RANKING ASTRO IN DIFFERENT CATEGORIES

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 28 авг 2024

Комментарии • 138

  • @Rvbyjenlvr.7
    @Rvbyjenlvr.7 2 года назад +146

    Moonbin never left the top 3 he is fr our ace

  • @harshadakharkar3373
    @harshadakharkar3373 Год назад +39

    Binnie literally ACE ❤❤
    Miss you binnie
    RIP

  • @garimadoloi9529
    @garimadoloi9529 2 года назад +83

    Moon bin is literally all rounder...

    • @MuslimahDoonkk
      @MuslimahDoonkk Год назад

      I agree with except rap and vocal, the rap king is Jinjin, and Voice king is MJ.

    • @arumetheun3914
      @arumetheun3914 Год назад +7

      @@MuslimahDoonkk what a lie moonbin ate all his members position maybe keep your unnecessary opinions for yourself 😂

    • @aliyahreid4970
      @aliyahreid4970 Год назад +5

      Agree no one can surpass moonbin on this one

    • @jackking2374
      @jackking2374 Год назад +1

      Couldn't agree more

    • @MuslimahDoonkk
      @MuslimahDoonkk Год назад

      @@arumetheun3914 keep your necessary opinion for yourself

  • @sanbinyharumumzt7798
    @sanbinyharumumzt7798 Год назад +13

    On point. Just for the stage presence I’ll have 1) Moonbin 2) Rocky

  • @arumetheun3914
    @arumetheun3914 Год назад +25

    Moonbin still an ace either based on visual and stage presence 🤭

    • @theunbiasedone
      @theunbiasedone Год назад

      And that’s your bias-ness talking so no one one fight you dear. You will see what you want to see just like others🤭

  • @elevatorkid4814
    @elevatorkid4814 Год назад +1

    in my opinion:
    vocal:
    1. MJ
    2. moonbin
    3. sanha
    4. rocky
    5. eunwoo
    6. jinjin
    rap:
    1. jinjin
    2. rocky
    3. moonbin
    4. eunwoo
    5. sanha
    6. MJ
    dance:
    1. rocky
    2. moonbin
    3. jinjin
    4. sanha
    5. eunwoo
    6. MJ
    visual:
    1. eunwoo
    2. moonbin
    3. sanha
    4. rocky
    5. MJ
    6. jinjin
    stage presence:
    1. rocky
    2. jinjin
    3. moonbin
    4. sanha
    5. MJ
    6. eunwoo
    my bias ranking of Astro:
    1. rocky
    2. moonbin
    3. MJ
    4. jinjin
    5. sanha
    6. eunwoo
    (no hate)

  • @binodjangpoudel3492
    @binodjangpoudel3492 Год назад +10

    moonbin and rocky all rounder

  • @aliyahreid4970
    @aliyahreid4970 Год назад +14

    Idk about y'all but this ranking seems useless since netizens always mention moonbin and eunwoo for visual and for vocal mj, moonbin and sanha lastly for stage presence it's always moonbin but yeah everyone has different opinions so yeah 😂

  • @iku9796
    @iku9796 2 года назад +68

    gotta disagree with a few ones. the dance ranking is off (mj is actually better than eunwoo, objectively speaking); as for stage presence moon bin should definitely be the one on the top. but then it's _your_ ranking , so yeahh....

    • @barsalidas7929
      @barsalidas7929 2 года назад +14

      Exactly my thoughts!!...MJ has better technique than Eunwoo in dancing and as for Stage presence MOONBIN DESERVES TO BE AT THE TOP. For me, the stage presence ranking goes:
      1. Moonbin
      2. Rocky
      3. MJ (he's really good in terms of stage presence, not appreciated enough, I feel so)
      4. Jinjin/ Sanha (Sanha improved sooo much)
      5. Eunwoo

    • @tsukidaisukii4881
      @tsukidaisukii4881 2 года назад +4

      We're in the same page

    • @bbychengs3284
      @bbychengs3284 2 года назад +1

      SPEAK YOUR TRUTH KING

    • @MuslimahDoonkk
      @MuslimahDoonkk Год назад

      Agree

    • @arumetheun3914
      @arumetheun3914 Год назад +4

      VOCAL
      1. MJ
      2. MOONBIN
      3. SANHA
      4. EUNWOO
      5. JINJIN
      6. ROCKY
      STAGE PRESENCE
      1. MOONBIN
      2. MOONBIN
      3. MOONBIN
      4. MOONBIN
      5. MOONBIN
      6. MOONBIN
      VISUAL
      1. MOONBIN
      2. EUNWOO
      3. NONE
      4. NONE
      5. NONE
      6. NONE
      😍😍😍😍😍

  • @jackking2374
    @jackking2374 Год назад +23

    This ranking only applies to minority while majority ppl never missed from mentioning moonbin and eunwoo and stage presence it's always moonbin since his predebut days while for vocal it's indeed mj followed by moonbin and sanha so i don't know what was this ranking aims for 😅😅

    • @theunbiasedone
      @theunbiasedone Год назад +2

      This is also an opinion tho, plus vocal ranking I’ve seen does tend to change from my observations. Objectively I’ll say Astro shouldn’t be ranked by fans in any way at least when it comes to vocals cos if the day an ‘actual expert’(there’s a reason I said this, I know there’s been one done by a self trained vocalist who’s known to hit or miss sometimes) decides to go into them it might cause a lot of problems because of fans/Bias opinions imo. So let’s just enjoy the unique contribution they all bring to the group and remember each person has a role in a song and the group as a whole. If Eg: say San-ha starts singing high notes(used it cos that’s a factor I’ve observed) like he really can what will say Moonbin do? (just an example pls) And it’s that brotherly bond and understanding that makes me like Astro as a group. Plus they all have very pleasant timbre to listen to. And stage presence is also subjective but yeah Binnie has always been one of the best in the group.
      So in essence I also don’t know what rankings are for, but I guess it’s part of K-pop fan culture?

    • @user-uv5bw4sj2p
      @user-uv5bw4sj2p Год назад

  • @user-ig8ok5ce1g
    @user-ig8ok5ce1g 6 месяцев назад +1

    ❤Moonbin je bio najbolji , svi ostali su isto bili posebni .Moonbin broj 1 u svemu.❤😅

  • @bbychengs3284
    @bbychengs3284 2 года назад +38

    yeah no... Honestly moonbin own stage presence.

    • @aram465
      @aram465 2 года назад +3

      Não vamos brigar por isso, afinal somos todas arohas e cada uma tem seu bias. Amo Astro 💜

  • @shukurullazokirjonov9511
    @shukurullazokirjonov9511 Год назад +2

    Cha Eun woo 🎉❤

  • @Jennie-Xing
    @Jennie-Xing Год назад +7

    I would put MJ before Eun Woo in rap and dance. On stages presence it's hard to put an order because each one of them have equal presence on their parts. They are an excellent group.

    • @theunbiasedone
      @theunbiasedone Год назад

      Have you seen all the vocal line rap before tho (like really stuff of them rapping seriously there’s a quite a few) if no then still don’t rank and just read opinions like me :D
      But I’ll agree with you an the stage presence part (it’s subjective cos everyone has what draws them to someone in a performance sometimes bias?, sometimes opinion? Etc). They all have presence at their part I don’t see any hole in presence which makes the group performances great. If you look at Astro sometimes you might wonder what the center position is for lol since they alternate with who is singing/rapping at the time and that’s great.
      In essence they’re an excellent group😉.

  • @minashi6538
    @minashi6538 2 года назад +17

    I think Eunwoo has a good stage presence 🖤

    • @wuwuuwu6760
      @wuwuuwu6760 Год назад

      same 😂 i like his stage presence though of course this is just my opinion

  • @aganbraganca5245
    @aganbraganca5245 5 месяцев назад +2

    I think for vocals eunwoo should be higher

  • @D.M.16
    @D.M.16 2 года назад +5

    I love Astro 💜 💕 ♥ 💖 ❤

  • @cha_eun_woo30397
    @cha_eun_woo30397 Год назад +3

    For me Eunwoo is the vocalist💙

  • @Sweety-kx1tq
    @Sweety-kx1tq Год назад +1

    Cha eun woo ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

  • @arumetheun3914
    @arumetheun3914 Год назад +8

    VOCAL
    1. MJ
    2. MOONBIN
    3. SANHA
    4. EUNWOO
    5. JINJIN
    6. ROCKY
    STAGE PRESENCE
    1. MOONBIN
    2. MOONBIN
    3. MOONBIN
    4. MOONBIN
    5. MOONBIN
    6. MOONBIN
    VISUAL
    1. MOONBIN
    2. EUNWOO
    3. NONE
    4. NONE
    5. NONE
    6. NONE
    😍😍😍😍😍

    • @deopinion4090
      @deopinion4090 Год назад +1

      🤣🤣🤣🤣 es notorio quien te gusta!! 🤣🤣. Y no tienes malos gustos

  • @Engene_Stay_forever
    @Engene_Stay_forever Год назад +1

    Can't believe the ace left us

  • @kittydarling6405
    @kittydarling6405 Год назад

    ♥ Both as individuals and a whole grp of entertainers, their diligence, qualities, character, dispositions, and the many other talents they bring on and off the stage, not to be left out-humor on crack, and as the guys we LOVE over any other ranking grp in the music industry, *to me our ASTRO stars are celestial deities from heaven.* I wish them love, health, prosperity, protection and anything else these guys could ever need in this life and the next. I wouldn't be able to thank them enough for being who they are! ASTRO6 ♥

  • @Khurshedalam418
    @Khurshedalam418 Год назад +1

    Sarangey Cha eun woo

  • @suchetabultisen9306
    @suchetabultisen9306 Год назад +7

    I think for the ranking of vocalist Eunwoo should be mention at the top before MJ...why she mention him at no.5??

    • @theunbiasedone
      @theunbiasedone Год назад +2

      Cos even if yes he’s good, on what basis should he be placed above MJ in terms of vocal ranking unless you’re an ‘actual expert’ in that field and you’ve come to correct an opinion based video. If you’re an actual proven expert then sure. But regardless of any rank he’s placed, I know he’s not at the very top plus I know it’s a fan made video at certain points.

    • @aganbraganca5245
      @aganbraganca5245 5 месяцев назад +1

      @@theunbiasedoneEunwoo vocals in top he has beautiful voice and also made his solo debute

  • @wuwuuwu6760
    @wuwuuwu6760 Год назад +1

    eunwoo❤

  • @FlairProducción
    @FlairProducción 11 месяцев назад

    Everyone was good, but MOONBIN was good at everything! He have special physical and artistic qualities and MOONBIN had them all: unique voice, unique dance, unique beauty, imposing stature, well built body and he worked hard to perfect all his skills, and that is why i love him so much since day 1!.

  • @ilibelieveastro
    @ilibelieveastro 2 года назад +12

    How can you say that
    jinjin is not a visual (see again using 👓)
    Sanha,eunwoo,moonbin can't rap (astro you and me and confession switch version , he's a giant baby he can do anything 😒)
    Mj can't dance (try opening ASTRO dance practice videos there will be a 175 cm men dancing 🤧)
    And please stop saying my boy can't dance his stage presence is not good his vocals aren't good Rocky is all rounder but eunwoo is not just a face have you ever listened to his solo songs 😒 people think fantagio's main focus is eunwoo but they only focus on his face they never try to give him more lines in songs they just give him 1-2 times centre position to him but if you listen to his solo songs love yourself (JB cover) ,love so fine, first love and his vocals in astro ballad songs you'll know how beautiful his voice is🥺 and his stage presence is no joke 😒 in last slide you said he is the best visual in ASTRO them tell me how can be a visual's stage presence can be worst in the group.
    If you're an aroha please don't make videos like this this video really made me cry because everytime i see people always just appreciate eunwoo's face they never try to look into him what he can do and I'm really tired of watching..
    I love them all because they're perfect as a GROUP💜 and i hope you don't get angry on my comment and try to understand this ASTRO IS ONE 🥺
    If we aroha rank them like this, then what will we say to the people who aren't even an aroha 😒
    And if you're not an aroha then why are you ranking them without even knowing aroha culture 😐..(sorry my english is really bad🌚)

    • @deopinion4090
      @deopinion4090 Год назад +1

      Oye LoL
      Se nota que eres aroha 😉
      Cuando es así, las y los fans aman al grupo entero, a pesar de que alguno de ellos tenga un poco más de popularidad. Ahora, sí, es real que cada uno destaque en algo dentro de su cualidad artística. Ellos mismos en programas y entrevistas han declarado y exaltado las cualidades específicas de cada miembro (y que ellos estén concientes de eso está muy bien, de ésta forma los siento situados en su realidad). Me queda claro que ellos se apoyaran bajo toda circunstancia lo cual los hace un buen grupo. Sus cualidades individuales ayuda a motivar a qué los otros miembros no se queden atrás. Pondré un ejemplo: si Rocoso es un as en el baile y MJ no, creo que lo que provoca es que MJ tenga que aplicarse para poder seguir el paso y ser uno con todos en la rutina de baile, eso es excelente. Otro: si EW es el visual te has dado cuenta que últimamente se han puesto a hacer ejercicio para mantener sus visuales en forma (lo cual la mayoría de los fans *AGRADECEMOS* ampliamente) y así mantenerse como grupo "visual". Podría decirte más ejemplos pero creo que tú los conocerás más que yo. Ahora sólo agregaré un comentario personal; de ✡️ y es que hay 5 miembros que son completamente extrovertidos y uno que es introvertido.
      Por lo que solo puedo decir de este último: ¡Wooww! Qué capacidad para vivir en éste ambiente artístico. Y me pregunto ¿Qué hace un cocodrilo viviendo mar adentro y en sus profundidades?

    • @theunbiasedone
      @theunbiasedone Год назад

      Don’t worry your English is just okay, I’m not going to really dig into this because you have the right spirit I’ve seen by far. Astro is really a well-rounded group, I have a believe except for official positions given by their label not by us fans let’s leave them be and enjoy the unique contributions they bring to the group. Six puzzle pieces that fit and make the group Astro Astro. For example Rocky has been given an honorary vocal position by fans not their label which isn’t bad but certain people will say oh even the rapper has the same position as Eunwoo without knowing it’s fan assigned because of high notes imo cos that’s the only thing they attach to it mostly🤷🏽‍♀️ and that is bad at times without taking time to listen to each and every member solo singing which there’s a lot where they showcase themselves well maybe except for JinJin he just wants to make music in peace so let’s leave him alone. So all in all Astro is a pretty well-rounded group. There’s nothing wrong in a way for opinion videos but currently I see them been used as bullets against others😂

    • @theunbiasedone
      @theunbiasedone Год назад

      @@deopinion4090 ​ exactly, they balance each other very well and complement each others growth. Hence the Rap/Dance line are improving their vocals and Vocal line are also improving on their dancing which then flows back into the group. Plus they really like to compliment each other in their speech. The only problem is that, as Astro begins to get more known internationally different people without knowing what you know and are “lazy” to get to know them start to feel why is this person not this when this person is clearly this than this person, sorry it’s confusing lol. Which is why I try to go about gently steering such opinions in any way I can since I’m stuck at home atm😂
      They truly influence each other positively and truly care about one other.

    • @holaholala3020
      @holaholala3020 Год назад

      ​@@theunbiasedone ​ "jinjin he just wants to make music in peace so let's leave him alone" Sorry i can't accept that sentence, that was stupid opinion. He was trained 3 years to be idol. To rap/sings, dance and performing on stage, not to be work on back stage, and seeing their members to be popular but not him. He be always making popular song for their group, but the fans not paying attention to his solo. It's fanmu fault for this 7 years not even once try to promote him. He doesn't even have a solo schedule that prepared by fanmu, he always got it from himself from his own connection. We can count it less than 3 he has his own sched for 7 years. He never get apportunity to show all of his capability. He's top dancer, he can play music (drum and electric guitar), he can do beatbox, he's a great rapper, he really good at basketball, snowboarding, he loves fishing. There is so much interesting thing but does fanmu even try to promotes one of his talent? No. He is astro's member, he is an idol, not their group personal producer song.
      And btw lately he said that he really want to do and have song that he really sing and show his capability, so let's wait. I comment this cause i want everyone to stop thinking that what he only want to do is making songs. He's an idol overall, he also want to be known.

    • @theunbiasedone
      @theunbiasedone Год назад

      @@holaholala3020 lol of all the praise I gave Astro as a group you chose that one line to comment on. It’s good that there’s someone who pays attention to him, but you took your own views out on what I wrote which I understand. Let’s leave him alone to develop and nuture that side of him well, when he wrote that song for the new bg it was so impressive so if someday we get top idol composer JinJin writing songs for other groups that’d be great. I only commented cos this by far seem like the biggest asset to him including the stuff you mentioned. It’s okay to feel he’s not going getting what’s due him but glad you pointed out fans role in this, if fans will pay attention to him then he will get a lot more attention. Don’t forget that at the end of the day there’s a business aspect of the job and if fans are not engaging how Will he. At the end of the day brands, shows etc will choose what will profit them. So if fans can rally then yea, but I truly believe working on his music skills and as you said singing will be good. Also Fantagio is a very fair company, to even be given the artistic freedom to even compose is a luxury most other idol groups do not have amongst other things. One thing I also use to remind myself is too look at them from a human society viewpoint, in normal life not everyone can have the same level of attention etc unfortunately. But I’m really looking forward to more for him and paying attention to it as well. I’ve been seeing you rooting for JinJin&Rocky so I remember your name well. Let’s continue to appreciate in our way

  • @nimashasubashini
    @nimashasubashini Год назад

    eun woo ❤️

  • @Victoria-gx1so
    @Victoria-gx1so 2 года назад +18

    Tbh all of them r visual

  • @holaholala3020
    @holaholala3020 Год назад

    Everyone should start open their eyes for jinjin's stage present. Start to watch his fancam and you will know he always give the best expressions. Since astro mostly have refreshing songs, he always show his smile while performing which is sometimes missing from other members.

  • @k-popfantasy9733
    @k-popfantasy9733 2 года назад +17

    Sorry but
    All of them has insane visual

    • @ccb3519
      @ccb3519 2 года назад +3

      Yeah idk why that starting to become an ranking

  • @dayviolet9005
    @dayviolet9005 Год назад

    I never could ranking them, every each of them has his charm, but I love them all and I think all of them are visuals and super talented boys💜
    Lastly but not less important, have you ever hear Jinwoo singing (like for real) he has a beautiful voice, but he likes to play and make the members laugh it doesn't matter if they're making fun of him💜

  • @multicolor8476
    @multicolor8476 Год назад +2

    I'm glad you had the presence of mind to rank Eunwoo #1 in Visuals, but you undervalued him in many ways...especially stage presence. Too many people want to tear Eunwoo down out of jealousy. You're rating a couple of them high for some strange reason...maybe to try to convince others.

    • @theunbiasedone
      @theunbiasedone Год назад

      Yep, it’s going to be yet another bullet to be used against him sadly people will forget it’s just an opinion video as use it to tear him. And I don’t know which parts you’re talking about but yeah there’s some parts that try to convince others imo as well, it might not be the same as yours but I’m just agreeing to the fact. Still Astro is one of the excellent groups out there so hey I guess everyone wins right

    • @aganbraganca5245
      @aganbraganca5245 5 месяцев назад +1

      Ya I am surprised he should be too in stage presence

  • @daniel_1235
    @daniel_1235 Год назад

    I completely agree with you ✨💕

  • @elizabethquimbiamba1950
    @elizabethquimbiamba1950 Год назад

    Moonbin is the first in dance and second in visual❤❤❤and for me he is the first in visual ❤❤

  • @ayushibaviskar3279
    @ayushibaviskar3279 2 года назад +3

    Tbh but all of them are insanely visually beautiful..🤗

  • @arism1868
    @arism1868 Год назад +1

    Creo que no has visto todo lo que Binnie sabía hacer en baile y sobre todo en presencia .

  • @yasmine-ej1xh
    @yasmine-ej1xh 9 месяцев назад +1

    Eun woo just his face😂😂❤

  • @aram465
    @aram465 2 года назад +11

    Pra mim o Rocky é o número 1 no quesito visual ( mais é a minha opinião e ninguém precisa concordar comigo ) ( ◜‿◝ )♡

    • @click2314
      @click2314 2 года назад

      You're blind. He's the ugliest in the group

  • @user-uv5bw4sj2p
    @user-uv5bw4sj2p Год назад

    해외 유저들은 문빈이 더 앞섬 판단 미스짤

  • @damytaylor8168
    @damytaylor8168 Год назад

    Moonbinn all over

  • @DivineLee3
    @DivineLee3 2 года назад +19

    Didn't agree with all
    MJ is better than Eun woo in dance

  • @sajaabdulhadi1010
    @sajaabdulhadi1010 Год назад

    Jinjin is THE MOST HaNdSoMe

  • @devitowibysanjaya3467
    @devitowibysanjaya3467 Год назад +1

    Vocal:
    1. Sanha
    2. Rocky
    3. Moonbin
    4. Mj
    5. Eunwoo
    6. Jinjin

    • @theunbiasedone
      @theunbiasedone Год назад

      Now this is the comment I like, not because it’s accurate but it just shows that this is indeed an opinion video and everyone can give their opinion without claiming it’s the right one💜
      Also I’m not agreeing or disagreeing to it with my comment.

  • @cdds4982
    @cdds4982 2 года назад +2

    mm.... i can agree with youu

  • @jinwoostan
    @jinwoostan Год назад +2

    jinjin is no 1 visual both in my opinion and in jinjin’s opinion HSHAHSH

    • @dayviolet9005
      @dayviolet9005 Год назад

      Count me on, My Jinwoo is #1 as well as Eunwoo💚

  • @Victoria-gx1so
    @Victoria-gx1so 2 года назад

    In my opinion

  • @MartaR-xw9mt
    @MartaR-xw9mt Год назад

    MJ 5th in Visual?😢 he should be at least 2nd, but for me 1st

  • @aishaibrahim9305
    @aishaibrahim9305 2 года назад

    🥺🥺😩😩

  • @MuslimahDoonkk
    @MuslimahDoonkk Год назад

    I think Jinjin not the last for visual.
    1. Eunwoo
    2. Sanha, Jinjin, MJ, Moonbin
    3. , Rocky

    • @arumetheun3914
      @arumetheun3914 Год назад +1

      What a bad taste ppl only knows moonbin and eunwoo visual duo so far 😅

    • @pengwinu
      @pengwinu Год назад +2

      Why why why only rocky on 3 😒 they're all good looking

    • @theunbiasedone
      @theunbiasedone Год назад +1

      Funny thing is that, in their Blueflame press conference in 2019. The reporters revealed their label cited Sanha as the next visual following Eunwoo. And beauty is subjective, Jinjin and Mj are breathtaking. Eunwoo, Sanha, Moonbin, Rocky are effortlessly handsome

  • @click2314
    @click2314 2 года назад +5

    Rocky should be last in visual. Jinjin should be 2nd or 3rd

    • @MuslimahDoonkk
      @MuslimahDoonkk Год назад +1

      Agree

    • @arumetheun3914
      @arumetheun3914 Год назад +1

      Jinjin 2nd you kidding me?? 😂😂

    • @click2314
      @click2314 Год назад

      @@arumetheun3914 nope. He's second next to eunwu. Other than eunwu, jinjin is more handsome than the rest.

    • @arumetheun3914
      @arumetheun3914 Год назад

      @@click2314 what a weird taste whatever helps you sleep at night if we asked blind ppl they're without no doubt to rank jinjin 2nd last cause the last is rocky

    • @click2314
      @click2314 Год назад

      @@arumetheun3914 i don't know if you can converse in english well but anyways, why are you very affected? Seems like you're the one who can't sleep at night because of this. Everyone knows rocky is last in visuals and Jinjin is 2nd. It's hard for you to swallow for sure but deal with it so it won't be hard for you.

  • @dalilarh3283
    @dalilarh3283 2 года назад

    I thought jinjin is the visual

    • @asareirene
      @asareirene Год назад

      Eunwoo and Moonbin I believe

  • @peejayingeniero7839
    @peejayingeniero7839 10 месяцев назад

    I think i love Rocky when he rap rather than jin...

  • @galaxy3451
    @galaxy3451 Год назад +1

    Visual should not be a ranking category fr