I love the subtle personality differences we can see between male and female Byleth. FByleth knew her brother wouldn’t be able to end her so thats why she did it herself, however, MByleth knew she could do it and that his attack would fail but by attacking her maybe she would feel less remorse. That’s my interpretation anyway, I find this so tragically beautiful that I wish this was real in game
Shame your channel got taken down. This is still out of all of the fan ideas I've seen for Three Houses is my favourite. Having Byleth be twins but one is the vessel and the other chooses the opposite path is such a great idea. Also "I can't afford to leave him again" and the "Nothing will separate us" Damn that's just a punch to the gut and you nailed it.
As someone who's only played as Male Byleth and who's favorite route is Azure Moon this really got me in the feels for both ways and yeah I may have had the same reaction if played as Male Byleth in both scenarios😢
Damn, can't believe the original got taken down. I only now found out because I'm going through the archives and trying to find what all of the videos I liked that got deleted were.
I really wish Three Houses did the same thing Genshin Impact did with the whole one sibling is good and the other becomes antagonistic thing would've been heartbreakingly tragic
This game needed a secret ending where everyone is united and any misunderstandings would be cleared up. All of the endings had to have at least 1 of the major group to be killed off. And 1 of the endings is just killing everyone and only 1 survives. Like if only Dimitri and Edelgard had a nice long talk about the things that had happened, then Dimitri would've helped her find another way to achieve her goal without needing to go on a killing spree towards those who disagreed with her.
That's the beauty of Three Houses character writing. The whole situation could have gone a lot smoother if the leaders of the four factions just got together and talked it out, but they're all too screwed up to ever consider something like that. Edelgard is too suspicious. Dimitri too unstable. Claude purposefully makes himself seem untrustworthy. And Rhea is blinded by grief and rage.
Yes, that how politics and class struggle work. If only they though about asking the nobles and the church to not oppress people, maybe hey would have said yes, disband there armies and abandon their privilege.
If I'm being real, Three Houses could've ended in a much better way but according to the devs they didn't want a "happy" ending for the game, so the plot line of how things turned out was just kinda stupid. Dimitri's anger was misdirected towards Edelgard and Edelgards method of "uniting the country" was a delusion from her thinking the empire should rule over everyone and whoever doesn't agree with her end up dead, plus not to mention the game has a school where you are teaching students to eventually kill each other
"was a delusion from her thinking the empire should rule over everyone" Edelgard doesn't care about the empire ruling everything, she doesn't even care about the empire at all. She hates the Empire as a structure. She conquers everything because 1) the war with the Church is inevitable to get rid of the crests and the Theocracy in general, 2) The Kingdom will always decide to fight with the Church because the Church is how they legitimise their existence and 3) The Alliance will generally choose to fight somewhat on the side of the Kingdom because they fear being absorbed afterwards. Three Hopes has shown that if Edelgard and Claude could end up in a situation where they are forced to reluctantly trust each other and actually communicate their goals to each other, they are in fact natural allies and only the Kingdom has to be conquered (and then again only because it chooses to defend the Church). In fact Claude and Edelgard are perfect allies because they cover each other's blind spots. Even in three houses, if you spare Claude in CF, he is hopeful that his goal might still be achieved with Edelgard at the head of the continent. But he only "trust" her there because he has no choice, sadly there is no opportunity for them to trust each other in time to avoid war in that path, which makes sense, both Claude and Edelgard are plotters, they see the worst part of themselves in each other.
@@Arkayjiya I have to add that claude only is willing to team up with dimitri when he has no other choice he never trusted him in azure gleam and its implied he was plotting against him while in azure moon its byleth claude trusts ( and in verdant wind claude simply takes advantage of byleths status to rally people he just cares that someone he trusts is in a position of power to do what he wants) in verdant wind your bond points with claude is raised if you say it would be better if rhea was dead ( meaning he liked the statement
![[Comic Dub] Fire Emblem Three Houses:Rising Star](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/UfaXxr_05sU/mqdefault.jpg)
![[Comic Dub] Fire Emblem Three Houses:Rising Star](/img/tr.png)
![[Comic Dub] Fire Emblem Three Houses:The Last Dance](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/62LHPt3azB8/mqdefault.jpg)
I honestly think it would of been cool to have the other gender you didn't choose end up your rival,enemy,and sibling.
Agreed
Genshin style
Reminds of how in Fire Emblem Warriors male Corrin is the ruler of Hoshido and female Corrin rules over Nohr
like pokemon or something hahahaha
Claude: damn, that shit's crazy
I can see both choosing both Claude route and Rhea route ngl
I love the subtle personality differences we can see between male and female Byleth. FByleth knew her brother wouldn’t be able to end her so thats why she did it herself, however, MByleth knew she could do it and that his attack would fail but by attacking her maybe she would feel less remorse.
That’s my interpretation anyway, I find this so tragically beautiful that I wish this was real in game
"If only there was another way"
man, if only she had chosen Claude time
Claude is chilling with Gendern't Byleth
I read it, it's worse.
Spoiler
.
.
.
.
.
Both the siblings die.
The "I don't regret choosing this path" line is going to be in my head for a while so thanks but no thanks
Shame your channel got taken down. This is still out of all of the fan ideas I've seen for Three Houses is my favourite. Having Byleth be twins but one is the vessel and the other chooses the opposite path is such a great idea.
Also "I can't afford to leave him again" and the "Nothing will separate us" Damn that's just a punch to the gut and you nailed it.
I will never forget when I saw this video for first time, I admit I was shocked, I'm sorry for what happened to your channel.
As someone who's only played as Male Byleth and who's favorite route is Azure Moon this really got me in the feels for both ways and yeah I may have had the same reaction if played as Male Byleth in both scenarios😢
Damn, can't believe the original got taken down. I only now found out because I'm going through the archives and trying to find what all of the videos I liked that got deleted were.
Thanks for reuploading your video, I missed it so much !
I'm writing a TTRPG campaign based on it
thx for reupload this
I really wish Three Houses did the same thing Genshin Impact did with the whole one sibling is good and the other becomes antagonistic thing would've been heartbreakingly tragic
This game needed a secret ending where everyone is united and any misunderstandings would be cleared up. All of the endings had to have at least 1 of the major group to be killed off. And 1 of the endings is just killing everyone and only 1 survives. Like if only Dimitri and Edelgard had a nice long talk about the things that had happened, then Dimitri would've helped her find another way to achieve her goal without needing to go on a killing spree towards those who disagreed with her.
The devs just didn't want 3 houses to be another fates
That's the beauty of Three Houses character writing. The whole situation could have gone a lot smoother if the leaders of the four factions just got together and talked it out, but they're all too screwed up to ever consider something like that.
Edelgard is too suspicious.
Dimitri too unstable.
Claude purposefully makes himself seem untrustworthy.
And Rhea is blinded by grief and rage.
Yes, that how politics and class struggle work. If only they though about asking the nobles and the church to not oppress people, maybe hey would have said yes, disband there armies and abandon their privilege.
@@RedADHD1919 That has absolutely nothing to do with the story.
I prefer those bittersweet endings. It's a story about war, everyone lose something
They know if one of them fell in love with claude instead
idea the male one is called Byleth and the female one is called Dyleth.
If I'm being real, Three Houses could've ended in a much better way but according to the devs they didn't want a "happy" ending for the game, so the plot line of how things turned out was just kinda stupid. Dimitri's anger was misdirected towards Edelgard and Edelgards method of "uniting the country" was a delusion from her thinking the empire should rule over everyone and whoever doesn't agree with her end up dead, plus not to mention the game has a school where you are teaching students to eventually kill each other
"was a delusion from her thinking the empire should rule over everyone"
Edelgard doesn't care about the empire ruling everything, she doesn't even care about the empire at all. She hates the Empire as a structure.
She conquers everything because 1) the war with the Church is inevitable to get rid of the crests and the Theocracy in general, 2) The Kingdom will always decide to fight with the Church because the Church is how they legitimise their existence and 3) The Alliance will generally choose to fight somewhat on the side of the Kingdom because they fear being absorbed afterwards.
Three Hopes has shown that if Edelgard and Claude could end up in a situation where they are forced to reluctantly trust each other and actually communicate their goals to each other, they are in fact natural allies and only the Kingdom has to be conquered (and then again only because it chooses to defend the Church). In fact Claude and Edelgard are perfect allies because they cover each other's blind spots. Even in three houses, if you spare Claude in CF, he is hopeful that his goal might still be achieved with Edelgard at the head of the continent. But he only "trust" her there because he has no choice, sadly there is no opportunity for them to trust each other in time to avoid war in that path, which makes sense, both Claude and Edelgard are plotters, they see the worst part of themselves in each other.
@@Arkayjiya I have to add that claude only is willing to team up with dimitri when he has no other choice he never trusted him in azure gleam and its implied he was plotting against him while in azure moon its byleth claude trusts ( and in verdant wind claude simply takes advantage of byleths status to rally people he just cares that someone he trusts is in a position of power to do what he wants) in verdant wind your bond points with claude is raised if you say it would be better if rhea was dead ( meaning he liked the statement
Edelgard awesome as always.
Yeah gurl, choose Claude and he chooses Dimitri! Or he chooses Claude! Claude is ALWAYS the answer.
😒
such cringey dialogue