I would have been crying during this performances this song has gotten me through the darkest days of my life where I was dying from my autoimmune disease before diagnosis. I wish Ian never left us ❤
You were a young man and rocked out to this. Felt every note. Now you reminisce but also wonder, where has it gone? And this reminds you it’s here, in its own way, Ian is still a part of you. His sadness shines a light on what you feel at times. You are still here. And maybe he’s not, but it doesn’t matter, the melancholy masterpiece lives on. To be enjoyed like a tall tree that was here before and after you. The leaves were beautiful though, weren’t they?
This song always hurts because unlike a lot of people I live this song. I deal with nihilistic depression. It's not sadness, it's total apathy. You were given a worthless life in an unjust world without permission and now you're forced to continue living this meaningless life one day at a time while everyone you know and love dies around you. "A loaded gun won't set you free, or so they say." It won't now your a ghost which is even more lonely and borning.
The music performance was great. I do wish that the vocals had given it a bit more of an operatic approach, as it is something that could easily be done with such a tone. If nothing else, a bit stronger, emotional tone would have worked better I think. Nothing against her voice, just that it wasn't a good match for the pathos of the song.
To be fair how can anyone top Ian Curtis's voice for this, a hard act to follow, mind you surprisingly Moby come reasonably close which I nether thought I would ever say lol
Great orchestra, horrible singer. Singer is out of tone, out of rhythm, exaggerated body language, horrible voice. The singer was unable to understand the real meaning of this amazing song. Ian Curtis did not deserve such a bad interpreter.
So much treacle poured over it that it'll eventually turn into amber. Ill-conceived, -transcribed, -arranged, everything. _New Dawn Fades_ transformed into something depressing. Deserves a footnote in the history of artistic poor taste.
Its a fantastic piece of music that is lifted with the strings and taken to a different place with the singers style, so what. Its not the original raw masterpiece by Ian, but as a UK northerner brought up with the punk and Indy music and groups around this time like joy division, I think Ian would have loved the twist, and why not.
Absolutely incredible!! I hope in my heart, Ian is looking down from heaven smiling & happy for what he left us!!
Ian is looking down with Wilson ,Gretton , Hannett and Denise
Lol you normies believe in heaven
@@pacifiedbeaumontewoah you’re so qUiRkY🤡
@@pacifiedbeaumonte respect people’s religion dumb bitch
@@david1092 lol, nuts to you and your intolerant fake beliefs, normie
I would have been crying during this performances this song has gotten me through the darkest days of my life where I was dying from my autoimmune disease before diagnosis. I wish Ian never left us ❤
I have heard this song a million times, this is a WONDERFUL touching tribute to Ian... I have goose bumps and tears in my eyes
me as well
What I find so beautiful about this is that in retrospect they make this song almost feel like a tribute to Ian and his legacy.
It IS a tribute.
YES!@@HalfdanRekkirsson
You were a young man and rocked out to this. Felt every note. Now you reminisce but also wonder, where has it gone? And this reminds you it’s here, in its own way, Ian is still a part of you. His sadness shines a light on what you feel at times. You are still here. And maybe he’s not, but it doesn’t matter, the melancholy masterpiece lives on. To be enjoyed like a tall tree that was here before and after you. The leaves were beautiful though, weren’t they?
I like the tree thing you said. Very apt.
Damn, this immortal song fits any genre...this could easily be a great film score
Kind of is. its heavily sampled by Moby that made the score for Michael mann´s movie HEAT.
@@Nomis3586 Right, I knew that. I actually referred to this particular performance, too bad's it's already "taken".
@@maricallo6143 Here it is if you or anybody reading this would like to see it. ruclips.net/video/E82UcXTsbOE/видео.html&ab_channel=ValidHD
Magnifique... Touchant... Beaucoup d'émotions... 👍
This brings the tears of joy to my my eyes!
Excellent version- thank god someone finally hit that top note ;)
i was there...it was superb!
Which orchestra was it? Great rendition
I really did not expect this to be as marvellous as it is
Listen to the Club Paradiso audio then this.. Amazing intensity.. and then a complete change of mood.. both brilliant
Thanks for uploading this ❤
:O orchestral arrangements of a Joy Division song, awesome.
Chills. Excellent job.
Wow that was absolutely phenomenal
This song always hurts because unlike a lot of people I live this song. I deal with nihilistic depression. It's not sadness, it's total apathy. You were given a worthless life in an unjust world without permission and now you're forced to continue living this meaningless life one day at a time while everyone you know and love dies around you. "A loaded gun won't set you free, or so they say." It won't now your a ghost which is even more lonely and borning.
What a night that was.
peter hook playing bass. funny no one noticed
Wouah, reinterpretation originale et magnifique, 🙏❤️
Powerful tune!
Beautiful Performance Of A Brilliant Song ❤
Wonderful, thank you for posting this.
Saw this concert in London at the Palladium October 2022. Blown away and very emotional. This version could be used in a James Bond title track
Grazie Ian
That's what I call a good cover, great vocals and music.
Lovely!!!
Cette version m accompagnera lors de mes funérailles 🖤
Idem....le plus tard possible ! Imaginez la voix de Siouxsie ici...
ou de Dame Pandora de Dark Sanctuary
The first time I heard Joy Division I knew and felt I was hearing something iconic. This is amazing!
Astonishing
Incredible
This ain't a reworking it's a completely different song ethereal, ghostly and otherworldly, incredible.
Merveilleux
merci Jan
Goosebumps.
Se escucha de huevos, gracias por su tributo al genio Curtis.!!!!
Eggs …….?? Wadyamean
I am on my knees!!!!
Holy shit!
Beauty
Wow!!!!
Hermosoooooooh
Wow, this orchestration gives Joy Division the roundness of a 40-year-old Porto. Cinematic!
4 marginados de Manchester, la luz y el espíritu
The music performance was great. I do wish that the vocals had given it a bit more of an operatic approach, as it is something that could easily be done with such a tone. If nothing else, a bit stronger, emotional tone would have worked better I think. Nothing against her voice, just that it wasn't a good match for the pathos of the song.
To be fair how can anyone top Ian Curtis's voice for this, a hard act to follow, mind you surprisingly Moby come reasonably close which I nether thought I would ever say lol
Ian would fucking love this he was never precious and he never minded other band members singing but hed love this pity Denise aint still around
Was Denise his wife?
@@keithsobolewski - No, her name was Debbie.
@@TmaadHMD still is
This would be great for a James Bond movie... - The vocalist gets it, takes it to another level, amazing!
I don't know of anyone I'd trust to do this except maybe Peter Murphy. Maybe.
I wasn't pleased with this one bit.
Αmazing.the name of the singer?
Mica Miller
lindo e triste
never ξανα!!
my god is heaven .... hi ian
👏
Is Hooky a part of this or did he do similar shows…….?
Music mint singer spoils it.
Wahouuuuuuu
😃❤
Who is the vocalist
Petros
Great orchestra, horrible singer.
Singer is out of tone, out of rhythm, exaggerated body language, horrible voice. The singer was unable to understand the real meaning of this amazing song.
Ian Curtis did not deserve such a bad interpreter.
Awful... It doesn't work. It's far too sappy and sounds like a Hollywood western film score.
So much treacle poured over it that it'll eventually turn into amber. Ill-conceived, -transcribed, -arranged, everything. _New Dawn Fades_ transformed into something depressing.
Deserves a footnote in the history of artistic poor taste.
Brilliant accompaniment, awful vocal.
Ouch. Not good at all.
Bullshit!
inappropriate search for dramatic style effects in the voice. Lack of decency. It’s like having Kate bush singing! Awful !
it´s just about taste.... I think Ians voice is better, but lack of decency is not correct in my opinion
Its a fantastic piece of music that is lifted with the strings and taken to a different place with the singers style, so what. Its not the original raw masterpiece by Ian, but as a UK northerner brought up with the punk and Indy music and groups around this time like joy division, I think Ian would have loved the twist, and why not.
Kate Bush: "What? Leave me out of this, thank you very much."
Sacrilige ! Nobody should cover Joy Division songs !
Best song ever