1 in 5 Albertians would move to the us. Remember when people all across the country were running there? Thats the liberal and NDP governments killing the Canadian spirt
As a french-canadian living in Quebec, I wouldn't say that Quebec despise Canada. Actually, people love Canada as a country and associate with most of its core value but do not feel at home when they cross the Ontario border. I assume it's exactly the same thing the other way around.
c normal le canada cest pas un pays. si tu force une frontière a des peuples différent oui sur papier ils sont du meme pays mais juste sa. moi nonplus je me sens pas cher moi hors quebec. je déteste pas le canada mais je suis pas canadien je suis québécois. de toute facon ya pas de identité canadienne ou meme de culture. un gars de toronto a rien avoir avec quelqun de alberta. le canada a pas d'histoire, sauf si tu est un loyaliste.
@@dmctztv3842 Le Canada a une histoire. Les différences de langue et de culture n'ont rien a voir. On peut se sentir membre d'un même pays malgré des différence culturel. Ils faut juste avoir un héritage et une histoire commune. Si ont regarde juste a la surface, on voit des différence entre les Québécois et le ROC.Mais si on regarde en profondeur, on peut voir des ressemblance. Des choses qui nous sont uniques. L' Écosse était autrefois(et l'est toujours) très différente de l'Angleterre. Pourtant, il reste très attaché à leurs pays. La même chose pour plusieurs régions de France ou d'Allemagne. Il faut juste que l'on commence a arrêté de regarder juste notre nombril, qu'on commence à s's'intéresser au autre et à ce que nos ancêtre nous on laissé.
@@guesly-a.coulanges1959 le territoire du canada a une histoire, le canada comme peuple a pas d'histoire ni culture ni identité. quelle ressemblence? un albertain est beaucoup plus similaire a un americain que un quebecois. ces regions de la france ont été assimilé par la force. ils otn détruit les langues et cultures des autres regiosn de la france. il a pas de belle petite histoire de famille. nos ancetres se sont battu pour le peuple quebecois.
@@dmctztv3842 Ce que vous dites est faux, en particulier sur la France. 1. Un territoire peut pas avoir d'histoire. Ç'est illogique. Un territoire est un bout de terre. La seule histoire qu'il peut avoir est une histoire géologique. 2. La France est c'est région se sont crée une culture commune. Ils n'ont pas été assimiler par la force. Dire le contraire prouve que vous n'avez que peu se connaissNce sur l'histoire de la France. D'ailleurs, bizarrement, c'est région "assimilé" ont conserver quelque part de leurs culture notamment dans l'accent français distinct d'une région à l'autre. Le Canada a un peuple. C'est juste que a force de vivre dans l'individualisme. On s'aveugle sur c'est chose et on pense plus a nous que autre chose.
Why dont you ask people who are at work? Instead of randoms walking around downtown, of course people with office jobs dont want to leave....they have jobs which are the last to be taken away.
Lenardz so your not proud to be Canadian is what your saying, so the grown up thing to do would be to move where you would prefer to live, no one is stopping you
What is the advantage of being Canadian, part of the 50 countries and some members of the British Commonwealth ? It is to be part of 50 and a few countries in the world which were colonized by the British between the 18th and 20th centuries. The English, wherever they conquered these nations, including New France, did so by force of arms. Even today, Canada, a country that is not really one, maintains allegiance to the Queen of England and her degenerate family in the person of the Governor General, Julie Payette. This Canada, so dear to the Canadians of the ROC, since its foundation and before, did everything to weaken Quebec, stole it and still steals it, by depriving it of the rights of passage for naval traffic on the St. Lawrence Seaway, for example, which since 1959, has contributed to the decline of Montreal, the hub of rail, naval and air transport until then, was the richest city in the country,.for the benefit of Toronto. It should also be remembered that the British deported 15,000 Acadians in 1755, attempted to eliminate the Amerindians by inoculating cloths worn by tuberculosis patients, at the time of the Conquest of New France, in the person of General Amherst. So, there is no pride in me proclaiming myself Canadian. My ancestors who came from France in 1656 settled on the Côte de Beaupré and in Trois-Rivières in Quebec since that date, which means that I am first Québécois, before being Canadian! Vive le Québec libre !
Lol they ask young white kids and a old white lady if they want to move.. why not ask males in their 30s and 40s? Or foreigners that are male. Anyways Canada has its positives and it sure has its negatives.. depends on the person where they fall into.
J C just because your in that demographic and are unhappy and are not successful that is your own issue, a majority of men by that age have a good career and have saved their money
Aren't Albertans outspoken about being closer to United States Americans? And Quebecuois had to fight to make their language official. Talk about segregating the Quebecouis brothers ...
Just not the country we want out here. Wish u guys the best out east but we don't like the direction u all are heading, so we want to go at it alone or join the States.
This country is far more concerned with one form of "pride" than another. I'm from Ontario and as an immigrant of 3+ decades I can say, confidently, that this country has aged like milk instead of wine.
Both Alberta and Quebec are propped up by billions of dollars in transfer payments and oil subsides. They're not going to separate without a major economic crash.
@ The Canadian federal government is the one who built that seaway while Quebec was floundering. It would not have complete rights to it in the event of separation. Quebec would also lose all of the tribal land in its north, where most of its strategic natural resources are. It would be a stunted 'country'.
@ Nunavik belongs to Quebec in the same way that Quebec belongs to Canada. If you accept the presumption that one self-governing region has the right of secession, then all regions must also have that same right. Surely the original inhabitants of the land have more of a right to self-determination than the descendants of French colonists?
4 года назад
@@realkosherpork9223 No, you got it all wrong, Nunavik is NOT a free entity, in fact it is just a zone where you will find more indigenous people.When you take a map of Quebec, you will see that Nunavik does not exist.I think I know more than you about my province, you probably have been told by Canadian propaganda that we would also do badly as a country, which is wrong because we would be in the top 25. I shall repeat myself: Nunavik does not exist as an entity just like how the ''grand nord'' where we have plans does not exist as an entity.Telling me Nunavik could go out of Quebec like that is like telling me a random city could go out if it wishes.
There's nothing to be proud of being Canadian with its anti-French and anti-aboriginal laws (Indian act) But Quebecers are proud to be Quebecers and the French language
lol there hating the US because of Trump what else could it be? I love the USA and people were always friendly to me lol.. there just being Canadians 😂
If Quebec separated in the 90s they'd be a 3rd world country by now, same thing would happen with Alberta and their dried up industry and job prospects, and high cost of living. They should be more thankful for all the money they get from the federal gov!
So you ask one old lady then a bunch of young kids.... Reality haven't set in yet for them. Maybe try asking some real adults that have to deal with the every day bs right now.
Hey Quebec, we’re taking our money away from you and leaving in our own pocket. Alberta doesn’t need you but you do need us, remember who’s money your living off. Alberta needs and will separate from Canada!
Alberta needs to stay, so does Quebec. For any of them to leave would be detrimental for Canada and whoever leaves. Back when Quebec was serious about separatism, even Albertans were raising money for people to go over to Quebec and persuade them to stay. It was a tight vote, but the vote to stay held true thankfully.
Also, Quebec is not living off Alberta. Quebec has sustained their own economy very well. The reason for equalization has more to do with the way taxes are ran in Quebec. Quebec is the future. Alberta needs to move on from oil.
Happy to be Canadian, even though the cost of living outpaces reality, though this opinion is from someone on disability pension being somewhat humbled by that and might not reflect in the same manner for other Canadians. Its better than being in a war torn area ran by dictator type govts or the land of the fee. Canada invested heavily into hydro electric projects in Quebec, and shortly after that a referendum was processed. That seemed like a slap in the face to other Canadians/Canadiens at the time as it looked like one of those sly moves by waiting until Quebec was enabled to have a self sustaining infrastructure, completed by Canadian tax payers. Alberta should focus on advancing away from a Bronze Age looking fossil fuel based infrastructure. They should be reminded that according to a Financial Times report that 12 million people die yearly from pollution globally, which dwarfs the numbers of people actually in Alberta. Does Alberta want to keep turning a blinded profiteering eye to that alarming statistic? What does being Canadian mean to them?
False! Quebec funded and developed its hydroelectric network on its own, without assistance from the federal government between the 60s and 80s . On the other hand, Newfoundland and Labrador has developed its hydro-electric network with the billions of Ottawa. Also, Lower Canada in the 19th century financed all western infrastructure alone for the creation of Canada, when there was no one on these vast territories to finance the rail network, from coast to coast.. Also, at the same time, Lower Canada (Quebec) paid off the debt of Upper Canada (Ontario), because it was the most populated territory at the time. The British stole the country from Quebecois and Canada afterwards since 1867. In the 1995 referendum, the federal government entered the referendum campaign with its billions of dollars, let us remember the sponsorship scandal - and the accelerated promise of citizenship for newcomers in Québec, encouraged to vote no in this referendum. Why ? Because Quebec is necessary to maintain confederation. Without Quebec, Canada simply would not exist!
Aren't alberta and quebec also the only 2 provinces that had trump rallies and are also notoriously racist? Can't we just turn them off and on again to reset them? If I go to quebec now, I pretend to be deaf and just use my phone for translating. I've never and will never treat someone who doesn't speak my language the way they treat people. I will and use all the tools at my disposal if I cannot find someone to help them in their native language. Not just, "oh you do not speak my language, okay bye." That is just rude, You're rude.
It's sure if you come with your hatred of Quebec You can't blame them for not welcoming you with a smile But tourists find old Quebec and the rest of the province more welcoming than the ROC
1 in 5 Albertians would move to the us. Remember when people all across the country were running there? Thats the liberal and NDP governments killing the Canadian spirt
Definitely more than that now
As a french-canadian living in Quebec, I wouldn't say that Quebec despise Canada. Actually, people love Canada as a country and associate with most of its core value but do not feel at home when they cross the Ontario border. I assume it's exactly the same thing the other way around.
c normal le canada cest pas un pays.
si tu force une frontière a des peuples différent oui sur papier ils sont du meme pays mais juste sa.
moi nonplus je me sens pas cher moi hors quebec.
je déteste pas le canada mais je suis pas canadien je suis québécois.
de toute facon ya pas de identité canadienne ou meme de culture.
un gars de toronto a rien avoir avec quelqun de alberta.
le canada a pas d'histoire, sauf si tu est un loyaliste.
@@dmctztv3842 Le Canada a une histoire. Les différences de langue et de culture n'ont rien a voir. On peut se sentir membre d'un même pays malgré des différence culturel. Ils faut juste avoir un héritage et une histoire commune. Si ont regarde juste a la surface, on voit des différence entre les Québécois et le ROC.Mais si on regarde en profondeur, on peut voir des ressemblance. Des choses qui nous sont uniques. L' Écosse était autrefois(et l'est toujours) très différente de l'Angleterre. Pourtant, il reste très attaché à leurs pays. La même chose pour plusieurs régions de France ou d'Allemagne. Il faut juste que l'on commence a arrêté de regarder juste notre nombril, qu'on commence à s's'intéresser au autre et à ce que nos ancêtre nous on laissé.
@@guesly-a.coulanges1959 le territoire du canada a une histoire, le canada comme peuple a pas d'histoire ni culture ni identité.
quelle ressemblence? un albertain est beaucoup plus similaire a un americain que un quebecois.
ces regions de la france ont été assimilé par la force.
ils otn détruit les langues et cultures des autres regiosn de la france.
il a pas de belle petite histoire de famille.
nos ancetres se sont battu pour le peuple quebecois.
@@dmctztv3842 Ce que vous dites est faux, en particulier sur la France.
1. Un territoire peut pas avoir d'histoire. Ç'est illogique. Un territoire est un bout de terre. La seule histoire qu'il peut avoir est une histoire géologique.
2. La France est c'est région se sont crée une culture commune. Ils n'ont pas été assimiler par la force. Dire le contraire prouve que vous n'avez que peu se connaissNce sur l'histoire de la France. D'ailleurs, bizarrement, c'est région "assimilé" ont conserver quelque part de leurs culture notamment dans l'accent français distinct d'une région à l'autre.
Le Canada a un peuple. C'est juste que a force de vivre dans l'individualisme. On s'aveugle sur c'est chose et on pense plus a nous que autre chose.
I don't feel any different going to Quebec. I really only notice the language.
Why dont you ask people who are at work? Instead of randoms walking around downtown, of course people with office jobs dont want to leave....they have jobs which are the last to be taken away.
Canada, under Trudeau, that is
Proud, fortunate, and greatful.
Many Quebecois de souche are proud to be Quebecois more than they are proud to be Canadien. Nothing wrong with that per se.
True north has shifted west. The moral Canada is now in the Prairies
When you have a PM actively trying to cause a depression it's hard to stay positive about your country.
Only the most ungrateful of people wouldn't be proud to be Canadian. Canada is the best country on earth.
Ashley Y 👍🇨🇦
Read this book : Two Solitudes. Then you'll understand something !! 😉
i'm from Québec and i'm proud To be canadian
I'm Canadian and I'm proud that Quebec helps make this country great
Good for you, do you feel more accepted now?
Would anyone say they’re not proud to be Canadian on NATIONAL TV on CANADA DAY?!
Lenardz so your not proud to be Canadian is what your saying, so the grown up thing to do would be to move where you would prefer to live, no one is stopping you
I would. They would edit it out though
It is from present day Quebec that we have the name Canada for our country !
Actually, it comes from the Huron-Iroquois word “kanata,” for village or settlement. So actually thank you indigenous people.
@@killedthedog yes and no, the second french colonie was called canada because of Jacques-cartier and samuel de champlain .
@@killedthedog Yeah, who were found in present day Quebec.
What is the advantage of being Canadian, part of the 50 countries and some members of the British Commonwealth ? It is to be part of 50 and a few countries in the world which were colonized by the British between the 18th and 20th centuries. The English, wherever they conquered these nations, including New France, did so by force of arms. Even today, Canada, a country that is not really one, maintains allegiance to the Queen of England and her degenerate family in the person of the Governor General, Julie Payette. This Canada, so dear to the Canadians of the ROC, since its foundation and before, did everything to weaken Quebec, stole it and still steals it, by depriving it of the rights of passage for naval traffic on the St. Lawrence Seaway, for example, which since 1959, has contributed to the decline of Montreal, the hub of rail, naval and air transport until then, was the richest city in the country,.for the benefit of Toronto.
It should also be remembered that the British deported 15,000 Acadians in 1755, attempted to eliminate the Amerindians by inoculating cloths worn by tuberculosis patients, at the time of the Conquest of New France, in the person of General Amherst.
So, there is no pride in me proclaiming myself Canadian. My ancestors who came from France in 1656 settled on the Côte de Beaupré and in Trois-Rivières in Quebec since that date, which means that I am first Québécois, before being Canadian!
Vive le Québec libre !
I fully agree with you
Lol they ask young white kids and a old white lady if they want to move.. why not ask males in their 30s and 40s? Or foreigners that are male. Anyways Canada has its positives and it sure has its negatives.. depends on the person where they fall into.
J C just because your in that demographic and are unhappy and are not successful that is your own issue, a majority of men by that age have a good career and have saved their money
I’m sure they asked many people...till they got the responses they wanted
Used to be a proud patriotic canadian.but now its a shitshow and I'm loosing faith in this place every second
Canada 🇨🇦 ❤️ Canada 🇨🇦 love ❤️
Manny Dhillon 😊🇨🇦🎉 Happy Canada Day, from Québec.
Aren't Albertans outspoken about being closer to United States Americans?
And Quebecuois had to fight to make their language official.
Talk about segregating the Quebecouis brothers ...
lospaisas original they fought more for political power but language won out. As the language laws attest to.
Only the republican wannabes are "closer" to the US>
I ❤️CANADA
luxaholic anonymous 👍🇨🇦😊
You are in the minority. Many of us remember canaduh when it really was worth loving.
Mick9 Many of us are doing what we can for this country. We haven't given up yet. Futile, maybe but we have to try. The other option is unthinkable.
Oh silly goose, our country is crumbling ever since WW2.
Just not the country we want out here. Wish u guys the best out east but we don't like the direction u all are heading, so we want to go at it alone or join the States.
This country is far more concerned with one form of "pride" than another. I'm from Ontario and as an immigrant of 3+ decades I can say, confidently, that this country has aged like milk instead of wine.
How could you NOT be proud to be Canadian!
City news good job dividing the country! Oh, and good job dividing the continent. Btw! Can you imagine taking a poll of who stopped to talk to you?
VIVE LE QUEBEC LIBRE !
I think its because Alberta and Quebec want to leave Canada and become independent which won't be a country without them
Both Alberta and Quebec are propped up by billions of dollars in transfer payments and oil subsides. They're not going to separate without a major economic crash.
@ The Canadian federal government is the one who built that seaway while Quebec was floundering. It would not have complete rights to it in the event of separation.
Quebec would also lose all of the tribal land in its north, where most of its strategic natural resources are. It would be a stunted 'country'.
@ Nunavik belongs to Quebec in the same way that Quebec belongs to Canada. If you accept the presumption that one self-governing region has the right of secession, then all regions must also have that same right.
Surely the original inhabitants of the land have more of a right to self-determination than the descendants of French colonists?
@@realkosherpork9223 No, you got it all wrong, Nunavik is NOT a free entity, in fact it is just a zone where you will find more indigenous people.When you take a map of Quebec, you will see that Nunavik does not exist.I think I know more than you about my province, you probably have been told by Canadian propaganda that we would also do badly as a country, which is wrong because we would be in the top 25. I shall repeat myself: Nunavik does not exist as an entity just like how the ''grand nord'' where we have plans does not exist as an entity.Telling me Nunavik could go out of Quebec like that is like telling me a random city could go out if it wishes.
What happened to New Brunswick, Nova Scotia etc. We are only 5 provinces now.
🇨🇦 forever...speaking as a 🇬🇧/🇺🇸 person.
Quebec pride lowest in rest of Canada 😶😂😂
There's nothing to be proud of being Canadian with its anti-French and anti-aboriginal laws (Indian act)
But Quebecers are proud to be Quebecers and the French language
@@linefrenette9116 Yeah, Canadians need to tone down the unfounded hate for Indigenous People and French-Canadians.
lol no one is gonna tell you the real reason infront of the camera lol
A sure sign of great leadership ! !
lol there hating the US because of Trump what else could it be? I love the USA and people were always friendly to me lol.. there just being Canadians 😂
Surprise surprise.
If Quebec separated in the 90s they'd be a 3rd world country by now, same thing would happen with Alberta and their dried up industry and job prospects, and high cost of living. They should be more thankful for all the money they get from the federal gov!
cnon not the fed government. The taxpayer, don't forget that
cnon nice to be treated as part of the country on Canada Day. I guess all the other provinces are doing great. Especially Ontario.
So you ask one old lady then a bunch of young kids.... Reality haven't set in yet for them. Maybe try asking some real adults that have to deal with the every day bs right now.
Ricks Y so have you started your move to the US then?
I'd be down to go to the states, not anywhere mind you, but certain parts of the East and West coast are actually quite progressive.
Sartorius988 Progressive = Regressive
What? This is so full of..... inset thought.
Hey Quebec, we’re taking our money away from you and leaving in our own pocket.
Alberta doesn’t need you but you do need us, remember who’s money your living off.
Alberta needs and will separate from Canada!
Good riddance,,,,,Racist Province of Alberta
Alberta needs to stay, so does Quebec. For any of them to leave would be detrimental for Canada and whoever leaves. Back when Quebec was serious about separatism, even Albertans were raising money for people to go over to Quebec and persuade them to stay. It was a tight vote, but the vote to stay held true thankfully.
Also, Quebec is not living off Alberta. Quebec has sustained their own economy very well. The reason for equalization has more to do with the way taxes are ran in Quebec. Quebec is the future. Alberta needs to move on from oil.
Oh Quebec...
Ben McInnes yes?
Happy to be Canadian, even though the cost of living outpaces reality, though this opinion is from someone on disability pension being somewhat humbled by that and might not reflect in the same manner for other Canadians. Its better than being in a war torn area ran by dictator type govts or the land of the fee.
Canada invested heavily into hydro electric projects in Quebec, and shortly after that a referendum was processed. That seemed like a slap in the face to other Canadians/Canadiens at the time as it looked like one of those sly moves by waiting until Quebec was enabled to have a self sustaining infrastructure, completed by Canadian tax payers.
Alberta should focus on advancing away from a Bronze Age looking fossil fuel based infrastructure. They should be reminded that according to a Financial Times report that 12 million people die yearly from pollution globally, which dwarfs the numbers of people actually in Alberta. Does Alberta want to keep turning a blinded profiteering eye to that alarming statistic? What does being Canadian mean to them?
False! Quebec funded and developed its hydroelectric network on its own, without assistance from the federal government between the 60s and 80s . On the other hand, Newfoundland and Labrador has developed its hydro-electric network with the billions of Ottawa.
Also, Lower Canada in the 19th century financed all western infrastructure alone for the creation of Canada, when there was no one on these vast territories to finance the rail network, from coast to coast.. Also, at the same time, Lower Canada (Quebec) paid off the debt of Upper Canada (Ontario), because it was the most populated territory at the time. The British stole the country from Quebecois and Canada afterwards since 1867.
In the 1995 referendum, the federal government entered the referendum campaign with its billions of dollars, let us remember the sponsorship scandal - and the accelerated promise of citizenship for newcomers in Québec, encouraged to vote no in this referendum. Why ? Because Quebec is necessary to maintain confederation. Without Quebec, Canada simply would not exist!
We know our history liar!
Aren't alberta and quebec also the only 2 provinces that had trump rallies and are also notoriously racist? Can't we just turn them off and on again to reset them?
If I go to quebec now, I pretend to be deaf and just use my phone for translating. I've never and will never treat someone who doesn't speak my language the way they treat people. I will and use all the tools at my disposal if I cannot find someone to help them in their native language. Not just, "oh you do not speak my language, okay bye." That is just rude, You're rude.
It's sure if you come with your hatred of Quebec You can't blame them for not welcoming you with a smile
But tourists find old Quebec and the rest of the province more welcoming than the ROC
@@linefrenette9116 The Maritimes is very welcoming as well
@@thecaynuck4694 i agree
Ive never seen a pro trump rally in Quebec. Pretty sad that you have to lie to demonize Quebec.
dough ford it's mess up.more canada
Better red then dead
Never conservative
vote for the bloc
Ontario stands with Quebec
Québec stands with no one
@@linefrenette9116 Quebec stands with the rest of Canada. Especially the East. But the West are very rude to them for no reason.
@@thecaynuck4694 Quebec stand with any provinces
And you're right about the rest