@Shen Shouting Xiaoting its tiring how agencies work with the role they give to the members. We have main vocalist like Mia, who sings always half of the song alone, or like Jihyo, Rosé and now Ningning, who are the main and there's always a lead vocalist who sings more than them. Waiting for a group with a main vocalist who actual has more lines but not exaggerating
Giselle: rap > vocals > dance Karina: dance > vocal > rap Winter: vocals > dance > rap Ningning: vocals > rap = dance Rap: Giselle > Karina > Ning = Winter (idk why people love winter as a rapper she’s not that good she just has a nice tone and so does Ning(I think it’s mostly cause winter raps more) they’re both equal for me tho. Dance: Karina > winter > Giselle > Ning Most people put Ning higher than Giselle and that’s fair but Giselle is more controlled and fluid while Ning just has more power. Vocals: Ning > winter > Giselle = Karina Most people put Karina higher than Giselle but it’s hard to say, Karina gets more vocal chances so it’s hard to equally judge but they both seem equally as good especially from what I heard in ‘savage’. Visual (to the standard): Karina = winter > Ning > Giselle All are beautiful
@@crmf Have to disagree dance wise, Giselle has better dynamics and doesn’t overcompensate by applying power (Ning does this) so a lot of people underestimate her actual technique. Her and Ning are pretty different dancers tho but Giselle has slightly better body control. Her moves can come across as not being powerful to the naked eye but she just isn’t gonna hide her lack of power, she lets it show. Giselle’s pops are also better and her lower body but Ning might have better arms however she’s really stiff in her neck through her shoulders (which is something lia from Itzy has problems with too just for comparison). If you want an example look at Ning’s fancam at the beginning of the savage choreo on Karina’s first verse.
@@crmf also some great points! Especially about Giselle’s torso but I still have to disagree. Ning has a tendency to apply too much power that she can make the moves look sloppy or overdoes it, her body control is lacking more than Giselle’s. I have to say Giselle has had less training than the others so she still lacks, she has recently admitted that she learns choreo the slowest but I feel that she’s still good at catching a lot of details, like in savage she’s the only one that touches her knees on the chorus. (Also just have to say some people confuse Ning for a good dancer just cause of her stage presence, not saying u do that just putting it out there) I respect your analysis tho I guess we just have different opinions.
Bruh why everyone complains about her and Winter ranking like tf its only 10sec and Winter could be Main Vocal as well so come on that's not a fucking big deal
@Des Since when its underestimate NingNing vocals when we say that? Since she already have the Main Vocal position how its underestimate that... here its more like u underestimate Winter's vocal
Okay if Aespa has not defined roles then. Karina and Ningning definitely could be main visual of the group. Cause when I comes to Ningrina no touches their face cards.
@@TheCarissa101 But the look is what fits the Korean standards more, Karina and Winter are very much in the standard Ningning no, because if it's for beauty then all should be visual.
![Seungmin "그렇게, 천천히, 우리(As we are)" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/kAzmhLHePqU/mqdefault.jpg)
1. Winter: 259.6 sec
2. Ningning: 248.4 sec
3. Karina: 198.3 sec
4. Giselle: 175.8 sec
Giselle deserves better! She is my 3nd bias!
Bruh the main vocalist should be first
can you do bts,enhypen,txt and stary kids plsssss
🌷-✨😅💖
@Shen Shouting Xiaoting its tiring how agencies work with the role they give to the members. We have main vocalist like Mia, who sings always half of the song alone, or like Jihyo, Rosé and now Ningning, who are the main and there's always a lead vocalist who sings more than them.
Waiting for a group with a main vocalist who actual has more lines but not exaggerating
Ningning is beautiful. She’s really one of the best vocalist in 4th Gen
In kpop***
I thought debut Kpop artists from 2018 and 2019 are 4th gen and then it's 5th gen starting from 2020 debuts.
@@bryanguegan4006it takes 4-5 years for there to be a new generation. 3rd Gen lasted 5-6 years. So will 4th Gen. 4th Gen is on their 3rd yesr
@@K4TSEYE Ok didn't know that.
Ngl she is the best 4th gen vocalist
She's one of the best Vocalist in 4th gen... Btw she's my bias!
She is the best 4th gen vocalist, name someone who is better than her
@@platinumslim6161 well there’s only a few like Nayul and Yechan
@@platinumslim6161 Kim Bora
@@crmf oh ok I didn't know that... Lol
@@platinumslim6161 monday
Ningning is a goddess in vocals, no one in 4th Gen can beat her.
I like NingNing and Winter's vocal, but Winter is my 2nd bias
@Eğlenelim ve Öğrenelim #ytabonelerimiçekme same
i did not put that tagged thing there it is just their name for youtube
I still think yuri is better than ningning....
@@aing9329 technique and octave ningning is way better than her even her tone sound so full compare to yuri
Ningning’s low notes in Dreams Come True really shocked me… such an amazing an versatile main vocalist !
aespa truly have the best vocals in the 4th gen
Ningning is the best 4th gen female vocalist. Argue with the wall 💅✨
Finally We got rapper Ningning
I love her vocal very special idk how to describe 😭
🌷-Ning Ning is not lost! She's a vocal beater!
Ningning vocal queen. ♥
the main vocalist
A common thing I see in groups is one of the or the lead vocalist usually gets the most lines.
This is only title track, in Aespa's all songs, Ningning has most line and lead vocalist is 2nd.
@@yuqisae doesn't winter have the most lines in next level
@@cdy7048 I don't say the Next Level is Winter?
Ranking:
1. DREAMS COME TRUE - 1:03.3 sec
2. SAVAGE - 59:6 sec
3. FOREVER - 54.7 sec
4. NEXT LEVEL - 37.1 sec
5. BLACK MAMBA - 33.4 sec
ALL - 248.4 sec
👑QUEEN NINGNING, WE LOVE YOU❤️
she always completes aespas songs
Ning Yi Zhou (Ningning)
Dreams Come True - 1:03.3
Savage - 59.6
Forever - 54.7
Next Level - 37.1
Black Mamba - 33.4
and Ningning always sing all the background sound
Giselle: rap > vocals > dance
Karina: dance > vocal > rap
Winter: vocals > dance > rap
Ningning: vocals > rap = dance
Rap: Giselle > Karina > Ning = Winter (idk why people love winter as a rapper she’s not that good she just has a nice tone and so does Ning(I think it’s mostly cause winter raps more) they’re both equal for me tho.
Dance: Karina > winter > Giselle > Ning
Most people put Ning higher than Giselle and that’s fair but Giselle is more controlled and fluid while Ning just has more power.
Vocals: Ning > winter > Giselle = Karina
Most people put Karina higher than Giselle but it’s hard to say, Karina gets more vocal chances so it’s hard to equally judge but they both seem equally as good especially from what I heard in ‘savage’.
Visual (to the standard): Karina = winter > Ning > Giselle
All are beautiful
giselles singing in lucid dream >>>>>
@@crmf Have to disagree dance wise, Giselle has better dynamics and doesn’t overcompensate by applying power (Ning does this) so a lot of people underestimate her actual technique. Her and Ning are pretty different dancers tho but Giselle has slightly better body control. Her moves can come across as not being powerful to the naked eye but she just isn’t gonna hide her lack of power, she lets it show. Giselle’s pops are also better and her lower body but Ning might have better arms however she’s really stiff in her neck through her shoulders (which is something lia from Itzy has problems with too just for comparison). If you want an example look at Ning’s fancam at the beginning of the savage choreo on Karina’s first verse.
@@crmf you’re right 100% idk why people think Giselle is a better dancer than Ningning or singer than Karina💀
@@crmf also some great points! Especially about Giselle’s torso but I still have to disagree. Ning has a tendency to apply too much power that she can make the moves look sloppy or overdoes it, her body control is lacking more than Giselle’s. I have to say Giselle has had less training than the others so she still lacks, she has recently admitted that she learns choreo the slowest but I feel that she’s still good at catching a lot of details, like in savage she’s the only one that touches her knees on the chorus. (Also just have to say some people confuse Ning for a good dancer just cause of her stage presence, not saying u do that just putting it out there) I respect your analysis tho I guess we just have different opinions.
dreams come true: 1:03
savage: 59.6
forever: 54.7
next level: 37.1
black mamba: 33.4
Lindo Ningning
In my opinion, I am the most beautiful voice in order
1.ningnig
2.karina
3.winter
4.giselle
And you guys
1 Ning Ning
2 Winter
3 Giselle
4 Karina
you are the most beautiful voice?? what
@@ayame._.what are you say?
winter is better than Karina in vocals
@@ayame._. LOL
The Main Vocalist of Æspa
NingNing most from the last:
1. Dreams Come True
2. Savage
3. Forever
4. Next Level
5. Black Mamba
Queen
The best!
ningning's voice in forever😭 she's an angel
Best 4th gen vocalist 💓💓💓
♡
Can you do Mayna (Hot issue) line distribution with all title tracks and b-sides
Ningning is the ace y'all.
Can you make a tutorial please
Line order of these songs that ningning had in these songs:
1°Dreams come true
2°Savage
3°Forever
4°Next level
5°black mamba
Me: waiting for savage to hit 1min
59.6😳
Aespa lest Line evolition girls 14/20
Do enhypen?and txt?
has de los integrantes de Stray Kids, please
loona line evolution
(G)I-DLE pliss
sao lấy ảnh ning dìm vậy :))))))))))
Where is Loona you said you would post before Aespa 🤔
He/she said that it will come after this video
just wait a few days lol
@@lovicious9812 ok
Bruh why everyone complains about her and Winter ranking like tf its only 10sec and Winter could be Main Vocal as well so come on that's not a fucking big deal
@Des Since when its underestimate NingNing vocals when we say that? Since she already have the Main Vocal position how its underestimate that... here its more like u underestimate Winter's vocal
Okay if Aespa has not defined roles then. Karina and Ningning definitely could be main visual of the group. Cause when I comes to Ningrina no touches their face cards.
@@TheCarissa101 But the look is what fits the Korean standards more, Karina and Winter are very much in the standard Ningning no, because if it's for beauty then all should be visual.
@Des yes. What about real main vocalist Ningning? Fans can complain if they want to.
NO!! NINGNING IS WAY BETTER THAN WINTER!