Giving NOCTUA All The Turbo Noises | Fan Showdown S5E8
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 16 июн 2024
- Pick up some Voxel PLA Pro for your 3D Printer
voxelpla.com
Most of the time a great PC cooling fan also is a quite PC fan. However sometimes the noise of something makes it just that much cooler. Everyone can agree nothing sounds better then a turbo in the boost, why cant we get that type of auricular feedback from a PC fan. Fun Fact we can.
If you like the fan showdown and want to get in on the action, check the links down below to find resources to help you create a fan and information on where to send your designs when complete.
My Twitch
/ majorhardware
Fan Showdown Instructions
• EVERYTHING you need to...
Fan Dims
www.thingiverse.com/thing:455...
Submit your design (at least .STL or .STP / .STEP file)
fanshowdown@gmail.com
Cameras used.
BlackMagic Pocket cinema 6k pro
amzn.to/3m2RLVw
Reddit
/ fanshowdown 
Наука
You should start a "fan favorite" section where ppl vote on their favorite looking fan
fan favorite fans fff
@@he8535 Oh, so I guess that would be hella good.
he could use the community poll. it supports four options w/ photos
Yes, a people's choice award
Would I win? 😉
i think the terminator needed some gaskets to actually do well, you could see air coming out from the seams between each piece of the fan
Agreed, the air also seemed to not desire getting pulled into the intake. My guess is that the intake/ velocity stack is to long while not having a trumpeted end, where it should curl back on itself. Pure conjecture though.
The airspeed is probably not fast enough for these impeller-fan designs to work properly. None of these turbo fans has really excelled..
It wasn't going to perform very well with the air having to make right angle turns to flow through. Printed PLA doesn't have a smooth enough surface and too much energy is lost to friction. If you look at the top performing fans, you'll see that they all have very little to no restrictions to flow.
gaskets would make a very minimal difference. its just a bad design
If he had at least used a screw to hold each corner and not just 2 corners. may have helped. since you could see the fog escaping it in the smoke test. it was made with 4 holes and only got given 2 screws. Also the print quality of those prints was NASTY!
Hi, Gumus here. Thanks for featuring the Sydney opera fan, and on 50th anniversary of it's opening, no less! I was really surprised by the performance, it was created purely as a meme / "would that even work" kind of thing. Same as the Flexi-fan I created back in season 3.
I'm glad it worked out and printed this well. I spent over 40 hours on this, mainly battling my CAD skills and researching the curve shapes. I had many 2D and 3D references, but in the end I created all of it from scratch. I learned a lot during the process and it even came out decent.
I immediately was like "holy cow the shitpost fan is working!"
Great job, I also was surprised at the performance, highly respectable.
Man the fog coming out of the back of the turbinator looks so solid and clean. love it.
The pressure was probably high even though the speed and volume was low
Also, kind of slow. Gaskets might help a bit, but with the 120mm frame and fan motor limitations....
removing the motor and adding a drone motor would be cool, see it spin at 15k lol.@@FixingWithFriends
The Opera House did way better than I expected, cool little design! The tri-fangle dangle was even more surprising, as usual the flow pattern was my clue that it was doing well the fact that it produced the most airflow of these is impressive for such a simple design versus the giant turbinator. (the second you said the air had to turn 90 degrees, I had a feeling it wasn't going to do well.)
turbines never flow as much as fans do. they can build pressure though, which fans suck at. Look at a bouncy house, radial fans, turbos for cars vs a desk fan or old plane..
You could see the trifangle dangle doing amazing in the smoke test! That was funny to see.
The turbinator might not make as many cfm, but I bet it has the best static pressure. That would be an interesting set of tests. See how high they could lift a racquetball in a tube or something.
Yep, was going to say that, Centrifugal compressors like that are.. well, compressors. They're designed to create pressure, not really high flow rates.
A metric ruler, an U-shaped pipe and some water would be a good pressure gauge. In most datasheets, the unit of static pressure is milimeters of water (mmH2O), so no unit conversion required.
The Turbinator could've used a gasket. It was losing some airflow between the fan and the rear section where they were connected.
It had gasket but what it really need is 4 screws.
I would love to get a retest with 4 screws. It obviously has a gasket
If he had at least used a screw to hold each corner and not just 2 corners. may have helped.
Ah that classic building "Opera Sydney House" 00:06:22
Love ya MH! Keep up the fantastic work, love this series!
ohhh PHOOEY!!! I came here just to point out his lysdexic mistake too :)
I was about to mention this too lol
you should send the top 5 fans to Steve from Gamers Nexus and have him do a bunch of thermal testing and see how practical they would actually be in a computer... or just do it urself
He could do it himself, but cross-pollination of communities that would come with doing a collab with GN would likely be hugely beneficial for both. That and GN has the hardware to not only run thermal load tests like was done in early Fan Showdown seasons, but to test all aspects of the fan, like the difference in airflow with a restriction in front as opposed to behind the fan, what thermal load it could reasonably cool when attached to a standardised cooler (maybe have 2 options like they already have with the 2 thermal loads for testing the different classes of air cooler rn), etc.
I'm happy with fans to be honest - Steve is lovely but sometimes you just want to see fans do battle out of context
You could send the top 5 fans to LTT and have them auctioned off for charity when you needed them back
I tried to get LTX to invite James but... I am pretty sure they wouldn't care about a suggestion from a random guy. Especially about a 'small' youtuber.
...Especially now, seeing his view on things. Even reading an email suggestion/feedback would be a waste of money.
I bet we could persuade Paul to do something with James.
(Also, @Dlanm2u lol)
@@dlanm2u LTT woudld lose the Noctua hub you included, fit all the fans to leaf blower and complain how crap they were and a complete waste of filament.
Hey, this series rocks! Crazy to see how far you've come. Just wanted to compliment the visual display during the smoke teating, as I think this was the perfect combo of showing the smoke, showing the fan, and clearly identifying the fan by name. Great work as always!
Waking up to find my v3 design made it into a showdown episode made my day. Thanks James! 🖖
I find it funny you didn't expect the tri-fan to do well and it ended up doing better than all of them 😅
**Edit**
Wow, this is the most likes anything I have ever written has gotten!! Thanks Guys!!
Exactly that was cool it was making some thrust remind me of an airplane prop
I think there's room to improve the shape of that fan for better laminar flow while still having three blades.
@@fluffy_unicorn859 the fewer teh blades and/or the slower the rpm ( not issue in these tests) the lower the frequency of the sound :)
I really appreciate the work you put into these videos! Its a pleasure to watch everytime
the trifangledangle would benefit by utilizing coanda effect on the edges that project into the lee side of the axis by rounding those over like a wing, with a slight hump forward to compress the air against the curved face leading into the capture zone of the windward fin behind. it would cut down the noise as well.
Video Idea:
Steve from GamersNexus had an extremely interesting discussion with a Noctua engineer about their upcoming 140mm next Gen fan. I would be very interested to hear you discuss fans with some of the key fan players.
Love your stuff.
Interesting that the 3-blader won this round especially pushing through a radiator. Fans with gaps that big between the blades typically dont do that well with pushing.
I also have a suggestion for next season: Instead of using the A12x25, get one of those 38mm thick 5000+ RPM Deltas or Nidec Servo fans and use that as the "host" fan. The challenge will be again, to move air, but also which is the quietest, and which will survive spinning full speed. I ***highly*** recommend that if you do this, you set up some sort of multi-layer plexiglass blast box around the testing area should a fan let go at full tilt.
And kiss Noctua sponsorship goodbye? I dont think so
The motor in the 5000 RPM deltas would grenade most of these designs, and the designs that survived would have clearance issues. Not worth the trouble. There's a reason noctua, and most other fans, don't spin ultra fast, but instead are hyper optimized to efficiently use a more limited RPM range. That's why this challenge is interesting.
Very cool fan designs....all of them!
The tri fangle dangle really does it for me. Coolest one here.
I was really impressed with the City Opera house fan! Very creative and still moved some air!
I'd love to see a side-by-side of each fan's airflow unrestricted v. restricted (through a cooler sink) as well as adding a way to test each fan's max static pressure developed!
It’s crazy to look at the background of The Fan Showdown and remember everything, so many memories. Seasons of member berries
You can actually see the patterns of the tri-fan producing, very cool!
You know it's been a while since I came to your channel. And this thumbnail made me think you were the rock
Sydney's opera always remind me of dune 2 wind turbines
That lavender purple color makes any fan look pretty
8:19 interesting exhaust pattern.
The Trifangle Dangle being a sleeper hit!
Awesome Video
Wow, I cannot believe the tri fangle dangle worked well! I thought that was going to be crap... But I ate my words, thoughts, inner dialogue.....
Surprised the Tri-Fangle Dangle did best. I had pegged either the Flower or that Turbinator thingy. And just to mention the last one, reason I had to watch this episode at once when I saw it, was the Sydney Opera House fan! 😁
Thanks! It's the second time I made it to the thumbnail - I also created the Flexi-fan in season 3
It'd be interesting to check the static pressure of the turbin fan.
I like to picture Major Hardware taking Major Bong Rips & blowing it at the Fans for testing
I dig your shirt, took me almost the whole episode before I noticed the silhouette.
We have been doing this a long time but it never gets old
So cool how you talk about functional parts (3d printed)
Got to enjoy just how well the stock fan holds up.
Love that editing technique around 4:25 where the pictures morph into one another
I want that triangle fan just for the looks. one of my favorites
6:22 “the opera Sydney house” 😂
You have to admit that was pretty funny
tri-fangle dangle, which frequency would you like? "ALL OF THEM!"
i dont watch all this guys vids..... but the ones i do watch have always been well put togther. pretty niche content but this guy deserves a good number more subs! keep it up dude
That triwing can could do great as a cost effective fan if optimised to be a hollow as possible. Material savings over millions of fans would be substantial.
At this point I wouldn't be surprised if you can just make an ASMR Livestream of just the smoke test that randomly switches between different fans. A separate meme stream could be just the fan sounds.
I have never seen airflow out the exhaust as satisfying as that turbinator. 8:34 It looks like a nuclear power plant steam exhaust chimney. Just a solid column of smoke moving in perfect smooth flow....
I'd really like to see a static pressure test, especially on the turbinator
I believe that thing should reign supreme above all other designs when it comes to that metric
I love this show.
8:48 you should've used 4 screws to hold the shroud on, there's an obvious gap where air is escaping that could've been reduced substantially by just putting all 4 screws in... probably the way derek thought you'd do it :P
seems he goes half ass once there is a "winner" like the dragon wing :/
Tri fan reminds me of a pedestal fan I saw years ago with three blades and that thing also sounded like a propeller aircraft.
the tri fangle had an intresting stripped patteren on the smoke output
Fantom of the Opera House sprung to mind as a name!
The trifangle-dangle sounded better than the previous, but the Sydney Opera fan sounded even better!
the Sidney opera house makes a nice relaxing sound.
Nice choice of Aircraft you got on your shirt.
Still in the top 10 let's go 🥳
The turbinator could do a lot better with a proper seal between components.
The Tri-Fangle kinda reminds me of the original rims on the Saab 900 Turbo :D
OK, I need to build the turbinator for myself because I love it.
The “Intake Tube” on that first design is called a Velocity Stack, it acts as a venturi tube and accelerates the air being taken in.
6:00 'Excellent acoustic sound quality'
As someone who has been at the Sydney Opera House MANY times both as a performer and an audience member - the acoustics have been famously bad. I remember seeing somewhere that as originally designed, the Concert Hall would have had decent acoustics but as manufactured... yikes.
The original solution was to put 3 sets of transparent circular sound baffles (halos or donuts, depending on how rude you felt) above the stage to redirect sound towards the audience rather than the beautiful ceiling. As this was still suboptimal, a veritable FOREST of microphones and speakers was also hung from the ceiling.
Further refurbishments were finished in mid-2022 which replace the donuts with pink metal petals (that look eerily like tongues) which can be raised, lowered, or angled in various ways for optimal performance. Various wall panels have also been adorned with some sort of wave interference pattern which does something to do with the reflections but, more importantly, looks VERY COOL. It's still not perfect - it's hard to hear left and right of you in the choir stalls, and there are some dead spots on the stage - but the new acoustics are much better.
Other improvements they made include enlarging the wings (handy for fitting an ensemble waiting to go onstage), turning the entire stage into a lovely set of hydraulic lifts (instant risers for your choir/orchestra), and adding RGB strips around the entire edge of the ceiling (gamer factor +1000). Apologies for the long comment and lovely fan!
Ideal travel fan for flying!!!
It would be incredibly interesting to see the smoke tests in super high frame rates. Not sure on the cost of an upgraded camera for that, but I 100% think it would improve data collection capabilities and add more interesting visual analysis for you and us the viewers.
I like how the Nakreous's sound adr'ed in
these almost need a "doug score" to balance subjective awesomeness, creativity, and performance
Thhhhiiiiissss... Is the turbinator
Bruh, Sydney opera house was designed like that to resemble the sails of a ship, which, according to the architect, was done to both seamlessly blend into the surroundings and to make something unique
One thought on turinator is the large change in cross sectional area behind the exhaust duct. This will create local low pressure around the center cone, likely causing separation and a big eddy in the center of the exhaust, thus making turbulence and slowing flow. I wonder if you had separate intake vanes on the exhaust duct if local fast flow from the perimeter might pull more air in and improve performance… hmm ok now im tempted to make an entry
Whoa, nice harmonics on the Turbinator - you see nice sharp peaks at 2 kHz, 4 kHz, 8 kHz…
The Turbinator is cool and all, but a real-world one is designed to slow down and compress air, then heat it with fuel to get the speed up again. Here, no heat is added, but the fan motor helps a little of course. So yeah, it shouldn't do well, and it doesn't...
I'd like to see a contest where entrants start with a top-5 GOAT design and try to improve on it.
The triangle fan sounds like a plane, ngl
The FLOW-er really should have been designed with 7 or 9 blades. The problem with using multiples of 4 specifically is that the fan blades align with the motor supports all at the same time, making it louder.
I'm actually a bit surprised Noctua went back to 4 evenly spaced supports, when their previous design had such a clever unevenly spaced 11 support design. But, knowing Noctua, I'm sure they tested every possible variable before settling on the current A12x24 design.
I'd like to see the Turbinator v 3.1 - with some double-sided tape or perhaps very thin foam padding, to seal it up a lot better
I can't believe the Opera House worked so well, and that the Tri-Fangle Dangle worked at all. The FLOWer was very significantly smoother than I expected
Very apt that the Sydney Opera House sounded better than the others.
I bet Tom came in pretty hot with his fan even if we _did_ see that episode.
I bet this is that series even if we're not new.
loved how opra house sounded
Need a compilation video of all smoke tests ever.
The noise from the Opera house fan was definitely the least annoying out of the lot. It also seemed to throw air out much cleaner and wider, which could be beneficial in some circumstances.
the opera house spinning at 2000 RPM is so silly, in the loveliest way
Only the best fan at that particular rpm. I've been waiting forever for you to do some higher RPM tests,!!
The turbinator is just a non fuel jet engine 😂
Danish Design always timeless
Just using my eyes, I feel like the turbonator has unrealized potential. That setup was zootin' air out the back in a straight line. It felt like it had a specific purpose of sending fast moving air a decent distance. That is a fan setup that would perform great as unrestricted intake. The sound however, gave me a headache.
The sound comes from the interferance between the roter and stater. The sound is still there if you remove the intake shroud.
Also I highly doubt that turnbinator is still rotating at 2000 RPM with all that mass and resistance from the compressor...
That title really had me expecting whooshing and fluttering 🥲At least there was some whistling.
I like the Tri-Fangle Dangle personally! I love spinning designs with three main bodies, like 3-blade propellers or 3-Spoke wheels!
I love that shirt too, and I think I need one! Can you point me to where you got it from?
That ad read was a plosive 4d experience.
Off topic but, that shirt is dope bro I like it
Our Gov is happily running our country into the ground, but Sydney, Australia has the best looking harbour on the planet. The bridge and the opera house strike a great contrast that rarely works when combining old with new aesthetics.
Always stay for the smoke testing
the reason the turbonator fan didnt flow a lot of air is because its based on a compressor, its not a fan at all. compressors are relatively low volume, high pressure, if you were doing a thrust/boost pressure test that fan would presumably do much better than the other designs.
G'day Major,
🤔Just wondering if we can get a Showdown of the Best Performing that are completely contained in the 120x120x25 frame size all reprinted on the new printer ???
Growing up in & around Sydney I knew exactly what Gumus had designed, SOH is a very Strikingly Beautiful Building & the Acoustics in the halls create an amazing concert experience.
Is there a spreadsheet somewhere with the fans performances and links to their designs? Would love to see what has performed the best
An air pressure test would be interesting comparison to add alongside airflow test 🤔
I think a very valuable test moving forward would be to add a static pressure test. CFM is fine, unloaded, but once running through any radiator of any kind, the more important specification becomes static pressure>CFM>Surface area, for cooling efficacy.
NACREOUS!
Maybe have a look at different new fans like the Apex Metal fans from Alphacool when they are available, there was also some low profile 120mm with a clear LED lit hub at computex but cant find it.
Unsurprisingly, the Sydney Opera House had the best acoustics in this episode.
You know what could be fun with the Turbinator? Find a Delta or Sanyo-Denso fan that can run 6000+ RPM and strap that bad boy on.
i think if the jet engine fan was sealed better it'd prolly be a top fan contender of all time
I wasn't even wearing headphones and my ears were destroyed