TEDxAmsterdam 2011 - Peter van Uhm

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 28 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 572

  • @Deposneek
    @Deposneek 13 лет назад +14

    Very inspiring talk, i listened in silence to him and that doesn’t happen often.
    As an ex VN soldier i fully support the generals opinion.
    Even after losing his own son in Afghanistan he still firmly believes in his ideals and knows how to express them on a way that is understandable and inspiring to allot of people, i can only say general van Uhm made me proud to be Dutch today, and proud i served in the Dutch armed forces.

  • @friendofcoal
    @friendofcoal 5 лет назад +6

    This General speaks the truth from the heart. I thank him and the Captain and all who serve.

  • @sebastiaanzijlstra2473
    @sebastiaanzijlstra2473 7 лет назад +13

    i was under his command,it was the best general and still is the best general we had..van uhm we salute you,your son will be remembered

  • @UnusSedLeo-w5l
    @UnusSedLeo-w5l 13 лет назад +4

    A great story and a great speech. This general, who lost his son, knows more than most of us will ever know. Because some of us take up these arms, means others can write here what they want, take up a profession of their dreams and live in peace.

    • @SSgtBlueUSMC0369
      @SSgtBlueUSMC0369 Год назад

      Blessed be the peacemakers and the one who stands the watch. Semper Fi

  • @paladin50554
    @paladin50554 13 лет назад +9

    A superb speech from someone that truly knows the price of war.

  • @linuxgnome
    @linuxgnome 13 лет назад +1

    I'm just glade that the majority of countries with guns and bombs are on the side of Democracy and peace, and not the other way around.
    We are dam lucky to have men like this General, who knows what it takes to keep the peace in this world, God bless him.

  • @WCricker57
    @WCricker57 13 лет назад +13

    It's my boss... Great speech, completely true!
    Reminder: he lost his Son in Afghanistan a few years ago. Deep Respect!
    All the best, Chief!
    WCricker
    Warrant Officer Royal Dutch Army

  • @Strath2k6
    @Strath2k6 13 лет назад +2

    Thank you, Sir. I served for 2 decades, and no one has ever made "why" as clear as you.

  • @651325
    @651325 9 лет назад +64

    Without Imgur I would have never ended up here. I think as a Dutch person I'm biased and already against guns, but I never thought about the bigger picture. Thanks

    • @friendofcoal
      @friendofcoal 5 лет назад +1

      Sometimes you can't see the forest for the trees, and sometimes you can't see the trees for the forest. It's always better to look at everything, then decide.... The Netherlands (Holland) is a very beautiful place with great people.

    • @Jinka1950
      @Jinka1950 4 года назад +1

      Tiny -- this kind of thinking you had is typical of someone who DOES NOT think about the big picture... typical Leftist Radicals in the U. S. A..

  • @superduperwiiuowner
    @superduperwiiuowner 9 лет назад +19

    As a US citizen, i completely agree with everything this man said. (also thanks Imgur)

  • @105mmgunner
    @105mmgunner 13 лет назад

    i had to stand ... as a retired troop from another country I can only watch in amazement at an increadibly Leader speak... thank you

  • @Bertuz1979
    @Bertuz1979 12 лет назад

    The best thing about this speach is that he does not talk about his son who died in Afghanistan..... Any other American speaker would have used this fact to support his statement, but this dutch speaker is realistic enough to not use this fact, thumbs up for this man. The story is also pretty solid, this guy knows what he talk about

  • @JaulLakeson
    @JaulLakeson 3 месяца назад

    This is one of the greatest speeches on the true nature of the Profession of Arms.

  • @JohnWillimon
    @JohnWillimon 13 лет назад

    I am humbled to be reminded what freedom truly means by this man who I do not know, when I presumed to think that only my countrymen could understand it. I salute a better man then myself.
    Karsh

  • @Kurou_Miyamae
    @Kurou_Miyamae 13 лет назад +2

    Is there an "I absolutely am amazed my this inspiring man" button?
    Great speech.

  • @ArnWe90
    @ArnWe90 12 лет назад +1

    Respect and gratitude from a fellow swedish soldier.

  • @58jumps
    @58jumps 13 лет назад

    As a combat veteran who was wounded several times I can only salute and applaud this General's service, along with his remarkable speech for its historical insight, clarity and societal value. I also have to salute and applaud the Captain's service as well. They fight so the rest of us don't have to. God bless them all.

  • @chaser49
    @chaser49 12 лет назад +4

    This is why I love working with the Dutch Military.......Respect from the Canadian Forces

  • @fredkerkhof
    @fredkerkhof 13 лет назад

    More than perfect. Strong speech. Respect for this General who showed that he is a real professional, standing for HIS soldiers. The best thing what could happen to our soldiers is that the General will go into politics after his retirement. Wouldn't he be the best Minister of Defence.

  • @BunkerGearGal
    @BunkerGearGal 12 лет назад +1

    OUTSTANDING! This should be required viewing!

  • @kskisbetterthanseals
    @kskisbetterthanseals 12 лет назад

    better than every politician. without a sheet of paper. My respect!
    greetings from your allies from germany!

  • @Strath2k6
    @Strath2k6 13 лет назад

    Thank you, General. You speak for all us that serve.

  • @mp3duk
    @mp3duk 13 лет назад +6

    What a great speech!! Very inspiring!!
    My utmost respect for this commander and his troops!

  • @claybarbieri9909
    @claybarbieri9909 2 года назад

    I served in my country's armed forces. And such men and women are why we have a country, and why many of us serve in our respective Armed Forces. And why, even though I served 8 years of active duty I never had to use my rifle in combat. Granted, many have needed to do since then. And for such I am grateful, my son lives in a time of relative peace, that would not exist otherwise.

  • @samuelbueno7863
    @samuelbueno7863 10 лет назад +3

    I think that the excellent speech of General Peter van Uhm is particularly ilustrative for helping to understand the vision postulated by the governs which send troops to fight terrorism, violent crime and other activities which erode civil life in various parts of the world and prevent the building up there of functional democracies with western features.

  • @Abbylicious
    @Abbylicious 12 лет назад +1

    There will always be people who still can find something negative in a perfect humble man/speach.
    I have nobody in the military and still have every body there.
    Respect for every one who gives their lives in order to trie to make the world a better place and protect there own.
    Moge de Here u en uw nageslacht rijkelijk zegenen. Als iedereen een beetje van dat nederigheid heeft van u, dan is de wereld al een stuk mooier!
    With Love...

  • @dutchbabyface
    @dutchbabyface 13 лет назад +2

    This video makes me even more proud of our forces, and what they are doing.

  • @varandapinto
    @varandapinto 13 лет назад +1

    Thank you Sir for you clear, perfect and opportune speech. Thank you for the work of your armed forces. With you and your soldiers we can have a better world.

  • @libertatispraesidium957
    @libertatispraesidium957 8 лет назад

    He is a hero, we need these people a lot in the coming century. These are worrying times, in which we need to be proud of our values and defend them.

  • @arnold9448
    @arnold9448 8 лет назад +3

    Very well spoken English Peter van Uhm! Lots of respect!

  • @BillyK058
    @BillyK058 13 лет назад +1

    Much respect for our Commander-In-Chief General van Uhm.
    Proud to serve under you sir!

  • @andy4an
    @andy4an 11 лет назад +5

    he starts at 0:56
    good talk. clear and appropriate information about hit views, and presented very well.

  • @thekameleon9785
    @thekameleon9785 9 месяцев назад +1

    May i note that this General lost his own son in Afganistan. He is also legend.

  • @FX3-UK
    @FX3-UK 13 лет назад

    If only our Dutch politicians could speak English that well and with such charisma. Bravo "mon generale"

  • @Strath2k6
    @Strath2k6 13 лет назад

    Bravo, General. You speak for Soldiers world-wide.

  • @em23
    @em23 13 лет назад

    deep respect for this man and the Netherlands.

  • @Goose3011
    @Goose3011 13 лет назад +2

    the longer I listen to the General's speech, the prouder I am serving for the Dutch Army

  • @mcguirejames
    @mcguirejames 13 лет назад +2

    I wish the Generals in my country were so well spoken.

  • @ScorpyEmp21
    @ScorpyEmp21 12 лет назад

    This man knows where he is talking about. Im in the dutch royal army myself and we do alot of diffrent stuff that other countries dont do. We give 'war' a diffrent meaning. We dont want to kill, we want to help! Our weapons decade because we dont use them so often! The Netherlands is also known with its 'Dutch Approach'. I hope we wont have to fight, all I want to do is help people in the world, and give them hope for the future.

  • @billchrono
    @billchrono 13 лет назад

    i am a big fun of science and the progress made through science for is our best hope and may i say the only hope for a better and peaceful future, but i still see the need for people like the general, i hope for a future that people with arms are not going to be needed sadly this time is not yet here

  • @MadAtreides1
    @MadAtreides1 9 лет назад +125

    Imgur brought me here

    • @martyn2533
      @martyn2533 9 лет назад +7

      Nationalism and democracy brought Peter Van Uhm here

    • @HoundDogBlue
      @HoundDogBlue 9 лет назад

      MadAtreides1 yes

    • @ninjamanfella
      @ninjamanfella 9 лет назад

      MadAtreides1 my username for youtube is so shit compared to imgur...

    • @MadAtreides1
      @MadAtreides1 9 лет назад

      ninjamanfella for me it's the other way around, my imgur username sucks hard

    • @BertalSofiane
      @BertalSofiane 9 лет назад

      MadAtreides1 .... same here ;)

  • @Tw1stedPepper
    @Tw1stedPepper 13 лет назад

    David Cameron and his cronies need to take a leaf out of this gentleman's book. He talks sense and actually realises with passion, that his armed forces are important and need support from every direction regardless of circumstance.
    In the UK we have to push and beg and start charities for this type of 'spoken' support for our troops and Armed Forces.
    An obvious Gentleman with a passions for freedom by the use of defence.
    Our current global leaders should watch this with envy!

  • @1canadianprepper
    @1canadianprepper 12 лет назад

    Much respect for our men and women who serve our countries

  • @edovansanten
    @edovansanten 13 лет назад +2

    Excellent presentation, compliments and respect!

  • @tomtess68
    @tomtess68 13 лет назад +2

    Deep respect. Beautiful Speech!

  • @SoYFooD2
    @SoYFooD2 13 лет назад

    en voor de mensen die denken dat hij dit niet meent
    van uhm heeft een van zijn zoons verleren in afganistan door en berm bom en weet dus maar al te goed wat voor over je soms moet brengen, en durft toch noch zo voor zijn iedeaalen uit te komen.
    deze man heeft mijn respepect

  • @ThatNordicGuy
    @ThatNordicGuy 13 лет назад

    The fact that he sounds exactly like a Dutch Sean Connery, just made this even better!

  • @sagman68
    @sagman68 13 лет назад

    The most important thing that is imparted in this speech is very succinct. He says "I do not like guns". Most soldiers don't like guns. They are tools. And like any tradesmen we learn how to use them.

  • @Strath2k6
    @Strath2k6 13 лет назад

    In 18 minutes he explains why we fight. Well done, General. I would follow you, Sir.

  • @HogeyeBill
    @HogeyeBill 11 лет назад +7

    The first part is a really good explanation of why civilians should not be restricted in firearms ownership. His grandfather’s story is a good illustration of the perils of civilian disarmament - he didn’t have access to a workable weapon.
    Great right of self defense quotes:
    “Sometimes only the gun can stand between good and evil.”
    “The gun may be one of the most important instruments of peace and stability in this world.”
    Notes:
    Steven Pinker says world less violent because of state monopoly of violence.
    1) reassurance - removes incentives for arms race
    2) incentives for less violence - abstaining from violence is more profitable than starting a war
    3) where there is little conflict, trade flourishes
    Note that all three also apply (even more so) to polycentric legal and defense systems. In short, he really doesn’t give any adequate argument for why *only a monopoly* would work. Neither does he count the costs of statism; instead he arbitrarily starts his statist “non-violence score” after the last big inter-statist war. I would argue the opposite, that the 20th century history of wars and democide prove that states are WAY too violent. I recently read a paper refuting his “democracies don’t attack each other” theory. One argument that moved me: the reason “democratic” states don’t attack each other today is because of US military hegemony. States in Communist Block (“iron curtain”) states didn’t attack each other either, since they were under Soviet hegemony. Another point made was that in WWII, it WAS a bunch of democratic countries at war with each other.
    The rest of the talk is weak apologetics for empire, neo-colonialist “nation building,” and flattering his hero masters in the USEmpire who (he thinks) saved his country from the Nazis. Note the patriotic dog and pony show of the deaf milfare asshole who lost her hearing while helping murder folks in a country she invaded. Duh!

  • @tuffk
    @tuffk 13 лет назад

    Great Job ,, Thank you Peter, Thanks to your father and son also.

  • @jaapongeveer6203
    @jaapongeveer6203 6 лет назад

    Thank you Captain Verhoef for your service

  • @leondouven8738
    @leondouven8738 2 года назад

    one off the greatest men i ever knew

  • @Kilroytheknifesnob
    @Kilroytheknifesnob 13 лет назад +1

    Fantastic talk, wish I could meet him.

  • @SSgtBlueUSMC0369
    @SSgtBlueUSMC0369 Год назад

    Still one of the best speakers ever to touch this topic! So many need to hear this and understand it. As we progress away from the gun it will leave a void that has been seen to many times around the world.

    • @vincentpol
      @vincentpol Год назад

      Peace?

    • @SSgtBlueUSMC0369
      @SSgtBlueUSMC0369 Год назад

      @@vincentpol No, you need to watch this again I’m afraid. Peace in many places is only a dream. Failed states and governments are a danger on a global scale. Who do you enforce peace with hopes and dreams? At the end of the day it’s really simple. People sleep safely at night because someone is willing to do violence on your behalf for the blanket of security they provide. I’m all for a peaceful world do not mistake what I’m saying at all, but it takes well trained people to make that happen.

  • @Ruben1L
    @Ruben1L 13 лет назад

    In the begin I laughed because of his typical Dutch prenounced English (I'm Dutch too), but I really respect this man, his son was resent killed in Afghanistan. Despite this he fight for freedom and peace.

  • @calexander230
    @calexander230 10 лет назад +12

    a patriot to the Dutch

  • @desertengineer1
    @desertengineer1 13 лет назад

    Excellent speech. Honest. Well said. Well supported by historic facts. No fluff. Direct. That's how it should be done. Wouldn't think twice to trade my entire 22 military years for a world free of violence, but reality is otherwise. Somebody has to do that job. I prefer it to be done by men and women of reason and heart. This guy gets it.

  • @INFMAR1
    @INFMAR1 12 лет назад

    Thumbs up from a U.S. Marine.

  • @jasonnwmartin
    @jasonnwmartin 12 лет назад

    A brilliant example of how ignorance and inaction does not forgive complacency.

  • @Cabo-Verde-bus-driver
    @Cabo-Verde-bus-driver 13 лет назад +2

    great leadership ! great man ! I love(d)
    this General !

  • @Dutchbird757
    @Dutchbird757 13 лет назад +1

    Excellent speech. Proud to be Dutch!

  • @ebonpaladin
    @ebonpaladin 13 лет назад

    This was definitely worth watching and what he is saying is just the God-honest truth. You don't have to like or agree with the decisions made by the gov't, but the individual soldier is just like you and me, the only difference being they signed on to defend the freedoms that we so casually enjoy.

  • @geniealdrich9005
    @geniealdrich9005 2 года назад

    I wish this Sterling human being could be President of the United States. God bless him his devotion intelligence courage

  • @Some2else
    @Some2else 13 лет назад

    Very impressive talk, usually i interrupt listening a speech several times, not so this one.

  • @Endelvelico
    @Endelvelico 13 лет назад

    I'm also a military, father and free citizen from Portugal. Unfortunately ours politicians and general public don't respect our own Armed Forces or care about ours 50 years old rifles (this is not a joke) and that's sad because Portugal stands for almost 900 years mainly due to ours military ancestors will and sacrifice. Like George Orwell said "People sleep peaceably in their beds at night only because rough men stand ready to do violence on their behalf."

  • @993rana
    @993rana 12 лет назад +1

    Very good military discourse. I wish in Spain, somebody expose the same speech.

  • @teddy7528
    @teddy7528 13 лет назад

    Eindelijk iemand die de belangrijkheid van de krijgsmacht aantoont ter handhaving van de vrijhrid en ter voorkoming van oorlog. Een krijksmacht kan nooit te sterk zijn.Si vis pacem,parabellum. Wie de vrede liefheeft, bewapene zich.
    Well done,general.

  • @Foundation13
    @Foundation13 12 лет назад

    What are you going on about? I live in Rotterdam and let me tell you; there is no brainwashing of naive Dutch people by North African immigrants. I think Dutch people in general are way to sober and stubborn to accept foreign values that would lead to violence. Van Uhm just made a great speech about how violence is applied nowadays and with which purposes. And I agree with all of them.

  • @sonparabailar
    @sonparabailar 9 лет назад +2

    Also brought here from imgur. Hello, from Texas!

  • @voordenhout
    @voordenhout 12 лет назад

    Thanks. It is good to get some positive feedback on this somewhat surreal conversation.

  • @AlexDerossard
    @AlexDerossard 13 лет назад

    You can't bring peace with a gun, you will only bring instability.
    However you can defend with a gun to preserve that what you already have.

  • @Shds0fGry
    @Shds0fGry 13 лет назад

    @Anderasio
    Correct. I was just trying to keep it simple. The Netherlands uses/used the Canadian model, including the Maple Leaf stamped on the side.

  • @Shds0fGry
    @Shds0fGry 13 лет назад

    @Anderasio @samgtree
    They have been using the Canadian made Belgian designed FN C7. It does look like the American rifle though.
    Also, fantastic speech.

  • @NRAGreer
    @NRAGreer 13 лет назад

    It's all ways for the good to stop evil. When the evil people are dead in are world.Then we all will be free.Good all ways wins over evil.

  • @bastat2shop
    @bastat2shop 13 лет назад +2

    a welcome change to the usual, great speech

  • @PaulRomeo27
    @PaulRomeo27 13 лет назад

    Respect for the General,Napoleon Bonaparte had once said" I better have an army with Sheeps and a Lion as leader than an army of Lions with a Sheep as leader!!

  • @desertengineer1
    @desertengineer1 13 лет назад

    @daetech I think he is referring to Weber's theory that the application of violence must have legitimacy from the state, essentially the "well regulated" militia argument that violence must be carefully applied through law.

  • @PERU905
    @PERU905 12 лет назад

    Tienes razón amigo en el ejercito las ordenes se cumplen sin dudas y murmuraciones que difícil habrá sido para algunos soldados que tomaron las armas con la vocación y convicción de usarlas para garantizar la paz y seguridad de su país en caso de alguna amenaza enemiga y reconocer ir en contra de sus principios haciendo lo contrario el mal uso de sus armas agrediendo matando soldados y familias civiles arrazando pueblos y condenandolos a la pobreza y miseria.

  • @rechteroever
    @rechteroever 13 лет назад

    General van Uhms ideals must be worldwide general ideals of every soldier. If that happen than his ideals will realy happen.

  • @Groningen.explorer
    @Groningen.explorer 13 лет назад

    Love the Netherlands i'm proud to be Dutch!

  • @jamescory5
    @jamescory5 12 лет назад

    Awesome speach and kudos to the Dutch Armed Forces and all of our allies. However, I don't understand the stupid comments about the this country's soldier or that. The fact is that the US Armed Forces and our allies, like the Dutch, and yes even France, are keeping you safe and free. There are bad apples and ignorant bold statements everywhere but General Van Uhm is a shining example of what is right with our armed forces.

  • @ypey1
    @ypey1 11 лет назад

    actualy i teared up. Don't forget this man lost his son not long before this speach on a peace keeping mission in afganistan! thats a realy imperssive speach.

  • @rockel83
    @rockel83 11 лет назад +4

    Impressive speech!

  • @fliteshare
    @fliteshare 12 лет назад

    You know a better way of removing delusions but through discussion ?
    And I don't know what makes me a sinner, those are your prejudgements.

  • @StatusPia
    @StatusPia 12 лет назад

    And repeat that day after day, after day and so on

  • @greyfoxgaming365
    @greyfoxgaming365 13 лет назад

    @ 1:58 does the female captain have a prosthetic leg or something? he says she suffered permanent injury to her legs, could it have been amputation?

  • @RenataGreenberg
    @RenataGreenberg 13 лет назад

    @ramsesmuc this is the wisest comment to the video i have read on this page. thank you

  • @AntonMelein
    @AntonMelein 13 лет назад +1

    Great speech indeed and the general made lots of statements which are facts.....!!! QPO

  • @knarfartanis
    @knarfartanis 13 лет назад

    Proud on the Dutch army!! And wat a good story!!

  • @withanametocome
    @withanametocome 12 лет назад

    I'm glad that you pointed that he pointed their violent monopoly of violence (are there non-violent ones, anyway?), it shows how common you are to his mind.

  • @israfel1980
    @israfel1980 13 лет назад

    @MarrooshDubai, he did not talk about justifying invading other countries, he talked about freeing people who are supressed by fear and violence. It is a shame you cannot see or want to comprehend this difference.
    Name one country the western forces have invaded that was not run weapons as a instrument of fear. I doubt you can, even if a government has been chosen by a majority of people, it is not worth anything if it does so while suppressing all people who would want to stand against them.

  • @vanstraten11
    @vanstraten11 10 лет назад

    "WE DID NOT KNOW" ISN'T ONLY USED BY THE GERMANS...THE DUTCH ARE EVEN BETTER AT IT!!!

  • @VxMAX
    @VxMAX 12 лет назад

    There will always be wars and conflicts. As long as there are rocks and sticks are around, there will always be someone to throw them at someone else. I see what the General is saying.

  • @withanametocome
    @withanametocome 12 лет назад

    And how can an arbitrary enclosure be 'occupied by foreigners' or be 'a sovereign nation'? What properties do its soil and seas have to have in order to be sovereign? To what violations and torts do those soil and seas have to be submitted to in order to be 'under foreign occupation'? Thanks in advance!

  • @daanjasper1
    @daanjasper1 13 лет назад

    @grieske You mean the monument for peacekeeping in Roermond?

  • @fliteshare
    @fliteshare 12 лет назад

    It isn't the "State" that has the monopoly on violence. It is the "Sovereign" that has that monopoly since the Treaty of Westphalia 1648.
    The French revolution assigned the citizenry as Sovereign. The American revolution "We The People". Even the Bolshevik revolution assigns "Workers Counsels" as their sovereign.
    Unlike Hitler whom abolished parliament after the Reichtags fire to become absolute ruler "Fuehrer".

  • @Bertuz1979
    @Bertuz1979 12 лет назад +1

    Actualy, I was in uniform for 4 years in the Dutch Airforce. I've been in Kirgizstan for a 3 month duty, so I know what I'm talking about.........

  • @CplCoffee
    @CplCoffee 13 лет назад

    beautiful speech, this is why I am joining the Canadian forces. To bring piece and if possible prevent wars

  • @fliteshare
    @fliteshare 12 лет назад

    "We The People" is the Sovereign who created the USA as Nation State and ensured recognition (according to Treaty of Westphalia) by all other Nation States to accomplish such.
    USA Constitution article VI "all treaties made"..."shall be the supreme law of the land", sounds like a reference to the Treaty of Westphalia to me.
    BTW the Treaty of Westphalia forms the basis of all international law. So, you hear something like diplomatic immunity or such, you now know where the concept got defined.