Nvee posted about the year of hard work she put into her breath control and stability training so that she could perform this stable on stage! I am beyond proud of her, she really has proved to herself and the world why she became an idol 🖤🖤🖤🖤
All of the Blackswan members have such distinctive vocal colors, textures, etc, it’s so satisfying to the ear! It feels like the industry favors just one type of voice and it’s doing the public such a disservice.
I'm so proud of our Blackswan girls, their voices really sound more harmonious and stable live, and without talking about how great the choreography is, they handle the show much better. NVEE and SRIYA's breathing and vocals together are magnificent ♥️😍✨Without a doubt Blackswan returned better than ever 😊👌
They are lucky because they can still perform and survive because the agency immediately looks for new members when many members leave. If it wasn't this agency, the name Black Swan would have disappeared because most agencies choose to disband the group immediately when the group doesn't bring good profits. For a group from a small agency, the agency really loves this group from the start of their re-debut and replacing replacement members.
Blackswan vocal stability is magnificent throughout the performance... Tht too within 1 year.... Can u imagine how powerful they will be aftr 3-4 yrs of their extreme hardwork???... Especially impressed by Sriya powerful vocals..... Surprisingly!!! Sriya is ACE OF BLACKSWAN. Go BLACKSWAN... U DESERVE ALL LOVE AND RESPECT ❤❤❤❤
People who are comparing them to illit. I mean seriously? Black swan's vocal projections & throw is so much better than Illit & except a few notes which they missed, through out the song they were singing & rapping on perfect scale. P.S. I'm not even a Black swan fan & it's my first time hearing them & they are good.
everyone was stable, so much improvement! Gabi's voice was a bit thin somehow (she's usually very stable) but other than that everyone was pretty strong.
@@mrtns.dav10 Oh that makes sense, she said she had the most complications with vocals for this comeback but I’m not sure why she did so great during karma/cat and mouse live performances
Nvee has always been an amazing singer, but she was not very stable while dancing last comeback. Hearing her improvement in just a year is genuinely insane. Wow
@@Yawnnznn Don’t be daft, that’s not the point. MJ sang and danced and had no problem with his vocals being stable and he didn’t use auto tune like these K-pop idols are. Only a few of these K-pop artists can sing with great vocal control while dancing e.g SNSD, BTS, IU, sistar and red velvet. It’s a known fact that most K-pop idols cannot meet the standard when it comes to singing because they’re more focused on visuals, dancing and becoming marketable. The standard for artist is beyond low so let’s not kid ourselves.
Huh no hate to illit...but blackswan is way more stable than illit..these girls have no privilege, they're also rookies yet performed better than them with intense choreography..
Blackswan are coming from a small agency with little training. They probably doesn't even have a vocal trainer. So yes they are way more stable than a group coming from a survival show and a huge company with a lot of priviledge
illit They are very bad at singing live, even though the notes of their song are easy. As for Black Swan, their song contains notes that are difficult to sing in live.
@@framboesa185 prefiro ter dignidade do que aceitar qualquer merreca em troca de fama. Elas nem ganham salário e tu acha mesmo que alguém consciente vai querer essa vida delas? acorda, alice 😂 nem tudo é inveja e sim bom senso. Tudo alma vendida e vão diretamente para o inferno onde vcs não deveriam sair
@@framboesa185elas nem recebem salário e tu acha que alguém vai ter inveja disso? venderam a alma e vcs vão diretamente para o inferno, onde vcs nunca deveriam ter saído. Sai pra lá, capetona.
![[BLACKSWAN] Roll Up_Dance Practice_Choreography_Video (Practice Room & Mirrored_ver.)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/x0gbOubf4wE/mqdefault.jpg)
![[4K] BLACKSWAN - “Roll Up” Band LIVE Concert [it's Live] K-POP live music show](/img/1.gif)
They deserve so much more attention they are hella stable dang
Sriya is not only a god top quality dancer, but her vocals are so stable!
They are so fcking stable omfg
NVee really improved a lot. And this is with her having asthma?!?!
she has asthma 😥
Another comment said shes been working hard for the whole year to get this table, it shows!!!!
There were actually some fantastic singers with asthma. NVee just happens to join the club.
Nvee posted about the year of hard work she put into her breath control and stability training so that she could perform this stable on stage! I am beyond proud of her, she really has proved to herself and the world why she became an idol 🖤🖤🖤🖤
She's a very good singer but breath control is an entirely different thing and she's so good now.
On top of the she has asthma, I can't imagine how much she had trained for this stability 😢
Nvees stability helped stabilize Gabi I think.
She has asthma? 😮@@pragnakedlaya9205
All of the Blackswan members have such distinctive vocal colors, textures, etc, it’s so satisfying to the ear! It feels like the industry favors just one type of voice and it’s doing the public such a disservice.
진짜 어ㅐ케 잘하냐
다른 그룹보다도 압도적으로 잘하는데..
올라가라 ㅠ
Yes
무대보면 알겠지만 안무 겁나 빡센데
라이브 이렇게 하는거 대단하지않냐고요~~~~~~😂😂❤❤
BLACKSWAN deserves so much attention
I'm so proud of our Blackswan girls, their voices really sound more harmonious and stable live, and without talking about how great the choreography is, they handle the show much better. NVEE and SRIYA's breathing and vocals together are magnificent ♥️😍✨Without a doubt Blackswan returned better than ever 😊👌
춤 추면서 이정도면 잘하는거다
블랙스완 화이팅♥♥♥
If they're debut in famous company, they'll be really popular
They are lucky because they can still perform and survive because the agency immediately looks for new members when many members leave. If it wasn't this agency, the name Black Swan would have disappeared because most agencies choose to disband the group immediately when the group doesn't bring good profits. For a group from a small agency, the agency really loves this group from the start of their re-debut and replacing replacement members.
@@LightCherryBlossom thinking back at it this is actually correct LOL any other company would have just dropped them.
Actually now the agency is working hard but not in their initial days so it's company not the group
group is great @@thisiscuvo.
Sriya&NVee vocal line💥
fatou rapping while dancing omg
1:38 Damn Sriya voice
Exactly.... My reaction ws that listening clean vocals of sriya😮👏😍💗
I am playing that part again and again she is so good 😮
The high note😨💗
Bro their vocals are still so stable 😫🤌🏻
I love how their voices come together in such incredible harmony. Gabi in a light and solid tone and Nvee has a more powerful tone of voice
And this is How 👏🏻 you 👏🏻 make 👏🏻a 👏🏻Comeback. BlackSwan girlies really rolling up and showing us how it's done. 🔥🔥🔥
You did gabi dirty in the thumbnail
Gabi is so pretty ❤
They all improve a lot!! I’m shock of Sriya and Nvee woww
Blackswan vocal stability is magnificent throughout the performance... Tht too within 1 year.... Can u imagine how powerful they will be aftr 3-4 yrs of their extreme hardwork???...
Especially impressed by Sriya powerful vocals..... Surprisingly!!!
Sriya is ACE OF BLACKSWAN.
Go BLACKSWAN... U DESERVE ALL LOVE AND RESPECT ❤❤❤❤
Choreography is tough they did so good👍
Sriya is literally multi talented❤
One of the best kpop group who can actually sing live🔥.
Gabi te amo
can we appreciated how deep sriya's voice is while dancing. its hard to do that very hard infact
I always appreciate her gorgeous voice.... 💯👈❤
Gabi ♥
Sriya ❤❤
Their EP was so good. I hope they get more attention and start getting fan chants and using BlackSwan light sticks. They look so cool too.
That high note was so good
thaat second chorus is so freaking hard to keep stability, you know, the chest rounding move. An they freaking DO IT!! love 'em
Gabi 😮 vocals perfect queen vocals. They are queens vocals perfect ❤❤❤❤❤ i love Black Swan Gabi, Sriya, Nvee, Fatou
They're hella stable... Put this one in shorts as well
1:58 ANGELICCCC
People who are comparing them to illit. I mean seriously? Black swan's vocal projections & throw is so much better than Illit & except a few notes which they missed, through out the song they were singing & rapping on perfect scale.
P.S. I'm not even a Black swan fan & it's my first time hearing them & they are good.
Fr
Fr
Yes.
Agreed
Men they r so stable
THEY GIVE THEIR ALLLL
they genuinely are so amazing!!
Uff Sriya's deep voice 😮
Nvee being stable while having Asthma is inspirational ❤
Put this one in shorts !!!
They're all great, but I really want to praise NVEE, she's got much better, more stable comparing to their last comeback's live performances.
👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
BLACKSWAN'S Vocals are underrated😢❤
They totally deserve all the love and attention❤❤
엔비가 상당히 안정적이네요. 엔비 체력만 좀 보강하면 라이브 거뜬할듯.
She has asthma
@@swati2899 She is unstoppable
What 😭? She is still slaying@@swati2899
@@swati2899still possible. She will get betetr
I agree. Envee no doubt is exceptional vocalist to say the least
My live vocals girls
TAAAA THIS COMEBACK IS SO GOOD
uau!!! 🥵🦢❤
I don't wanna bring other groups down but Swannies are better than some new groups which can't sing a song without cracking every few second.
Fr
1:55 wow 🤩
Omg thanks you!!
nvee's improvement is amazing. she sound so stable now.
Black swan SUPPORT ❤
Put this in shorts !!!!!!
They never put the good ones in shorts
@@Yawnnznn ikr 😑
everyone was stable, so much improvement! Gabi's voice was a bit thin somehow (she's usually very stable) but other than that everyone was pretty strong.
Yeah i noticed this, i think that can be related with her only few lines in the song
@@mrtns.dav10how would that relate? ( real question)
@@Sydbeam Idk maybe she's having problems with her stability or choreo, or something is impacting her performance so just few lines were given to her
@@mrtns.dav10 Oh that makes sense, she said she had the most complications with vocals for this comeback but I’m not sure why she did so great during karma/cat and mouse live performances
I think the lines are bit lower than her comfortable range. The whole song is a bit low compared to say La Boum or Cat & Mouse. 🤔
the stability is crazyyy and I love their stage presence. this era is one for the books !
They are damn confident
Nvee be eating them those CDs dang
Elas são incríveis ❤
Fatou is so stable
Amassaram com força ❤
Wow sriya is amazing!!! Literally how is she so good??? 😮😮❤❤
Second. Love ur vids
My gurlsss are so hardworking and talented.... they deserve more recognition....
Nvee vocals periiod
Wow NVE so goodddd
NVee omfggggg
they are that good and people still pay them dust
The girls have much talent ❤
Nvee slayed 🔥
hey could you put this in shorts..in this way they would get more recognition
They never put the good ones in shorts
1:39 this part is my favourite Sriya voice 🔥🔥
Slay
MY GIRLSSSS SLAYYYYY
sriya killed it
It's too difficult 😫 😪, now i can feel them, girls u have done great job❤❤
Audience cheering yeah,this is tough song to perform so fast
Hybe por que você não é assim?
Wowww❤❤
Early!!pin??love your channel btw
Please xin tooo❤
Nvee's live vocal HOW
❤❤
❤❤❤❤❤
Nvee has always been an amazing singer, but she was not very stable while dancing last comeback. Hearing her improvement in just a year is genuinely insane. Wow
Put this in shorts
They never put the good ones in shorts
Ikr !!
Can you please do shorts on them....
Omg Their vocals are so good they need more attention 🧡💙
🫡🫡🫡
Bts - best of me...also?
Stable, what this group SCREAMS
This is stable to you lot?🤣
Their singing is perfect and stable because their dancing was too difficult for live singing, so their live singing is considered very good
@@13jonah13 this is a new low then, Michael Jackson could never 💅🏽✨
@@buttercuplove4630since when was MJ in kpop
@@Yawnnznn Don’t be daft, that’s not the point. MJ sang and danced and had no problem with his vocals being stable and he didn’t use auto tune like these K-pop idols are. Only a few of these K-pop artists can sing with great vocal control while dancing e.g SNSD, BTS, IU, sistar and red velvet. It’s a known fact that most K-pop idols cannot meet the standard when it comes to singing because they’re more focused on visuals, dancing and becoming marketable. The standard for artist is beyond low so let’s not kid ourselves.
@@buttercuplove4630 you sound bitter babe
If it was illit they were probably bashed fir not being stable....how hypocrite are kpop stans??
Huh no hate to illit...but blackswan is way more stable than illit..these girls have no privilege, they're also rookies yet performed better than them with intense choreography..
Illit vocals are fine but blackswan are on a different level
Blackswan are coming from a small agency with little training. They probably doesn't even have a vocal trainer. So yes they are way more stable than a group coming from a survival show and a huge company with a lot of priviledge
illit They are very bad at singing live, even though the notes of their song are easy. As for Black Swan, their song contains notes that are difficult to sing in live.
a gabi é muito tenebrosa, canta como se tivesse dentro do banheiro 😂 nada contra ela, mas que mulher despreparada…
Canta melhor amiga,no caso tenta até pq o talento dela você NUNCA vai ter!
@@rhaniellynunes9839 eu sei o talento dela… ter dado pro ceo
@@sixpunk e vc nem dando consegue algo então tá tudo certo
@@framboesa185 prefiro ter dignidade do que aceitar qualquer merreca em troca de fama. Elas nem ganham salário e tu acha mesmo que alguém consciente vai querer essa vida delas? acorda, alice 😂 nem tudo é inveja e sim bom senso. Tudo alma vendida e vão diretamente para o inferno onde vcs não deveriam sair
@@framboesa185elas nem recebem salário e tu acha que alguém vai ter inveja disso? venderam a alma e vcs vão diretamente para o inferno, onde vcs nunca deveriam ter saído. Sai pra lá, capetona.
Sriya ❤❤❤