if anything these videos carry on that legacy, i dont really like what they did necessarily with this video, but if it turns the younger on to Joy Division, thats a huge win. Theres no need to gatekeep, no hate one love
@@Astronomnomnomicon I’m not exactly sure why you think young people have such poor taste. The video is not good. Period. It’s not gatekeeping. It’s acknowledging that the video is low effort and generic.
@@Gino565 Yeah, I'd rather watch the LP going round to be honest. Then again , I could just dig the bugger out and put it on rather than click here! Music's still great though.
@@Gino565 Yeah it's just a ridiculously inappropriate video for Joy Division and I'm curious to know who was behind this. It's like a hedge fund bought out the rights and got in a marketing firm that normally do ads for corporate clients or something. Just terrible in my opinion. Maybe it'll get a few junior accountants into their music.
“I’ve been waiting for a guide to come and take my by the hand. Can these sensations make me feel the pleasure of a normal man.” Those lines gave me goosebumps. I was instantly hooked to Unknown Pleasures. An incredible and sublime opening song to a timeless album.
1983, walking around Sheffield with my Unknown Pleasures T shirt on getting weird looks off everyone comments on how heavy/weird they were to listen to but i didn't care i truly believed in the music although dark at that time and still is i suppose but they have made a big impact on my life, when i'm feeling down i get my JD vinyls out and play them. It's strange now how opinions have changed about them and they have now influenced many bands i'm sure. Devoted till the end RIP Ian
Ian was the first and tragically left us too soon. His brief passage in this world was enough to leave a legacy that inspired hundreds of bands and still remains 🤘🌹
why a sexy female dancer? this song doesn’t make me feel sexy. this song makes me feel compassion for others with disorders. i love this song. the video is a cool image but not in harmony with the song in my humble opinion. maybe i’m wrong? who knows?
Hi I love making music. I am currently working on this channel to create Joy Division instrumental. in the future, I will deal with other performers, but in the event that it will be interesting to you. please rate my content. thanks :)
I love this song. It reminds me of driving in a city in the dead of night with not a soul around. This is so far from that I can’t begin to describe my utter loathing of it.
There’s music for musicians and there’s music for everyone else. Making Joy Division videos has been a mistake from the beginning. We love Joy Division for what we hear not for what we see.
Have you ever noticed the HUGE curse of music videos? No matter what cool ephemeral images or moods you once had in your head when you heard the music by itself, they vanish forever once you see the music video because those images get permanently burned into your head as part of the track.
Right. (Constructive criticism) what they should do is listen to the lyrics. What does this video have to do with the lyrics. "I've go the spirit, but loose the feeling". I dont see how this video incorporates that with the visuals. "Cars are crashing, lights are flashing, getting frequent now". I see no sign of that in the video. Just give us what we want. A video that pays homage to the band and the death of an amazing musician. I get a feeling of a crowded Manchester city centre with this song. Dark and murky. Eerie like the music. This song makes you feel so many different emotions at once. For me and I speak for many others when I say, this is our favourite song and the first one we heard from the group. Lets relive the moment when we first heard it.
I understand people not liking it, but do you really want literal crashing cars and flashing lights in the video because those are the lyrics? You wouldn't want that, exactly. The refrain is "I've got the spirit, but lose the feeling" But what does that actually mean? I don't see how you could necessarily incorporate it. "Heart and Soul: one will burn" also will mean different things to different people. The "Love Will Tear Us Apart" video is perfect, but it's mostly just the band with some simple video effects. I found this one interesting, the way it somehow misses the mark, although it obviously includes some of the usual post-industrial tropes. I guess the woman could represent "feeling" here. But these songs are still without a definitive video and I think I agree with others that they maybe shouldn't have one. The album artwork is the music's visual counterpart, if it has any.
@@rmilrta I know what you mean and I agree with you. I also dont see how you could make a music video to this song. The lyrics as you said mean different things to different people. So yeah I agree with your words.
@@rmilrta i love this song and this video really dissapointed my expectations(it fuckings sucks sm) my disappointment is immeasurable and my day is ruined
@@rmilrta uh...no, I believe I have to disagree with you mate. There are many ways of interpreting this song, most certainly. And I myself would prefer having to look at the artwork of "unknown pleasures" itself, than this wretched video. But if a music video is really that nessesary, then implicitly should be applied. For instance, for the whole "lights are flashing, cars are crashing" thing, one could easily show a short blurry clip of a traffic, in the night for instance, where everything is a mess or so. For the "spirit, but lose the feeling", they can have a man pace on with his life in panic and so on. I suggest you check out "Agent Orange" by "Ski Patrol". It has a similar themed video and you'll see what I mean when I talk on relevancy. Note: The channel that uploaded the song is called "Dark entries records". Cheers!
@@IncredulousMisanthrope The blurry night traffic is a creative starting point of course, but there's a million ways to go. I wouldn't say it's impossible to allude to it: I meant it it doesn't *have* to be. The "spirit/feeling" part is a bit too abstract for me. I would find it hard to convey that as a concrete image. You probably agree on this, and perhaps this isn't how you'd do it, but I thought this was one way the first video in this series went wrong ("We were strangers...away too long" as two blokes in a quarry take turns trying to take a piece out of each other.) Doesn't mean I won't look at the video! It's hard to make a Joy Division video that doesn't ramp up the usual interpretations too much. I made a video for In A Lonely Place for a Media Studies GCSE in 1988 when I was in college. I suspect people here would prefer it to some of these...
This song is just so good, it doesn't matter what images I'm seeing my mind creates a video, of experiences and memories I had. Thanking the stars for Joy Division, as usual!
@@jboyle453519 imagine if the people who made it were actually creative. They could gave gotten true artists to make these, If anything. What's good about is , is the basicness to it. The use the some and the art work, WHICH are great! There part was to add some random model to dance to it??? At least a true artist, making the same video would have had a passionate, hot, but TRUE JD fan dancing to it, not some random gap model ?
The fan made video on youtube is miles better than this because it actually seems connected with the song. never thought I’d say a fanmade thing is better than the real thing
Essentially these reimagines are just fan made too. Just this concept doesn't work. Maybe for She Lost Control but not this. This video gives no sense of the chaos around us
Love it. Who knows what Curtis would have thought of this ? Guardians of orthodoxy always make me laugh. They speak in the name of artists, especially when they're dead.
@@lonelyproductions Sure, I mean this song - for me- express a lot, and almost of the fans of JD could feel the same, and this kinds of videos are not the best way to show what all of us expected
When I listen to disorder, a naked girl moving around with dance moves that don't even match the song is definitely not what comes to mind. Hate to say it but I could of made a better video with my samsung phone just making some cheap edits of live shows.
Hi I love making music. I am currently working on this channel to create Joy Division instrumental. in the future, I will deal with other performers, but in the event that it will be interesting to you. please rate my content. thanks :)
Am I the only one that likes these videos? I have the give them credit, I mean sure it could be seen as bad but it's pretty unique in its own way, it's artistic
@@Miodrag.Vukomanovic Well, maybe yes, although I don't know. But Joey Santiago is by far more technically skilled in playing a guitar than Sumner ever will be, that's for sure
Hi, thanks for your interest in the newest official Joy Division videos for their hit album "Closer". First up, we have "The Eternal", set on the Malibu beach in sunny Southern California. Featuring a bevy of bodacious babes spraying each other down with orange Sunkist soda (they are a generous sponsor), their studly bronze boyfriends whistle along with the tune while tearing up the surf on their jet skis. I'm sure you and all your friends are going to love it very much. Please keep an eye out for the new line of tie-dyed "Closer" t-shirts and bikini thongs that will be front and center in every Hot Topic and Walmart soon!
It's nice to see the traumatized model from the American Apparel ads getting some new work... even if that job is sleepily shaking off an opioid high in front of her boyfriend's iPhone 5. Seriously?! This is not Joy Division nor was it made by anyone who even cares for Joy Division's legacy. I was so excited for this project when it was announced, but it has really let the fans down.
@@VangaurdTDS no, this video is awful. It has nothing to do with the song. If there was an original video that was released with this one, it would be 180 degrees away from whatever the hell this is fucking nonsense is supposed to be.
John Doe the video isn’t awful, it just doesn’t live up to whatever preconceived notion you had of it in your head. I’m sorry but that’s just the truth of the situation 🤷♂️.
Look at the comments. It's not just me. Let me see if I can spell it out for you: listen to the song, watch the video. Does A connect with B whatsoever? I'm sorry that you have some misguided conception that this video is great, but I hate to tell you that it misses the mark by a lot.
John Doe and look at the comments, it’s not just me either. I don’t get your point as you simply seem to be a conformist. Also, I didn’t say the video was great either, I just think it’s okay. I’m sorry you hate originality so much.
nothing or nobody could ever or do this song any justice, i pity the person who had the job, still its Joy Division at there very best and my favourite song , 40 years old and still brilliant . thank you Joy Division even though it didnt last long enough, RIP Ian Curtis
Disorder é uma das minhas músicas favoritas na vida, e é realmente decepcionante a preguiça com que produziram esse vídeo, essa canção merecia muito mais.
Im 51. Went into an ice cream shop in a small tourist beach town in Ontario this summer - 15 year old budding goth behind the counter with a JD UP shirt on. "Nice shirt!" -- ruined his week with just 2 words.
I always imagined the video to this song to be a midnight drive, late night with the radio crackling slightly and light rain, not some preying mantis having an aneurysm coursing through her arms in an ikea parking lot. Ian didn’t die for this, I’ll tell you that for free
Esta canción me da una sensación de una etapa de transición entre la adolescencia y la adultes, en la cual el mundo real golpea con fuerzaa causa de, sus problemas y vos cayendo en un poso, en donde reina el desorden y la desesperación.
Yo siempre lo tome como una apreciación al desorden emocional, en el cual tus sentimientos son inestables y el unico modo de sentirte mejor es enfocarte en tu espiritu, cayendo asi poco a poco en la depresion
it's funny because they still haven't realized that all these music videos look like shit and it has nothing to do with the true essence of joy division
Mark Fisher about Joy Division: "They had so thoroughly stripped out Rock’s libidinal motor - ‘Sex has disappeared from these unknown pleasures; (...) it would be better to say that they were, libidinally as well as sonically, anti-Rock." And thats a reason why is this video bad.
Hi I love making music. I am currently working on this channel to create Joy Division instrumental. in the future, I will deal with other performers, but in the event that it will be interesting to you. please rate my content. thanks :)
In my opinion, this song is so beautiful if the video is on the cult cinema's cinematography set up, showing a girl who sits on a "ayunan", holding a tambourine in her left hand, and her right hand is hitting her left knee with a rainbow rose. And one more, the whole video is "black and white".
@@brawnylilyspark Unfortunately, these reimagined videos have been so terrible. It blows my mind how out of touch with Joy Division's essence these videos have been. It's almost like the videomaker had a preconceived idea for a short film, and in order to make it, they forced it upon a Joy Division song, whether it was appropriate or not.
It's weird how many likes this has but so many negative comments. I actually didn't dislike it and I sometimes don't get why people hate it. Their reasons are sometimes a bit in contradiction to or not exactly what I seem to like about a music video, for example "It doesn't show the lyrics in any way", as if a music video's purpose is to visualize the lyrics. I would say I like Radiohead's video for "No Surprises". But I'm not too sure about what I like about it or videos in general. This music video fits pretty well to me. There's not a lot happening, I think using the album's artwork on the girl was a nice idea and it has some kind of theme to it. The only thing I don't like is that it looks so polished in contrast to this old raw song
Nah give me skate boarding videos with that vhs overlay dark alleyways lights at night in the distance trees going by a car window at night sun sets and drugs thats what this needs for a video
I've been listening to Joy Division and loving their work for over 30 years. I love this because its an angle of JD I haven't seen 1,000 times. Thank you!
Hi, thanks for your interest in the newest official Joy Division videos for their hit album "Closer". First up, we have "The Eternal", set on the Malibu beach in sunny Southern California. Featuring a bevy of bodacious babes spraying each other down with orange Sunkist soda (they are a generous sponsor), their studly bronze boyfriends whistle along with the tune while tearing up the surf on their jet skis. I'm sure you and all your friends are going to love it very much. Please keep an eye out for the new line of tie-dyed "Closer" t-shirts and bikini thongs that will be front and center in every Hot Topic and Walmart soon!
This better be good. They can't screw this one up or she's lost control. Shadowplay was probably the "best" one so far but again they better not screw this one up
![Joy Division - Atmosphere [OFFICIAL MUSIC VIDEO]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/1EdUjlawLJM/mqdefault.jpg)
What we actually needed were clips of Ian dancing his heart out.
Imagine thinking some random chick ass is somehow like......relevant to this music.
Imagine taking one of the best songs of the century and using as the background for your student movie
I think a movie student could make it better , it must been the worst student if so.....
But the tune doesnt change rip
Imagine being this butthurt over a good song and a pretty girl.
@@charlesbaer9971song is not about women dancing
Just enjoy the song and the pretty girl. @@InstituteOfLowerLearning
Joy division will always be known for its great music. Don't let these kind of videos get in the way of this great legacy.
if anything these videos carry on that legacy, i dont really like what they did necessarily with this video, but if it turns the younger on to Joy Division, thats a huge win. Theres no need to gatekeep, no hate one love
Got to respect the album cover in the back round tho
@@Astronomnomnomicon I’m not exactly sure why you think young people have such poor taste. The video is not good. Period. It’s not gatekeeping. It’s acknowledging that the video is low effort and generic.
@@Gino565 Yeah, I'd rather watch the LP going round to be honest. Then again , I could just dig the bugger out and put it on rather than click here! Music's still great though.
@@Gino565 Yeah it's just a ridiculously inappropriate video for Joy Division and I'm curious to know who was behind this. It's like a hedge fund bought out the rights and got in a marketing firm that normally do ads for corporate clients or something. Just terrible in my opinion. Maybe it'll get a few junior accountants into their music.
"There's a fine line between being artistic and being a dickhead." P. Hook.
Takes someone to bend your ego
He trod that line very drunkenly I thought. Give him his due, he gave more than his bit.
It's beautiful - but useless. And as William Morris once said: 'Nothing useless can be truly beautiful.'
-Tony Wilson
It’s AI people but I think sumner has this😂 1
“I’ve been waiting for a guide to come and take my by the hand. Can these sensations make me feel the pleasure of a normal man.” Those lines gave me goosebumps. I was instantly hooked to Unknown Pleasures. An incredible and sublime opening song to a timeless album.
Imagine... One of the most passionate, innovative and sincere songs as an advert, to sell Gap t-shirts.
Joy Division, Reimagined
She's not even wearing a shirt, Mike.
@@charlesbaer9971 Either way she's still selling Gap--or Crap. Awful.
@@vvault2022 No one is forcing you to listen to the song.
@@charlesbaer9971 If you hadn't said so, I wouldn't have noticed that. You are a genius! Keep it up champ! 👍
Loving the comments
Loving your profile picture 💯☺
😂😂😂😂
@@cindym9963 I love your picture !
Loving this LOVE
1983, walking around Sheffield with my Unknown Pleasures T shirt on getting weird looks off everyone comments on how heavy/weird they were to listen to but i didn't care i truly believed in the music although dark at that time and still is i suppose but they have made a big impact on my life, when i'm feeling down i get my JD vinyls out and play them. It's strange now how opinions have changed about them and they have now influenced many bands i'm sure. Devoted till the end RIP Ian
I don't know what you guys are talking about but I love this music video. Art has no boundaries
Ian was the first and tragically left us too soon. His brief passage in this world was enough to leave a legacy that inspired hundreds of bands and still remains 🤘🌹
Ojalá lo hubiera sabido 💔
Is this a Calvin Klein commercial?
Felipe Díaz Bo exactly... disgrace to joy division
The other one was a shampoo commercial
Nope. It's Victoria's Secret...
nailed it
why a sexy female dancer? this song doesn’t make me feel sexy. this song makes me feel compassion for others with disorders. i love this song. the video is a cool image but not in harmony with the song in my humble opinion. maybe i’m wrong? who knows?
These new videos for the songs are shite. I'd rather just have a plain black screen with lyrics lol.
Hi
I love making music. I am currently working on this channel to create Joy Division instrumental. in the future, I will deal with other performers, but in the event that it will be interesting to you. please rate my content.
thanks :)
Castrated Look away.
Yes, I think these videos are
needlessly stupid, a damn consequence of '' digital '' marketing.
@Noah Palin No.... you shut fucking up, I thinks you are a ''milenial'' who don't known anything about joy division.
Well, who's stopping you?
please stop, leave joy division alone
I mean...they were a band for 9 months in the late 70s.....
This chick is hot.....good on whoever owns the masters 🤣✌🎃🤘
I love this song. It reminds me of driving in a city in the dead of night with not a soul around. This is so far from that I can’t begin to describe my utter loathing of it.
You mean this one? ruclips.net/video/9ryJB-FF_Jg/видео.html
Te entiendo 😢
Lost souls. Very apt.❤
Dont screw it up, this is my favourite song
Too late, lmao!
Is this shit being done on purpose
Ian Curtis' voice must be the most haunting of all times. So sad and yet so beautiful...
There’s music for musicians and there’s music for everyone else. Making Joy Division videos has been a mistake from the beginning. We love Joy Division for what we hear not for what we see.
Have you ever noticed the HUGE curse of music videos? No matter what cool ephemeral images or moods you once had in your head when you heard the music by itself, they vanish forever once you see the music video because those images get permanently burned into your head as part of the track.
yeah but this one is terrific , you have to admit it
My sentiments exactly
Just turn your face away from the screen, problem solved
Day in.. day out.. day in day out... Day in Day Out, Day in Day Ouuut...
Last time I checked, Joy Division and TikTok don’t mix.
Dont tell me they are using joy division now😐😐😐😐
For real though.
fuck
Re-laaaax
Tiktok already has a “Disorder”
Right. (Constructive criticism) what they should do is listen to the lyrics. What does this video have to do with the lyrics. "I've go the spirit, but loose the feeling". I dont see how this video incorporates that with the visuals. "Cars are crashing, lights are flashing, getting frequent now". I see no sign of that in the video. Just give us what we want. A video that pays homage to the band and the death of an amazing musician. I get a feeling of a crowded Manchester city centre with this song. Dark and murky. Eerie like the music. This song makes you feel so many different emotions at once. For me and I speak for many others when I say, this is our favourite song and the first one we heard from the group. Lets relive the moment when we first heard it.
I understand people not liking it, but do you really want literal crashing cars and flashing lights in the video because those are the lyrics? You wouldn't want that, exactly. The refrain is "I've got the spirit, but lose the feeling" But what does that actually mean? I don't see how you could necessarily incorporate it. "Heart and Soul: one will burn" also will mean different things to different people. The "Love Will Tear Us Apart" video is perfect, but it's mostly just the band with some simple video effects.
I found this one interesting, the way it somehow misses the mark, although it obviously includes some of the usual post-industrial tropes. I guess the woman could represent "feeling" here. But these songs are still without a definitive video and I think I agree with others that they maybe shouldn't have one. The album artwork is the music's visual counterpart, if it has any.
@@rmilrta I know what you mean and I agree with you. I also dont see how you could make a music video to this song. The lyrics as you said mean different things to different people. So yeah I agree with your words.
@@rmilrta i love this song and this video really dissapointed my expectations(it fuckings sucks sm) my disappointment is immeasurable and my day is ruined
@@rmilrta uh...no, I believe I have to disagree with you mate. There are many ways of interpreting this song, most certainly. And I myself would prefer having to look at the artwork of "unknown pleasures" itself, than this wretched video. But if a music video is really that nessesary, then implicitly should be applied.
For instance, for the whole "lights are flashing, cars are crashing" thing, one could easily show a short blurry clip of a traffic, in the night for instance, where everything is a mess or so. For the "spirit, but lose the feeling", they can have a man pace on with his life in panic and so on.
I suggest you check out "Agent Orange" by "Ski Patrol". It has a similar themed video and you'll see what I mean when I talk on relevancy.
Note: The channel that uploaded the song is called "Dark entries records". Cheers!
@@IncredulousMisanthrope The blurry night traffic is a creative starting point of course, but there's a million ways to go. I wouldn't say it's impossible to allude to it: I meant it it doesn't *have* to be. The "spirit/feeling" part is a bit too abstract for me. I would find it hard to convey that as a concrete image. You probably agree on this, and perhaps this isn't how you'd do it, but I thought this was one way the first video in this series went wrong ("We were strangers...away too long" as two blokes in a quarry take turns trying to take a piece out of each other.) Doesn't mean I won't look at the video!
It's hard to make a Joy Division video that doesn't ramp up the usual interpretations too much. I made a video for In A Lonely Place for a Media Studies GCSE in 1988 when I was in college. I suspect people here would prefer it to some of these...
My memory of where I was the first time I heard this amazing song is deeper than this video.
Much much deeper
No one would have been able to make a less Joy Division-related video than this one here. It was difficult but they managed to do it.
This song is just so good, it doesn't matter what images I'm seeing my mind creates a video, of experiences and memories I had. Thanking the stars for Joy Division, as usual!
Terrible as expected. This song deserves so much better
This song deserves no video.
U watched it tho
It's sad when all I can really say about this video is the girl was hot.
drownsoda I like it
@@jboyle453519 imagine if the people who made it were actually creative. They could gave gotten true artists to make these, If anything. What's good about is , is the basicness to it. The use the some and the art work, WHICH are great! There part was to add some random model to dance to it??? At least a true artist, making the same video would have had a passionate, hot, but TRUE JD fan dancing to it, not some random gap model ?
The fan made video on youtube is miles better than this because it actually seems connected with the song. never thought I’d say a fanmade thing is better than the real thing
Essentially these reimagines are just fan made too.
Just this concept doesn't work.
Maybe for She Lost Control but not this.
This video gives no sense of the chaos around us
Defines the age, corporations blunder and fan projects bloom.
I love this song with all muy soul, but this video ...just no...
Gatsu speaking straight facts
I saw you on a Death Grips video; So you're into Berserk, Joy Division, and Death Grips? Nice, a guy with taste.
Wow, thank you very much Rohan
@@manulenjoyer Im talking to Camilo but you are welcome Mr.Doge
@@GamingOS 😳😳😳😳😳😳
Album of the Century❤❤❤
Tiktok girl in parking garage
Caleb Mastronardi 🤦🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️😂😂😂
Excellent not this video
Dude you don't appreciate the dimension
Hahaha
Hit or miss I guess they never miss huh?
Love it.
Who knows what Curtis would have thought of this ?
Guardians of orthodoxy always make me laugh. They speak in the name of artists, especially when they're dead.
Really? Is this the best that you can do? It was made without feeling, It is boring and been quite frankly: sucks
I guess you could say they’ve got the spirit but lost the feeling. And I agree with you, practically all of these reimagined music videos have sucked.
@@lonelyproductions Sure, I mean this song - for me- express a lot, and almost of the fans of JD could feel the same, and this kinds of videos are not the best way to show what all of us expected
@@lonelyproductions I loved that word play hahaha
@@lonelyproductions maybe they made this video intentionally badly for that lyric
If you're going to reimagine the song, it helps to have an imagination
When I listen to disorder, a naked girl moving around with dance moves that don't even match the song is definitely not what comes to mind. Hate to say it but I could of made a better video with my samsung phone just making some cheap edits of live shows.
Hi
I love making music. I am currently working on this channel to create Joy Division instrumental. in the future, I will deal with other performers, but in the event that it will be interesting to you. please rate my content.
thanks :)
Yeah? Go on and do it then Boomer.
Am I the only one that likes these videos? I have the give them credit, I mean sure it could be seen as bad but it's pretty unique in its own way, it's artistic
They're really puting effort into dissapointing us, each video is significantly worse than the previous one.
That guitar, that guitar, what a brilliant carving of riffs
You can tell the Pixies were deeply influenced by Joy Division in this song.
@@Miodrag.Vukomanovic Well, maybe yes, although I don't know. But Joey Santiago is by far more technically skilled in playing a guitar than Sumner ever will be, that's for sure
@@MrTuurte who cares about technical skill, they're both great guitarists and they will be remembered for their musicality
Let’s hope this never happens for Closer
Closer doesnt get hot topic funding we never will
If they screw with Decades...
Just wait till decades or isolation
These videos deserve the same kind of reviews the CATS movie received.
Feeling, feeling, feeling, feeling, FEELING, FEELING, FEEEELLING
This video need the feeling:c
Joy division will always be the best thing about my high
Oh god just stop.
Please don't do this to Closer
Se fizerem com o Closer eu vo chorar 😭😭😭😭😭😭
Hi, thanks for your interest in the newest official Joy Division videos for their hit album "Closer". First up, we have "The Eternal", set on the Malibu beach in sunny Southern California. Featuring a bevy of bodacious babes spraying each other down with orange Sunkist soda (they are a generous sponsor), their studly bronze boyfriends whistle along with the tune while tearing up the surf on their jet skis. I'm sure you and all your friends are going to love it very much. Please keep an eye out for the new line of tie-dyed "Closer" t-shirts and bikini thongs that will be front and center in every Hot Topic and Walmart soon!
Ian Curtis y Joy Division más vivos que nunca. Banda legendaria.
At this point it seems like they are just making fun of us
It's nice to see the traumatized model from the American Apparel ads getting some new work... even if that job is sleepily shaking off an opioid high in front of her boyfriend's iPhone 5.
Seriously?! This is not Joy Division nor was it made by anyone who even cares for Joy Division's legacy. I was so excited for this project when it was announced, but it has really let the fans down.
You people are awful.
@@VangaurdTDS no, this video is awful. It has nothing to do with the song.
If there was an original video that was released with this one, it would be 180 degrees away from whatever the hell this is fucking nonsense is supposed to be.
John Doe the video isn’t awful, it just doesn’t live up to whatever preconceived notion you had of it in your head. I’m sorry but that’s just the truth of the situation 🤷♂️.
Look at the comments. It's not just me.
Let me see if I can spell it out for you: listen to the song, watch the video. Does A connect with B whatsoever? I'm sorry that you have some misguided conception that this video is great, but I hate to tell you that it misses the mark by a lot.
John Doe and look at the comments, it’s not just me either. I don’t get your point as you simply seem to be a conformist. Also, I didn’t say the video was great either, I just think it’s okay. I’m sorry you hate originality so much.
When I heard this sound, I only could imagine a person walking alone in the street of a disturbed city.
With this video, you loose the spirit, the feeling and the respect who deserve one of the greatest song in the history of rock!!!
Legit how I will dance in my room alone once I press play ▶️ 🎶🎶🎶✨ RIP Ian Curtis
This is an insult to Ian Curtis and the rest of the band
chess jeez it’s just a video lol chill
He committed suicide he does not give a shit or know. LOL
@@CelestialWoodway I know, right? These comments are so fucking edgy. Oh wait... A subculture was birthed from this; I get it now
Its official.
Did stephen/hooky/barney sign off on this? This is the best they could come up with? For shame...
nothing or nobody could ever or do this song any justice, i pity the person who had the job, still its Joy Division at there very best and my favourite song , 40 years old and still brilliant . thank you Joy Division even though it didnt last long enough, RIP Ian Curtis
My favorite bass-line ever
Hooky is the greatest bass player of all time in my book.
Someone posted this song few days ago on Twitter and I got hooked instantly. Like... the bassline is fucking enchanting!
Disorder é uma das minhas músicas favoritas na vida, e é realmente decepcionante a preguiça com que produziram esse vídeo, essa canção merecia muito mais.
Conheço a banda através de Transpotting
I love this song but I was expecting something better than this video! Please create a better video for this!
This video is a betrayal of what this band represents.
True, ..... on purpose ? The roots of Warsaw/JD go against todays politicaly correct narrative.
This whole project has been a massive flop and i wish youd just stop at this point. Its just pretentious, video after video.
The sound that marked those years...
Not Disorder pls
Im 51. Went into an ice cream shop in a small tourist beach town in Ontario this summer - 15 year old budding goth behind the counter with a JD UP shirt on. "Nice shirt!" -- ruined his week with just 2 words.
Here we go Again. Here's to hope
Scratch that. No hope
I was wandering, there is a lot of people with a big soul just like Ian, may god bless them.
honoured to say i’m the first dislike. well done on ruining one of my favourite songs
Dunno mate, I still love the song, but the video....
Max Autunno i’m clearly being hyperbolic.
Anonymous Duckling video’s a bit dreadful innit
The world is a rough place for having such thin skin.
I always imagined the video to this song to be a midnight drive, late night with the radio crackling slightly and light rain, not some preying mantis having an aneurysm coursing through her arms in an ikea parking lot. Ian didn’t die for this, I’ll tell you that for free
I love joy division forever 🖤
This pseudo-modern commercialclip transports the Manchester '79 mood not for any single second.
Esta canción me da una sensación de una etapa de transición entre la adolescencia y la adultes, en la cual el mundo real golpea con fuerzaa causa de, sus problemas y vos cayendo en un poso, en donde reina el desorden y la desesperación.
Yo siempre lo tome como una apreciación al desorden emocional, en el cual tus sentimientos son inestables y el unico modo de sentirte mejor es enfocarte en tu espiritu, cayendo asi poco a poco en la depresion
Timeless perfection belittled by juvenile egocentricism.
it's funny because they still haven't realized that all these music videos look like shit and it has nothing to do with the true essence of joy division
Excellent ce clip; Joy Divison is a Legend.
Mark Fisher about Joy Division: "They had so thoroughly stripped out Rock’s libidinal motor - ‘Sex has disappeared from these unknown pleasures; (...) it would be better to say that they were, libidinally as well as sonically, anti-Rock." And thats a reason why is this video bad.
Yeah, this is exactly the kind of vid that Curtis would have approved of.
My favorite song with not doubt, missing you Ian.
Just got the album today for vinyl its so good
I think the people behind the video were like "alright let's just make the chick dance like the lines"
PERHAPS THE GREATEST AUTHENTIC ROCK AND ROLL SONG OF ALL TIME...
Guys...
I don’t wanna see my favourite song ruined
Edit: Fine... it sucks
I have bad news
The song's not ruined, it's just a bad video
Hi
I love making music. I am currently working on this channel to create Joy Division instrumental. in the future, I will deal with other performers, but in the event that it will be interesting to you. please rate my content.
thanks :)
keep me out Great work dude, keep it on 👍
Music was at it's highest point 79-80... Thank you Ian
You could of literally just showed someone driving down a street at night
Instead you choose this
Edit: instead you choose TITS :-(
Someone once did a video to "Ceremony" driving through an industrial part of town and it was great.
In my opinion, this song is so beautiful if the video is on the cult cinema's cinematography set up, showing a girl who sits on a "ayunan", holding a tambourine in her left hand, and her right hand is hitting her left knee with a rainbow rose. And one more, the whole video is "black and white".
BEYOND ANY SONG ELSE DISORDER,,,,IS THE BEST ROCK SONG OF ALL TIME JOY DIVISION FOREVER !
I’ve been waiting for this one to come out and I’m scared 😬
Are you disappointed? I am. :(
MIKERUPTION very. But I expected to be disappointed :/
@@brawnylilyspark Unfortunately, these reimagined videos have been so terrible. It blows my mind how out of touch with Joy Division's essence these videos have been. It's almost like the videomaker had a preconceived idea for a short film, and in order to make it, they forced it upon a Joy Division song, whether it was appropriate or not.
The only thing more bewildering than this video is that it has more likes than dislikes.
It's weird how many likes this has but so many negative comments.
I actually didn't dislike it and I sometimes don't get why people hate it.
Their reasons are sometimes a bit in contradiction to or not exactly what I seem to like about a music video, for example "It doesn't show the lyrics in any way", as if a music video's purpose is to visualize the lyrics. I would say I like Radiohead's video for "No Surprises". But I'm not too sure about what I like about it or videos in general.
This music video fits pretty well to me. There's not a lot happening, I think using the album's artwork on the girl was a nice idea and it has some kind of theme to it. The only thing I don't like is that it looks so polished in contrast to this old raw song
Nah give me skate boarding videos with that vhs overlay dark alleyways lights at night in the distance trees going by a car window at night sun sets and drugs thats what this needs for a video
No, god no, disorder is my favorite song
Yeah. This actually better be good
@@DonnyBomb well...it really isn't lol!
@@IncredulousMisanthrope unfortunately
This is what I look like listening to joy division and I dont care
This is blasphemy, and then some. Or in layman’s terms, it’s shite.
I've been listening to Joy Division and loving their work for over 30 years. I love this because its an angle of JD I haven't seen 1,000 times. Thank you!
Well, they did it.
They couldn't even make something half decent for my favorite Joy Division song.
Love this video 🖤
ONLY NEED LYRICS ON SCREEN, I LOVE JOY DIVISION, BUT THIS REIMAGINED VIDEOS ARE REALLY BAD
felipe andrés cortés gutiérrez don’t watch them then
She Lost Control: Will feature a woman stripping & having sex w/ multiple people 😛😛😛
Ian did not die for this.....
Por más que tratan de imitar la estetica de joy division en estos videos les falta feeling feeling feelin feeling feeling feeeeeeeelinggg!!
La idea está buena pero al menos podrían haber puesto a alguien que sepa bailar,esa tipa tiene 0 ganas
@@enzofernandez4725 ja ja ja ja ja así es totalmente aritmica, no va con la rola
Yo esperaba ver autos chocando
estaba mejor el negrito que cantaba desafinado
Love that us Joy Division fans hate this video so much. Music taste and understanding translating to visual preferences.
Je sais pas qui a reimaginer ce clip mais je le trouve vraiment en phase avec joy division et Ian
The day has finally come
Hi, thanks for your interest in the newest official Joy Division videos for their hit album "Closer". First up, we have "The Eternal", set on the Malibu beach in sunny Southern California. Featuring a bevy of bodacious babes spraying each other down with orange Sunkist soda (they are a generous sponsor), their studly bronze boyfriends whistle along with the tune while tearing up the surf on their jet skis. I'm sure you and all your friends are going to love it very much. Please keep an eye out for the new line of tie-dyed "Closer" t-shirts and bikini thongs that will be front and center in every Hot Topic and Walmart soon!
I forgot how bad these "Reimagined" videos were. Now I remember.
A dead chinchilla would be more meaningful , than this imagination
why not billions of views, joy divion among the streaming services
This better be good. They can't screw this one up or she's lost control. Shadowplay was probably the "best" one so far but again they better not screw this one up
After watching the video, like most, I am disappointed. This video had a lot of potential but instead it's just a girl dancing. Lame
Nakey and hot girl- unlike Ian who danced in a purely emotive way.
I'm still waiting for that guide to come and take ME by the hand...
Se pasan de pirinola con los vídeos de mi joy division..😢
Si también me decepcionó