Justify your answer | Can you find the angle X? |

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 28 сен 2024

Комментарии • 56

  • @luigipirandello5919
    @luigipirandello5919 3 месяца назад +10

    Very nice problem.

    • @PreMath
      @PreMath  3 месяца назад +3

      Many many thanks, dear 🌹

  • @phungpham1725
    @phungpham1725 3 месяца назад +4

    Thank you! Your method is much more better than mine!
    1/ Drop the height CH = h to the base AB and label HD=a
    We have h=a.sqrt 3 --> h=HB=a+1
    so a.sqrt3= a+1-> a=(sqrt3+1)/2->
    h=(3+sqrt3)/3 (1)
    2/ AH= 2-a=(3-sqrt3)/3 (2)
    3/ tan (x) = h/AH= 2+sqrt3
    --> x= 75 degrees 😅

    • @PreMath
      @PreMath  3 месяца назад

      Excellent!
      Thanks for sharing ❤️

  • @philipkudrna5643
    @philipkudrna5643 3 месяца назад +2

    I love that you can solve the problem just by logic reasoning and without trigonometry!

    • @PreMath
      @PreMath  3 месяца назад

      Excellent!
      Glad to hear that!
      Thanks for the feedback ❤️

  • @aljawad
    @aljawad 3 месяца назад +1

    Nice! I went straight to trigonometry and a combination of the laws of sines and cosines to reach the same result.

  • @jimlocke9320
    @jimlocke9320 3 месяца назад +2

    As phungpham1725 did, drop a perpendicular from C to AB and label the intersection as point H. Let DH = a. ΔCDH is a 30°-60°-90° special right triangle, with longer side √3 times as long as the short side, so CH = a√3. ΔCBH is a 45°-45°-90° special isosceles right triangle, so its sides CH and BH are equal. BH = a + 1 so a + 1 = a√3, and a = 1/(√3 - 1). AH = 2 - a = 2 - 1/(√3 - 1) = (2√3 - 2)/(√3 - 1) - 1/(√3 - 1) = (2√3 - 3)/(√3 - 1). CH = a√3 = (1/(√3 - 1))(√3) = √3/(√3 - 1). tan(x) = CH/AH = (√3/(√3 - 1))/((2√3 - 3)/(√3 - 1)) = (√3)/((2√3 - 3)) = 3/(6 - 3√3) = 1/(2 - √3), and arctan(1/(2 - √3)) = 75° to within the precision of my scientific calculator. If we are not required to provide an exact result, we are done. Otherwise:
    The 15°-75°-90° right triangle appears frequently in geometry problems, so we check for ΔACH being such a triangle, in which case, x would be exactly 75°. We recall that the sides of a 15°-75°-90° right triangle, short - long - hypotenuse, are (√3 - 1):(√3 + 1):2√2, or (long)/(short) = (√3 + 1)/(√3 - 1) and check for a match. Since (2 - √3) is smaller than 1, we multiply both numerator and denominator by (√3 + 1) to make the numerator equal (√3 + 1) and see if the denominator is (√3 - 1). So denominator (2 - √3)(√3 + 1) = 2(√3 + 1) - (√3)(√3 + 1) = 2√3 + 2 - (√3)(√3) - (√3)(1) = 2√3 + 2 - (3) - √3 = (√3 - 1). We have the same numerator and denominator as for the 15°-75°-90° right triangle. Angle x is opposite the long side, so x = 75° exactly, as PreMath also found.

    • @PreMath
      @PreMath  3 месяца назад

      Excellent!
      Thanks for sharing ❤️

  • @prossvay8744
    @prossvay8744 3 месяца назад +2

    LBCF=60-45=15°
    LACD=180°-(60°+x)
    Let CD=a
    In ∆BCD
    1/sin(15°)=a/sin(45°)
    so a=sin(45°)/sin(15°) (1)
    In ∆ACD
    a/sin(x)=2/sin(180°-(60°+x)
    a=2sin(x)/sin(60°+x) (2)
    (1) and (2)
    sin(45°)/sin(15°)=2sin(x)/sin(60°+x)
    so sin(45°)sin(60°+x)=2sin(x)sin(15°)
    sin(45°)=1/√2
    sin(60°+x)=sin(60°)cos(x)+sin(x)cos(60°}=√3/2cos(x)+1/2sin(x)
    1/√2(1/2)(√3cos(x)+sin(x))=2sin(x)sin(15°)
    1/2√2(√3cos(x)+sin(x))=2sin(x)sin(15°)
    2Sin(15°)=√3/2√2cot(x)+1/2√2
    Sin(15°)=sin(45°-30°)
    =Sin(45°)cos(30°)-sin(30°)cos(45°)
    =(1/√2)(√3/2)-(1/√2)(1/2)=√3/2√2-1/2√2
    2(√3/2√2-1/2√2)=√3/2√2cot(x)+1/2√2
    2(√3-1)=√3cot(x)+1
    √3cot(x)=2√3-2-1=2√3-3
    cot(x)=(2√3-3)/√3
    cot(x)=(6-3√3)/3=2-√3
    So x=75°❤❤❤

    • @PreMath
      @PreMath  3 месяца назад

      Excellent!
      Thanks for sharing ❤️

  • @CloudBushyMath
    @CloudBushyMath 3 месяца назад +3

    Interesting

  • @Mediterranean81
    @Mediterranean81 3 месяца назад +1

    Drop a perpendicular from C to AB in E
    EBC is isoceles right triangle so
    Let AE= x
    BE= 3-x
    We have AEC is a right triangle
    So AC^2= x^2 + (3-x)^2 = 9-6x^2
    BC^2 = 2(3-x)^2 = 18-12x+2x^2
    In ABC we have all the sides know so let's use Law of cosines
    cos x = AC^2+AB^2-BC^2/2*AC*BC
    9+9-6x^2-18+12x-2x^2/2*√(18-12x+2x^2) √(9-6x^2)
    Simplifies to (√6-√2)/4 which is cos 75°
    So x=75°

    • @PreMath
      @PreMath  3 месяца назад

      Excellent!
      Thanks for sharing ❤️

  • @jamestalbott4499
    @jamestalbott4499 3 месяца назад

    Thank you!

  • @quigonkenny
    @quigonkenny 3 месяца назад +3

    As ∠ADC is an exterior angle to ∆DBC at D, ∠BCD = ∠ADC-∠DBC = 60°-45° = 15°. Additionally, as ∠ADB is a straight angle, ∠CDB = 180°-60° = 120°.
    As ∠CDB is an exterior angle to ∆DCA at D, ∠DCA = ∠CDB-∠CAD = 120°-x.
    By the law of sines:
    1/sin(15°) = BC/sin(120°)
    BC = sin(120°)/sin(15°)
    sin(15°) = sin(60°-45°)
    sin(15°) = sin(60°)cos(45°) - cos(60°)sin(45°)
    sin(15°) = (√3/2)(1/√2) - (1/2)(1/√2)
    sin(15°) = (√3-1)/2√2
    BC = (√3/2)/((√3-1)/2√2)
    BC = (√3/2)(2√2)/(√3-1) = √6/(√3-1)
    BC = √6(√3+1)/(√3-1)(√3+1)
    BC = (3√2+√6)/(3-1)
    BC = (3√2+√6)/2
    By the law of cosines:
    CA² = AB² + BC² - 2(AB)(BC)cos(45°)
    CA² = 3² + ((3√2+√6)/2)² - 2(3)((3√2+√6)/2)/√2
    CA² = 9 + (√3+1)²(6/4) - 3(3√2+√6)/√2
    CA² = 9 + (3/2)(4+2√3) - (9+3√3)
    CA² = 3(2+√3) - 3√3 = 6
    CA = √6
    By the law of sines:
    2/sin(120°-x) = √6/sin(60°)
    √6sin(120°-x) = 2sin(60°) = 2(√3/2)
    sin(120°-x) = √3/√6 = 1/√2 = sin(45°)
    120° - x = 45°
    x = 120° - 45° = 75°

    • @PreMath
      @PreMath  3 месяца назад

      Excellent!
      Thanks for sharing ❤️

  • @johnbrennan3372
    @johnbrennan3372 3 месяца назад +1

    Nice geometric method.

    • @PreMath
      @PreMath  3 месяца назад

      Glad you think so!
      Thanks for the feedback ❤️

  • @andreasproteus1465
    @andreasproteus1465 3 месяца назад +1

    Apply sine rule to CBD: CD = sin(45)/sin(15) = 2.73
    Apply sine rule to ACD: sin(x)/CD = sin(120-x)/2 = (√3cos(x) + Sin(x))/4 => 4/CD = √3cot(x) +1
    Giving cot(x) = 0.27 and x = 75°.

    • @PreMath
      @PreMath  3 месяца назад

      Excellent!
      Thanks for sharing ❤️

  • @marcgriselhubert3915
    @marcgriselhubert3915 3 месяца назад +1

    Let's use an orthonormal, center D, first axis (DB)
    The equation of (BC) is y = -x +1, the equation of (DC) is y = -tan(60°).x = -sqrt(3).x. By intersection we have point C:
    C(-(1 + sqrt(3))/2; (3 +sqrt(3))/2)
    DC^2 = (1/4).(1 + 3 +2.sqrt(3) +9 + 3 +6.sqrt(3))
    = 4 + 2.sqrt(3)
    VectorAC((3 -sqrt(3))/2; (3 +sqrt(3))/2) and
    AC^2 = (1/4).(9 + 3 -6.sqrt(3) + 9 + 3 + 6.sqrt(3)) =6
    In trianglesADC: CD^2 = AC^2 + AD^2 - 2.AC.AD.cos(x)
    or 4 + 2.sqrt(3) = 6 + 4 - 4.sqrt(6).cos(x),
    then cos(x) = (6 - 2.sqrt(3))/(4.sqrt(6)) =
    (sqrt(6) - sqrt(2))/4 = cos(15°) = sin(75°)
    Finally x = 75°

    • @PreMath
      @PreMath  3 месяца назад

      Excellent!
      Thanks for sharing ❤️

  • @mvrpatnaik9085
    @mvrpatnaik9085 3 месяца назад

    Elegant Solution

  • @redfinance3403
    @redfinance3403 3 месяца назад

    What an amazing problem. I suppose the intuition between drawing the perpendicular would have been that the sides were of lengths 2 and 1. I was imaging how the problem would vary with different lengths but I should’ve focused on the fact that the lengths were 2 and 1. I guess that could be something to look out for in other problems, maybe it will help! Trigonometry solution : easy, geometry solution : 😮

  • @giuseppemalaguti435
    @giuseppemalaguti435 3 месяца назад +1

    ctgx=(4sin15/√3sin45)-1/√3...tgx=2+√3...x=75

    • @PreMath
      @PreMath  3 месяца назад

      Excellent!
      Thanks for sharing ❤️

  • @GhdVhs
    @GhdVhs 3 месяца назад

    0:44

  • @Teamstudy4595
    @Teamstudy4595 3 месяца назад +2

    1$t view

  • @wackojacko3962
    @wackojacko3962 3 месяца назад

    I want $100 dollars for every degree. $7,500 dollars. Thank you very much. 🙂

  • @Ashi-cq7tj
    @Ashi-cq7tj 3 месяца назад +1

    Pin me 😂😂

    • @PreMath
      @PreMath  3 месяца назад

      Thanks dear❤️

  • @GhdVhs
    @GhdVhs 3 месяца назад

    0:44

  • @unknownidentity2846
    @unknownidentity2846 3 месяца назад +2

    Let's find x:
    .
    ..
    ...
    ....
    .....
    Let's assume that A is the center of the coordinate system and that AB is located on the x-axis. Then we obtain the following coordina
    tes:
    A: ( 0 ; 0 )
    B: ( 3 ; 0 )
    C: ( xC ; yC )
    D: ( 2 ; 0 )
    The lines CB and CD can be represented by the following functions:
    CB: y = −tan(45°)*(x − 3) = −(x − 3)
    CD: y = −tan(60°)*(x − 2) = −√3*(x − 2)
    Both lines intersect at C, so we can conclude:
    −(xC − 3) = −√3*(xC − 2)
    xC − 3 = √3*(xC − 2)
    xC − 3 = √3*xC − 2√3
    2√3 − 3 = √3*xC − xC
    2√3 − 3 = (√3 − 1)*xC
    xC
    = (2√3 − 3)/(√3 − 1)
    = (2√3 − 3)(√3 + 1)/[(√3 − 1)(√3 + 1)]
    = (6 + 2√3 − 3√3 − 3)/(3 − 1)
    = (3 − √3)/2
    yC
    = −(xC − 3)
    = 3 − xC
    = 3 − (3 − √3)/2
    = 6/2 − (3 − √3)/2
    = (6 − 3 + √3)/2
    = (3 + √3)/2
    Now we are able to calculate x:
    tan(x)
    = (yC − yA)/(xC − xA)
    = yC/xC
    = [(3 + √3)/2]/[(3 − √3)/2]
    = (3 + √3)/(3 − √3)
    = (1 + 1/√3)/(1 − 1/√3)
    = (1 + 1/√3)/[1 − 1*(1/√3)]
    = [tan(45°) + tan(30°)]/[1 − tan(45°)*tan(30°)]
    = tan(45° + 30°)
    = tan(75°)
    ⇒ x = 75°
    Best regards from Germany

    • @unknownidentity2846
      @unknownidentity2846 3 месяца назад

      After viewing the video I have to say that I like your solution very much.👍

    • @LuisdeBritoCamacho
      @LuisdeBritoCamacho 3 месяца назад

      I like your Way of Reasoning. Congratulations!!

    • @PreMath
      @PreMath  3 месяца назад

      Excellent!
      Thanks for sharing ❤️

    • @unknownidentity2846
      @unknownidentity2846 2 месяца назад +1

      @@LuisdeBritoCamacho Thank you very much for your kind feedback and sorry for the delayed answer.
      Best regards from Germany

  • @LuisdeBritoCamacho
    @LuisdeBritoCamacho 3 месяца назад +1

    STEP-BY-STEP RESOLUTION PROPOSAL :
    01) Draw a Vertical Line from Point C until Red Line. Call this Point E. CE = h
    02) Draw two Lines : One Horizontal passing through Point C and another Vertical passing through Point B. The Meeting Point is F
    03) Angle DBC = 45º
    04) Angle BDC = 120º
    05) Angle DCB = 180º - (120º + 45º) = 180º - 165º = 15º
    06) Angle ECD = 180º - (90º + 60º) = 180º - 150º = 30º
    07) Now : Angle ECB = 45º
    08) Line CB is the Diagonal of a Square [BECF].
    09) Triangle CDE is (30º - 60º - 90º)
    10) Calculating the Diameter (D) of Square [BECF] :
    11) 1 / sin(15º) = D / sin(120º) ; D = sin(120º) / sin(15º) ; D ~ 3,35 (Exact Form = sqrt(6) / (sqrt(3) - 1)
    12) D = S * sqrt(2). Being "S" the Side Length of Square [BECF]
    13) 3,35 = S * sqrt(2) ; S ~ 2,366 (Exact Form = sqrt(3) / (sqrt(3) - 1)
    14) AE = 3 - 2.366 ~ 0,634
    15) X = arctan(2,366 / 0,634) ; X ~ 74,999º
    16) ANSWER : The Angle X is equal to 75º
    17) A little bit boring!
    Best Wishes from Cordoba Caliphate - Center for the Studies of Divine Knowledge, Thinking and Wisdom. Department of Mathematics.

    • @PreMath
      @PreMath  3 месяца назад

      Excellent!
      You are the best!🌹
      Thanks for sharing ❤️

  • @AmirgabYT2185
    @AmirgabYT2185 3 месяца назад +2

    x=75°

    • @PreMath
      @PreMath  3 месяца назад +1

      Excellent!
      Thanks for sharing ❤️

  • @kikilolo6771
    @kikilolo6771 3 месяца назад +2

    I was so close to the solution 😭 next time I will be able to solve these problems

    • @PreMath
      @PreMath  3 месяца назад

      Great attitude! Keep it up👍
      Thanks for the feedback ❤️

  • @misterenter-iz7rz
    @misterenter-iz7rz 3 месяца назад +1

    E is the circumcenter of ABC.😮

    • @PreMath
      @PreMath  3 месяца назад +1

      Thanks for the feedback ❤️

  • @Martin-hi7wx
    @Martin-hi7wx 3 месяца назад

    I used both the sine and cosine formulae to determine the size of x. It takes less time.

  • @hongningsuen1348
    @hongningsuen1348 3 месяца назад +1

    Method not using construction but a calculator for fast solution in exam:
    1. In triangle BCD, angle BCD = 60 - 45 = 15
    2. In triangle BCD, find CD by sine rule: CD = (1)(sin45)/(sin15) = 2.732....
    3. In triangle ACD, find AC by cosine rule: AC^2 = CD^2 + 2^2 - (2)(2)(CD)cos60 (Use ANS key to directly input CD from last step.)
    AC^2 = 6
    4. In triangle ACD, by sine rule: sinX = (2.732)(sin60)/sqrt 6 = 0.966
    Hence X = arcsin 0.966 = 74.996

    • @PreMath
      @PreMath  3 месяца назад

      Excellent!
      Thanks for sharing ❤️

  • @himadrikhanra7463
    @himadrikhanra7463 3 месяца назад

    45 degree?

  • @Martin-hi7wx
    @Martin-hi7wx 3 месяца назад

    Sine formula to calculate length of CD in triangle CBD. Then cosine formula to determine CA in triangle CAD. Then sine formula to determine x in Triangle CAD.

  • @stephenbrand5779
    @stephenbrand5779 3 месяца назад

    What an elegant solution. Mine involved the use of the sine rule and lots of fiddly algebra. Much prefer yours.