#kpopdiet #girlsday #Minah Girls Day 걸스데이 Minah has struggled with her weight since debut. Through continuous dieting and working out Minah has worked to transform her body.
The stylists for them are definitely contributing to people thinking they are “chubby.” They put them in skirts or shorts that are so high waisted and cut into their torsos. Minah has a body where cutting it up with two pieces disrupts her bodyline, making her appear bulkier in the torso. They should really stick with tailored bodycon dresses that are sewn to flatter the individual members bodies.
@Gabbie Cruz Why even call them a stylist in that case, if your only profession is styling one body type rather than having the knowledge of how to appropriately style all body types.
the thing with minah is she also has a shorter torso than the other girls in girls day and her stylists haven't been the most aware of how to style her properly so even though she's never been even remotely chubby or close to overweight, her costumes don't compliment her figure as well as they could.
@@TheRzabcia by not using full skirts as they make hips look more wide, higher waisted shorts so the band doesn't sit on the fullest part of the body, crop tops that sit above the waist (many of hers were not tailored for that and cut her body awkwardly).
@@TheRzabcia a good comparison is if you look at Yeri's Psycho outfit from fancams (the black and white checkered crop top one) vs her Bad Boy outfit from MCountdown. First one is styled properly as Yeri also has a shorter torso whereas her Bad Boy outfit the pants are too low and the shirt crease where it's tucked in sits wierdly because it's not where the narrowest part of her waist is. Hence the styling makes her look boxy rather than sleek. I also myself have a shorter torso so these are things I had to learn when styling myself in general clothing.
Minah seems to be struggling the most out of her members to decide what her next move should be after Girls Day, She's got a nice voice but it doesn't look like she's getting much singing opportunities so she's focusing on her figure for landing dramas and possible sponsors.
This is kinda sad ending. I hope Minah can have a better chance at showing her talents. She’s so pretty and has a great voice! I just hope things will be better for her.
It makes me sad that even someone like Minah, incredibly talented, visual, charisma, amazing vocal, cutest facial expression, LITERALLY AN ICON, and there's still people bashing about her body shape. Like she's always been perfection to me like her body shape never was a thing that came into mind at all.
Sometimes I wonder what it would be like if girl's day hadn't disbanded, but I know kpop is a fast moving industry. I hope Minah can find her path whatever that may be :)
I really liked Minah in My Beautiful Gong Shim! For me, her acting was really likeable and relatable. I'm usually skeptical when idols act but she's really good. Sad thing that My Absolute Boyfriend didn't do well. I dropped watching it though, acting was great but the story was something I couldn't handle. Hopefully, I'd see Minah through dramas too! Fighting!
So beautiful and pretty, intelligent, she will go far, great actress as well, I loved her character in Gong Shim, she played an integral role keeping the rest of the cast looking great due to her efforts, love MINAH alot.
There are so many wonderful things that can be said about Minah I wouldn't know where to start... She's beautiful and full of talent . So, I'll just say love her🥰
You should make a video of singer Son Seung Yeon, her underweight change is impressive. One of the most drastic I have ever seen. She was obese in the past, an now she has abs
It breaks my heart that the stuff she's doing now doesn't seem to be recieved well given how sweet and talented she is, I feel like she must think she was most successful skinny (during something) so she might be so skinny now as an attempt to bring that back? Also I would love if you did videos on oh my girls seunghee and arin. Seunghee keeps getting thinner and I know she mentioned an incredibly unhealthy diet to get there, and arin got REALLY skinny during secret garden, and she's been kind of on and off since.
Butterfly (her latest comeback) is such a good song. I didn’t know it didn’t chart. Such a shame. It’s a really nice feel good song :( love her voice. Great video!
Butterfly was her best comeback in my opinion I’m so upset it didn’t do well. She genuinely does deserve so much better as an artist, people underestimate her and girls days abilities so much :(
I love your video so much like i watch every single one and luckily you always upload when I'm on youtube so I'm early, really brings my moods tbh💕 Thank you for your hard work 😙
Please do a video about SNSD's Yoona when you have chance. She is always been thin but you can see SM sometimes put her at her limit, she had one of the craziest agenda in kpop in 2010-2014 while filming doramas/movies and promoting and touring with SNSD. She went from a health and thin body to a very boney that time, she looks healthier nowadays since that she only focus in her acting career.
Does anyone else think this could be a similar situation to Hitomi from izone, everyone loves her for her chubby cheeks and overall cute appearance but maybe she also doesn’t like it and would rather come off as mature so she lost so much weight to lose the fat in the face but it turned into an extreme diet and left her boney and sickly? I do know this channel is doing a video on hitomi but just thought it was something to bring up while watching this. Hope she’s ok though and can find confidence in the future.
Firstly I want to say that girl’s day is my UG I love these girls so much. Secondly, yeah girls day are truly visual jackpot like look a them !! Stunning !! Thirdly, I’m very sad because Minah is my bias and she didn’t has the chance to shine especially thanks to her unique, powerful and beautiful voice !
shes cute and adorable, seeing her on drama's so cute.. then you can see her doing sexy concept i did not expect that haha. She is also very smoll but has a temper haha
Minah is the most beautiful girl, I loved her in beautiful gong Shim and absolute boyfriend, but hyeri, yura and sojin are so beautiful too I love girls day
in my country being chubby and thick is the standard and if you are thin sometimes they'll call you stick and boned person unless u r a model.so its kinda hard on skinny girls
Hi, I was wondering if you could do one on these on Jisoo as (I believe) you have done a vid on each of the bp members except her and her she has had a lot of significant weight changes
Yesss, although lululuna has done one, in my opinion AMFG could do a better research and a prefer her videos, im not hating on lululuna is just my preference :)
She was beautiful not being skinny, specially in beautful gong shim drama, shes already perfect and madly attractive and gorgeous, probably the most beautiful korean figure I’ve seen.
All members have gained a bit since Uh-Oh era exept Miyeon who lost so much weight that really scarred me. But Minnie maintained while Yuqi got really heavy in Lion era. Now Yuqi lost a FREAKING lot of weight for Oh my God comeback and Minnie too. Both are almost as thin as in Hann era. While Shuhua who was very very thin and stable suddenly gained a lot.
2016 I think. It was a success and she won an excellency award in acting. Ratings were really good too. In 2013 she received the Rookie Actress Award at the Gwangju International Film Festival for her performance in the movie Holly. My absolute boyfriend tanked in South Korea but it did so well internationally. Yes I'm a fan hihi
This is the first video of yours that I didn't like. It felt sooooo long and SLOW! also most of the time there were no updates "she mantained her weight this year" was mentioned at least 4 times. Quality over quantity! I rather wait more for your content that putting myself through this misery again.
She/he made a viddo over facts! If thats the fact then what are going to do? Lols does idol have to weight carelessly? Like is it a fiction? No its not
I’m surprised you didn’t bring this video up ruclips.net/video/fqmJjv7ivYk/видео.html I couldn’t find translations but their are purposefully showing unflattering pictures of her and she seemed embarrassed but trying to act like she was okay with it. She has the type of body where her weight pools in her stomach but her legs stay pretty slim (similar to Tiffany and Yeri) and That is considered the least attractive body type in SK. The stylist didn’t help either because the outfits looked good on the other girls but were really unflattering on Minah.
![NOSFERATU - Official Trailer [HD] - Only In Theaters December 25](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/nulvWqYUM8k/mqdefault.jpg)
The stylists for them are definitely contributing to people thinking they are “chubby.” They put them in skirts or shorts that are so high waisted and cut into their torsos. Minah has a body where cutting it up with two pieces disrupts her bodyline, making her appear bulkier in the torso. They should really stick with tailored bodycon dresses that are sewn to flatter the individual members bodies.
@Gabbie Cruz Why even call them a stylist in that case, if your only profession is styling one body type rather than having the knowledge of how to appropriately style all body types.
Not to mention that their stylist gives her clothes that are way too tight smh
Omg!! Say it louder sist all over kpop stylist must learn it from you,
the thing with minah is she also has a shorter torso than the other girls in girls day and her stylists haven't been the most aware of how to style her properly so even though she's never been even remotely chubby or close to overweight, her costumes don't compliment her figure as well as they could.
Rosemary Gurak and she was also more of an Apple body so it made her look more fuller than her members
How do you style a body like that?
@@TheRzabcia by not using full skirts as they make hips look more wide, higher waisted shorts so the band doesn't sit on the fullest part of the body, crop tops that sit above the waist (many of hers were not tailored for that and cut her body awkwardly).
@@mavel2038 pretty much!
@@TheRzabcia a good comparison is if you look at Yeri's Psycho outfit from fancams (the black and white checkered crop top one) vs her Bad Boy outfit from MCountdown. First one is styled properly as Yeri also has a shorter torso whereas her Bad Boy outfit the pants are too low and the shirt crease where it's tucked in sits wierdly because it's not where the narrowest part of her waist is. Hence the styling makes her look boxy rather than sleek.
I also myself have a shorter torso so these are things I had to learn when styling myself in general clothing.
Minah seems to be struggling the most out of her members to decide what her next move should be after Girls Day, She's got a nice voice but it doesn't look like she's getting much singing opportunities so she's focusing on her figure for landing dramas and possible sponsors.
AMFG Videos plzzz do a jimin update :3333
Pls do a video for IZ*ONE Hitomi ty :)
Yes please do about Hitomi from IZ*ONE
a video for Krystal fx pleaseee
AMFG Videos hitomi from izone please, she's had a dramatic weight loss that is so concerning
This is kinda sad ending. I hope Minah can have a better chance at showing her talents. She’s so pretty and has a great voice! I just hope things will be better for her.
Namjoon’s IQ of 148 right. It makes me sad when amazing singers just turn into actresses
alex is a spy yea:( she seems to be having bad luck I just hope her talent gets put to even better use!!
Minah is so talented and beautiful as she was before it’s sad that she had to diet even though she looked healthy already
minah was the first girl idol i really liked ❤ thank you for this video on her. Shes amazing
Minah is such a natural beauty and she is so confident about not wearing make up
14:24
me :looks cute, might watch
video: the show tanked, got horrible ratings, and got cancelled
me: pikachu face
AndYouWillBeWithMe I was SHOCKED because i literally love that drama
my sister watched it so you should still check it out
Really? Why i can see until the end? But it's kind of not finished
Wait is the drama based off the manga?
I hate the idea that apparently she I considered unattractive in Korea because she is absolutely stunning
It makes me sad that even someone like Minah, incredibly talented, visual, charisma, amazing vocal, cutest facial expression, LITERALLY AN ICON, and there's still people bashing about her body shape. Like she's always been perfection to me like her body shape never was a thing that came into mind at all.
Girl's day songs give me the best nostalgia 😍😍😍
Ashley Miranda fr fr ❤️
I love that she doesn’t constantly talk about dieting or her weight
Sometimes I wonder what it would be like if girl's day hadn't disbanded, but I know kpop is a fast moving industry. I hope Minah can find her path whatever that may be :)
Minah bias forever 💖 miss Girl's Day so much
I really liked Minah in My Beautiful Gong Shim! For me, her acting was really likeable and relatable. I'm usually skeptical when idols act but she's really good. Sad thing that My Absolute Boyfriend didn't do well. I dropped watching it though, acting was great but the story was something I couldn't handle. Hopefully, I'd see Minah through dramas too! Fighting!
I really REALLY loved "Butterfly"! I hope she gets to do more of what she loves in the future, either being singing or acting, 방민아 사랑해!!!
Stylists really need to learn that there are different body types and the same outfit won't work for each all body types.
So beautiful and pretty, intelligent, she will go far, great actress as well, I loved her character in Gong Shim, she played an integral role keeping the rest of the cast looking great due to her efforts, love MINAH alot.
I love Minah She's such a doll.
There are so many wonderful things that can be said about Minah I wouldn't know where to start... She's beautiful and full of talent . So, I'll just say love her🥰
You should make a video of singer Son Seung Yeon, her underweight change is impressive. One of the most drastic I have ever seen. She was obese in the past, an now she has abs
Could you please do izones Hitomi?
I think she got abs too
Could you do seunghee, sorn of clc or jisoo, no much people knowns about their weight loss
(Sorry if I have grammatical errors, I'm from Spain)
Lululuna did a vid of jisoos weightloss if u want to see it
@Elanur Kula she has already done a Jennie one
It breaks my heart that the stuff she's doing now doesn't seem to be recieved well given how sweet and talented she is, I feel like she must think she was most successful skinny (during something) so she might be so skinny now as an attempt to bring that back?
Also I would love if you did videos on oh my girls seunghee and arin. Seunghee keeps getting thinner and I know she mentioned an incredibly unhealthy diet to get there, and arin got REALLY skinny during secret garden, and she's been kind of on and off since.
Butterfly (her latest comeback) is such a good song. I didn’t know it didn’t chart. Such a shame. It’s a really nice feel good song :( love her voice.
Great video!
I know Girl's Day stylists always give them super tight pants
lisa lol I’ve noticed that too. It hung on to the little “fat” they had. I never understood that
Butterfly was her best comeback in my opinion I’m so upset it didn’t do well. She genuinely does deserve so much better as an artist, people underestimate her and girls days abilities so much :(
I love your video so much like i watch every single one and luckily you always upload when I'm on youtube so I'm early, really brings my moods tbh💕
Thank you for your hard work 😙
Please do a video about SNSD's Yoona when you have chance.
She is always been thin but you can see SM sometimes put her at her limit, she had one of the craziest agenda in kpop in 2010-2014 while filming doramas/movies and promoting and touring with SNSD.
She went from a health and thin body to a very boney that time, she looks healthier nowadays since that she only focus in her acting career.
wow ive never been this early
and can u pls do a video on jisoo from blackpink her weightloss always goes unnoticed
korean beauty standards are horrible tbh. she looked totally fine before. why are they so against having some meat on your bones 🤦♀️🤦♀️
I adore Minah so I stick to her through thick or thin.
Can you do mamamoo solar or hwasa next pls
yura has the best body ever she didn't even Starve herself
Does anyone else think this could be a similar situation to Hitomi from izone, everyone loves her for her chubby cheeks and overall cute appearance but maybe she also doesn’t like it and would rather come off as mature so she lost so much weight to lose the fat in the face but it turned into an extreme diet and left her boney and sickly? I do know this channel is doing a video on hitomi but just thought it was something to bring up while watching this. Hope she’s ok though and can find confidence in the future.
Firstly I want to say that girl’s day is my UG I love these girls so much. Secondly, yeah girls day are truly visual jackpot like look a them !! Stunning !! Thirdly, I’m very sad because Minah is my bias and she didn’t has the chance to shine especially thanks to her unique, powerful and beautiful voice !
shes cute and adorable, seeing her on drama's so cute.. then you can see her doing sexy concept i did not expect that haha. She is also very smoll but has a temper haha
She was my fav idol T.T
Please do a video about G-idle Shuhua or Yuqi!
Minah is the most beautiful girl, I loved her in beautiful gong Shim and absolute boyfriend, but hyeri, yura and sojin are so beautiful too
I love girls day
I love your videos!! Thumbs up💫✨
Can you do Secret members?
Great idea I think she has done one of the members though.
She did jieun for sure. Not sure about the others
Minah don’t give up!! Keep on working hard, I want to see you a solo artist! Try new things! Fighting!
in my country being chubby and thick is the standard and if you are thin sometimes they'll call you stick and boned person unless u r a model.so its kinda hard on skinny girls
3:46 is-is she wearing a swimsuit *in front of a skirt??* man the fashion attempts of old kpop never fail to surprise me lol. her stylist was wildin
Hi, I was wondering if you could do one on these on Jisoo as (I believe) you have done a vid on each of the bp members except her and her she has had a lot of significant weight changes
Lululuna did a great vid of jisoos weightloss, u should see it if u want
Yesss, although lululuna has done one, in my opinion AMFG could do a better research and a prefer her videos, im not hating on lululuna is just my preference :)
She was beautiful not being skinny, specially in beautful gong shim drama, shes already perfect and madly attractive and gorgeous, probably the most beautiful korean figure I’ve seen.
Visual princess but i miss u very much 😿😤😠😭🙀 and her gorgeous members too i miss u girls 😿😤😠😭🙀
you cold also do a video of jamie park’s weight loss or ryujins weight gain
Me @14:25: oh that’s good
Me @14:41: oop
wow I didn't know "I'm a woman too was by Girls' Day Minah, it's such a sexy song
what didn’t help is that they give her clothes that didn’t flattered her shape so it made her look “chubbier” than others 😔
Could you do Shindong, he lost weight lately
Can you do Arin's Weightloss? Or Hitomi's Weightloss?
I miss Minah so much😭
Im so confused what are the stylists thinking, we can literally do better than them
Can you do one about jooheon of monsta x? :'( My baby
Heyy can you maybe do Shuhua from G idle next? Her weught gain and the hate she gets😔 if you have time ofcourse!❤
Could you do Gidle Minnie's weight loss? She lost quite a lot.
All members have gained a bit since Uh-Oh era exept Miyeon who lost so much weight that really scarred me. But Minnie maintained while Yuqi got really heavy in Lion era. Now Yuqi lost a FREAKING lot of weight for Oh my God comeback and Minnie too. Both are almost as thin as in Hann era. While Shuhua who was very very thin and stable suddenly gained a lot.
Please do Hwasa!!
thank you for making this
Love Minah♥️😍
I'm watching Absolute Boyfriend right now just bc she's the lead I can't believed it was not a succes in Korea, whyy?? :(
kpop idols when thru hard sh*t bcs people saying that they are thin or chubby....
She looked healthier before and cuter. :(
I love minah.
Please make one for Iz*One Hitomi!
Can you please do a video about iz*one hitomi? She got so skinny after the disbanding rumors please make a video about her
Girl's day will not disbanded
great video
Damn i remember all the hate she got for her appearance. People said horrible things about her.
great video
I miss Girl's Day so much, but can we agree that the Ring My Bell outfits were a crime against humanity?
hey, can you do a video about ateez's wooyoung weight loss please? i want more people know this bcs it's not healthy
Krystal fx pleaseee
Can you do Jessica jung?
Can make a video oh my girl Arin on seunghee
Please do jisoo from BLACKPINK!! Love your videos!!
What year is my beautiful Kong shim. I thought it was a huge success
2016 I think. It was a success and she won an excellency award in acting. Ratings were really good too. In 2013 she received the Rookie Actress Award at the Gwangju International Film Festival for her performance in the movie Holly. My absolute boyfriend tanked in South Korea but it did so well internationally. Yes I'm a fan hihi
Early!!
She's beautiful, why doesn't she get married?
Can u do f(x) victoria? She was always been critized about her weight 😢
omg wow 🙇♀️🙇♀️🙇♀️
뮤지컬도좋지만 드라마에도 얼굴을 비춰줬으면 좋겠네 보고싶네
Great videos as usual, could you do hyuna I mean her weight journey has been very sad
She has one alredy
@@rtto2031 can you send me the link???
@@ferdaousismaili6157 ruclips.net/video/RMME9G4yEMw/видео.html
@@sav939 thank you so much
I love girl's day shes my bais forever and im Always Daisy faiting ❤💓👑
This is the first video of yours that I didn't like. It felt sooooo long and SLOW! also most of the time there were no updates "she mantained her weight this year" was mentioned at least 4 times. Quality over quantity! I rather wait more for your content that putting myself through this misery again.
She/he made a viddo over facts! If thats the fact then what are going to do? Lols does idol have to weight carelessly? Like is it a fiction? No its not
if it’s possible, could you do a video on got7’s youngjae?
I would be over the moon happy though to actually get her weight at her heaviest 😂😂🤧🥺
please do jiyeon and hyomin of t-ara
I’m surprised you didn’t bring this video up ruclips.net/video/fqmJjv7ivYk/видео.html I couldn’t find translations but their are purposefully showing unflattering pictures of her and she seemed embarrassed but trying to act like she was okay with it. She has the type of body where her weight pools in her stomach but her legs stay pretty slim (similar to Tiffany and Yeri) and That is considered the least attractive body type in SK. The stylist didn’t help either because the outfits looked good on the other girls but were really unflattering on Minah.