Wow. This is a moving story. Brought me to tears. I did wish I was in the military when I was growing up, and parents kept me in a "reality check" because I am Deaf. I am very proud of you, Keith Nolan. You are my hero!
As I am losing my hearing, I have always been lead to believe that my career options are severely limited. You have led me to believe otherwise. I cannot thank you enough.
Important Key Points: - 4:11 Deaf soldiers serving in the past. - 4:45 Deaf Isreal soldiers - 5:58 Disablities in the US Military - 7:28 Other examples of what Deaf soldiers can do - 10:28 Nolan getting his uniform - 16:23 The Four Levels
You have fully inspire me I'm gonna keep trying! I was the first deaf cadet in my high school JROTC private first class but I really wanted to joined the military to keep the family tradition going but been turned down. I'm going to keep trying!! Thank you! Thank god for your inspirational speech! I can do it! HOOAH!!
So sad that we refuse to make an accommodation for this devoted and loyal young man. He is willing to do the work and we because it's hard just say NO.
I'm very proud of you, Keith Nolan! Congratulations on your wonderful speech !!! All are deaf RIGHTS !!! Here in Brazil does not accept deaf enter the military service, but I am even more fighting!
I support Keith, I know first hand what deaf people can do everything except hearing. They can do many of the non combat jobs without putting anyone in risk for their lifes. They can be part of the support team. I have few deaf friends who can be President of US. They are soooo smart! is unbeleivable how fast they learn and get the message. Even faster than hearing people!!
I belive that he has the right to serve his country. There are many jobs that would be able to do and more that open up as more technology is used in the military. It is true these days that they are finding small reasons to disqualify people from joining as well as letting them go, and forcing some out of the military. So as much as I feel that a deaf person can serve their country. Unfortunately it's not up to me.
Eu estou muito orgulhosa por você, Keith Nolan! Parabéns pela sua palestra maravilhosa!!! Todos os surdos são DIREITOS!!! Aqui no Brasil não aceita surdos ingressam no Serviço Militar, mas estou lutando ainda mais!
I really commend this guy's efforts, and feel that he should be able to serve in the military. I feel that he has proven that he could pass any of the physical training programs, and drills they have to offer. He has shown so much dedication and determination in his passion for service to our country. Everyone willing to serve--who chooses to serve, should be allowed to serve. Over the decades, doors have been opened to the military, I hope his dream becomes a reality for him.
Keith can actually read lips "pretty well." Reading lips is MUCH more complicated than people think, even the best lip-readers don't catch everything (or even close)! If a person is talking behind you, or just not directly in front of you, you're out. Then there's group conversation (how do you know where to look and who's talking?). And reading the lips of a drill sergeant screaming? Near impossible. Lipreading is good for basic conversation, with context, that's about it.
I really enjoyed your video! As an Army Vet and current ASL student, I found your experiences to be very interesting. I can share your video with my fellow students and friends! Also, THANK YOU FOR YOUR SERVICE!! God Bless!!
Wow! That was inspiring!!! Thanks so much for posting! I know a hearing fellow who thought he would join the Navy like his Dad and brother...but found out when senior in HS that he has a genetic heart defect. Never knew...no signs...so was disqualified from service. Changed career...now is computer tech teacher at middle school. Best of luck to Cadet Nolan. He obviously really cares about serving his country in the military.
I knew few soldiers who served in few campaigns in Iraq and Afghanistan. They only know few deaf person can perform during wartime such as sniper. I asked them why sniper? They said a sniper only needs a spotter who responsible for communication and give a confirmation from either sniper or base commander. A sniper, of course, requires being silent and reminding unseen from the enemy. I think deaf person like Keith Nolan would have an honor to be part of armed services.
Superb ! Hats off to the spirit of the guy !!! All the nuts who have given pessimistic comments ... don't really understand the tremendous efforts that this guy must have taken to reach this far. Guys ... learn something from this.
I'm glad people keep on fighting for the rights for deaf to join the military cause its been my dream to serve for the military been wanting to serve my country and follow my great grandfather's footsteps i hope they sign the bill for the rights of deaf joining the military cause it will be my honor to join the military
not only should he be allowed to join the military, but also he is quite the officer material. I feel if he is let in, he will go quite far in his military career
The deaf can read lips, blinks lighting Lan Guage and the most important read energy. They can teach you things you never knew existed. Thanks for making this video.
Deaf or HH, I see no problem. Everyone communicates by email, or texting, phone to phone anyway. Also, they can have service dogs. Deaf are so visual and have different perspectives to bring to the service.
I am one of those deaf kids that aspired to join the military, even applied to Annapolis Naval Academy in 1995. No good. This is stunning, and amazing.. I am inspired!
17:33 "policy is policy and if your deaf you're disqualified" that sentence just sounds so emotionless and disappointing I can't imagine being told that
I was in the army. I went in being fluent in ASL. My sergeants thought it was interesting and liked watching me practice my ASL for church activities on Post. I had 1 Chaplin who told me there was no use for it in the Army. Yes we use our own version of sign language for things but it’s basic and that’s that. I had another chaplain who thought it was neat that I signed. He had never really thought about their being a use for it but could see the practicality of it and always loved watching me sign for church.
Parabéns, Keitan Nolan!!! Estou muito orgulhosa por você mesmo!!! Eu também estou tentando lutar aqui no Brasil, porque aqui no Brasil proibiu os surdos ingressam no Serviço Militar.
I support keith nolan all the way.. He did good fight and go though.. I proud of him.. Hes good history I never forgot his name.. Keith keep it up I know you will not give up and proof them wrong.. Deaf and hearing are same period and deaf have skill somehow.. he is my favorite one the he is fighter his right to be military.. he in my mind .. I forward for his future.. thumb up to Keith.. clap clap clap to him
This was a really interesting video. I was born deaf in one ear where I can hear fine with the other. I've had family that served in WWII and Vietnam (3 great uncles served in infantry). By the time I turned 18 years old in 2010, I called my local Marine recruiter and was told I was disqualified and couldn't serve because I needed to hear above a certain threshold in my left ear. I tried other branches but no avail. I do understand the very importance during combat roles, but there is a good point of non-combat roles. Nearly 8 years later even though I'm creating a life for myself now, I still wonder how things could have been had I been able to serve my country somehow.
I had taken a ROTC course at Jacksonsville State University back in the Spring of '92. I ended up taking the award as the best cadet for Military Science Lv1. I proved them wrong and I got the chops to move up. Sadly, at the time, I'm not eligible to take part for Lv2 and beyond. I still have the same fire in my belly to get out there and serve MY COUNTRY!! If I had done what Keith did 20 years ago, this comment is a moot point. I'd stand with Keith 110% as well as the Troops!!
As a veteran (7 years as an Infantry and Signal Corps Officer), I salute your dedication to serve your country! It is easy to turn to barriers (e.g. talking on radios and communication during combat/training), while not acknowledging that logistics/JAG/admin focuses on computerized reports and (some) communication soldiers on computers/servers (to name a few jobs). Though there will have to be an MOS and deployment eligibility agreement, we need to fight for men and women who want to serve!
i served in the army, i was an infantryman and lost a good bit of hearing from an RPG in kandahar back in 2010..... i feel sorry for the deaf community that wants to serve, and i do think that you should be allowed to serve in some ways, and do a degree you can serve (not in the military but you can be contracted into doing some things on post).... but i could never agree with deaf in the combat roles, i am sorry but communication was a big part of my job... when the RPG blew up near me i couldnt hear anything at all for almost a week, followed by the ringing in my ear slowly getting better.... the blast happened on my very first mission out of the 1 year deployment over there... and it made the rest of the patrols suck ass that week (luckily we already used hand and arm signals and kept talking to a minimum, but there were still important things that i need to listen for)... i have no problem with you being in as a finance or computer tech guy.... and trust me you dont want to go into a combat MOS, it robs you of your sanity
White14Man ugh why do people think that because of my username that i wasnt in??? im not some motard who wanted every veteran to think im some guy who has no life outside the military... news flash, military has a dark sense of humor... we sang cadences like "napalm sticks to babies", "going to the playground, where all the children play, pull out my uzi and i spray spray spray singing left right left right kill"... "blood on the risers" "my girls a vegetable, she lives in the hospital" i was an 11b who was with the 4th ID, i wasnt airborne, wasnt ranger, wasnt SF... i was a leg, did 4 years and got out as an E4
thats awesome Deaf can do it I have known many Deaf have skilled for combat in any action. can do with or without an interpreter in training. Most of the time they do Body Language or gesture for communication during the war. I do not see why not for Deaf to join any Military. You Go Keith Nolan. Hope this change.
One serious problem! How do a deaf soldier communicate during night operations?? That is BIG no no bec that reason can get the deaf soldier and his fellow hearing teammates KIA ASAP! Interpreter for deaf combat soldiers?? U kidding.. most interpreters do not want to interpret in combat.. COMMON SENSE!!
They have technology such as night goggle for communications. Don't be negative about it. Be supportive for Keith Nolan. He has his desire dream to come true. Important is "no Barrier " for our Deaf Community have their opportunities experienced.
If you think night goggle will allow you to read lips as clearly as during the day, you will have a hard time. If you think combat will always let your team-mates afford time to turn their eyes towards you so they can see your answer, while bullets are flying, you'll have a hard time. How would you call for reinforcement, if you're the only one of your squad left alive, or near the radio? Face it: deaf people might have a place as analysts, translaters, etc. And Keith Nolan here proves it. But they have certainly no place in any position where vocal communication is used, be it as crewmembers of any type of vehicle, as gunners, as radar or radio operators, etc. I'm sorry, but that is not being negative. That is being realist.
MrVanmojo23, I've been proudly serving for 9 years now in the United States Marine Corps. I am not "dumb" as you state in your comment. During the ongoing downsizing that DOD is tasked with, I see many Sergeants fighting to stay in. They too are not dumb and serve their country proudly. I proudly serve and fight for your right to be narrow minded.
Wow. Looks like there is one way in which the Canadian military beats the U.S. military. The 2965 Royal Canadian Army Cadet Corps was formed in 1979 at the Newfoundland School for the Deaf in St John's, Newfoundland. It is the only army corps for deaf cadets in Canada, but that's more than America's got! In 1988, Cadet Lieutenant Doreen Fowler became the first deaf female commanding officer. America has a lot of catching up to do.
As a Special Forces Officer and the father of a deaf son, I back you 100%!!! Please contact me if you get this message. My son is a genius! He is a world class athlete and a math genius. This young man and many others like him are hired by huge space and technology businesses. Many would be huge assets to the military in Crypto, communications, coding, and any of the high tech military commo and equipment. Especially the Airforce should use these young people. It they can make it at Apple, Amazon and other top tech companies, they can also be ahuge assett to our military!!!
Wish these changes were starting when I was younger. I always wanted to join the army....my dream was to serve in JAG. Was always told growing up, "you can't, your Deaf!" I refused to accept in my childhood ideology! But once I was older I had to accept they were right. Glad this young man refuse to accept!!!
the safety supervisor at my job said that no deaf person can work here. Whether they are an employee or contractor. She has a lot of prejudice. This company is too screwed up and promotes that kind of people. And this company is on the S&P 500.
I AM VERY SURPRISED THAT Keith Nolan IS DEAF WHO JOINED THE US ARMY. I AM PROUD OF HIM. I MISSED TO JOIN THE AIR FORCE IN 1984 BECAUSE THEY REFUSED ME AS I AM DEAF AS MY FATHER WAS A PILOT OF AIR FORCE. NOW I AM A PRESIDENT OF NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF THE DEAF, INDIA. GOD BLESS HIM.
I don't remember if I added comments here. No problem if a deaf person can do non-combat MOS as long not in combat areas. 2 major problems is US Fed medical laws for military do not allow hearing impairments and often defense budget can be a problem providing military positions for deaf but good chance if one has crucial or rare skills like fluent Arabic. Maybe Trump may help but I don't count on it. My Army Rotc combat training in 1970s revealed life-threatening dangers for deaf cadets AND for fellow soldiers in field exercises. That's why I was not allowed in night FX at Fort Drum but allowed for live weapons training at ranges. Seriously no real combat vet soldiers want to babysit a deaf soldier in combat at all. Sadly, I have heard horror stories of US soldiers KIA bec of hearing loss caused by explosions in combat. An execption is Israeli Defense forces do now draft deaf Israelis for non-combat positions.
Keep going sounds like you're doing so well! Don't let ANYONE stop you or tell you, you can't continue! That's bull!! Good Luck! Let us know how you're doing I know you will go far!
As a former military member myself, I must admit I would at first be hesitant about being in a high stress situation with a physically disabled person. However, he expressly mentioned non-combat roles, and furthermore, given sufficient reassurance that he could preform satisfactorily, I would gladly welcome him into any job, regardless of any disability.
I am very surprised to see it . Any deaf can do anything if they have good languages . I am very proud of Keith Nolan's service . The Peoples in the world are neglecting all deaf . Special Indian government are refusing all handicapped peoples .
This is complicated. For starters - any interpreter willing to see this through is worth their weight in gold. I know for a fact, having worked for the Army Engineer Corps that the budget for services is drawn from the US Army. That is a budget that can absorb any interpreting bill. Any. So if there’s a qualified (certified) interpreter to be an accommodation - I don’t care if they ask for $300/hr (mind you this would require a complete change of life- whatever you do, imagine now starting that job at 4am and functioning in the US Army bec they need YOUR SKILLS) - whatever they ask for, they are worth.
I wonder what has happened in the 2 years between the time this video was posted and me actually discovering and watching it. I believe if you focus on what Deaf people CAN do, that list will be much longer than the list of what they CAN'T do! His superiors should try to introduce him to their superiors. The people who KNOW AND DEPEND ON him SUPPORT him. Hearing people merely trying to defend Deaf people can't match Deaf people showcasing their own talents and abilities!!!
Great job Deaf Cadet Private Keith Nolan! For fighting on to join the military of the United States of America. Keep up fighting for yourself and for other Deaf people. I'm sure there are some Deaf people like me are fighting to get equal with those hearing people. You did very well and keep it up! : )
I was born to serve. With one kidney I was denied. My father has just retired and my younger brother is now 10 years into his military career. Hate my self.
+kison pyne People with one kidney can't serve in the American military. Heck, people with too many missing teeth can't join. " The service may reject aspiring soldiers with gastrointestinal ulcers, acute or chronic pancreatitis, hernias, anemia, bleeding disorders and dental problems such as missing teeth, which could limit a recruit’s ability to eat a healthy diet. Recruit hopefuls with hearing problems and poor night vision may also miss the cut. Vision must be at least 20/30 to 20/40 in one eye, and 20/70 to 20/100 in the other eye, with or without corrective lenses. Army docs also check recruits for joint problems such as poor mobility and arthritis." -work.chron.com/armys-minimum-physical-requirements-join-13518.html
Interesting that a lot of these commenters(?) can't seem to wrap their heads around the idea of a "non-combat" role. What a shame. But on another note, I hope Nolan gets into the army one day so he can serve his country like he wants to.
my husband is/was an ASL interpreter, before he enlisted in the Army. It's a shame that they don't allow deaf people, I'm sure there are so many Hearing that know ASL that would open up even more jobs, would be kinda cool. However with the Military so over strengthened it's harder for hearing people to get jobs.
As a vet, I know that if you were deaf, you wouldn't be eligible for service. If you became deaf during service, youd be med boarded. There are many things that would disqualify you for service, hearing loss is just one of the things.
:') I've always had a soft spot for the military. And this proves how the military can be so hard on you, yet you feel like you don't belong anywhere as much as in the military. When you go thru that much with other people, nothing matters. not appearances, not disabilities, nothing. I personally haven't been in the military. I'm only 16, but my dad has been in it for 37 years. He tells me all about it, and how close you get. I tried AF ROTC.. i regret it.. not because i didn't like it, but because i didn't try hard enough.. i guess back then i wasn't as serious about the military as i am now.. Now i'm afraid to go back, 1 its my senior year. and 2, I always feel that regret and shame when i go near the ROTC room even tho I changed schools. regardless, being in that atmosphere made me feel more at home than when i'm with my own family. That mentality has always been my outfit.. and my only regret in life is not trying hard enough..
They should teach troops sign language as it allows you to talk without having to make any noise and allows a greater level of communication in key situations that require stealth :P
This is awesome!! Loved learning about this guy's passion and dedication towards becoming a soldier! (Also, I think the interpreter meant to say 'oorah')
@ Hallamfoebell I don't know since Deaf people may have no experience of military yet. Just start putting Deaf soldiers and hearing soldiers together and start testing in fake practice combat. When they see something isn't work out, maybe they can figure out to solve it. Maybe Deaf soldiers will need to train more to understand hearing soldiers' way and hearing soldiers will do the same to understand Deaf's way. The more they practice together, the more they can work each other well. I may be w
you should take this argument up with congress you have a valid argument with proof and research backing you up im sure they would love to hear you out as we all have freedom of speech you have the mind of and intellenge worker good luck hope you get accepted one day
I'm a sophomore in College and wanted to do AFROTC and when I asked to join I was told no, multiple times by multiple people and I wish I hadn't given up. I hope that I can do some sort of work in the Air Force upon graduation but in a non combat role, like Emergency Management
If you think I'm lying go to the recruiter and ask if you can join with one kidney. It's a "permanent disqualification " wish I was wrong. Have a good day.
MOST OF YOU HAD NEVER BEEN TO REAL Battlefield and it is very LOUD and you can barely hear the soldiers' frantic screams while bullets riddling' anywhere. No difference for deaf soldiers.
I understand that you feel that you could best serve the military by serving in a "noncombat role". The issue is that all service members, regardless of their assigned job are trained to deploy to combat environments. The complex environments that service members of all jobs and branches work in require the full use of their senses to include sight and hearing. Soldiers who have become disabled have relevant combat/military experience that is an asset to the military.
YES Yes Deaf can do! OH boy If I were young for sure I join!! Me Sad B/C I am not young....... But I really do encourage Young Deaf to JOIN! To show hearing ppl that Deaf can do in military. Please keep this up!! :-))
Glad he doing what he wanted to do, for be in Military...No matter what..I was in Army JROTC in Houston, Texas since almost 4 years as Cadet..I was in Cadet Captain in my last rank as I was in Instructional Staff and 6 awards...Go for it....Be All You Can Be, Go Army
Hand wave to you Keith for making it in the military, I know that there will be tough to enter third level after the commander told you that "you can't enter this due to medical test" & Policy is policy which is a full of baloney. The highest commander should have visited Israel Defense Force & study how Deaf soldiers join the military training. Bring up to Congress to change the policy. Black & women make it why not Deaf? Famous word "Deaf can do anything except hearing" Keep on fighting!
I always figured somewhere down the line the Army ought to start letting in people with physical handicaps. It'll eventually become a starship troopers (the book, not the ridiculous movie lol) scenario where anyone who is deemed psychologically fit to swear the oath can join the Army. No matter what handicap they will find a job for you. This could perhaps even apply to Navy and Air Force too. But not so much the Marines since every Marine is considered a rifleman and can be in combat anytime
Take a course in military science. Advanced memory skills, and perceptions r highly values in this situational awareness, along with sensory prediction. Now, with the time like this, our enemies prolly have several or more high skilled soldiers who r also deaf. Deaf hands r very highly important when build IEDs, ammo supports, gun repairs, and even 'heightened memory' helped with modeling IEDs, speed planting, and the numbers to remember when need to dial to blow it up.
That's a very moving story. You are dealing with the government, which is often a long and challenging progress. It's been a few years since this was posted - how has your situation progressed? I hope you are able to affect change and fully serve in the military.
@haudace Research has shown that they do. People who learn a sign language from birth use it in the same way as spoken language, even in ways that are really surprising. Deaf babies with signing parents will "babble" in sign language, repeating one part of a sign over and over, and native signers who stub their toe will unthinkingly sign an expletive the same way hearing people might unintentionally swear.
@ Hallamfoebell Ok, I still understand your concern, but give a try. Deaf people can see around better than hearing people by using their Deaf eyes. They will be able to see their teammate and looking out at the same time. If one of them duck, he might already trained to duck also. If Deaf people see something wrong, some of them can use their voice to warn others. You might not be able to understand them unless you get used to their voice.
Hello I'm Rossy and deaf, else. I totally agree this guy thats ever gooood POINT! I must Vote for him who has right for policy to change new thats about deaf should to join in the Military if they COULD do it!... Yeeeeah!
duckieroxy24 I agreed. I am impaired from South Texas who can handle the training and shoot a gun accuracy, etc but I get an no all because of my deafness. very disappointing
glad that i figure your information about deaf military. its very inspired me so much. brilliant that you wont give up for your goal which is for deaf military. hopefully that you can make it and wish you good luck! (thumb up) bravo, bravo, bravo!!! also i wanna add yours on my youtube as favorite file. thanks for your sharing with us.
Wow. This is a moving story. Brought me to tears. I did wish I was in the military when I was growing up, and parents kept me in a "reality check" because I am Deaf. I am very proud of you, Keith Nolan. You are my hero!
Keith Nola is my hero too!! HOOAAH!!
As I am losing my hearing, I have always been lead to believe that my career options are severely limited. You have led me to believe otherwise. I cannot thank you enough.
Amazing. His “disability” has caused him the “ability” of going beyond himself to become a top performer. This Man inspires me!
Important Key Points:
- 4:11 Deaf soldiers serving in the past.
- 4:45 Deaf Isreal soldiers
- 5:58 Disablities in the US Military
- 7:28 Other examples of what Deaf soldiers can do
- 10:28 Nolan getting his uniform
- 16:23 The Four Levels
You have fully inspire me I'm gonna keep trying! I was the first deaf cadet in my high school JROTC private first class but I really wanted to joined the military to keep the family tradition going but been turned down. I'm going to keep trying!! Thank you! Thank god for your inspirational speech! I can do it! HOOAH!!
So sad that we refuse to make an accommodation for this devoted and loyal young man. He is willing to do the work and we because it's hard just say NO.
I'm very proud of you, Keith Nolan! Congratulations on your wonderful speech !!!
All are deaf RIGHTS !!!
Here in Brazil does not accept deaf enter the military service, but I am even more fighting!
After so many years in the military......I'm Deaf ....I was in Artillery.
Yep, I understand that bec if a .45 pistol or 50 cal BMG is fired near me; my left ear will ring for few hours.
I was born with hearing loss and I want to join the military
@@littlebitness6756 same
I support Keith, I know first hand what deaf people can do everything except hearing. They can do many of the non combat jobs without putting anyone in risk for their lifes. They can be part of the support team. I have few deaf friends who can be President of US. They are soooo smart! is unbeleivable how fast they learn and get the message. Even faster than hearing people!!
as a woman joining the military next year and having a passion for ASL, this is truly inspiring. DEAF CAN DO IT!
I belive that he has the right to serve his country. There are many jobs that would be able to do and more that open up as more technology is used in the military. It is true these days that they are finding small reasons to disqualify people from joining as well as letting them go, and forcing some out of the military. So as much as I feel that a deaf person can serve their country. Unfortunately it's not up to me.
belive is wrong spell! :)
Gm...me name abhijeet gurav sms re or you army deaf where job piz
This brought tears to my eyes. Bravo for this man’s courage. Deaf have so much to offer,
It's great to see not only the leaders accepting him, but also the other cadets encouraging him!
Eu estou muito orgulhosa por você, Keith Nolan! Parabéns pela sua palestra maravilhosa!!!
Todos os surdos são DIREITOS!!!
Aqui no Brasil não aceita surdos ingressam no Serviço Militar, mas estou lutando ainda mais!
I really commend this guy's efforts, and feel that he should be able to serve in the military. I feel that he has proven that he could pass any of the physical training programs, and drills they have to offer. He has shown so much dedication and determination in his passion for service to our country. Everyone willing to serve--who chooses to serve, should be allowed to serve. Over the decades, doors have been opened to the military, I hope his dream becomes a reality for him.
Keith can actually read lips "pretty well." Reading lips is MUCH more complicated than people think, even the best lip-readers don't catch everything (or even close)! If a person is talking behind you, or just not directly in front of you, you're out. Then there's group conversation (how do you know where to look and who's talking?). And reading the lips of a drill sergeant screaming? Near impossible. Lipreading is good for basic conversation, with context, that's about it.
I really enjoyed your video! As an Army Vet and current ASL student, I found your experiences to be very interesting. I can share your video with my fellow students and friends! Also, THANK YOU FOR YOUR SERVICE!! God Bless!!
Hello
Your comment is very interesting you
I don't mind if we can be friends
Wow! That was inspiring!!! Thanks so much for posting! I know a hearing fellow who thought he would join the Navy like his Dad and brother...but found out when senior in HS that he has a genetic heart defect. Never knew...no signs...so was disqualified from service. Changed career...now is computer tech teacher at middle school. Best of luck to Cadet Nolan. He obviously really cares about serving his country in the military.
I knew few soldiers who served in few campaigns in Iraq and Afghanistan. They only know few deaf person can perform during wartime such as sniper. I asked them why sniper? They said a sniper only needs a spotter who responsible for communication and give a confirmation from either sniper or base commander. A sniper, of course, requires being silent and reminding unseen from the enemy. I think deaf person like Keith Nolan would have an honor to be part of armed services.
Superb ! Hats off to the spirit of the guy !!!
All the nuts who have given pessimistic comments ... don't really understand the tremendous efforts that this guy must have taken to reach this far. Guys ... learn something from this.
This individual embodies everything it is to be an American Soldier. I hope and pray you are given the opportunity you deserve sir.
Good luck. You are an incredible person. There is room for change in the military. Don't give up the fight.
Hello, your comment here is very interesting to view
I don't mind if we can be friends
I'm glad people keep on fighting for the rights for deaf to join the military cause its been my dream to serve for the military been wanting to serve my country and follow my great grandfather's footsteps i hope they sign the bill for the rights of deaf joining the military cause it will be my honor to join the military
not only should he be allowed to join the military, but also he is quite the officer material. I feel if he is let in, he will go quite far in his military career
Amazing video! Thank you for excellent interpreting and English subtitles.
The deaf can read lips, blinks lighting Lan Guage and the most important read energy. They can teach you things you never knew existed. Thanks for making this video.
Deaf or HH, I see no problem. Everyone communicates by email, or texting, phone to phone anyway. Also, they can have service dogs. Deaf are so visual and have different perspectives to bring to the service.
Thank you for your service young Sir! Your story makes me proud to be American and proud of you! Give them Heck Sir!👍🙏🙏❤️🇺🇸🐍
Continue inspiring other DEAF like you. God bless!
I am one of those deaf kids that aspired to join the military, even applied to Annapolis Naval Academy in 1995. No good.
This is stunning, and amazing.. I am inspired!
17:33 "policy is policy and if your deaf you're disqualified" that sentence just sounds so emotionless and disappointing I can't imagine being told that
I was in the army. I went in being fluent in ASL. My sergeants thought it was interesting and liked watching me practice my ASL for church activities on Post. I had 1 Chaplin who told me there was no use for it in the Army. Yes we use our own version of sign language for things but it’s basic and that’s that. I had another chaplain who thought it was neat that I signed. He had never really thought about their being a use for it but could see the practicality of it and always loved watching me sign for church.
Parabéns, Keitan Nolan!!!
Estou muito orgulhosa por você mesmo!!!
Eu também estou tentando lutar aqui no Brasil, porque aqui no Brasil proibiu os surdos ingressam no Serviço Militar.
Cadet Nolan you're an inspiration to many who deaf and wanting to enter the Armed Services.... Keep up the good work
Here in Canada I so much wanted to be in the Army, but could not because of my hearing loss. Blessings to you Cadet Private Nolan.
You are really inspired me. Go Keith Nolan!
I support keith nolan all the way.. He did good fight and go though.. I proud of him.. Hes good history I never forgot his name.. Keith keep it up I know you will not give up and proof them wrong.. Deaf and hearing are same period and deaf have skill somehow.. he is my favorite one the he is fighter his right to be military.. he in my mind .. I forward for his future.. thumb up to Keith.. clap clap clap to him
This was a really interesting video. I was born deaf in one ear where I can hear fine with the other. I've had family that served in WWII and Vietnam (3 great uncles served in infantry). By the time I turned 18 years old in 2010, I called my local Marine recruiter and was told I was disqualified and couldn't serve because I needed to hear above a certain threshold in my left ear. I tried other branches but no avail. I do understand the very importance during combat roles, but there is a good point of non-combat roles.
Nearly 8 years later even though I'm creating a life for myself now, I still wonder how things could have been had I been able to serve my country somehow.
I had taken a ROTC course at Jacksonsville State University back in the Spring of '92. I ended up taking the award as the best cadet for Military Science Lv1. I proved them wrong and I got the chops to move up. Sadly, at the time, I'm not eligible to take part for Lv2 and beyond. I still have the same fire in my belly to get out there and serve MY COUNTRY!! If I had done what Keith did 20 years ago, this comment is a moot point. I'd stand with Keith 110% as well as the Troops!!
As a veteran (7 years as an Infantry and Signal Corps Officer), I salute your dedication to serve your country! It is easy to turn to barriers (e.g. talking on radios and communication during combat/training), while not acknowledging that logistics/JAG/admin focuses on computerized reports and (some) communication soldiers on computers/servers (to name a few jobs). Though there will have to be an MOS and deployment eligibility agreement, we need to fight for men and women who want to serve!
i served in the army, i was an infantryman and lost a good bit of hearing from an RPG in kandahar back in 2010..... i feel sorry for the deaf community that wants to serve, and i do think that you should be allowed to serve in some ways, and do a degree you can serve (not in the military but you can be contracted into doing some things on post).... but i could never agree with deaf in the combat roles, i am sorry but communication was a big part of my job... when the RPG blew up near me i couldnt hear anything at all for almost a week, followed by the ringing in my ear slowly getting better.... the blast happened on my very first mission out of the 1 year deployment over there... and it made the rest of the patrols suck ass that week (luckily we already used hand and arm signals and kept talking to a minimum, but there were still important things that i need to listen for)... i have no problem with you being in as a finance or computer tech guy.... and trust me you dont want to go into a combat MOS, it robs you of your sanity
White14Man ugh why do people think that because of my username that i wasnt in??? im not some motard who wanted every veteran to think im some guy who has no life outside the military... news flash, military has a dark sense of humor... we sang cadences like "napalm sticks to babies", "going to the playground, where all the children play, pull out my uzi and i spray spray spray singing left right left right kill"... "blood on the risers" "my girls a vegetable, she lives in the hospital"
i was an 11b who was with the 4th ID, i wasnt airborne, wasnt ranger, wasnt SF... i was a leg, did 4 years and got out as an E4
Yes he is right for good very important sign language hands and help other 👂 people woke up . Thank him God bless him . Praise The Lord Amen 🙏
Hello Donna
I we love to be friends with you if you don't mind me asking
thats awesome Deaf can do it I have known many Deaf have skilled for combat in any action. can do with or without an interpreter in training. Most of the time they do Body Language or gesture for communication during the war. I do not see why not for Deaf to join any Military. You Go Keith Nolan. Hope this change.
One serious problem! How do a deaf soldier communicate during night operations?? That is BIG no no bec that reason can get the deaf soldier and his fellow hearing teammates KIA ASAP! Interpreter for deaf combat soldiers?? U kidding.. most interpreters do not want to interpret in combat.. COMMON SENSE!!
They have technology such as night goggle for communications. Don't be negative about it. Be supportive for Keith Nolan. He has his desire dream to come true. Important is "no Barrier " for our Deaf Community have their opportunities experienced.
If you think night goggle will allow you to read lips as clearly as during the day, you will have a hard time.
If you think combat will always let your team-mates afford time to turn their eyes towards you so they can see your answer, while bullets are flying, you'll have a hard time.
How would you call for reinforcement, if you're the only one of your squad left alive, or near the radio?
Face it: deaf people might have a place as analysts, translaters, etc. And Keith Nolan here proves it.
But they have certainly no place in any position where vocal communication is used, be it as crewmembers of any type of vehicle, as gunners, as radar or radio operators, etc.
I'm sorry, but that is not being negative. That is being realist.
MrVanmojo23,
I've been proudly serving for 9 years now in the United States Marine Corps. I am not "dumb" as you state in your comment. During the ongoing downsizing that DOD is tasked with, I see many Sergeants fighting to stay in. They too are not dumb and serve their country proudly. I proudly serve and fight for your right to be narrow minded.
In 2023. Is there deaf people allowed to go war?? I would love to be trained as Top Deadly Sniper for Solider
Wow. Looks like there is one way in which the Canadian military beats the U.S. military. The 2965 Royal Canadian Army Cadet Corps was formed in 1979 at the Newfoundland School for the Deaf in St John's, Newfoundland. It is the only army corps for deaf cadets in Canada, but that's more than America's got!
In 1988, Cadet Lieutenant Doreen Fowler became the first deaf female commanding officer. America has a lot of catching up to do.
Go Cadet Nolan! I'm behind you!
when the audience applauded my heart swelled
As a Special Forces Officer and the father of a deaf son, I back you 100%!!! Please contact me if you get this message. My son is a genius! He is a world class athlete and a math genius. This young man and many others like him are hired by huge space and technology businesses. Many would be huge assets to the military in Crypto, communications, coding, and any of the high tech military commo and equipment. Especially the Airforce should use these young people. It they can make it at Apple, Amazon and other top tech companies, they can also be ahuge assett to our military!!!
Wish these changes were starting when I was younger. I always wanted to join the army....my dream was to serve in JAG. Was always told growing up, "you can't, your Deaf!" I refused to accept in my childhood ideology! But once I was older I had to accept they were right. Glad this young man refuse to accept!!!
the safety supervisor at my job said that no deaf person can work here. Whether they are an employee or contractor. She has a lot of prejudice. This company is too screwed up and promotes that kind of people. And this company is on the S&P 500.
THANK YOU!
THIS GUY IS AMAZING! I hope he gets his wish to be a 2nd LT!
F**k all your negativity, he has a major barrier yet does better then most of you could!
I am support u in 110%!! I want to become deaf pilot for USAF!
Just posted this on a forum, good luck Cadet!
Im sure this guy have done a massive effort to make this possible but Ted talk are often very inspiring but this is just sad in a sick world!
dont give up!! big voice can hear!!
I AM VERY SURPRISED THAT Keith Nolan IS DEAF WHO JOINED THE US ARMY. I AM PROUD OF HIM. I MISSED TO JOIN THE AIR FORCE IN 1984 BECAUSE THEY REFUSED ME AS I AM DEAF AS MY FATHER WAS A PILOT OF AIR FORCE. NOW I AM A PRESIDENT OF NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF THE DEAF, INDIA. GOD BLESS HIM.
I don't remember if I added comments here. No problem if a deaf person can do non-combat MOS as long not in combat areas. 2 major problems is US Fed medical laws for military do not allow hearing impairments and often defense budget can be a problem providing military positions for deaf but good chance if one has crucial or rare skills like fluent Arabic. Maybe Trump may help but I don't count on it. My Army Rotc combat training in 1970s revealed life-threatening dangers for deaf cadets AND for fellow soldiers in field exercises. That's why I was not allowed in night FX at Fort Drum but allowed for live weapons training at ranges. Seriously no real combat vet soldiers want to babysit a deaf soldier in combat at all. Sadly, I have heard horror stories of US soldiers KIA bec of hearing loss caused by explosions in combat. An execption is Israeli Defense forces do now draft deaf Israelis for non-combat positions.
Keep going sounds like you're doing so well! Don't let ANYONE stop you or tell you, you can't continue! That's bull!! Good Luck! Let us know how you're doing I know you will go far!
it will be great challenge to stand for us and for others my generation is all in military but I love to support any how !
As a former military member myself, I must admit I would at first be hesitant about being in a high stress situation with a physically disabled person. However, he expressly mentioned non-combat roles, and furthermore, given sufficient reassurance that he could preform satisfactorily, I would gladly welcome him into any job, regardless of any disability.
I am very surprised to see it . Any deaf can do anything if they have good languages . I am very proud of Keith Nolan's service . The Peoples in the world are neglecting all deaf . Special Indian government are refusing all handicapped peoples .
This is complicated.
For starters - any interpreter willing to see this through is worth their weight in gold. I know for a fact, having worked for the Army Engineer Corps that the budget for services is drawn from the US Army. That is a budget that can absorb any interpreting bill. Any. So if there’s a qualified (certified) interpreter to be an accommodation - I don’t care if they ask for $300/hr (mind you this would require a complete change of life- whatever you do, imagine now starting that job at 4am and functioning in the US Army bec they need YOUR SKILLS) - whatever they ask for, they are worth.
I wonder what has happened in the 2 years between the time this video was posted and me actually discovering and watching it. I believe if you focus on what Deaf people CAN do, that list will be much longer than the list of what they CAN'T do! His superiors should try to introduce him to their superiors. The people who KNOW AND DEPEND ON him SUPPORT him. Hearing people merely trying to defend Deaf people can't match Deaf people showcasing their own talents and abilities!!!
Great job Deaf Cadet Private Keith Nolan! For fighting on to join the military of the United States of America. Keep up fighting for yourself and for other Deaf people. I'm sure there are some Deaf people like me are fighting to get equal with those hearing people. You did very well and keep it up! : )
I was born to serve. With one kidney I was denied. My father has just retired and my younger brother is now 10 years into his military career. Hate my self.
Your a liar, there is nothing preventing people with one kidney to serve. You must be saying this shit to get some type of sympathy
+kison pyne People with one kidney can't serve in the American military. Heck, people with too many missing teeth can't join.
" The service may reject aspiring soldiers with gastrointestinal ulcers, acute or chronic pancreatitis, hernias, anemia, bleeding disorders and dental problems such as missing teeth, which could limit a recruit’s ability to eat a healthy diet. Recruit hopefuls with hearing problems and poor night vision may also miss the cut. Vision must be at least 20/30 to 20/40 in one eye, and 20/70 to 20/100 in the other eye, with or without corrective lenses. Army docs also check recruits for joint problems such as poor mobility and arthritis."
-work.chron.com/armys-minimum-physical-requirements-join-13518.html
Interesting that a lot of these commenters(?) can't seem to wrap their heads around the idea of a "non-combat" role. What a shame. But on another note, I hope Nolan gets into the army one day so he can serve his country like he wants to.
"Unthinking respect for authority is the greatest enemy of truth." -Albert Einstein
my husband is/was an ASL interpreter, before he enlisted in the Army. It's a shame that they don't allow deaf people, I'm sure there are so many Hearing that know ASL that would open up even more jobs, would be kinda cool. However with the Military so over strengthened it's harder for hearing people to get jobs.
As a vet, I know that if you were deaf, you wouldn't be eligible for service. If you became deaf during service, youd be med boarded. There are many things that would disqualify you for service, hearing loss is just one of the things.
:') I've always had a soft spot for the military. And this proves how the military can be so hard on you, yet you feel like you don't belong anywhere as much as in the military. When you go thru that much with other people, nothing matters. not appearances, not disabilities, nothing.
I personally haven't been in the military. I'm only 16, but my dad has been in it for 37 years. He tells me all about it, and how close you get. I tried AF ROTC.. i regret it.. not because i didn't like it, but because i didn't try hard enough.. i guess back then i wasn't as serious about the military as i am now.. Now i'm afraid to go back, 1 its my senior year. and 2, I always feel that regret and shame when i go near the ROTC room even tho I changed schools.
regardless, being in that atmosphere made me feel more at home than when i'm with my own family. That mentality has always been my outfit..
and my only regret in life is not trying hard enough..
They should teach troops sign language as it allows you to talk without having to make any noise and allows a greater level of communication in key situations that require stealth :P
I believe the deaf are great teachers
i hope kenya defence force is watching this clip of US deaf soldier.
This is awesome!! Loved learning about this guy's passion and dedication towards becoming a soldier! (Also, I think the interpreter meant to say 'oorah')
robyyynnnnn lol Hoorah! :) I agree
@ Hallamfoebell I don't know since Deaf people may have no experience of military yet. Just start putting Deaf soldiers and hearing soldiers together and start testing in fake practice combat. When they see something isn't work out, maybe they can figure out to solve it. Maybe Deaf soldiers will need to train more to understand hearing soldiers' way and hearing soldiers will do the same to understand Deaf's way. The more they practice together, the more they can work each other well. I may be w
you should take this argument up with congress you have a valid argument with proof and research backing you up im sure they would love to hear you out as we all have freedom of speech you have the mind of and intellenge worker good luck hope you get accepted one day
I'm a sophomore in College and wanted to do AFROTC and when I asked to join I was told no, multiple times by multiple people and I wish I hadn't given up. I hope that I can do some sort of work in the Air Force upon graduation but in a non combat role, like Emergency Management
If you think I'm lying go to the recruiter and ask if you can join with one kidney. It's a "permanent disqualification " wish I was wrong. Have a good day.
Let's get this start!
MOST OF YOU HAD NEVER BEEN TO REAL Battlefield and it is very LOUD and you can barely hear the soldiers' frantic screams while bullets riddling' anywhere. No difference for deaf soldiers.
I understand that you feel that you could best serve the military by serving in a "noncombat role". The issue is that all service members, regardless of their assigned job are trained to deploy to combat environments. The complex environments that service members of all jobs and branches work in require the full use of their senses to include sight and hearing. Soldiers who have become disabled have relevant combat/military experience that is an asset to the military.
YES Yes Deaf can do! OH boy If I were young for sure I join!! Me Sad B/C I am not young....... But I really do encourage Young Deaf to JOIN! To show hearing ppl that Deaf can do in military. Please keep this up!! :-))
Glad he doing what he wanted to do, for be in Military...No matter what..I was in Army JROTC
in Houston, Texas since almost 4 years as Cadet..I was in Cadet Captain in my last rank as I
was in Instructional Staff and 6 awards...Go for it....Be All You Can Be, Go Army
Hand wave to you Keith for making it in the military, I know that there will be tough to enter third level after the commander told you that "you can't enter this due to medical test" & Policy is policy which is a full of baloney. The highest commander should have visited Israel Defense Force & study how Deaf soldiers join the military training. Bring up to Congress to change the policy. Black & women make it why not Deaf? Famous word "Deaf can do anything except hearing" Keep on fighting!
I always figured somewhere down the line the Army ought to start letting in people with physical handicaps. It'll eventually become a starship troopers (the book, not the ridiculous movie lol) scenario where anyone who is deemed psychologically fit to swear the oath can join the Army. No matter what handicap they will find a job for you. This could perhaps even apply to Navy and Air Force too. But not so much the Marines since every Marine is considered a rifleman and can be in combat anytime
Excellent voice interpreter! Thanks
He doesn't have a disability, he is more able than most of the people in the army including the top knobs
Take a course in military science. Advanced memory skills, and perceptions r highly values in this situational awareness, along with sensory prediction. Now, with the time like this, our enemies prolly have several or more high skilled soldiers who r also deaf. Deaf hands r very highly important when build IEDs, ammo supports, gun repairs, and even 'heightened memory' helped with modeling IEDs, speed planting, and the numbers to remember when need to dial to blow it up.
Hey Keith, Congrats great job! Im proud that deaf can join military. Honor salute to you! Im canadian.
That's a very moving story.
You are dealing with the government, which is often a long and challenging progress. It's been a few years since this was posted - how has your situation progressed? I hope you are able to affect change and fully serve in the military.
@haudace Research has shown that they do. People who learn a sign language from birth use it in the same way as spoken language, even in ways that are really surprising. Deaf babies with signing parents will "babble" in sign language, repeating one part of a sign over and over, and native signers who stub their toe will unthinkingly sign an expletive the same way hearing people might unintentionally swear.
Excellent presentation! Very good and inspiring story. Too bad he can't fully participate in the 3rd level classes and stuff, but there's always hope!
wow
Thank you for Korea subtitles.
The world's first Deaf in the military
@ Hallamfoebell Ok, I still understand your concern, but give a try. Deaf people can see around better than hearing people by using their Deaf eyes. They will be able to see their teammate and looking out at the same time. If one of them duck, he might already trained to duck also. If Deaf people see something wrong, some of them can use their voice to warn others. You might not be able to understand them unless you get used to their voice.
Loving the US army with all my heart for accepting and allowing deaf people to be soldiers.
I forgot one more thing, in Jamaica not allowed deaf to drive any vehicles and some place too. Right on damn man. Their government road Act is idiot !
Hello I'm Rossy and deaf, else. I totally agree this guy thats ever gooood POINT! I must Vote for him who has right for policy to change new thats about deaf should to join in the Military if they COULD do it!... Yeeeeah!
duckieroxy24 I agreed. I am impaired from South Texas who can handle the training and shoot a gun accuracy, etc but I get an no all because of my deafness. very disappointing
Two words, man: radio communications.
glad that i figure your information about deaf military. its very inspired me so much. brilliant that you wont give up for your goal which is for deaf military. hopefully that you can make it and wish you good luck! (thumb up) bravo, bravo, bravo!!!
also i wanna add yours on my youtube as favorite file. thanks for your sharing with us.