I genuinely want to see Johnny do a challenge like this but with all the time he needs. It's kinda depressing to see him fail only because he didn't have enough time to figure things out.
I agree. I think the video would have been better if they ACTUALLY baked the entire thing from scratch and heck, got a World Record person to come out and see it too 😂
I understand making the time shorter to create the entertaining chaos but there’s a difference between cutting it close and giving way too little time. They consistently give him way too little time. Even if it was something like every 3rd episode he got significantly more time would be good. It’s more frustrating than entertaining this way. Like if it’s a challenge that would normally take 8 hours then give him 7. Not give him 4 hours for an 8 hour challenge.
I hate it too. Rachel’s admitted she messes with the time in WAR to make things more dramatic but I hate to see people set up to fail. It’s unkind and feels icky to watch.
Panicked hunched over pantsless Keith gesturing emphatically to the cake covered Rachel on the floor is such a surreal moment. This whole video is art. I don't know what kind yet but definitely art.
@@VirgoLunaKnight I understand, but still -- the people have spoken ! We would be INTERESTED in seeing a beautiful, perfected item with more time for Jonny !!
I was thinking the same, but I realized that this series is probably about embracing failure and just being unhinged and having fun, not about doing things perfectly and being precise. That's what makes it different from Jonny's own ytb channel. So maybe when he gets more views and subscribers on his channel, he will be able to do things with bigger production like this.
Please start allowing Johnny to take more time to plan and execute and maybe do test runs. It'll be way more entertaining, although i know it would be more expensive to produce. He's so talented i just want to see one of his crazy visions come to real life
@@zevo9314 Or even just as they did it but give him enough time to figure out how to make part of it cake without it just falling everywhere, because if it just collapses as a mess in Rachel's lap how is that less wasteful?
@@JaxHolder1 yeah, if this was given proper time, it could be done and given to an on theme event to not waste it. youd have to do a bricking strategy with something sturdier. marshmallow rice is an obvious one, to use as a sort of mortar, with other harder cookies and crackers performing structural work. obviously a lot of dowels and maybe some wooden platforms
@@alexpalaciossantos4940 totally agree. I think it would be more entertaining to see them accomplish these extravagant things and maybe connect it to charity
It was so fun to watch it devolve into the point where Rachel is speechless and being crushed under the cake, Keith has no pants on and is shouting, and Johnny is frantically trying to finish decorating around them lmao
It's not fun at all, it's just annoying. The appeal of Johnny, other than his lovely personality, is that he's actually capable of doing these type of cakes, but then they give him way too little time. If this just going to be The Miserable Failure show who is that different than Without a Recipe? Honestly, Johnny, if you're reading these comments...stop doing these shows unless they change the format, because it's actually going to ruin your reputation as a hyper-realistic cake artist since they keep setting you up to fail and make it look like you can't pull these things off!
Yes! And they’ve been overlapping with People Vs. Food, Mythical, and Smosh. It’s like the 4 greatest channels just all collaborating for different content and I love all of it.
I only wish we could actually see her reaction without the fillers and Botox. It kills the authenticity of expressions. 😢 she’s so beautiful already. I wonder who’s telling her she needs the work. 🫶🏻
I absolutely love the editing decision to use Jonny's tiktoks as a bumper, like "look, he is actually good at this normally, despite this absolute clusterf*ck he's decided to do today"
@@systematicirony666 Nah it is, it's making him look very inept at something he professes to be good at. And that's not his fault, it's the fact that they give him such unreasonably short time limits to do giant tasks like this. I love Jonny and it's hard to watch him be set up to fail all the time.
I never know what to expect when I walk into the Try Guys office... All I can say is that it's a new, wonderful experience every time. And yes, even for Without A Recipe 😅 Love you guys! ❤
Rosanna, you are a fraud. Your backlog of Colleen Ballinger collabs are pretty vile in hindsight aren't they 🤔 Please don't pretend that your own fans haven't been asking you to disavow your friendship with her for months now, we know 😉 The Mr Beast bs seems like a poor distraction and I know I'm not alone in thinking that. It won't go away @RosannaPansino you have disappointed a lot of people
Ngl it's kinda frustrating that it seems Jonny is not being provided the tools, time, and appliances for whatever giant you've tasked him to do. Jonny is a great content creator and brings a lot of vibrancy to your videos and I feel that's deserving of setting him up for success instead of constantly setting him up for failure. I'd rather see Jonny succeed; he's so talented with baking and decorating and when given the right tools and what not, he creates amazing things. Allowing him to do that will absolutely bring you more views than watching him fail will. I hope this doesn't come off too critical, I do really enjoy the channel and have been a fan for a long time, I just got frustrated to see Jonny lose yet again with what seems like purposeful efforts on the try guys side.
thats the point of these videos. its to challenge him and make it entertaining. i understand that even with all the tools it would still be challenging and entertaining but this a format that the guys like to use, and they’re also probably gonna tweak it as it progresses. also it would be a bigger production for them to do.
@@melissa_jpg Not really. The point is to entertain and get views at the end of the day, and I'm watching to be entertained. And based on the top comments, I'm clearly not the only one who feels this way.
Yes! I think this could be done in all cake, but only for a huge event where it would all be eaten. I'd definitely enlist Charm City Cakes to help, though! They know structure for these huge projects.
Everyone did a great job, but extra kudos for an executive producer who will literally almost drown in cake for a successful Try Guys video. Yay Rachel !!
Johnny covered in frosting, Rachel on her knees trying to catch an armful of cake, Keith in his underwear screaming, is the most unhinged renaissance painting.
I love these videos. I also would love to see an episode where Johnny gets to show off his real skills and “is it cake” the guys or people in the office. He’s so talented so it would be nice to have him show off a bit
Yes! Like have Johnny make a 'is it cake' and put it in the office and they just record to see how long it takes for someone to notice and interact with the fake object.
It’s so nice to see the Internet’s favourite Pastry Maker Barbies doing a crossover like this. Also, imagine if the subject of the cake was someone over 6 feet tall.
This video is so cute! Rosanna spinning while inside the cake looked so happy! Keith's underwear was an unexpected suprise. At least they didn't chop off his legs when he was to tall for the cake, like Eugene did with the doll😂😂
Keith standing there in his underwear panicking while Johnny and Rachel are panicking about the cake falling is comedy gold! Imagine is Rosana really did dive out and slide down the side 😂
This series is quickly becoming "Johnny gives himself way too much to do in way too little time and stresses himself out" lol I hope we get to see him at his best too
There's a part after that where she says something like "but wait I thought it was--" before she addresses Keith undressing, so I think she figured it out before they put her into it
I want Jonny to succeed on these wild attempts, but I also wish we could have made this a series of the guest coming in to Rachel holding a falling piece of illusion cake with an awkward smile.
I remember watching compilations of Without a Recipe (specifically of Keith) and wondered what Ro & Keith's height difference genuinely looked like. Now we know and it's hilarious. (Also them having to shoot a bit wider at first to get Keith and Ro in frame). This also made me think of the giant wedding cake Safiya made and also had Ro surprised with
@@Twinkalmia she has been avoiding denouncing her friendship and multiple video collaborations with Colleen Ballinger. Oh and she was also upset with Mr Beast for editing her out of 3rd place in a game of hide and seek, but tbh that seems like a distraction from Colleen, especially seeing as she announced her beef on Trisha's podcast. Istead of a public statement in support of victims, she just said she and Trisha spoke in private. Which is fine when it comes to Trisha specifically but doesn't get her off the hook for failing to speak up on HER relationship with Colleen.
@@Twinkalmia On Trisha Paytas’s podcast, Rosanna said Mr Beast edited a video she was in to make it look like she did poorly. She said it felt like a “boy’s club” when filming and hinted towards it being for sexist reasons. People found out a male youtuber was edited out the same way though, so that was quickly disproven. People then started sending her death threats and claiming she was saying all this for clout. (which is crazy to me because she’s rosanna pansino😭) I said “put respect on her name” because so many male youtubers covering the drama treated her as if she was some rando. They acted as if she wasn’t a youtube legend/incredibly well known just because she was in the wrong. It ended up becoming a huge sexism thing where men were incredibly harsh to her, while women treated her fairly. sucks to see :/
@@dandelion_official4812you’ve posted like so many comments on this video about the Colleen drama, over and over? I know the situation is not great - but, chill.
My favorite parts of these are always the inevitable moments in which Johnny realizes he needs help with something and conscripts whoever's in earshot.
@@rebeccalazzell5262I looked it up, Mr. Beast apparently edited her out of a video and stuff like that and now she’s getting death threats for calling him out on it
God Jonny is so precious, I love him! All of the try guys' secondary members. Jonny, kwesi, lewberger, try spouses. And if course our Miles (miss him!). I'm so glad they have an awesome lineup of fun and silly friends that bring so much to their channel. I love that Jonny was originally (seemingly) a one-time judge and now makes videos with the try team regularly.
I'm so happy Jonny has a place where people help him bring his fever dream creations come to life! People expecting context for Keith being pantsless must be new 😂@11:07 (Bonus: Keith cakes on cakes at the end!!!)
Ro looked so adorable in the cake! Loved Keith's butt cheeks on the cake. Thank you Rachel for helping Jonny and getting Keith the skirt to wear. 2nd Try LLC where your bosses taking their pants off is regular occurrence.😆 Thanks Jack for getting the cakes and tubs of buttercream icing.
This might be one of my favorite videos 😂 Rachel covered in cake, Keith unexpectedly taking his pants off, Rosanna in a cake, and all of Johnny's energy 💯
Keith panicked going "I can't go out there now, I don't have any pants on anymore!" 😂😂😂 Then Rachel absolutely covered in frosting up to her ELBOWS 😭 haha. I love Rosanna, she is so sweet and cute! Every video I see her in, she is just bubbly and excited, she's the best. This is such a great series, I love Jonny. I would love to see what he could do in challenges without such a short time limit! Maybe in a separate series lol
I think a really simple fix for this would have been to sand or shave part of the foam backing off. Just enough to tilt it slightly so gravity was working with you instead of against. Johnny is such an excellent cake maker and I would actually like to see him excel a little more on the channel and have proper materials and solutions given to him. Still super fun videos though I can't think of too many videos on the main channel that I don't enjoy from the try guys and company 💖
I watched this with my baker roommate and the way she raged at this entire video was hilarious. But seriously…why not give him either several days to work on this or not try to do something this big?? Because basically he did nothing. None of it is cake, he didn’t make the butter cream, he only made a little cake. It just seems weird.
Try Guys Last Year: We’ve hired a HR to make sure we keep our business practices respectable. Try Guys HR Team watching Keith randomly remove his pants: 😓
johnny is one of the most talented people and they always put him through amounts of stress no human brain should be able to handle. just putting him in situations
I already watched this video twice yesterday on Patreon, but it's SO FUNNY that I'm watching it again on the main channel! I can never get enough of Jonny Cakes chaos!
Jonny THANK YOU SO MUCH for NOT wasting resources by making cake that we all KNOW gets thrown out because no one eats that much cake, or people often bake cakes tougher to be structurally stronger and we as viewers can surmise that when the content is over it is thrown away. So you had the forethought to decide to nor waste..thank you!!waste for content isn't necessary YOU PROVED IT WITH GREAT CONTENT🙌🙌 . BTW you both slayed in those princess 👸 dresses. She bakes, she cares about sustainability and she slays..I'm here for it👏👏👏👏👏
Johnny whispering so Jack won't hear only to realize Jack would hear perfectly being the sound guy 😂 💀 I love the chaos in Jonny videos so much Also, I have the same underwear as Keith 😂😅
Jonny deserves the time he needs in future videos (if he'd prefer it)❤ Big new projects like these don't usually work out on the first try for nearly anyone, so it'd be great to see persistence by letting him problem solve and try again if that's something he'd be interested in! He's such a fantastic addition to this channel.
For the love of god, give jonny more time to bake his cakes. These things are meant to be challenging not impossible. It doesn't even have to be a week, maybe just 2 days if the project's this big. They pull 2-day shoots even for Without A Recipe so this should also apply for cooking challenges that are extremely hard to pull off. The reveal wasn't as satisfying knowing that the only cake part of the dress fell off before they even began.
This makes me so happy, seeing Johnny have his own segment. But also how cute 🥰 that he surprised Ro💜 she’s definitely loved by the right kind of boy channel✨
I loved the idea but the video feels disappointing. Everything was done to ensure it would fail and the chaos ensuing looked fake and constructed. It feels like no one even tried to do a good job, or only tried for a brief moment before crashing it. It reminds me of Claire Saffitz going on Jimmy Fallon's show where he 100% purposefully messed up his cake to get funny reactions from Claire.
This video is just perfection. Ro is so tiny next to Keith, The cake catching, the frosting stains. Keith without pants. Its all just, perfection. I also love how Keith just de-pants with little to no thought in front of his whole office.
I genuinely want to see Johnny do a challenge like this but with all the time he needs. It's kinda depressing to see him fail only because he didn't have enough time to figure things out.
I agree. I think the video would have been better if they ACTUALLY baked the entire thing from scratch and heck, got a World Record person to come out and see it too 😂
I think he bit off more than he could chew, not really thinking about how long it would take in his time constraint
@@Nevertoleave happened last time too though
I understand making the time shorter to create the entertaining chaos but there’s a difference between cutting it close and giving way too little time. They consistently give him way too little time. Even if it was something like every 3rd episode he got significantly more time would be good. It’s more frustrating than entertaining this way. Like if it’s a challenge that would normally take 8 hours then give him 7. Not give him 4 hours for an 8 hour challenge.
I hate it too. Rachel’s admitted she messes with the time in WAR to make things more dramatic but I hate to see people set up to fail. It’s unkind and feels icky to watch.
Keith providing no help at all other than taking off his pants is.... amazing.
lol his only contribution
That's exactly what he said he would do... Just be there
Keith taking his pants off and just standing aghast next to the cake made my entire day
I missed the part where he actually took his pants off and glanced back at 10:28. You can imagine my surprise lol
I did not expect no pants when I started watching this at work
The most relatable thing I’ve ever seen 😂. Panic and take your pants off.
okay lol when did he take off his pants??
The way that he casually takes off his pants like 3 times in this video shows how often the Try Guys have to change in front of camera
Keith just in his underwear helping them while a giant cake falls apart on top of Rachel is everything.
Rosanna: “How many pieces of cake are in here?!? How many pounds of cake?”
Keith & Johnny: “……..Right……”
Panicked hunched over pantsless Keith gesturing emphatically to the cake covered Rachel on the floor is such a surreal moment. This whole video is art. I don't know what kind yet but definitely art.
Comedy art!
Renaissance art
with the panic and multiple figures i’m thinking baroque expressionism (either way it’s a type of frantic beauty that i absolutely adore)
It does resemble a form of baroque expressionism, but the overall feel is more akin to dadaism.
@@scaathreykr you are absolutely correct and i love it
Why do they give him such short time limits?!?!?! I want to see him do this stuff with extra time and perfect it!
Right?! This sweet man deserves all the time!
Right!! Give Johnny more time!!
It's to make it challenging and interesting...
In one pod cast they have discussed their process
Rachel does the same for without a recipe as well
@@VirgoLunaKnight I understand, but still -- the people have spoken ! We would be INTERESTED in seeing a beautiful, perfected item with more time for Jonny !!
I was thinking the same, but I realized that this series is probably about embracing failure and just being unhinged and having fun, not about doing things perfectly and being precise. That's what makes it different from Jonny's own ytb channel. So maybe when he gets more views and subscribers on his channel, he will be able to do things with bigger production like this.
Please start allowing Johnny to take more time to plan and execute and maybe do test runs. It'll be way more entertaining, although i know it would be more expensive to produce. He's so talented i just want to see one of his crazy visions come to real life
this one, while wasteful, would have been so epic if it was entirely made out of cake over several days
@@zevo9314 yes! Or at least rice crispies or something!
@@zevo9314 Or even just as they did it but give him enough time to figure out how to make part of it cake without it just falling everywhere, because if it just collapses as a mess in Rachel's lap how is that less wasteful?
For real we love Jonny and want to see him feel good about creating badass works of wildness in this role that he's now in!
Johnny: "I'm not failing this time"
Also Johnny: *giving himself like 12 hours to bake hundreds of cakes*
Pretty sure it wasn't him who set the time limit
With one oven ... And it's a champagne cake... That didn't look very sturdy
Nothing wrong - total logic 💯 😂
@@JaxHolder1 yeah, if this was given proper time, it could be done and given to an on theme event to not waste it.
youd have to do a bricking strategy with something sturdier. marshmallow rice is an obvious one, to use as a sort of mortar, with other harder cookies and crackers performing structural work. obviously a lot of dowels and maybe some wooden platforms
@@alexpalaciossantos4940 totally agree. I think it would be more entertaining to see them accomplish these extravagant things and maybe connect it to charity
he didn't give himself the time limit
It was so fun to watch it devolve into the point where Rachel is speechless and being crushed under the cake, Keith has no pants on and is shouting, and Johnny is frantically trying to finish decorating around them lmao
It's not fun at all, it's just annoying.
The appeal of Johnny, other than his lovely personality, is that he's actually capable of doing these type of cakes, but then they give him way too little time.
If this just going to be The Miserable Failure show who is that different than Without a Recipe?
Honestly, Johnny, if you're reading these comments...stop doing these shows unless they change the format, because it's actually going to ruin your reputation as a hyper-realistic cake artist since they keep setting you up to fail and make it look like you can't pull these things off!
11:21 Rachel catching the cake, Keith with no pants, Jonny panicking and covered in buttercream - pure perfection ❤
I wonder if they ever told her or she's just finding out now.
It was the most unhinged but funniest moment 😂
Rachel with the tutu for Keith
I wish we saw Rosanna’s reaction when she found out it wasn’t really cake😂
I love how the try guys have basically adopted other content creators. They still have their own chanels, but they are try guys.
yessss, sisiter creators. it's so wholesome
Yes! And they’ve been overlapping with People Vs. Food, Mythical, and Smosh. It’s like the 4 greatest channels just all collaborating for different content and I love all of it.
I never really realized how tiny Rosanna is??? so much talent and personality in such a tiny container
Especially next to Keith, the size difference was not expected
I remember seeing her house tour and that house is so big she looks like a tiny doll haha
She said in one of her vidoes that she is 4ft 11inches. Which I think is insane cause I’m 4ft either 11 or 12inches and 1/2 with ro
Sameeee I was like woahhhh 😮
It is very noticeable in collabs, her own setup has the camera very low for her and it's a struggle to fit guests in lmao.
A collab between two of the most iconic Without a Recipe judges?
YES PLEASE!!!!
Omg, Without a Recipe: pro edition
I only wish we could actually see her reaction without the fillers and Botox. It kills the authenticity of expressions. 😢 she’s so beautiful already. I wonder who’s telling her she needs the work. 🫶🏻
@@nicolecomfort-mcdermott4743i cant tell if you’re trying to be nasty
@@nicolecomfort-mcdermott4743 Seriously, what is the point of this nasty comment? Are you that miserable that it made you feel better about yourself?
@@nicolecomfort-mcdermott4743stfu none of ur business wether she does surgeries or not, her body not yours
I absolutely love the editing decision to use Jonny's tiktoks as a bumper, like "look, he is actually good at this normally, despite this absolute clusterf*ck he's decided to do today"
If I were Johnny, I'd stop doing these shows because they're ruining his reputation and making him look like he's shite at hyper-realistic baking!
@@sandpiperr
No it's not?
@@systematicirony666 Nah it is, it's making him look very inept at something he professes to be good at. And that's not his fault, it's the fact that they give him such unreasonably short time limits to do giant tasks like this. I love Jonny and it's hard to watch him be set up to fail all the time.
I never know what to expect when I walk into the Try Guys office... All I can say is that it's a new, wonderful experience every time.
And yes, even for Without A Recipe 😅
Love you guys! ❤
I never realised how tiny you were. Keith is like twice your height.
@@WellISaidItikr!😭i’ve always known she’s short but seeing her next to a tall guy is crazy lol
I love when you're on the show. That's how I know it's an extra good episode!
Rosanna, you are a fraud. Your backlog of Colleen Ballinger collabs are pretty vile in hindsight aren't they 🤔 Please don't pretend that your own fans haven't been asking you to disavow your friendship with her for months now, we know 😉 The Mr Beast bs seems like a poor distraction and I know I'm not alone in thinking that. It won't go away @RosannaPansino you have disappointed a lot of people
Right in the middle of the mr beast drama...
Ngl it's kinda frustrating that it seems Jonny is not being provided the tools, time, and appliances for whatever giant you've tasked him to do. Jonny is a great content creator and brings a lot of vibrancy to your videos and I feel that's deserving of setting him up for success instead of constantly setting him up for failure. I'd rather see Jonny succeed; he's so talented with baking and decorating and when given the right tools and what not, he creates amazing things. Allowing him to do that will absolutely bring you more views than watching him fail will. I hope this doesn't come off too critical, I do really enjoy the channel and have been a fan for a long time, I just got frustrated to see Jonny lose yet again with what seems like purposeful efforts on the try guys side.
right? I'm done with these Jonny videos, and that's not because I don't like Jonny, it's because of this format.
thats the point of these videos. its to challenge him and make it entertaining. i understand that even with all the tools it would still be challenging and entertaining but this a format that the guys like to use, and they’re also probably gonna tweak it as it progresses. also it would be a bigger production for them to do.
@@melissa_jpg Not really. The point is to entertain and get views at the end of the day, and I'm watching to be entertained. And based on the top comments, I'm clearly not the only one who feels this way.
100% agree
Could not have said it better.
Keiths CAKE sitting atop the CAKE at the end, was a work of art in itself.
Cakes on cake, baby.
I love that Johnny recognizes what a waste of cake it would be to make that whole thing cake and they used a base instead
Yes! I think this could be done in all cake, but only for a huge event where it would all be eaten. I'd definitely enlist Charm City Cakes to help, though! They know structure for these huge projects.
Jonny asking Jack to get off sound to get him items than talking crap how he didn’t get enough is great 😂
😂😂😂
Jack using his errand as a chance to check out the TVs is so relatable. 😂😂
Next Jonny video: Jonny makes DOG CAKES for Eugene. (Either regular cake shaped like a dog or Dog-safe cakes for Eugene's doggies.) 😊
Why not both
Bring Emma even more anxiety by giving her a replica of herself but in cake 😅
@@caithenry8429 😆😆😆
REPLICA CAKES OF THE THREE DOGS YESSSSS
And then gives up part way through and puts frosting on a dog statue because he only gave himself a couple hours
keith just stripping in the corner before helping is honestly one of the funniest thing he's ever done
Everyone did a great job, but extra kudos for an executive producer who will literally almost drown in cake for a successful Try Guys video. Yay Rachel !!
Johnny covered in frosting, Rachel on her knees trying to catch an armful of cake, Keith in his underwear screaming, is the most unhinged renaissance painting.
The way Keith's first instinct when the cake started to fall apart was to take his pants off 😂😂😂
Edit: Keith's cakes on top of the cakes
I really do be giggling a lot
I love these videos. I also would love to see an episode where Johnny gets to show off his real skills and “is it cake” the guys or people in the office. He’s so talented so it would be nice to have him show off a bit
Yes! Like have Johnny make a 'is it cake' and put it in the office and they just record to see how long it takes for someone to notice and interact with the fake object.
@CosmicRiverstone Telling them there will be one but secretly doing several objects feels like the right amount of chaos.
Yes! All of this!
Yes! This needs to happen!
@@CosmicRiverstone i love this idea! this will be super chaotic and fun!
We love Johnny, give him some more time for these ridiculous projects. I want to see him not fail something for once
It’s so nice to see the Internet’s favourite Pastry Maker Barbies doing a crossover like this. Also, imagine if the subject of the cake was someone over 6 feet tall.
I think the guys should have been carefull with their scoring around Rosanna.
They might have to make a serious video after 2 years.
If you watch to the end you can see Keith's ass perched on top of the cake and get a general idea
You kind of see that in the last five seconds of the video 😂
Rachel really is the MVP of this episode- the after math of her catching the cake was gold 😂
This video is so cute! Rosanna spinning while inside the cake looked so happy! Keith's underwear was an unexpected suprise. At least they didn't chop off his legs when he was to tall for the cake, like Eugene did with the doll😂😂
Missed opportunity for Eugene 😈
We also got to see Keith's own cakes 👀
Eugene must've been out that day 😂
Keith's buns perfectly atop the cake at the end took me out 😂
Why is no one talking about Rachel having the time of her life, just covered with cake & frosting?? So precious! ❤
Keith standing there in his underwear panicking while Johnny and Rachel are panicking about the cake falling is comedy gold!
Imagine is Rosana really did dive out and slide down the side 😂
This series is quickly becoming "Johnny gives himself way too much to do in way too little time and stresses himself out" lol I hope we get to see him at his best too
Rosanna believing the dress is fully cake is fantastic 😂
There's a part after that where she says something like "but wait I thought it was--" before she addresses Keith undressing, so I think she figured it out before they put her into it
@@murikolsthey probably told her but cut it out of the edit 😂
If Johnny had the extra time and more cakes to work with, I'm sure he would have pulled off a full cake ballgown.
@@murikolsshe said "I thought it was paint!" So she had no clue 😂
I want Jonny to succeed on these wild attempts, but I also wish we could have made this a series of the guest coming in to Rachel holding a falling piece of illusion cake with an awkward smile.
Keith losing his pants mid crisis is perfect 😂
I remember watching compilations of Without a Recipe (specifically of Keith) and wondered what Ro & Keith's height difference genuinely looked like. Now we know and it's hilarious. (Also them having to shoot a bit wider at first to get Keith and Ro in frame).
This also made me think of the giant wedding cake Safiya made and also had Ro surprised with
This has become my favorite show, Johnny's chaotic energy and Rachel just willing to do whatever it takes to help him, its just perfection.
Rosanna looked so happy being part of that cake especially with the crown
i love the ft. rosanna part because that made me immediately think that johnny is officially a try guy 😝❤️
What an adorable comment, indeed in our hearts he is also a try guy!!!
If this doesnt become a regularish series, Imma riot. Jonny is amazing and hilarious. The episodes with him are always so fun!
its so refreshing to see someone put respect on Rosanna’s name considering all the drama recently
Girl what drama?
@@Twinkalmia she has been avoiding denouncing her friendship and multiple video collaborations with Colleen Ballinger. Oh and she was also upset with Mr Beast for editing her out of 3rd place in a game of hide and seek, but tbh that seems like a distraction from Colleen, especially seeing as she announced her beef on Trisha's podcast. Istead of a public statement in support of victims, she just said she and Trisha spoke in private. Which is fine when it comes to Trisha specifically but doesn't get her off the hook for failing to speak up on HER relationship with Colleen.
@@dandelion_official4812 yeah, i wasn’t talking about colleen at all bud. just the mr beast stuff.
@@Twinkalmia On Trisha Paytas’s podcast, Rosanna said Mr Beast edited a video she was in to make it look like she did poorly. She said it felt like a “boy’s club” when filming and hinted towards it being for sexist reasons. People found out a male youtuber was edited out the same way though, so that was quickly disproven. People then started sending her death threats and claiming she was saying all this for clout. (which is crazy to me because she’s rosanna pansino😭)
I said “put respect on her name” because so many male youtubers covering the drama treated her as if she was some rando. They acted as if she wasn’t a youtube legend/incredibly well known just because she was in the wrong. It ended up becoming a huge sexism thing where men were incredibly harsh to her, while women treated her fairly. sucks to see :/
@@dandelion_official4812you’ve posted like so many comments on this video about the Colleen drama, over and over? I know the situation is not great - but, chill.
My favorite parts of these are always the inevitable moments in which Johnny realizes he needs help with something and conscripts whoever's in earshot.
I love that the Try Guys are not just about them trying things, but also provides a space for other creators to try things as well. What a delight! 🧡
Perfect timing for our QUEEN ROSANNA!!!
Just the sweetest, and TOTALLY should be celebrated and raised up!
Keith said, " You know what this needs? NOT MY PANTS!"😂 Totally valid
so glad this came out right when rosanna has been dealing with so much garbage online, she could use some positivity on the feed ♥
😱whattt? She seems so sweet?! What's been happening? I'm out of the loop
What happened?
@@rebeccalazzell5262I looked it up, Mr. Beast apparently edited her out of a video and stuff like that and now she’s getting death threats for calling him out on it
i’d just like to say since that weird other guy got the boot y’all have been pumping out top tier content.
Tbh that guy was really weird i forgot about him
Even the editing jokes have been substantially better! Wild how that weird other guy had so much control over the general energy of production
the weird other guy, omg 😂😂
And you had to bring him up many months later like why?🙄
i genuinely forgot about him lmaooo 😭
Love seeing people be so kind and loving to Ro after all the drama the last few weeks ❤
I just love that Jonny is just a regular thing now on this channel. (I cant spell sorry😅)
Keith's ass perched on the dress at the end is an award winning shot 😂😂😂.
Keith just feeding the chaos by taking his pants off 😂
As Kelsey Darragh once said, “why does Keith always look like he’s wearing a diaper?”
God Jonny is so precious, I love him! All of the try guys' secondary members. Jonny, kwesi, lewberger, try spouses. And if course our Miles (miss him!). I'm so glad they have an awesome lineup of fun and silly friends that bring so much to their channel. I love that Jonny was originally (seemingly) a one-time judge and now makes videos with the try team regularly.
I always forget how short Rosanna is and being next to Keith it's absolutely unreal to me.
I'm so happy Jonny has a place where people help him bring his fever dream creations come to life!
People expecting context for Keith being pantsless must be new 😂@11:07 (Bonus: Keith cakes on cakes at the end!!!)
Ro looked so adorable in the cake! Loved Keith's butt cheeks on the cake. Thank you Rachel for helping Jonny and getting Keith the skirt to wear. 2nd Try LLC where your bosses taking their pants off is regular occurrence.😆 Thanks Jack for getting the cakes and tubs of buttercream icing.
This might be one of my favorite videos 😂 Rachel covered in cake, Keith unexpectedly taking his pants off, Rosanna in a cake, and all of Johnny's energy 💯
Rosanna is so tiny next to Keith! This video made me so happy, amazing job try team! 💜💙💚
Keith panicked going "I can't go out there now, I don't have any pants on anymore!" 😂😂😂 Then Rachel absolutely covered in frosting up to her ELBOWS 😭 haha. I love Rosanna, she is so sweet and cute! Every video I see her in, she is just bubbly and excited, she's the best.
This is such a great series, I love Jonny. I would love to see what he could do in challenges without such a short time limit! Maybe in a separate series lol
I think a really simple fix for this would have been to sand or shave part of the foam backing off. Just enough to tilt it slightly so gravity was working with you instead of against. Johnny is such an excellent cake maker and I would actually like to see him excel a little more on the channel and have proper materials and solutions given to him. Still super fun videos though I can't think of too many videos on the main channel that I don't enjoy from the try guys and company 💖
Yes! The structure was too straight, almost pushing the cake out
I watched this with my baker roommate and the way she raged at this entire video was hilarious.
But seriously…why not give him either several days to work on this or not try to do something this big?? Because basically he did nothing. None of it is cake, he didn’t make the butter cream, he only made a little cake. It just seems weird.
Oh my gosh, Rosanna is a treasure! And Johnny having the idea to make her into the cake?! Amazing!
A treasure who still supports Colleen Ballinger 🤮
@@dandelion_official4812she came out with a statement recently today.
Try Guys Last Year: We’ve hired a HR to make sure we keep our business practices respectable.
Try Guys HR Team watching Keith randomly remove his pants: 😓
Funnily enough because it was on camera its safe lol.
Tbf, Keith is the least threatening man alive, especially pantless lmao
johnny is one of the most talented people and they always put him through amounts of stress no human brain should be able to handle. just putting him in situations
It’s so unfair honestly, let him work his magic!
I love Rosanna so much
Girllll I’ve seen enough cake making shows to know there was gonna be an issue when there was no boards or dowels
i was very surprised johnny didn't know he needed boards! rookie mistake!
The height difference with Rosanna and Keith is impressive.
I already watched this video twice yesterday on Patreon, but it's SO FUNNY that I'm watching it again on the main channel! I can never get enough of Jonny Cakes chaos!
I love how Keith just decided to be pantsless. I love that for him.
I haven’t even finished the video but Keith helping in his underwear has me CACKLING 🤣🤣🤣
Jonny THANK YOU SO MUCH for NOT wasting resources by making cake that we all KNOW gets thrown out because no one eats that much cake, or people often bake cakes tougher to be structurally stronger and we as viewers can surmise that when the content is over it is thrown away. So you had the forethought to decide to nor waste..thank you!!waste for content isn't necessary YOU PROVED IT WITH GREAT CONTENT🙌🙌 . BTW you both slayed in those princess 👸 dresses. She bakes, she cares about sustainability and she slays..I'm here for it👏👏👏👏👏
This is the perfect surprise for Ro!🙌👸and super ambitious of Jonny, can't imagine how stressed he was😱
Do you think I should go to jail?
Jonny videos are my new favourite try guy videos. If he’s in it, I pause life to watch 🧡
Johnny whispering so Jack won't hear only to realize Jack would hear perfectly being the sound guy 😂 💀
I love the chaos in Jonny videos so much
Also, I have the same underwear as Keith 😂😅
You know its good when you see Rosanna Pansino ❤
“Get it off or rachel, she’s gonna die!!” Hahahah
gotta love that the direction the channel is going is like 50% the try guys and their friends taking turns torturing each other mentally /gen
Jonny deserves the time he needs in future videos (if he'd prefer it)❤ Big new projects like these don't usually work out on the first try for nearly anyone, so it'd be great to see persistence by letting him problem solve and try again if that's something he'd be interested in! He's such a fantastic addition to this channel.
I love how increasingly crazy these cake videos are getting lol
Ro being the most petite among them standing next to Keith is such a tripy scale 🤣🤣
For the love of god, give jonny more time to bake his cakes.
These things are meant to be challenging not impossible. It doesn't even have to be a week, maybe just 2 days if the project's this big.
They pull 2-day shoots even for Without A Recipe so this should also apply for cooking challenges that are extremely hard to pull off.
The reveal wasn't as satisfying knowing that the only cake part of the dress fell off before they even began.
This makes me so happy, seeing Johnny have his own segment. But also how cute 🥰 that he surprised Ro💜 she’s definitely loved by the right kind of boy channel✨
Rosanna: I fit! 👸
Keith: i fit! 🍑
LMAO
I loved the idea but the video feels disappointing. Everything was done to ensure it would fail and the chaos ensuing looked fake and constructed. It feels like no one even tried to do a good job, or only tried for a brief moment before crashing it. It reminds me of Claire Saffitz going on Jimmy Fallon's show where he 100% purposefully messed up his cake to get funny reactions from Claire.
I love how Johnny has become a TryGuy
This video is just perfection. Ro is so tiny next to Keith, The cake catching, the frosting stains. Keith without pants. Its all just, perfection. I also love how Keith just de-pants with little to no thought in front of his whole office.
in a moment of crisis, Keith’s first instinct was to take his pants off
I LOVE that part of the show is Johnny pulling people away from work at the office to do a sidequest.
I was sad we didn't get to see Rosanna break out of the cake but the after credit scene with Keith was sooo worth it hahahah :D
Rosanna is just precious and so is Johnny! He is the sweetest! Rachel is always so calm and helpful and Keith is hilarious.
You know, I never knew I wanted to wear a cake dress, but after seeing this…
I love Princess Rosanna she's living her sweet fantasy literally! ❤❤
Me crying "please use tiers" softly to Jonny the whole time 😂
KEITH'S CAKE BULDGING ON TOP OF THE ACTUAL CAKE IN THE END. MESMERIZING.
I love LOOVE Rosanna's hair!!😍 don't get me wrong blonde's great but this deep brown really compliments her well😊
yess and she usually wears extensions but i think her natural length suits her sm
Coming here to say this very thing! So pretty 😍
“I brought some spare ganache from my home.” As you do.