Aarambh Batch for UPSC 2024: unacademy.com/batch/aarambh-armb-comprehensive-batch-for-upsc-cse-2024-bilingual/CKU48FNX Enroll Now at 40% Off: unacademy.com/combo/slug/KPIGI/subscribe
I think sir you should awarded with best instructor in polity in the whole country. Jaha thodasa v interest nhi tha politics me apne itne asan tarike se samjhate h... That's mind blowing.
Go and read the m laxmikant very throw then you will understand how details of this topic was given in laxmikant. Sir, has provided us just summary, not so details of this topic
State legislature can also have extra territorial jurisdiction while making laws and if there is sufficient nexus between state and the object, then the state law can operate outside state also.
I AM VERY MUCH GRATEFUL FOR YOUR LESSONS REGARDING POLITY. I HAVE A QUESTION SIR ---CAN STATE MAKE LAWS IF THERE IS CERTAIN SCENARIOS WHERE STATE HAVE SUFFICIENT NEXUS ON THE OBJECT OUTSIDE THE TERRITORIAL BOUNDARY OF THE STATE. I APOLOGIES IN ADVANCE IF SOMETHING WRONG HAVE BEEN ASKED.
Doctrine of territorial nexus says that laws made by a state legislature are not applicable outside the state, except when there is a sufficient nexus between the state and the object.
7:54 i think u r wrong sir... u said it is only available to parliament... but Article 245 clause 2 says : The laws made by a state legislature are not applicable outside the state, *except when there is sufficient Nexus between the state and the object* .
Sir, What about in that case where the state law has been reserved for the consideration of president and received his assent, there state law prevails or Parliament make a law on that matter??
In case the bill is reserved for the consideration of the President and later it received the assent of him the the State law shall prevail over central law
Watch Dr Sidharth Arora''s Free Class Series on Unacademy here: www.unacademy.com/a/High-Probability-MCQs-for-UPSC-CSE-Prelims Call Dr Sidharth Arora''s team on 7825860058 and take your UPSC CSE Preparations to the next level.
Sir, In case states passes a resolution to make laws (regarding matters which are in state list) then parliament is entitled to make laws on that matter. Is it permanent entitlement to parliament i.e. from now on that particular matter only parliament will make laws or it is for some fixed duration??
usually or generally used by judiciary to take a narrow decision on the state and central law which is repugnant and mainly during national emergency ....... u can relate it to doctrine of harmonious construction where judiciary takes out a narrow solution when 2 article contradict for a particular judgment and give its decision
yes it is, Ref - Minerva mills vs union of india, 1980. Everything is india is under judicial review. Though it is upon judiciary if it considers ac 11 as null and void but i don't think there is any flaw in the article which needs to be turned down.
Role of governor partisan of governor deployment of armed forces in a particular state veto over state Bill's parliament legislate on state list cases against cm president rule
Call Dr Sidharth Arora's team on 7825860058 and take your UPSC CSE Preparations to the next level. To avail the BEST offers on any Unacademy Subscription, click here:unacademy.onelink.me/RICs/jfgycm0j
May be, You came here having a Pre Assumption that Sir will teach A,B,C,D.. But mistakenly, Sir started teaching Indian Polity and that too, Center State Relations.😂
![Digital Circus Episode 4 [TRAILER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/abZtsmMUbJo/mqdefault.jpg)
Aarambh Batch for UPSC 2024: unacademy.com/batch/aarambh-armb-comprehensive-batch-for-upsc-cse-2024-bilingual/CKU48FNX
Enroll Now at 40% Off: unacademy.com/combo/slug/KPIGI/subscribe
4:38 lecture starts
thanks man
4:39
Sbko pta h bhai
Krne do na unko advertise
Kahe aatankvad kr rhe ho
Thank you bolne k liye...meh directly 4:39click ki😅🤭
Thanx Bhai
Thanks
I think sir you should awarded with best instructor in polity in the whole country. Jaha thodasa v interest nhi tha politics me apne itne asan tarike se samjhate h... That's mind blowing.
Very true !!!
And this is just a summary....
Ye socho inke full detailed lectures kitne jyada interesting honge...
not that impressive
@@subhankarece it is interesting for those who understand not for those who don't
Sir I always start reading a new chapter only by watching your video . You create intrest in that chapter. Amazing sir .
Great sir best faculty in india for polity , complex topics bhi bade asani se samjh aa gya
0:57 "Ignorance is strength."💪-Orwell(1984) 😉
Dear Sir, Thank you so much. It is true that this topic is not mentioned very clearly in Laxmikanth.
Go and read the m laxmikant very throw then you will understand how details of this topic was given in laxmikant.
Sir, has provided us just summary, not so details of this topic
@@kittuharsh7 Yes
State legislature can also have extra territorial jurisdiction while making laws and if there is sufficient nexus between state and the object, then the state law can operate outside state also.
Doctrine f pith n substance
Mind-blowing session sir ☺️👍
I'm law student and I was literally messed by this topic .
Your lecture helped me alot 🤍
haha same here .. 2nd year law student. Not able to get this topic clearly
Which law college u????
Sikkim govt law college
@@mridulchhetri6069 3 or 5 yr llb ur????
Which year u r?? Sis🤔
3rd
Sir you are Guruji ❤ . No one can teach like you. Thank you sir .
great explanation, sir.
Sir you r too good I respect you from bottom sir. Thank you for helping
You mean bottom of the heart??
Just bottom sounds below the belt😝
@@tikeshwarpatel9379 naughty patel 😁
sir ne kaafe aacha samjhaya or Finology pe bhi bahut aacha samjhaya
Most stylish and best educator of unacademy
59 apps ban .... Data wala explaination shi ho gya ... Waah sir
Thank you so much sir ☺️
Rubbing axe blade till 4:38
Thank you bhai
Are bhai bhai bhai
Great conceptual explaination
I want to learn law subjects from siddhartha sir .... unacademy provide such kind of lectures for judiciary aspirants
Simplified. Very helpful.
Thanks a million
19:35 felt like he is speaking underwater 😄
Sir thankyou so much for this session I was very confused with this relationship but now it's all clear 😊😘
अज्ञानता में महानता है।
Excellent course
Thank you sir 🙏🏼🙏🏼
sir please upload a video on Parliamentary Motions. It will be very helpful.
I AM VERY MUCH GRATEFUL FOR YOUR LESSONS REGARDING POLITY. I HAVE A QUESTION SIR ---CAN STATE MAKE LAWS IF THERE IS CERTAIN SCENARIOS WHERE STATE HAVE SUFFICIENT NEXUS ON THE OBJECT OUTSIDE THE TERRITORIAL BOUNDARY OF THE STATE. I APOLOGIES IN ADVANCE IF SOMETHING WRONG HAVE BEEN ASKED.
No,state dont have that power to make laws.
Doctrine of territorial nexus says that laws made by a state legislature are not applicable outside the state, except when there is a sufficient nexus between the state and the object.
Sir will you take class on Parliamentary Committee , Groups?
Thank you sir
7:54 i think u r wrong sir... u said it is only available to parliament... but Article 245 clause 2 says : The laws made by a state legislature are not applicable outside the state, *except when there is sufficient Nexus between the state and the object* .
Sir aap concept clear KR dete h thanks a lot
Very clear explanation👌👍
Sir, What about in that case where the state law has been reserved for the consideration of president and received his assent, there state law prevails or Parliament make a law on that matter??
In all cases that he told like emergency, international treaty etc. I think President will never give his assent ..
In case the bill is reserved for the consideration of the President and later it received the assent of him the the State law shall prevail over central law
Yes but centre also have power to make law on same matter to overrides the state law
The one missing in his marathon lecture
Great sir
Start at 4:37
Good sid
Thankyou sir💯
Dear Sir please make a vedio on emergency concept
Sir your are too good
Sir should we have to remember all the articles or some enough ?
nexus wale point se GOI data privacy laws kyu nhi bana rhi bahar k companies k against ?
Or sir kya london ki branch india me bana skti hai rule
Hello sir ,m from Rajasthan i wanna join your coaching for LLM & NET ,,, plz help ,,,
This so much important topic should not be taught in haste......🙄
Watch Dr Sidharth Arora''s Free Class Series on Unacademy here: www.unacademy.com/a/High-Probability-MCQs-for-UPSC-CSE-Prelims
Call Dr Sidharth Arora''s team on 7825860058 and take your UPSC CSE Preparations to the next level.
Start with 4:40
Sir 254 mein ordinary law nhi sirf law in context of concurrent list pe hi applicable hoga naa?
is it live class on unacademy or recorded
Recored
Sir ji I wish ki aapka individual course ka option bhi hota
Yaa.... ♥
Nice video sir
thanks 💜
Nahi aise hi share kijiye
best
Bindas ho sir ap
Please start a institute in muzaffarpur, bihar....
Acha tha
What is the difference between a resolution and a law.
Resolution is center and law is state it seems
18:10 I think this is art.251,whereas art. 254 is about concurrent list.
Yes
Sir, In case states passes a resolution to make laws (regarding matters which are in state list) then parliament is entitled to make laws on that matter.
Is it permanent entitlement to parliament i.e. from now on that particular matter only parliament will make laws or it is for some fixed duration??
The laws cease to have effect on the expiration of six months after the resolution has ceased to be in force
Start from 4:40
great
4:38 jump
Can you take classes in English, beneficial for others
🖤
Videos start in 4:40
sir i really didn't understand the doctrine of pith and substance
usually or generally used by judiciary to take a narrow decision on the state and central law which is repugnant and mainly during national emergency ....... u can relate it to doctrine of harmonious construction where judiciary takes out a narrow solution when 2 article contradict for a particular judgment and give its decision
4.37
Article 247
Sir aap sanjay dutt se kam nhi lagte ho🤣
Hello sir
Whether article 11 is under judicial review or not? Anyone
yes it is, Ref - Minerva mills vs union of india, 1980. Everything is india is under judicial review. Though it is upon judiciary if it considers ac 11 as null and void but i don't think there is any flaw in the article which needs to be turned down.
@@pawanjain8637 I also don't think that there is any flaw, just wanted to confirm about the judicial review part. Cheers
Sir ek bar naukri mil jane di fir plus course bhi join kr lenge yarr
Ap parate hai ya sif add hi dete hai
Gdp to _ve chl rhi superpower😒
Kaha rehte ho aap
-ve in progress
👍👍
Is it a part parliament chapter of Laxmikanth, anyone please let me know??
3
Your voice losses clarity in between...
Starts at 4.40
Revise 17th july
👍
Plz Centre state realtion tession area bataiye
Role of governor partisan of governor deployment of armed forces in a particular state veto over state Bill's parliament legislate on state list cases against cm president rule
Her yek lecture mai ap 4min.zaya karte ho
acha toh matlba advertise bhi na karen
Sir you used hindi more then english plz use english to understand students from all over India
Call Dr Sidharth Arora's team on 7825860058 and take your UPSC CSE Preparations to the next level.
To avail the BEST offers on any Unacademy Subscription, click here:unacademy.onelink.me/RICs/jfgycm0j
🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
6:43 sir 😅
maluka ias😑😑😑
Totally confuse.because u can explain not a proper way to understand.just u read and delivered.below average rating
Exactly.
To understand him you should have a base of polity if you don't have that read NCERT and make your base strong
May be, You came here having a Pre Assumption that Sir will teach A,B,C,D..
But mistakenly, Sir started teaching Indian Polity and that too, Center State Relations.😂
i very sorry sir
Okokrakice ok
👌👌
But it's Mumbai 👌
Not Bombay 🙏
Kay asap law BHU padhate ho
Sala takala Pura brief me nahi Padhaya
5 minute to baat karte khatam kar diya