It is the most widely known 'black key' among Chopin Etude. The cheerful and clear melody is impressive and addictive. It's so nice to hear Pollini's clean interpretation. It's so beautiful.
I love this etude. It is youthful, proud, boastful, joyful, and athletic. It has an boundless optimism that renders one hope. That's it. It means hope!
This has always been my favorite Chopin etude of them all to play. Most of them leave my standard repertoire after learning them, but this and a few others stayed over the years.
I hate moments like at 1:00!! The melody is so delicate and beautiful, absolutely my favorite moment in the piece……. And it lasts for 4 bars and only appears once 😭😭😭😭
I really dislike lang lang... Really overrated and his playing doesn't fit Chopin's work at all. I really don't understand his popularity. Maybe people became dumber?
Vincent he is famous bc of his technical skills, his hands r very fast and he has emotion WHILE his techical skills are good so he is famous. There are people who dislike him but this is what I think :)
@YSFmemories It's not always the easiest part >.< My girlfriend is an amazing pianist and probably could play the bulk of this up to tempo, but when it gets to any big chords or octaves, her hands are just incredibly small and can't reach. For her, the octaves would be the hardest part, and that might be what Chopin096 is experiencing as well.
This version reveals that it is just impossible to play the octaves at the end in the markes tempo : even Pollini has to arrange it and play it slower !
@YSFmemories was that long explanation good enough "mere mortal" cause guess what? Even prodigies, are just mere mortals. They just got genetically given gifts, and also they put in effort, that's it. They're lucky to get those gifts, but the thing is, any prodigy can beat "mere mortals," if they put in effort, and any "mere mortals" can beat a prodigy, if they put in effort.
@YSFmemories And even if you have a talent for the thing, it's still hard. Talents are passed down genetically, but to use those talents, you also have to work like other kids. Sure, the talent gives you a boost in certain ways, like an early start, or fast understanding, but for the parts your talent does not give, you're worse then a "mere mortal"
@christianchoi1 Do you even know what full speed is? If you've played it at full speed, I'll be glad to hear. Sure, perhaps, just perhaps, there might be some pianists who can play it at full speed. But for the rest of us mere mortals, it is a very difficult task. And for casual pianists like myself who like to learn pieces of music but are not good enough to achieve perfection, playing the octaves at a "good enough" speed is much simpler than the rest of the piece.
@Chopin096 Trust me, that is like the easiest part of this etude =/ (granted since it's a given you won't be able to play it full speed, you won't even try, otherwise it is impossibly hard)
@audreyhsux5727 my mom can make another, but she's too lazy. So much for being a computer genius, she can't make a converter that always videos longer then 3 minutes, but then again, chopin's etude isn't that long, then again, she's too lazy
@YSFmemories Oh and another thing, I HATE GIVING OPINIONS. That's my opinion. I use things from evidence, or scientifically proven facts, but, unless it's necessary, I hate giving opinions.
@audreyhsux5727 and even if I'm sub prod, I was actually bad at everything when I was younger. My family line on both side are intelligent, and on one side we're physically talented. But for me, all those genes, dominant, recessive, auto-somal, sex-linked, whatever hocus pocus, never really kicked in till 20...10, they never kicked in till 2010
@audreyhsux5727 ...I also have a very bad case of becoming nervous around unknown ppl without someone I know right next to me, being in front of public, etc. I forgot which phobia it was. I literally tracked down websites to find my phobia and i have around 50 0.0...btw, are you a girl...sorry if this is off topic, you just sound a little creepy
@YSFmemories -.-" be quiet. I know the difference between a song and a piece. I just don't have good grammar since I started english late, and forgot too much of my native language. A "good enough" speed is not good at all, you have to play the same tempo throughout the whole piece. Sure, there are stuff like piano, forte, accel., rit., etc., but you still have to have the tempo in there. The speed, my piano teacher, who's sub-prodigy, can play, and even she has a hard time.
@audreyhsux5727 SORRY SORRY I just have a very...peculiar relationships when it comes to girls ^^" I was called a girl a lot for my behavior and how high I can scream despite my regular low voice -.-"
Listen to Rubinstein or Zimerman with this Etude and you'll discover this Etude new. They play it so much more logical (as one user put it - voices more separately) and more musically. Sorry, Pollini as good as you are you found your masters! xD
@christianchoi1 "I learned this song before, and I learned many other songs" That alone is enough to discredit the rest of your argument. If you don't even know the difference between a song and a piece, I don't think any of your expert musical advice has any weight. Calling others an idiot because your opinion differs does not make you a genius. If you're even having trouble finding the right notes for simple octaves, you probably aren't at the level to play this.
Cowgoesmoo2 there is a huge gap difference between entertainer and an artist. Lang Lang isn't a complete artist-half breed-half entertainer, half artist. You might have a different opinion on that, and I respect it. And... Playing the etude with an orange is a complete show off with no aesthetic beauty what so ever. It was entertaining, but at the cost of the music, of Chopin. That is why it is a disgrace.
+Li Kevin I don't understand the hate for his orange performance. He was clearly just having fun and showing the more joking side to playing a Chopin etude; it wasn't a musical performance, but rather, a comedic one. It did not "cost the music" in any way, which is exactly what I don't understand at all. The purpose was to entertain, and he entertained us, so there is no disgrace there. It also had some resemblance to the actual piece, putting an even more entertaining aspect to it.
+Li Kevin Though I agree with you, who cares? Let people experiment in their own way. If you don't like something, don't watch it instead of acting like they've commited a crime. (The biggest problem with the classical music community is conservatism. Just look at history... Sure, doesn't mean that you have to like everything new, but being open can really do you good.)
It is the most widely known 'black key' among Chopin Etude. The cheerful and clear melody is impressive and addictive. It's so nice to hear Pollini's clean interpretation. It's so beautiful.
“Wow turning the black keys into white keys!”
🤦
I N T E R E S T I N G
He was playing the etude at like 75% speed lol
I remember this sentence
Two set piano battles quote
absolutely flawless; how I like this man playing Chopin.
I think this is truly excellent. The best performance of this Etude on youtube.
I wonder where these people are in life 14 years later.
@@ScrunggeI’m right here and still think this is the best performance of this Etude
I love this etude. It is youthful, proud, boastful, joyful, and athletic. It has an boundless optimism that renders one hope. That's it. It means hope!
Well put. This is the optimism etude and no 10 is the happiness etude :D
This has always been my favorite Chopin etude of them all to play. Most of them leave my standard repertoire after learning them, but this and a few others stayed over the years.
The most perfect rendition of this piece. ever.
Such a musical performance!
Gave me goosebumps!! Wow!
Unbelievable!
Magnífico !!!! Great interpretation !!!!
처음 들었을땐 뭐 그냥 똑같은데? 했는데 자세히 들어보니까 소름돋음 어떻게 저렇게 세심한 디테일까지 하나하나 완벽하게 친거지?
Chopin was the Einstein of music. Every note is perfect.
Amazing talent, his fingers are skimming across the piano and his notes are like a river flowing down a stream
Pollini is the master of Chopin etudes
Wonderful ! Thank you for posting :)
sparkling
폴리니가 진짜 제일 정석임. 이것보다 더 좋을수가 없는듯
I hate moments like at 1:00!! The melody is so delicate and beautiful, absolutely my favorite moment in the piece……. And it lasts for 4 bars and only appears once 😭😭😭😭
Masterpiece
Why are people disrespecting each other's culture here... Aren't we suppose to enjoy the music regardless of our culture, nation or race?
Indeed.
Don't disrespect my culture
zoidberg
I find myself doing this a lot, especially when the piece is "fun" to play (like this one).
Astonishing...i'm speechless
*NICKNAME: BLACK KEYS*
Love it!
Brad Balkcon me too
The 15 people who disliked this are either deaf or have no soul
and for your information. go to imslp.org
you can find almost all classical music sheet there
welcomed
Those few octaves at the end are discouraging me, but still, I would love to learn this eutde.
Nothing should discourage you
말할수 없는 비밀에서 들은거랑 좀 많이.... 아주 많이... 그냥 다른 곡인 느낌ㅋㅋㅋㄷ
몇년째 여기 서식중인데 들을때마다 감탄..
거기가 느리게 친거고 원래 빠르게 치는 곡임
들을때마다 소름돋음 ㄹㅇ
우리가 듣던거 다 깨부수는 연주다.. 처음 들었을때 진짜 개충격이었는데..
perfect!!
Be nice! Be sweet!
어나더 레벨이다
폴리니 흑건이 제일 좋다...
내가 말할수없는비밀에서 알던 흑건이 아닌데.... ㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷ 진짜 ㄱㅐ미쳤네
Thanks Chopin
Lang Lang disliked this four times. ;)
I really dislike lang lang... Really overrated and his playing doesn't fit Chopin's work at all. I really don't understand his popularity. Maybe people became dumber?
Vincent he is famous bc of his technical skills, his hands r very fast and he has emotion WHILE his techical skills are good so he is famous. There are people who dislike him but this is what I think :)
@@tristan1042 I agree that he is a god on the technical side. But emotionally, imo, his playing is empty.
Lol
@@vincent-ataramaniko stfu get s@&#
쇼팽이, 악보가 요구하는 흑건은 이런거군요.
how do you dislike this???
1:12 the one and the only white key played by the right hand
Im now trying to learn it 😣
강약조절 오져요
목표서울대23학번 긍개
@YSFmemories
It's not always the easiest part >.< My girlfriend is an amazing pianist and probably could play the bulk of this up to tempo, but when it gets to any big chords or octaves, her hands are just incredibly small and can't reach. For her, the octaves would be the hardest part, and that might be what Chopin096 is experiencing as well.
This version reveals that it is just impossible to play the octaves at the end in the markes tempo : even Pollini has to arrange it and play it slower !
Then listen to Cziffra!
Or horowitz
@YSFmemories was that long explanation good enough "mere mortal" cause guess what? Even prodigies, are just mere mortals. They just got genetically given gifts, and also they put in effort, that's it. They're lucky to get those gifts, but the thing is, any prodigy can beat "mere mortals," if they put in effort, and any "mere mortals" can beat a prodigy, if they put in effort.
amazing! I love Pollini! he's perfect pianist! bravo! can't describe my emotions with words!
@YSFmemories And even if you have a talent for the thing, it's still hard. Talents are passed down genetically, but to use those talents, you also have to work like other kids. Sure, the talent gives you a boost in certain ways, like an early start, or fast understanding, but for the parts your talent does not give, you're worse then a "mere mortal"
subscribed!
@christianchoi1 Do you even know what full speed is? If you've played it at full speed, I'll be glad to hear. Sure, perhaps, just perhaps, there might be some pianists who can play it at full speed. But for the rest of us mere mortals, it is a very difficult task. And for casual pianists like myself who like to learn pieces of music but are not good enough to achieve perfection, playing the octaves at a "good enough" speed is much simpler than the rest of the piece.
What it felt, l played this for George Sand
시원하면서 냉정미가 있는 상쾌한 곡이네요~ 민트색 투명한 유리구슬 느낌? 백건은 약간 하늘색 투명한 유리구슬..
The best ever
Who found themselves playing on the desk along with this
Wow! I thought that was just me!
I literally do this with so many pieces. Just putting the volume down on my electric piano and pretending I could play this
@Chopin096 Trust me, that is like the easiest part of this etude =/ (granted since it's a given you won't be able to play it full speed, you won't even try, otherwise it is impossibly hard)
i wish i could play like Leeteuk,,, :)
does anyone know where i can find the sheet music? :)
우와 미쳤다
Anyone came from TwoSet Violin?
Partisan Mapping yep
Partisan Mapping in which video from TwoSet do they talk about this Etude?
@@ThaisCostalonga the turning black keys into white keys video
Thais Costalonga the piano battle one
👍 nice
@audreyhsux5727 and also we used to have a converter, but my dad drove over the computer with it ^^"
피아노 학원에서 이 곡 배우는데 손가락 꼬임
@audreyhsux5727 my mom can make another, but she's too lazy. So much for being a computer genius, she can't make a converter that always videos longer then 3 minutes, but then again, chopin's etude isn't that long, then again, she's too lazy
every day.
☁️
0:56 - 1:14
beauty
@YSFmemories Oh and another thing, I HATE GIVING OPINIONS. That's my opinion. I use things from evidence, or scientifically proven facts, but, unless it's necessary, I hate giving opinions.
1:22
0:10
1:36
dude that comment was 3 months ago, no use replying to it.
wow this was before youtube changed their reply system lol, i don't even know who i'm replying to
Gg
@Not a Glass Pane Lol :)
@audreyhsux5727 ...how old are you?
Today CHOPIN is a warrior againt fools foolishness lies
@audreyhsux5727 and even if I'm sub prod, I was actually bad at everything when I was younger. My family line on both side are intelligent, and on one side we're physically talented. But for me, all those genes, dominant, recessive, auto-somal, sex-linked, whatever hocus pocus, never really kicked in till 20...10, they never kicked in till 2010
@audreyhsux5727 oops the always was supposed to be allows
there was student who slept when they music subject in school
Really???
@audreyhsux5727 or unless it's a coincidence
@audreyhsux5727 OH and I'm going to Korea in the summer, so, can't go to this iiym or whatever...
Pretty Little Liars....
@audreyhsux5727 ...I also have a very bad case of becoming nervous around unknown ppl without someone I know right next to me, being in front of public, etc. I forgot which phobia it was. I literally tracked down websites to find my phobia and i have around 50 0.0...btw, are you a girl...sorry if this is off topic, you just sound a little creepy
Hyun-Min Choi Are you still using RUclips? ..한국인 같기두 하구
came here becuz of LEETEUK>
@YSFmemories oh, and I am in my first year in junior high, but my skills for piano is challenged even by sophomore-senior high schoolers.
@YSFmemories -.-" be quiet. I know the difference between a song and a piece. I just don't have good grammar since I started english late, and forgot too much of my native language. A "good enough" speed is not good at all, you have to play the same tempo throughout the whole piece. Sure, there are stuff like piano, forte, accel., rit., etc., but you still have to have the tempo in there. The speed, my piano teacher, who's sub-prodigy, can play, and even she has a hard time.
진짜 좆되누 어케했노/..
Fuck. Approximately 10 notes a sec....
@audreyhsux5727 SORRY SORRY I just have a very...peculiar relationships when it comes to girls ^^" I was called a girl a lot for my behavior and how high I can scream despite my regular low voice -.-"
so many replies to your comment... now i can thumb down your comment multiple times!! haha!
@audreyhsux5727 well, starting to
@audreyhsux5727 and even if I did make a video, you wouldn't find it unless you're the stalking type.
Terzultima battuta, le ottave: mi accorgo solo ora, dopo 30 anni, che trasforma il 2/4 in 3/4. Fatte a tempo sarebbero molto più veloci.
Listen to Rubinstein or Zimerman with this Etude and you'll discover this Etude new. They play it so much more logical (as one user put it - voices more separately) and more musically. Sorry, Pollini as good as you are you found your masters! xD
Don't be so objective. Most of piano players won't agree with you.
Clément BRUN Funny, that you call this "objective". However in music everything is subjective! :D
Yet you're the one seemingly making objective statements, which was his point.
@christianchoi1 "I learned this song before, and I learned many other songs" That alone is enough to discredit the rest of your argument. If you don't even know the difference between a song and a piece, I don't think any of your expert musical advice has any weight. Calling others an idiot because your opinion differs does not make you a genius. If you're even having trouble finding the right notes for simple octaves, you probably aren't at the level to play this.
calm down......
Literally black keys
Is a robot!! A robot playng the song!!!!!!!
트와이스
🤢
And here is lang lang... playing it with an orange. God...... What a disgrace.
Ayyy! I also saw the video on that.
+Li Kevin lolololol a DISGRACE? Wtf? Usually we're supposed to be impressed if dogs or people can play the piano with their feet.
Cowgoesmoo2 there is a huge gap difference between entertainer and an artist.
Lang Lang isn't a complete artist-half breed-half entertainer, half artist. You might have a different opinion on that, and I respect it. And... Playing the etude with an orange is a complete show off with no aesthetic beauty what so ever. It was entertaining, but at the cost of the music, of Chopin. That is why it is a disgrace.
+Li Kevin I don't understand the hate for his orange performance. He was clearly just having fun and showing the more joking side to playing a Chopin etude; it wasn't a musical performance, but rather, a comedic one. It did not "cost the music" in any way, which is exactly what I don't understand at all. The purpose was to entertain, and he entertained us, so there is no disgrace there. It also had some resemblance to the actual piece, putting an even more entertaining aspect to it.
+Li Kevin Though I agree with you, who cares? Let people experiment in their own way. If you don't like something, don't watch it instead of acting like they've commited a crime. (The biggest problem with the classical music community is conservatism. Just look at history... Sure, doesn't mean that you have to like everything new, but being open can really do you good.)