Daniel Smith Color Showdown Ep 4: Phthalo Turquoise vs Ultramarine Turquoise | Watercolor Comparison

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 25 окт 2024

Комментарии • 87

  • @InLiquidColor
    @InLiquidColor 6 лет назад +55

    I actually really liked the texture of Ultramarine Turquoise in the gauze test! I thought it was really unique and different to the others I've seen from your tests. That being said, phthalo turquoise is my first love, was on my first DS palette, and I cannot not choose that as my winner :)

    • @jittersaunt
      @jittersaunt 5 лет назад +5

      I agree about the gauze. I thought it was cool even though it didn't give her what she's looking for.

  • @Renilou2
    @Renilou2 5 лет назад +12

    I prefer Ultramarine Turquoise. I adore the affect of the ultramarine turquoise had with the gauze! The separation of color that would be perfect for rivers and streams! The way the color separates with the heavy watery wash! OMG its so beautiful! I have this tube of DS watercolor and never tried it but now I will. Phthalo turquoise is just too easy to make with PG7 & PB15.3 that is already on my palette.

  • @virginia-marieparker6325
    @virginia-marieparker6325 4 года назад +7

    I’m returning to my watercolor after a twenty year absence. I’ve binged your color comparative vids for three days now. Beyond a most sincere THANK YOU for all your efforts in throughly presenting my every option, I am without words to adequately express my gratitude.

    • @AmandaMG6
      @AmandaMG6 4 года назад +4

      I’d be curious what the palette you’re building will hold ☺️

    • @virginia-marieparker6325
      @virginia-marieparker6325 4 года назад +3

      It’s with new eyes and LOADS MORE information on pigments, their light-fastness, quality of wash, ability to mix with other colors and retain clarity, etc. (you know😉) that I build slowly. Sorting/reviving old Windsor Newton’s Artist’s. The Cotmans are mostly, (the earth tones are still good) relegated to practice. I got it down to ordering 6 new Daniel Smith! Just got them today- and wow weeeee, are they beautiful! So, now I find myself having a Jerry’s Artarama link open on my phone again- ya know, cuz, it’s like an addiction. 😜🤣 and I want more. 🤷‍♀️

    • @paintingtracey
      @paintingtracey 10 месяцев назад

      OMG, I am in the exact same boat, but I am giving my cotmans away. I just bought a set for the travel palette. I dont want to struggle with bad paint. I have bought so much new paint and have a tab open for Dicblick, cheap joes and Jerrys all-the-time. It's starting to feel like an illness, ha ha. I have recently started to add acrylic and now I want to add watercolor to my oil painting routine (oil goes on top, lol). How did your palette shape up and changed over 3 years? @@virginia-marieparker6325

  • @kathrynt98011
    @kathrynt98011 6 лет назад +20

    I have some ideas for showdown pairs!
    Lemon Yellow vs Hansa Yellow Light
    Burnt Sienna vs Italian Burnt Sienna
    Perylene Red vs Pyrrol Red
    Triple threat! Quinacridone Rose, Quinacridone Pink, Quinacridone Lilac
    Quinacridone Burnt Orange vs Transparent Red Oxide
    PY110 vs PY139 (I can never remember the color names of these so I just use the pigment numbers)
    Pyrrol Crimson vs Anthraquinoid Red
    Genuine Alizarin Crimson vs Permanent Alizarin Crimson
    Indian Red vs Venetian Red
    Cobalt Teal vs Cobalt Turquoise
    Phthalo Green Blue Shade vs Phthalo Green Yellow Shade
    Phthalo Blue Green Shade vs Phthalo Blue Red Shade
    Perylene Violet vs Quinacridone Violet
    Carbazole Violet vs Quinacridone Purple
    Ok I think that’s all for now

  • @cherylj.harris4967
    @cherylj.harris4967 3 года назад +2

    Adoring the Phthalo Turquois; a beautiful jewel tone!

  • @MeowMeowKapow
    @MeowMeowKapow 6 лет назад +16

    I have phthalate turquoise, but not ultramarine turquoise! And yeah, it’s one of my color loves. If you mix phthalate turquoise with perylene violet is makes a gorrrrrgeous........Neutral-ish purple sort of thing. Love it. Used it a lot in one of my inktober videos (the one of the wicked/wick’d witch!) I also specifically used that mix to do crazy amounts of layering in that piece so can also confirm that phthalate turquoise is an EXCELLENT glazing color!
    This series is super fun, and I love seeing your huge range of tests! And the movement of the paint being described as batshit crazy? Pretty accurate. =>.

    • @OtoKano
      @OtoKano  6 лет назад +1

      Oh man I am so going to have to try mixing it with perylene violet. Thank you!

  • @dedesu3
    @dedesu3 6 лет назад +7

    I really liked the gauze on the ultramarine turquoise side best. Really cool with the pulling out of the blue.

  • @jaimeanderson9238
    @jaimeanderson9238 6 лет назад +11

    I have both and the ultramarine wins for me. The way the colors separate when they dry is just magical.

    • @heelerjustheeler879
      @heelerjustheeler879 3 года назад +1

      I was entranced by that color separation as well while watching this!

    • @LLS1190
      @LLS1190 3 года назад +1

      Did I miss her pointing out how much the two colors separated, particularly in the gradation and gauze tests? It was really noticeable, but I didn't hear her address it.

  • @KateGoesExploring
    @KateGoesExploring Год назад +1

    Thank you so much for testing these!

  • @EveBolt
    @EveBolt 6 лет назад +17

    The ultramarine turquoise is doomed to fail the gauze test, with it's granulating and not granulating combo mix XD
    These are so similar, yet I'd be hard pressed to pick only one, as I can see myself using both depending on the circumstance. Also, the mixes with UM Violet are soooooo pretty!! ♥ Thank you for doing this episode!!

    • @OtoKano
      @OtoKano  6 лет назад +2

      Although the differences between them are sooooooo subtle, I would struggle to justify having both on my palette. Why does Daniel Smith have to make so many beautiful yet oh-so-similar colours?

  • @KatieReadsKoziesAndMore
    @KatieReadsKoziesAndMore 6 лет назад +8

    The gauzing effect of the ultramarine turquoise is beautiful. I’m in love with it. How it could be used, I don’t know. But it sure is lovely. Thank you.

  • @CobraDove1111
    @CobraDove1111 6 лет назад +4

    That Ultramarine Turquoise texture is AMAZING' Im getting that colour

  • @emilymaness
    @emilymaness 4 года назад

    Love both! Pthalo Turquoise is my favorite of the two. I think it’s just so beautiful and adds so much to so many different types of paintings.

  • @sumbae7668
    @sumbae7668 3 года назад +1

    I love the ultramarine turquoise. But I'm a big fan of any ultramarine color/shade in general. I'm considering to buy it as an addition to my palette. Thank you for all of your thorough and good reviews

    • @annenglish2935
      @annenglish2935 2 года назад

      I just bought Daniel Smith Ultramarine Turquoise!!! I have the paint dot card so I can see what the actual color looks like on paper! I'm in love with this color! I also recently found a beautiful color by Da Vinci... look at "Seaglass" PB15:4, PG7! I also bought their color sample dot card with 24 paints and it had a Cobalt Turquoise PB36 in it, also beautiful! There's so much joy in finding a feel good watercolor! Happy 😊 painting!

  • @artwithalexander5359
    @artwithalexander5359 Год назад

    how funny, i like everything you were disappointed in. after this comparison i will be putting the ultramarine version on my list. the duel color show is exsactly what i like about it and the more controlled water effects.

  • @McQuizzical
    @McQuizzical 5 лет назад +3

    Thank you so much for all do here. Turquoise (and duck egg blue) are my favourite colours, but its so difficult to find just the right shade, there seems to be so many variations, I find anyway. I'm wondering if you're planning on doing a review of the Cobalt Turquoise at all please? Unless you have already and I just need to search through your videos a little better? Thank you again ☺

  • @SadieSavestheDay
    @SadieSavestheDay 6 лет назад +5

    I feel like turquoise is such a popular color at the moment! I wonder how these two compare to a PB16 turquoise? I’ve always also been curious how they would stand up to Holbein’s discontinued peacock blue with PB17, which made a lot of people sad when it disappeared.

    • @OtoKano
      @OtoKano  6 лет назад

      I'm so glad you asked this. I much prefer the Daniel Smith's phthalo turquoise to W&N or Holbein's. I love the PB16 version too. I just find DS's one mixes nicer with their Quin Rose, and I am all about that Quin Rose 😂In terms of comparison, DS's one is s fraction more green-ish than the PB16.

  • @197432879
    @197432879 2 года назад

    I vote for Phthalo Turquoise and I have it and use it a lot but was curious about the Ultramarine Turquoise, so thank for the video!

  • @LeySketch
    @LeySketch 6 лет назад +1

    These have got to be the most similar paints in this series yet! Wow. It's almost eerie how similar their mixes are too, aside from a couple of variations. What a shame ultramarine turquoise doesn't separate and granulate more because it would make it such a cool colour!

  • @rachelconnor2327
    @rachelconnor2327 3 года назад

    I just discovered your videos yesterday, and I love them. They’re so lovely, interesting, and useful. Thanks very much. :)

  • @gwensimmons_gigi1629
    @gwensimmons_gigi1629 6 лет назад +1

    Thanks for the Danny Color Showdown review! 😘👍🏾 Love this series...

    • @OtoKano
      @OtoKano  6 лет назад

      You are so welcome, and thank you for watching the video!

  • @tainadelcaribe
    @tainadelcaribe 6 лет назад +2

    Ok now you’re just taunting me with Daniel Smith goodness! I have issues with purples and teals as in, if I could that would be the color of everything (with some hints of coral and blue here and there). This is such a great duo to compare. I love the Phthalo Turquoise, but the separation of pigments for Ultramarine Turquoise in the gauzing test is just beautiful!!! Why do you have to make my wish list longer?! 🤣 I mean it’s your fault, not mine, that I watch your videos and keep adding and wanting more colors. 🙄

    • @OtoKano
      @OtoKano  6 лет назад +1

      I am totally and utterly happy to be blamed for your shopping list getting longer! :D

  • @ColleenM61
    @ColleenM61 6 лет назад +1

    Whoo hoo! Just as I finished watching the other 3 in this series, sad that I was done (I really wanted more!) I see you uploaded another one! Sighs happily...now on to watch.

    • @OtoKano
      @OtoKano  6 лет назад +1

      I saw your other comment and prayed that you stayed online long enough to catch this video coming out! Enjoy :D

    • @ColleenM61
      @ColleenM61 6 лет назад

      I JUST ordered the Phthalo Turquoise...I see now how much I NEED it :) Thanks!

  • @abontirp3262
    @abontirp3262 6 лет назад

    These two colors are LIFE !!

  • @wulfseig1864
    @wulfseig1864 4 года назад

    I have the Ultramarine Turquoise and forgot about it as well. How funny. I checked my stash after watching this and found it. I don't see any reason to have both since they are both mixes. I try to stay away from mixes. If I like a mix color and use it a lot, like Indigo, I will mix it myself from tubes on my palette. TFS

  • @HaleysArt
    @HaleysArt 5 лет назад +1

    Love this series! I’d like to see a comparison of French ultramarine blue and ultramarine blue, and Italian burnt sienna and burnt sienna! 😊🙏🏻

  • @Spiroffd
    @Spiroffd 6 лет назад +2

    What an excellent series. Now I know that I want to get moon glow and I myself would prefer ultramarine turquoise as I prefer the granulation. I also don’t like how overpowering phylos can be.

    • @OtoKano
      @OtoKano  6 лет назад

      So glad you are enjoying the series. Yes, moon glow is such a lovely color.

  • @CloudslnMyCoffee
    @CloudslnMyCoffee 4 года назад

    I am living for that mix of permanent green and ultramarine turquoise

  • @jittersaunt
    @jittersaunt 5 лет назад

    I would absolutely pick Phthalo Turquoise. I feel like Ultramarine Turquoise is a shade you can easily get from the Phthalo Turquoise. That said, when you showed the blooming....I absolutely love the Ultramarine Turquoise. However, I agree with you that it's not a reason to add it to my palette.

  • @bobbijolane367
    @bobbijolane367 6 лет назад

    Phthalo turquoise is in my top 3 faves too! So yummy! 💙💚

  • @stevesidare2493
    @stevesidare2493 5 лет назад +4

    Try mixing Ult Turq with Napth Maroon. (Deep Blue Grey results)

  • @LanaGoesArt
    @LanaGoesArt 6 лет назад +1

    I love watching your tests. Up untill now, I never had any turquoise in my palette (but was mixing it, when needed), but now I fell, like I really want/need the Phthalo Turquoise. :) Also the sound effects were pretty cool! :D

    • @OtoKano
      @OtoKano  6 лет назад

      Have to say, THIS phthalo turquoise is particularly worth having because it's such a nice shade of turquoise. Personally, it's perfect shade. Hope you enjoy it!

  • @FayeWulf
    @FayeWulf 6 лет назад +1

    I have the Daniel Smith Dot chart but it doesn't have pigment information but I wish it does. The Ultramarine Turquoise is a colour that I mix a lot and use and never knew there was already a mixture out there on the market that would make things a lot more convenient !! I like the more subtle ultramarine granulation in the paint since it is something that is not very common with ultramarines.
    And that gauzing texture of the Phthalo Turquoise really messes with my trypophobia.

    • @OtoKano
      @OtoKano  6 лет назад +1

      Faye, try this document, it's the DS chart with all the pigment info on each color: www.dropbox.com/s/alvgoxmvb6pauwm/251WColor1217.pdf?dl=0
      Yes, definitely avoid doing the gauzing if you have typophobia!

    • @FayeWulf
      @FayeWulf 6 лет назад

      Oh my... Gosh. You're just full of information and resources!!! ♥️♥️♥️

  • @ChristinaTodd1970
    @ChristinaTodd1970 6 лет назад

    I like them both but prefer the color of the phthalo over the ultramarine. That said, phthalo colors scare me because they are so staining and leave little room for error. I don’t have either of these on my palette, but i do have cobalt turquoise which is a different color entirely. If i had to pick between these two you’ve shown, i would pick the phthalo even though its a staining color.

  • @Dan.B.Artist
    @Dan.B.Artist 6 лет назад +1

    I haven't used turquoise colours very much, I should try and explore colours I don't use. You should try Tia from Eventually Everything Mixes it's PG50 with a black pigment it has beautiful granulation and feel it would work really well with your gauze technique! Seeing the colours in this video has given me an idea......

  • @Chen-sl9ev
    @Chen-sl9ev 2 года назад

    thanks for sharing! Curious though, what is it that you are using for testing gauze? Some sort of net?

  • @MissRuthina
    @MissRuthina 5 лет назад

    Are you still doing the colour showdown? If you are, would you be able to do cobalt teal blue and sleeping beauty turquoise? Or, if you think there are two even more similar.
    I've been swatching and swatching from the dotcard and genuinely just don't know which one I like more.

  • @fufufuaru
    @fufufuaru 3 года назад

    with the addition of phthalo blue turquoise in the DS line, i wonder how it compares to these two

  • @Turbogittan
    @Turbogittan 6 лет назад +1

    I love your videos 😍 Thank you very much 🤗

    • @OtoKano
      @OtoKano  6 лет назад

      you are so welcome, thank you for watching it!

  • @tashak8946
    @tashak8946 2 года назад

    How did you make your test sheets? I tried sending watercolor paper through a printer without any success. Please advise.

  • @MedaHalmaciu
    @MedaHalmaciu 6 лет назад +3

    Very useful. I can't afford DS and I just bought 53 Holbein tubes, but I think I would prefer ultramarine turquoise just because I like the way it looks more

    • @OtoKano
      @OtoKano  6 лет назад

      So you finished the list? What colours did you go for? (it's okay if the list is too long to type out, please don't worry.) Really hope you enjoy all those yummy colors.

    • @MedaHalmaciu
      @MedaHalmaciu 6 лет назад +1

      I had to, although at a certain point I was tempted to take the preselected 60 color box. I chose lots of colors I liked even if they were mixes or opaque, I also chose lots of toxic ones like cadmiums and cobalts, lots of pyrols and some essentials that I use a lot of like ultramarine. I chose the sigle pigments out of 2 similar colors like the imidasolones and isoindolones over the permanent yellows. I had to give up most of the earth tones that I don't use a lot anyways and I also got some crazy colors like cad green light and compose green. They should get here tomorrow. I'll let you know how I like them.

    • @OtoKano
      @OtoKano  6 лет назад +1

      woooo you got such a lovely wide range of colours. Nice! I really like the imidaz and Iso yellows, they are so luminous on paper. I really hope you enjoy playing with them!

  • @layercakearts
    @layercakearts 6 лет назад +50

    Oh stop already! Now you're just my watercolor crack dealer, color decadence in every video. Swoon.... ; )

    • @OtoKano
      @OtoKano  6 лет назад +3

      lmao ha ha I am your color dealer!!

    • @layercakearts
      @layercakearts 6 лет назад +9

      haha yes soon we will be meeting in the parking lot for some old school out of stock quin gold.... "ppssssst, hey how about some PB49, it's good stuff"

    • @jittersaunt
      @jittersaunt 5 лет назад +2

      @@layercakearts I completely agree!!! I could watch her compare colors all day!!!!

    • @HaleysArt
      @HaleysArt 5 лет назад +1

      Hahaha love it!! Too funny!

  • @sorsofia
    @sorsofia 6 лет назад

    Phthalo turquoise is on my wish list.

  • @caitlinjeanne
    @caitlinjeanne 6 лет назад +1

    This is a super useful comparison, thank you! Recently I'm finding that turquoise (different brand, PG15:3 + PG7) is a really magical mixing color and reaching for it more and more often these days. It used to go totally ignored on my palette. Now I've been looking at turquoises in other brands so this comparison of phthalo vs. ultramarine is a great resource. :)

    • @OtoKano
      @OtoKano  6 лет назад +1

      So glad this was useful for you. I've tried a few different phthalo turquoise and personally this one is my favourite. I find the other brands have a little bit more greener mixes.

  • @artistjoh
    @artistjoh 2 года назад

    With such beautiful cobalt turquoises available I do not understand why there is any need to use these less lightfast versions.
    i would be more interested if someone made a turquoise out of Ultramarine green with a green shade Ultramarine blue. It would be a weaker tinting strength color, but should be an excellent granulating color.
    However, the beauty of the new Deep Sea Green in the Schmincke super granulating range suggests that a turquoise made from PB29 and PG18 is the perfect way to go. High lighfastness plus all the the transparency of ultramarine and viridian with their ability to granulate makes that mix the ideal color. That Deep Sea Green is simply gorgeous.

  • @MissRuthina
    @MissRuthina 5 лет назад

    A video on phthalo green BS and phthalo green YS?
    I already have phthalo green BS in my pallet. I really love mixing this colour with pretty much anything. I feel like neither of these colours are really... Appealing enough to justify buying it when I feel like mixing phthalo green BS with phthalo blue GS makes a colour I like more. Like. Even if I wanted to be lazy I could premix them on my palette; by which, I mean squirting some of each onto either side of the pan and seeing what mixture I get each time. Lol

  • @MarvYulia
    @MarvYulia 6 лет назад +2

    Very good, you do incredible work.

    • @OtoKano
      @OtoKano  6 лет назад

      So glad you like it :D

  • @dljmka
    @dljmka 6 лет назад +1

    Thank you for another great comparison! ❤

    • @OtoKano
      @OtoKano  6 лет назад

      You are so welcome :D

  • @anam00090
    @anam00090 6 лет назад +1

    Hi Oto. Have you tested Schmincke's Prussian Green? It's a mix of PB60 and PG7, not quite Phthalo mix (pigment-wise) but is quite strong as well. Would be great to know how different it is from these two... I don't even know why I need this many blues and turquoises, recently saw your Kremer Ultramarine Green swatch and am officially in love with that one too. They all mix differently as well and I keep having 6-7 blues on my palette :/

    • @OtoKano
      @OtoKano  6 лет назад +2

      No I haven't tried it yet. I'm not as well versed in Schmincke as I am with Holbein and DS. I know what you mean about the blues on the palette, in my new one I have like 6??? Why do I need 6?

    • @anam00090
      @anam00090 6 лет назад +2

      The only one I gave up (no more space on the palette) was Sennelier Indigo and everyday I look at the tube thinking I'm missing out 😔

    • @OtoKano
      @OtoKano  6 лет назад +2

      I did exactly this for my last palette and regretted it the whole time. I'm firmly putting indigo back into my new palette.

  • @zlee11
    @zlee11 6 лет назад +1

    What is the "Jacksons" website to which you keep referring?

    • @OtoKano
      @OtoKano  6 лет назад

      It's an art supplies store online. www.jacksonsart.com/?acc=46ba9f2a6976570b0353203ec4474217&___store=jacksonsart_en

  • @CloudslnMyCoffee
    @CloudslnMyCoffee 4 года назад

    So ph turq is Pth bl gr and pth gr y. Ultra turq is ultramarine blue andpth green blue

  • @davef85
    @davef85 6 лет назад

    What exactly is gauzing? I’ve never heard of that technique before?

    • @OtoKano
      @OtoKano  6 лет назад

      ruclips.net/video/BFfU4ON3ch4/видео.html first technique in the video will show you what gauzing is.