INTEGRATING POK INTO INDIA / LT GEN PR SHANKAR (R)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 10 сен 2024
- #GUNNERSSHOT #InternationalRelations #UPSC #CSE #StrategicAffairs #defence
INTEGRATING POK INTO INDIA / LT GEN PR SHANKAR (R)
SHOT IS A CHANNEL FOR DEFENCE & STRATEGIC AFFAIRS, TECHNOLOGY AND WELFARE OF ARMED FORCES PERSONNEL.
GUNNERS SHOT is a channel in which the best of Indian Military and Strategic experts express their views and opinions.
GUNNERS SHOT is a non partisan channel devoted to high quality.
Support Gunners Shot with your contribution through GPay to +91 9384855773
SUBSCRIBE TO GUNNERS SHOT RUclips CHANNEL@ / @gunnersshot
SUBSCRIBE TO GUNNERS SHOT TECH CHANNEL @ / @gunnersshottech-jl6gp
Join the channel as a member @ / @gunnersshot
THIS VIDEO IS AVAILABLE IN PODCAST FORM @ / @gunnersshot
Gunners Shot RUclips Channel has multiple .playlists to enhance your viewing experience.
All articles are available @ www.gunnersshot.com
Follow Gunners Shot WhatsApp Channel @ whatsapp.com/c...
Twitter : @palepurshankar or @gunners_shot1
Join Telegram group @ t.me/gunnersshot
Disclaimer : Views expressed on this channel by this who appear on it are their personal opinions and can not be attributed to GUNNERS SHOT
The recent loss of soldiers is unacceptable however we should not let our emotions get the best of us.
Trust in our armed forces shouldn't falter as it is very easy for us to judge them from the comfort of our homes, the moment we start doubting our forces the enemy wins.
Jai Hind Jai Bharat 🇮🇳
@General Saab, thanks for the on-point analysis 🙏🏽
Brilliant Analysis Sir ! This channel is one of the most authentic channels on Bharatiya National Security. Analysis is based on deep thinking and highly insightful unlike most other channels who just talk on the surface. 🙏
The idea of using soft power in winning the people of the two regions of PoK and GB is a great idea especially via satellite and internet. Hats off to you for such a strategic vision.
Brilliant topic and insights.IA should have clarity how much GB/chitral to take back, role of afgans and neutralize ccp influence. Can have a show in details with y 56:47 our and col. Ajay Raina's thoughts.
Sat sri akaal honorable P R Shankar sahib ji as well all listners...
Salutations to the General for this Great strategy and insight.
While acquiring GB is brilliant, wouldn’t we get into a Bigger mess acquiring Azad Kashmir - where the people are indoctrinated with Anti-India ideology?
Moreover, would a Hindu majority Ruling Party be inclined to add more Muslims into India?
Bahot acha sir, aaj apne dil jeet liya
Thank you
Sir, I hope the people in power listen to you
Excellent realistic assessment General
I'm a Baloch but I agree with you ..dear Genral .R. Shankar ❤❤
Shankar Sir, you are right and agree with your options. Rightly said, we have to create conditions such that they look to join India.
Thank you sir to show us real situation in J and K
Correct way forward Sir
Sir, Thanks for setting the right narrative to address the kashmir issue. Sir, only request to you is to maximum the presentation screen, especially for people watching on mobile, where the content is difficult to read. Thanks 😊
Yes. XINJIANG...
Thank you for this video. Learned a lot.
Hello sir...
Apko aisa lagta nahi humne 1965 me haji peer passgain kiya tha par deplomatically khoya to abhi humare pass mauka aur dastur bhi hai aur isise hume poonch se srinagar distance cover karne me aasani ho jayegi
Son of India 🫡
Ji ja ji tumara pak
Agar hum unhae muslim ki nazar sae dekhaengae wo bhi hamain hindu sikh ki nazar se dekhaengae agar hum unhe apne hindustani bhai behan ki nazar se dekhengae they will reciprocate. General shankar the great is right we have to do something.
Thanks.
General Saheb, do not know about the past but at 1.04, you seem to have misunderstood what Suresh Mohite has written. His statement says, Pakistan thinks/believes that we/Indians are kamjor/weak and we cannot do anything. He was not saying that he thinks Indians are weak and cannot do anything.
Sorry if I have misread him
The economic interests of China in POK and GB are also to be taken into calculation if we start some activities to help the people of this area politically and financially. The another angle is our own internal constituencies which have certain other calculations as defined by some foreign agencies. So India has to devise strategies to tackle all the three adversaries and few more, how do you advise to tackle them. Regards
Lets not forget, Balochistan also wanted to accede to India but was taken over by Pakistan through force.
Quote from a news channel : On March 27, 1948, the All India Radio quoted VP Menon, Secretary of the Department of States, as saying that the Khan of Kalat had approached India for accession
General Saheb, at 58.00 It needed to be said, and I am glad that you have said about Israel army. Fan club of Israeli army is not limited to India. Though India has more fans. I am holding myself back from what I would like to say on the subject. Suffice to say, should not be compared with Indian army at all.
Having said that, sorry, I could not ask/repeat my question on live session as been travelling quite a bit. This is your first video I have seen since last week or so.
Thanks!
thanks a lot
I understand US forces are stationed in Pak for TTp etc .doubt India will do anything...could you pl discuss our readiness for war ..so long counter insurgency operations is no battle readiness
The economic interests of China in POK and GB are also to be taken into calculation if we start some activities to help the people of this area politically and financially. The another angle is our own internal constituencies which have certain other calculations as defined by some foreign agencies. So India has to devise strategies to tackle all the three adversaries and few more, how do you advise to tackle them. Regards ❤
Sir Rahul will not cooperate. He is like Jinnha
Lt gen Ravi, in my humble opinion our govt must pledge support internationally for the rights of baluchistan and Afghanistan claim of LOC. Politically they will be defeated, what do you think?
Oflate whatever is happening in J&K, it is being propagated by others as well. Pak at this stage alone can't afford to. My feelings sir. Jai hind
Ownership is 90 % of world international law.
Considering recent lok sabha results in JnK, how should gov approach for assembly elections? If given power separatists will enter gov machinery. Should GoI instead conduct panchayat/municipal elections and after few years conduct assembly election?
Sir, let us talk practical, we should be pragmatic in our approach, if politicians talk like that ,it is understood, you being a soldier should not talk that we will integrate POK into India. We are not even able to handle the situation in our own Kashmir and we are taking about taking pok back. If we as a country really want to do it, then first we should make our country strong. Pakistan also knows that indians keeping on talking high , but it comes to action, we lack
Hmm
There is hearsay that Pakistan is trying to convert Gilgit baltistan into 5th province.. Your views? Btw as always excellent session
Pak ,s fifth Provence will be iojk .
AbhiNonDones, come on
Hmm
Hello sir
Muje lagta nahi modi ki trump elect hone ke pahile cross border bada action lenge
Hello Sir, does the government hear and listen to everything you say here,? or is it just another Gunners Shot blog? How can we ensure they(the NDA government) will consider the points you have discussed here and take immediate action
Ask your friends or anyone you know to see this video
Great presentation Sir. I mostly agree with everything that you say, but there are some interesting points which I think you should consider and on which your thoughts will be interesting.
Unfortunately I can't post my thoughts/analysis on an open forum. Is there an email address or someplace I can send my thoughts to you. I can assure that I have some good thoughts and some genuine insights on this topic. Thanks. 🙏
send it to my email in the channel
Come and try
Don't try to win on table talks.
Hmm
don't you think first we should integrate Jammu first, integrating a land mass is of no use unless people who stay there get integrated, churan bejo, ok, but itna bhi nahi..!! after 75 years we should have learnt that..!!
Hmm
In matter of Pakistan , India needs to look outside rather than inside.
Pok mp seat in Parliyament
Judical system for Pok
Banking system for pok
Tv chanel
Hospital system für pok
!!!!!!
Xinjiang supoort case open!!
Thanks sir
Salo ja raha ha iojk tum sa sath Khalistan bi .pok aho tumara antamsovkar ready ha koh Hindu Kush welcome
Keep dreaming bhikario
Keep dreaming
Sir we are driven by Americans,I think IMF financing Pakistan bcos PM modi visited MOSCO
Hmm
Are we ready with cyber ...satellite...electronic war with Pak..China.?? With apologies I don't think we have modern warfare skill sets..including leadership....we should cordinate and sign a treaty with Afghanistan only they can help us
Why in the1971 war when pakistan was defeted and 97000 pakistan amry at our mercy we did not take POK. Mistake by congress Gov.?
no point looking over the shoulder
@@gunnersshotmap dal kar tum jeet nhi sakta .nonsense
Eik inch zamin nhi la sakka tum west pak ki .sari war harra ho west pak sa .azad kashmir GB cheena ha west pak na .lost was 27/2 tea machine .IAF surrender.
@@rajalapli3637bete IAF tumhari baap hai jisne f-16 giraya aur 80km andar balakot me ghus kar air strikes kiya.
Gilgit baltistan ka elaka tumne Raja Hari Singh se liya us time Kashmir & gilgit baltistan India ka part aur control me nahi tha.
1971 WAR me puri PAF aur Pak foj ko surrender karwaya tha karib 860 PAF ke officers aur jawano ne bhi surrender kiya tha hahahaa
West side me tumse Siachen,turtuk, tyakshi,dhotang, chalunka, Point 5310, Point 5770 Point 5608, quaid post bhi le liya tha
Next time pura pok lenge aur West Pakistan ko tor denge jese east pakistan ko tor ke alag kiya Humne with 93,000 surrender of pak military 😂
Aj Pakistan ek kangal bikari desh hai agar India chahe to Pakistan me behene wala sabhi rivers ka paani band kar ke Pakistan ko tabha kr sakta hai samjha
Pakistan ka end andar se hi hoga
ruclips.net/video/vn4PItA1yLk/видео.htmlsi=RY0Mq4N3dfqGLOWH
Pakistan west side me bhi hara
Rajnath Singh is incompetent
Hmm
Good morning Sir, great inputs, 👌 Show. need one clarification. Do you discuss these points with the upper circles of the present govt? Great show
They will see it now
Nation is only concerned eith Yogi Modi..kejriwal not realzing at the border we are loosing at the hands of Pak..US ..loosing bravehearts....i feel very sad for their familes ...Modi has no spine against joint Pak US China assault ...Putin will not intervene
Modi has lost vigor. He is more interested in promoting his personality like what Nehru did. He should step down
Hmm
Nehru's incompetence has to be rectified by force. Period.
Hmm
Hahahaha, kar k delhao, ABE NANDAN
Thanks
Paise kaha se mil rahe hai ? ISI ko paise de kaun raha hai ? Woh paise locals ko kaise pahuch rahe hai ? If India is going to become a 5 trillion economy, with a high degree of self sustainability, wouldn't that mean BJP is doing everything right ?
Aim across the LOC all you want, but the answers to foundational causes behind this conflict lie closer to home also.
Our system is not able to contain 120 km by 70 km plot 😂😂😂 how will they manage karakoram highway...
Eik inch zamin nhi la sakka tum west pak ki .sari war harra ho west pak sa tum.azad kashmir GB cheena ha tum sa pak na .lost was tea is a fantastic .great power west pak zindabad .
@@rajalapli3637 Abe kis jooth ki duniya me jee raha hai tu
ek Inch nahi bahut Sara elaka west pakistan se le liya India ne aur West side me bhi Pakistan buri tarah se Hara ye baat khud pakistani retired officers bol chuke hai mere pas proof bhi hai.
Gilgit baltistan ka elaka tumne Raja Hari Singh se liya tha us time Kashmir Raja Hari Singh ke control me tha India ke control me nahi. India ne 2/3 kashmir apne pas rakha Pakistan se kahi Jayda.
West Pakistan me 1965 war ke Pakistan ka Lahore, Sialkot, Hajipir, dograi samet 1,959 sqkm area le liya tha aur Un ke vaje se baad me wapas de diya
1971 me tumhara pura east pakistan le liya humne aur west side me Pakistan ka turtuk including Turtuk, Dhothang, Tyakshi (earlier called Tiaqsi) and Chalunka of Chorbat Valley sab le liya tha. Pakistani Sindh ka 4,000 sqkm bhi india ne apne kabze me le liya. 1987 me qamar sector ka elaka bhi Pakistan se le liya. 1999 me Point 5608 aur point 5310, point 5770 bhi Pakistani elake se le liya. 1984 me Siachen Pakistan se le liya
Next time pok bhi le lenge
F-16 shot down fantastic, 93,000 surrender fantastic
Wait and watch.Jk complete part of India
Hmm