As a charter holder of both, I knew where this was going just by the title. You are spot-on Mark. I am looking forward to seeing what the CFA Institute comes up with for this section of the curriculum.
Seeing you have both Charters, what do you think about a hypothetical consolidation of the CAIA into the CFA (since CFA is more recognised of the two)? And potentially even consolidating CFP into the CFA? That would simply things for clients and regulators. Clients wouldn't have to understand the various qualifications or weight the pros and cons. And regulators can stop having separate licensing exams that duplicate 90% of the content
@@Nigel3005 Funny enough, I hold the CFP designation too (for the territory of South Africa). The only reason I hold all three is due the different focus areas. Had the CFA designation sufficiently satisfied the private markets and wealth management need at the time that I was enrolled, I would have opted only for the CFA designation. I often question the value of holding designations from three separate institutions given the cost and administrative burden of keeping them all. I agree that it would make things easier for regulators and the market too. Again, I would opt for the CFA designation given the rigorous process.
@@bartsimpson1231 personally I struggle to justify the value of the CFP from FPI. As an Accountant, the course was quite underwhelming and I honestly don't feel that the CFP course truly adds value (or at least significant value) that you can provide to a client. What's your thoughts?
Mark, I agree with all of your points, but CFAI non-profit? Mark, you know for sure better than many of us (given your down-to-earth experience) how to profit from the non-profit. There are many ways how to disseminate money legally from a non-profit and to "profit" from it.
I think he pointed out India candidates because it’s quite costly and they have an interest bearing monthly EMI plan for people who can’t afford a single $1400 payment
I read this article a few nights ago and struggled to understand the point he was making. To accuse the CFA of not caring about the client is insulting to the institution. The client has and remains the key focus of this institution and it's candidates. I get the feeling the CEO clearly has not looked at the CFA curriculum. I hope the CFA doesn't respond and I fear he might get the boot. This was disgraceful
oh common Mr. CEO. We're in finance... we're supposed to be in control of our emotions... Well but to me this article seem like a minor complain, one that the CFAI could just ignore (they could totally destroy it with a rebuttal, but I don't see how they need to).
The reason he said India is because it is quite expensive for us Indians to afford this course. In India we do not have a normal finance major degree and our colleges are pretty shit. The fact they are charging 300$ for the mock papers is just even crazier. You would be taking a huge risk not to buy it. And when those dollars convert to rupees it gets extremely hard for us to afford it. I think they should have just made it free instead of charge 300$ for that as well. But who cares about international students, when you can get more dollars?
@@whatdafuq4648Eventually you gotta pay it And cfai is moving in that direction too Charging 25k Inr for additional qbank is crazy And if you don't buy it people who did are gonna score better than you Thank goodness I never have to face this crap
He didn't even have the caia designation until like last yr. I don't even know how he was the ceo for caia for numerous yrs without even having the designation lol
“It is difficult to get a man to understand something when his salary depends on his not understanding it” - Upton Sinclair
"Somebody gonna get a hurt real bad!" - Russel Peters.....very good reference!
Mark Meldrum with a Russell Peters reference is the combo I didn't know I needed
As a charter holder of both, I knew where this was going just by the title. You are spot-on Mark. I am looking forward to seeing what the CFA Institute comes up with for this section of the curriculum.
The best response from the CFA should be no response. It's a complete waste of their time
@@SD-gw5vm agreed.
Seeing you have both Charters, what do you think about a hypothetical consolidation of the CAIA into the CFA (since CFA is more recognised of the two)? And potentially even consolidating CFP into the CFA?
That would simply things for clients and regulators. Clients wouldn't have to understand the various qualifications or weight the pros and cons. And regulators can stop having separate licensing exams that duplicate 90% of the content
@@Nigel3005 Funny enough, I hold the CFP designation too (for the territory of South Africa). The only reason I hold all three is due the different focus areas. Had the CFA designation sufficiently satisfied the private markets and wealth management need at the time that I was enrolled, I would have opted only for the CFA designation. I often question the value of holding designations from three separate institutions given the cost and administrative burden of keeping them all. I agree that it would make things easier for regulators and the market too. Again, I would opt for the CFA designation given the rigorous process.
@@bartsimpson1231 personally I struggle to justify the value of the CFP from FPI. As an Accountant, the course was quite underwhelming and I honestly don't feel that the CFP course truly adds value (or at least significant value) that you can provide to a client.
What's your thoughts?
Mark, I agree with all of your points, but CFAI non-profit? Mark, you know for sure better than many of us (given your down-to-earth experience) how to profit from the non-profit. There are many ways how to disseminate money legally from a non-profit and to "profit" from it.
I think he pointed out India candidates because it’s quite costly and they have an interest bearing monthly EMI plan for people who can’t afford a single $1400 payment
Purchasing power parity sucks🙂
exactly
It's not CFAI that is changing and hurting you, it's you that is not changing and hurting yourself,, Well Sayed.
There is a small section on visual artwork in the CAIA curriculum as of 2023 (I just took the test last week).
I read this article a few nights ago and struggled to understand the point he was making. To accuse the CFA of not caring about the client is insulting to the institution. The client has and remains the key focus of this institution and it's candidates. I get the feeling the CEO clearly has not looked at the CFA curriculum.
I hope the CFA doesn't respond and I fear he might get the boot. This was disgraceful
BURN! Mark ROASTED William! Come at us, William!
Education is the best equalizer in life, totally agree!
oh common Mr. CEO. We're in finance... we're supposed to be in control of our emotions... Well but to me this article seem like a minor complain, one that the CFAI could just ignore (they could totally destroy it with a rebuttal, but I don't see how they need to).
Overreaction by the CEO on the new syllabus
The reason he said India is because it is quite expensive for us Indians to afford this course. In India we do not have a normal finance major degree and our colleges are pretty shit. The fact they are charging 300$ for the mock papers is just even crazier. You would be taking a huge risk not to buy it. And when those dollars convert to rupees it gets extremely hard for us to afford it. I think they should have just made it free instead of charge 300$ for that as well. But who cares about international students, when you can get more dollars?
Yeah, but if CFAI is willing to allow us to pay fees with monthly instalments via third party , isn’t that a way forward?
@@whatdafuq4648Eventually you gotta pay it
And cfai is moving in that direction too
Charging 25k Inr for additional qbank is crazy
And if you don't buy it people who did are gonna score better than you
Thank goodness I never have to face this crap
He didn't even have the caia designation until like last yr. I don't even know how he was the ceo for caia for numerous yrs without even having the designation lol
If they want to continue to be known for alternative investments, they can specialize in crypto 😀
The great irony is that CAIA use the same code of ethics as CFA.
You should ask CAIA for a consulting fee 😂 They sure gonna act upon your input
RUSSELL!!!
What’s the time stamp?