@astrokid Frank, Max and Ian should've received an award for their outstanding work on this trilogy. It marked me forever, and I will definitely talk about it to my children, it must never be forgotten.
@@yungcade4480 there's a reason Foot Fungus is one of Anthony's favorite tracks on Stokeley. It's not because it's good, he likes it because it's actually a secret shoutout to Melon's feet
@astrokid I mean it's okay. But if we honest if the video was exactly the same in every way but having other people. Everyone would hate it and call it stupid edgy shit. It's not like it's a work of art it's just 3 idiots being gross for shockhumor. My younger self loved it but the more I grow up the less appealing the stuff is. So I'm glad the boys grew out of that.
Jack Hanigan Exactly! So confused seeing that. I guess it got old fast for him? The breakdowns of the track are BAD.ASS. Rest of the filler is waiting time really
I remember that you put voicemail in the best tracks section of the weekly review video and here you put it as your least favorite song? your are so confusing
Maybe the rest of the album lets the song pale in comparison? Maybe its a less interesting song in the context of the album compared to others? Also; least favourite doesnt necessarily mean he hated it.. Why are you people like this?
Poppy seems to be the type of artist going forward that, even if you don't personally like or agree with any given album or EP she releases, will always be doing something abstract and weird. Might be a gimmick, might be her artistic merit, might be her personality. Either way, I think she's an artist to keep your eyes on. I could see her doing some amazing things in the future. :) Thanks for reviewing the EP, Anthony!
@ahegaofish I mean you can call her a Mars Argo copy all you want but that doesn't change the fact that she is much better then Mars Argo ever was or will be
algorithms suggest this whole ep for my playlists at least weekly, and i enjoy the songwriting and delivery four years later. and now that it's autumn, i can wear headphones, which is giving me much more clarity of bass sounds.
Okay...just because it is his least favorite on the EP does not mean he hates it. He likes the song. It's like ranking 5 really good deserts. All 5 are great but you still have to rank them in order and unfortunately one of those five is going to be the least favorite...but still liked. Understand? Does everyone understand how this works??????
You gave Voicemail your track of the week when it came out and now it's your least favorite track??? You literally didn't say a single negative thing the entire review and it still only gets a decent 7?? I agree with the rating but geez, make up your mind, melon.
No review for MADAME X by Madonna. It’s one of the most “out there” pop releases this year. Although it’s very inaccessible for mainstream but I think it’s one of Madonna’s riskiest releases. Mirwais and Madonna are my favorite combination for her.
I remember discovering the poppy channel right before she was getting famous there was a music video in there she must be trying to launch off her music carrier all along.
Melon, you remind me of my father. While I don't always agree with what you say, your opinions are very well fleshed out, and I have seen neither of you in person.
What about Madonna's Madame X; I'm curious what do you think about the album as a whole and if you like something from it (I know you're opinon on the songs released before the album, but still :) ).
It's almost as if just because a track is the best thing to release in a specific week, once the full album comes out, it may not be as good as the rest of the tracks or something. Crazy, huh?
Has anyone ever listened to Sizzy Rocket?? I found her a few months ago & completely fell in love with her latest album Grrrl....it maybe one of my fav albums of this year so far. This is just the kind of music that my ears ❤️. I do not listen to many mainstream artists, I came across her searching through music that is not on any charts. I hope there are other people out there that have the same taste as me....Somewhere!!???
Hey Anthony you should check out Any Human Friend by Marika Hackman. It’s shaping up to be one of the best of the summer in terms of deep, fun, indie music. Every song that’s been released is outstanding and shows that she’s gotten more comfortable not only in her sexuality but musical style and doesn’t give a f🦆 what anyone thinks of her. So, it’s raw, it’s passionate, it’s topical and fun.
this isn’t exactly an album that’s easy to understand at first, but when one takes time to process everything, it becomes more than just an edgy sound choice done well. HIGHLIGHTS: metaphors are very well thought out, poppy has a great rapping and singing voice, the production ofc. WEAKPOINTS: meat could’ve been even better if it described how we got to the point where humanity was at in the song. it just sort of happens, but as a warning song, shouldn’t there be a solution presented to us on how to avoid getting to the very thing you warn us not to get to? or is this just some kind of vegans anthem? FAV. TRACKS - CHOKE, VOICEMAIL, THE HOLY MOUNTAIN LEAST FAV. TRACK - MEAT 8-9/10 recommended to: ????
Well I don't think a song's weakpoint should be something you expected from it or something you would have liked featured in it or the fact that it had potential to be even better. Plus I don't think Meat should give a solution to the problematic, that's not the point. The things that the track narrates is just a means of concientializing about the topic. I would recommend it to someone that enjoys industrial sounds and pop and is willing to hear that weirdly mixed lol
With Meat, as with almost all their songs, they leave it to the listener to decide what it means, and what action or shift it inspires. I admire the hell out of them for that.
Mmmm Melon. Yes. I agree. Okay I can see what you’re saying there. Oh nice man that’s a great connection. Wow that was a great representation of that piece. Uh huh. Yep. Overall this was a solid review of Poppy EP. I’m gonna give this review a light to decent 9. I would have given you a 10 if you weren’t blinking S.O.S. in Morse code the whole video.
I have no god damn idea who this person is but your videos have been making me want to look into her. Comparisons to Evanescence, Nine Inch Nails and Marilyn Manson make this sound entirely different than what I expected.
![Kodak Black - Catch Fire [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/A4ch-olIuZo/mqdefault.jpg)
“poppy is your mommy.”
-poppy, 2k19.
dysperisenjoyinghimself.
Or how they would write it in England... Puppy is your Mummy.
no shes not
That song is actually from 2018
I listen to Voicemail just for that line. Makes me hard.
Just rewatched Human Cake recently, I forgot your toenails were featured in there
@astrokid the whole Cake trilogy is a RUclips classic
Those were some nasty ass toenails men like if anthony used to have fungus or something
@astrokid Frank, Max and Ian should've received an award for their outstanding work on this trilogy. It marked me forever, and I will definitely talk about it to my children, it must never be forgotten.
@@yungcade4480 there's a reason Foot Fungus is one of Anthony's favorite tracks on Stokeley. It's not because it's good, he likes it because it's actually a secret shoutout to Melon's feet
@astrokid I mean it's okay. But if we honest if the video was exactly the same in every way but having other people. Everyone would hate it and call it stupid edgy shit. It's not like it's a work of art it's just 3 idiots being gross for shockhumor. My younger self loved it but the more I grow up the less appealing the stuff is. So I'm glad the boys grew out of that.
Poppy`s new music has sky rocketed in quality
Not even it's all just techno/electronic synth crap she barely even songs in her songs anymore.
Alexandra Cranberry This EP is the best stuff she’s put out period.
@@ElHombretheman you're an idiot too fix your music taste
@@MeowmeowAlexandra How about you just let people enjoy what they want instead of telling them to 'fix' their taste in music?
The Holy Mountain is beautiful.
The title track, Voicemail, and especially Scary Mask are some of the best songs of the year.
She keeps getting better.
Poppy is incredible.
Poppy is a less interesting version of titanic sinclairs last "project" mars argo
@@punpunpunyama9271 Poppy's project got a completely different direction than Mars Argo's
@@Kr3k3r007 musically, yes, but the lore, the videos, the way poppy acts/the persona, it's all the exact same as mars argo
Yeah but like, you forgot Meat, which is the best song
@@punpunpunyama9271 mars argo was just a naive/hipster girl tho. Poppy has been completely different since late 2016
I thought you liked voicemail? You called it a banger
Jack Hanigan Exactly! So confused seeing that. I guess it got old fast for him? The breakdowns of the track are BAD.ASS. Rest of the filler is waiting time really
voicemail is unbearable
OMG, HE STILL LIKES VOICEMAIL. He just thinks the other songs are better.
Worst doesn’t necessarily mean bad.
I’ve noticed he doesn’t like repeating himself too much so I assume he just skipped it since he’s already talked about it.
I remember that you put voicemail in the best tracks section of the weekly review video and here you put it as your least favorite song? your are so confusing
I remember liking it initially too but it feels a little clunky now. Not a bad song tho.
Opinions change, hence the name, opinions.
Yeah he does that a lot. I guess he likes stuff on first listen and then it gets stale on him? Or he doesn't like it in context of the album?
It’s his least favorite. Least favorite does not mean he disliked it.
Maybe the rest of the album lets the song pale in comparison? Maybe its a less interesting song in the context of the album compared to others? Also; least favourite doesnt necessarily mean he hated it..
Why are you people like this?
yeah scary mask is pretty good
Poppy seems to be the type of artist going forward that, even if you don't personally like or agree with any given album or EP she releases, will always be doing something abstract and weird. Might be a gimmick, might be her artistic merit, might be her personality. Either way, I think she's an artist to keep your eyes on. I could see her doing some amazing things in the future. :) Thanks for reviewing the EP, Anthony!
Everything about Poppy was used before on Mars Argo. It's Titanic Sinclair's signature move: copy + paste
@ahegaofish I mean you can call her a Mars Argo copy all you want but that doesn't change the fact that she is much better then Mars Argo ever was or will be
@@tommym7321 do we care?
死神 you say faggot so often in your comments, I’m starting to believe you yourself may be one.
I wish mars fan would stop being so toxic
Ugh the track Meat is so good. I’ve been obsessed since the EP dropped.
I eat meat and I still like it. The meat industry is screwed up and could be more humane in the least.
Eric Alex Anderson I just like the song bruh
Jojo Nicole the energy your comment emits is ughhh I love it
@@ViridianCityCards There's no humane way to kill something that doesn't want to die. Just fyi I know it's been 7 months.
@@JojoNicole same? But its content is certainly interesting and makes me think. To act otherwise is silly.
This EP was a 9 review it again
10/10! Review it again!
strong 7 to a light 8
No
Still waiting on your Poppy-Choke EP review melon.
algorithms suggest this whole ep for my playlists at least weekly, and i enjoy the songwriting and delivery four years later. and now that it's autumn, i can wear headphones, which is giving me much more clarity of bass sounds.
We get that you liked the record but choking that child wasn’t the way to explain the record name
He just wants to prove his point. And don't worry - the child was handicapped.
Scary mask scared the hell out of me, and voicemail just made me laugh in such a good way. I love her
Legit threw my phone when I saw voicemail in least favorite. Thats the best one on the project! Oh well to each his own.
rip this dudes phone
The RUclips version is good but they messed with the production for the final version
Not a 10/10 because it isn’t Deathgrips I see melon
This EP is probably one of my favorite projects this year, with this otoboke beaver record and the new PUP album
Voicemail is an amazing song you Melon
i give this EP an 8, Poppy is killing it and i hope she keeps this up
You didnt have to say you wanted to choke billie eilish melon wtf!!
Great review Anthony, but I think the part where you said you wanted to choke out Poppy to fulfill your sexual fantasies of her was pretty messed up.
That melon just can't take a no....probably because he choked her out.
Cillian Clarke can't say no if you can't breathe
Wait; thats messed up?
:( guess Ima go be ashamed in the naughty boi corner
what happened to voicemail being in the best of the week wtf
That week is over.
Very well! Now you gave Poppy even a full review, in the past she was a mention between others. I like that!
WHAT Voicemail is amazing,
You said you loved every second of it in your WTR, whatever.
But besides that I agree.
Nate Nordwall He did the same thing with Foals’ Sunday and that was a much shorter turn around 😞
He's just making up a reason to not give it an 8. Smh
Okay...just because it is his least favorite on the EP does not mean he hates it. He likes the song. It's like ranking 5 really good deserts. All 5 are great but you still have to rank them in order and unfortunately one of those five is going to be the least favorite...but still liked. Understand? Does everyone understand how this works??????
eltravos99 well if you give something an average of 7 then the lowest scoring thing is below a 7.
@@amicia6742 Maybe Fantano should do a video on the differences between rating a single track and rating an album and then everyone will shut up.
Melon help me. I dropped my donut on the floor. Can you make me another one?
A real Terminator would eat it anyway
Lmfao
Great video, Anthony! Idk why you had to end it by saying “Poppy, choke forever,” but all in all a great vid! Keep it up!
Poppy’s albums are always on point, she’s incredibly talented.
@Ice Block they both are and even better together
Poppy is one of the best Pop artists out right now. This EP is fantastic.
You gave Voicemail your track of the week when it came out and now it's your least favorite track??? You literally didn't say a single negative thing the entire review and it still only gets a decent 7?? I agree with the rating but geez, make up your mind, melon.
Slade
Dude, its called “he then listened to the rest of the ep”
Scary Mask is MILES AHEAD the best thing off this thing.
Scary Mask is basically X on steroids.
It's an insane mix of pop and metal, with a sprinkle of Ronny J sounding 808 on the "Am I Okay M A S K" bridge
I love it
Garbage
I'm a crystal castles fan and meat is my favorite on the album, voicemail is my next favorite
Best EP since forever
I get that Poppy is our mommy but you didn't have to put your kid up for adoption.
Voicemail is literally the best track here.
Imagine a world in wich Anthony reviewed igor
poppy loves you poppy will always love you
No review for MADAME X by Madonna. It’s one of the most “out there” pop releases this year. Although it’s very inaccessible for mainstream but I think it’s one of Madonna’s riskiest releases. Mirwais and Madonna are my favorite combination for her.
I think the reason Poppy's channel isn't that big is because it never went anywhere
Exxxactly
poppy is god
OMG Poppy is my favorite Korean Singer!!!
“Poppy lore has gotten pretty deep and pretty weird”. So does that mean the melon cult has competition?
Is the bald man going to review Flamboyant album by Dorian Electra
Lil Poppy
Yung Pop
I remember discovering the poppy channel right before she was getting famous there was a music video in there she must be trying to launch off her music carrier all along.
Melon, you remind me of my father. While I don't always agree with what you say, your opinions are very well fleshed out, and I have seen neither of you in person.
Funny way of spelling Big K.R.I.T
I’ll vote blue for the rest of my life Anthony please I just want to see my kids
I HAVE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS!!!
You are still the prettiest girl I know, melon. 💘
this is an easy 10/10 hun
Choke me Poppy
I’ve been hooked on Poppy new EP for a few weeks now. It’s so good. 😍✨
Great review but I'm a bit miffed. The one track you didn't talk about individually was voicemail and that is my fav off this ep!
Voicemail was the best track of the week and it's your least favourite
????
What about Madonna's Madame X; I'm curious what do you think about the album as a whole and if you like something from it (I know you're opinon on the songs released before the album, but still :) ).
I can't wait to see poppy do a stoner metal album
Classic Review: Songs from the key of Life
Never heard of Poppy until you, so thanks for suggesting her to me Melon
P O P P Y i’M POPPY
Every time Fantano reviews a Poppy project he's like "I hope Poppy does this ____" and it's literally exactly what she does every time lol wtf
I’m betting strong 8 or light 9 on I disagree
Choke EP is pretty much Yeezus for Nicole Dollanganger fans
This dude really likes Primal Scream considering how many times its been there in the background.
You put Voicemail in the best track of the "weekly roundup" then you say it's the least fav?
He did the same with Kings Dead on the Black Panther Album
Yeah wtf
It's almost like he can change his mind?? Holy shit it's like he's human
@@ireneagedah4464 bruh chill
It's almost as if just because a track is the best thing to release in a specific week, once the full album comes out, it may not be as good as the rest of the tracks or something. Crazy, huh?
This is waaaaaayyyy better than the first.
Review the new LINGUA IGNOTA album please!
I've been waiting for this review
thanks for taking care of my dog today, appreciate it
Really digging melons "screamadelica" worship lately
Has anyone ever listened to Sizzy Rocket?? I found her a few months ago & completely fell in love with her latest album Grrrl....it maybe one of my fav albums of this year so far. This is just the kind of music that my ears ❤️. I do not listen to many mainstream artists, I came across her searching through music that is not on any charts. I hope there are other people out there that have the same taste as me....Somewhere!!???
It’s about time melon. I been waiting.
Poppy is the leader in the creation of hyperpop
Hey Anthony you should check out Any Human Friend by Marika Hackman. It’s shaping up to be one of the best of the summer in terms of deep, fun, indie music. Every song that’s been released is outstanding and shows that she’s gotten more comfortable not only in her sexuality but musical style and doesn’t give a f🦆 what anyone thinks of her. So, it’s raw, it’s passionate, it’s topical and fun.
Popthony Poptano
What’s the album on the background?
this isn’t exactly an album that’s easy to understand at first, but when one takes time to process everything, it becomes more than just an edgy sound choice done well.
HIGHLIGHTS: metaphors are very well thought out, poppy has a great rapping and singing voice, the production ofc.
WEAKPOINTS: meat could’ve been even better if it described how we got to the point where humanity was at in the song. it just sort of happens, but as a warning song, shouldn’t there be a solution presented to us on how to avoid getting to the very thing you warn us not to get to? or is this just some kind of vegans anthem?
FAV. TRACKS - CHOKE, VOICEMAIL, THE HOLY MOUNTAIN
LEAST FAV. TRACK - MEAT
8-9/10
recommended to: ????
Well I don't think a song's weakpoint should be something you expected from it or something you would have liked featured in it or the fact that it had potential to be even better. Plus I don't think Meat should give a solution to the problematic, that's not the point. The things that the track narrates is just a means of concientializing about the topic.
I would recommend it to someone that enjoys industrial sounds and pop and is willing to hear that weirdly mixed lol
With Meat, as with almost all their songs, they leave it to the listener to decide what it means, and what action or shift it inspires. I admire the hell out of them for that.
Jessie HoolaHoops McGee that actually is a really good point.
@@dysperdotted 👍🏼 it's the mark of true art imo ✌🏼
Meat is one my favorite luv everything about it the music her voice and the words it's a great song 🐱
Thank u melon, I don’t care about any of this but now I have an opinion in case someone asks
Great review but I didn’t appreciate you calling jay z fat lips
Mmmm Melon. Yes. I agree. Okay I can see what you’re saying there. Oh nice man that’s a great connection. Wow that was a great representation of that piece. Uh huh. Yep.
Overall this was a solid review of Poppy EP. I’m gonna give this review a light to decent 9. I would have given you a 10 if you weren’t blinking S.O.S. in Morse code the whole video.
Poppy is my mommy
I don’t know about you, but I’d give Screamadelica a 10/10? And thanks for the reminder to listen to that again!!! Love your content.
Meat is my jam
nice review melon but did you really have to send me my dog in the mail dead.
Anthony is a fake vegan I just delivered 30 lbs of steaks to him from Postmates
I’ll be waiting here patiently until Melon reviews Peppa’s Pig new album, it’s fucking fire 🔥
Album of the year? Really melon? Are you in her cult?.
the holy mountain reminded me of westworld and i love dat
I have no god damn idea who this person is but your videos have been making me want to look into her. Comparisons to Evanescence, Nine Inch Nails and Marilyn Manson make this sound entirely different than what I expected.
Great review
Subscribed.
Wow melon please treat me like the title
There is meat on me 🥩🍖🦴
Choke and holy mounatin are bangers
anyone know the album on the top shelf? i'm intrigued and kinda want to listen
Need this Big K.R.i.T. review next big dawg 🌟🌟
When are you joining SMP Live?
I'm strictly here for the t-shirt on 🤓. Brings back memories 🤟
Too late melon I already think this EP is a 10
the korn influence made my internal teenage boi very happy.
Great review but you didnt have to say she is on opiates because her name is poppy. I expected more from you melon
I was thinking the same thing about Crystal castles, great call.