The N Word
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 18 сен 2024
- It's not "my country right or wrong", and it's certainly not "no wall no USA at all", it's "make my country right, when it is wrong".
-----
Join the community discord! ► / discord
Watch Us LIVE (And Click Dat Sub Button!) ► / gameboomers
GB Archive Channel ► / gameboomer
Dev Kit Channel ► / @thedevkit
SFO Backups Channel ► / channel
BitChute ► www.bitchute.c...
Rumble ► rumble.com/c/c...
Brighteon ► www.brighteon....
DailyMotion ► www.dailymotio...
Odysee ► odysee.com/@Sh...
-----
SUPPORT THE SHOW:
BTC:bc1q6udqgvfm9uaj59l24ut7f73wvsfu707kk6pn3m
SubscribeStar! ► www.subscribes...
Streamlabs! ► streamlabs.com...
Patreon! ► / shortfatotaku
Paypal! ► paypal.me/short...
Humble Bundle Affiliate Link! ► www.humblebund...
Amazon CAN Affiliate Link! ► amzn.to/322aFAa
Amazon USA Affiliate Link! ► amzn.to/30PLxgN
Amazon CAN Wishlist! ► www.amazon.ca/...
Amazon USA Wishlist! ► www.amazon.com...
-----
SFO-CIAL MEDIA! HYUK HYUK
DA TWEETS ► / sfosecretary
DA FACES ► / sfotaku
DA GABS ► www.gab.com/sh...
DA MINDS ► www.minds.com/...
DA PARLERS ► parler.com/pro...
DA STEAMS ► steamcommunity....
-----
Credits:
Thumbnail ► Me!
Background ► / cryomancerlex
Music ► • Parasite Eve OST - Out...
#CanadaDay #CanadaDay2021
Honestly, the belief that the native americans have some kind of everlasting ownership of America means you believe in racial nationalism.
B...ba..based????
Native American ethnostate when?
Yes, it's based to point out how primitive the Native American ethic is...
While strutting about as if they also have eternal moral righteousness over every other American in some way, *_and ofc, especially the white man lol._*
They fought a war against more technologically sophisticated colonizers and lost.
*_They can get the fuck over it._*
The way of the world in the past was: Conquer or Be Conquered.
*_They're just humiliated that they lost, and now their hatred is a petty, pathetic form of vengeance._*
@@avemarduk3718 What's hilarious is these same high and mighty Native Americans can't even acknowledge that most of their tribes had conquered, enslaved, and subjugated other tribes for centuries before them darn evil wypipo ever showed up. The idea that any race, ethnicity, or state has any moral high ground regarding conquest is a farce.
Especially when they are not the original inhabitants of North America. The tribes we call native Americans are of a Siberian ancestor. The oldest remains in America were the kennewick man who is actually a Causcoid, ancient European. Recent studies even back up that a different population predates the tribes who crossed the Pacific Ocean on the ice land bridges. In many of their cultures, especially the earliest ones, they had stories of encountering “pale skinned goat eaters” when they arrived in America who they warred with and pushed North. As we know from our study of the Incans, some of pale skins went south and established many of the tribes along central and south America, with influence even among Gulf based empires such as the Aztecs whose founder was a Causcoid.
I'm 25% black so I say the "n" word at only a quarter of my usual volume as per the instructions from the bro communist manifesto which also informs me that I must conform and accept my victimhood now that we have reverted back to the "one drop" rules.
I disagree with communizim
"reverted" when was it ever not the case?
I’m half black, so I only say ‘nig’.
"Patriotism is supporting your country all the time, and your government when it deserves it."- Mark Twain
Had hoped he'd compare nationalism and patriotism
@@ShermanistDruid That was Charles De Gaulle.
As i remember he said that patriotism is the love of your country compared to everyone else. While Nationalism is the hate of everyone else except your nation.
Mark Twain didn’t day that, but still a good quote.
@@ShermanistDruid patriotism is a mindset while nationalism is more of a political ideology
@@Nathan-jh1ho
I'd say they're both political ideologies it's just that nationalism have been the popular one for the last +100 years.
I'd say that patriotism is about preserving the effort that previous generation have been invested in the country, while nationalism is imo top down state or king and contains a vague ideal of the perfect citizen.
I've been tricked, backstabbed, and quite possibly bamboozled
"We've been spackledorffed!"
"That's not even a word and I agree with you"
Its a surprise, but a welcome one!
Run amuck, led astray,
Somewhat kerfuffled
@@Emppu_T. Bewildered.
immigrants must prove their nationalism to qualify for citizenship, but citizens are discouraged from showing nationalism...
I love how people hate the only countries that allow them to spew their hate.
Probably because those countries allow a bunch of other things to happen as well. Bad-mouth the CIA? How dare you criticize a country that gives you the privilege to do that!
on some level I can understand it; its like a woman who always nags and provokes her husband for no real reason. She has a biological urge to periodically test his mettle and check to see if he has become more or less pathetic/useless. Thus, the more the husband offers no resistance and just takes her abuse, the stronger her urge to provoke him and force him to stand up for himself; women don't want pathetic and submissive men, nor should they.
I'd wager a BIG part of the reason these people have these beliefs is purely because they know they're not supposed to. On some primal level, they want to test the mettle of their society and see how pathetic and submissive it is. Well we've let them get away with their nonsense again and again and again and again, to levels no other society would even begin to tolerate: how can they help but keep moving goalposts? We've proven ourselves so weak and submissive to their insane demands, so unwilling to lift a finger in defense of our own values, children, property, and sometimes even lives, how can they not be completely obsessed with doing anything and everything to provoke a reaction? What fucking good are we if we can't even stand up to shrieking, insane manchildren whose power comes ENTIRELY from our unwillingness to just fucking say, "no"? Why on earth would they want to identify themselves with such a pathetic and weak society? Why not do everything in their completely unearned power to replace our weak and useless population with 3rd world patriarchs who will, at the very least, stand up for their own families and communities instead of wagging their finger as it all falls apart around them?
Western society has become an impotent, hen-pecked husband, and radical leftists are our nagging wife. She's a cunt, yeah, but she wouldn't even dream of acting that way if we just grew a sliver of a fucking spine.
@@geomancer6894 the CIA is not the country, nor is the government the country. I hate the government but I love my country
@@geomancer6894 the CIA isn’t America lmao
@@jaredkalergi5498 I would agree with you more except you don't take in to account that modern man isn't allowed to stand up to his wife if he doesn't want to face prison time and societal scorn just like the third worlder is allowed by society to stand up for himself in the West because the establishment protects them from being held accountable for their actions.
If there was no punishment for standing up for yourself more people would do it like they did in the past. Now with a highly centralized and controlled society with the elite protecting the nagging wife and uppity third worlder for a reason to keep down good people, the only actions are to either take it or start a revolution to overthrow it.
Clicked onto this with blazing speed.
Indeed!
Same
The word stated summons me
There are literally people who get offended at the American flag.
Good, Let them stay afraid of a symbol of the Free world.
🎩
🐍 no step on Snek! 🇺🇸🇭🇰
> symbol of the free world
Precisely why they fear it.
3 types of socialism
Of people = communism
Of state = fascism
Of race = nazism
Last I checked Symbol of the Free World didn't mean dismantling countries because muh democracy.
@@darunealbane Socialism is economic policy. America is Market Socialism. Haven't been Capitalist since the Regan Admin.
@@SilvesterBathroomStallone Wrong name for that kind of talk.
You don't forget, lest you repeat history. You forgive.
this exactly. Dev should have said forgive, not forget.
i was quoting him
Regarding the Topic of History being dragged up, People blamed/asked to pay for it who weren't even alive back then, i found there is a huge Double Standard among People and their Countries Bad Deeds in History and Bad Deeds of other Countries History, i recently noticed something curious
F.e.: I recently noticed that you find this also a lot among People of the American Right (at least Personalities) who usually have reasonable and logical Takes, but when it comes to this? Oh Boy
I found a lot of American Conservative Commentators who talk about how Slavery f.e. shouldn't be constantly dragged up and thrown at Americans. Yet at the same time i was surprised to see that a lot of them only believe that when it comes to Things their Country has done that was horrible.
They at the same Time (Now that all of the Holocaust Victims and Perpetrators are almost all gone) that this is a bad thing and how it's dangerous because it will make Germans stop being aware of what, and i quote "Their Relatives/Grandpas/Great Grandpas have done to Jews"
Apparently we Germans not born or having anything to do with that Time are likely to either not care about it or turn into Nazis if the Holocaust isn't the Top Topic of German History anymore.
It kinda shows the Double Standards sadly a lot of People have when it comes to such Topics á la "Blaming Slavery on Americans nowadays, or keep dragging it up and constantly talk about it in Public Discourse, Media etc. is a bad thing, People should not do that."
But when it comes to other Countries and their Population who had nothing to do with a Horrible Thing their Country did in the Past, you see the same People suddenly constantly want to bring it up, think it needs to be constantly hammered into that Countries' Peoples Brains, Claim that Country "wants to forget it, doesn't care about it" etc etc.
Whenever someone, even if i agree with them on a lot and share their Politics, shows a huge Lack of Facts and Logic and Reason etc. on just one Topic alone, i start to question their Authenticity as well as if they have any Respect for their Viewers & the Fact that they will notice the Double Standard
In the case above i was happy that there always were some Top Comments towards these certain Conservative American Personalities and how they didn't expect someone who supports "Facts & Logic and not Emotions over Facts & Logic" not applying this universally.
Was glad to see that they have American Fans who noticed the Double Standard and spoke out to them about it
ruclips.net/video/W9qSfCGbuJ0/видео.html
I love that you use contryballs when you talk about contrys
thats actually nice
Gtfo you anime pfp!!
@@thhrjdh5564 you're watching a channel with the name "otaku"
@@birdinformation4505 but does he have an anime pfp???
@@thhrjdh5564 ruclips.net/video/ahrBOvz1jzA/видео.html
@@thhrjdh5564 stfc
I like osaka
And uzaki, miku, kaede and other cool anime girls
"If you're an English liberal getting mad at me talking about this, don't worry, the rest of French philosophy is garbage, you're fine."
Me: *quietly puts away the musket*
Screw the musket, and break out the pikemen. Me thinks we need another Hundred Years’ War to remind people what suffering really looks.
@@kyriss12longbowmen.
I was 2 when the final residential school was shut down. I really don't think that I should be held responsible for actions taken by a Government that was elected before I was even born, regardless of how heinous those actions were. Happy Canada Day Dev.
I'm the child of a residential school survivor. And when it's said that the trauma reverberates down the generations I know exactly what that means. And I agree with you completely.
Since I first heard of the calls to cancel Canada Day I thought it was stupid. Canceling Canada Day would and will (since many communities did so) only upset people whom the First Nations' should be trying to get on their side. It's just ..., well, stupid. Yes there are bad things in our country's history. But there are lots of good things too. We should celebrate the good and remember the bad - so we can do better in the future.
So I thought a much better idea would have been to hold Canada Day celebrations and set aside 15 or 20 minutes. Invite a survivor or local chief to come in and give a short speech or personal story about how residential schools were bad, umkay. And then a couple minutes silence for those buried in the newly rediscoverd Graves, and then go on with things. This would inform more people without just poinlessly getting them angry at you.
But of course the leftist twitterauty won't settle for anything less then maximum negative impact. But the First Nations' leadership should know better then to line up behind those demands. Unfortunately it seems they don't actually know better.
@@PresleyPerswain Thank you for understanding. The events that took place were unacceptable and we need to be vigilant that things like the residential school scenario never happens again, but this really feels like the left is trying to pick at a scab here. The wounds don't heal when you constantly rip the band-aid off to show everyone how nasty the cut was.
Smarter people than me (Dr. Savage) defines a nation as: common language, common culture, and borders. I think I'll stick to that.
Snap into a Slim Jim ! Oooohhhh yeeeaahhh!
@@cptfarzkizz8823 Need a little excitemenT? SNAP INTO A SLIM JIM!!!! OOOH YEAHHH
@@yarlodek5842 much better 😁
America is absolutely NOT a nation by your definition. No shared language. No shared culture. No enforced border.
Change my mind.
@@terminsane indeed, it's a collection of many nations. Probably around 50.
I feel more American than Cuban, I am an American Nationalist.
American is not a race, it's a creed.
Why would you want to be Cuban??
@@TGNXAR isnt his point based on neither being race but both being nation? Since you know... the whole video is nations.
@@TherealTenmanI Mandalorian reference.
Yes, the USA is a nation, but not one based upon an ethnicity or race, but on (as Dev said) civic nationalism. That is, based upon an ideal, or a creed.
Merica merica uber alles
I thought this was just gonna be a clip of Dev having a heated Gamer moment, I was disappointed when I saw the video's length.
I mean it still could‘ve been one, but thats one hell of heated gamer moment.
@@SwampGreen14 like something Louis Le Vau would do
"Would you want that?"
No. The good amounts for SOMETHING. Every single one of these people that I've talked to about this refuse to budge an inch and reject that the good amounts for something. Slavery being made illegal means something. If the only things that matter are the atrocities, then bring back the slaves. Since apparently doing good accounts for nothing.
I disagree with that sentiment btw, that doing good accounts for nothing. I resoundingly reject the notion my ancestors were completely evil and beyond any redemption when they worked to end slavery world wide when they didn't have to. It's beyond the pale to just delete all the good they tried to promote, did, in favor of focusing exclusively on the evils of other members of the society.
P.S. Sure don't forget the evils, but don't forget them BOTH. Otherwise what's the point of remembering just the evils?
Exactly, never forget the bad, but never forget the good as well. People aren't evil or good, it's all shades of grey, it's all nuances and complicated. If they can't see it that way, they are willfully blind because they want to feel and be a victim rather than actually be a responsible adult.
The entire population growth of poorer countries especially in africa is an exclusive result of the technological and scientific progress and trillions of dollars of foreign aid from the opressive nations.
Before that they had subsistence farming and 4 out of 6 children died Before reaching adulthood.
The ammount of untimely deaths prevented by this evil opressors goes into the billions.
This positive outlook on Western civilisation is also completely justifief
"I'm assuming you are probably from America..."
Me from Brazil:
I mean, Brazil is in America
Its in South America
Yea unimaginative colonizers kinda messed that up. Is it to late to rename continents?
@@LuciferNyx404
Yes there is: “American”.
@@LuciferNyx404 "United Statians"?
As I'm watching a JonTron video, a Dev video comes up! Gotta watch both now ahh
Anyway, as a child of a Vietnamese immigrant, I can understand the importance of nationalism and I believe I am a Canadian patriot. Our country has issues but what country doesn't? I stand by Canada even though it's getting worse in regards to free speech and I wish it could be fixed. I'm just one voter. :x
Let's go get some '
It's both heartwarming and concerning to see that some of the most ardent supporters of the west are people who have immigrated here
Funny, I got the reverse, watching a SFO video while being recommended a jontron vid.
@@conservativedemocracyenjoyer yeah it is concerning but maybe it takes a different perspectives and differing point of view in life to appreciate the west more
Pride in ethnic background is nationalism.
Pride in civic background is patriotism.
They are not interchangeable, despite being used so.
Didn't know you were the word-boss, I use both to describe myself in relation to America, and if you don't like it, go suck a fart...
GIVE ME MY MUSKET, THE GERMANS ARE TALKING ABOUT NATIONALISM AGAIN
Nationalism doesn’t have a side. Idk why people keep saying it leads to fascism when it doesn’t. Even thd USSR was Nationalistic to an extreme degree
assign things along a left-right continuum is one if the biggest red herrings of layman political science
I like this comment.
In the end, nationalism is simply a byproduct of human nature and our need to live in communities as a social animal. Nationalism is a force of nature like fire or gravity, and can be used for good or ill.
It's because people don't actually know much about fascism beyond the nationalistic aspect.
@@somercet1 lol no, it was in 1920 when Polish kicked Bolsheivks ass, and the Whites rallied the old Guard to protect Mother land.
the problem with globalism is at some point all governments do bad things and if their is one government their is no where to run to.
it blows my mind that people think a globalized government would somehow be less corrupt and more effective
@@Vizaru that is why I don't push my options of Nationalism on people often. I'm not a globalist and don't desire land by force. Eventually people will come together if we can get free speech. Sadly it is people within my tribe that control and act out much of the censorship.
FYI: "Aboriginal survivors of Canada’s residential school era have mixed emotions about the Canadian federal government’s November 23 decision to pay $2 billion in reparations to survivors. Although satisfying to some, the financial compensation has left other survivors feeling insulted, if not infuriated.
The unprecedented reparations deal includes a $10,000 "common experience" payment to the approximately 90,000 living students who attended the residential schools; an additional $3,000 for every year the students attended; nearly $200 million in funding for healing and educational programs; and the option of pursuing individual claims of abuse through the courts. Survivors 65 years and older can apply for an early payment of $8,000."
This was agreed on in 2006.
And this is my point too. Injustice at the State level cannot be healed with money. This isn’t wrongful imprisonments of individuals. It is badly considered public policy. It is an argument for libertarianism and nothing more. Even residential schools were entirely evil as an attempt to commit cultural genocide, the nation is not liable for those wrongs. Germans filled the camps in WW2. Are Jews able to keep asking for money from them?? Nope. They are entitled to remind people of the past... but I cannot be held responsible financially for the decisions of my forefathers. If I am, then I will do what I can to avoid that liability. And that means finishing the job of cultural extermination and that is NOT the ideal of nationalism that Dev outlines.
A fellow Canadian here. My wife and I discussed the Canada day celebration a few times over the last week and decided we would enjoy it as usual. I refuse to carry the burden of guilt and shame for something I didn't do and couldn't prevent. I feel anger and frustration on behalf of the Indigenous people that were destroyed over a horrible ideology and I won't ever forget it, but I won't take on the weight of another's evil. Peace and Happy Canada Day.
As a child of a residential school survivor, one who understands the reality of intergenerational trauma these institutions created, I say good for you. The cancel Canada Day movement is really stupid IMHO. I would rather celebrations were carried out as normal, but perhaps community organized ones took 15 or 20 minutes out to let a survivor or chief give a speech, or better yet tell a story about how these schools were bad and then a minute or 2 of silence for the recently rediscovered grave sites. It would inform more people, without angering themby taking away their celebrations.
I mean, I’m racist, so I can say it
D O N T S A Y I T
Do it
@Chad Deo Vindice i
@Chad Deo Vindice G
@Chad Deo Vindice i'm gonna call 911 😤📞👮
Joke btw
Nationalism, at its core, is recognizing that your country--be it native or adopted--is good or has done good even as it has done wickedness.
Damn Right
No. It's not a question of good. That is subjective to individual values. It core is the strength of national values. It is a faith in the people. It's why some seek to divide in such petty ways. People born of the land. To be adopted is fine but one should recognize why they want it first. A paper cannot truly hold the values of the people and words are also only of the individual. Support free speech.
No... that's inherently wrong
YES
Civic Nationalism, that is the name of what I believed all along...
Nippon?
Though he was going to say a certain country that sounds like “knee jerk”. You know the word, it starts with N
You know the thing
If you call niger nijer then you shall be slaughtered
Oh right it’s our favourite salad dressings
Montenegro
Country that starts with N...
Hmm...
Must be Norway
“French philosophy is garbage” Dev, you know you could of just removed philosophy and replaced French with France?
Its still good out in the country and smaller towns. The big cities are f'd now though. I seen it happen over 20 + years. A definate case of urban decay.
Oh and taxes are insane now there. You would not believe,
@@vlnow yeah, despite my rather disparaging comment, I do love both France and her people. Paris though and other urban areas are pretty unpleasant, though that goes for most of the western world.
I'm so tired of this platform. 90% of my comments vanish seconds after I type them.
i see this one!
I'm so happy you're talking about nationalism! I hope you're well
same
Nationalism and socialism are not necessarily opposed. Marxism and nationalism are (at least in theory). Socialism is a matter of market intervention by the state. Quite commonly a strong aspect of Nationalist states. National socialism, which was progressively moving away from a free market state, should be rightly recognized as an example of this.
The problem is the obsession with forcing everything onto the left/right dichotomy: the similarities between fascist and communist states are handwaved away with horseshoe theory, stopping people from looking deeper into the matter.
Ha. I thought this was going to be you getting cancelled for that custom cola bottle. Still time I guess...
Now that's some clickbait and the best video intro I've ever seen on YT
HOO BOY, THIS WILL BE GOOD
Watching this before it gets banned
0:31 damn you dev. I'm not angry, just disappointed.
Nah dev is based
As someone born and raised in the US. The South even. If a mass grave was found of dead slaves I think there would be at least some relief in being able to recover some that were never found and given proper burial. There has been a long, loooong issue of there never being proper accounts of who they were or anything about them and who these days they may have ties to. Families that have lived here so long but never knew who their ancestors were because they were never given the thought to record anything about them or even those that died at sea on their way. There's better ways to find out information on remains of both humans and animals and even things like rocks and other things in the world to properly date all information possible.
I'd have to say 'NO' to the idea of July 4th being cancelled. In fact if something like this was found around then or very recently, it should be celebrated as part of it. Having found a large piece of history that could properly be placed and recorded among the many other things we have to share our history. The good and the absolutely terrible things must be out there to show nobody is perfect but the perfect storms happened to somehow make things as they are today.
I'd be happy to say, if that mass grave was found that I'd be able to say 'You were missed. Welcome back and in a time where you can be properly be remembered instead of further hurt from what you passed. Your history has been sorely missed and welcomed to stand side by side instead of casually forgotten.'
Honestly Dev... asking about these sorts of things in other countries is kinda... not good if you don't really know what the feelings are or thoughts on these things as states. The South has a lot of need of recovering things that not only the past, but all sorts of terrible weather has destroyed and buried so far down that people desperately want to recover anything possible.
Nice insight
@@Rain..._ Thank you. Normally anything said from anyone from the South gets shouted down but I know Dev enough to know I can at least say something and not have to worry about specific bias.
I mean the Prussians were fighting wars to unify the German people... it’s not like he predicted something that did not occur not too long ago. The Austrians are Germanic and the Prussians did want to bring them into the Empire.
"if you're an English liberal..."
**Cough** Sargon **cough**
Are you accusing me of grooming?!
WOOO SFO video on my birthday.
happy birthday!
its my birthday too:)
@@ShortFatOtaku thanks Dev
Similar shit we have to deal with down in the upside-down colonies. Waaaay too many ree-rees refer to Australia Day as Invasion Day (ahistorically may I add). Just wait till they start suggest the Canadian flag be changed...
Well for Canada it actually makes sense to change the flag considering it doesn't hold any actual deep meaning.
The colonial flag ironically was more representative than the current flag
Ya almost got me there Dev.
As a foreigner to the West, I never understood the insane and asinine hate towards Nationalism.
Aren't you supposed to (at least) be proud of your good traditions, culture, achievements, among other things, not actively fight it and try to destroy it?
For fuck's sake, a lot of (vocal) people are saying that waving your country's flag is "racist" and "fascist" because the small moustache man and his army did it too. When you say that in any country, people automatically know that your goals and intents are malicious, and thus you're an enemy, but the West seems to glorify these people. What the fuck?
What country are you from originally?
@@SpartanTrigger ...sorry, but the situations regarding my country makes talking about it (or even mentioning it) tad a bit difficult.
The N word with a hard R is Nascar
Yes. I know about that word that begins with "n" and ends in "r", that describes horrible people:
NEIGHBOR!
If they want to be an enemy then that's fine with me.
I know a bad word that has an n, an i, an er, and a g or two. Yes gents, I'm talking about
-
-
-
-
-
-
Ginger!
I’d like to add that nationalism was initially created, if not originally thought of, by the Western Hemisphere because of the destruction of monarchy and absence of any strong ethnic connection. America and the rest of the hemisphere needed another justification for their own independence. Civic nationalism is significantly harder to implement when the native population didn’t die in a mass depopulation like the native peoples of the Americas
I disagree with the big fat check part. As a permanent resident in Canada I pay those taxes but have no personal or even ancestral connection with anything Canada did wrong.
The Canadian government committed horrible atrocities to those native children in the residential schools, many of whom still live to this day, and in the justice system when someone is wronged they have a legal right to receive compensation, in this case from the Canadian State. The fact you didn't personally attack native children has nothing to do with whether or not the Canadian state should compensate those it has abused. If the Canadian government decides, and it almost certainly won't, to compensate the survivors of the residential school system, your taxes won't be raised either way because the Canadian government does not really pay for thing with taxes anyway, but with a complex combination of debts, bonds, fiat currency and the like.
Yes. it is true. Canadian government did do the exact same thing China is doing to Uygur muslims today back in 1860's
But unlike China, the government realized that that was wrong and put an end to it and tried to give back what was lost.
We are trying to heal. We want to make things right under the current restraints of 2021 societal standards.
No we can't just leave and give back all the land. That's not how modern society works. We need to come together and try and settle our differences and try to move forward as one people. one nation.
Now call me a Nazi and block me on social media.
Me and my classmates had a sorta similar discussion in history class, but we were talking about Christopher Columbus Day. A lot of the black students said that we shouldn't celebrate that day since Christopher Columbus was a bad person, I said that we shouldn't forget about the day though, and at least remember all of the different explorers and stuff, like the Explorers Day in Animal Crossing. Idk, this video just kinda reminded me of that debate so I thought I'd put it out there.
Mexican culture has a history of aztec human sacrifices. Its also full of beautiful art and architecture
"I'm assuming you're probably an american listening to this right now"
LMAO XD NAH I'm Norwegian
Here's my problem with the idea that we should just cash out checks to everyone affected by this tragedy: It may be the government of Canada that is responsible, but they are my tax dollars going towards any check that is being sent. It is not the people who are responsible for this tragedy who will suffer the consequences. It is the modern Canadian.
Let me be clear, I'm not saying this shouldn't be the solution. I think it may be the best solution out of a lot of bad options. But the Canadian government, as much as we would like to be able to hold it accountable as a distinct entity, punishing it punishes every Canadian even if we had nothing to do with the bad decisions it made in the past.
In my opinion, the people directly responsible for the decisions that caused the tragedy should be the ones who suffer the consequences. We're instead diffusing responsibility across the giant face of the federal government, and these individuals suffer no real consequences. It's not justice. It's just an easy way to appear to be doing justice.
Aahhh my N words!
My fellow Nationalists 🙋🏽♂️
Nationalism. Love it.
Come to Dee-Troit sometime.
I can understand the anger and the hurt felt towards the sins of a country's past. Hindsight is 20/20. However, I don't care about the indignation leftists feel and I simply want to be left alone when I celebrate and enjoy holidays and entertainment.
having a big think about this video as USA independence day is tomorrow and I just KNOW Twitter is gonna be hostile as fuck to actual unironic celebration of the holiday
It's ok. Statues were pulled down so history has been fixed.
This is really good. I'm shocked I haven't had this explained to me by any other RUclipsr or teacher. Thank you, Dev.
Glad you liked it!
Hey Dev I'm status Metis here in Canada and have met and known residential school survivors (but not being one myself), yet this talk of "Cancelling Canada day" has concerned me while I believe the government should fix what it has done wrong and help the people that they have wronged, and perhaps a more sombre Canada day is necessary this year, at the end of the day despite my own love for my culture, we are all Canadians and need to get along and move past our darkness while still ensure that justice is done. Fighting over this like many people have will ensure that we will never be able to move forward nor true justice be done. Anyway, I agree with you Happy Canada Day.
"in order to live in civil society you must eventually forget."
no. you can forgive, but if you forget then you open yourself to the problems of the past. if we forget about the rise of communism in germany during the end of WW1 and the interwar period then we forget how Hitler rose to power and become susceptible to the rise of another. if we forget the massacres of the past then we become susceptible to the demonizing of the reactions to such massacres. just like someone with amnesia, the lack of knowledge of the past results in naivety that can become preyed upon, either knowingly or unknowingly.
he didn't speak in english. could be a translation thing. i think we get the point.
@@ShortFatOtaku "Forget" had a subtly broader connotation in older English, I think. It reminds me of the Bible verses that say God forgets our sins: He absolutely forgives sins, but I doubt He looks at the nail-print scars of His torturous death and wonders where they came from...
@@ZeDawgear forget and forgive are about the same age, though forgive migrated to english in the 1500s, so from an english perspective 13th century is forget and 16th century is forgive. plenty of bibles use forgive rather than forget.
@@ShortFatOtaku before forgive (root word germanic) there was pardon (root word latin). he may have meant that the francs had peacefully assimilated the natives, rather than through more brutal means. during the french revolution there was an idea that you could do the same by stripping away a persons national identity and forcing yours on theirs, resulting in a global nation and thus end all wars and strife between classes. it stems from a scientific theory that variations of living things are a matter of environment and by treating something different from conception onward you could change them into a different variation. most europeans were under this umbrella, but africans were not and thus it wasn't a conflict of their version of equality to bring back slavery (abolition began in 1315). based on the events given context to the quote the quote is more about assimilating others into a culture rather than 2 merging into a third unifying culture. if i am right then it is one of the foundational ideas of communism, in that it is the ruling class which imposes false divisions on the lower class and by eliminating those divisions you eliminate strife in the lower classes. this is done by stripping people of their national identity in favor of the communist's 'class' identity (which is just another national identity).
i haven't studied the underlying philosophies of communism, instead i read the early philosophies communists used to support their ideas, though i did go more into the scientific ones as that has killed millions well after it was debunked (well before communism came about too).
The two dirty no no words nowadays are “nationalism” and “capitalism”, keep in mind n@zis we’re left wing but nationalists ,just like the soviets, soviets were super nationalists by the way
The Nazis were not left wing, they were centre right, they sought to uphold heirarchies, but they were socialist.
@@electricelephant7471 They were economically far left and socially far right
The USSR was an interesting paradox. Under Lenin, the bolsheviks tried to completely dismantle all forms of nationalism, up until Poland demolished them and they realized that blind ideology wasnt actually as useful a tool to maintain cohesion in as diverse an empire as the USSR.
Stalin took this a step (or twelve) further by basically completely reviving the idea of Russian ultra-nationalism, just with the red star instead of the double headed eagle, in order to fight WW2, or the Great Patriotic War as it is known in Russia.
After Stalin's death, the communists took a kind of weird middle ground, they got rid of Russian ultra-nationalism again like Lenin wanted, but instead of becoming internationalist as Lenin and Trotsky had envisioned, instead simply replace it with a new, "Soviet" nationalism.
This is why Stalin occupies this strange sort of spot of admiration in Russian culture, he was the first time since the revolution that Russia itself was considered strong, and while Stalin was doubtless evil, cruel, and insane, he DID rally the Russian people against what was essentially an attempt by the Germans at mass ethnic-cleansing.
@@viysnjor4811 I prefer Dev's triangle model he talks about. I don't think interventionism is what makes something left or right, that's the libertarian/totalitarian axis. Left right is about tradition and preserving heirarchies vs the left equality and flattening heirarchy.
@@electricelephant7471 Where did he talk about his triangle model?
Dev, you were so close to greatness. You could have received a sponsorship from the NYJA if you had only said the word.
I enjoyed the vid tho.
In 2007, the Canadian federal government began a program to identify and pay living victims of residential schools. The payout was a maximum of $275 000 depending on the abuse suffered and these payoutd went to about 38 000 people. So there's the big fat cheque mentioned by SFO.
Some people will say that you can't reverse years of abuse with a pile of cash, which is absolutely true. But most people who make that point aren't doing it in good faith; they're just leveraging your goodwill because they want something.
5:45 just wanted to say this part is extremely inaccurate. The people of Prussia used to speak Baltic, such as Old Prussian. Idk where he got Slavic from they're completely different groups.
The lands around Brandenburg (Berlin) used to be Slavic. Maybe he was reffering to this?
We still haven't found any supposed bodies in Canada
No, I'm tired of these "stains" without noting the remarkable things. Especially where a mistake is now treated as such, and effort, however incremental is taken to do better. If that's done, you focus on what you've done well. And seek to replicate and improve on it.
This works the same for people. You likely know people who only focus on their worst mistakes or errors. Do they grow and improve? Or are they miserable, and often make those around them the same?
What about those who've made mistakes, but focus on improving and their accomplishments? Not someone who doesn't believe they made any mistakes, but ones who acknowledge it but don't dwell on them?
They tend to be the heartfelt success stories you see around. And your country can again too if they people choose to do the same.
Just one correction:
While Israel is in theory supposed to be a jewish state only, their arab minority is very large. Around 30% of their population is Arab.
OH NO, THE N-WORD!!! AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH
Oh, this is going to be good.
Oh.
You sound so disappointed.
Even your PFP is sad.
3 videos in one week??? It must be Hanukkah
Great video. I believe shared values are a far better foundation than a nation than genetics. Some people will value freedom, some equality. Some will value stability, and some will value change. There is no way to hold a nation together based on genetics with people of opposing values without using force and compelling the minority to submit to the majority, which will always end in war and balkanization eventually.
A nation based on shared values and mutual respect for those who may not share their values is the only rational choice for human freedom and prosperity.
Probably your best video in a long time. I can tell you read Ben Shapiro’s Right Side of History.
This is almost spooky. I was literally thinking about most of what you talk about throughout this week.
I live in a bitterly divided country and get appalled when people suggest only splitting into ethnic states would guarantee peace.
Most people have no idea how say Europe also had many different 'tribes'.
The point about forgetting the past is so important.
"Civic Nationalism"? Oh you mean a Republic. Hail Rome.
For some reason I feel like the Roman anthem would be playing in the background after that hail Rome lol
The agreed-upon willingness to forget slights and massacres to forge a whole out of factions. Is that why Quebec license plates say "je me souviens"? 🤔
Best possible title
It's called we do a little trolling
Is this because of the debate Destiny had about the definition of genocide?
Also, thank you for reminding me that country balls(& one Jew cube) are a thing.
Most likely because Dev is Canadian and it is Canada Day
A civic nation is a IDEA that everyone can get behind. A common goal for all to seek,work, and fight for
Civic Nationalism is just another word for Empire and I wish people would warm back up to that word, if only to clean up the etymology a bit.
Happy Canada Day, Dev!
you too! did you have fun?
@@ShortFatOtaku Yeah, hung out with my wife and played some SNES games on the Switch!
We also ordered poutine from a new local poutine place, but it was just terrible
ShortFatOtaku happy Canada Day,🇨🇦
"... in Wales, English is spoken," sure.
We give them an A for effort, at least.
Happy Canada day Dev! And well spoken on the subject
I'll say until I'm blue in the face. You are not your ancestors. You are not culpable for their crimes, nor do you have claim to their virtues.
8:37 the message to keep Sargon from hitting the down vote.
Also Poland CAN into space.
finding a genocidal massive grave of children who were raped and thrown into shallow graves... kinda puts a damper on any sort of Canadian pride.
@Pike Man Yeah but these kids were murdered and buried in unmarked graves... That's like holocaust levels of evil my dude. I don't know the full story here, I'm not Canadian, but if ever there was a legitimate excuse for, I dunno pumping the breaks on national pride, this would be it.
The 4th is right around the corner here in the states and if we discovered we'd raped, murdered, and covered the corpses in mass graves of over a thousand children... well I wouldn't feel very festive.
I'm not trying to say Canada shouldn't ever be proud of the good it's done, but, when you find out something this fucked up, maybe a little self reflection is in order.
It's ok to be nationalist
Actually Canadian. And Metís so some of my ancestors treated other ancestors badly. OK. And both sets mistreated the mixed race ancestors badly. Under the left wing radicals we would simply cause more suffering. Bad things were done. An official apology was issued by the last Government. Are these pratices still happening? No. Good start. To heal and move past this let us who were neither perpatrator nor victims build the foundation of a new and better nation that never would allow anyone to be willfully harmed. To build a peaceful enlighted unified future. Accept and celebrate what we have in common and where we differ. That is the dream to fight for.
same lol
Basically we need to be Japan
Aye, I can only speak for myself but the UK needs to shut down it's boarders, Japan is a great model to follow in that respect.
It is no nation we inhabit, but a language.
Make no mistake; our native tongue is our true fatherland.
If that was the case, we'd be british
we aren't
oh fuck he said it
Here in Denmark a new word has emerged. Green Nationalism. It refers to people who just want to fix climate change instantly and won't compromise by using less than ideal ways to get there, but only their perfect idealized ways. Like, instead of making farms more CO2 neutral they want everyone to simply go vegan or at least vegetarian. They don't want more research into nuclear power but only into windmills and solar panels. It was kind of interesting seeing the word used by a politician.
The views that you quote are so very, extremely Parisian and upper class. The regional cultures of France were actively exterminated during the 19th and 20th centuries, and the resentment held in the provinces towards the capital over this is still very much alive. The rivalry between northern and southern France is still a thing as well. Segregation between economic classes was never really broken, even in the days of supposed universal public schools and conscription. WW1, the alleged "war of nationalism", was made complex because soldiers spoke various dialects, and some people (Breton and Basque) were explicitely sent to die first by the generals. By the way, the St Barthelemy massacre is also still taught in schools and while the Catholics would like to forget it, the Protestants won’t ever let them.
Accepting to melt into a national union is disrespecting your ancestors and sucking the cocks of the conqueror. It’s accepting the extermination of the losers and not daring to question the victor’s version of events.
Yeah. To this day, France is the only major European country that hasn't signed the European Charter on Minority Languages, because apparently it's "unconstitutional". As a native speaker of a minority language (I'm not French, but my native language is also spoken in France), it makes my blood boil.
Half the people complaining about US flag holders and how insecure they are have pride flags in their bio
Catholicism gets much of the blame, but it wasn't the only religious group that participated in the residential school program.
You know what? Happy Canada day.
He acknowledges that slavery, having been abolished over a century ago, and the Canadian students are very different scenarios but then attempts to analogize exactly that with his grave of slaves on independence day theoretical
I don’t think past slights must only be forgotten. They can also be forgiven.
The meaning of a nation's 'Day' was always to focus on the best qualities. Any negative incident you bring to the table is essentially irrelevant to it. Maybe it can be a bit harder to compartmentalize if something recent happened, but at the end of the day, it doesn't change what the nature of the Day is. And maybe you think it's stupid that it's so one-sided, but I think you'd have to be dishonest to pretend you don't at least understand the nature of it.
It is best to forgive rather than to forget. We forget the hurt and pain, we never forget that it ever happened, if we do then the old wound will open up again with new anger and bitterness.
Happy Canada day Dev.
surprise surprise identitarions think nationalist can only be ethic