BTW - I've written HF corporate and suggested a shop / workbench stool with that same seat. Their other options too weak for my liking. I'm down to 245 from 330, but I still buy like it's supporting my former weight.
That’s a sound observation…although…the item name is literally: “ICON Professional Adjustable Shop Seat with Tool Storage”. If the casters were better on the Dewalt stool…I’d just put the Icon seat on it and call it a day.
I've been using the Icon seat for about a month now. On day one I did not like the casters. I replaced them with ones from a company called Shop Skates. In my case I went with smaller wheels but the difference is night and day from the OEM casters.
Just bought one and in the same boat. Guy it home and was like hey this is comfy but stiff at casters. Had the red Pittsburgh but its retired . Been using an ikea adinrok no cushion but tall enough and back rest is needed
I’d love to do it but they’re just not on my radar due to the absolutely ridiculous price point. Even at half the cost they would be the most expensive chairs in this space.
Right. All these other stools can get nearly as low. I’ve also found that the min and max heights that most of these brands market theirs stools with….are totally inaccurate. Which is why I was hoping this was taller.
@@DemoDad101And are EASILY changeable. Danged site cheaper than a $600 stool. I have the Dewalt. I’m fine with it. Might upgrade the casters. Might not. I keep my floor pretty debris free.
$600 for a seat? That’s outrageous! Until you look at that pneumatic one that lifts you from creeper position up to chair height. Thanks for the review. For me none of them go low enough. Since I work off of jack stands.
Great video and personally the low seats are great for working on cars which is what most people would use it for. I bought one of those dewalt seats and returned it after a few days because it was so terrible, it was easy to tip over with its narrow base and being so tall, too tall in my opinion for working on most equipment. The seat was very terrible and casters were garbage but otherwise it was pretty sturdy built. I was wondering what are the brand of those white and stainless cabinets that you have all over in the background. I have the gladiator garage works kind but i personally haven’t seen the ones you have. Pretty cool
![Made in the USA | Vyper Chair - Best Shop Stool You'll Ever Buy! [Elevated Height]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/nN89vw3ST2I/mqdefault.jpg)
![Made in the USA | Vyper Chair - Best Shop Stool You'll Ever Buy! [Elevated Height]](/img/tr.png)
This is the exact type of comparison review i was searching for. Thank you for the video!
I’m glad you found it helpful!
I like mine. Had it for 6 mos or so. It's a mechanics seat, not a shop stool, so I don't expect it to be high enough to be able to work at my bench.
BTW - I've written HF corporate and suggested a shop / workbench stool with that same seat. Their other options too weak for my liking. I'm down to 245 from 330, but I still buy like it's supporting my former weight.
That’s a sound observation…although…the item name is literally: “ICON Professional Adjustable Shop Seat with Tool Storage”. If the casters were better on the Dewalt stool…I’d just put the Icon seat on it and call it a day.
I've been using the Icon seat for about a month now. On day one I did not like the casters. I replaced them with ones from a company called Shop Skates. In my case I went with smaller wheels but the difference is night and day from the OEM casters.
I will have to look into that. I’m sure it’s better than trying to make one good stool out of three decent ones lol.
Just bought one and in the same boat. Guy it home and was like hey this is comfy but stiff at casters.
Had the red Pittsburgh but its retired . Been using an ikea adinrok no cushion but tall enough and back rest is needed
It’s a decent seat. It’s pretty “tippy” though.
I wish you would do comparison between the viper chair and all the other chairs I've been looking at the viper chair and I just can't justify $600
I’d love to do it but they’re just not on my radar due to the absolutely ridiculous price point. Even at half the cost they would be the most expensive chairs in this space.
Try out viper, I’m in the same boat rn and have been watching vids nonstop on those seats, hard to compete
I’m close to buying one. Need to give the Icon chair a little more time though.
@@DemoDad101 I am too, but seeing if any can compete, hence finding your vid. I hope it works out well you either way!
You are expecting the stool to perform a function it was not designed for. There is a reason it was built so low.
Right. All these other stools can get nearly as low. I’ve also found that the min and max heights that most of these brands market theirs stools with….are totally inaccurate. Which is why I was hoping this was taller.
Did you try sticking the ram/seat from the HF onto the DeWalt base?
The casters on the dewalt base suck.
@@DemoDad101And are EASILY changeable. Danged site cheaper than a $600 stool. I have the Dewalt. I’m fine with it. Might upgrade the casters. Might not. I keep my floor pretty debris free.
$600 for a seat? That’s outrageous!
Until you look at that pneumatic one that lifts you from creeper position up to chair height.
Thanks for the review. For me none of them go low enough. Since I work off of jack stands.
I agree. However, Over the last 8 years... I've spent probably about that much trying to find a cheap stool that works well.
Put the seat on the Dewalt seat stand the post looked the same size
The only problem with that is that the dewalt casters are the absolute worst!
Great video and personally the low seats are great for working on cars which is what most people would use it for. I bought one of those dewalt seats and returned it after a few days because it was so terrible, it was easy to tip over with its narrow base and being so tall, too tall in my opinion for working on most equipment. The seat was very terrible and casters were garbage but otherwise it was pretty sturdy built. I was wondering what are the brand of those white and stainless cabinets that you have all over in the background. I have the gladiator garage works kind but i personally haven’t seen the ones you have. Pretty cool
I’ll be doing a video on those cabinets soonish.
@@DemoDad101 ok thanks
Nice review. Mite have to give that a try now
Thank you for watching! I'm pleased with this stool. I think the best solution is to have a stool for the bench and a stool for work on the lift.
Nice seat
It’s not bad. Very comfortable. Wish it rolled better. You also can’t lean over much as it topples easily.
Were you able to get it as tall as the DeWalt stool? I need thet height with a comfortable seat
I left it alone. I do find it a little tippy already so I don’t know if it would be wise to raise the center of gravity.
@@DemoDad101 appreciate the response, looks like I'm not going to get this one
How much was the member only deal?
It was $86.
get the viper chair, you will never buy another chair again, time and money saved, problem is you will want another LOL
Just swap the seats icon DeWalt hybrid
The Dewalt has terrible casters
how bout just putting the harbor freight seat on the Dewalt base?
I would but the casters are a nightmare on the Dewalt base.
Drop the seat on the other stool.
I would still be left with terrible casters on the Dewalt base.