🚀 Interested in getting an in-depth look at the Tesla Cybertruck's Electronics Architecture? Our detailed reports cover everything you need to know! Reach out to us at 📧 sales@leandesign.com for more information or visit our websites 🌐 leandesign.com and 3isinc.com to explore our offerings.
you will never set a 48v standard with a 100,000 dollar vehicle it would need to be on something affordable like a honda crv or toyota rav4 or corolla/civic type vehicle.
@@billybobbob3003 Well, it won't by itself but gotta start somewhere, and it makes sense to start from a lower volume product while ramping up the design and finding & fixing any issues that may arise. Just like how Tesla started their production initially with Model S/X then 3/Y as they've grown.
When was the last time an OEM gave a nod to a benchmarking company. Tesla and Munro guys rock!! Thanks Dale. We engineers watching these videos found one more interesting guest!!
I really enjoyed Dale, dude has the perfect personality for the explanation when doing the deep dive on the nitty-gritty of the technicals. Would like to see more of Dale in the future good job, Dale.
Finally someone a little more knowledgable in electronics, that partnership with 3is and Intrepid already pays off. But some of those 48V mild-hybrids have quite a higher number of 48V actuators: for stabilization control at the stabilizer actuators (Audi Q7, Porsche Panamera), small oil pumps and water pumps (Mercedes), or the actuator on a compressor shaft (Audi SQ7, a non hybrid, yet with a 48V sub-net). In general, Audi Q7 4M was the car that introduced a number of 48V components already in 2015 and on. The list of 48V components in Cybertruck is: 2x radiator fans (BLDC), 1x HVAC blower (BLDC), power steering actuators (front 2x, rear: 1x), oil pumps at the drive units (1 oil pump per traction motor), 4x window regulator motors (BLDC) (Brose), 1x wiper motor, 1x accessory power feed to the frunk (400W), 1x accessory power feed to the roof (400W), 3x domain controller ECUs (Left Front Controller, Right Front Controller, Rear Body Controller), 1x power conversion system (PCS 2), 1x 48-volt lithium-ion battery. I am not sure about the headlights and tail lights, whether they are supplied 48V or 12V/16V. To mention a few components that draw notable power but that Tesla kept at 12/16V (could have been converted to 48V, but were not): air compressor for suspension, (that is still 12/16V for sure, CareSoft already analyzed that) Autopilot ECU, MCU, Hydraulic Control Unit, Trailer Control Module.
In a video with the tesla engineers, they said that the AC and other HV accessories had to be built to work on 400V AND 800V because the battery can be connected 400V 0r 800V depending on the capabilities of the DC fast charger it is connected to. Can't stop the HVAC just because it's an 800V system but while charging on a Tesla 400VDC charger, the charge port only sees 400V.
Excellent work by Sandi Munro's team. Tesla is sweeping all the legacy automakers on everything... On everything... Batteries, Manufacturing of the body, Power & Control of vehicle's hardware-components, Communication Network... All for the sake of making the vehicle more efficient and saving cost... BUT in an INTELLIGENT WAY.
Tom appears in many of our videos, particularly those related to batteries. On the other hand, Dale works for 3iS and is unlikely to feature in future videos.
Are you clueless? It's not all American, do you know where China is for many parts? WOW...no wonder Trump got elected, we are doomed. This goof is a useless dumb product. A Mush continues to prove he's another stable genius...oy vey.
This was a great video. And so is the 48v system. But, ha, there was/is so much more they could have talked about. Many videos worth, I guess! The reason, I've understood, for separating the controllers is to avoid a single fault failure and wiring cries-crossing the body frame. (Guess I'd have to buy the report to be sure. 🙂). Thank you, Munro Associates. We need a Part 2 & 3 & more.
You can hear a little frustration - the same tone as Sandy really - with how Detroit refused to take bigger steps. For these guys it was 42V. For Sandy it was castings. I cannot help but think back to the rise of Japanese cars in the Oil Crisis. Detroit COULD have responded better - these guys (or guys like them) would have responded better but the management refused to let them swing the bat and the rest is history. GM, Ford and Stellantis have tremendous design and manufacturing prowess - they lack leadership with a fire in the belly to do great things. Elon's biggest advantage is resolve. He will make the decisions and move on while they work their Powerpoint decks over months of meetings. And Elon will say to his Engineers - here's the bat - swing the damn thing. Go work up a few options and price them out. And it will be a cross-functional team with no turf wars and no politics. Just like the beginning of those companies - before the bloat.
Yes. Blue is the primary standard color, though it's not an enforced standard or anything. There are alternative colors too, for forklifts more so, if there are 2 48v forklifts with different battery sizes you would ideally use different connectors so they only go into the charger that's setup for that size. Or you install a communication module on the battery and have compatible chargers to read the battery information and charge profile. Since they're all keyed, blue (48) won't go into red (24v) or grey (36v).
I suspect a significant reason high voltages weren't used in the past is that it's difficult to make filament lamps at higher voltages that resist the vibration in a car environment
Could be! Also the circular effect of the lighting contractor didn't want to sink development money if the OEM didn't commit to 48V, and neither did the electric motor contractors, or the wiring loom contractors, and all that inertia stopped development across the board for half a century. But then real technological developments weren't Detriot's forte, and the beginnings of emissions, fuel economy, and safety requirements caught them with their pants down.
@@markplott4820 Now, Now, Mark, you're entering into the ignorance zone, like Sandy often does when it comes to electricity. While a "grain of wheat" filament bulb works at 1/2 Volt, all those "filament" bulbs in your house are 120V in the USA, and 220-240 V elsewhere.
Oh, so Cybertruck is taking more first steps towards the Unboxed process than just Etherloop - Doors already got separate controllers, which is pretty much required for unboxed as each part needs to be standalone so that you can test them individually in a testing station. And when integrating into the main body you have to just slap one connector in and be done with it.
Most OEMs use a variety of controllers scattered around the vehicle. Tesla moving almost everything to two main boards was one of the "features" that Munro loudly touted in past videos. Of course that design led to high repair costs when anything went poof.
@@Miata822 I am aware but what unboxed requires in something completely different compared to traditional controllers+CAN. Every piece needs to be able to be tested separately by plugging the car into simulated & populated ether-loop, so it needs to have full capabilities as standalone without any other controllers around. Which is why every piece needs a computer that serves as "local controller", doors included.
I kept thinking why do they look familiar. Then I realized all their head and hand movements, and sitting low behind the table reminded me of a Muppets episode. lol. Pretty cool that "Hi Sandy" was on that circuit board.
"why dis-integrate" ? because they run one etherloop connection to the door. and then everything in the door radiates out from that controller ... it saves copper going from each component to the body controller.
Plus you shorten the control loop for things in the door that must cooperate. For example, dropping the window an inch when unlocking and opening the door, all handled in the local door controller without adding traffic to the vehicle controller etherloop.
I think it also simplifies the number of cables that go to the door, which bend everytime one opens and closes the door. They can have more stress relief on smaller count.
I bet the reason for the door controllers is that they're on etherloop and integrate DACs and audio amplifiers for the speakers. I might be wrong, but I hope it's that futuristic!
"It ain't Rocket Science!" Oh... Wait.... Maybe it IS! . Next we'll have the same old Muppets complaining about misuse of personnel between companies.... Except this time "Tesla" was *BENEFITTING* from "SpaceX expertise! (Their logic should be "imaginative "?)
@@rogerstarkey5390 nonsense, they didnt invent those electronics they just used it. the solar panels on satellites are super way advanced and efficient but more expensive that what use on the ground for example.
@@carholic-sz3qv re: "bullshit and then there is still 12v everywhere?" exactly this is a bunch of BS, it's a bunch of "fantasizing" and EGO STROKING (every EE knows this).
48v is going to be insanely important with campers/RV'ers soon with most solar systems running on it. Will be nice to see what kind of Tesla components/lights/USB/latches/motors use 48v as their input in the future that can be ordered and fit to an RV (or offgrid solar solution)
It makes sense to command steering over CAN bus. CAN bus has inherent priority arbitration where messages to lower numbered device addresses automatically defer lower priority messages to higher numbered addresses by over-writing their 1 bits in the message header with 0 bits. CAN bus is also isochronous, that is messages always take a deterministic amount of time to deliver. Ethernet does not guarantee such characteristics, both of which are critically important to communicating a driver’s command input to be executed by the steering gear motor. Priority and timelines are more important to steering than the bus bit rate. The Cybertruck steering rack may be manufactured by ZF, and CAN may be what ZF is more comfortable working with regardless of other factors.
Ethernet is a physical spec that says nothing about the message protocol that's run over it. You can easily run CAN over Ethernet (instead of IP over Ethernet) and get the full benefits you describe. What's more likely the reason is electrical isolation. They wanted the redundant system completely isolated, and in effect, they could use anything they wanted there, no matter what the rest of the car uses.
@@HenryLoenwind Thank you for the reply. That is not entirely true. CAN may be encapsulated in Ethernet frames at layer 2, but the Ethernet physical layer in a bus topology* does not support inherent priority arbitration, so that is lost. Ethernet supports priority after a fashion, but it is supported in the message header, not physically at the bit level. *Switched Ethernet is a way to prevent contention.
@@wtmayhew arbitration what you said is totally true. On the deterministic part, Ethernet can be deterministic and is how Tesla designed their protocol. Nothing on the ether loop is routed dynamically, according to Tesla it's all statically time sliced so everything is fixed in place (I should say fixed in time?) and synchronized
What on earth are those two humungous chips on the 'Hi Sandy' circuit board (14:44) doing? It just controls one three phase motor and a position sensor - seems like an excessive number of IO pins for such a relatively simple task?
There's 2 because of redundancy, you can see the pcb has two identical circuits on each half of it. Why so big, no idea really, they may want more pins for extra sensors and redundancy but it's still looking like way too much. Maybe there were no smaller chips that fit their reliability requirements.
With 45 legs each side it's probably a custom ic maybe with built-in redundancy. Also they're measuring a lot, to give accurate feedback to the steering wheel.
Quite unusual to have a chip with that many pins in a SOIC, usually you'd go to a BGA. It certainly looks like around 200 pins per chip. Recall that there are two of this complete assembly for redundancy (plus one for the rear). But it does look like there are two three-phase drivers for per-motor driver and logic redundancy. Assuming these are directly controlled bridges, that would be four control lines per phase for a total of twelve. There does not seem to be sufficient transistor packages for anything more. But it occurs that they might have cross-over redundancy were either logic chip can drive the motor through either bridge set (even maybe on a per-phase basis). This would require 24 control lines on each logic chip. Then they might have each chip monitor the outputs of the other bringing the IO count to 32. Still seems way short of the number of pins on the chips.
Sandy: “This is wire in a Tesla. It’s the most amazing wire I have ever seen in my career. It is capable of passing current, which is absolutely amazing and shows why you should pump up my Tesla stock.”
Shilling is their prime objective. They think Tesla has done what no other has done before, too bad, Tesla copies all others that have done so much more, for so much longer. It's sad to have such a fake, phony, fraud as your hero. Wake up.
The few things that run on 800 V except the main motors, also must run on 400 V, since during charging, they "just" split the battery in two and get half the voltage. That way they can use current Superchargers. So they can not use the power electronics for a "simple" 800 V or 400 V system. All of that stuff has to be state of the art Tesla or made in close cooperation with Tesla.
How does the copper weight savings compare to the added weight needed to convert down to 16/12V? An entire extra module for the trailer seems like a bad trade off
@@danharold3087because Sandy worships Tesla and shows little respect for the competition! That is the issue I have with this channel! Support the entire ev movement if you want total recognition!
Wondering how much of the 48V has been redesigned at what level(hardware, firmware?). It is a common practice to use a low voltage motor driven at higher voltage(3d printer steppers being one example), just by controlling the pulse width to ensure not overdriving the current through the coil. Unless a true 48V system is needed(such as fine control down to low speeds, with sustained high output and torque at full voltage), the design change is not really doing much other than adding an additional stepup converter and efficiency loss and probably reduced MTBF, at a marginally improved performance(seems to be consistent with the Dale's remarks towards the end). Just some 💭. Excellent technical discussion as always.❤👍
This just scratches the surface. I would like to see deeper dive. If you can’t analyze the protocol at least peel open the physical layer. What does Ethernet traffic look like on an analyzer under different load conditions? What are the pin outs? What do all the modules do?
Very good presentation... Would like to see comment on the motor for that huge windscreen wiper! Is it 48V and is it a special large hi-torque motor or just a standard wiper motor. Thanks, Frank
Why not use BLDC-motors for the window lift? How about the audio system? Does that run on 48 volts? Most audio amplifiers running on 12 volts contain a step ut DC-DC converter. With a 48 volt supply you can basically skip the step up converter and run the output amplifiers directly from the 48 volt supply.
This is all The rite stuff Well done Tesla and Munro. I really love how open Tesla has been with its technology for anyone. Bottom line is truly bettering the world. Now if we could just stop all the bank fraud and get people to stop stealing But anyway very informative video 48v is smart
13:20, 48 or 12V motor with a given power will have the same amount of copper inside. It is just the wiring of that motor that will benefit from having less copper. A 48V motor need 4x more turns per tooth of stator or rotor of 4 time smaller wire...
QUIET WINDOW WINDER Reports of the Cybertruck window mechanism being very quite is presumably down to the motor being 48v and I guess the extra power allows a lower winder gear ratio so fewer motor turns needed?
@@ChuckvdL True, but it does mean more power if you do keep cables and current the same. And, as said, it could explain observations that the CT winder is very quiet.
Question? What is the dashboard running on 48 volts or 12 volts? Could that window motor use 12 volts. On that board I'm guessing IGBTs What size gauging wire's are they using. Side experiment has anybody ever recorded the CYBER TRUCK being hit by lightning? TESLA making in house Electronics as far as boards, capacitors, transistors or Igbt's? What was the thickness of that board on that steering motor? Are all these boards coated on the surface? Sandy said we should've been on 48 volts, since the 60's. -Why didn't the BIG 3 convert, SANDY might know. Reason for the separate modules on each side, could be for safety or a built in protection. Could be 12 volt is cheaper, wonder if that plays a role?
Q1: Could that window motor use 12 volts(?). A1: yes. re: "Sandy said we should've been on 48 volts, since the 60's." well for better or worse Sandy says all kinds of stuff, but what must be understood is that what he says is SEPARATE from whether or not it's even true. Q2: Could be 12 volt is cheaper, wonder if that plays a role? A2: you bet your a$$ it does, what the pictures of parking lots we've been seeing in both Florida and Arizona filled with undelivered Cybertrucks reflects is all the CANCELLATIONS of people who didn't sign up to spend $100 Grand on a vehicle (with questionable looks). no, they put down their $100 Dollar deposit on the promise of a sub $50,000 Dollar vehicle (with questionable looks) therein what the DOUBLING of the MSRP from $50K to $100K represents is a classic "scam" known as a BAIT AND SWITCH (everybody knows this).
The reason 12 volt stuck around so long is the inertia of the supply chains, one high level Change like moving to 48v disrupts everything, but because Tesla is highly integrated they can do it.
Power loss is proportional to the square of the current flow. If you double the volts, you half the current and reduce the power lost in the wiring to a fourth....
Exactly. That’s one magic relationship. It’s especially important for the high loads like steering. Was pointed out that the A/C is too high a load even for 48v. Lower losses means less fire risk - something hybrids & ICE are prone to.
Teslas switch from lead acid LV battery of nominally around 14.6 volts when charging to the lithium ion battery which is around 15.6 volts when charging also gives a little advantage. It's a bit higher but still being within the tolerable range for 12 volt components.
Amazing. QUESTION: Is there an integrated brake controller for the trailer? I had to buy a model X cable for my Model Y from Tesla and a third party brake controller to velcro to my dashboard in order to run the brakes on my camper.
@@danharold3087 Yes I lean toward understanding it as you did but it was unclear if it's just for the lights or also does brakes. Model Y only does the lights and the brake pins were inactive without that workaround.
why not 24v whiere their is a ton of supply already from military and commercial equipment. I suspect the answer is because then I couldn’t sell you shiny new 48v stuff
depends on if they do system engineering to stay in silos as its easy to talk yourself into 12V only in a silo as my electronics are cheaper with 12V total
I have a GEM car 72 v and want to bring it into the modern era, with solar and 2 battery systems one that can be charging while the other is running.. I have 6 12 c sopar pannels to cover the back bed of the pick up wrap and wonder the best way to incorperate this system with modern parts. any suggestions?
Sorry but going to a higher voltage there is little change in copper, section but a clear increase in insulation and slight gain on efficiency. That is where the real gain comes from. On a motor, Amp*turns shall remain similar given a magnetic field to be generated. Less amps implies more turns in the winding, simple that. Cheers !!!!! Hi Sandy!
🚀 Interested in getting an in-depth look at the Tesla Cybertruck's Electronics Architecture? Our detailed reports cover everything you need to know! Reach out to us at 📧 sales@leandesign.com for more information or visit our websites 🌐 leandesign.com and 3isinc.com to explore our offerings.
you will never set a 48v standard with a 100,000 dollar vehicle it would need to be on something affordable like a honda crv or toyota rav4 or corolla/civic type vehicle.
14:49 had me laughing. Thanks for that. 🙂👍
@@billybobbob3003 Well, it won't by itself but gotta start somewhere, and it makes sense to start from a lower volume product while ramping up the design and finding & fixing any issues that may arise. Just like how Tesla started their production initially with Model S/X then 3/Y as they've grown.
Most iconic car ever made!
@@matthiasgrunwald895 yep more iconic than 1969 camaro ya right lol.
lol, to write “hi sandy” on circuit board is just nuts :)
😅
Same on at least one casting
Not only that but it’s written on every board in every cybertruck. Because how could they know which truck is going to Sandy. The commitment 😂
@@ColeBlack2
It's screen printing, of course it's on every board.
Some circuit board designers have a sense of humor. 😄
More of this type of content please! Excellent discussion.
We've got more of these coming soon! Thanks for watching!
Indeed!
@@MunroLive How about compact TRUCKS the Ford Ranger or a Chevy Colorado vs Toyota Tacoma?
That would be on the History channel.
Please find someone which knows I comes from Intensity of the current, amps (amperes) is only the unit of measure.
When was the last time an OEM gave a nod to a benchmarking company. Tesla and Munro guys rock!! Thanks Dale. We engineers watching these videos found one more interesting guest!!
This is my favorite type of Munro Live content. Thanks guys.
Love the little “Hi Sandy” Easter egg
I really enjoyed Dale, dude has the perfect personality for the explanation when doing the deep dive on the nitty-gritty of the technicals. Would like to see more of Dale in the future good job, Dale.
FYI, the Air Pump is a powered by a 48v brushed motor. Love this content, I just took delivery of a beast and I’m learning all about it!
Finally someone a little more knowledgable in electronics, that partnership with 3is and Intrepid already pays off. But some of those 48V mild-hybrids have quite a higher number of 48V actuators: for stabilization control at the stabilizer actuators (Audi Q7, Porsche Panamera), small oil pumps and water pumps (Mercedes), or the actuator on a compressor shaft (Audi SQ7, a non hybrid, yet with a 48V sub-net). In general, Audi Q7 4M was the car that introduced a number of 48V components already in 2015 and on.
The list of 48V components in Cybertruck is:
2x radiator fans (BLDC),
1x HVAC blower (BLDC),
power steering actuators (front 2x, rear: 1x),
oil pumps at the drive units (1 oil pump per traction motor),
4x window regulator motors (BLDC) (Brose),
1x wiper motor,
1x accessory power feed to the frunk (400W),
1x accessory power feed to the roof (400W),
3x domain controller ECUs (Left Front Controller, Right Front Controller, Rear Body Controller),
1x power conversion system (PCS 2),
1x 48-volt lithium-ion battery.
I am not sure about the headlights and tail lights, whether they are supplied 48V or 12V/16V.
To mention a few components that draw notable power but that Tesla kept at 12/16V (could have been converted to 48V, but were not):
air compressor for suspension, (that is still 12/16V for sure, CareSoft already analyzed that)
Autopilot ECU,
MCU,
Hydraulic Control Unit,
Trailer Control Module.
This was great. As a technician, I am excited for the future. It is really great to have companies working on transparency for us!
🤗THANKS TOM,DALE AND MUNRO FOR THE UPDATES🧐🔋🔋🔋
Excellent presentation. Thank you Tom and Dale. Agree more Tom and Dale.
Our pleasure!
In a video with the tesla engineers, they said that the AC and other HV accessories had to be built to work on 400V AND 800V because the battery can be connected 400V 0r 800V depending on the capabilities of the DC fast charger it is connected to. Can't stop the HVAC just because it's an 800V system but while charging on a Tesla 400VDC charger, the charge port only sees 400V.
Awesome and informative.
Glad you liked it!
This is very valuable content. A 20m video talking about the window drive motor would be great.
I agree, being in service I would love to learn the “why”
Excellent work by Sandi Munro's team.
Tesla is sweeping all the legacy automakers on everything... On everything... Batteries, Manufacturing of the body, Power & Control of vehicle's hardware-components, Communication Network... All for the sake of making the vehicle more efficient and saving cost... BUT in an INTELLIGENT WAY.
More Tom and Dale please!
Tom appears in many of our videos, particularly those related to batteries. On the other hand, Dale works for 3iS and is unlikely to feature in future videos.
This is so good. This is all American. This is putting America back to work, baby. Let’s go.
Do you know where lots of parts come from for Tesla? Another one that is easily fooled
How is that. The truck is one huge failure...
Are you clueless? It's not all American, do you know where China is for many parts? WOW...no wonder Trump got elected, we are doomed. This goof is a useless dumb product. A Mush continues to prove he's another stable genius...oy vey.
I want that hour of talking about the window lift motor, Dale!
These gents rule! gracias
This was a great video. And so is the 48v system. But, ha, there was/is so much more they could have talked about. Many videos worth, I guess! The reason, I've understood, for separating the controllers is to avoid a single fault failure and wiring cries-crossing the body frame. (Guess I'd have to buy the report to be sure. 🙂). Thank you, Munro Associates. We need a Part 2 & 3 & more.
When two old geezers pour out some wiring and boards you know it’s going to be good 😊!
You can hear a little frustration - the same tone as Sandy really - with how Detroit refused to take bigger steps. For these guys it was 42V. For Sandy it was castings. I cannot help but think back to the rise of Japanese cars in the Oil Crisis. Detroit COULD have responded better - these guys (or guys like them) would have responded better but the management refused to let them swing the bat and the rest is history. GM, Ford and Stellantis have tremendous design and manufacturing prowess - they lack leadership with a fire in the belly to do great things. Elon's biggest advantage is resolve. He will make the decisions and move on while they work their Powerpoint decks over months of meetings. And Elon will say to his Engineers - here's the bat - swing the damn thing. Go work up a few options and price them out. And it will be a cross-functional team with no turf wars and no politics. Just like the beginning of those companies - before the bloat.
Hi Sandy
It’s an incredible nod to Sandy.
Great episode please make a follow up episode. Deeper dive great interest in all this rocket science truck.
For a deeper dive, you can purchase one of our reports! leandesign.com/reports/
Audio is a bit low but fantastic content as always
Look like the BABY BLUE color is a standard for 48V not only for Tesla but also for Anderson connector like the SB serie for instance.
Yes. Blue is the primary standard color, though it's not an enforced standard or anything. There are alternative colors too, for forklifts more so, if there are 2 48v forklifts with different battery sizes you would ideally use different connectors so they only go into the charger that's setup for that size. Or you install a communication module on the battery and have compatible chargers to read the battery information and charge profile.
Since they're all keyed, blue (48) won't go into red (24v) or grey (36v).
I suspect a significant reason high voltages weren't used in the past is that it's difficult to make filament lamps at higher voltages that resist the vibration in a car environment
Could be! Also the circular effect of the lighting contractor didn't want to sink development money if the OEM didn't commit to 48V, and neither did the electric motor contractors, or the wiring loom contractors, and all that inertia stopped development across the board for half a century. But then real technological developments weren't Detriot's forte, and the beginnings of emissions, fuel economy, and safety requirements caught them with their pants down.
Filament lamps only need to be 1.5v nominal voltage.
Cathodes for lighting can do 12v.
projector lamps need 48v.
and LED don't even need 3v.
@@markplott4820 Now, Now, Mark, you're entering into the ignorance zone, like Sandy often does when it comes to electricity. While a "grain of wheat" filament bulb works at 1/2 Volt, all those "filament" bulbs in your house are 120V in the USA, and 220-240 V elsewhere.
@@shazam6274and don't last durang an earthquake if the power is on
Your correct. LEDs with constant current drivers, easy peasy.
I really like the info given in this video. More please!
Thanks for the introduction! And I really wish for a video about that interesting pulse charging method for 48V battery🤩
"it's rocket science" Glad to own some of that myself.
Oh, so Cybertruck is taking more first steps towards the Unboxed process than just Etherloop - Doors already got separate controllers, which is pretty much required for unboxed as each part needs to be standalone so that you can test them individually in a testing station. And when integrating into the main body you have to just slap one connector in and be done with it.
Most OEMs use a variety of controllers scattered around the vehicle. Tesla moving almost everything to two main boards was one of the "features" that Munro loudly touted in past videos. Of course that design led to high repair costs when anything went poof.
@@Miata822 I am aware but what unboxed requires in something completely different compared to traditional controllers+CAN. Every piece needs to be able to be tested separately by plugging the car into simulated & populated ether-loop, so it needs to have full capabilities as standalone without any other controllers around. Which is why every piece needs a computer that serves as "local controller", doors included.
I kept thinking why do they look familiar. Then I realized all their head and hand movements, and sitting low behind the table reminded me of a Muppets episode. lol. Pretty cool that "Hi Sandy" was on that circuit board.
Would love you to do a deeper dive video on the PCS2!
👀
Hahaha, that's high level praise hidden on that PCBA... 14:33
Now I want to know about the Cybertruck door modules :)
Yes please. Have him talk 1/2 an hour about that motor component. Seriously
More on power electronics please. There are some geeks that love to learn more about this stuff.
Very interesting. Always tune into Munro for anything Tesla.
“hi, Sandy!”
Lol!!
Super, hyper interesting video. Really well presented.
The wealth of knowledge of both of you is impressive.
Thank you.
You know you've made it when a board says Hi Sandy
"why dis-integrate" ? because they run one etherloop connection to the door. and then everything in the door radiates out from that controller ... it saves copper going from each component to the body controller.
That was my first thought as well.
It's also easier for troubleshooting. Since everything nearby connects to the same board.
Plus you shorten the control loop for things in the door that must cooperate. For example, dropping the window an inch when unlocking and opening the door, all handled in the local door controller without adding traffic to the vehicle controller etherloop.
I think it also simplifies the number of cables that go to the door, which bend everytime one opens and closes the door. They can have more stress relief on smaller count.
Way faster, easier production there too.
"Hi Sandy" hahaha that's amazing
48V seems like a strategic goal to achieve 100% electrification of transportation
I bet the reason for the door controllers is that they're on etherloop and integrate DACs and audio amplifiers for the speakers. I might be wrong, but I hope it's that futuristic!
Just door functions, audio is handled in the main controllers.
After this detailed explanation by Dale it’s very clear as to why the Cybertruck took 6-7 years to develop. State of the art electronics!
"It ain't Rocket Science!"
Oh... Wait.... Maybe it IS!
.
Next we'll have the same old Muppets complaining about misuse of personnel between companies.... Except this time "Tesla" was *BENEFITTING* from "SpaceX expertise!
(Their logic should be "imaginative "?)
bullshit and then there is still 12v everywhere?
@@rogerstarkey5390 nonsense, they didnt invent those electronics they just used it. the solar panels on satellites are super way advanced and efficient but more expensive that what use on the ground for example.
@@carholic-sz3qv re: "bullshit and then there is still 12v everywhere?" exactly this is a bunch of BS, it's a bunch of "fantasizing" and EGO STROKING (every EE knows this).
@rogerstarkey5390
Same old Muppets saying. Elon not all that smart. He didn't do everything.
Awesome video! Please make another episode.
Stay tuned 👀
48v is going to be insanely important with campers/RV'ers soon with most solar systems running on it. Will be nice to see what kind of Tesla components/lights/USB/latches/motors use 48v as their input in the future that can be ordered and fit to an RV (or offgrid solar solution)
I really like that battery disconnect. That could industry wide as useful as it is.
the industry already has such things, bmw started using 16v smart lithium batteries way before anyone else
I laughed so hard when I saw Sandy’s name on the motor control board ! I guess Sandy is famous now congratulations 🎊🎉🎈🍾 Sandy
Good work men, I'll use the cutoff, when welding parts on the CT. Jim
Very interesting great job, can’t wait to find out why the heck they moved the dang modules in the door
Loved that review. Keep them coming.
Thank you - MORE OF THIS
It makes sense to command steering over CAN bus. CAN bus has inherent priority arbitration where messages to lower numbered device addresses automatically defer lower priority messages to higher numbered addresses by over-writing their 1 bits in the message header with 0 bits. CAN bus is also isochronous, that is messages always take a deterministic amount of time to deliver. Ethernet does not guarantee such characteristics, both of which are critically important to communicating a driver’s command input to be executed by the steering gear motor. Priority and timelines are more important to steering than the bus bit rate.
The Cybertruck steering rack may be manufactured by ZF, and CAN may be what ZF is more comfortable working with regardless of other factors.
Ethernet is a physical spec that says nothing about the message protocol that's run over it. You can easily run CAN over Ethernet (instead of IP over Ethernet) and get the full benefits you describe.
What's more likely the reason is electrical isolation. They wanted the redundant system completely isolated, and in effect, they could use anything they wanted there, no matter what the rest of the car uses.
@@HenryLoenwind Thank you for the reply. That is not entirely true. CAN may be encapsulated in Ethernet frames at layer 2, but the Ethernet physical layer in a bus topology* does not support inherent priority arbitration, so that is lost. Ethernet supports priority after a fashion, but it is supported in the message header, not physically at the bit level. *Switched Ethernet is a way to prevent contention.
@@wtmayhew arbitration what you said is totally true. On the deterministic part, Ethernet can be deterministic and is how Tesla designed their protocol. Nothing on the ether loop is routed dynamically, according to Tesla it's all statically time sliced so everything is fixed in place (I should say fixed in time?) and synchronized
Fascinating insight! Thank you :)
Will there be a followup video on the cast aluminum frames and why they aren't suitable for bearing loads beyond the footprint of the vehicle?
What on earth are those two humungous chips on the 'Hi Sandy' circuit board (14:44) doing? It just controls one three phase motor and a position sensor - seems like an excessive number of IO pins for such a relatively simple task?
There's 2 because of redundancy, you can see the pcb has two identical circuits on each half of it. Why so big, no idea really, they may want more pins for extra sensors and redundancy but it's still looking like way too much. Maybe there were no smaller chips that fit their reliability requirements.
With 45 legs each side it's probably a custom ic maybe with built-in redundancy. Also they're measuring a lot, to give accurate feedback to the steering wheel.
Redundancy, especially with sheer by wire.
Depends on the inverter architecture, it might not be just 2 transistor per phase. Think more efficient, tighter control ;)
Quite unusual to have a chip with that many pins in a SOIC, usually you'd go to a BGA. It certainly looks like around 200 pins per chip. Recall that there are two of this complete assembly for redundancy (plus one for the rear). But it does look like there are two three-phase drivers for per-motor driver and logic redundancy. Assuming these are directly controlled bridges, that would be four control lines per phase for a total of twelve. There does not seem to be sufficient transistor packages for anything more. But it occurs that they might have cross-over redundancy were either logic chip can drive the motor through either bridge set (even maybe on a per-phase basis). This would require 24 control lines on each logic chip. Then they might have each chip monitor the outputs of the other bringing the IO count to 32. Still seems way short of the number of pins on the chips.
He’s such a tease, love it!
It's not just about saving copper, but also about reducing problems with contacts, high currents and fires.
Really cool. Thank you!
Sandy: “This is wire in a Tesla. It’s the most amazing wire I have ever seen in my career. It is capable of passing current, which is absolutely amazing and shows why you should pump up my Tesla stock.”
Perhaps you should have watched the video.
Shilling is their prime objective. They think Tesla has done what no other has done before, too bad, Tesla copies all others that have done so much more, for so much longer. It's sad to have such a fake, phony, fraud as your hero. Wake up.
The few things that run on 800 V except the main motors, also must run on 400 V, since during charging, they "just" split the battery in two and get half the voltage. That way they can use current Superchargers. So they can not use the power electronics for a "simple" 800 V or 400 V system. All of that stuff has to be state of the art Tesla or made in close cooperation with Tesla.
I was looking for this comment so I wouldn't replicate it. Exactly right sir.
Other than the propulsion motors, what runs on 800 volts? I think the steering motors are 48v.
@@paulmorrow8372 They mentioned that the AC compressor was HV
Tesla semi is 1000v, megawatt class.
@@markplott4820 Which is all well and good. But how compatible is it with charging at lower voltage levels?
How does the copper weight savings compare to the added weight needed to convert down to 16/12V? An entire extra module for the trailer seems like a bad trade off
Amazing info about the Tesla tech ❤
Only Tesla would take the time to write "Hi Sandy" on their equipment!
Only Tesla has a reasonable expectation of 'Sandy' ever seeing their equipment. Even more so on RUclips.
@@danharold3087because Sandy worships Tesla and shows little respect for the competition! That is the issue I have with this channel! Support the entire ev movement if you want total recognition!
❤
Wondering how much of the 48V has been redesigned at what level(hardware, firmware?). It is a common practice to use a low voltage motor driven at higher voltage(3d printer steppers being one example), just by controlling the pulse width to ensure not overdriving the current through the coil. Unless a true 48V system is needed(such as fine control down to low speeds, with sustained high output and torque at full voltage), the design change is not really doing much other than adding an additional stepup converter and efficiency loss and probably reduced MTBF, at a marginally improved performance(seems to be consistent with the Dale's remarks towards the end). Just some 💭. Excellent technical discussion as always.❤👍
so… safe and sound…. ✨
Please bring Dale back soon.
Dale works for 3iS and is unlikely to feature in future videos.
This just scratches the surface. I would like to see deeper dive. If you can’t analyze the protocol at least peel open the physical layer. What does Ethernet traffic look like on an analyzer under different load conditions? What are the pin outs? What do all the modules do?
Youll have to $$$ for the "deeper dive" my friend.
For a deeper dive, you can purchase our reports! leandesign.com/reports/
Very good presentation...
Would like to see comment on the motor for that huge windscreen wiper! Is it 48V and is it a special large hi-torque motor or just a standard wiper motor.
Thanks, Frank
It's 48 V, we have a detail study of that motor. Good question.
excellent ...EXCELLENT!
Many thanks!
Why not use BLDC-motors for the window lift?
How about the audio system? Does that run on 48 volts? Most audio amplifiers running on 12 volts contain a step ut DC-DC converter. With a 48 volt supply you can basically skip the step up converter and run the output amplifiers directly from the 48 volt supply.
Currently 24v but plan on going to 48v:
ruclips.net/video/J5zDNaY1fvI/видео.html
Thank you!
You're welcome!
And this is the first Gen from them. By 3rd gen should be great.
48V dc Been used on aircraft since the second war or as long as I've been an aircraft engineer. 1970's
This is all The rite stuff Well done Tesla and Munro. I really love how open Tesla has been with its technology for anyone. Bottom line is truly bettering the world. Now if we could just stop all the bank fraud and get people to stop stealing But anyway very informative video 48v is smart
13:20, 48 or 12V motor with a given power will have the same amount of copper inside. It is just the wiring of that motor that will benefit from having less copper. A 48V motor need 4x more turns per tooth of stator or rotor of 4 time smaller wire...
I think he is talking about the wiring coming from the controller to the motor.
I’d question your logic.
48v will have thicker insulation, but very thin copper.
For a given wattage, 4x voltage can use a quarter of the current.
Very interesting thanks!
Please dive into the bidirectional on board charger (: i think it would fit in all vehicle due to the small size
Thanks so much
World Peace
What is that constellation looking thing right above the "Hi Sandy"? No one seems to mention that.
QUIET WINDOW WINDER
Reports of the Cybertruck window mechanism being very quite is presumably down to the motor being 48v and I guess the extra power allows a lower winder gear ratio so fewer motor turns needed?
More voltage doesn’t mean more power when you also reduce the current.
@@ChuckvdL True, but it does mean more power if you do keep cables and current the same. And, as said, it could explain observations that the CT winder is very quiet.
Question?
What is the dashboard running on 48 volts or 12 volts?
Could that window motor use 12 volts.
On that board I'm guessing IGBTs
What size gauging wire's are they using.
Side experiment has anybody ever recorded the CYBER TRUCK being hit by lightning?
TESLA making in house Electronics as far as boards, capacitors, transistors or Igbt's?
What was the thickness of that board on that steering motor?
Are all these boards coated on the surface?
Sandy said we should've been on 48 volts, since the 60's.
-Why didn't the BIG 3 convert, SANDY might know.
Reason for the separate modules on each side, could be for safety or a built in protection.
Could be 12 volt is cheaper, wonder if that plays a role?
Q1: Could that window motor use 12 volts(?). A1: yes. re: "Sandy said we should've been on 48 volts, since the 60's." well for better or worse Sandy says all kinds of stuff, but what must be understood is that what he says is SEPARATE from whether or not it's even true. Q2: Could be 12 volt is cheaper, wonder if that plays a role? A2: you bet your a$$ it does, what the pictures of parking lots we've been seeing in both Florida and Arizona filled with undelivered Cybertrucks reflects is all the CANCELLATIONS of people who didn't sign up to spend $100 Grand on a vehicle (with questionable looks). no, they put down their $100 Dollar deposit on the promise of a sub $50,000 Dollar vehicle (with questionable looks) therein what the DOUBLING of the MSRP from $50K to $100K represents is a classic "scam" known as a BAIT AND SWITCH (everybody knows this).
Yes!!! Hi Sandy!! 😂
4:15 isolated jump-start post can take 12/16/48V
The reason 12 volt stuck around so long is the inertia of the supply chains, one high level Change like moving to 48v disrupts everything, but because Tesla is highly integrated they can do it.
Next to grreting phrase for Sandy - tha Star sign Taurus :-)
Power loss is proportional to the square of the current flow. If you double the volts, you half the current and reduce the power lost in the wiring to a fourth....
Copper losses (I^2R) are NOT significant in an Automobile. savings is in reduction of Conductor size as current drops to a specific load.
Exactly. That’s one magic relationship.
It’s especially important for the high loads like steering.
Was pointed out that the A/C is too high a load even for 48v.
Lower losses means less fire risk - something hybrids & ICE are prone to.
Teslas switch from lead acid LV battery of nominally around 14.6 volts when charging to the lithium ion battery which is around 15.6 volts when charging also gives a little advantage.
It's a bit higher but still being within the tolerable range for 12 volt components.
Amazing. QUESTION: Is there an integrated brake controller for the trailer? I had to buy a model X cable for my Model Y from Tesla and a third party brake controller to velcro to my dashboard in order to run the brakes on my camper.
I recall hearing an integrated brake controller in this video. They mention 4 and what is the other connector 7? wire outputs. In short Yes.
@@danharold3087 Yes I lean toward understanding it as you did but it was unclear if it's just for the lights or also does brakes. Model Y only does the lights and the brake pins were inactive without that workaround.
why not 24v whiere their is a ton of supply already from military and commercial equipment.
I suspect the answer is because then I couldn’t sell you shiny new 48v stuff
decades ago some of the auto manufacturers we supplied where then looking changing from 12VDC to 36VDC or 48VDC
Is either end of the 48V tied to chassis or is it floating?
depends on if they do system engineering to stay in silos as its easy to talk yourself into 12V only in a silo as my electronics are cheaper with 12V total
With the post still on the battery, is there physical lockout to prevent bumping the connecter back into place by accident?
Yes, a plastic latch.
What percent of the CT is still 12v?
Q: What percent of the CT is still 12v? A: "A LOT...!!!" (best Donald Trump voice)
How do you want to count it. By device or by amount of current used. If that sounds odd then I asked the right question to get you thinking.
@@phillyphil1513then we cannot believe it!
@@danharold3087 I was thinking by device, but now im also i interested in current also.
@@0ricle The video tells us the high current devices are 48. Not sure who said it first but the heat pump operates off the high voltage battery.
I have a GEM car 72 v and want to bring it into the modern era, with solar and 2 battery systems one that can be charging while the other is running.. I have 6 12 c sopar pannels to cover the back bed of the pick up wrap and wonder the best way to incorperate this system with modern parts. any suggestions?
48v is becoming more popular in the off grid solar charging and battery systems.
Sorry but going to a higher voltage there is little change in copper, section but a clear increase in insulation and slight gain on efficiency. That is where the real gain comes from. On a motor, Amp*turns shall remain similar given a magnetic field to be generated. Less amps implies more turns in the winding, simple that. Cheers !!!!! Hi Sandy!