@@daydream10.18well jessica was a main vocalist so it does mean something. Based on this perf alone, jessica hit all her notes right just like how it was recorded. Maknae's high note was underwhelming since she lacks power here compared to the recorded one.
watching this and thinking, do they even remember performing this? they were going back and forth simultaneously performing in japan and korea during this era
The quality of their voices is always terrific, but it's a totally different feel when they're singing to an audience than when they're singing to a microphone. Steve P.
Taeyeon, Sunny, Hyoyeon = The Shortys Seohyun, Yoona, Yuri = The OG Bermuda Triangle of Visuals Jessica, Tiffany, Sooyoung = The overseas, since Jessica and Tiffany are from the USA, and Sooyoung first debuted in Japan.
![FOREVER 1 - GIRLS' GENERATION [Music Bank] | KBS WORLD TV 220819](/img/1.gif)
이걸 이제 푸네......... 내가 얼마나 그렇게 찾았었는데....
윤아야 우흐원 선생님누구무섭해
와 저때 코디 왤케이쁘냐 요즘나오는 청순 걸그룹들 옷보다 훨남....
Came here after watching Tiffany's reaction while listening to this song after a very long time during her special radio DJ stint
Yes Tiffany queen and seo high note is really good, I miss this
이 노래만 들으면 티파니의 수상소감이 생각난다.
“어머니는 제 곁을 일찍 떠나셨지만 대신 8명의 자매를 주셨어요”
이 노래처럼 단짝으로 오래오래 함께하길 소녀시대
It's really hard to watch one SNSD music video without ending up going MV marathon 😩 SMent just give them a comeback dannngit...
🤣😂😅
Dang same
Seohyun invented stable vocals. Perfect-pitched as always
it was flat. jessica ate
@@mlee.a9002 it's not flat, it's just she was given a lower note.
@@mlee.a9002 a jessica stan talking about flat vocals... yikes
@mlee.a9002 not the Jessica set up. 🙄🤨
@@daydream10.18well jessica was a main vocalist so it does mean something.
Based on this perf alone, jessica hit all her notes right just like how it was recorded. Maknae's high note was underwhelming since she lacks power here compared to the recorded one.
노래도 잘부르고 춤도 잘추고 대체 못하는게 모야ㅠㅠ
이거 엔딩에서 뽀뽀 한번 했다고 기사 엄청 뜨고 지상파에서 그래도 되느냐 온갖 난리 치던 꼰머들 있었는데... 기억 새록새록
진짜 추억
이거 핵 명곡임
Miss this era ㅠㅠㅠㅠ yuri why you're really pretty 😂😂
she's Beautiful ♥♥ I love her
Jihaan Farahiyah correction she's beautiful
컴백무대 보려고 중3 때 학원에서 몰래 DMB로 봤었는데 🥺🥺
왕표WP 와 dmb라는 단어도 너무 오랜만이에오
ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
하 친구 생일축하 영상 만들 때 항상 사용하던 띵곡 ㅜㅠㅠㅜㅠㅠ
I need a 2023 version of this
갑자기 떠서 왔는데 너무 이쁘다ㅠ
Forgive me. I still can't help myself but cry the whole time.
Charmagne Dumayago me too haha :')
I just miss those times
I swear bruh i feel sad at alot of OT9 performances. Especially the ones at which you know there wasnt any termoil.
내가 이거 소시의 쿠키폰에 DMB 녹화본 아직도 가지고 있음ㅋㅋㅋ개추억이넹...
I really love this era, they were all so cute and innocent
Meanwhile this song came from a mini-album where the lead song had a sexy concept. LOL
BRING THIS ERA BACK P L E A S E.
no one can do that T_T
Let’s all play Time Machine by SNSD HAHAHA
라이브 오지고ㅠㅠ그립다 소녀시대 영원히 함께하자 ❤️
마지막에 뽀뽀 퍼포먼스 했다고 네이버 메인기사에 실시간 검색차트 씹어먹던 시절,,,
헉 갑자기 떠오름 ㄷㄷㄷ 대박
They are singing live and there is no difference on their recorded and live voices
어린 마음에 우리 언니들 어쩜 우정도 저렇게 돈독할까 하면서 나도 친구들이랑 사이좋게 지내야겠다는 마음을 가지게 해준 교육적이기까지한 띵곡,,,,🤦♀️
사랑 노래만 나오던 가요계에서 우정 노래가 나와 좋았던
쌩라이브실화냐 어우 진짜 예뻐 한명도 빠짐없이 다 예쁘네 사랑스럽다 소시ㅠㅠㅜ
Seohyun technically owns this song
YoonSic at the end though
They all are real sisters no matter what.
쌩목소리로 부르는 라이브 짱 좋당...💓
i like yuri, yoona, seohyun in here
watching this and thinking, do they even remember performing this? they were going back and forth simultaneously performing in japan and korea during this era
forreal 😭😭😭 there's literally no more performances of this song
Seohyun high note is great
어우 사랑해 소시ㅠㅠㅠ❤❤❤
OMG look at them, just a pretty babies. I miss this SNSD:'(
high notes and adlib queen JESSICA JUNG! .. she's so pretty here and also yuri and yoona :)
Yoona is the prettiest
Yoona beautifullll :*
I miss SNSD😭
++😭
Seohyun is so cute and pretty girl
Jessica is so cute 💗 I miss you unnie 😍 I miss snsd forever 9 girls
지금 봐도 이때 무대의상 너무 예쁘다ㅠㅠㅠ
I watched one SNSD video, I fell into a rabbit hole. I miss them so much
Same here. But mine started because of their funny variety clip before getting hooked by their songs or mv.
miss ko na kayo 🤧
I love that they are singing live. It's hard to find idols singing live on music shows these days.
소녀시대 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
The quality of their voices are perfectly blended❤️
The quality of their voices is always terrific, but it's a totally different feel when they're singing to an audience than when they're singing to a microphone.
Steve P.
this era is so precious !
ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 무대만 봐도 추억돋는다
I remember watching this in Music Core. Those were the times when you wait for there comeback ❤️.
My Frieeeeeeenndddd ~~ Seohyun's high note ♥
Yuri is so pretty
Yoona and Yuri is the cutest😘😍
이무대 진짜 넘 사랑스러움 그 자체였다 ㅠㅠ
Seo Hyun is so cuteeeeeeeee
Seohyun looks so pretty here
It's 2024 and still listening to this beautiful song.❤️🎶
i love this stage so much..i can't help myself crying whenever i'm watching this..reminising their good old times as ot9😭😭
천사같애ㅜㅜㅜㅜ
You don't need "MR removed" for check they was sing in live or not, you can hear that!
Yoona's smile is so beautiful and pure...
Taeyeon, Sunny, Hyoyeon = The Shortys
Seohyun, Yoona, Yuri = The OG Bermuda Triangle of Visuals
Jessica, Tiffany, Sooyoung = The overseas, since Jessica and Tiffany are from the USA, and Sooyoung first debuted in Japan.
Sudden SNSD marathon, I rmb first watching this in 2014
Really miss that time where they just enjoy to perform on the stage and be happy ;)
파니 금발 졸귀야ㅜㅜ
Hyoyeon looks so cute, pretty, and sweert in here cause her hairstyle
I really loved this song !!! FriendShip forever, SNSD !!!!!!!!!
3:15 sooyoung and taeyeon ❤
#BringBackSicaPlease they are happier when they are complete
Tiffany,jssica,yoona so cute
yuri is so pretty here i LOVE yuri in berets !!
The only song that Taeyeon just have one line 😂😂😂😂
seohyun unnie is so pretty
Yoonyul so cute
Seohyun Beautiful Queen 😍 😍 TURKEY ❤️ Turkish Sone 😍 TURKEY ❤️ ❤️ Legend Girls 9❤️❤️
I don't cry often but for some reason, whenever I'm watching old snsd videos, I just bawl my eyes out 😭😭
Miss u Jess :'(
Taeyeon dying from the cuteness but trying her best hahaha i can see it
now i've realise, taeyeon only sing one line and one adlib in this song 😂
and she is mostly on the side too 😂
She's probably quite glad as well, she hates cute concepts
@@zapdos6244 yeayy, but still love this song 😍
she sings three adlibs but the camera guy never went to her.
@@null6955 I think she didn't bother singing it coz it's too cute
세젤예 융프로디테 ❤❤
2021 nangis bombay ngeliat ini 😭😭
Miss You my Queen NGG SNSD Girls'Generation OT9 👑
Sabar. Tunggu 2027, 20tahu anniv rilis lagu. Kayak S.E.S 😂
@@arifbudianto3855 😁😁😂
@@arifbudianto3855 berharap ajah SUJU ajah bisa berarti SOSHI juga bisa
Yuriiii
this is my whole life way back then
Talk about sica’s vocals in 2:04
윤아 유리 뭐야,,,,대박이다..,
Taeyeon is the cutest!! So pureeee
Tiffany: saranghae.. ek
fanny eonnie so pretty 💞
Ang sarap talaga pakinggan ng kanta na to... nakakarelax....
Yung tipong kahit hindi muh masyadong naiintindihan ung salita pero ang sarap parin pakinggan...😊😊
This song is so cute!!!!!!!!!!❤
03:14 SooTae💓🥰
Wiat is that seohyun baby hit that high note ? What a rare view
9/9/2018😍💋
I just noticed that now Tiffany is here like a doll she is very beautiful and so cute
This performance will always be famous (and iconic) 💖
Tiffany : My heart missed my members~
2021 I still always watching this live stage video. Do u feel the same?
이때 진짜 소녀시대 레전드였는데 ㅎㅎㅎ
SooTae just what did you do? :D :D
Jessica and Seohyun leaders of this song
At 0:29 Triplets
You mean 2 of the tallest members? Yoona is taller than both Yul and Seo (not trying to seem rude).
+Jasdeep Atwal yeah but I was talking about the group of the tallest member
Oh okay!
They do it all the time with Sunny too. Always wonder why theu did that... why buried the short members between two tall members?
seriously looool Taeyeon was next to all 4 tallest members (SeoYooYulSoo)
is it real? Taeyeon and Sooyoung's kiss? Cuteeee~
Tiffany I miss you
可愛すぎて涙が出そうになった❣️やっぱりソシはキラキラしている❣️✨
Yuri is so beautiful here