RESERVATION, is it Neccessary?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 27 авг 2024
  • ► Open account with Delta Exchange India and get 10% off on trading fees for 2 months: india.delta.ex...
    ► Open account with Delta Exchange and get 10% off on trading fees for 6 months: delta.exchange...
    ►► UPCOMING EVENTS
    2-DAY OPTIONS TRADING OFFLINE WORKSHOP - All-New Trend Following Workshop
    ► BENGALURU | Aug 03 & 04 - workshop.prsun...
    ► CHENNAI | Aug 10 & 11 - workshop.prsun...
    ► MUMBAI | Aug 24 & 25 - workshop.prsun...
    ► ONLINE Options Workshop for US & Indian Markets
    AUG 31 & SEP 01 - workshop.prsun...
    ► Launched Recently - Intraday Option Buying Strategy using Technical Analysis: rpy.club/cours... (Fee: ₹2,499)
    CONTACT Details - 7358447138, 8122135785, 9150609409
    ► ► IMPORTANT LINKS
    ► Options Workshop for US & Indian Markets
    Please fill this form and we will get back to you with all the details - forms.gle/7aRK...
    ► ONLINE OPTIONS WORKSHOP for US & Indian Markets
    Interested people may fill this form: forms.gle/Jze1... - we will get back to you during office hours.
    CONTACT Details - 7358447138, 9150609409
    ► Options Trading Online Workshop (For People With Decent Knowledge) - workshop.prsun...
    ► To join P R Sundar's flagship Mentorship program: bit.ly/prsment... (Minimum Capital: Rs.5 Crores)
    ► Intraday Short Straddle - A Unique Setup with New ADJUSTMENTS! (With Recorded Q&A) Register here: bit.ly/prs-str...
    ► New Course: Supertrend Indicator (Identifying Trend & Executing Trades) - workshop.prsun...
    ► MISSION OPTIONS (Options Trading Free Course for Beginners) - bit.ly/Mission...
    Our official Telegram channel - t.me/PRSundar64
    Follow us on Twitter - / prsundar64
    Follow us on Instagram - / prsundar64
    ----------------------------------------------------------
    - Local Cues & Global Cues
    - Nifty & Bank Nifty Performance
    - Institutional Data - FII & DII
    ----------------------------------------------------------
    ► Background Music Credits:
    / chukimusic
    Beat made by Chuki Beats
    ----------------------------------------------------------
    #reservation #prsundar

Комментарии • 569

  • @shashikantvashist1545
    @shashikantvashist1545 Месяц назад +76

    Sir your observation is not based on facts, i am telling you reality: In IIT JEE ADVANCE my son got 507th rank and he could not entered in CS (Computer Science) but his close friend who was from reserved category got 2298 rank and he entered in CS in same university, in UPSC my niece got 78th rank and could not get IAS but one from reserved category scored 438 rank and became a IAS, how can you justify such a big difference

    • @jpm1982Prad
      @jpm1982Prad Месяц назад +14

      See the video properly, if you have a small cake then sharing will be hard if you increase the size of the cake then every society will get it. So the problem is the limited number of seats and availablity of jobs.

    • @syedibrahim4543
      @syedibrahim4543 Месяц назад +4

      That is what he mentioned out of 50000 people writing the exam , top 5000 is already the top 10% of the people wrote the exam . So all are qualified. It is not then like 2000 rank is a worst rank getting seat .

    • @shivaramprasadpulagam6655
      @shivaramprasadpulagam6655 Месяц назад +7

      Bcz of the opportunities the sc and st lost from generations culturally and economically….when I a, child sc and st used to sit on floor and used to come for less daily wages …they used to live in huts outside the village and live by eating mice ….so let them get seat …if your son is really good and hard working ….he will start a company and becomes ceo …who knows ?

    • @vaishnava6333
      @vaishnava6333 Месяц назад +2

      Sir you are only comparing one aspect.

    • @kumaragurubaraneb7805
      @kumaragurubaraneb7805 Месяц назад

      But take census in IIT... if reservation is not implemented their seats would have been plundered and no single marginalized people would have entered

  • @annamalaian0711
    @annamalaian0711 Месяц назад +80

    The only problem I have with reservation is “until when?” Do 2nd generation need reservation after their 1st gen availed reservation? 3rd? There has to be an end right? No political party will take the risk of losing vote by even talking of gradually removing reservation.
    Edit: I’m not against reservation. It is needed for a large section of the society. But my problem is with People who absolutely have no need of it but will still use it simply because it’s available. That is why I said about there has to be an end like 2nd gen or 3rd gen, while continuing reservation for 1st generation people who REALLY DESERVE RESERVATION.

    • @siramakr
      @siramakr Месяц назад +7

      Why are you bothered when education was denied did we count till which generation...

    • @annamalaian0711
      @annamalaian0711 Месяц назад +7

      @@siramakr Mr logic head. Education denied in past doesn’t affect 2nd generation and going forward. Even I’m first generation graduate from my family, but I didn’t use reservation in my life, even though I’m eligible. And I know that I don’t need it anymore. But still I can choose to apply reservation benefits to my child. This needs to stop. Why does a 2nd or 3rd generation need reservation? After a point, it’s just milking benefits as long as it exists.

    • @dra7682
      @dra7682 Месяц назад +5

      until Intercaste marriages become common and society accept it with open heart.

    • @CriticRoshun
      @CriticRoshun Месяц назад +4

      @@annamalaian0711 until the social justice is served and atrocities are stopped towards underprivileged.

    • @siramakr
      @siramakr Месяц назад +1

      @@annamalaian0711 don't just think about you.. you are not the only example...

  • @ShouvikRoy.
    @ShouvikRoy. Месяц назад +136

    If you want to remove reservation from the system, then remove caste system first . Then automatically caste based reservation will vanish😂. Work on the root cause not symptoms .

    • @thedeadwalkingguy
      @thedeadwalkingguy Месяц назад +28

      as long as there is reservation, there will be caste system............its complex....problem is those who need the reservation they stilll don't get tit......but some enjoy benefit for many generations

    • @jaikumar848
      @jaikumar848 Месяц назад +18

      ​@@thedeadwalkingguywhy cast exist in marriage? Because of reservation? If reservation removed then caste will abolish from marriage?

    • @janmejaypatel8228
      @janmejaypatel8228 Месяц назад +11

      Caste is there.... because it is given by the government.... congress wanted to keep this system...so that they can support muslim in india ..... simply divide and rule ..... remove reservation.... within 10 to 20 years there will be no caste.... guarantee 😂😂😂

    • @shivram8426
      @shivram8426 Месяц назад

      bull shit.....

    • @Poco-me5eq
      @Poco-me5eq Месяц назад +3

      Caste is simply a manifestation of differing abilities of people to get an education. Some castes simply cannot become educated.

  • @padmanabhanr4242
    @padmanabhanr4242 Месяц назад +34

    Bigger problem in India is corruption, violation of rules by most people. Singapore developed from almost nothing since its independence to a super developed country now. All people there follow rules be it citizen or politician or government office. In india, common man does not even wear a helmet when riding two-wheeler. Thillalangadi in most activities, frauds, scams etc..With such behaviour, nepotism, scams will never change in India..

    • @siramakr
      @siramakr Месяц назад

      I remember mahanathi dialogue of Rajesh to Kamalhasan...see it again...

    • @rajaramk8323
      @rajaramk8323 Месяц назад

      Baseless and meaningless speech

    • @onlineclashes2784
      @onlineclashes2784 Месяц назад

      The problem you are telling is in human nature and it's not only in india.
      Talk about man made problems.

  • @reallifelorehindi4133
    @reallifelorehindi4133 Месяц назад +29

    First time I have seen that a man who not enjoys any reservation still supporting reservation. you are genuine.❤

    • @Cosmochill-il7pt
      @Cosmochill-il7pt Месяц назад

      It should be actually be called "de reservation". All judiciary, bureaucracy, media, business and politics is dominated by certain castes. India has been ruled by oppression by brahmins and banias and reservations is needed to make a level playing field for all

  • @perumalnadar8321
    @perumalnadar8321 Месяц назад +12

    Mr PRS is right. People who are really talented don't prefer govt jobs 😂

  • @swapnilpupulwad9445
    @swapnilpupulwad9445 Месяц назад +4

    Being a teacher you have deep understanding of the social systems in this regard. Good insight.

  • @kevinpunmiya7397
    @kevinpunmiya7397 Месяц назад +59

    Imagine if margin requirements for reserved category was 30% lower than general. With the same strategies, their ROI will be much higher and all your clients will go to them, even though you’re much more productive and intelligent.
    That’s how reservation hurts India.

    • @jaikumar848
      @jaikumar848 Месяц назад +3

      Lets do caste and economic census of india and find out of SC/ST have millions

    • @kommuranjith7710
      @kommuranjith7710 Месяц назад +12

      Imagine ur not even allowed to do trading ,, trading is for certain caste ,,oh k constitution gave some rights for u to do trading ,,but u don't have funds because ur marginalised for years ,, all the better ways of earning are kept with few castes,,,no body is ready to let u earn better ways,,,due to ur caste ......

    • @newandhra
      @newandhra Месяц назад

      Compare the resources distribution also ....hypocrite😂

    • @newandhra
      @newandhra Месяц назад +2

      ​@@kommuranjith7710 Any way BSE and NSE are reserved for only Banias and Brahmins .....

    • @chitrambalam8509
      @chitrambalam8509 Месяц назад

      @@newandhra well said !!!

  • @Biju735
    @Biju735 Месяц назад +3

    Once I was not in favour of the reservation. Over the years I've seen that on the ground there is still rampant injustice and discrimination against lower castes even after 75 years of independence.
    If educated and relatively wealthy are not willing to give up their discriminatory mindset what is the logic for expecting lower and backward class giving up reservation?

  • @ayushkaushik9637
    @ayushkaushik9637 Месяц назад +50

    In Singapore, Indians, Chinese etc. are not given things. They are taking it due to their skills and competencies.

    • @janmejaypatel8228
      @janmejaypatel8228 Месяц назад +6

      Population of Singapore and India ... Sundar will not talk about that...

    • @siramakr
      @siramakr Месяц назад

      Non sense

    • @arjunganesan9067
      @arjunganesan9067 Месяц назад

      There exists inbuilt accomodation of all races to promote brotherhood when Singapore started building from scratch

  • @RK-rj1zn
    @RK-rj1zn Месяц назад +4

    hello sir. I may not agree with a few points and logic, but I really commend you for talking about socially relevant issue. It needs a lot of courage to speak about these issues.

  • @harshva1981
    @harshva1981 Месяц назад +38

    Can you implement reservation in Indian Cricket Team and expect India to win world cup.... If not then how can you expect ISRO DRDO or other govt agencies like BHEL SAIL etc to peroform at par with foreign counterparts

    • @marthandansk1991
      @marthandansk1991 Месяц назад

      True

    • @newandhra
      @newandhra Месяц назад +3

      Actually India is loosing more matches and won only two world cups because there is reservation.....yes reservation is verymuch needed in cricket team

    • @newandhra
      @newandhra Месяц назад +3

      If we implement reservations no team can ever beat INDIA ......

    • @aremvee29
      @aremvee29 Месяц назад +1

      All the space and defense organisations are provided with reservations and their success rate is much higher that bcci which is the most casteist institution . It is shame to compare cricket and ISRO

    • @varmanindia
      @varmanindia Месяц назад +1

      Without reservation india failed to win a cup since 2013 and did it this year only. So your perspective is wrong

  • @rpb4865
    @rpb4865 Месяц назад +24

    Difference is not 99 to 90. Difference is more like 95/98 to 55/60. So your analogy and whataboutism doesn't work in case of Indian reservation system

    • @thawsifsarve5554
      @thawsifsarve5554 Месяц назад +1

      They are securing less marks as they did not have same privileges to study. Who knows their parents might be illiterates

    • @arneshpalanisamy6352
      @arneshpalanisamy6352 Месяц назад

      He is talking about specifically Anna University counselling cut off. (Backed with data you can check it yourself). Tamil Nadu has done an amazing job in upbringing the OBC but not so much the SC/ST. There is this book titled "Dravidian years" by S Narayanan. You can read it which emphasizes the changes this brought about in the administration. It is a fair judgement which does speak that SC/ST have been ignored and post 2005 the innovative speciality/ extra ordinary contribution (TN had 5% of population of the country contributing 20% of the GDP) wore off.

  • @eranjaneyah1368
    @eranjaneyah1368 Месяц назад +3

    Most of the parents Of IAS and IPS are the same IAS and IPS, this will happen in india only

  • @raviprasad20
    @raviprasad20 Месяц назад +1

    Thank you for daring to speak on a tough subject. You have exposed me to new perspective

  • @eskutts
    @eskutts Месяц назад +14

    People want to end reservation but don't want end to casteism and discrimination, that's where the problem lies. People who have not faced any discrimination due to their religion or caste assumes that discrimination doesn't exist in the society today. And this issue is mainly prevalent in the rural areas of the country, so everyone must research on discrimination in the rural areas of the country and try to change their mindset about everything. They must think from others point of view/perspective.

  • @abubackersiddique707
    @abubackersiddique707 Месяц назад +8

    Though you have gone out of your syllabus, we appreciate your boldness to express yourself on social cause 🎉
    Hope you be more successful and we need people like you in our society 💐🌺🎉🌹
    Best wishes to you Sir 👍

  • @gabhjith5939
    @gabhjith5939 Месяц назад +19

    The problem is already well off second generation people are exploiting this system. they should have additional parameters like net income to avoid just caste based reservation to support the needy ones.

    • @kishor9023
      @kishor9023 Месяц назад +1

      This is a good idea. However it will not solve the reservation problem immediately because there are many waiting in the queue. it will take another century or more to be equal in income.

    • @kumaragurubaraneb7805
      @kumaragurubaraneb7805 Месяц назад +1

      It should b applied for higher caste also... they should have voluntarily given all their stakes in every sphere since they had got well off years before...

  • @aaarkp
    @aaarkp Месяц назад

    Spoken honestly and boldly. Much truth in what you say. Enough people like you speaking out CAN and WILL make a difference! Kudos to you!

  • @TheFKPM
    @TheFKPM Месяц назад +7

    Non Brahmin Forward community. NBFC

  • @triyambakatp4493
    @triyambakatp4493 Месяц назад +15

    Dear Mr Sundar
    Your point of view has some shortcomings.
    I wish to bring those points to your attention, with examples.
    Because of the reservation not properly restricted, the son of a cobbler has to compete with the son of an IAS officer. Do you think it is fair?
    Solution is, there must be a cap either by way of sieging the reservation for one generation or by putting income limits, that is creamy layer.
    Second example.
    Some forward community families have remained Purohits for generations and stayed economically weaker.
    Some SC ST families who took advantage of reservations, became financially very sound and have become ultra rich. But they still get reservations because they belong to SCST.
    Don’t you think this is injustice?
    Solution is, reservation only on economic grounds.
    It is good to have social justice, but it should be fair enough

    • @eranjaneyah1368
      @eranjaneyah1368 Месяц назад

      We don't have a proper system to gauge the economical condition, most of the property is black, so it is difficult to give reservation on the basis of economy. Ex. To get EWS reservation people are gifting their property to relatives and after getting job they are taking back.
      In our country even Ambani son can get income certificate with 30000 per annual

    • @triyambakatp4493
      @triyambakatp4493 Месяц назад

      True, but it may not be impossible to get some stringent laws. However injustice are to be resolved

    • @Biju735
      @Biju735 Месяц назад

      Once I was not in favour of the reservation. Over the years I've seen that on the ground there is still rampant injustice and discrimination against lower castes even after 75 years of independence.
      If educated and relatively wealthy are not willing to give up their discriminatory mindset what is the logic for expecting lower and backward class giving up reservation?

    • @aishwaryajawahar5694
      @aishwaryajawahar5694 Месяц назад

      How much percentage of Pandits/prohits are being economically weak and how much percentage of SC/ST in wealthy state... We cannot compare one on one but comparison on percentage basis ... Contrarily how much percentage of top management both in govt and private sectors are from SC/ST ... The answer to your question lies there ...

    • @triyambakatp4493
      @triyambakatp4493 Месяц назад

      It is not the question of percentage, examples are given for more clarity.
      Regarding the percentage of SCST officials in government of Karnataka , one will be surprised to see that more than 80% of higher positions are occupied by SCST because they enjoy reservation in promotions too. This may be the case in other states too.
      However in private sector, as there is no reservation, so things are different and only talent prevails.

  • @ghosh77
    @ghosh77 Месяц назад +1

    Which came first? Caste system or quota in govt. Jobs ?
    Which came first should go first.

  • @rohitmaharana1
    @rohitmaharana1 Месяц назад +14

    Ok but that's not true. The truth is that when a UC doc scores 90 in entrance, he gets to be a specialist, in the same exam ST/SC may get 20-30 marks and still be a specialist. Now these aren't the same grade! 99-100 sure but 20-100 are not the same grade

    • @newandhra
      @newandhra Месяц назад +2

      Because in majority of entrance exams EWC cutoff is faaarr lesser than sc/St cutoff

    • @varmanindia
      @varmanindia Месяц назад +1

      Which college in india gives reservation for sc st at 20,30 marks? Don't blabber. It's around 96% or above.

    • @sivaji2000
      @sivaji2000 Месяц назад

      @@varmanindia Your are actually blabbering....The difference is like 98 - 45.....Go and check cutoffs for various national level exams

    • @varmanindia
      @varmanindia Месяц назад

      @@sivaji2000 no way you get a medical seat for 45%. I'm talking pre neet.

    • @prsrivastav
      @prsrivastav Месяц назад

      ​Google it bhai for jee neet cutoff of obc @@varmanindia

  • @balajeed2037
    @balajeed2037 Месяц назад

    "Dear Mr. Sundar,
    I wanted to take a moment to express my heartfelt appreciation for your insightful video on reservation and reality in India, particularly in comparison to Singapore. Your explanation was crystal clear and provided a much-needed perspective on this important topic. Your efforts to educate and inform are truly valued and appreciated.
    Thank you for sharing your knowledge and expertise with us. Keep up the fantastic work!
    Best regards,
    Balajee D

  • @jayawantnajan223
    @jayawantnajan223 Месяц назад +7

    My respect towards P R Sunder increased many more times.

  • @dvr6311
    @dvr6311 Месяц назад +12

    A person who get into a good government job which means he can afford to give good education to their kids but they will also take reservation for their kids is it rite ?

  • @user-sp5me3vi3j
    @user-sp5me3vi3j Месяц назад +2

    Sir, please if you want to share your perspective then ok, but don't make judgements. I have a huge respect for you for your rest of the videos. There are soo many flaws and wrong informations that i can see here. Please don't make this kind of videos.

  • @manishjain7607
    @manishjain7607 Месяц назад +2

    Merit basis must choose govt

  • @CajjieP4Peace
    @CajjieP4Peace Месяц назад +2

    Mr PR Sundar im from Goa, I dearly follow both yours and Akshats daily uploads and in someway I consider Goans to be south Indians. North Indians look outwards whereas South Indians(and I mean in principle) look inwards. Thereby South Indians have more intellectual periscope to cognify Indias Problems. Period.

  • @kollurusubrahmanyam9861
    @kollurusubrahmanyam9861 Месяц назад +2

    Not Justified Mr Sundar......Thank god atleast the private sector is not filled with Reservation....

  • @VENKAT2070
    @VENKAT2070 Месяц назад +5

    Mr.Sundar is a great human being. I liked the way he donated in covid. Great knowledge 👏 please make such more videos atleast at the weekend's

  • @mattavinay
    @mattavinay Месяц назад +2

    More research is needed by you in this topic. Comparing India with Singapore is absurd. This is like a large cap stock being compared with Penny stock. Population explotion is the root cause of all problems.

  • @bhagwanmethe337
    @bhagwanmethe337 Месяц назад +11

    Your analogy can not be justifiable .

  • @SahilSharma-mu4uk
    @SahilSharma-mu4uk Месяц назад +1

    That is fine but i would like to hear only about the stock market from PR Sundar. Leave the reservation thing for the government

  • @AltAJAX
    @AltAJAX Месяц назад +4

    The more I watch You Sir, the more my RESPECT for you increases. ❤️😊

  • @rahulganapathy6094
    @rahulganapathy6094 Месяц назад

    Mr. Sundar you are absolutely right, i see lot of negative comments, i belong to a upper community and i completely understand the rationality and explanation given by you...More power to people like you who dare to speak the truth abd reality

  • @vishanthanm7687
    @vishanthanm7687 Месяц назад +25

    Reservation in now a days is a dumb ass... Reservation when it was brought in 90s the only intension is to apply that for only 3 years.. Not for infinity time period. Your info is completely wrong in JEE FC cut off is 93.23%, SC cut off is 60.09% 🤦‍♂️what is this huge difference?? Is it fair first. 60% candidate not knowing even proper english getting in IIT-C. Even the same difference for NEET. As you said if the difference was 1% or even 5% in marks is acceptable, where is 60 and 93 ??? The only intension here is vote bank, dalith population in India is far more than FC people, to get dalith votes nd retain authority political party play this game. If in Singapore Indians are given opportunity, in TN we have now more north indian workers.. Can you ask any reservation for north indian workers in TN for representation politically or judicially?? Then there will be riots next day in TN. Also who said you need to go to coaching ?? Book is in your hand, study & understand.. I studied my entire CA journey on my self.. Coaching is not a need its a luxury. Tomorrow will you ask all Backward caste people to go by rolls Royce since upper caste people are going? There are able to afford luxury they do. That's it.

    • @rajmohanksr
      @rajmohanksr Месяц назад +1

      Can u show some references that it was for 3 yrs only

    • @vishanthanm7687
      @vishanthanm7687 Месяц назад

      @@rajmohanksr Pls check the discussion papers of GOI (SC) orders, 1963

    • @kishor9023
      @kishor9023 Месяц назад

      I believe ur data is wrong, the difference should be for ST. We are not able to tolerate this inequalities for past 70 years. Think about their grand parents being treated like unequally for several centuries. his point is valid, we need to increase jobs, and stop nepotism.

    • @md8uniya684
      @md8uniya684 Месяц назад

      ​@@kishor9023 They don't know anything about untouchability.

    • @vishanthanm7687
      @vishanthanm7687 Месяц назад +1

      @@kishor9023 There is no point is saying to stop nepotism.. The nepotism which he meant is ILLEGAL as per Indian law.. A CAs son becoming a CA is not nepotism, a doctors son becoming a doctor is not nepotism.. If you come by supressing exams that is not nepotism that is cheating. So do you mean Ananth ambani is nepotism kids??? No, it's his wish, if that's nepotism then do you think he should give the business to ST people???

  • @tarunhashatn6748
    @tarunhashatn6748 Месяц назад +2

    Sir I am totally agree with you 💯

  • @ponparthi
    @ponparthi Месяц назад +1

    why sudden jump on topic outside stock market and option selling

  • @vijaykumarperumula5003
    @vijaykumarperumula5003 Месяц назад

    Sir it is very clearly explained, the problem is the scarcity of opportunities.... rather than reserving some opportunities for some sections.❤

  • @ranbirmarwah
    @ranbirmarwah Месяц назад +1

    Sir i love your boldness and your choice of topics for videos takes guts to so

  • @partha1kundu
    @partha1kundu Месяц назад +10

    When your son becomes ill go to and sc st doctor for operation...sitting in ac room, becoming financially independent you are talking like this...and what about the son of doctor is getting the reservation and son of begger has no reservation because he is upper class...if you want to see the effect just impose reservation in indian cricket

    • @Vlr09262
      @Vlr09262 Месяц назад

      Foolishness

    • @ramkumarganesan2144
      @ramkumarganesan2144 Месяц назад

      In TN dmk oppose NEET, but the entire dmk family gets treatment only in London.
      They believe only in white Oxford trained physicians

  • @gopinathn6602
    @gopinathn6602 Месяц назад +1

    U r great thinker for better India sir

  • @bhojyanaik0907
    @bhojyanaik0907 Месяц назад

    The explanation and examples given regarding reservations are awesome. Great, sir.🎉

  • @shreehariprasad6432
    @shreehariprasad6432 Месяц назад +3

    Lets do a social experiment and Allow people to choose what ever the caste they want just like they can change the religion or nationality

  • @reneevimal
    @reneevimal Месяц назад

    You have to think from the perspectives of all stakeholders rather than thinking from your own situational perspective. You earn in crores. How many people do you employ? Have the situation of reserved class changed even after 50 years? I feel whatever akshat talked made sense.

  • @Dinesh-sk1cp
    @Dinesh-sk1cp Месяц назад +1

    Very well explained sir, thank you 🙏🏻

  • @ironmanavengerss4959
    @ironmanavengerss4959 Месяц назад +1

    In mumbai engineering vjti college for general closing was 98 percentile and st was 19 percentile

  • @venup44
    @venup44 Месяц назад

    I think its blessing in disguise for OCs, as they are not even looking at government jobs, there by becoming entrepreneur and working in private jobs and getting richer.

  • @sukeshcjr6722
    @sukeshcjr6722 Месяц назад +1

    Agreed your point, sir! But your conclusion was based on Anna UNIVERSITY cut off.
    Please Check IIM - Ahmedabad Entrance cut off - General (80), OBC (75), SC (70), ST (60) These are percentiles, not percentage (There is a lot of difference)

  • @musicIfeelhappy
    @musicIfeelhappy Месяц назад

    Great to see some people still have guts to speak Truth 🔥

  • @AREntertainments5678
    @AREntertainments5678 Месяц назад

    Equal opportunity for everyone!! I got great respect for you Sir!

  • @Grga-y7x
    @Grga-y7x Месяц назад

    Mr P. R u r started attracting 90 percent of people in the state, u are preparing a long straddle to be a politician, all the best 🎉

  • @namdeolohakare5598
    @namdeolohakare5598 Месяц назад

    Good topic sir. It should be discussed and some remedies should be taken by government.

  • @reddynaveen975
    @reddynaveen975 Месяц назад

    My kind request to pr sundar is to protest for reservation of the scheduled people in stock market tooo . If you earn profit of 1cr(after paying taxes) give 30% of your money.

  • @AK-fy8qf
    @AK-fy8qf Месяц назад +1

    An obc getting 30% rebate and dalit 100% rebate in F&O while UC pays full premium. This slis reservation.

  • @miltonthiraviam4406
    @miltonthiraviam4406 Месяц назад +1

    Salute for your courage ❤indeed discussion

  • @ultimatechallenge540
    @ultimatechallenge540 Месяц назад +2

    Great video ❤

  • @velsinin
    @velsinin Месяц назад +1

    Hi Sir. I have great respect for you but whatever you said cannot be applied in India when you are talking about Job reservations Untill education the reservation is OK but after that y ur giving reservation which is non sense exams are common for all in that whoever scores higher mark give them the seat why u r bringing reservation in that

  • @sen101
    @sen101 Месяц назад +1

    I have great respect for you and your dedicated knowledge sharing. However My personal views in Singapore the point you mentioned about Chinese, Malay and Indians is rather race based allocation / representation and not reservation. If reservations are justified will you say the similar thing in sports as well!

  • @milindkamthe2286
    @milindkamthe2286 Месяц назад +1

    Problem is with the population. Govt should bring a law to curb the exponential increase in population. It will not benefit this generation but surely will the next 100 generations.

  • @Vivekkhanna1973
    @Vivekkhanna1973 Месяц назад +2

    Your analysis is not good......lacks maturity.

  • @necessities8713
    @necessities8713 Месяц назад

    Three things which you didn't consider sir:
    1. Basis of reservation can't be caste any more after 75 years.
    2. The problem is 2 percent people in govt job are deciding policies for the country which significantly impact even the rest 98 percent.

  • @aniketbarve2009
    @aniketbarve2009 Месяц назад +7

    change reservation from caste to economic status

    • @Arun123-w2x
      @Arun123-w2x Месяц назад +1

      Its already done. Upper caste also comes under reservation now

    • @drarunaj
      @drarunaj Месяц назад

      ​@@Arun123-w2xWhat about people who are well off and belongs to OBC/SC/ST??
      will they still get reservation??

    • @Arun123-w2x
      @Arun123-w2x Месяц назад

      @@drarunaj Thats based on creamy layer. i already mentioned about this in my main comment. If they come above creamy layer limit, they will not get reservation. its similar to upper caste reservation

    • @namdeolohakare5598
      @namdeolohakare5598 Месяц назад

      You are right

  • @nathu63
    @nathu63 Месяц назад

    People crying over jee cut off, dont worry you were never going to get selected😂

  • @Sympl3535
    @Sympl3535 Месяц назад +8

    Waste argument 😊
    I thought you might speak logically so watched whole video 😂

  • @vinaydwivedi187
    @vinaydwivedi187 Месяц назад +1

    Karnataka govt approved bill for reservation in pvt sector, who will pay taxes to these govt?

  • @shivram8426
    @shivram8426 Месяц назад +1

    Reservation is necessary but not for creamy layer... a single family taking over all reservations. But this is nonsense by this guy.

  • @ravulapraveen8914
    @ravulapraveen8914 Месяц назад

    Thanks for your humanitarian approach

  • @hallmark1969
    @hallmark1969 Месяц назад +1

    very true n good.respect your understanding

  • @chitrambalam8509
    @chitrambalam8509 Месяц назад

    Great that you supported reservation system despite you are belonging to FC. You are bold and practical!!!.

  • @kedarkulkarni2781
    @kedarkulkarni2781 Месяц назад

    My opinion is after 75 years of independence, do not increase the % of reservation but try to reduce for fair competition....
    This will curb the brain drain from India...
    Why Mr Sunder became citizen of Singapore... some government policies must have made him to escape India 😥

  • @user-er3cs5so3x
    @user-er3cs5so3x Месяц назад

    Congratulations for pr sundar sir this very good video I am a big fan of you I am a blind person from Andhra Pradesh from Anantapur district I am following your videos till now since 2022

  • @govind4k
    @govind4k Месяц назад

    I will start a honest political party and make you as party president. Fully agreed with you. You explain with examples that is like Kohinoor 🙏🙏

  • @AAvlogsNewZealand
    @AAvlogsNewZealand Месяц назад

    Nice antique Ganesha decor

  • @thomasstanly8205
    @thomasstanly8205 Месяц назад

    it is so clear that he is not addressing a lot of issues with the reservation system we are following now. In my opinion the problem is not reservation itself but the implementation is done purely for political gain

  • @DilipDeo2105
    @DilipDeo2105 Месяц назад

    Pointless discussion. There is nothing to be agitated about Akshat's view.
    Leave this for politicians to discuss.
    Better focus on your domain of expertise.

  • @amanpreetsidhu1467
    @amanpreetsidhu1467 Месяц назад

    you are wrong this time sir, difference between general and OBC or Sc is not 99 and 97 , for govt jobs if it is 92 for general then it is 48 for SC

  • @ushadevi-dy9ke
    @ushadevi-dy9ke Месяц назад +1

    Sorry Sunder you are wrong
    its injustice

  • @vijayanandr7294
    @vijayanandr7294 Месяц назад +1

    People often misunderstand this. "Reservation is not for uplifting economical status but the social status and representation". What qualification made Nirmala Sitharaman a Finance Minister in the first place? People will get affected but thats the karma of your forefathers. Peace✌

    • @nravis1
      @nravis1 Месяц назад

      She is an economist !!

    • @subramanianadaikalam9277
      @subramanianadaikalam9277 Месяц назад

      Joke. Reservation for OBC for 3rd generation now is unwarranted. It is the most abused vote bank politics. Soon, I would see 100% reservation. Because 95% of Indians are in reservation category now. You will continue to see brain drain and migration to greener pastures. It is not your salary income that is considered like EWS but it is other income more than 8 Lakhs (like your investments etc.,). Even if your salary is 3 Lakhs per month you can still get OBC NCL certificate. It is not right, it should be salary income and they can even raise it to 10 L per annum as well but 99% OBC gets OBC NCL certificate, no use of this and it is easy to get certificate by bribing too without much verification Only STs deserve reservation, even SCs are better off now and those you availed should make way for others who have not availed at all. No fucking politicians have spine to do these changes, we will continue to be doomed in corruption. Only 3-5% of people pay tax to manage education, health, infra etc.,

    • @subramanianadaikalam9277
      @subramanianadaikalam9277 Месяц назад

      It is the same qualification that Sonia got and Droupadi Murumu got. Sorry you cannot get reservation in politics, else Nehru would not have become PM then Indira then Rajiv then Sonia etc.,

    • @vijayanandr7294
      @vijayanandr7294 Месяц назад

      Don't we all know what President in India in reality means? Why not a powerful ministry given? Economical status is subjective but social status isn't. Also don't get diverted this is about Congress or BJP. It's the same across. Until there's a so-called elite caste person seen working in garbage collection or sewage cleaning, there's no equality that exists.

    • @vijayanandr7294
      @vijayanandr7294 Месяц назад

      @@nravis1 There are 'N' number of economists with Masters across communities. I'd be happy to see her as FM if she had contested and won the elections. Again this is not about BJP or Congress. This has been happening across.

  • @satishbhairannawar6793
    @satishbhairannawar6793 Месяц назад

    Kudos to u. Very few people speak daringly

  • @nathu63
    @nathu63 Месяц назад

    Man who understands Money, facts and figures will understand reservation🙇

  • @user-ib3of1xt9i
    @user-ib3of1xt9i Месяц назад

    தமிழர்களுக்கு மட்டுமே பகிர்ந்தளிக்கும் எண்ணம் அதிகமிருக்கு...

  • @anandpandya8673
    @anandpandya8673 Месяц назад

    It should be on the basis of economic background.

  • @dhirajwal5195
    @dhirajwal5195 Месяц назад

    Reservation was to bring equality in the society. We should do away with Reservation now in Jobs as well as Education. It has to be merit based.

  • @Martingale_Stochastic
    @Martingale_Stochastic Месяц назад +1

    You are saying this because you are in stock market trading community. The day you will face the situation where all risk is yours but 50% of your profit after taxes will be directed to SC ST trader because he couldn't trade then we will see what your reaction will be.
    Then you will understand how others feel when they don't get seat despite rank

  • @technicalexperience2785
    @technicalexperience2785 Месяц назад

    Very rarely i saw a person from upper caste, supporting the reservation system. The whole thing is consumed by the upper caste ppl due to undue social advantage. They never saw that, only concerned about peanut. All unsuccessful ppl from this group feels their reason of failure is reservation system. Cause of very bridge collapse & every unexpected death of a patient is imposed on lower caste engineering/doctor. If reservation system or even low caste ppl r removed totally, than also India is not going to change.
    Whatever logic u give, biased ppl will never understand.
    I salute u sir.

  • @bharathraj-mg9hx
    @bharathraj-mg9hx Месяц назад

    Problem in India is nepotism/castism, donation paid seats who buy degree with money. Reservation is the saviour of India.

  • @nomadseeker584
    @nomadseeker584 Месяц назад

    Lot of bold statements sir..kudos to you ! Ths s real indian 2 movie

  • @sandipvakude2377
    @sandipvakude2377 Месяц назад

    Sir,
    Very good view
    Why don't you stand for election ?
    Good people will always keep away from election & then bad people grab opportunities & form Govt.
    You have very large no.s of followers ...you definitely will win

  • @infinity3800
    @infinity3800 Месяц назад +8

    1.OBC Population--50-60% Reservation--27%
    2.OC Population in States--5-6%
    Reservation--10%

    • @newandhra
      @newandhra Месяц назад +1

      ​@DPRK442u please go and get signatures to prove that they are not with him....😂😂

    • @SandhyaRani-ev3yk
      @SandhyaRani-ev3yk Месяц назад

      ??? What do you mean???

    • @subramanianadaikalam9277
      @subramanianadaikalam9277 Месяц назад

      Joke. Go figure out. OC doesn't have reservation, it is EWS portion of OC that too 10% of the non reservation seats, which means only they have to score above OBC to get it. I hope you understand this fact. Why do OBC need reservation after 75 years .. people getting it continue to get for kids and their grand kids, come out of it and allow other OBC to benefit.

  • @bhaskarrao110
    @bhaskarrao110 Месяц назад

    Subdarji,
    I respect you a lot for your views on many things, especially finance. But this topic needs a wider discussion and debate. It shall not be a drawing room discussion. I support reservation, but with some rectifications. We all generally get biased depending on our socioeconomic status etc.

  • @parimp
    @parimp Месяц назад

    very useful video, giving a highly matured view.

  • @TheVillageLife-wz1ui
    @TheVillageLife-wz1ui Месяц назад +1

    If education and health services are free or funded 100% by Govt no reservation is required. Students can make their choice based on interest and grades they got. Instead fighting for reservation, more jobs have to be created so that everybody gets piece of cake.

  • @dvr6311
    @dvr6311 Месяц назад +2

    There are many OC as well who can’t afford to provide their children quality education how can they be ignored worst cast system

  • @hindushakthi6849
    @hindushakthi6849 Месяц назад

    But happening in reverse ,
    OC people are not getting jobs , SC ST people becoming rich and rich ,
    Reservation in IIT will drag the county growth ,
    as you said if one person having more Idlies he can share ,
    but there is no idlies for him , how he can share , if he share what he has
    he has to face hungryness .

  • @user-sp5me3vi3j
    @user-sp5me3vi3j Месяц назад +2

    Sir, I didn't think you should make these kind of videos.

  • @southcomet
    @southcomet Месяц назад +2

    Even if the FC community student put 200% effort govts reservation system ensures he won't get a seat in a good college forget top tier university... That's the undisputed truth practically seen... No matter how much ever drumming up support for reservation through all these channels...

  • @ahmedmudassar1404
    @ahmedmudassar1404 Месяц назад

    Beautiful and logical arguments

  • @manish4583
    @manish4583 Месяц назад

    There have been a lot of debate on whether reservation is good for society or bad for society.
    But no one talks about the casteism feeling still existing in the society.
    I am an admirer of akshat shriwastava ji for the various issue he has raised, but I would love to see him speaking on the bad effects of casteist/religious mindset of society and how it is destroying our nation.