I really think Elder Princess Shroob should be ranked slightly lower than her younger sister. She actually shows compassion for her sister, unlike vice versa, and she's genuinely doing what she believes is best for her people. The younger Princess Shroob seems to go out of her way to be malicious, and she honestly behaves kind of like a brat.
I'd actually rank Luigi above Mario, the moment where he shares the cookie with his baby self on Yoshi's Island is so wholesome, and he did it when nobody was looking so he didn't require the glory of being recognised as kind-hearted
@@salimgueclue2611 I agree on so many levels. He is always ranked lower than his overrated brother. Literally, if we think personality wise, Luigi would be above his brother.
@@Baldi_n_Friends not really. You can like Luigi better as a character but he’s definitely more flawed than his brother in-universe. In a way that makes him more relatable, but the point is mario isn’t really shown to have any ‘inner demons’ like Luigi is sometimes implied to have.
@@callinater6133 Ok true, but I think his relatability is what makes him stand out. Meanwhile, Mario is always happy or angry. In other words, Mario is just... bland.
I have to disagree with the bad to evil category since 1. The Shroobs actually care about each other and all they wanted was a new home after their old one was destroyed 2. The Dark Star is amoral so it doesn't know the difference between good and evil 3. You were right to rank Fawful higher than Antasma in your Mario villains list. But now that accuracy is thrown out the window 4. Fawful has the longest list of crimes in the Mario and Luigi series such as multiple successful killings even on screen, attempted world domination, both physical and mental torture, stealing, attempted murder, false imprisonment, causing an epidemic with the same disease on 2 races, attempted betrayal, attempted populicide, brainwashing, and being the one to unleash the Dark Star in the first place so everything the Dark Star does is all Fawful's fault. Plus Fawful would rather kill himself than find it within himself to find redemption if it wasn't for the fact that he's comedic relief he would have landed a pure evil wiki spot since Fawful not only knows that he's evil and lacks morals but he loves every second of it. As a result Fawful the REAL most evil character in the Mario and Luigi series. 5. Antasma could also count as amoral since he's just a physical embodiment of nightmares similar to how the Dark Star is a physical embodiment of darkness. But I do agree with Bowser's ranking
While I agree with you about Fawful, I personally disagree with you about Princess Shroob, she knows what she's doing is wrong and doesn't care, the only thing that prevents her from being considered pure evil is the fact the she cares about her sister.
@@Wolfywolf7 yeah it's funny. And speaking of in the Mario and Luigi series King Boo would end up in the grey area this time not as dark grey as Bowser though but only because he only has 1 appearance unfortunately seriously King Boo aside from Luigi Mansion and the Sports games he is criminally underutilized.
@@Wolfywolf7 yeah when he isn't in Luigi's Mansion he's pretty much Loki sometimes villainous sometimes pleasant depending on the moment. And when that gem is on his head his darkest side rears it's purely evil head. Anyways I like both designs the Luigi's Mansion design is the best for intimidation and when he's being a straight up villain. His other design is good when he's in a docile albeit mischievous mood. Also here is what I have in mind for King Boo in future games. 1. The next Paper Mario game: secret boss and post story mode playable character. 2. Luigi's Mansion 4: obviously the main antagonist and final boss. And this should be the game that officially confirms that King Boo is NOT Bowser's ghost just to keep King Boo as his own character. 3. Mario Kart 10: 1 out of 10 of the default roster playable characters alongside Mario, Peach, Bowser, Luigi, Toad, Yoshi, DK, Wario, and Waluigi. 4. The next New Super Mario Bros game: secret boss
@@Wolfywolf7 I have my own idea of what King Boo or the Boo species are in general. They're a form of mischievous spirits not spirits of the dead in fact they would be more similar to fairies from the Zelda series except more ghostlike and more willing to cause chaos. And since you can't permanently kill a Boo they are in a way immortal ( King Boo states in the DS remake of Mario 64 that Boos can't die for good so they'll always be back and he's no exception) which is why they can be effective soldiers (given that they don't require things that Bowser's other minions would require and they are very hard to beat if you aren't just playing with a star or other items similar to the star) which is why Bowser more often than not makes partnerships with King Boo and even has Boos in his army.
@@GenesisSonicN64Mariooh ok. So with that rule in mind luigi… Is still more good. D-depending on if you consider him sharing a cookie with his baby self thoughtful or just narcissistic
Peasley really is a good character. I love how he helps the Mario brothers selflessly. Not like other characters from the series that are blind, "Huh, the Mario brothers?, World destruction? Nah fam we're just chilling"
@ApatheticFish3667 In the end of the game while the castle is blowing up, Peasley just shows up to the Mario Bros. and tells them to leave instead of just... TAKING THEM ON HIS FLYING MACHINE! (Because lord forbid their shoes get his cushion dirty...) He might not have DIRECTLY tried to kill them, but he still left them behind when he could've saved them. He HAD the chance.
@@furret1907 I don't think that cushion would have held all three of them. And he probably wouldn't have blown up the castle if he didn't think they could escape in time.
I personally think Bowser should be ranked evil instead of neutral. Sure, he did try to help Mario and Luigi in superstar saga, but that was only because he didn’t want his castle being destroyed when he kidnaps peach. Sure, he did go through a lot of things in Superstar saga, like getting amnesia, working with popple, getting unconcous and turned to bowletta, and even blown up in the end. That game was the only time bowser didn’t deserve what was coming to him. But the other games tell a different story. In partners in time, he willingly teamed up with his younger self to try and stop the bros just to kidnap peach, once more. In bowsers inside story, he actually DID help to save the day. But not because it’s for morality. It’s because he had the mindset of “No one can take over this world, except me”. He only went on this journey to try and beat Mario. Dream team however, he was the most evil. Teaming up with Antasma, actually defeating the bros when they had their guard down, setted off with Antasma to steal the dream stone, plot for world domination, kidnapping peach AGAIN, even betraying Antasma in the end, and ended up swallowing the dream stones shards, which corrupted him into a Godlike being of evil.
when I was younger, I thought Antasma was Cackletta reincarnated, because he looks very similar to her Also because of that stupid bat multiplication attack thing he does
I wouldn’t say Princess and Elder Princess Shroob are as evil as, let’s say Fawful. They at least cared for their species and each other, and wanted to do the best for them, even if their tactics are pure evil and horrifying for their victims. But Fawful had no care in the world for anyone but himself, even planning to betray and kill Cackletta. He nearly drained and annihilated Peach for his own use of her voice, was the one to awake the dark star, and even when he was defeated he tried to use the last of his powers to blow up the Weegee bros. His plans involved him taking over Bowser and Peach’s castles and causing everyone to become BEEG bois so he can be unstoppable. He deserves the gold medal of chortles and evilness, and if you don’t agree you may as well just be brainwashed so you can bow to the Lord Fawful.
Ok goddamit I’m so wrong, the shroobs after all tried to destroy an entire planet while Fawful was only conquering one place, and the Shroobs overall could’ve went with the easier way and joined forces and gained peace with the inhabitants.
@@zay2k539 The shroobs would have gone extinct as long as they didn't take action, at least as far as I know. What they did was pure evil yes but it didn't come from pure evil they just had to do what was necissary to survive (and got carried away)
@@Imar13 I get what you're saying, but they were only driven by the greed for destruction, not survival. And even if they were in need for survival, their methods of torture and death would be considered unnecessarily cruel.
Will princess shroob doesn't really care about her subjects at all but I have to say but that's the only true shroob that I can name about that doesn't care about each other
Idk if captain goomba should rank ahead of the bros, because at the end of the day he still works for bowser who wants world domination. Mario is contributing to a more noble cause I’d say.
@@liamtherobot9656 mario is not disrespectful either (in fact he’s pretty much the only person in the series that isn’t mean to Luigi in any way) so that isn’t really a point in favour of goomba.
Mario & Luigi Series Characters: Good to Evil THE GOOD 1) Captain Goomba 2) Mario 3) Luigi 4) Prince Dreambert 5) Prince Peasley 6) Stuffwell 7) Starlow 8) Dr Toadley 9) Toadsworth 10) Eldream 11) Brouqe Monsieur 12) Shockron 13) The Z Keeper 14) Bowser Jr 15) The Massif Bros. 16) Professor E. Gadd 17) Kylie Koopa 18) Princess Peach 19) Queen Bean 20) Princess Lipid 21) Ned Smith 22) Lady Lema THE GREY AREA 23) Birdo 24) Koople 25) Dr Snoozemore 26) Brouqe Madame 27) Broggy 28) Fritter 29) Mr Thwomp 30) Harhall 31) Brickle 32) Not-So Globin 33) The Star Door 34) Whizderm 35) Bowser 36) Kamek 37) Mrs Thwomp 38) J'jora BAD TO EVIL 39) Popple 40) Midbus 41) The Monty Moles 42) Private Goomp, Sergeant Guy and Corporal Paraplunk 43) The Best Fitness Friends 44) Cackletta 45) Fawful 46) Antasma 47) The Dark Star 48) The Shroob Princesses
I'm happy to see more mario & luigi content. I kinda wish you used music from the series instead of just royalty free music you can hear in thousands of other videos.
@@poweroffriendship2.0 there's a difference between uploading a video containing someone talking over background music and uploading a video containing _just_ the background music.
@@Bonnielikescats he also blowed up toad town a thousands times,turned toads to bricks,destroyed peach's castle in paper jam,which could've killed her and the toads but he didn't seem to care.
Great opinions on good to evil! However in my opinion the number one most evil villain is none other than The Dark Star because it’s evil eyes and it’s dark and has the ability to turn everything into darkness.
Me personally it's Fawful since 1. The Dark Star is amoral it doesn't know the difference between good and evil it acts on instinct rather than motive. 2. Fawful was the one who unleashed the Dark Star in the first place 3. Aside from being comedic Fawful lacks any of the redeeming qualities that some of the other villains have for example Cackletta: she genuinely cared about Fawful even if she wasn't overly protective ( the feeling is NOT mutual, in fact Fawful planned to get rid of her when she was no longer useful to him) The Shroobs: they genuinely care about each other and all they really wanted was a new home after they lost their old homeworld. Antasma: was genuinely hurt when Bowser betrayed him albeit Bowser had a good reason to. The BFF's: they do care about each other even if they are rude to each other they basically act like they are siblings. Fawful lacks any of those qualities in fact the only reason he isn't pure evil is because he's comedic relief.
@@chadpeterson5698 you forgot about Midbus,who respected Fawful and obeyed his every orders and was royal to him,yet when Midbus died Fawful was like: "Oh no! Anyways."
@@chadpeterson5698 very late but hard agree, idk why people act like Fawful caring about Cackletta after the second half of Superstar Saga is canon. Like if that was his motive why did he literally never once mention her, even when ranting about his past she isn't even an afterthought. He never says stuff about losing her, it's always about how he lost and got screwed over. Just like how after Midbus died or whatever, Fawful never mentions him again either. Yet I've seen a lot of people try to force this headcanon that he cares about one or both of them, maybe to make him redeemable or something idk?
@@lunari64_ At least when you're running away cause you're scared you have the justification of you know being scared but running away because you're lazy is much worse.
Let me get this strait, you guys included Harhall, who has like, five minutes of screen time in Superstar Saga and is not seen again after that, but you left out the Koopalings, who have MAJOR roles in the side stories. I was disappointed.
Id personally put starlow in the grey area, shes a jerk to almost everyone except Mario and peach for no real reason and causes a lot of problems with her hostility and rude behavior
This was pretty alright for the most part. I felt it wasn't as well researched as the Kirby video to be honest. It's missing important characters and there are some things I felt may have been missed. You forgot: The Koopalings. They're important characters, as they were highly important to both Minion Quest and Bowser Jr.'s Journey. The rest of the Elite Captain Quartet. They're also important. They're Captain Goomba's main partners. The rest of the Shroobs. The Shroobs in general are important to rank due to their importance to Partners in Time's plot. While yeah, most of what they did could be summed up in the Princess Shroob section, it's probably important to note them as well. Corrections: Peach's reason for being on the low end of good is a pretty shallow one. I'd argue mostly being kidnapped means she's not likely to have the screen time to do much anyway, so it's less impactful for her overall morality than implied in the video. She still deserves to be on the low end of good though because she still risked the poor Birdo's voice being replaced with explosive vocabulary as a strategy. While for the greater good so that Cackletta couldn't use the Bean Star, she basically used some random bystander as a meat shield for her plan, which could be considered somewhat manipulative in nature, even if for a good cause. That, and using telekinesis to throw Bowser out of her castle doesn't do her morality any favors, considering she never does that when she's kidnapped, and it's never explained why that is. Mario has to save her plenty of times despite her potentially having the power to clearly defend herself in those situations. Is the Birdo that Peach used the same one that is Popple's Rookie? I don't remember Birdo's voice ever returning to her, so I doubt it's the same Birdo, even if Super Mario Wiki seems to think it is. Britta should probably be below Brickle. I got the vibe that many of her workers were frightened of her, even if it's fair to ensure they aren't slacking. Brickle's worst deed was a misunderstanding and a waste of time. Plus, if I recall correctly, Britta got herself in danger because when Mario and Luigi uncovered that passageway up the sandflow, she told them to stay put because it was rumored that there would be treasure, and went in by herself with a goal of stashing it for herself in mind. A greedy act that didn't end well. Nitpicks: I have trouble trying to gather whether Fawful being evil enough that he'd likely have no problem doing what Antasma did constitutes as enough to put him on the bronze medal of evil instead of Antasma, but ultimately, it could probably go either or. Fawful's clearly more evil minded considering Antasma's genuine team up with Bowser, so in a sense, he should be higher, but Antasma's got a higher body count, so it's probably fair to put him lower on the morality scale since the body count is more proof than just knowing the character and assuming he'd do the same offered the chance. This is a nitpick, take it with a grain of salt.
You're wrong about the shroobs. Yes, they made a show out of conquering the mushroom kingdom, but they went to earth because their home planet was dying. They needed a new home and new sources of energy. Of course they took it in very violent and cruel ways, but I thought the shroob princesses wanted the best for their people. Why do you think there were no other planets mentioned that the shroobs had? Because there weren't any. Likely the shroobs stayed on their planet, minding their own business, until they had no choice but to seek new lands
*Good:* + T-Series (they make sick music and are the #1 ranked YTer in the world) + MrBeast (Always donating to charity, god bless that man) + Pyrocynical (Just a cute little lesbian. Also a furry) + Rooster Teeth (A massive group of wholesome people who make animations, games and podcasts) + JackSepticeye (He's Oirish; that makes him good) + GradeAUnderA (He's Bri'ish; that makes him good) *Neutral:* + PewDiePie (Good man, however he did say the n word once and that is unacceptable) + Keemstar (Funny gnome man who picks fights with people on Halo and Twitter, but he does run the news which is cool I guess) + LeafyIsHere (Literally the chaotic neutral of all of RUclips. Do anything and he roasts you. At least he's funny) + DarkSydePhil (Just your everyday man who needs to pay his taxes you guys) + SuperMarioLogan (Got CaD'd by Nintendo, invented the absolute satan-spawn that is Jeffy, but he was a nice person) + Markiplier (He is cool and funny but he also plans to make people deaf by screaming so much, he can't be good with such a sad and lousy plan) *Evil:* + RyansToyReviews (They ripped off Mario Kart) + Jake Paul (Fights people just so he can suck his own cock) + Logan Paul (Makes fun of dead people and tried to make Pikachu in real life by tazoring rats or something. Also fought KSI) + Onision (Let his two-year-old jump out a window, and his books are shit) + RiceGum (Who the fuck eats rice while chewing gum??? But yeah he cyberbullies people) + Dream (He's a cheat)
I was hoping we'd see Yikk on this list but I guess his role in the game was far too small to include him, kinda sad , he was actually one of my favorites
@@lolsu5820 Yikk was the owner of the Tower of Yikk who slumbered in the book Bowser opened after he defeated the tower. Yikk tells Bowser about his research on boos then introduces the Boo Ray Machine for Bowser to use so Mario & Luigi can go after the first star sage in Bowser's body, after Bowser uses the Boo Ray the first time Yikk calls the first use of the Boo Ray on a living being a sucess then goes back to sleep in his book. It wasn't a large role in the game but I still enjoyed it
If you ask me that makes him more heroic being fearful of the unknown the unpredictability of the outside world on what’s out there the endless possibilities of your demise that would scared anyone yet Luigi still perceive to go on I like to think that the one thing that scares him more than the monsters in the mushroom kingdom is the fear of losing his friends and family and uses that as motivation to power though the obstacles in his way even if some he gets treated poorly by his them he still goes though life and death to save them not really asking anything in return and that’s why he’s my favorite character in the Mario universe
@@Wolfywolf7 I didn’t really reply to you on my first comment so I was confused either that or that was a joke you post with this XD soAgain I was confused
11:25, Au contraire, he must have known that he sent Peach back to the time of the shroob invasion setting up the entire plot of M and L Partners in Time.
I know people already said this but Fawful should be lower in fact he should be lower then the Shroobs because he helped Cackletta in addition to trying to conquer if not destroy the Mushroom Kingdom.
I would say the most evil would be the shroobs definitely. Their goals seemed to be destruction and conquest, not relaly carring how many bodies they have to trample over to do so. Heck, the one of the first "dungeons" of the game (vim factory), you see toads having their life force sucked out of them, ensnared by trees, just to power their fleet. IMO, the shroobs had the most "evil" vibes and were fairly close to victory, really only failing due the the Mario bros. and dumb luck.
nope it has to be Fawful since 1. the Shroobs care about each other and they conquered out of necessity since they only wanted a new home after their old one was destroyed 2. Fawful unleashed the Dark Star in the first place and he doesn't care about the collateral damage 3. in fact Fawful aside from being comedic has NO redeeming qualities he doesn't care about anyone and he will stop at nothing until he gets what he wants. 4. the Mario Bros couldn't stop him without Bowser and visa versa. combined with dumb luck as a result Fawful was even closer to victory than the shroobs.
@@chadpeterson5698 1. Not true at all as far as caring for each other go. Elder Princess Shroob and Commander Shroob literally sent them to suicide, just to try and gain ground on the Mario Bros. Yes their old planet was (likely) dying, but there were other planets they could have easily inhabited, and they certainly didn't have to conquer the Mushroom Kingdom to get what they want. 2. Pretty sure Shroobs give 2 craps about collateral damage as well. 3. Shroobs have zero redeeming qualities as well. 4. Dumb Luck never had anything to do with Fawful failing. And we don't know what would have happened if Bowser didn't get involved. Also, the BFF were in the midst of betraying him and likely would have succeeded if not for Bowser Jr. The Shroobs meanwhile were far closer to succeeding...in fact, they had even succeeded for a time. I will give you that mentality, Fawful and the Shroobs were very similar in goals...as was Cackletta for that matter. But the Shroobs were the closest to actually achieving their goals.
@@IamCanadian3333 there are a couple of problems 1. Princess Shroob and Elder Princess Shroob both care about each other with Elder Princess Shroob saying that she will avenge her sister after the Mario Bros killed her. And Elder Princess Shroob and Princess Shroob alike while they may not care about individuals they do care about their whole race. 2. The collateral damage with Fawful is even bigger given that the Dark Star threatens life itself and Fawful doesn't even care just as long as he can kill the Mario Bros yeah he'll obliterate kingdoms if not the entire world if it means getting rid of a couple of people. 3. Caring about others especially family is a redeeming quality and Princess Shroob and her big sister do care about each other like I said before. 4. The BFF's if they couldn't even beat the Koopalings and Bowser Jr how could they be a real threat to Fawful especially given that Fawful at one point knocked Bowser out with a single blast of his vacuum helmet and Bowser is obviously stronger than the Koopalings and just as strong if not stronger than Bowser Jr. Also yeah Bowser was neccessary in stopping Fawful especially given how Fawful planned things since he planned to incapacitate most of the population by inflating them with blorbs, then using Bowser as a means of getting rid of everyone else by have Bowser eat them. And also there are many things left to sheer dumb luck for example if Bowser didn't encounter Brogue Monseir he wouldn't get the vacuum block and that was a key part in stopping Fawful, if Bowser wasn't blown into the Cavi Cape tunnels he couldn't get to the area where he gets blasted by electricity and as a result the Mario Bros wouldn't have access to the warp pipes that lead out of Bowser's body so they would be stuck inside him as a result they wouldn't even learn about the Star Cures so Fawful would would be free to get the Dark Star without intervention and even if they somehow managed to learn about the Star Cures the Mario Bros would never be able to get all 3 of them since they would be stuck inside Bowser and Bowser would be stuck inside a safe so yeah Fawful's defeat was down to sheer dumb luck.
@@chadpeterson5698 A few problems with your points: 1. As far as the Shroob sisters go, yes they cared for each, but that’s about it. About their whole race, sure, but that’s more because they are conquerors and that’s part of their power. Fawful falls into that camp too tbh, he cares enough about his army he brainwashes them instead of killing them outright…plus he did revive Cackletta, something he did not have to do. He clearly had some care for his master. 2. That’s super speculative and tbh not even true. He clearly values his whole life, and his goal has always been personal power…which is why he absorbed the dark star’s power instead of just letting it lose. He wants to rule the whole world. He was only willing to sacrifice himself after he was already beaten and on the brink of death anyways. That hardly counts. 3. Just like Fawful cares about Cackletta, and to a lesser extent Midbus. 4. A few points. Captain Goomba and his crew which included the Koopalings had defeated Fawful…twice…in the same manner that Bowser Jr. defeated the BFF…the exact same manner actually. So even if you want to use that point, it kind of goes against you. Fawful, an upgraded version lost to Bowser, so that point is also down the drain. In the first game, that was just a surprise attack, and a stab in the back is hardly considered a “I beat you 1v1 fair and square” fight. And that is superseded anyways by my previous point about Captain Goomba. All that “luck” you mentioned, was actually just player progression and a result of Fawful’s own doing or Bowser’s/Mario’s doing. If you want to take that literally, then every single story was “dumb luck.” And that doesn’t actually help your point. What I was referring to with the Shroobs was when Bowser abducted “Princess Peach,” as well later found out that actually put a wrenching the shroob’s plan to take over the future. It was blind dumb luck that Bowser had showed up, it wasn’t due to the Mario Bros. actions or the shroobs actions, it just happened, and it was to the detriment of the shroobs.
@@IamCanadian3333 well technically Fawful doesn't care about Cackletta he only saved her because he still had some use for her similar to why Palpatine saved Anakin Skywalker in Star Wars because Palpatine still saw Vader as useful and planned to replace him when his usefulness was at an end. Fawful takes a similar approach to this except the roles are reversed to a degree, Fawful keeps Cackletta around so she can conquer the Mushroom and Beanbean Kingdoms so when Fawful makes his move to get rid of her he can assume power without much trouble nice and easy. Also no Fawful doesn't care about Midbus either since he doesn't even bat an eye when Midbus dies in fact he brushes it off like it was nothing. Also Fawful like all villains is arrogant and Bowser had help from his minions in the battle against Fawful ( particularly in that attack when Fawful summons lots of energy balls and Bowser has to throw Goombas at him. ) also my dumb luck argument is more legitimate than you give it credit for since what do you think would have happened if Bowser wasn't blown directly into the Cavi Cape tunnels which the moles were digging if that didn't happen then the Mario Bros wouldn't have discovered the pipe yard and as a result they wouldn't have been able to collect all 3 Star Cures even if some of the other events were to come to pass since Bowser and the Mario Bros indirectly would be stuck in a safe in a junkyard, Fawful would have taken the power of the Dark Star and he would have won. All it took for Fawful's plans to go awry was Bowser getting blown to the right place at the right time.
In my opinion Dark Star is the truly worst of the bunch. The only reason it is defeated is that dark star got Cocky after absorbing the other half of his power (stolen by Fawful) after being recently reawakened and still not used to it's mimicked body of bowser, by the legends Dark star was a universe level threat, who I doubt even Princess Rosalina could defeat. Antasma atleast had the argument of being manipulated and turned evil from the wishes of Nightmare stone.
Still waiting for these Good to Evils: Super Mario Characters: Good to Evil (Mainstream Games) Donkey Kong Country Characters: Good to Evil Super Smash Bros. Playable Characters: Good to Evil Minecraft Story Mode Characters: Good to Evil Telltale's The Walking Dead Characters: Good to Evil Telltale's Batman Characters: Good to Evil Batman Arkham Series Characters: Good to Evil The Last of Us Characters: Good to Evil Nintendo Heroes: Good to Most Good
@@Wolfywolf7 I know, but on their channel (Game Domain) in their community tab they said that they are aware of 1up Binge. So lets just see 1Up Binge's take Super Mario: Good to Evil (Mainstream Games)
Plz do the Henry stickmin collection characters *good to evil* Good: Charles Calvin Grey: Henry stickmin Bad: Reginald copperbottom and right hand man Evil: Dimitri
@Alexander Philippe How about we only focus on the ones that are only on screen like Henry, Ellie, Charles, hurbert Galeforce, and even Dave Panpa, Burt Curtis, and sven svenson
I would say the most good goes to either any of the visitors or the owl. While NiGHTS is one of the good guys, they’re a little more antiheroic in comparison.
You are absolutely right about Bowser Jr. being a good guy Reason is already mentioned but I wanna add something as well The whole reason Bowser Jr. helping his dad capture Princess Peach is just to impress Bowser Or just to help his own father His point is not evil He is a good guy
The shroobs were only trying to live. They definitely cared about eachother a lot. The elder loved her sister with all her heart. Even shroobs worth is caring for a baby. War is awful no one is spared. Not even babies. Like the shroob children whose heads Mario crushed and the attempt on baby Mario and Luigi’s lives. But the shroobs did not destroy their planet it was shunned by starlight indicating that it’s star died or said planet was ejected from its orbit. Everything other than the shroobs is correct. The shroobs should be right before cackletta in my opinion.
Where are the Koopalings? They were like, main characters in Bowser Junior's Journey, I think they deserved to be on this list, yet they aren't... And also the other Captains as well, they're all distinct characters... Also, Peach should have been much lower due to the fact she used a Birdo in order to save her own sorry ass from Fawful and Cackletta taking her voice, and the worst part is Mario and Luigi failed to get it back, and so the poor Birdo lives the rest of her life with that explosive vocabulary that Fawful and Cackletta meant to replace Peach's voice with, so yeah, Peach is not good IMO, and I think Peach should have been a little lower... I also hate Peach for a variety of other reasons as well... Also, Starlow is such a massive asshole and an annoying pest, Starlow should also be much lower on the list as well IMO...
I have an objection for the shroobs while yes they did a lot of harm to the mushroom kingdom their acts were by pure desperation of finding a new home acording to partners in time. Not that it justifies their actions but they had their reasons.
Portal Characters: Good to Evil 🏅 Gold Medal of Good: Caroline 🥈 Silver Medal of Good: Atlas and P-Body 🥉 Bronze Medal of Good: The Cores Grey Area: Cave Johnson, Defective Turrets 🥉 Bronze Medal of Evil: Turrets 🥈 Silver Medal of Evil: Wheatley 🏅 Gold Medal of Evil: GLaDOS
My list: Most good: Atlas and P-Body Silver Medal: Chell Bronze Medal: Caroline Grey area: The Announcer Wheatley (If you go into the lore you'll realize why Wheatley isn't evil) Defective Turrets Evil: Bronze Medal: Turrets Silver Medal: Cave Johnson Gold Medal: GLaDOS
Mario & Luigi: Paper Jam is canon to the Mario & Luigi series. That crossover is canon to both series. I wasn't talking about generic characters, person who replied to the deleted comment
im not very into mario universe so im asking while being not sure about this: why there is no Wario and Waluigi on this list? I mean they are from antoher franchise or something?
I disagree on the Shroob princesses being the most evil. Yes, they came to Mushroom Kingdom with a lot of destruction, but they had to do it for the survival of their race. Is it evil for someone to destroy, when it is the only way to survive? And Mario and Luigi didn't tried to reason with them, they committed Genocide.
don't really think they could've, considering peach trapped elder in the cobalt star for who knows how long, I doubt she'd just let it be water under the bridge, and by the time they get to her they've killed her younger sister. So there's a very low chance elder would even try to reason with them
For Splatoon: Good: Agent 3 Neutral: Captain Cuttlefish Evil: DJ Octavio For BOTW: Good: Mipha Neutral: Link Evil: Calamity Ganon (or Astor if you include AOC) For Pokémon SwSh: Good: Leon Neutral: Piers Evil: Chairman Rose
@@Wolfywolf7 ehh, grizz isn’t really evil. We don’t know enough about him, he could just be eating golden eggs for survival. He’d be a perfect fit for the bottom of the grey area.
@@Wolfywolf7 the salmonids aren’t exactly innocent, their not sentient and for all we know, their dangerous. We just don’t know much about grizz to put him as bad. But he would go in the bottom of the grey area.
You mention bowser jr's development but not the fact that he doesnt beleave in the concept of good and evil, or that he believes he is the good guy. Smh my head
Some people think Luigi should be ranked higher than Mario, but I think they should be ranked both on the same spot. I ,mean they are both very loyal to one another and will always do what's right and save the day
The Elder Princess Shroob is the only Shroob that speaks perfect english. When Fawful says “I have fury” he truly does mean it, speaking of which, he started out as a bean salesman during the past version of Partners in Time, before Cackletta’s reign of terror. I don’t think Captain Goomba would want to be classified as a hero.
You forgot the giant caterpillar Wiggler who appears in both Bowsers Inside Story and Dream Team. I would probably put him in the upper half of the grey zone, possibly at the top of the Grey zone if Paper Jam was included.
Don't forget that Dark Star takes form of Bowser to make himself more powerful. Eventually absorbing Fawful and dark power being complete. And finally fighting Bowser and dying.
I have a question about Dreambert. Since he obviously has the title of prince, and we get no mention of a king or queen, does that mean, he technically rules over the island?
🎮 Paper Mario Villains: Evil to Most Evil - bit.ly/30ZPO0z
Subscribe to 1upBinge - bit.ly/3jD1y08 🔔
JUST DO CRASH BANDICOOT VILLAINS TO POWERFULL AND EVIL TO MOST EVIL
Undertale good to evil and Henry Stickmin good to evil
Metroid: Good to Evil 👾
You guys should do resident evil 5 good to evil next time
I really think Elder Princess Shroob should be ranked slightly lower than her younger sister. She actually shows compassion for her sister, unlike vice versa, and she's genuinely doing what she believes is best for her people. The younger Princess Shroob seems to go out of her way to be malicious, and she honestly behaves kind of like a brat.
I'd actually rank Luigi above Mario, the moment where he shares the cookie with his baby self on Yoshi's Island is so wholesome, and he did it when nobody was looking so he didn't require the glory of being recognised as kind-hearted
luigi is always underrated
@@salimgueclue2611 I agree on so many levels. He is always ranked lower than his overrated brother. Literally, if we think personality wise, Luigi would be above his brother.
In a sense that is selfish as he is giving it to himself
@@Baldi_n_Friends not really. You can like Luigi better as a character but he’s definitely more flawed than his brother in-universe. In a way that makes him more relatable, but the point is mario isn’t really shown to have any ‘inner demons’ like Luigi is sometimes implied to have.
@@callinater6133 Ok true, but I think his relatability is what makes him stand out. Meanwhile, Mario is always happy or angry. In other words, Mario is just... bland.
I have to disagree with the bad to evil category since
1. The Shroobs actually care about each other and all they wanted was a new home after their old one was destroyed
2. The Dark Star is amoral so it doesn't know the difference between good and evil
3. You were right to rank Fawful higher than Antasma in your Mario villains list. But now that accuracy is thrown out the window
4. Fawful has the longest list of crimes in the Mario and Luigi series such as multiple successful killings even on screen, attempted world domination, both physical and mental torture, stealing, attempted murder, false imprisonment, causing an epidemic with the same disease on 2 races, attempted betrayal, attempted populicide, brainwashing, and being the one to unleash the Dark Star in the first place so everything the Dark Star does is all Fawful's fault. Plus Fawful would rather kill himself than find it within himself to find redemption if it wasn't for the fact that he's comedic relief he would have landed a pure evil wiki spot since Fawful not only knows that he's evil and lacks morals but he loves every second of it. As a result Fawful the REAL most evil character in the Mario and Luigi series.
5. Antasma could also count as amoral since he's just a physical embodiment of nightmares similar to how the Dark Star is a physical embodiment of darkness.
But I do agree with Bowser's ranking
While I agree with you about Fawful, I personally disagree with you about Princess Shroob, she knows what she's doing is wrong and doesn't care, the only thing that prevents her from being considered pure evil is the fact the she cares about her sister.
@@Bonnielikescats I didn't say that about the shroobs I said that about the Dark Star and MAYBE Antasma
@@Wolfywolf7 yeah it's funny. And speaking of in the Mario and Luigi series King Boo would end up in the grey area this time not as dark grey as Bowser though but only because he only has 1 appearance unfortunately seriously King Boo aside from Luigi Mansion and the Sports games he is criminally underutilized.
@@Wolfywolf7 yeah when he isn't in Luigi's Mansion he's pretty much Loki sometimes villainous sometimes pleasant depending on the moment. And when that gem is on his head his darkest side rears it's purely evil head. Anyways I like both designs the Luigi's Mansion design is the best for intimidation and when he's being a straight up villain. His other design is good when he's in a docile albeit mischievous mood. Also here is what I have in mind for King Boo in future games.
1. The next Paper Mario game: secret boss and post story mode playable character.
2. Luigi's Mansion 4: obviously the main antagonist and final boss. And this should be the game that officially confirms that King Boo is NOT Bowser's ghost just to keep King Boo as his own character.
3. Mario Kart 10: 1 out of 10 of the default roster playable characters alongside
Mario, Peach, Bowser, Luigi, Toad, Yoshi, DK, Wario, and Waluigi.
4. The next New Super Mario Bros game: secret boss
@@Wolfywolf7 I have my own idea of what King Boo or the Boo species are in general. They're a form of mischievous spirits not spirits of the dead in fact they would be more similar to fairies from the Zelda series except more ghostlike and more willing to cause chaos. And since you can't permanently kill a Boo they are in a way immortal ( King Boo states in the DS remake of Mario 64 that Boos can't die for good so they'll always be back and he's no exception) which is why they can be effective soldiers (given that they don't require things that Bowser's other minions would require and they are very hard to beat if you aren't just playing with a star or other items similar to the star) which is why Bowser more often than not makes partnerships with King Boo and even has Boos in his army.
“Mario is higher up then his brother”
Matpat-bullshit
He said he's only counting his actions in the Mario and Luigi series
@@GenesisSonicN64Mariooh ok. So with that rule in mind luigi…
Is still more good. D-depending on if you consider him sharing a cookie with his baby self thoughtful or just narcissistic
@@susiehaltmann3342 True
When I saw that captain goomba was the best good I screamed “LETS GO”
Me too bro
I was like "Huh?"
I agree he should be number one because of everything he’s done
had to be done.
I personally think he should be in the grey area since, bowser
Peasley really is a good character. I love how he helps the Mario brothers selflessly. Not like other characters from the series that are blind, "Huh, the Mario brothers?, World destruction? Nah fam we're just chilling"
To be fair, Peasley competed against the Mario Bros for no reason, AND he tried to kill them!
@@furret1907 He tried to kill them? Yeah I don't thing we're playing the same game.
@ApatheticFish3667 In the end of the game while the castle is blowing up, Peasley just shows up to the Mario Bros. and tells them to leave instead of just... TAKING THEM ON HIS FLYING MACHINE! (Because lord forbid their shoes get his cushion dirty...)
He might not have DIRECTLY tried to kill them, but he still left them behind when he could've saved them. He HAD the chance.
@@furret1907 I don't think that cushion would have held all three of them. And he probably wouldn't have blown up the castle if he didn't think they could escape in time.
I personally think Bowser should be ranked evil instead of neutral. Sure, he did try to help Mario and Luigi in superstar saga, but that was only because he didn’t want his castle being destroyed when he kidnaps peach. Sure, he did go through a lot of things in Superstar saga, like getting amnesia, working with popple, getting unconcous and turned to bowletta, and even blown up in the end. That game was the only time bowser didn’t deserve what was coming to him. But the other games tell a different story. In partners in time, he willingly teamed up with his younger self to try and stop the bros just to kidnap peach, once more. In bowsers inside story, he actually DID help to save the day. But not because it’s for morality. It’s because he had the mindset of “No one can take over this world, except me”. He only went on this journey to try and beat Mario. Dream team however, he was the most evil. Teaming up with Antasma, actually defeating the bros when they had their guard down, setted off with Antasma to steal the dream stone, plot for world domination, kidnapping peach AGAIN, even betraying Antasma in the end, and ended up swallowing the dream stones shards, which corrupted him into a Godlike being of evil.
when I was younger, I thought Antasma was Cackletta reincarnated, because he looks very similar to her
Also because of that stupid bat multiplication attack thing he does
It would’ve been awesome if it was doe
Hes a man isnt he?
@@yukieagle115 yeah
@@yukieagle115 Gender can change through reincarnation.
WHY DOES THAT MAKE SO MUCH SENSE!?!?
About the Zeekeeper: he also saves everyone at the end when they fall off of Bowser's castle. And I'd definitely count Kuzzle in good
I wouldn’t say Princess and Elder Princess Shroob are as evil as, let’s say Fawful. They at least cared for their species and each other, and wanted to do the best for them, even if their tactics are pure evil and horrifying for their victims. But Fawful had no care in the world for anyone but himself, even planning to betray and kill Cackletta. He nearly drained and annihilated Peach for his own use of her voice, was the one to awake the dark star, and even when he was defeated he tried to use the last of his powers to blow up the Weegee bros. His plans involved him taking over Bowser and Peach’s castles and causing everyone to become BEEG bois so he can be unstoppable. He deserves the gold medal of chortles and evilness, and if you don’t agree you may as well just be brainwashed so you can bow to the Lord Fawful.
Ok goddamit I’m so wrong, the shroobs after all tried to destroy an entire planet while Fawful was only conquering one place, and the Shroobs overall could’ve went with the easier way and joined forces and gained peace with the inhabitants.
@@zay2k539 The shroobs would have gone extinct as long as they didn't take action, at least as far as I know. What they did was pure evil yes but it didn't come from pure evil they just had to do what was necissary to survive (and got carried away)
@@Imar13 I get what you're saying, but they were only driven by the greed for destruction, not survival. And even if they were in need for survival, their methods of torture and death would be considered unnecessarily cruel.
The difference is Fawful wanted to rule the world, the Shroob sisters wanted to genocide and kill every and enjoyed it
Will princess shroob doesn't really care about her subjects at all but I have to say but that's the only true shroob that I can name about that doesn't care about each other
Idk if captain goomba should rank ahead of the bros, because at the end of the day he still works for bowser who wants world domination. Mario is contributing to a more noble cause I’d say.
Plus they even know they're the bad guys
Captain Goomba is never disrespectful to his minions
Agreed, Mario and Luigi should be above Captain Goomba.
@@AmazingSpider-Man no one asked for your opinion
L+
Cause you look like a minion
@@liamtherobot9656 mario is not disrespectful either (in fact he’s pretty much the only person in the series that isn’t mean to Luigi in any way) so that isn’t really a point in favour of goomba.
Kirby Characters: Good to Evil
Pure: Kirby
Good: King Dedede
Grey Area: Magolor
Bad: Marx
Evil: Void Termina
And I want Brad to do this
Kirby saved the world, he defeated Marx
Pure Evil: Star Dream.
@@Wolfywolf7 Bandana Dee really wouldn’t do anything evil unless possessed or something.
@@warioland523 tbh i think pure evil would be nightmare
Mario & Luigi Series Characters: Good to Evil
THE GOOD
1) Captain Goomba
2) Mario
3) Luigi
4) Prince Dreambert
5) Prince Peasley
6) Stuffwell
7) Starlow
8) Dr Toadley
9) Toadsworth
10) Eldream
11) Brouqe Monsieur
12) Shockron
13) The Z Keeper
14) Bowser Jr
15) The Massif Bros.
16) Professor E. Gadd
17) Kylie Koopa
18) Princess Peach
19) Queen Bean
20) Princess Lipid
21) Ned Smith
22) Lady Lema
THE GREY AREA
23) Birdo
24) Koople
25) Dr Snoozemore
26) Brouqe Madame
27) Broggy
28) Fritter
29) Mr Thwomp
30) Harhall
31) Brickle
32) Not-So Globin
33) The Star Door
34) Whizderm
35) Bowser
36) Kamek
37) Mrs Thwomp
38) J'jora
BAD TO EVIL
39) Popple
40) Midbus
41) The Monty Moles
42) Private Goomp, Sergeant Guy and Corporal Paraplunk
43) The Best Fitness Friends
44) Cackletta
45) Fawful
46) Antasma
47) The Dark Star
48) The Shroob Princesses
I'm giving fawful the top spot in bad to evil
@@JuJu-bq9uq Okay, how come?
I'm happy to see more mario & luigi content. I kinda wish you used music from the series instead of just royalty free music you can hear in thousands of other videos.
@@Wolfywolf7 boo is the best and always will be :)
Unfortunately, Nintendo wouldn't allow that because the company takes them down for copyright.
@@poweroffriendship2.0 there's a difference between uploading a video containing someone talking over background music and uploading a video containing _just_ the background music.
I always Love the Mario & Luigi Series! & Seeing a Good to Evil On It is a Even Bigger Treat than the Paper Mario Vids! Amazing Job!
Bowser Best Deeds to Worst Deeds:
Best Deeds: Being a Good Dad to Bowser Jr.
Worst Deeds: Kidnapping Peach
Didn't he try to destroy the universe?
@@subifyouhatetiktokandreddit234 No, he tried to control it.
@@Bonnielikescats wrong,Destroy it,it's said in the manuel.
@@Bonnielikescats he also blowed up toad town a thousands times,turned toads to bricks,destroyed peach's castle in paper jam,which could've killed her and the toads but he didn't seem to care.
@@cbfranco3307 The manual for which game?
The Mario & Luigi series could shift over to the Nintendo switch
Well, would you look at that
Great opinions on good to evil! However in my opinion the number one most evil villain is none other than The Dark Star because it’s evil eyes and it’s dark and has the ability to turn everything into darkness.
Me personally it's Fawful since
1. The Dark Star is amoral it doesn't know the difference between good and evil it acts on instinct rather than motive.
2. Fawful was the one who unleashed the Dark Star in the first place
3. Aside from being comedic Fawful lacks any of the redeeming qualities that some of the other villains have for example
Cackletta: she genuinely cared about Fawful even if she wasn't overly protective ( the feeling is NOT mutual, in fact Fawful planned to get rid of her when she was no longer useful to him)
The Shroobs: they genuinely care about each other and all they really wanted was a new home after they lost their old homeworld.
Antasma: was genuinely hurt when Bowser betrayed him albeit Bowser had a good reason to.
The BFF's: they do care about each other even if they are rude to each other they basically act like they are siblings.
Fawful lacks any of those qualities in fact the only reason he isn't pure evil is because he's comedic relief.
@@chadpeterson5698 you forgot about Midbus,who respected Fawful and obeyed his every orders and was royal to him,yet when Midbus died Fawful was like:
"Oh no!
Anyways."
@@cbfranco3307 Fawful didn't even say that he doesn't even bat an eye he was more like "meh, he was just a pawn anyway."
@@chadpeterson5698 very late but hard agree, idk why people act like Fawful caring about Cackletta after the second half of Superstar Saga is canon. Like if that was his motive why did he literally never once mention her, even when ranting about his past she isn't even an afterthought.
He never says stuff about losing her, it's always about how he lost and got screwed over. Just like how after Midbus died or whatever, Fawful never mentions him again either. Yet I've seen a lot of people try to force this headcanon that he cares about one or both of them, maybe to make him redeemable or something idk?
Being scared is being lazy, understandable have a nice day
thank you someone else said it I will not stand for luigi slander in this house
@@lunari64_ At least when you're running away cause you're scared you have the justification of you know being scared but running away because you're lazy is much worse.
Let me get this strait, you guys included Harhall, who has like, five minutes of screen time in Superstar Saga and is not seen again after that, but you left out the Koopalings, who have MAJOR roles in the side stories. I was disappointed.
Id personally put starlow in the grey area, shes a jerk to almost everyone except Mario and peach for no real reason and causes a lot of problems with her hostility and rude behavior
I somewhat agree, especially in bowser's inside story.
@@mystery4561 in every mario and luigi game except superstar saga and partners in time, at least stuffwell is better than that useless piece of astral
I hated how she treated luigi
I would not be surprised if she was working for Fawful
This was pretty alright for the most part. I felt it wasn't as well researched as the Kirby video to be honest. It's missing important characters and there are some things I felt may have been missed.
You forgot:
The Koopalings. They're important characters, as they were highly important to both Minion Quest and Bowser Jr.'s Journey.
The rest of the Elite Captain Quartet. They're also important. They're Captain Goomba's main partners.
The rest of the Shroobs. The Shroobs in general are important to rank due to their importance to Partners in Time's plot. While yeah, most of what they did could be summed up in the Princess Shroob section, it's probably important to note them as well.
Corrections:
Peach's reason for being on the low end of good is a pretty shallow one. I'd argue mostly being kidnapped means she's not likely to have the screen time to do much anyway, so it's less impactful for her overall morality than implied in the video. She still deserves to be on the low end of good though because she still risked the poor Birdo's voice being replaced with explosive vocabulary as a strategy. While for the greater good so that Cackletta couldn't use the Bean Star, she basically used some random bystander as a meat shield for her plan, which could be considered somewhat manipulative in nature, even if for a good cause. That, and using telekinesis to throw Bowser out of her castle doesn't do her morality any favors, considering she never does that when she's kidnapped, and it's never explained why that is. Mario has to save her plenty of times despite her potentially having the power to clearly defend herself in those situations.
Is the Birdo that Peach used the same one that is Popple's Rookie? I don't remember Birdo's voice ever returning to her, so I doubt it's the same Birdo, even if Super Mario Wiki seems to think it is.
Britta should probably be below Brickle. I got the vibe that many of her workers were frightened of her, even if it's fair to ensure they aren't slacking. Brickle's worst deed was a misunderstanding and a waste of time. Plus, if I recall correctly, Britta got herself in danger because when Mario and Luigi uncovered that passageway up the sandflow, she told them to stay put because it was rumored that there would be treasure, and went in by herself with a goal of stashing it for herself in mind. A greedy act that didn't end well.
Nitpicks:
I have trouble trying to gather whether Fawful being evil enough that he'd likely have no problem doing what Antasma did constitutes as enough to put him on the bronze medal of evil instead of Antasma, but ultimately, it could probably go either or. Fawful's clearly more evil minded considering Antasma's genuine team up with Bowser, so in a sense, he should be higher, but Antasma's got a higher body count, so it's probably fair to put him lower on the morality scale since the body count is more proof than just knowing the character and assuming he'd do the same offered the chance. This is a nitpick, take it with a grain of salt.
You're wrong about the shroobs. Yes, they made a show out of conquering the mushroom kingdom, but they went to earth because their home planet was dying. They needed a new home and new sources of energy. Of course they took it in very violent and cruel ways, but I thought the shroob princesses wanted the best for their people. Why do you think there were no other planets mentioned that the shroobs had? Because there weren't any. Likely the shroobs stayed on their planet, minding their own business, until they had no choice but to seek new lands
Video Idea: *RUclips: GOOD to EVIL*
Seriously, I would pay to see a video listing who the most pure and who the most evil big RUclipsrs are.
That would be controversial as hell.
*Good:*
+ T-Series (they make sick music and are the #1 ranked YTer in the world)
+ MrBeast (Always donating to charity, god bless that man)
+ Pyrocynical (Just a cute little lesbian. Also a furry)
+ Rooster Teeth (A massive group of wholesome people who make animations, games and podcasts)
+ JackSepticeye (He's Oirish; that makes him good)
+ GradeAUnderA (He's Bri'ish; that makes him good)
*Neutral:*
+ PewDiePie (Good man, however he did say the n word once and that is unacceptable)
+ Keemstar (Funny gnome man who picks fights with people on Halo and Twitter, but he does run the news which is cool I guess)
+ LeafyIsHere (Literally the chaotic neutral of all of RUclips. Do anything and he roasts you. At least he's funny)
+ DarkSydePhil (Just your everyday man who needs to pay his taxes you guys)
+ SuperMarioLogan (Got CaD'd by Nintendo, invented the absolute satan-spawn that is Jeffy, but he was a nice person)
+ Markiplier (He is cool and funny but he also plans to make people deaf by screaming so much, he can't be good with such a sad and lousy plan)
*Evil:*
+ RyansToyReviews (They ripped off Mario Kart)
+ Jake Paul (Fights people just so he can suck his own cock)
+ Logan Paul (Makes fun of dead people and tried to make Pikachu in real life by tazoring rats or something. Also fought KSI)
+ Onision (Let his two-year-old jump out a window, and his books are shit)
+ RiceGum (Who the fuck eats rice while chewing gum??? But yeah he cyberbullies people)
+ Dream (He's a cheat)
@@rossduncan9516 t-series more good than me. Beast??? He gave a homeless man a home and gave money to almost everyone
@@zacattac43 Shit, my bad. Forgot to mention that these listings within each category weren't in any particular order lol
@@rossduncan9516 oh ok, just saying if it were a list, I’d put him first
But you know it’s my opinion
Thank you!!!!
I have been waiting so long for this and it's here!!! Thank you!!!! Yes!!!! :D
Do Mario RPG Legend of the Seven Stars character good to evil
Good: Mario
Grey area: Bowser
Bad to evil: Smithy and the Smithy gang
I'd argue Geno is the top of the "Good" area since Mario was legitimately about ready to deck a kid in the face.
I was hoping we'd see Yikk on this list but I guess his role in the game was far too small to include him, kinda sad , he was actually one of my favorites
Whos yikk?
@@lolsu5820 Yikk was the owner of the Tower of Yikk who slumbered in the book Bowser opened after he defeated the tower. Yikk tells Bowser about his research on boos then introduces the Boo Ray Machine for Bowser to use so Mario & Luigi can go after the first star sage in Bowser's body, after Bowser uses the Boo Ray the first time Yikk calls the first use of the Boo Ray on a living being a sucess then goes back to sleep in his book. It wasn't a large role in the game but I still enjoyed it
@@mlpfan1993 ah ok i did not remember his name
I would love to see you guys ranking Knack characters from good to evil
9:13 oh, it was Chakron doing it?
I never understood what that random voice in the game was, not even after beating it
Yeah, it didn't translate well, in the Japanese version they make it a lot more obvious
5:44 like... she's a straight up f*cking bully to our favourite green plumber.
Tekken (All characters): Good to Evil
They forgot the most important character.
TOADBERT
By boogity
7 try of asking for Undertale characters: good to evil.
7th try of liking this comment
@@carpetbombjesus thanks, how many time do you think i have to do.
Good: Sans
Neutral: Frisk
Bad: Flowey
@@StarmisYTP Good is more Papyrus.
It's evil not eviel
Luigi isn't lazy, he just gets scared. There's nothing wrong with feeling emotion.
Oh yeah that's right, I forgot emotions don't exist on this channel
If you ask me that makes him more heroic being fearful of the unknown the unpredictability of the outside world on what’s out there the endless possibilities of your demise that would scared anyone yet Luigi still perceive to go on I like to think that the one thing that scares him more than the monsters in the mushroom kingdom is the fear of losing his friends and family and uses that as motivation to power though the obstacles in his way even if some he gets treated poorly by his them he still goes though life and death to save them not really asking anything in return and that’s why he’s my favorite character in the Mario universe
@@Wolfywolf7 -_-?
@@Wolfywolf7 I didn’t really reply to you on my first comment so I was confused either that or that was a joke you post with this XD soAgain I was confused
I always referred to Britta as "the Meg Griffin Block" because that's exactly who she looks like.
Luigi is a coward at times but I believe that should not make his morality worse than mario
Also he's not lazy just very cowardly
@@levi0xl He's both.
@@baconbasket6247 but he's more cowardly then lazy
@@Wolfywolf7 damn bro I kinda agree. But luigi is more evil in mario kart I think everyone can agree
“Mario is higher up then his brother”
Matpat-bullshit
Hitman (World of Assassination trilogy): Good to Evil
video: mario and luigi characters: good to evil
RUclips: paper mario
Ratchet and clank villains evil to most evil
11:25, Au contraire, he must have known that he sent Peach back to the time of the shroob invasion setting up the entire plot of M and L Partners in Time.
Nintendo Heroes: Good to Most Good
1:51 Well that's surprising, alright
11:25 I strange old man in a white coat gave it to me
I think the dark star is the most devilish in the Mario and Luigi were
Who was the one awakened the Dark Star in the first place. I'll give you a hint his name rhymes with awful. And his list of crimes is MUCH bigger.
I know people already said this but Fawful should be lower in fact he should be lower then the Shroobs because he helped Cackletta in addition to trying to conquer if not destroy the Mushroom Kingdom.
I would say the most evil would be the shroobs definitely. Their goals seemed to be destruction and conquest, not relaly carring how many bodies they have to trample over to do so. Heck, the one of the first "dungeons" of the game (vim factory), you see toads having their life force sucked out of them, ensnared by trees, just to power their fleet. IMO, the shroobs had the most "evil" vibes and were fairly close to victory, really only failing due the the Mario bros. and dumb luck.
nope it has to be Fawful since
1. the Shroobs care about each other and they conquered out of necessity since they only wanted a new home after their old one was destroyed
2. Fawful unleashed the Dark Star in the first place and he doesn't care about the collateral damage
3. in fact Fawful aside from being comedic has NO redeeming qualities he doesn't care about anyone and he will stop at nothing until he gets what he wants.
4. the Mario Bros couldn't stop him without Bowser and visa versa. combined with dumb luck as a result Fawful was even closer to victory than the shroobs.
@@chadpeterson5698 1. Not true at all as far as caring for each other go. Elder Princess Shroob and Commander Shroob literally sent them to suicide, just to try and gain ground on the Mario Bros. Yes their old planet was (likely) dying, but there were other planets they could have easily inhabited, and they certainly didn't have to conquer the Mushroom Kingdom to get what they want.
2. Pretty sure Shroobs give 2 craps about collateral damage as well.
3. Shroobs have zero redeeming qualities as well.
4. Dumb Luck never had anything to do with Fawful failing. And we don't know what would have happened if Bowser didn't get involved. Also, the BFF were in the midst of betraying him and likely would have succeeded if not for Bowser Jr. The Shroobs meanwhile were far closer to succeeding...in fact, they had even succeeded for a time.
I will give you that mentality, Fawful and the Shroobs were very similar in goals...as was Cackletta for that matter. But the Shroobs were the closest to actually achieving their goals.
@@IamCanadian3333 there are a couple of problems
1. Princess Shroob and Elder Princess Shroob both care about each other with Elder Princess Shroob saying that she will avenge her sister after the Mario Bros killed her. And Elder Princess Shroob and Princess Shroob alike while they may not care about individuals they do care about their whole race.
2. The collateral damage with Fawful is even bigger given that the Dark Star threatens life itself and Fawful doesn't even care just as long as he can kill the Mario Bros yeah he'll obliterate kingdoms if not the entire world if it means getting rid of a couple of people.
3. Caring about others especially family is a redeeming quality and Princess Shroob and her big sister do care about each other like I said before.
4. The BFF's if they couldn't even beat the Koopalings and Bowser Jr how could they be a real threat to Fawful especially given that Fawful at one point knocked Bowser out with a single blast of his vacuum helmet and Bowser is obviously stronger than the Koopalings and just as strong if not stronger than Bowser Jr. Also yeah Bowser was neccessary in stopping Fawful especially given how Fawful planned things since he planned to incapacitate most of the population by inflating them with blorbs, then using Bowser as a means of getting rid of everyone else by have Bowser eat them. And also there are many things left to sheer dumb luck for example if Bowser didn't encounter Brogue Monseir he wouldn't get the vacuum block and that was a key part in stopping Fawful, if Bowser wasn't blown into the Cavi Cape tunnels he couldn't get to the area where he gets blasted by electricity and as a result the Mario Bros wouldn't have access to the warp pipes that lead out of Bowser's body so they would be stuck inside him as a result they wouldn't even learn about the Star Cures so Fawful would would be free to get the Dark Star without intervention and even if they somehow managed to learn about the Star Cures the Mario Bros would never be able to get all 3 of them since they would be stuck inside Bowser and Bowser would be stuck inside a safe so yeah Fawful's defeat was down to sheer dumb luck.
@@chadpeterson5698 A few problems with your points:
1. As far as the Shroob sisters go, yes they cared for each, but that’s about it. About their whole race, sure, but that’s more because they are conquerors and that’s part of their power. Fawful falls into that camp too tbh, he cares enough about his army he brainwashes them instead of killing them outright…plus he did revive Cackletta, something he did not have to do. He clearly had some care for his master.
2. That’s super speculative and tbh not even true. He clearly values his whole life, and his goal has always been personal power…which is why he absorbed the dark star’s power instead of just letting it lose. He wants to rule the whole world. He was only willing to sacrifice himself after he was already beaten and on the brink of death anyways. That hardly counts.
3. Just like Fawful cares about Cackletta, and to a lesser extent Midbus.
4. A few points. Captain Goomba and his crew which included the Koopalings had defeated Fawful…twice…in the same manner that Bowser Jr. defeated the BFF…the exact same manner actually. So even if you want to use that point, it kind of goes against you. Fawful, an upgraded version lost to Bowser, so that point is also down the drain. In the first game, that was just a surprise attack, and a stab in the back is hardly considered a “I beat you 1v1 fair and square” fight. And that is superseded anyways by my previous point about Captain Goomba. All that “luck” you mentioned, was actually just player progression and a result of Fawful’s own doing or Bowser’s/Mario’s doing. If you want to take that literally, then every single story was “dumb luck.” And that doesn’t actually help your point. What I was referring to with the Shroobs was when Bowser abducted “Princess Peach,” as well later found out that actually put a wrenching the shroob’s plan to take over the future. It was blind dumb luck that Bowser had showed up, it wasn’t due to the Mario Bros. actions or the shroobs actions, it just happened, and it was to the detriment of the shroobs.
@@IamCanadian3333 well technically Fawful doesn't care about Cackletta he only saved her because he still had some use for her similar to why Palpatine saved Anakin Skywalker in Star Wars because Palpatine still saw Vader as useful and planned to replace him when his usefulness was at an end. Fawful takes a similar approach to this except the roles are reversed to a degree, Fawful keeps Cackletta around so she can conquer the Mushroom and Beanbean Kingdoms so when Fawful makes his move to get rid of her he can assume power without much trouble nice and easy. Also no Fawful doesn't care about Midbus either since he doesn't even bat an eye when Midbus dies in fact he brushes it off like it was nothing. Also Fawful like all villains is arrogant and Bowser had help from his minions in the battle against Fawful ( particularly in that attack when Fawful summons lots of energy balls and Bowser has to throw Goombas at him. ) also my dumb luck argument is more legitimate than you give it credit for since what do you think would have happened if Bowser wasn't blown directly into the Cavi Cape tunnels which the moles were digging if that didn't happen then the Mario Bros wouldn't have discovered the pipe yard and as a result they wouldn't have been able to collect all 3 Star Cures even if some of the other events were to come to pass since Bowser and the Mario Bros indirectly would be stuck in a safe in a junkyard, Fawful would have taken the power of the Dark Star and he would have won. All it took for Fawful's plans to go awry was Bowser getting blown to the right place at the right time.
In my opinion Dark Star is the truly worst of the bunch. The only reason it is defeated is that dark star got Cocky after absorbing the other half of his power (stolen by Fawful) after being recently reawakened and still not used to it's mimicked body of bowser, by the legends Dark star was a universe level threat, who I doubt even Princess Rosalina could defeat. Antasma atleast had the argument of being manipulated and turned evil from the wishes of Nightmare stone.
Popple is hilarious lol
Pac-Man: Good to Evil 🟡
Come on 1upbinge make it happen please 🙏
Yea
@Daniele Silvestri Leave it up to 1upBinge to decide on that.
@Daniele Silvestri I feel like if they did they'd do Pac Man World and/or Ghostly Adventures
Let Brad host it
Fawful is most likely the most fanfavorite of all, well hes my favorite villain atleast🤣
3:47 I would not call it laziness. He's just prone to more fear.
do Kingdom hearts original characters good to evil.
good: sora
neutral: Riku
Evil: Master Xehanort
Love these videos
Still waiting for these Good to Evils:
Super Mario Characters: Good to Evil (Mainstream Games)
Donkey Kong Country Characters: Good to Evil
Super Smash Bros. Playable Characters: Good to Evil
Minecraft Story Mode Characters: Good to Evil
Telltale's The Walking Dead Characters: Good to Evil
Telltale's Batman Characters: Good to Evil
Batman Arkham Series Characters: Good to Evil
The Last of Us Characters: Good to Evil
Nintendo Heroes: Good to Most Good
Here’s one FNF characters Good to evil
And mods too I just forgot
Whatever
@@Wolfywolf7 I know, but on their channel (Game Domain) in their community tab they said that they are aware of 1up Binge. So lets just see 1Up Binge's take Super Mario: Good to Evil (Mainstream Games)
Antasma gets the gold medal for me.
Fawful gets the silver medal for me.
That my opinion for the evil side.
@2017a Samuel Virtic same
At least Antasma works well with others.
Fawful only wanted to rule the world, the Shroob princesses tried to genocide and kill everyone while enjoying it
I love how the 3 Purple villains are the most evil
Plz do the Henry stickmin collection characters *good to evil*
Good: Charles Calvin
Grey: Henry stickmin
Bad: Reginald copperbottom and right hand man
Evil: Dimitri
@Alexander Philippe How about we only focus on the ones that are only on screen like Henry, Ellie, Charles, hurbert Galeforce, and even Dave Panpa, Burt Curtis, and sven svenson
@Alexander Philippe how about we focus on their personalities or on their actions yet they also have bios
@Alexander Philippe Let's just focus on what we do know about the characters instead of what we don't know
@Alexander Philippe All least just look up the characters and they are more than what you think
@Alexander Philippe Do you even look on the Henry stickmin Wikipedia fandom
26:01
Princess Peasley
Finally Luigi and his boyfriend can both be princesses together
Yes princess bfs
NiGHTS Into Dreams: Good to Evil 🌙
The Good 😇: NiGHTS
The Grey Area: Nightopians
Bad to Evil 🔥😈: Wizeman the Wicked
I would say the most good goes to either any of the visitors or the owl. While NiGHTS is one of the good guys, they’re a little more antiheroic in comparison.
@@smashster1787 Right good call while Reala and Wizeman the Wicked definitely belong in the bad tier.
You are absolutely right about Bowser Jr. being a good guy
Reason is already mentioned but I wanna add something as well
The whole reason Bowser Jr. helping his dad capture Princess Peach is just to impress Bowser
Or just to help his own father
His point is not evil
He is a good guy
The shroobs were only trying to live. They definitely cared about eachother a lot. The elder loved her sister with all her heart. Even shroobs worth is caring for a baby. War is awful no one is spared. Not even babies. Like the shroob children whose heads Mario crushed and the attempt on baby Mario and Luigi’s lives. But the shroobs did not destroy their planet it was shunned by starlight indicating that it’s star died or said planet was ejected from its orbit. Everything other than the shroobs is correct. The shroobs should be right before cackletta in my opinion.
Where are the Koopalings? They were like, main characters in Bowser Junior's Journey, I think they deserved to be on this list, yet they aren't... And also the other Captains as well, they're all distinct characters...
Also, Peach should have been much lower due to the fact she used a Birdo in order to save her own sorry ass from Fawful and Cackletta taking her voice, and the worst part is Mario and Luigi failed to get it back, and so the poor Birdo lives the rest of her life with that explosive vocabulary that Fawful and Cackletta meant to replace Peach's voice with, so yeah, Peach is not good IMO, and I think Peach should have been a little lower... I also hate Peach for a variety of other reasons as well... Also, Starlow is such a massive asshole and an annoying pest, Starlow should also be much lower on the list as well IMO...
@Daniele Silvestri Yeah, I agree, oof
You should do a Hermitcraft Season 7 Good to Evil
Good: Joehills, Impulse, Iskall
Grey area: Mumbo Jumbo, Bdubs, Grian
Evil: Scar, Doc, ZombieCleo
Good🥹:
1st🥇: Captain Goomba
2nd🥈: Mario
3rd🥉: Luigi
4th: Prince Dreambert
5th: Prince Peasley
6th: Stuffwell
7th: Starlow
8th: Dr. Toadley
9th: Toadsworth
10th: Eldream
11th: Broque Monsieur
12th: Chakron
13th: The Zeekeeper
14th: Bowser Jr.
15th: The Massif Bros.
16th: Prof. E. Gadd
17th: Kylie Koopa
18th: Princess Peach
19th: Queen Bean
20th: Princess Lipid
21st: Bedsmith
22nd: Lady Lima
Grey Area🫤:
23rd: Birdo
24th: Kuzzle
25th: Dr. Snoozemore
26th: Broque Madame
27th: Broggy
28th: Britta
29th: Mr. Thwomp
30th: Harhall
31st: Brickle
32nd: Nutsoglobin
33rd: The Star Door
34th: Wisdurm and Durmite
35th: Bowser
36th: Kamek
37th: Mrs. Thwomp
38th: Jojora
Bad to Evil😈:
39th: Popple
40th: Midbus
41st: Monty Moles
42nd: Private Goomp, Sergeant Guy, and Corporal Paraplunk
43rd: Best Fitness Friends
44th: Cackletta *Bowletta*
45th: Fawful
46th🥉: Antasma
47th🥈: Dark Star
48th🥇: Princess Shroob and Elder Princess Shroob
I have an objection for the shroobs while yes they did a lot of harm to the mushroom kingdom their acts were by pure desperation of finding a new home acording to partners in time. Not that it justifies their actions but they had their reasons.
Nintendo Heroes: Good to Most Good
Standard: Pokémon Trainer
Society Saving: Fox McCloud or Mario
World Saving: Samus, Link or Kirby
I agree with you
Society saving fox and mario? They both litterally saved galaxies.
@@cbfranco3307 and if you count paper mario, mario has saved a multiverse
@@callinater6133 yay
Paper Mario characters good to evil
Good: Tippy
Grey Area: Bowser
Evil: Dimentio
Portal Characters: Good to Evil
🏅 Gold Medal of Good: Caroline
🥈 Silver Medal of Good: Atlas and P-Body
🥉 Bronze Medal of Good: The Cores
Grey Area: Cave Johnson, Defective Turrets
🥉 Bronze Medal of Evil: Turrets
🥈 Silver Medal of Evil: Wheatley
🏅 Gold Medal of Evil: GLaDOS
Glados is more evil. Wheatley is just stupid
Well, In that case
Wait portal has story I just thought it was just a fun game to play with some portals.
GlaDOS shouldn’t be #1.
My list:
Most good: Atlas and P-Body
Silver Medal: Chell
Bronze Medal: Caroline
Grey area:
The Announcer
Wheatley (If you go into the lore you'll realize why Wheatley isn't evil)
Defective Turrets
Evil:
Bronze Medal: Turrets
Silver Medal: Cave Johnson
Gold Medal: GLaDOS
Yeah this was going to happen eventually.
THE GOLD MEDAL OF GOOD SHOULD OF BEEN MARIO AND LUIGI TOGETHER!
No captain goomba seriously risked his life to save his master sure bowser is a bad guy but that doesn’t mean he is that bad
You say paiamaja like that too, awesome o always hear it as paja maja
Mario & Luigi: Paper Jam is canon to the Mario & Luigi series. That crossover is canon to both series. I wasn't talking about generic characters, person who replied to the deleted comment
im not very into mario universe so im asking while being not sure about this: why there is no Wario and Waluigi on this list? I mean they are from antoher franchise or something?
They don't exist in the mario and Luigi series. This list is just based on the Alpha Dream Series, not the whole mario franchise in general.
@@stephendreamteam1139 @The_MLS_Team thats kinda sad
Suggestion: Super Mario enemies Weak To Powerful (Goombas, Koopas, stuff like that )
I disagree on the Shroob princesses being the most evil. Yes, they came to Mushroom Kingdom with a lot of destruction, but they had to do it for the survival of their race. Is it evil for someone to destroy, when it is the only way to survive? And Mario and Luigi didn't tried to reason with them, they committed Genocide.
don't really think they could've, considering peach trapped elder in the cobalt star for who knows how long, I doubt she'd just let it be water under the bridge, and by the time they get to her they've killed her younger sister. So there's a very low chance elder would even try to reason with them
Splatoon: Good to Evil
Breath of the Wild: Good to Evil
Pokémon Sword and Shield: Good to Evil
@@Wolfywolf7 btw I know your joking but meant the human characters.
For Splatoon:
Good: Agent 3
Neutral: Captain Cuttlefish
Evil: DJ Octavio
For BOTW:
Good: Mipha
Neutral: Link
Evil: Calamity Ganon (or Astor if you include AOC)
For Pokémon SwSh:
Good: Leon
Neutral: Piers
Evil: Chairman Rose
@@Wolfywolf7 ehh, grizz isn’t really evil. We don’t know enough about him, he could just be eating golden eggs for survival. He’d be a perfect fit for the bottom of the grey area.
@@Wolfywolf7 the salmonids aren’t exactly innocent, their not sentient and for all we know, their dangerous. We just don’t know much about grizz to put him as bad. But he would go in the bottom of the grey area.
@@Wolfywolf7 we don’t know what he does with the eggs...
Thank God Mario and Luigi is voiced by Kyle like I wanted
But his voice was cracked. Brad should have done it.
Oh OH I GOT IT annoying orange characters + TV show good to evil
There is no show in Ba Sing Se. also, the Earth King has invited you to Lake Laogai
Here’s a bit of a challenge for you guys: Darksiders characters from good to evil!
luigi was shown to be more nicer and noble then luigi
You mention bowser jr's development but not the fact that he doesnt beleave in the concept of good and evil, or that he believes he is the good guy. Smh my head
Did you completely forget about paper Jam?
I dont blame but seriously, it’s important for the koopa troop characters
You should do a Mario 1
Resident Evil Villains: Evil to Most Evil
Least Evil: Jack Krauser
Evil: Nemesis
Most Evil: Albert Wesker
Some people think Luigi should be ranked higher than Mario, but I think they should be ranked both on the same spot. I ,mean they are both very loyal to one another and will always do what's right and save the day
Awesome
Thumbnail
Good:mario & luigi
Netural:bowser
Evil:fawful & antasma
Mario & luigi series good to evil
The good
🥇)captain goomba
🥈)mario
🥉)luigi
4)prince deamert
5)prince pesely
6)stuffwell
7)starlow
8)dr toadley
9)toadsworth
10)eldream
11)broque mousier
12)clackron
13)the zeekeeper
14)bowser jr
15)the massif brothers
16)professor egad
17)kylie koopa
18)prinses peach
19)queen bean
20)prinsess lipid
21)bedsmith
22)lady lima
The grey erea
23)birtho
24)kuzzle
25)dr snoosemore
26)broque madame
27)broggy
28)britta
29)mr thwomp
30)harhall
31)brickle
32)notsoglobin
33)the star door
34)wisdurm
35)bowser
36)kamek
37)mrs thwomp
38)jojora
Bad to evil
39)popple
40)midbus
41)the monty moles
42)private goomp,sergeant guy & corporal parpalok
43)boss fitness friends
44)cackletta
45)fawful
🥉46)antasma
🥈47)the drak star
🥇48)the too shroob prinsesses/the shroobs
Let's not forget that Fawful mobilized and weaponized both Bowser's and Peach's castles against Bowser with zero fucks given about who got in the way.
I think Luigi is better than Mario cause of dream team giant Luigi battles,unlike Bowser,Luigi grew big due to being worried about his bro
I feel like they’re both the same
Fair I guess
There’s no evidence suggesting that mario doesn’t hold the same values towards his Bro.
The Elder Princess Shroob is the only Shroob that speaks perfect english. When Fawful says “I have fury” he truly does mean it, speaking of which, he started out as a bean salesman during the past version of Partners in Time, before Cackletta’s reign of terror. I don’t think Captain Goomba would want to be classified as a hero.
You forgot the giant caterpillar Wiggler who appears in both Bowsers Inside Story and Dream Team. I would probably put him in the upper half of the grey zone, possibly at the top of the Grey zone if Paper Jam was included.
I Love It a Lot
Don't forget that Dark Star takes form of Bowser to make himself more powerful.
Eventually absorbing Fawful and dark power being complete.
And finally fighting Bowser and dying.
Khalon: Request to 1-upBinge;
Super Mario villain deaths gruesome to most gruesome;
Least gruesome; Antasma
Gruesome; Bowser
Most cruel;
Video Game Parents Good to Evil.
Excellent
And that one guy said jr. isn't a hero
I have a question about Dreambert. Since he obviously has the title of prince, and we get no mention of a king or queen, does that mean, he technically rules over the island?
bowser jr is my favorite so i screamed yes
No offense but your voice sounds cracked. Brad should have done this list.