Ending Welfare as We Knew It | Retro Report

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 31 июл 2024
  • Bill Clinton's 1996 welfare reform was supposed to move needy families off government handouts and out of poverty. Decades later, has it worked? Lesson plan for educators: bit.ly/RR-welfare
    Sign up for a free Retro Report in the Classroom newsletter to receive free teacher resources: retroreport.org/educationnewsl...
    Browse through dozens more lesson plans and videos here: www.retroreport.org/education/
    CONNECT WITH RETRO REPORT
    Website: www.retroreport.org
    Twitter: / retroreport
    Facebook: / retroreport
    Instagram: / retroreport
    RUclips: / retroreport
    Retro Report in the Classroom: www.retroreport.org/education/
    Retro Report Newsletter: www.retroreport.org/newsletters/
    Retro Report is an independent, nonprofit news organization that injects context into today’s discussions of both current events and history. Learn more at RetroReport.org.

Комментарии • 72

  • @justmyopinion9883
    @justmyopinion9883 Год назад +32

    Why was so much attention given to social welfare programs, but very little attention to corporate welfare, bank bailouts etc?

    • @sulimanthemagnificent4893
      @sulimanthemagnificent4893 Год назад +3

      Because... It's socialism (statism) for the banks and hyper capitalism (moneyism) for everyone else.
      Socialism is statism, and the state is always, ALWAYS, used by monied interests unless it's minor states (think Norway).

    • @justmyopinion9883
      @justmyopinion9883 Год назад

      @@sulimanthemagnificent4893 Thank you. Well said.

    • @GTA5Player1
      @GTA5Player1 3 месяца назад

      Don't forget tax evasion by the top 1% which costs US tax payers $150 billion a year!

  • @dantheman4421
    @dantheman4421 8 лет назад +60

    I am disabled. My back was shattered in an automobile accident where I was a passenger. Almost completely wheelchair ridden, and I live in a liberal state, NY. And they still give me a hard time. Things need to change.

  • @HJ-ju4ui
    @HJ-ju4ui 4 года назад +53

    how a country treats their poor population is a direct show of their values

    • @phildegrave9243
      @phildegrave9243 3 года назад

      And they're willingness to commit suicide

    • @devenwithtwoes5856
      @devenwithtwoes5856 2 года назад +1

      Worst case scenario is a horrible thing to focus on .

    • @Skoda130
      @Skoda130 Год назад +3

      @@devenwithtwoes5856 its not a worst case scenario. It's reality.

    • @Roddy556
      @Roddy556 2 месяца назад

      How a person handles their personal finances is a direct show of their competency at life.

  • @mksabourinable
    @mksabourinable 6 лет назад +23

    Meanwhile Canada is starting a minimum guaranteed income pilot....

  • @yvesoberon1153
    @yvesoberon1153 4 года назад +37

    If you want to permanently end poverty in someone's life, you can't simply throw a little money and order them to get a job. You need to restore the educational system; half the adults in Detroit can't read so how are they going to get work without being exploited since they can't read contracts? You need to provide mental health services as many in poverty suffer mental illness - it's dammed depressing and can make you feel hopeless and ineffectual even if you don't have a mental illness. You need to build confidence. Most people can get a job, but can they keep it? Will they sabotage because unconsciously they think they can't hack it? Many people not just the poor do. Wages need to rise dramatically. You cannot live on minimum wage now and that used to support a family of four to buy a home and car. Minimum wage needs to increase. You need to have universal health care so the people who get sick don't drop out or go homeless to pay bills. Our country is failing and we're all in danger not just the poor. We can't expect them to excel while everyone else declines.

    • @RETROREPORT
      @RETROREPORT  4 года назад +4

      You make some very good points

    • @theallseeingeye9388
      @theallseeingeye9388 3 года назад +1

      As a non American, I am taken back when you state that half of detroits adult population cant read.
      Anyone else can confirm this?

  • @gin3868
    @gin3868 5 лет назад +11

    So it would've maybe worked if it had been used by all states to get the poor get trained for jobs, but still, there would need to be a safety net (it obviously needs to influence people to get jobs but also a 1yr time limit when there are no jobs is too little, I feel like it should depend on job availability in the state or that the number of benefits should decrease the more time you're on them) still expecting people not to need Welfare when you allow them to get paid 8$/hr is laughable

    • @Roddy556
      @Roddy556 2 месяца назад

      A work camp type program I could get behind. Broke? Go work for food and housing at a government infrastructure project.

  • @astroemerald3175
    @astroemerald3175 3 года назад +8

    I think welfare needs overhauling . Agreed 100 % . Also , let’s see companies / individuals that pay zero or near zero tax should pay up NOW .

    • @Roddy556
      @Roddy556 2 месяца назад

      So the welfare recipients? Lol

  • @rocknroll368
    @rocknroll368 4 месяца назад +1

    Why do seniors have to work longer before getting social security that they were FORCED TO PAY INTO ALL THEIR WORKING LIVES? Politicians spent the social security funds on Welfare, Wars, Military, illegal immigrants etc.

  • @talyahr3302
    @talyahr3302 Год назад +4

    Universal basic income would really help fix this problem and the mindset behind welfare

    • @Roddy556
      @Roddy556 2 месяца назад

      That just sounds like more welfare.

    • @DKD81-tf1db
      @DKD81-tf1db Месяц назад

      @@Roddy556 Cool story, buddy.

    • @Roddy556
      @Roddy556 Месяц назад

      @@DKD81-tf1db not really a story but okay

  • @LemystereManCarloc
    @LemystereManCarloc 8 лет назад +8

    great videos as always

  • @UserName-ts3sp
    @UserName-ts3sp 3 месяца назад

    the alligator guy… very good point and a great way of articulating it. don’t feed the gators.

  • @onestevewilson
    @onestevewilson 8 лет назад +5

    Great film. Thank you for this!

  • @einavzash
    @einavzash 4 года назад +2

    a lesson to remember

  • @cazu2479
    @cazu2479 Год назад +1

    Thanks Reagan

  • @bobblueford
    @bobblueford 10 месяцев назад +1

    People don't seem to understand that if he had not given in to the republicans at that time, we would have ended up with all three government branches controlled by them in 1997.
    he went too far to the left in his first two years, and that created a backlash that gave republicans full control of the Congress in 1994. By working with them during this time, he managed to win back some of the supporters he had lost in his first two years and evened out the Congress again in 1998.

  • @GTA5Player1
    @GTA5Player1 3 месяца назад +1

    Tax evasion by the top 1% costs the US $163 billion, but yeah... let's focus on some poor mom on welfare! LOGIC

  • @ironmage6105
    @ironmage6105 3 месяца назад

    Old slick Willie Clinton, just don't accept a cigar if he offers one.....musty!

  • @robertmasina7388
    @robertmasina7388 4 месяца назад

    At that time, I say a better word usage should have been "reduce" welfare as we know it rather than "end" welfare.

  • @lamaripiazza5226
    @lamaripiazza5226 3 года назад +1

    9:34 This didn’t age well

  • @lennarthagen3638
    @lennarthagen3638 Год назад +1

    Welfare is like the best thing in the world ever

  • @heavenly2k
    @heavenly2k 4 года назад +3

    I hope Bill Clinton starts picking up my phone calls and finally agrees to do a boxing match with me . I'm so excited to knock him the fuck out but I need to win the right way, in the ring .

  • @jking6736
    @jking6736 5 лет назад +8

    This bill just needs to be reversed. Cool inside it's all because of those evil Republicans they want to take money from the poor and my mom lives off of disability if we lose that buddy that I'm not going to be able to probably eat fully

    • @Celisar1
      @Celisar1 4 года назад +1

      Kyle Mortensen
      If the fathers paid for their children a lot of mothers wouldn’t be in financial difficulties raising their fellow children.

    • @jking6736
      @jking6736 4 года назад

      I just turned 16 a few weeks ago and right now good welfare is what's needed

  • @devenwithtwoes5856
    @devenwithtwoes5856 2 года назад

    Welfare to work allowed welfare department access to the family court system by means of court connect nonprofit organizations, hospitals, Social workers . Bill C knew exactly what doors he was opening. These public assistance Departments need people on welfare . From a business perspective the people welfare are the CLIANT. they are doing whatever they need to do to get their product to their clients . Like any business would .

  • @darthstarkiller6605
    @darthstarkiller6605 5 лет назад +4

    You should be forced to take randomized drug test if you want to be on welfare

    • @yvesoberon1153
      @yvesoberon1153 4 года назад +9

      No one wants to be on welfare.

    • @agroteraaaa
      @agroteraaaa 4 года назад +1

      @Kyle Mortensen yikes! the misogyny jumped out 😳

    • @Celisar1
      @Celisar1 4 года назад +2

      Kyle Mortensen
      Again, every child has two parents. Why don’t the fathers share the responsibility to provide for the children?

    • @whyputaname
      @whyputaname Год назад +1

      Maybe you should be forced to take a randomized drug test when you go for your license, or go for a job, get a gun license, Fishing license, hunting license.

    • @whyputaname
      @whyputaname Год назад

      ​@@Celisar1
      Because men are @$$holes..