Doubt: Take The Truth From The People Of Bid’ah Because Abu Hurayrah Took From The Shaytān
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 12 июн 2020
- #mufti_muneer #Muhammad_hijab #Salafi
Doubt: Take The Truth From The People Of Bid’ah Because Abu Hurayrah Took From The Shaytān
• The Salaf Narrated Fro... Doubt: The Salaf Narrated From Innovators Between “Mufti” Muneer & Shaykh Muhammad ibn Hadi al-Madkhali
What we learned from the Hadeeth is that:
1. Zakatul Fitr is foodstuff that is collected by the leader of the Muslims, & 2. Shaytan is a liar who mixes truths with falsehood, & 3. Ayatul Kursi protects from Shaytan.
May Allaah have mercy upon Shaykh Muqbil . He totally knocked the socks off these Juhhaal.
Aameen wa aye na'am he sure did رحمة الله تعالى
As mentioned earlier, a scholar getting a hadith is different then a laymen sitting in a class of mixed innovators, with vulnerability to bida. & then they say refuting is only for the scholars but taking from Ahl-bida is for all. how much of a reversal of preserving din is this? Did you even teach them salafiya? This is why Usul is first. it is the value not to be compromised!
assalamuvalaikkum brother.why he mentioned dr zakir naik in this video?is he a deviant?
@@mahinshaanthru6494 Zakir Naik praised Daddu , Arifi who are with the muslim brotherhood ( Ikhwani ). Zakir praised them despite knowing that some have warned against them , so zakir is with them without a doubt. May Allah guide us , barakhallahfeekum.
May Allah guide us and keep us firm 🤦🏾♂️
How they don't mis-understand a simple hadith, subhaanallah, may ALLAH guide these people, laa hawla wa laa quwwata illaa billahi
Aameen
بارك الله فيك ووفقك
Jazak Allahu kheyr, amazing job. May Allah reward you for this great effort and multiply your reward by those who follow you in goodness.
Love this channel. ❤
Abu hurayrah confirmed it from the rasool alaihis salaam. If I speak to a satan today I can’t confirm it with the nabi unless it’s already discussed in the ahadeeth IN WHICH CASE I SHOULDNT NEED TO DISCUSS IT ANYWAY.
Simple
Al-humdulliah wal Islam wa Sunnah. & NEVER take knowledge from ANY OF THOSE PEOPLE who were on the list (etc) & the four sitting together, EVER!
جزاك الله خيرا
Notice how the companion Abu Hurairah said he "claimed", he did not take any knowledge from the shaytan he took knowledge from the messenger of Allah peace be upon him when because he said he "claimed" something, which implies he did not believe or take knowledge from him.
JazakAllahu Khayr, Shows how sneaky they are with their doubts. Subhan'Allah the evidence is against them. How deluded are these people, May Allah guide them and us to the siraat al mustaqeem. Ameen
The Sunna is the اقوال statements and أفعال actions, and the تقرير conformation of Rasullah. The Hadith of Abu Huraira and Shaytan is about التقرير conformation. With that principle of conformation by the Prophet ,it allows us to accept the truth whatever we find it.
الحمد لله
Assalamualikum jazakallah hul khair 🇮🇳🙋🏻♂️
People praises Mohammad Munir that he has studied in KSA but I will say, man has not benefited from the ‘ilm. May Allaah guide him. Aameen.
I don't understand what's the matter with some American students of knowledge (those who studied), maybe America has a bad influence on them,
All he did is memorize, but he doesn't have understanding in what he learned, he's not a good teacher, and he doesn't explain anything well.
We shouldn't take knowledge from celebrity scholars and fake muftis
Yea let’s listen to some random guy on RUclips
@@supersayain48
This random guy will dismantle and is dismantling all of those celebrity fake deviant scholars and muftis.
if you respond the saafiqah refute in excess... they are one extreme, but your muamiyah open up the doors to ahlul bida wrongly on the other opposite extreme and used hadith scholars deceptively/ in error, its like mixing up a mujtahid/ahl ilm with a non mujtahid to open up a laymen to this vulnerability, yet you complain about laymen refuting which they can do with ilm but they aren't to sit with ahlul bida still. It maybe for a patient to call out a bad doctor but its not for a patient to be a doctor and look at a body to tell healthy cells from unhealthy ones!
If there wasn't refutations , then ahlul bida known for their dishonesty for all we know would lie more like the sufis do in their private gatherings, who you don't speak out againt for example. May Allah protect us and guide us to establish the truth and its virtues for Allah's sake ! (Amin).
~ oh and another thing 1) shaytan went to Abu Hurairah, not the other way around in fact he imposed on him Radiyallahu anhu
2) Abu Hurairah did what the salafis are saying to do and went to the Prophet peace and blessings on him.
3) Quran says verify the news of a fasiq IF A FASIQ COMES TO YOU (NOT YOU GO TO THEM), why would you trust someone whose info who needs verification... its an oxymoron, this is not general advice at all but specific as shown by these 3 points!
now its not my place to make tabdi, h/e innovators are worse then fasiqs so my question would can you take ilm from a person who isn't deemed innovator but has innovator errors?
that person might take the ruling of someone like tahir wyat right? unclear to say the least as was stated! - you should of clarified what unclear means like Sh Dawud Adib did, it means don't take from him, until his situation is clear but who clarifies it? thats something maybe you can make a video about brother Nasir, My request Insha Allah. Jazak Allahu Khayr!
how are warnings removed, what does not clear mean and other relevant terms and readinsg for an english speaker perhaps!
I like you channel and the contents in it Masha Allah may Allah accept it and put Barakah in it and helps us to benefits from it. But is this a good manhaj to correct a scholar by exposing accusations like this on the internet before interacting with him previously in private? Did the true scholars of the past like Imam Ahmad ibn Hanbal use to expose the people of innovation without a prior private notice? If we want to help them for the sake of Allah with sincerity is this method appropriate for such goal? Please help me understand? May Allah forgive us me and forgive y'all, give us understanding and guide us all. AMEEN
Scholars should be openly and publicly exposed since they spread misguidance openly and publicly. If u do it privately, then how those who have fallen into their misguidance be corrected?
Ya Allah guide the Ummah and protect the Ummah from these deviated figures.
@NasirAlHanbali Who is the man on the far left next to "Mufti" Ibn Muneer?
14:08 what is democratic person? A man who goes with the majority/? Or a person who lives (born) in a democratic country, but completely against it and a striver of truth?
Salam, barakAllahu feek for the knowledge..
However it is not appropriate to name out ppl.. we nvr know if theyd taubah or their true intention. We can only say the wrong poiints but not pointing names ..
There's no point in saying their names, they're on video!
Asalama alaiykum brother.
Naming people is necessary so that seekers of the truth can be careful from who they take knowledge from.
Let's say someone from Ahlul Bidaah is spreading innovation and misguidance while you know that what they are conveying to the people is falsehood. Will you be afraid in warning people and naming X, Y and Z because it " is not good to name people incase they make taubah or because maybe they have good niyaah"?
Akhi the whole point of the video is to warn against people that have deviated from the truth.
Our Ulama, (May Allah have mercy on the ones that are dead and preserve the ones alive) are much obliged to call out people preaching misguidance.
May Allah guide us all to the straight path.
If they did smthing wrong publicly, then they have to be addressed publicly aswell. And as for their Tawbah, then that has to be done publicly, so that the ignorant ppl. get to know that it was wrong and the more knowledgeable ppl. know that knowledge can be sought from him.
->That's the case at least with anyone who has a big influence on ppl. Like scholars, students of knowledge, youtubers, instagrammers,...
Abu Usamah? Is a deviant? How do you judge? He is known to be a Salafi in Aqeedah and Manhaj. He may not agree with you or Salafi Publication on the issue of Hajr, Tabdee of other well known Salafis, the way you refute without any Rahmah, adhab, Rifk etc. Yes. The others are known either only having Salafi Aqeedah and with Ekhwan Muslimoon Manhaj. And others like Hamza Yousuf known to oppose totally Salafi Aqeedah aswell the Manhaj. So we Salafis have to be fair. Good video though, but dropping names of known Salafis coz of their mistakes or they or you don't agree with them on an issue, is not from the way of the Salaf. This is ghuloo.
Agreed
Maybe you don't know what he knows. You're doing the same thing you're accusing him of by accusing the brother of refuting unfairly. Shaykh Ahmad an-Najmee (may Allaah have mercy upon him) warned against Abu Usamah due to him defending the figureheads of Bid'ah, such al-Ma'ribi. He also praises deviants, such as Zakir Naik, and also sits with them without clarifying their evil.
JazakaAllah khair
Yea totally agree with you bro
ruclips.net/video/mZEBNz7kmOA/видео.html
4:14 i think Hijab was asking for the limits at 1:01 but mufti muneer failed to answer properly.
I don't get it he did call shaytan a liar
Yes, the narrator Abu Hurrairah (May Allah be pleased with him) didn’t take the narration from the shaytan, rather he took it from the prophet as he confirmed it. So it was said by the shaytan, but it was the prophet of Allah who confirmed it being true.
I have a doubt why was nouman ali khan mentioned pls clarify and also zakir naik ??
Nouman ali khan fabricated and made up a whole hadith and zakir naik has made some great mistakes in his talks. I think this account posted them. Look them up
it seems to me they are trying to justify sufism and their strangeness in particularly with other bida! taking ilm from the unknown unseen etc. really?
It's a huge push from American government to corrupt Islam. Muslims will be the majority by 2050, so if they make sure that generations of Muslims have watered down Islam, or if they take them completely out of Islam, then their "problem" is solved. Just look to the innovations of so called American scholars, the so called American Islamic schools, the videos of women, female "imams", gay masjids... It is intolerable and all a very deliberate move from higher powers against Islam. May Allah protect us all in this time.
Please clarify about Omar Suleiman please. What is about him that should be addressed and that we should be aware of? He is a Salafi isn’t he??
He participated in a rally in support of LGBT, which is haram in Islam, how can someone support this haram rallies being caller and Daee.
He is not salafi, never was
He participated in a pagan ritual ! Just search on RUclips , you'll see the video
What could u say this except wrong istedlal but is this mistake 'sufficient' to take him off the manhaj ??
well we first need to prove that he is truley upon the manhaj already, then after that we could ask ourselves if this mistake is enough to take him off the manhaj.
Yes he made a mistake, like many he's done, but this shows that he is unreliable,
All this so called daee speaking of Allah religion without knowledge all in the name of mufti may Allah protect us
Taking 'ilm from shaytan... Come on now 😂😂
Who is the sheikh in the beginning of the video and what is he saying brother?? i am curious 😀
He is sheikh Rabee Almadkhali, he said ; we defy people of bidaa , people of bidaa of beliefs and people of politic bidaa , between us and you alsalf , between us and you the books , as salaf said between us and you funerals
ruclips.net/video/dgE66eUuovU/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/7oOqxebevGk/видео.html
"We challenge the people of innovations and desires..." he said, watch this 2 mins video if you wanna know who and what all he said.
I think sheikh rabee al madkhali may Allah preserve him
WAIT whats wrong with Zakir Naik. the others i do not watch.
These group of guys are a youthful joke.
After Muhammad Ibn Muneer said that the Salaf(may Allaah be pleased with them) unanimously agreed that you can't take any knowledge from a innovator(which is 100% true), he then questioned it by saying if that "is absolutely true?". So he thinks it's basically ok to take knowledge from a person of innovation sometimes??? I can't believe people who continue to follow these speakers. Stay safe and take your knowledge from the real Scholars of Ahlul Sunnah wa Jamaah, and real students of knowledge who don't cause fitna,division,and they don't call to themselves. Not these guys who lack knowledge, and come up with strange concepts that the Salaf (may Allaah have mercy on them) would never entertain. May Allaah guide all of us....Aameen
Aameen.