I hate it when people assume this. why would belle agree to having her heart taken from her chest? helping, yes but not this. Regina made belle forget that she took her heart. there is a difference between wanting to help someone and letting them take your heart. guys, belle is NOT that fucking stupid!!!!
Xenia Martin exactly. I know belle wants to help but she would never agree to emotionally manipulating rumple like that. Besides that Regina literally started to crush her heart. No one would willingly agree to that. Also I feel like her motivation to help is because she feels guilty for being gullible and not stopping rumple’s dark actions not because she wants to get revenge on him or anything malicious
Because Belle has been selfish and nasty a few times. Anna for one, lots of Lacey for another, and she thinks only of what she wants with Rumple sometimes. Not that he hasn't hurt her, of course, but it would hurt her heart anyway.
Luís Dias her heart isn't black...it's HIS heart that black from all the dark deeds he's done....but I really don't like Belle sometimes. For gods sake.. she knows who he is more than anyone knows.
![OUAT - 4x19 'Looking for your wife's heart?' [Belle, Will, Rumple & Maleficent]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/z7dSGgKhif8/mqdefault.jpg)
![OUAT - 4x19 'Looking for your wife's heart?' [Belle, Will, Rumple & Maleficent]](/img/tr.png)
![OUAT - 5x06 'Belle, you're in danger' [Rumple & Belle]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/wMoMYiTQdX0/mqdefault.jpg)
Belle: "What are you doing here?"
(Me) Rumplestiltskin: "Well, it is my shop."
they way they look at eachother after he puts her heart back 🥰🥺
Belle didnt even bother to hold will's hand. Thank goodness
Omg belle! Go after him!
Amanda L Exactly what I was yelling through my tears during this scene :)
Her heart is breaking for him :(
Why am i tearing up? Great scene.
He says goodbye to Belle so often. If only they had been dedicated to making it work early on.
1:33 Like her heart is even darker than Hook's! How the hell is that possible?!
Wait Belle didn't know Regina ripped her heart out? I thought Belle and Regina were both in on the agreement to get back at Rumple
I hate it when people assume this. why would belle agree to having her heart taken from her chest? helping, yes but not this. Regina made belle forget that she took her heart. there is a difference between wanting to help someone and letting them take your heart. guys, belle is NOT that fucking stupid!!!!
Regina erased her memory. She can't remember, even though she did agree to it
Xenia Martin
you are right!!!
Xenia Martin exactly. I know belle wants to help but she would never agree to emotionally manipulating rumple like that. Besides that Regina literally started to crush her heart. No one would willingly agree to that. Also I feel like her motivation to help is because she feels guilty for being gullible and not stopping rumple’s dark actions not because she wants to get revenge on him or anything malicious
1:27 how is her heart soo black?
Will always looks like he ships Rumple and Belle
Now I'm waiting for them to bring in Giselle and Kida
Who?
+Zoe Sherwin Giselle is from Enchanted, and I believe Kita is from Atlantis.
So when was will with Anastasia?
Freaking Atlantean magic would freak out everybody in storybrooke
1:36 why is her heart black?
Because Belle has been selfish and nasty a few times. Anna for one, lots of Lacey for another, and she thinks only of what she wants with Rumple sometimes. Not that he hasn't hurt her, of course, but it would hurt her heart anyway.
Luís Dias I think that's just shadow
Luís Dias her heart isn't black...it's HIS heart that black from all the dark deeds he's done....but I really don't like Belle sometimes. For gods sake.. she knows who he is more than anyone knows.
since you pointed that out I'm just now noticing that!
Luís Dias lacy probably did that
Roerbotcarlyle I’ve you gold Scotland zeina 😊😊😊😊😊😊
Roerbotcarlyle I’ve you gold Scotland zeina 😊😊😊🏠😊😊😊😊😊😊
Roerbotcarlyle I’ve you gold Scotland zeina
Roerbotcarlyle I’ve you gold Scotland zeina boyfreind