The 1975 Gets Malaysian Festival Cancelled |
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 25 июл 2023
- Was halting Good Vibes Festival a necessary action? Why Malaysian queers don't rise up and fight? How much should artistes meddle with affairs of the country?
The Daily Ketchup Podcast is powered by Audio-Technica.
Get $10 off selected microphones from the AT20 series with ‘TDKAT10’ at sea.audio-technica.com
Get up to $30 off at Ergotune with promo code "22+TDK": ergotune.com/?ref=TDK
Get up to $45 off at EverDesk+ with promo code "22+TDK": everdeskplus.com/?ref=TDK
Subscribe for more content like this: bit.ly/dailyketchup
We're also on Spotify: bit.ly/dailyketchupSpot
If you have any stories to share, let us know here: forms.gle/XRRtnMG1w56M8yrFA
For business/sponsorship enquiries: singapore.sales@grvty.media
Work with us : grvty.media/careers
Be part of our projects : Stay tuned ;)
=====
Follow Us On Our Socials
• Facebook: / mosg.tv
• Instagram: / dailyketchup
• Website: mosg.tv
Cast:
• Shermane Wong / justshermz
• Daniel Lim / danlim11
• Jonathan Paul / jonathanpaul.sxw
• Denise Oh / ohthedenise
Behind the Cam:
• Julian Chin
• Daren Khek
• Amirul Nashtrie
Edited by:
Shermane Wong
Nabil Abdul Latiff 
Развлечения
Seeing how some ppl here saying that the Malaysian government is wrong to stop the whole show, i think they're missing one of the important point. THE LETTER signed by both the band mgmt and also the organizer with the government.
That letter since it is also signed by the organizer most likely included the risk of the immediate stop of the event if the clause was broken (don't be naive, government sure have a clause else for what sign the document). As mentioned before, the government did not approve the performance for 1975 until both the band mgmt and organizer seek for help and the current government being the more liberal one gave way by making them sign this document. So, either the organizer could have just mic killed and kicked the fella off stage immediately when he start doing stupid things, else face the consequences that comes along for their failure to keep him under control within the country's norms.
Do understand, partial of us in Malaysia are liberal ppl, but we also know the need to be smart enough to know to play along the borderline when in public. Conservatives are growing in power in Malaysian politics due to the wrong reasons, and what Matt Healy had done is just a disservice to the path that the current government is trying to pave to a better Malaysia.
JP was so point on on his comments.
I believe if this were to happen in Singapore, the authorities would do something too. My man was literally walking into a foreign country and thrashing the country’s government on stage which is pretty rude ..?
Well, I think imprisoning your own citizens for their sexual preferences is pretty rude too but maybe that’s just me
Singapore wouldn't cancel the entire festival though. Seems most of the backlash comes from the cancellation, including it amplifying the response to what Matty Healy did. They should have just kicked out 1975 and banned them from Malaysia then let the rest of the festival continue, instead they've really damaged a lot of confidence that local contributors to these kinds of festivals will have in doing them in the future alongside foreign contributors and visitors more generally. Malaysia is already underrated as a tourist destination, this reaction will make it even worse.
@@hw985a out govt probably wouldn't have cancelled the entire festival if it isn't for our upcoming state elections. Times are a bit sensitive, so as much as most of us locals are disappointed, we sort of understand.
@hw985a well I agree with you on this matter they could’ve handled the situation better with minimal damage but at the same time they mainly got cancelled because of the insensitive comments they made on stage. Personally I don’t think things would get this bad if what they did was just kissed on stage. TBH I don’t think Malaysians is that conservative in the city,mainly just the suburban area with overly religious people..😢
Plus do mind that the state election is just around the corner…..they’re probably also trying to not upset the “religious” people lmao…
i really appreciate the fact that there is someone like jon paul on the panel of a podcast that is sort of acting as the devil’s advocate in this scenario, being willing to openly share his views despite the potential backlash he might receive. it genuinely gives the discussion alot more depth and opportunity to dig deeper into the issue to make the discussion more interesting. keep it up jon paul🙂👍🏻
they should know the laws of the land before doing anything risky
Lol, everyone is claiming how harsh the laws are against the LGBTQ community in Malaysia. Let me tell you the reality of what is happening in real life, you can be LGBTQ in Malaysia and no one will bother you if you keep it to yourself or in your circle, as long as you do not preach it in public. There are few trans people in the condo I live in and we always have small talk in the lift, etc. I may not agree with their actions, but I still respect them as human beings as long as they respect the community as well.
The way I laughed out loud when Speak Now and She’s American came up 😂
WELL DONE TDK 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
For the knowledge of the people of Singapore 🦁 before they wanted to do a concert in Malaysia, Malaysia already rejected the 1975 because of the bad background after that they plead to the the government to come and the government gave a letter of agreement on what can be done and what can't be done they agreed, suddenly on stage they reneged on the agreement, now muslim countries like egypt they also cancel travis scott and 1975 is also canceled in jakarta and taiwan now singers always bring diseases to spread in people's countries
Been wanting to listen to this!! Good job guys for genuinely discuss the topic! Love the openness and more in-depth of your guys opinion on this issues!! Btw Jon paul slayy~
Well said Jon Paul, the discussion of 24:45 onwards can be summarized to ""A paradigm of hypocrisy in the realm of liberty manifests when an individual engages in unconventional conduct by actively suppressing or undermining divergent belief systems.""
End of the day if ur performing at other pples country then u jolly well respect their law
Which law tho?
The syariah law? Or the outdated law passed down during the British colony period when homosexual is thought to still be curable?
If the laws were true and enforceable then 40k of Malaysian males out of 17m population would need to be imprisoned assuming that around 5% of the male population is not strictly heterosexual according to social studies.
The outdated law needs to be repealed just as many commonwealth countries have done, but it takes time.
The issue is more on the comments Matty Healy made about the government without sufficient understanding in the ruling party that had only recently took charge.
omg the troy and abed COMMUNITY reference at the start!!!
Cool. Cool cool cool 😉
We can't really label LGBT issues as being western or asian/eastern.
Just speaking about homosexual relationships, large empires like China and Japan have had history of same sex relationships (in fact it is all over the world).
It did not have to do with moral or anything because that is Natural since ancient times.
It was in fact westernization when a lot of countries were colonized where the anti homosexual laws were then enforced in many countries to enact control on the colonized.
These laws are not traditional, not natural, and it was definitely not a norm for people who do not practice the respective religion sects to be restricted in such a way.
It is natural for these colonial laws that goes against human nature to be removed after we gained independence and when the doctors stopped diagnosing non-heterosexual preference to be an illness.
However, many governments then again have kept these laws/statute to control the population (encourage birth rates and treating their people like livestock), or to the favor of the major conservative religious groups.
As the majority of the people are getting more educated with more information and knowledge accessible through the internet, laws that infringes human rights are bound to be removed in time.
We can't call this westernization. It is simply a revolution that follows the emergence of internet, development of technology and medical researches.
The process doesn't happen overnight, and it will take time, and lots of time in a country which is more controlled by religious conservatives that politicize these issues to their advantage.
If 2 within 100 males in a population is identified as a homosexual, and 3~5 are identified as bisexuals, we will have about 5% of the male populations who are not strictly heterosexual.
If we have 15m male population in a country, that would account for up to 750,000 individuals. Lets say 5% of them has decided to leave for a country that are more LGBT friendly, the country will lose 37,500 talents to more accepting countries. More if we were to account for females and families who decided to migrate for an environment which is healthier for the heart and soul.
In this era where countries compete among each other with GDP as the main factor, once the government and political parties realize how much talents in the workforce they are losing, change will definitely set its foot in; or well, they can continue to let the conservatives stay in power and try getting more FTs in to replace the local talents they've lost, and yeah countries that imports these talents would continue to stay overjoyed.
Is it westernization now because look how western bring it to everyworld, every aspect, not related like sports, entertainment,etc. SO its quite annoying
Will the festival take place next year?
Hey TDK crew!
Thats why, in politics, democracy's flaw is not everyone in the population made critical and good decision.. Not everyone is self aware
Dan pls do the peanut bar rap, will comment for algo
Hahahahahah is that the one where the Dean starts crying halfway??
Algooooooooooooooooooo
Libertarianism sounds like a good idea on paper, but it has very unrealistic assumptions for it to work such as "private companies can takeover the role of helping poorer people via charity".
I didn't get to see the strokes because of 1975. Thank you Ratty Healy.
was the cut on 0:20 a reference to 1975 😂😂
Puking, spitting, smashed someone's drone, alcohol & cigarettes are not allowed on stage especially during performance in Malaysia. He & media keep connecting this incident through kissing acts with 🌈 community. Now the government / politician got a strong point using this as bad example for future event denial & cancel this community.
OMG DAN KNOWS THE RAP BY TROY AND ABED FROM COMMUNITY!!!!
Troy and Abed in the mooooorning!
Same tattoo? What relationship relationship are they?
1975 who?
Sherm said almost nothing in this episode😢. Come on guys let her talk haha
Compared to earlier podcasts, It is a better nuanced political conversation
I think the depth of thinking is not quite there, but it is improving massively as the podcast goes on
Good job!
Wiki says that he was born with ADSD. Could that have contributed to his personality the way it is now?
Malaysia chose to become a signatory to the United Nations Universal Declaration of Human Rights. The band was right to call out Malaysia's hypocrisy for not doing what it agreed to and stop discriminating against people based on their sexuality.
RESPECT somebody law. Is it hard? trans in malaysia actually rich, always work in various field.come on
😂
People who don't even live in Malaysia "knows everything" in the comment section 😂 funny shit. Welp, that's American mentality for sure.
One thing's for sure, few Malaysians understand how the country works. Take the workshy Malays for example, they actually believe the country belongs to them.
W Malaysia Government
ALGOOOOO
Sherms so cute!!! 😂😂
08:51 Ai Yae Yae Yae Yae - Power Ranger ruclips.net/video/h82S00EB5pc/видео.html
1. It's wrong of Anwar to apply a blanket ban on the whole music festival. It hurts many innocent parties. It's very unfair. In fact, people should sue the government for this injustice.
2. It’s wrong of Anwar to compete with PN in being more conservative. Anwar can never win PN in this. It’s a dead end. And worse, it would make Malaysia more conservative and make PH lose more votes in future.
3. LGBT communities and cultures exist in Asian societies before the arrival of Westerners. Some emperors in China were gay/bisexuals. Homosexuality was viewed as ordinary and accepted in society for most of Chinese history.
4. Islamic fundamentalist politicians want to ban public music performances and movies, but such public performances have been part of the Malay tradition and culture and existed even before the arrival of Islam. So aren’t the Islamic fundamentalists trying to erode and eradicate local culture?
5. Many Islamic fundamentalists are hypocrites. In fact, many have been caught following the IG and Twitter of sexy girls and porn stars and saving photos of sexy girls and porn in their phones. The religion police should surveil and catch these hypocritical PAS politicians first before they catch anyone else, eg, by installing cameras in the bedrooms of these politicians on Islamic holy days to make sure they practice what they preach: you shall not have sex during Islamic holy days, and also check their phones and computers regularly to make sure that they don’t surf porn. We can let this be an opt-in kind of thing: those who want an Islamic fundamentalist life can opt in to these surveillances. Apply this fundamentalist way of life onto the fundamentalists themselves first, before trying to dictate it onto other people.
6. In Malaysia, two mutually consenting adult men kissing is not ok, but child marriage and rape are ok?
Your comments make sense, but not in this imperfect mixed up world/nation.
There's no 1 step out of their current mindset for the conservative Malaysians, change takes time.
You can't simply undo what has been imprinted into one's mind for over for more than 50 years.
well two things to be mad at.
1) Matty overstepped yes, he is rude and gross.
2) The msian govt shouldnt close the wholeeee event, mistakes after mistakes.
Way i see it, hate on matty for his douchey actions sure, but artists always display such things without ANY repercussions. Eg Lady gaga in russia. And shes deemed as a hero. But why not him? because of his questionable, RUDE behaviour at the start.
Msian govt closing whole even to me simpily proved matty's point. t]That the gvt dont care about his people. LGBT or the hard working vendors that went down to makign a living. Either way, totallllly a bad call. You can't blame the 1975 for making the govt close the whole event. its the govt call. not coz of 1975 action.
I feel musician should stay out of politics or if they wanna be involve don't let it be obvious but subtle through their artforms
If they just wanna make money, I agree.
However note that pop culture/music is usually made and coincide with the current issues affecting the livelihood of the people, politic or not.
You guys talk a lot about Malaysia issue but when it come to sensitivity of law and religions, better to have someone who really Malaysian and a lawyer and someone from that mentioned religion and also representative from LGBTQ themselves. This is really one sided.
Seems like you are new to this podcast. One of the host is a Malaysian,another one is lesbian so I think it's quite representable. They are being moderate which is majority of the viewer are.
They are not really talking about the law so having a lawyer there is totally not suitable. Malaysia and Indonesia is muslim majority country ,most Asians will know that those 2 countries are more conservative than others.. oh Brunei is also very conservative.
Dan is a Malaysian and Denise is part of the LGBTQ community, so...
Yes I also agree this episode was quite one sided.....they should've get someone that actually went to the music festival maybe. Plus Dan left Malaysia like years and years ago please...
It’s ok u tried 😅
Have you see the dogs doing it in the open …… if you do the same …… you are just like the dogs …..
do what ? kiss ? holding hands ? hand over shoulder ?
lmao, PDA only, not sex in public