Get Nebula with 40% off annual subscription with my link: go.nebula.tv/realtimehistory Watch 16 Days in Berlin: nebula.tv/videos/16-days-in-berlin-01-prologue-the-beginning-of-the-end Gift Nebula to a friend: gift.nebula.tv/realtimehistory
I would love a Real time History on the Military reform and political shifts that happened post-war and how it leads us into the Modern Military settings or a similar 2 hour piece on the War on terror
Democracy is a lie! It is not democracy! Democracy works till to about 300 people, fully informed, intelligent, steady informed! That is not the reality with modern so called democracies! It's a Playboy show to get the votes using the primitive levels and temporary affections of the general people crowds driven by style, fashion... Thats not democracy . Democracy originally originated in European Greece...where smart, intelligent people voted.and discussed their decisions. They steadily actively participated...
I never understood why America didn't realise from the massive French effort and defeat that this was a conflict that couldn't be won by military means.
America was hot off of two world wars where it both got to play with kid gloves compared to the other nations and financially straddle its own alliance, and saw itself as the pre-eminent world power by the time the French left Vietnam, there's no way it wasn't going to try.
After the fall of China to Communism in 1949, America could not allow French prestige to drop in the late Fifties and early Sixties; France at that point was nearly Communist. The threat to post war Europe of a potentially Communist France was real. So the US took this role for them.
My dad was born in Vietnam in the 60s he said he remembers seeing dead people burning and that in the jungle one of the ways the Vietnamese could tell when the Americans was close by was by the smell of their aftershave
You forgot to mention that during the Japanese occupation, Ho Chi Minh had put together a large insurgency to fight the Japanese. During this time the Allies had received news that Japan was planning to invade India, so both Britain and the USA asked Ho Chi Minh if he would assist the Allies with fighting the Japanese. He said he would if they promised two items: Keep the French out of Vietnam after the war and allow Vietnam their rightful independence at the same time. Both Britain and the USA promised both. Consequently, the Brits sent a special unit called the Chindits into Vietnam and the USA a special unit called Merrill's Marauders, both supported locally by Ho Chi Minh's insurgency. They sabotaged and fought the Japanese to the end of the war and helped hold down several divisions, thereby diverting the Japanese plan to invade India. After Japan was defeated the Allies reneged on their promise to Ho Chi Minh and allowed the French to return. In addition, independence was put on the back burner. Ho Chi Minh opposed the return of the French and severely defeated them at the Battle of Dien Bien Phu. In addition Vietnam was divided by the Allies, the Soviets getting North Vietnam and the western Allies administering South Vietnam through the USA. These factors helped set up the early ingredients of the cause of the Vietnam War. Thousands of lives lost on both sides, including the killing of civilian populations and the tremendous carnage of the environment through the spraying of agent orange and the dropping of cluster bombs. And the rest is history.
The unique thing about Vietnamese Communists is that they the only communists that got into power by their own struggle agaisnt forreign occupants, not set up by a Communist superpower nor through subversion of a non-communist sovereign state. So Communism became cohesive with patriotism in Vietnam. Is not a coincidence when the so-called "Nationalistic", "Democratic" RVN were filled with former French collaborators. And the ones who fought agaisnt the French were consisted of either Communists and Communist sympathizers.
@@ucnguyenanh9414nếu cộng sản viêt nam không chấp nhận bán Hoàng sa và Trường sa cho Trung quốc thì làm gì thắng được😅. Hãy đọc bản cam kết của Phạm văn đồng ký rồi hả nói chuyện
They was no promise. Read Logevall's Embers of War--there was no promise. As much as the Americans hated French Colonialism, they feared Communism expansion worst.
@geologyandchill: For me the most "awesome" thing about this video was that it described the Tonkin Gulf incident as though it had really happened instead of revealing the truth that it was a lie concocted by McNamara in his imagination, or that it wasn't revealed to be a lie until decades after the Vietnam War had ended. Just as justice delayed is justice denied, a truth withheld is a lie preserved.
@@mrcheese7944: I'd be interested to read your thoughts about what I wrote in my reply if you wrote them in standard English, but I don't read emoticons.
My grandfather fight in the Vietnam war to chase away the French and American away from their one world order ideology. And he is true from what we see today. What a great vision he and his generation have. 🎉
Càng tìm hiểu, càng thấy các cụ nhà mình ngày xưa siêu ghê. Đời đời biết ơn các anh hùng, liệt sĩ đã ngã xuống vì độc lập dân tộc và thống nhất tổ quốc!
Miền Nam Việt Nam muốn độc lập khỏi miền Bắc Việt Nam. Một triệu người đã chạy vào miền Nam vào những năm 1950 để thoát khỏi chủ nghĩa cộng sản. Hồ Chí Minh đã giết hàng trăm ngàn người dân của mình vào thời điểm đó.
@@cyclone8974Considering how the population is a total of 34 million, then it makes sense that most of the population liked or tolerated Ho's government
Congratulations to an excellent 2+ hours documentary on the Vietnam War 1955 - 1975. I especially appreaciate that the documentary allowed several sides to witness in quotes and interview segments what really happened. I also appreciated that you dug into the two sideshows Laos and Cambodia, which most American documentaries just pass by as almost forgotten parts of the First and Second Indochina War. I myself was a young 23 year old TV reporter and war correspondent for Swedish TV News, based in Bangkok from 197 onwards,, focusing on the three sideshows Laos, Cambodia and Thailand, I totally agree with your conclusions in the epilogue. You did a great job! I hope many Americans will watch this documentary. It should be shown at all major universities and colleges in the history, polirical science and social science departments.
I'm a Nebula subscriber, but the home page design keeps me from finding the content I want to find. So, I end up watching what you release on RUclips, while missing what goes up on Nebula.
@JB-yb4wn not yet, I'd love to check it out though This war is so underreported such as the Korean War There is alot of information that we know that isn't being released to the public it seems.
38:00 I was a democrat for 15 minutes as a kid. I was a mc’publican for many years. Duped by the corporate media. Now I am a patriot who no longer believes ANY of the corporate oligarchy’s propaganda or anything their bogus uniparty says or does. What’s this have to do with Vietnam? It was Vietnam when the land of the free, home of the brave lost her way. We haven’t rediscovered it yet. Maybe last weeks epic election is the first baby step? I hope so. Almost 59,000 American and 2M Vietnamese souls call out for a new time of justice. We must reform. Or we, like all empires before us, will collapse under our own weight. And if asked many around the world might say “rightfully so.” I love my country. But we must prioritize our moral compass once again lest we be despised by humanity. The human race who cannot understand why the only people who cannot see it…are us.
They did know it but they were too afraid of defeat until the country itself went to war against the war. It says in the documentary they were afraid of China and being the responsible for the fall of the country to communists.
It's always interesting to see how much you can distill a war down to the nuts and bolts. To realize that those 8 years of direct intervention boiled down to a documentary that's less than three hours is both impressive on the part of Real Time History and depressing with the scope of the war. For every second of this video, roughly 6 American soldiers were lost.
37:28 in 2007 I worked for a big News-Talk radio station in LA. Through the course of my regular duties I met numerous very interesting people. One luncheon I will remember forever. My guest was former PLO. His previous job was building explosives. Deployed against Christians visiting the Holy Land. Like Saul of Tarsus in the Bible. He killed Christians. This gentleman (yes, gentleman) had himself become a Christian many years earlier and was then working in the mission field. The exact same field that was his target in the early 1980’s. His name was Kamal Saleem. He looked at me across the table with black eyes that seemed to peer through the ages. “My friend what the West will never fully and truly understand? You may own all the watches. Every single one. But the Arabs? Arabs own the time.”
Many people still don't understand how crazy the Battle Ia Drang was. It was basically our best regiment against theirs. We would not have won without Hal Moore and Hueys.
34:25 Jesse, Your pronunciation of Iroquois (ii-ruh-kwa) is correct by Canadian standards, but all the US Army chopper pilots I knew called it the Huey. If they said Iroquois, they pronounced it ii-ruh-koy. PS A friend of mine commanded a squadron of Army helicopters, a mix of Hueys and OH-58s. The official name of the OH-58 was the Kiowa, but everybody in the squadron called it the Little Bird. My friend let me ride along on a lieutenant's checkride in an OH-58. After the LT completed his checkride, the WO swapped me into the pilot's seat and I got to fly the bird. Fun. I had no problems flying the bird in motion, but I failed to hover steady. Takes practice.
@@thatguythedude1563 No, I am not wrong. I accept that you pronounce Iroquois correctly, but US Army chopper pilots called it ii-ruh-koy when they used the official name -- which was almost never. Maybe they were wrong, but that is how they pronounced it. Mostly they avoided Iroquois. They called it Huey.
@@hlynnkeith9334you are actually 100% correct…they called them Hueys. My father was a 1st Lieutenant in Vietnam…& he has actually written a couple books about his experiences in the war. When I was younger…I actually spent 5 weeks in Vietnam with him. We flew into Hanoi…& drove all the way down south to Saigon…(Ho Chi Min City).
1:02:35 I never heard of a 106mm recoilless rifle. I thought perhaps you mistook a 105 for a 106. I looked it up with an AI search. To wit: The 106mm recoilless rifle, also known as the M40, is a portable, crew-served anti-tank weapon developed by the United States. Although its caliber is often referred to as 106mm, it is actually 105mm, with the 106mm designation intended to prevent confusion with incompatible 105mm ammunition from the earlier M27 recoilless rifle. So we were both right!
My dad fought in this war. A Purple Heart Sargent. He passed away a few years back. He told me that they put kids in trees to shoot you, if you didn’t shoot them you was dead. Our men would come up on camps, and they would be cooking there dog outside over fire, because lack of food. Dad told me he could not tell me everything, tears would start in his eyes when he would talk about in. He said we never want war on our own turf, and Japan can take us out without firing one shot😢
And the VC and NVA understood the body count idea very well, even though we killed huge numbers of them we could never find the bodies. They out played our game.
@@marknewton7539: I stand corrected. I admit that I didn't watch the whole video and wrote what I did in anger after the video seemed to be saying that the Tonkin Gulf incident had actually happened.
Books mentioned as sources in this documentary (in order of appearance): •Vietnam: History, Documents and Opinions on a Major World Crisis by Marvin E. Gettleman (1966) •The Vietnam War: A Concise International History by Mark Atwood Lawrence (2008) •The Vietnam War: An Encyclopedia of Quotations by Howard J. Langer (2005) •When Heaven and Earth Changed Places: A Vietnamese Woman’s Journey from War to Peace by Le Ly Hayslip & Jay Wurts (1989/2017) •The Vietnam War by David L. Anderson (2005) •Lyndon Johnson and the American Dream by Doris Kearns Goodwin (2019) •The Indochina Wars: Great Power Involvement- Escalation and Disengagement by Marek Thee (1976) •Patriots: The Vietnam War Remembered From All Sides by Christian G. Appy (2004) •The Vietnam wars by Kevin Ruane (2000) •Working Class War: American Combat Soldiers and Vietnam by Christian G. Appy (1993) •A Rumor of War by Philip Caputo (1977/2017) •U.S. Marines in Vietnam: The Defining Year 1968 by Jack Shulimson, Leonard A. Blasiol, & Charles R. Smith (1997) •Vietnam-Perkasie: A Combat Marine Memoir by William D. Ehrhart (1995) •Withdrawal: Reassessing America’s Final Years in Vietnam by Gregory A. Daddis (2017) •Vietnam: The Definitive Oral History Told From All Sides by Christian G. Appy (2008) •Grunts: The American Combat Soldier in Vietnam by Kyle Longley (2008) •Australia and the Vietnam War by Australian Department of Veterans’ Affairs (AnzacPortal) (2023) •U.S. Army Special Forces 1961-1971 by Francis J. Kelly (2015) •Russians Acknowledge a Combat Role in Vietnam by Francis X. Clines for The New York Times (1989) •At War in the Shadow of Vietnam: U.S. Military Aid to the Royal Lao Government 1955-75 by Timothy Castle (1993) •Moua Thao (video interview) by EGUSD Oral Histories Project aka Time of Remembrance (2016) •Back Fire: The CIA’s Secret War in Laos and Its Link to the War in Vietnam by Roger Warner (1995) •Why Vietnam Invaded Cambodia: Political Culture and the Causes of War by Stephen J. Morris (1999) •Disturbed Forests, Fragmented Memories: Jarai and Other Lives in the Cambodian Highlands by Jonathan Padwe (2020) •Fire and Rain: Nixon, Kissinger, and the Wars in Southeast Asia by Carolyn Woods Eisenberg (2023) •Vietnam in Military Statistics: A History of the Indochina Wars 1772-1991 by Michael Clodfelter (1995) •Historians and the Vietnam War: The Conflict Over Interpretations Continues by George W. Hopkins (2000) •The Media and the Military: From the Crimea to Desert Strike by Peter Young & Peter Jesser (1997) •The Media at War: Communication and Conflict in the Twentieth Century by Susan L. Carruthers (2011)
I've been listening to your guy's videos while on my break at work, before i go to sleep, while going for a walk. They are so immersive that even without the video and graphics, it is so well explained that you can follow exactly what is happening as it's happening (almost in real time 😉)
@@realtimehistory You guys are the best, regardless of budget. The only real adversary your videos have in terms of depth is the Battlefield series which was produced something like 30 years ago. Keep it up please! History nerds like me appreciate the time you put into these series.
Some of the very important things you missed were that Strategic Hamlets were not "Strategic" they were almost always concentration camps. As per stated the a US report on the conditions of strategic hamlets. Another things was that Deim's brother Nhu was the head of SV secret police. Responsible for mass crackdowns and deaths.
I understand that my Grandfather was a much kinder and thoughtful man before he had gone overseas. And he was quite literally nothing of the man he once was when he came back to his wife. I've always known how fortunate I was for never having to go to such a place in my lifetime.
@@SkanzoolNot really the French have a poor war record, the Algerians didn't have guns for those 150 years but the second they did the French got kicked out.
I’ve had these honor and pleasure of meeting several Vietnam war veterans at my job in the last 13 plus years; however, they’ve retired or moved on in recent years. As a US Navy veteran myself, it’s been an incredible experience to discuss their journey there and back. 🇺🇸☝🏻
I deployed to Iraq with a 1SG who was a Vietnam war vet. 1SG Yakoogi, with the 1st en bn. Funniest man I ever met. They forced him to retire when we got back in Dec 07😢
@@RebelliousEra what could possibly be confusing aside from possibly 1SG? I'm sure even navy guys would recognize the rank, they see marines all the time.
Some mis information here: 6:00 that was the exaggerate number, there was various estimated numbers from different sources, but evidence only showed close to 5,000 were executed. There weren't even that many landlords. And those executed were not North Vietnamese, they were mostly Hoa Chinese who where former French Henchmen brought to Vietnam during the colonization. The Hoa Chinese control 80% of Vietnam rice market and land before 1954 while working for the French.
Born in 1955, I grew up as a "news junkie" throughout this period. What you have presented is nothing new to me. Still, your presentation is a useful review of the period.
@@joshjwillway1545 An aware person had to keep their eyes open and their head "on a swivel". I remember watching Uncle Martin's speech at the Lincoln Memorial. There were all these guys wearing paper hats. Still, "judged by the content of their character, not the color of their skin" really stuck in my mind. Now, the "woke"/DEI crowd says that I'm "racist" for believing in racial equality. I am the staff armed guard at a large, Black church, willing to die to protect my family on any given sunday. Our world is upside down.
They left out the promises made to Ho Chi Minh if he and his insurgent army helped the Brits and Americans fight the Japanese occupation. Those promises were never to allow the French back into Vietnam after the war and give Vietnam total independence. Not very balanced in my view and in the end total betrayal.
Our 1813 Campaign video was a big flop, so we stopped with that era for a while. But we're going to to do some more 19th century content next year and will probably return to the Napoleonic Wars again.
@@realtimehistory I loved the 1813 video and hope to see the entire "downfall" covered. The parallels with both WW1 and 2 are breathtaking and need to be revealed. "If you build it, they will come" even though a bit more slowly than either you or the algorithm would like!
The way my country threw garbage on me when I returned to San Diego and kicked me out of bars is the worst memory, I have from this conflict. The USA treated us the worst imo.
My grandfather always told me it wasn’t like that when he got back after 3 tours. But he was living right outside Austin Texas on a ranch at the time so maybe that’s why he got the hero’s welcome lol I say hate the politicians not the soldiers.
I was on a US Navy ship that picked up 1100 "boat people" off the coast of Vietnam Jan-Feb. 1981. One of these people was a former ARVN Major. He had been on the run since 1975 when SVN fell to the Communists. He had been to several US Army schools while serving in the ARVN and told me "I was stunned how many of my fellow Officers, Enlisted men, friends, relatives were secret supporters of the Communists. No wonder we were defeated. But, the first people the Communists rounded up were those "supporters" (traitors to the ARVN, SVN) and they were either shot or sent to the camps." He just managed to escape on a boat with his family. There are a lot of reasons why the ARVN, SVN. USA were defeated and it was a terrible policy to become in involved with that conflict starting back in 1945 by supporting the French efforts. Just a great example of the failure of the USA being the "world policeman" and JFK's disaster of "Go anywhere, pay any price"...etc....
Communist doctrine has for long standardized the elimination of the “useful idiots” as a first step when taking control, as those people are seen as being easily led to oppose communist control once it occurs - the idea that those who oppose whomever is in charge, just because they are in charge, are not worth keeping around.
The Tonkin Gulf incident remained well concealed lie for decades after the Vietnam War had ended; it never happened and was nothing more than the creation of McNamara's imagination; please don't take my word for this, look it up; there is an excellent video about this right here on RUclips. The Vietnam War wasn't fought to stop the spread of communism, and, ultimately didn't, but for nothing more than the financial benefit of the American Military Industrial Complex. The Vietnam War not only to provided the American Military Industrial Complex with a huge market for their goods, but with a real war in which to test them, and those people couldn't care less about how many thousands of lives were lost in that testing. It was for that alone that at least 58,000 Americans came home in body bags and three to four times as many came back with major, serious bodily injuries (loss of arms, legs, sight, PTSD, etc.) which pretty much ruined what was left of their lives. And let's not forget about the horrifying effects of the use of agent orange, not just on our own troops years after the war was over, but on the civilian population of Vietnam.
I've nearly finished Max Hasting's epic 2018 story of the Vietnam conflict which, while it has one or two perhaps-inevitable limitations, is generally brilliant. But, I have to say, although it's obviously a different communication mode, this is even better. "Magnificent" would my adjective of choice.
I'm not going to lie when it comes to the section on the Tet offensive I feel like you guys should have covered a few more battles because the battle for Hue was not even the worst. I do think that was a bit of a miss
The way the Vietnam War went for the US largely resembles the way the Afghanistan War went for the US years later. Lol. I'm assuming there was no way for anyone to know what tactics the Taliban would use, but if there was any idea that, considering the terrain, and the defeat of the Soviet Union in the same area, it would be even just slightly similar to the tactics used in Veitnam, somebody could have possibly prevented or lessened the number of troops lost in Afghanistan
Get Nebula with 40% off annual subscription with my link: go.nebula.tv/realtimehistory
Watch 16 Days in Berlin: nebula.tv/videos/16-days-in-berlin-01-prologue-the-beginning-of-the-end
Gift Nebula to a friend: gift.nebula.tv/realtimehistory
I would love a Real time History on the Military reform and political shifts that happened post-war and how it leads us into the Modern Military settings or a similar 2 hour piece on the War on terror
Semper Fidelis, 3:17 ...
Fail, how could you leave out the Gulf of Tonkin incident? Kinda a big part in how the U.S. got dragged into this shitstorm.
Democracy is a lie!
It is not democracy!
Democracy works till to about 300 people, fully informed, intelligent, steady informed!
That is not the reality with modern so called democracies!
It's a Playboy show to get the votes using the primitive levels and temporary affections of the general people crowds driven by style, fashion...
Thats not democracy .
Democracy originally originated in European Greece...where smart, intelligent people voted.and discussed their decisions.
They steadily actively participated...
😊😊
I’m here because my wife doesn’t wanna hear about Space Marines anymore when she goes to sleep.
Your wife only wants to hear about Chaos space marines. Most wives love CSM.
Mine is tired of Infographic narration. 😂
So you got the next closest thing. That’s hilarious to me. Bro is addicted 😂
Divorce.
I wish I could like this comment twice were in the same spot 🤣
I never understood why America didn't realise from the massive French effort and defeat that this was a conflict that couldn't be won by military means.
America was hot off of two world wars where it both got to play with kid gloves compared to the other nations and financially straddle its own alliance, and saw itself as the pre-eminent world power by the time the French left Vietnam, there's no way it wasn't going to try.
Seriously..? It all stems from Truman and De Gaulle's 5th republic. Besides Johnson was a slave to the military industrial complex.
Ego and pride
Population Control War
After the fall of China to Communism in 1949, America could not allow French prestige to drop in the late Fifties and early Sixties; France at that point was nearly Communist. The threat to post war Europe of a potentially Communist France was real. So the US took this role for them.
Valeu!
My dad was born in Vietnam in the 60s he said he remembers seeing dead people burning and that in the jungle one of the ways the Vietnamese could tell when the Americans was close by was by the smell of their aftershave
You forgot to mention that during the Japanese occupation, Ho Chi Minh had put together a large insurgency to fight the Japanese. During this time the Allies had received news that Japan was planning to invade India, so both Britain and the USA asked Ho Chi Minh if he would assist the Allies with fighting the Japanese. He said he would if they promised two items: Keep the French out of Vietnam after the war and allow Vietnam their rightful independence at the same time. Both Britain and the USA promised both. Consequently, the Brits sent a special unit called the Chindits into Vietnam and the USA a special unit called Merrill's Marauders, both supported locally by Ho Chi Minh's insurgency. They sabotaged and fought the Japanese to the end of the war and helped hold down several divisions, thereby diverting the Japanese plan to invade India.
After Japan was defeated the Allies reneged on their promise to Ho Chi Minh and allowed the French to return. In addition, independence was put on the back burner. Ho Chi Minh opposed the return of the French and severely defeated them at the Battle of Dien Bien Phu. In addition Vietnam was divided by the Allies, the Soviets getting North Vietnam and the western Allies administering South Vietnam through the USA. These factors helped set up the early ingredients of the cause of the Vietnam War.
Thousands of lives lost on both sides, including the killing of civilian populations and the tremendous carnage of the environment through the spraying of agent orange and the dropping of cluster bombs. And the rest is history.
The unique thing about Vietnamese Communists is that they the only communists that got into power by their own struggle agaisnt forreign occupants, not set up by a Communist superpower nor through subversion of a non-communist sovereign state. So Communism became cohesive with patriotism in Vietnam. Is not a coincidence when the so-called "Nationalistic", "Democratic" RVN were filled with former French collaborators. And the ones who fought agaisnt the French were consisted of either Communists and Communist sympathizers.
@@ucnguyenanh9414nếu cộng sản viêt nam không chấp nhận bán Hoàng sa và Trường sa cho Trung quốc thì làm gì thắng được😅. Hãy đọc bản cam kết của Phạm văn đồng ký rồi hả nói chuyện
@@ucnguyenanh9414 Them and the Yugoslavs
Now I understand the whole problem better.
They was no promise. Read Logevall's Embers of War--there was no promise. As much as the Americans hated French Colonialism, they feared Communism expansion worst.
almost 3 hours of free amazing documentary!!! thank you so much, this is awesome!
@geologyandchill: For me the most "awesome" thing about this video was that it described the Tonkin Gulf incident as though it had really happened instead of revealing the truth that it was a lie concocted by McNamara in his imagination, or that it wasn't revealed to be a lie until decades after the Vietnam War had ended.
Just as justice delayed is justice denied, a truth withheld is a lie preserved.
Almost 4 hours if we include adds 🥹
You should check out “The Vietnam War” by Ken Burns, 10 part 18hour documentary!!! Really in depth and interesting.
@@Merlinever😮😮😅 19:59
@@mrcheese7944: I'd be interested to read your thoughts about what I wrote in my reply if you wrote them in standard English, but I don't read emoticons.
My grandfather fight in the Vietnam war to chase away the French and American away from their one world order ideology. And he is true from what we see today. What a great vision he and his generation have. 🎉
For those that make it to the end. The plug for 16 Days in Berlin and Rhineland 45 are both absolutely worth it !
Love these detailed videos of all conflicts. This is the way
Probably in my top 2 documentary's specifically with the Vietnam War. Excellent
Sometimes it's wild to think that most important part of human history is actually wars. Most geopolitical map is based on them.
That's why I'm interested in the wars. The history of nations is modelled after the wars they fought
Càng tìm hiểu, càng thấy các cụ nhà mình ngày xưa siêu ghê. Đời đời biết ơn các anh hùng, liệt sĩ đã ngã xuống vì độc lập dân tộc và thống nhất tổ quốc!
Do Viet Cong, khong hieu tai sao nguoi viet di giet nguoi viet.
Miền Nam Việt Nam muốn độc lập khỏi miền Bắc Việt Nam. Một triệu người đã chạy vào miền Nam vào những năm 1950 để thoát khỏi chủ nghĩa cộng sản. Hồ Chí Minh đã giết hàng trăm ngàn người dân của mình vào thời điểm đó.
@@cyclone8974Considering how the population is a total of 34 million, then it makes sense that most of the population liked or tolerated Ho's government
@@cyclone8974 không có CIA thì Diệm đã chết ở cái nhà nguyện nào đó bên trời Âu chứ không phải trong thùng xe quân sự. "Miền Nam" là "miền Nam" nào?
🥰💝Vietnam
Such a great video! Thanks for your incredible effort! What's your plan for the next year?
I haven't looked at our production planner today, but I'm pretty sure it's world domination.
Congratulations to an excellent 2+ hours documentary on the Vietnam War 1955 - 1975. I especially appreaciate that the documentary allowed several sides to witness in quotes and interview segments what really happened. I also appreciated that you dug into the two sideshows Laos and Cambodia, which most American documentaries just pass by as almost forgotten parts of the First and Second Indochina War. I myself was a young 23 year old TV reporter and war correspondent for Swedish TV News, based in Bangkok from 197 onwards,, focusing on the three sideshows Laos, Cambodia and Thailand, I totally agree with your conclusions in the epilogue. You did a great job! I hope many Americans will watch this documentary. It should be shown at all major universities and colleges in the history, polirical science and social science departments.
I'm a Nebula subscriber, but the home page design keeps me from finding the content I want to find. So, I end up watching what you release on RUclips, while missing what goes up on Nebula.
Alright almost 3 hours let’s go!
Facts im so tired of 3 min videos and all of the shorts
You've done an amazing job! Thankyou!
Superb documentary! Cant wait to watch your others
Fantastic video, really informative.
The Vietnam War stories never get old!
That is because Vietnam is all about corruption and that is stilla thing to this day.
Excellent, excellent documentary!! I was intrigued by it and glued to it throughout.
This an absolutely amazing and thorough documentary. Thank you!
This is the best coverage I've ever seen of vietnam war and I've seen a bunch.
Have you seen "The 10,000 Day War" series?
@JB-yb4wn not yet, I'd love to check it out though
This war is so underreported such as the Korean War
There is alot of information that we know that isn't being released to the public it seems.
@@tylermorrison420
There is an excellent Korean war series going on right now with indie nydel.
Do see Ken Burns documentary series on this conflict. I’ve watched it twice!!
Quality first!
Tôi là người Việt Nam🇻🇳 tôi cám ơn bạn đã đăng tải thước phim lên để mọi người trên thế giới xem hiểu về đất nước và con người Việt Nam 🇻🇳
The fall of South Vietnam to the Communists and the fall of Afghanistan to the Taliban have eerie parallels.
now watch ekreine
They should have fell to the racist right, right?
@@nonono88no different circumstances, and totally different beliefs involved in the Ukraine vs Russian war.
@@mikeosgood3846 guess it depends whom do you believe
20 years in each war if you really want to be eerier
38:00 I was a democrat for 15 minutes as a kid. I was a mc’publican for many years. Duped by the corporate media. Now I am a patriot who no longer believes ANY of the corporate oligarchy’s propaganda or anything their bogus uniparty says or does. What’s this have to do with Vietnam? It was Vietnam when the land of the free, home of the brave lost her way. We haven’t rediscovered it yet. Maybe last weeks epic election is the first baby step? I hope so. Almost 59,000 American and 2M Vietnamese souls call out for a new time of justice. We must reform. Or we, like all empires before us, will collapse under our own weight. And if asked many around the world might say “rightfully so.” I love my country. But we must prioritize our moral compass once again lest we be despised by humanity. The human race who cannot understand why the only people who cannot see it…are us.
America needs to worry more about the internal than the external
Awesome video!!! Thanks for concisely packing it all into under three hours, I can dig into specifics from here :)
They did know it but they were too afraid of defeat until the country itself went to war against the war. It says in the documentary they were afraid of China and being the responsible for the fall of the country to communists.
It's always interesting to see how much you can distill a war down to the nuts and bolts. To realize that those 8 years of direct intervention boiled down to a documentary that's less than three hours is both impressive on the part of Real Time History and depressing with the scope of the war.
For every second of this video, roughly 6 American soldiers were lost.
Love this, thanks bro. Very nice job on grow and content
A concise and thorough and honest history of the conflict. Thank you.
37:28 in 2007 I worked for a big News-Talk radio station in LA. Through the course of my regular duties I met numerous very interesting people. One luncheon I will remember forever. My guest was former PLO. His previous job was building explosives. Deployed against Christians visiting the Holy Land. Like Saul of Tarsus in the Bible. He killed Christians. This gentleman (yes, gentleman) had himself become a Christian many years earlier and was then working in the mission field. The exact same field that was his target in the early 1980’s. His name was Kamal Saleem. He looked at me across the table with black eyes that seemed to peer through the ages. “My friend what the West will never fully and truly understand? You may own all the watches. Every single one. But the Arabs? Arabs own the time.”
I'm just into part 2 here, but I have to say, well done. This is intelligent, nuanced, and truthful - excellent.
And as a PS to that,having got to the end, all told: truly excellent, gets highest level of recommendation.
Amazing content! Thank you so much for this!
Awesome channel!
Many people still don't understand how crazy the Battle Ia Drang was.
It was basically our best regiment against theirs. We would not have won without Hal Moore and Hueys.
The more I watch foreign docs about the wars, the more I admire the wisdom & strength & sacrifice of the golden generations whom liberated Việt Nam
Fantastic long form video. 10/10.
How can I donate for more documentaries? This is an incredible resource thank you!!
I have watched every doc on every war and this guy tells me something new
This is the best documentary on the Vietnam war I've watched ,
Only a few people know we supported Ho Chi Minh, but we turned our back on him. Study your history.
34:25 Jesse, Your pronunciation of Iroquois (ii-ruh-kwa) is correct by Canadian standards, but all the US Army chopper pilots I knew called it the Huey. If they said Iroquois, they pronounced it ii-ruh-koy.
PS A friend of mine commanded a squadron of Army helicopters, a mix of Hueys and OH-58s. The official name of the OH-58 was the Kiowa, but everybody in the squadron called it the Little Bird. My friend let me ride along on a lieutenant's checkride in an OH-58. After the LT completed his checkride, the WO swapped me into the pilot's seat and I got to fly the bird. Fun. I had no problems flying the bird in motion, but I failed to hover steady. Takes practice.
i am actually iroquois and ur still wrong
@@thatguythedude1563 No, I am not wrong. I accept that you pronounce Iroquois correctly, but US Army chopper pilots called it ii-ruh-koy when they used the official name -- which was almost never. Maybe they were wrong, but that is how they pronounced it. Mostly they avoided Iroquois. They called it Huey.
@@hlynnkeith9334you are actually 100% correct…they called them Hueys. My father was a 1st Lieutenant in Vietnam…& he has actually written a couple books about his experiences in the war. When I was younger…I actually spent 5 weeks in Vietnam with him. We flew into Hanoi…& drove all the way down south to Saigon…(Ho Chi Min City).
Great stuff 👍
I hope I never have to fight in war
I have the total opposite in desires
@@Mal0Imperzialmao!!!!!
Great in depth analysis of the conflict taking in Laos and Cambodia that some others forget.
Omg you saved my day with this video
1:02:35 I never heard of a 106mm recoilless rifle. I thought perhaps you mistook a 105 for a 106. I looked it up with an AI search. To wit:
The 106mm recoilless rifle, also known as the M40, is a portable, crew-served anti-tank weapon developed by the United States. Although its caliber is often referred to as 106mm, it is actually 105mm, with the 106mm designation intended to prevent confusion with incompatible 105mm ammunition from the earlier M27 recoilless rifle.
So we were both right!
If you are ever in Oklahoma City the 45th infantry museum has one on display. Along with every weapon and gadgets used in every American war.
My dad fought in this war. A Purple Heart Sargent. He passed away a few years back. He told me that they put kids in trees to shoot you, if you didn’t shoot them you was dead. Our men would come up on camps, and they would be cooking there dog outside over fire, because lack of food. Dad told me he could not tell me everything, tears would start in his eyes when he would talk about in. He said we never want war on our own turf, and Japan can take us out without firing one shot😢
And the VC and NVA understood the body count idea very well, even though we killed huge numbers of them we could never find the bodies. They out played our game.
Another fantastic documentary, absolutely love it!
@jasonniffen3043: "Another fantastic documentary.."
Except for the lies about the Tonkin Gu[f incident being true.
@@Merlinever We literally say it didn't happen at 22:10. "There was no attack on August 4th"
@@marknewton7539: I stand corrected. I admit that I didn't watch the whole video and wrote what I did in anger after the video seemed to be saying that the Tonkin Gulf incident had actually happened.
Books mentioned as sources in this documentary (in order of appearance):
•Vietnam: History, Documents and Opinions on a Major World Crisis by Marvin E. Gettleman (1966)
•The Vietnam War: A Concise International History by Mark Atwood Lawrence (2008)
•The Vietnam War: An Encyclopedia of Quotations by Howard J. Langer (2005)
•When Heaven and Earth Changed Places: A Vietnamese Woman’s Journey from War to Peace by Le Ly Hayslip & Jay Wurts (1989/2017)
•The Vietnam War by David L. Anderson (2005)
•Lyndon Johnson and the American Dream by Doris Kearns Goodwin (2019)
•The Indochina Wars: Great Power Involvement- Escalation and Disengagement by Marek Thee (1976)
•Patriots: The Vietnam War Remembered From All Sides by Christian G. Appy (2004)
•The Vietnam wars by Kevin Ruane (2000)
•Working Class War: American Combat Soldiers and Vietnam by Christian G. Appy (1993)
•A Rumor of War by Philip Caputo (1977/2017)
•U.S. Marines in Vietnam: The Defining Year 1968 by Jack Shulimson, Leonard A. Blasiol, & Charles R. Smith (1997)
•Vietnam-Perkasie: A Combat Marine Memoir by William D. Ehrhart (1995)
•Withdrawal: Reassessing America’s Final Years in Vietnam by Gregory A. Daddis (2017)
•Vietnam: The Definitive Oral History Told From All Sides by Christian G. Appy (2008)
•Grunts: The American Combat Soldier in Vietnam by Kyle Longley (2008)
•Australia and the Vietnam War by Australian Department of Veterans’ Affairs (AnzacPortal) (2023)
•U.S. Army Special Forces 1961-1971 by Francis J. Kelly (2015)
•Russians Acknowledge a Combat Role in Vietnam by Francis X. Clines for The New York Times (1989)
•At War in the Shadow of Vietnam: U.S. Military Aid to the Royal Lao Government 1955-75 by Timothy Castle (1993)
•Moua Thao (video interview) by EGUSD Oral Histories Project aka Time of Remembrance (2016)
•Back Fire: The CIA’s Secret War in Laos and Its Link to the War in Vietnam by Roger Warner (1995)
•Why Vietnam Invaded Cambodia: Political Culture and the Causes of War by Stephen J. Morris (1999)
•Disturbed Forests, Fragmented Memories: Jarai and Other Lives in the Cambodian Highlands by Jonathan Padwe (2020)
•Fire and Rain: Nixon, Kissinger, and the Wars in Southeast Asia by Carolyn Woods Eisenberg (2023)
•Vietnam in Military Statistics: A History of the Indochina Wars 1772-1991 by Michael Clodfelter (1995)
•Historians and the Vietnam War: The Conflict Over Interpretations Continues by George W. Hopkins (2000)
•The Media and the Military: From the Crimea to Desert Strike by Peter Young & Peter Jesser (1997)
•The Media at War: Communication and Conflict in the Twentieth Century by Susan L. Carruthers (2011)
👍 love the detail
I wish more people appreciated history. Otherwise we are doomed to repeat it
What a great documentary! Probably the only one that cover both sides on youtube. Also provided great facts about how U.S began to involve in vietnam.
Great documentary! Thank you for including the Hmong during this period.
The effort that this channel puts into its documentaries and videos is felt, thank you for the great information!
I've been listening to your guy's videos while on my break at work, before i go to sleep, while going for a walk. They are so immersive that even without the video and graphics, it is so well explained that you can follow exactly what is happening as it's happening (almost in real time 😉)
Thanks!
Brilliant documentary thank you 😊
I love love this channel but nothing beats the 10 part series about the Vietnam War by Ken Burns and Lynn Novick.
would love to get the budget that Ken Burns has for his projects. I think we produced our series with 0.1% of the money he had for his series.
Search Battlefield Vietnam. Im still trying to figure out the music
@@realtimehistoryfacts haha.
Absolutely.
@@realtimehistory You guys are the best, regardless of budget. The only real adversary your videos have in terms of depth is the Battlefield series which was produced something like 30 years ago. Keep it up please! History nerds like me appreciate the time you put into these series.
This is why i miss the History channel
Great video!
Some of the very important things you missed were that Strategic Hamlets were not "Strategic" they were almost always concentration camps. As per stated the a US report on the conditions of strategic hamlets. Another things was that Deim's brother Nhu was the head of SV secret police. Responsible for mass crackdowns and deaths.
Vietnam is a sore spot for me and my family. We lost 2, plus 3 wounded in that Damm war!
I understand that my Grandfather was a much kinder and thoughtful man before he had gone overseas. And he was quite literally nothing of the man he once was when he came back to his wife. I've always known how fortunate I was for never having to go to such a place in my lifetime.
Boo hoo unless your from Vietnam
Bookmarked for watching later :). Looking forward to it!
How many adverts do you need on your videos!?
Thanks documentary
90% of kids my age in the 1960 ssss didn't even know where Vietnam was located at.yet 30%% were volunteers .
The French didn't learn anything from Indochina. After they had been kicked out there, they tried the same game in Algeria with the same outcome
And Algeria has been an outcast for decades.
@GUITARTIME2024 Why outcast?
Outpost?
Algeria?? Do you even know what you're talking about? France had been in Algeria for 130 years. It was effectively their country.
@@SkanzoolNot really the French have a poor war record, the Algerians didn't have guns for those 150 years but the second they did the French got kicked out.
I’ve had these honor and pleasure of meeting several Vietnam war veterans at my job in the last 13 plus years; however, they’ve retired or moved on in recent years. As a US Navy veteran myself, it’s been an incredible experience to discuss their journey there and back.
🇺🇸☝🏻
I deployed to Iraq with a 1SG who was a Vietnam war vet. 1SG Yakoogi, with the 1st en bn. Funniest man I ever met. They forced him to retire when we got back in Dec 07😢
@@PorkChopAChunky that guy has no clue what any of that means
@@RebelliousEra what could possibly be confusing aside from possibly 1SG? I'm sure even navy guys would recognize the rank, they see marines all the time.
@@RebelliousEraAT EASE
Some mis information here:
6:00 that was the exaggerate number, there was various estimated numbers from different sources, but evidence only showed close to 5,000 were executed. There weren't even that many landlords. And those executed were not North Vietnamese, they were mostly Hoa Chinese who where former French Henchmen brought to Vietnam during the colonization. The Hoa Chinese control 80% of Vietnam rice market and land before 1954 while working for the French.
amazing documentary
Westmorelands ultimate personal goal was to be declared a theatre commander so he could push for a fifth star.
Born in 1955, I grew up as a "news junkie" throughout this period. What you have presented is nothing new to me. Still, your presentation is a useful review of the period.
If you don't mind me asking, what was it like growing up in a period of such rapid change?
@@joshjwillway1545 An aware person had to keep their eyes open and their head "on a swivel". I remember watching Uncle Martin's speech at the Lincoln Memorial. There were all these guys wearing paper hats. Still, "judged by the content of their character, not the color of their skin" really stuck in my mind. Now, the "woke"/DEI crowd says that I'm "racist" for believing in racial equality. I am the staff armed guard at a large, Black church, willing to die to protect my family on any given sunday. Our world is upside down.
I am a serious student of The Vietnam Conflict and this is the best overall.program I have seen.
LOL
This is the best History channel by far. First class information, presentation, balance of both sides and well researched and appropriate images.
They left out the promises made to Ho Chi Minh if he and his insurgent army helped the Brits and Americans fight the Japanese occupation. Those promises were never to allow the French back into Vietnam after the war and give Vietnam total independence. Not very balanced in my view and in the end total betrayal.
RTH upload 😫😫😻😻😻😻 yippee !!
This was very interesting and Helpful in understanding the Vietnam 🇻🇳 War 😮 Thanks for putting this on for us to view 👍👌
Since this battle, the US has lost every skirmish it has started worldwide.
Wow, this is a brilliantly produced documentary which provides as much as detail as possible in under 3 hours. I will be watching more than once!
Will there be more Napoleonic wars documentaries? I was hoping you would do one about the war of the fourth coalition at some point.
Our 1813 Campaign video was a big flop, so we stopped with that era for a while. But we're going to to do some more 19th century content next year and will probably return to the Napoleonic Wars again.
@@realtimehistory I loved the 1813 video and hope to see the entire "downfall" covered. The parallels with both WW1 and 2 are breathtaking and need to be revealed. "If you build it, they will come" even though a bit more slowly than either you or the algorithm would like!
@@realtimehistoryit wasnt a flop. Keep up the great work!!!!!
@realtimehistory really? I loved that content. Such a shame.
You guys are awesome 👌
"Ear collecting is soon discontinued" is a wild sentence
The way my country threw garbage on me when I returned to San Diego and kicked me out of bars is the worst memory, I have from this conflict. The USA treated us the worst imo.
My grandfather always told me it wasn’t like that when he got back after 3 tours. But he was living right outside Austin Texas on a ranch at the time so maybe that’s why he got the hero’s welcome lol I say hate the politicians not the soldiers.
I was on a US Navy ship that picked up 1100 "boat people" off the coast of Vietnam Jan-Feb. 1981. One of these people was a former ARVN Major. He had been on the run since 1975 when SVN fell to the Communists. He had been to several US Army schools while serving in the ARVN and told me "I was stunned how many of my fellow Officers, Enlisted men, friends, relatives were secret supporters of the Communists. No wonder we were defeated. But, the first people the Communists rounded up were those "supporters" (traitors to the ARVN, SVN) and they were either shot or sent to the camps." He just managed to escape on a boat with his family. There are a lot of reasons why the ARVN, SVN. USA were defeated and it was a terrible policy to become in involved with that conflict starting back in 1945 by supporting the French efforts. Just a great example of the failure of the USA being the "world policeman" and JFK's disaster of "Go anywhere, pay any price"...etc....
Communist doctrine has for long standardized the elimination of the “useful idiots” as a first step when taking control, as those people are seen as being easily led to oppose communist control once it occurs - the idea that those who oppose whomever is in charge, just because they are in charge, are not worth keeping around.
0:32 giggity
This guuuuy
Heh heh. Alllll righttt
Hello from I love learning about history
Got my drinks, comfy in bed, lets do this!
The Tonkin Gulf incident remained well concealed lie for decades after the Vietnam War had ended; it never happened and was nothing more than the creation of McNamara's imagination; please don't take my word for this, look it up; there is an excellent video about this right here on RUclips.
The Vietnam War wasn't fought to stop the spread of communism, and, ultimately didn't, but for nothing more than the financial benefit of the American Military Industrial Complex.
The Vietnam War not only to provided the American Military Industrial Complex with a huge market for their goods, but with a real war in which to test them, and those people couldn't care less about how many thousands of lives were lost in that testing.
It was for that alone that at least 58,000 Americans came home in body bags and three to four times as many came back with major, serious bodily injuries (loss of arms, legs, sight, PTSD, etc.) which pretty much ruined what was left of their lives.
And let's not forget about the horrifying effects of the use of agent orange, not just on our own troops years after the war was over, but on the civilian population of Vietnam.
The new world is youtube makers that are not academics, but this guy has worked hard for this vid 👍
I've nearly finished Max Hasting's epic 2018 story of the Vietnam conflict which, while it has one or two perhaps-inevitable limitations, is generally brilliant. But, I have to say, although it's obviously a different communication mode, this is even better. "Magnificent" would my adjective of choice.
I'm not going to lie when it comes to the section on the Tet offensive I feel like you guys should have covered a few more battles because the battle for Hue was not even the worst. I do think that was a bit of a miss
This is what i needed ......thanks RTH and a very happy halloween
Nice, thanks for uploading!
If the Anzacs aren't mentioned then your documentary is missing over half it's content...
we have an extra chapter for the non-US and non-Vietnamese armies
That would be marvelous @@realtimehistory
Those artillery squads just getting their bells rung all day
What an absolute mess. Thanks for the documentary!
Well that was a fantastic documentary.
When you look at the equipment, the bases,it should be a big lesson about warfare
You are the best thank you so much.
This is some top quality material, excellent documentary👌 better than most TV productions
The way the Vietnam War went for the US largely resembles the way the Afghanistan War went for the US years later. Lol. I'm assuming there was no way for anyone to know what tactics the Taliban would use, but if there was any idea that, considering the terrain, and the defeat of the Soviet Union in the same area, it would be even just slightly similar to the tactics used in Veitnam, somebody could have possibly prevented or lessened the number of troops lost in Afghanistan