Marbury vs. Madison: What Was the Case About? | History
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 13 сен 2017
- What happened in the 1803 United States court case between William Marbury and James Madison? What affect did it have on the young nation?
Subscribe for more from HISTORY:
histv.co/SubscribeHistoryYT
Newsletter: www.history.com/newsletter
Website - www.history.com
/posts
Facebook - / history
Twitter - / history
HISTORY Topical Video
Season 1
Episode 1
Whether you're looking for more on American Revolution battles, WWII generals, architectural wonders, secrets of the ancient world, U.S. presidents, Civil War leaders, famous explorers or the stories behind your favorite holidays.
HISTORY®, now reaching more than 98 million homes, is the leading destination for award-winning original series and specials that connect viewers with history in an informative, immersive, and entertaining manner across all platforms. The network’s all-original programming slate features a roster of hit series, epic miniseries, and scripted event programming. Visit us at HISTORY.com for more info. 
Развлечения
In case you wanted to know, Marbury never did get his commision.
thank you
RIP Marbury
lol poor guy
@@Ballsackgamin No, he never did what are you talking about lol
cite a source or something but from what ive seen he never did
Who else is here for online learning
me
Me
meee
Ok, whatcha need?
Same
Thanks. The public school system is failing me. I am so thankful for the internet!
literally same
Haha, we had to watch this in class.
Amen
@@cococoffee2305 lmaooo same
High five 😭
Lol I still don't get it
What don’t you get?
Your not alone
Rae ! Judge Marbury wanted his job he just did not get it because Supreme Court could not order to the new President to hire this guy, because separation of powers and even though there was a law that ordered supreme court to decide about it, they considered that law unconstitutional because separation of powers is mandatory by the constitution
Watching it again helps!
It's a little complicated. The court ruled that based on the Constitution, Congress attempted to give the court powers that it shouldn't have. It did not have the power to compel the president to give Marshall his job. The power to rule laws unconstitutional was NOT one of the powers given to the Supreme Court, so by declaring a law unconstitutional anyway, the court was in effect taking the power of judicial review for itself.
thanks for speaking english for us people with only 2 brain cells
In times of Corona, the courses still go on online... So, we get in touch with Marbury v. Madison, in online class. Thanks youtube, to explain the case in a funny, clear way. Greetings from Belgium
when you learn more from youtube then school
GEBC insider And, yet, you still don’t know the difference between “then” and “than”.
@@ziondenkins8689 I was just about to say that💀
@@kaebynj.quintero2993
me too lmaooo
been three years still go to this wonderful source
I’m only here for a grade.
same
Feel like your korean
@@joshuacha6261 I am- is it cause of my name? xD
Same
I wish the videos that we had to watch for school had captions so we could just open the transcript of the video and find the part we needed. :(
@William Stephenson nope
all in three and a half minutes??!! I love this guy!
I bet Marbury was just sitting there in the court room being bored asking himself why did ever do this just for a job.
Mans had to secure that bag! Evidently... it DIDN'T WORK...
Thank you for this video I’m taking notes and from the book I just didn’t understand what was going on and what commission were and it was all confusing with words I didn’t know so thank u for helping me understand !!
There’s two big takeaways from this case:
1. By ruling that the Judiciary Act gave the Court powers not granted by the Constitution and therefore was unconstitutional, Marshall himself acted outside the scope of the Constitution, because reviewing or interpreting a law (this is what Judicial Review is) was not an express power given to the courts under Article III. Now because of Marbury v. Madison, it is an implied power.
2. The second takeaway is Marshall upholding the Constitution instead of ruling in favor of his Federalist buddies.
I hope i can use this for my classwork
Your first point is not entirely true. According to Article 6 of the constitution, legislators and judges must obey the constitution. Marshall pointed out that the legislators violated this
I know this post is 2 yrs ago but I want to respond to it anyway. Your second point is a bit of an overgeneralization. Historians believed that Marshall wanted to rule in favor of his Federalist buddies but thought that Jefferson would have simply ignored his writ, making the Court looks toothless. He played the long game. By giving Jefferson the technical win, he basically pushed Jefferson to accept the ruling, even though judicial review ended up aligning more with the Federalist ideology in the long run.
3. If they had e-mail, the case would never have been.
As a teacher, I am here to design a lesson to help online learners understand this very important case!! Hang in there students!!
I'm here studying for an important legal brief I have to write for class.
This video finally got it for me. I needed the plot, the story. Great video!
I've been looking for a good video on this case that would work for my class, for years. Thank You!
He cuts to the case and gives you the run down without all the extra stuff other videos have. This was helpful.
Extra is not normally bad, but I wonder what he considers extra
What I learned: Marbury needs to chill out
Literally watching this before my final for government thanks so much
This has to be the most clever way to win without letting the other side think you did
Thank you for the video!
Do you guys have to watch the video like 2 times to understand the whole thing?
clearest video i've found, thank you so much!
I needed this for my FRQ tomorrow in AP US Gov. Thank you a lot lol
Really helpful video! Helped a lot to understand in a more simple way the long case!
Watching this for the third time...thank you so much!
I love it!!! Thanks for the comical cartoon analysis!!!!
who’s here from their civics classes??
me
So helpful!!!!!!! Thank you so much
That’s crazy. I always knew it established judicial review, the courts strongest power, but…
I never knew that the reason was because Marshall had ruled that the court didn’t have the power to rule in this case. So by limiting the supreme courts power in this case, and taking away the powers granted by the judiciary act of 1789, he ended up giving the court its strongest power. Ironic
THANK YOU!
I finally get it thank you so much omg
Thank u so much u have cleared my doubts
This was the longest 3 min of my life
Here because of the medius touch yt channel. I wish my life was taught in high school and even middle school because there are so many things that people need to know by the time they're adults.
GOOD JOB THANK YOU. Now I have to write a case brief
Thank you so much for this video!
No
This really helped me understand the case for my history project, thanks! :)
Wow great explanation of the case
Wow! I learned so much!
Why is the History Channel doing a history lesson? WHERE'S THE QUANTUM THEORY? WHERE IS THE ALIENS?
Wheres the Manley men doing manly jobs in their manly cars, that's what the history channel was made for
The time is day
OMG THANK YOU
Here for political science final ...wish me luck guys politics are not my strong suit. This video helps so much with the questions I have regarding the case. Bless you guys ❤️
When you learn more from a 3 minute video than a whole class lecture
I’m about to fail lmao
The first line in this video made me chuckle a little because I'm currently in my first year in law school and I've already had 3 professors yell at us that Marbury is not nearly as important a case as it is often said to be, and that it's not even the most important judicial event of 1803--that would be the Louisiana Purchase.
Thank you for this video! Mucho helpo on homework.
Watching Hamilton really gets you into the story of the US
Great vid/presentation
very helpful
Excellent video
😭 I’m here for school
"No fair, I want my Judge Job" -> kudos for the creative method of explaining it
BLESS RUclips OMG, SO MUCH BETTER THAN THOSE HELLA LONG ARTICLES
FOR GED . THX YOU
I LOVE IT!
Nice vid
This guy keeps your attention so well
This broke down everything way better for me
thanks for summarizing a case study for me for my 9am
2:47 Why is "God Save the Queen" playing in an American history video?
The song might actually be "My Country 'Tis of Thee" which is an American patriotic song riffed from "God Save the Queen".
Jezza Thompson Thanks for the clarification
@@MonkeyBidness359 Good point!! 🎵🎶🎵
this was probably the most interesting thing ive learned about in history
Who is this man I need to quote him for my essay lmao
Very cool
This video would be better with the captions
Ok I eventually understand this issue after watching twice, reading comments, and watching the 3rd time.
I need more explanation about Madison and Mabury’s cases
My APUSH teacher didn’t bother to teach us this in an hour but this video could in 3 mins 🤦🏻♀️
Did Marbury get his job, I’m really confused
No he did not.
No
It would have violated the separation of powers and things would really be a mess today if it had gone the other way. This was a very important precedent that secured a part of our democracy and Constitution.
@@MicksMom365 I wish I got this comment 2 years ago 😭but thank you
You left out where it says any law going against the Constitution is null and void.
I m impress
A great case for to understand the Constitution importance
what’s the background song from 1:32 to 2:32
background music is a bit distracting but good review
Is there a transcript somewhere?
can you add english subtitle?
0:04 = The most important case in the supreme court?
Why? What other cases/decisions were important?
Note: I'm neither a history buff nor a current student.
MaxPro gave the court the ability of judicial review. This ability means it can declare laws unconstitutional or constitutional.
Brown v. Board of Education of Topeka - Supreme Court outlaws segregation in public schools and also overturned the "separate but equal" doctrine which held that if facilities for both races were equal, they could be separate.
McCullough v. Maryland - the Court declared that states could not hamper the exercise of legitimate public interests. Introduced the "necessary and proper clause" which gave the federal government the ultimate authority over individual states
It screwed up America, that's why it's so important.
June Benedict Penolio Those definitely were important but SCOTUS couldn't hand those decisions down without judicial review
Thx for breaking it down for dummies like me lol
What I don’t quite understand is if the Supreme Court didn’t have the power of judicial review then exactly what would they be doing?
Okay. I still don't get it. What was so important about this case? I get what happened and why it happened. But I fail to see why this case has become so important.
Bro, I am a freshman in high school and I have my first AP US Gov test tomorrow, and I am so freaking confused on everything. I have no clue how I got in that class 🥲.
After 2 hours I understand
I had this on blast and my PC fans are louder...
2:06
Lol one of the Ap questions on the test
I’m still so confused lmfaoo
Anyone else have problems with the "volume" on their videos? I have it turned up to 100% and it's still hard to hear (has to be absolutely silent in the classroom...not a single rustle of paper, LOL!) 😕
In the 10+ years before Marbury did the Court NOT engage in judicial review of the other two branches of government?
Yay school
this video is great for 7th grade civics.
Who else is here for station activities? 🤣 I am! haha!👋
“Chill out buddy” 💀
I'm here from all the roe v wade hysteria but this is a great video explaining the abstract and fundamental implications of this ruling. Who knew how compelling us history could be?
when will they ever learn?
alguem me manda o lonk desse trem dublado
Lmao commenting during watching this in social studies online class
What is your name? My history class is obsessed and we need to know!!
I’m in the exact same situation lmao, my entire class worships this guy and we’re trying to find out who he is. If your class happens to find anything mine would love that!
Paul Laudiero
Anyone else here beacouse of corona shut down your school
PupDaUltima Gacha yupp
In hindsight, President John Adams should have issued an Executive Order to ensure Marbury received his commission.
Ahan 👌🏼
There's so much more to say about all those things he mentioned 🙃🙃