I think Eli Manning should be a SECOND-year inductee, not First-Ballot First-ballot should be reserved for the Tom Brady's, the Deion Sanders, the Walter Payton's of the world Eli had two seasons where he over-achieved, which is one more season than Joe Flacco Winning 2 Super Bowls, and owning Tom Brady, definitely gets you in, but let's calm down.....
As a Giants fan him being first ballot is ridiculous. The two playoff runs were really good. But just ignoring the stretch es of years where he led the league in interceptions and the giants being flat out bad is silly.
Eli Manning's fault that he's 117 and 117, but then Steve and I will say the defense is the reason they won those games so which one is it is it the defense that hurt Eli, or is it Eli fault
lol huh, he had the 25th ranked defense for one of those super bowls and until mahomes he had the most passing yards in a single season (reg + post) in nfl history with over 5,000
@@mattr1100that defense held the unbeaten patriots that was putting 35 points a game and held them til 10 he’ll yeah it was defense primarily the defensive line Eli made a couple good throws but eli is not a hall of famer
No you're not going to get away with that, so he's saying the defense won a lot of games, but then he says Eli Manning is a 117 and 117 quarterback, and says Eli Manning only made the playoffs in 6 out of his 16 seasons so which one is it
Eli to me isn’t one of the best QBs to ever play the game…. Man I think the HOF is starting to go in a direction where this is who we have to pick from and in Eli case it does look like he’s going to get in first ballot…. Deion 100 on levels to this
Eli Manning's legacy is a very, very poor man's version of Kawhi Leonard's in the NBA really if you think about it. Steps up in the biggest moments come playoff time, but whether because of health or just not being consistent enough, there's a lack of a consistent great body of work season after season. The big difference with these guys is that Kawhi Leonard has multiple seasons where he was legit elite in the regular season AND playoffs to the point where some argued he was the very best at one point. When was that ever Eli Manning ?
Outside the two runs Eli was a below average quarterback if we being objectively honest he missed the playoffs 10 years and led the league in picks 3 times and was 500 qb
He was a slightly above average QB and was never considered a top 5 QB not even once in any season he played in.Like if your going to be anything at least be for real
What team went into a regular season game saying oh crap that's Eli Manning? He wasn't feared at all or ever considered a elite qb. I agree with Stephen A hall of famer yes, but not a lock
Stephen A is actually right on this one 🏈 😅
He's wrong actually
He’s definitely wrong
I think Eli Manning should be a SECOND-year inductee, not First-Ballot
First-ballot should be reserved for the Tom Brady's, the Deion Sanders, the Walter Payton's of the world
Eli had two seasons where he over-achieved, which is one more season than Joe Flacco
Winning 2 Super Bowls, and owning Tom Brady, definitely gets you in, but let's calm down.....
He beat Brady head to head twice
@@darioramirez1009 I said that. That doesn't make you first ballot.
It just gets you in. You have to do other things great to be firsts ballot.
He's first ballot no question
Doesn't even make sense to say this. You think he deserves the votes or not?
@itzaiden1239 no he's not.
If Eli gets in Romo, Palmer, Rivers, Stafford, Ryan, Flacco, needs to get in.
SA is spot on. He gets the nod cuz hes got 2 rings but his stats do matter and eli was simply average his whole career
If Eli gets in than Tony Romo needs to get in also because Romo too me was better. Playoffs wise Eli was elite
Tony No-Mo didn't even sniff a Super Bowl 😅😅😅😅.
@@rodneywilliams590 still better than Eli overall
Molly, “He’s top 11 in passing yards!” Who the F says top 11. Maaaaaaaan!!! Eli is NOT a first ballot.
Helll no! He was never a top 5 QB.
You should look at the stats before you comment. 4th in the league in passing yards in 2011, 1st Drew Brees 2nd Tom Brady 3rd Matt Stafford 4th Eli. 😂
If TERRELL OWENS HAD TO WAIT THEN ELI NEEDS TO AS WELL!!
Let’s be honest Eli really he won 2 rings because of his defense
SAS needs to have a Lebron graphic when it comes to Eli Manning 😂😂😂
As a Giants fan him being first ballot is ridiculous. The two playoff runs were really good. But just ignoring the stretch es of years where he led the league in interceptions and the giants being flat out bad is silly.
Not first ballot but absolutely yes hall of famer
He gets in but I don't think he should be first ballot. He had 2 insanely good seasons while the others were mediocre.
Eli Manning's fault that he's 117 and 117, but then Steve and I will say the defense is the reason they won those games so which one is it is it the defense that hurt Eli, or is it Eli fault
He should get in the HoF, but not first ballot…for the very few times, I do agree with SAS on this one
dan just put derek jeter and eli manning in the same sentence what the hell is this take🤦🏽♂️
He won those Super Bowls because of his defense
lol huh, he had the 25th ranked defense for one of those super bowls and until mahomes he had the most passing yards in a single season (reg + post) in nfl history with over 5,000
I didn't see the defense throw bombs to Tyree or Manningham, or a TD pass to Plaxico Burress
Yes & no. He made plays too bro
The most casual of takes 😂😂
@@mattr1100that defense held the unbeaten patriots that was putting 35 points a game and held them til 10 he’ll yeah it was defense primarily the defensive line Eli made a couple good throws but eli is not a hall of famer
Stephen A is right not first ballot
Stephen A is on the spot Eli won 2 super bowls but he is not elite
His defense won a lot of games
No you're not going to get away with that, so he's saying the defense won a lot of games, but then he says Eli Manning is a 117 and 117 quarterback, and says Eli Manning only made the playoffs in 6 out of his 16 seasons so which one is it
Can't tell the story of the nfl with out mentioning eli manning
No doubt. Beat Brady twice on the highest stage.
Yes siiir!!
Eli beat Brady and Belichick...in the Super Bowl TWICE...1st ballot HOF...
Eli to me isn’t one of the best QBs to ever play the game…. Man I think the HOF is starting to go in a direction where this is who we have to pick from and in Eli case it does look like he’s going to get in first ballot…. Deion 100 on levels to this
Dan clearly wasnt really for it, but he has to be on the "for" side
Eli Manning's legacy is a very, very poor man's version of Kawhi Leonard's in the NBA really if you think about it. Steps up in the biggest moments come playoff time, but whether because of health or just not being consistent enough, there's a lack of a consistent great body of work season after season. The big difference with these guys is that Kawhi Leonard has multiple seasons where he was legit elite in the regular season AND playoffs to the point where some argued he was the very best at one point. When was that ever Eli Manning ?
If eli gets in then jim plunkett deserve it too
Dan is sooo wrong!!!!
So is Molly like wtf
He's not 1st ballot. Stop it
Absolutely not. I agree with SAS
Dudes not even a HOF honestly
Outside the two runs Eli was a below average quarterback if we being objectively honest he missed the playoffs 10 years and led the league in picks 3 times and was 500 qb
I mean come on Stephen A is right, Eli was great but idk about lock! A HOF yes but 1st ballot idk
Tom Brady bid for undefeated season or patriots cause I didn't no he played all 11 positions on offense and defense
Hell no
Hate to tell steven a but he is a manning first ballot watch steven a a hater😂😂😂😂😂
He was a slightly above average QB and was never considered a top 5 QB not even once in any season he played in.Like if your going to be anything at least be for real
What team went into a regular season game saying oh crap that's Eli Manning? He wasn't feared at all or ever considered a elite qb. I agree with Stephen A hall of famer yes, but not a lock