkimmins1717 13 дней назад +1

    Hate from Australia

  • @mikedubs9940
    @mikedubs9940 19 дней назад

    Ah we love it when ya get drum

  • @mikedubs9940
    @mikedubs9940 19 дней назад

    Lock stock and barrel 100

  • @mikedubs9940
    @mikedubs9940 19 дней назад

    Me too hidden barn

  • @mikedubs9940
    @mikedubs9940 19 дней назад

    100 drinks

  • @mikedubs9940
    @mikedubs9940 19 дней назад

    Ya need a team

  • @user-da3kjk2lk4lw
    @user-da3kjk2lk4lw 19 дней назад +1

    A bit disappointing not seeing stuffs that are actually findable.

  • @jonathanfinkel3461
    @jonathanfinkel3461 19 дней назад

    ruclips.net/user/clipUgkxdEXSgy7oJlaXX9xEFhMETSBzYio251TJ?si=C6b5cqTRxUq4CxjS
    "it PROBABLY will make my top 100..." finishes 3rd...

    • @FredMinnick
      @FredMinnick  19 дней назад +1

      thanks for sharing that cllip. not gonna lie this doing so well was one of the bigger surprises for me. held up, though. blinds don't lie

    • @FireontheMountain321
      @FireontheMountain321 17 дней назад

      @@FredMinnickBlinds can lie based on many factors. Next year, you may want to blind bottles multiple times and see if you consistently rank them high.

  • @ShadeShifted
    @ShadeShifted 18 дней назад +10

    Good grief I had no idea this would be so incredibly boring to watch. Wow, there’s no way people sit through the entire thing.

    • @FireontheMountain321
      @FireontheMountain321 17 дней назад +1

      Surprised he didn’t put some Total Wine house brands in his top five. Cellar Aged at 67th behind a lot of these other bottles should be illegal.

  • @mikedubs9940
    @mikedubs9940 19 дней назад

    😂😂😂

  • @mikedubs9940
    @mikedubs9940 19 дней назад

    A fart?

  • @mikedubs9940
    @mikedubs9940 19 дней назад +1

    Most of which we never try.Getting bored.just saying

  • @mikedubs9940
    @mikedubs9940 19 дней назад

    To call this distinguished is silly…my huckleberry

  • @mikedubs9940
    @mikedubs9940 19 дней назад

    Pooped

  • @mikedubs9940
    @mikedubs9940 19 дней назад

    Just don’t thank SLB.. they have a lot.of pooo

  • @mattstorr728
    @mattstorr728 19 дней назад

    It was a great time Fred! We appreciate what you do thanks for the time and effort put into the top 100🥃💨

  • @mikedubs9940
    @mikedubs9940 7 дней назад

    Geez Fred .It was nice getting buzzed with you.The spit cup is a belly acre but better than getting kicked in the nuts..If ya don’t sleep under the desk
    You make me laugh in a time when it is tougher to laugh.Thanks man.First for your service.

  • @mikedubs9940
    @mikedubs9940 19 дней назад

    Lock stock and barrel 100